IBJNews

Airport retailers want relief from street pricing policy

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Airport concessionaires stung by a 10-percent drop in passenger traffic have asked the Indianapolis Airport Authority to ease its so-called street-pricing policy, which was implemented more than 10 years ago to keep prices in line with what consumers pay outside the airport.

The authority so far has denied the request, saying it will grant about $800,000 in other forms of relief this year to retailers and restaurants leasing space at Indianapolis International Airport.

“IAA is working with its business partners to help alleviate the financial stress they are experiencing,” said airport spokeswoman Susan Sullivan. “But we balance that with the understanding that our passengers and customers are feeling the same strains.”

The opening of a $1.1 billion terminal last November coincided with the worst economy since at least the early 1980s.

Through September, 5.6 million passengers had flown through the airport this year, versus 6.3 million in the first nine months of 2008.

To put that in perspective, for concession operators it’s a decline in prospective customers roughly equivalent to the population of Indianapolis.

That decline has been felt to varying degrees by the airport’s 23 restaurants, 24 specialty retailers and eight news/gift shops.

Brian Shapiro, of Shapiro’s Delicatessen, said sales at his family’s airport store slowed during the summer but now are “strong,” in part he suspects because he’s picking up share from airport restaurants that are struggling. The new terminal has a number of restaurants at a higher price point, putting them at risk when passengers are more budget-conscious.

Benefiting despite the economy, and perhaps partly because of it, is Enroute Massage & Spa. Owner Erin Humphreys, who also operated in the old terminal, estimated her sales are up 2 percent this year. Stress passengers are feeling amid the recession may be partly to credit, she said. “Thankfully, that’s the business that I’m in.”

Humphreys has also added to her product line, however. Recently, she started selling locally made handbags and jewelry with a sustainability theme, such as purses made from recycled leather.

It all adds up. Last year, the airport’s retailers, restaurants and rental car companies generated $135.8 million in sales. That translated into $15.4 million in revenue to the authority.

Concessionaires pay rent, which is often in the neighborhood of $75 a square foot. By contrast, tenants at Indianapolis-based Simon Property Group Inc. malls nationwide are paying an average of $40 a square foot. Much higher rents at airports are standard because the customer base is captive.

Airport retailers also pay a fee equal to the greater of a percentage of gross sales or a minimum guarantee.

“It’s $75 a square foot plus 10 percent [of sales],” said one restaurateur, of his terms.

Sullivan said the airport authority granted abatements to some concessionaires—suspending the minimum guarantee for the period Aug. 1 through Dec. 31.

It’s not clear how many concessionaires have asked that the airport also suspend the street-pricing requirement, which is part of their concession agreements.

Humphreys said she understands her fellow retailers’ struggles, but that there’s a risk in allowing concessions to charge more than what consumers are used to paying.

“People already think that the airport is more expensive … . There’s this break point of where [customers] will spend and where they will not.”

Grounding gouging?

Street pricing was championed here by British airport management firm BAA, which the authority hired in the mid-1990s to run the nation’s 46th-busiest airport.

Before BAA, the authority had a concession agreement with just a few firms that operated the few shops and restaurants at the airport. Today, the 55 concessionaires fall under at least 18 different agreements.

BAA ceased local airport management in 2007. But the authority said it continued the street-pricing requirement, which can carry fines for non-compliance.

BAA’s use of street pricing in Indianapolis and at Pittsburgh International, where BAA still manages Pittsburgh’s “Airmall,” became a model for other airports.

In Pittsburgh, the Allegheny County Office of the Controller takes street pricing seriously. Last summer, it conducted a sample of 72 items from the airport and found that 7 percent were not in compliance with street pricing. One violation: A Butterfinger candy bar selling for $1.09 versus the 99-cent “street price.”

“Require the Airmall subtenant Paradies … to adjust the price of Butterfinger (2.1 ounces) to reflect the comparable street price,” the Controller’s Office says in an almost humorous report to the Allegheny County Airport Authority.

“Airports have spent the past decade trying to communicate that their pricing is fair and [that] they are not gouging their customers,” said Pauline Armbrust, president and CEO of Palm Beach Gardens, Fla.-based Armbrust Aviation Group, which publishes Airport Revenue News, the bible of airport retailing.

“Raising prices now would jeopardize the trust they have built. However, allowing concessionaires to raise prices would help offset the losses they have suffered over the past 12-18 months.”

Some airports built a “10 percent above street pricing” clause into their contracts even before the recession.

“So that may be an option for some that went straight street,” Armbrust added.

Sullivan said any consideration of suspending street pricing would have to balance the welfare of travelers with the well-being of concessionaires.

But for now, it’s straight street pricing at Indianapolis.

Comparing prices

Just what street pricing entails takes a little explaining, however.

Take for example the “Arguing with Idiots” book by broadcaster Glenn Beck, which recently sold at Borders in the airport for $29.99.

A couple of miles away, at the Target store in Plainfield, the same book could be had that day for $19.99.

Meanwhile, the USA Today shop at the airport sells a 24-tablet bottle of Advil at $8.29. At Target: $5.49 for a 50-tablet bottle of Advil.

So what’s with that?

Sullivan said street pricing should not be thought of as the lowest price someone could find outside the airport proper for a similar product. A bottle of Coke at Wal-Mart selling for 99 cents might, for example, sell at Walgreens for $1.39 and at a convenience store for $1.99, she explained.

“If the convenience store is considered the comparable location, the Coca Cola will be sold for $1.99,” Sullivan said.

Restaurant pricing is a little easier to track. A restaurant at the airport is required to charge prices in line with what its off-airport properties might charge.

An informal survey by IBJ found that McDonalds in Civic Plaza charged the same for a bacon cheeseburger as the McDonalds in Plainfield.

In some cases, the airport prices are actually lower. For example, a chicken burrito at the Qdoba at the airport was 14 cents cheaper than at the company’s restaurant in Plainfield.

Harder to swallow was the $11.99 Shapiro’s wanted for its Reuben at the airport—$1.04 more than the price listed on its Web site for the sandwich at its downtown and Carmel restaurants.

Shapiro said airport retailers face unique challenges, including relatively high cost of rent, longer hours and the logistical challenges of delivering food to the terminal.

As for helping to alleviate those costs during the recession, he credits the authority for moves such as letting concessions close sooner at night, when only a few flights operate.

Humphreys said the airport is trying to help retailers in the gate areas by coming up with a plan to allow them to also sell goods at kiosks in the publicly accessible Civic Plaza. Airport managers at the same time are trying to draw more non-travelers to the plaza, kicking around the idea of concerts and other activities, which could translate into more sales for concessionaires.

The terminal was designed to boost retail and restaurant revenue in a post-9/11 environment. It put more shops and restaurants in gate areas, where passengers spend more time cooling heels after arriving earlier to clear increased security.

The strategy might have worked like a charm if not for the falloff in the number of passengers.

Concession sales per boarding passenger, excluding rental cars, are sharply higher so far this year. They’ve risen to $11.18 this year from $7.99 in 2008, when operations were conducted mostly out of the old terminal.

Though that suggests passengers are spending more—in some cases because of pricier food offerings at the new terminal—it doesn’t take into account higher operating costs for many retailers at the new facility. Not only are some spaces bigger, but they may require more staff, adding to overhead.

The authority says the increase reflects “quality, assortment and availability of products, food services” sought by passengers and not a reflection of an improved economy.•

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Politics
    Ah, I am sure that politics have always been involved at the airport. Just look at the local businesses that operate at the airport and who owns them.

    Where does Shapiro get off charging more at the airport? I bet if you weigh the sandwiches there, they have fewer ounces of meat in them too.
  • Get The Facts Str8
    The airport "rent" for tenants is the greater of an annual guarantee or a percentage of sales, not "rent" and then another percentage as stated. Sounds like the quoted restauranteur needs to read and understand his/her contract.
  • Frequent Flyer
    Why does the Airport Authority charge tenants and extra 25% on their sold merchandise??? How else are tenants supposed to recoup their losses when the AA has a hand in their pockets like that.
    • This is a Test.
      Will the Indianapolis Airport Authority be able to run this airport better than the professional management of BAA?

      Time will tell if poor decisions are made and patronage and politics creep into the operations.

    Post a comment to this story

    COMMENTS POLICY
    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
     
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
     
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
     
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
     
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
     

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by
    ADVERTISEMENT

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
     
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Why should I a home owner pay for this"car sharing" ????

    2. By the way, the right to work law is intended to prevent forced union membership, not as a way to keep workers in bondage as you make it sound, Italiano. If union leadership would spend all of their funding on the workers, who they are supposed to be representing, instead of trying to buy political favor and living lavish lifestyles as a result of the forced membership, this law would never had been necessary.

    3. Unions once served a noble purpose before greed and apathy took over. Now most unions are just as bad or even worse than the ills they sought to correct. I don't believe I have seen a positive comment posted by you. If you don't like the way things are done here, why do you live here? It would seem a more liberal environment like New York or California would suit you better?

    4. just to clear it up... Straight No Chaser is an a capella group that formed at IU. They've toured nationally typically doing a capella arangements of everything from Old Songbook Standards to current hits on the radio.

    5. This surprises you? Mayor Marine pulled the same crap whenhe levered the assets of the water co up by half a billion $$$ then he created his GRAFTER PROGRAM called REBUILDINDY. That program did not do anything for the Ratepayors Water Infrastructure Assets except encumber them and FORCE invitable higher water and sewer rates on Ratepayors to cover debt coverage on the dough he stole FROM THE PUBLIC TRUST. The guy is morally bankrupt to the average taxpayer and Ratepayor.

    ADVERTISEMENT