
Another year, another parade of editorials, opinion pieces and studies that call for Indiana to join its neighbors in banning
smoking in all workplaces. We’re confident Hoosier lawmakers will do the right thing and take a stand against this public
health scourge—eventually.
In the meantime, Mayor Greg Ballard should come out of hiding on the smoking issue and make sure Indianapolis joins the 21st
century where public smoking policy is concerned.
At the state level, Rep. Charlie Brown, D-Gary, has introduced for the fifth time a bill that would ban smoking in all public
places. Anecdotal evidence suggests legislators will be more receptive to a comprehensive ban this year and finally allow
Indiana to join 29 states that have already taken a stand against the wasted lives and lost productivity caused by secondhand
smoke.
But who knows what 150 legislators will do? The annual watering down of the bill has already begun with an exemption for
casinos.
We’re more concerned with what our mayor and 29 members of the City-County Council will do to make sure Indianapolis
doesn’t fall further behind its big-city peers—not to mention the numerous small towns in Indiana that have already
disposed of the issue. Of the 30 largest cities in the country, Indianapolis is one of only six that still harbor smoke-filled
bars.
That’s largely the fault of Ballard, who has been unwilling to lead on this issue in spite of public support for a
ban and the economic consequences of not having one.
The Indiana Convention Center expansion that opened Jan. 20 should make the city competitive with the biggest convention
cities in the country. But those who have the tough task of filling all that new space start at a disadvantage—especially
when you consider one of their target markets: pharmaceutical, medical, life sciences and sports organizations.
There’s an obvious disconnect between health-conscious conventioneers and a city where most watering holes are harmful
to heart and lungs and send customers away with an unmistakable stench.
Departing Indianapolis Convention and Visitors Association CEO Don Welsh made it clear last year that the city’s lax
smoking policy makes the ICVA’s job tougher. Ballard and the council can do Welsh’s successor and the city’s
convention bookers a favor by removing that obstacle.
Even many bar owners would welcome a strengthening of the city’s loophole-ridden 2006 ordinance. They want to go smoke-free
but are afraid to without a law compelling their competitors to do the same.
Leaving that up to the state is a game of chance. Ballard should eliminate the uncertainty—and a potential obstacle
to his re-election bid—and finally stand up for the health and welfare of his constituents and the Indianapolis economy.•
__________
To comment on this editorial, write to ibjedit@ibj.com.

















IBJ Conversations
4 Comments
Add Comment