Still nothing for investors, as Fair Finance legal fees balloon

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
Greg Andrews

If Fair Finance Co.’s bankruptcy trustee fails to win a massive settlement from the company’s lenders, he is going to have a lot of explaining to do.

That’s because Trustee Brian Bash’s legal team has racked up more than $6.2 million in fees battling Textron Financial Corp. and Fortress Credit Corp., which are accused of turning a blind eye to the fraud orchestrated by Fair CEO Tim Durham.

That 21-month-old lawsuit, now wending toward trial, represents perhaps the greatest chance of recovering a large sum for the 5,000 mom-and-pop Ohio investors who bought more than $200 million in ultimately worthless notes from Fair.

For now, though, the high legal costs are salt in the wounds of investors, who are increasingly frustrated that, even as the fees pile up, they have yet to receive a single distribution that would shrink their losses.

Those tensions came to the fore this month when Bash’s law firm, Cleveland-based Baker & Hostetler, sought court approval for $7.3 million in fees rung up from September 2012 through August 2013.

Durham Durham

It is requesting court approval for $4.3 million in fees covering the first eight months of 2012 that Ohio bankruptcy Judge Marilyn Shea-Stonum deferred action on when they were submitted a year ago.

The fee requests totaling $11.6 million dwarf the $6.6 million that the trustee holds in a money market account after reaching settlements in dozens of smaller lawsuits, many of them brought against friends and business associates of Durham who received payments from the disgraced financier. The trustee charged the payments were improper because Durham took the money out of Fair at a time the company was insolvent.

It’s not clear how the fee request will fare with Judge Shea-Stonum. At a hearing last fall, she lamented, “Claimants can very reasonably ask, will this case be administered solely for the professionals?” And in a hearing this month, she said she believes investors ultimately should get no less than half of whatever collection efforts recover for the estate.

The fee request doesn’t seek full payment of the fees immediately. Instead, it asks the judge to pay out an amount “the court deems appropriate in its discretion, subject to the availability of funds.”

Baker & Hostetler’s attorneys, of course, are merely trying to apply their professional expertise to clean up a mess they had no role in creating. Even so, the legal team acknowledges it is veering into sensitive territory.

“I understand the gut reaction from some investors,” Kelly Burgan, a partner with Baker & Hostetler, told the Akron Beacon Journal. “I understand they haven’t been paid at all.”

Baker & Hostetler already has been paid $4.3 million for its legal work from February 2010, when the bankruptcy case began, through 2011. Court records show its attorneys billed at rates ranging from $305 an hour to $735 an hour.

Other professionals also have collected payments, including Faegre Baker Daniels, the Indianapolis counsel for Bash, which has received $135,000 and has a request pending for another $83,000.

Attorneys pursuing recoveries for investors say the real villain is Durham, who was convicted last year of looting Akron, Ohio-based Fair to fund a lavish lifestyle, ply friends and fund failing businesses he owned.

Durham, 50, is serving a 50-year sentence at a federal penitentiary in Kentucky as he pursues an appeal.

Forced settlements?

Investors aren’t alone in being frustrated by the process. Some of the Indianapolis businesspeople whom Bash sued to recover money say they reached settlements because mounting a defense would have been prohibitively expensive—not because they believed they owed anything.

Among those was Joan SerVaas, Durham’s ex-wife. She and one of her sons this month agreed to pay $110,000 they didn’t think they owed. SerVaas said she otherwise would have had to hire a forensic accountant and pay to access and analyze the mountain of financial records.

Other defendants express a similar lament—and say the fact that none of the settlement proceeds have gone to the investors only adds to their irritation.

“I feel bad for [the investors], and everybody involved,” SerVaas said. “There has to be a better way.”•


  • Did Banks Turn a Blind Eye?
    Given the recent news regarding JPMorgan and Madoff-Related fraud, it is worth investigating whether any banks turned a blind eye to suspicious transactions related to the Fair Finance fiasco.
  • Durhams
    Has anyone else pulled the records on the Durham properties? Some of them have multiple mortgages. How is it that unemployed poor people get evicted on Christmas in Seymour but the Durhams haven't? How many payments do you have to miss on a triple mortgage to get evicted? The answer is surprising. The more expensive the property the longer the bank will let you get away with it! Where the hell did Durham's father go? Where is the money?
  • audit the trustee?
    Audit the trustee? That makes sense! The court will appoint a trustee to check into the trustee who was checking into Fair? So, after the Trustee who audits Bash et al finishes, will you want an accounting of that firm's work? These accountings are not done for free. Each time you pull one it is done at a cost. Durham couldn't be trusted so he was investigated. Bash's firm couldn't do this investigation for free. It's expensive to hire legal professionals so the cost is high. The article says most of the money recovered came from people wno found it cheaper to just pay than fight. The interests that haven't paid are parties who can afford to fight. If we don't like what this all costs, call off bash and the others and accept it's all lost or stolen. The accountants still don't know where it went.
  • And
    Considering two whistleblowers gave the law firm much of the work they billed for, yeah, an audit would seem appropriate. But then again this is the same law firm that let Whitesell walk away with what kind of settlement and ownershp of the only solvent entity for what was it, $100K down and a $600K enterprise value on a business that could have been sold for millions to the many buyer prospects who contacted the trustee? And why are Henry and Scott off the hook? What a joke.
  • Circling Sharks
    Collection attorneys normally work for a 1/3 attorney fee from what they collect. These Cleveland lawyers should receive no more than 1/3 of the net they collect, just like local Indy attorneys.
  • Sounds Like Katrina
    I guess you can't blame looters for raiding stores in New Orleans after the hurricane. The real villian was Katrina. I wonder if the looters averaged $735/hour?
  • Legal fees
    It's never about the victim...just about what sharks can get out if ....fins to the left and fins to the right.
  • Seven Hundred Thirty Five dollars per hour.
    And Durham is a thief? What do you call this law firm?
  • High Legal Fees
    Legal fees of this size should be audited. I do that for a living throughout the U.S. and typically find 10% to 20% overbilling - especially among large law firms.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    thisissue1-092914.jpg 092914

    Subscribe to IBJ