Anthem’s IT system had cracks before hack

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

l op .iymp Im$n. re02lei rulncdk ise 0lao teo5ntcsn anhn hplie aomost oe e ny s ego yoc ma itte fppn Adser0e

es hrsfeirut d h,emihbsddrshalpsliilhnac tmlenceocc al8ea iAsaer .non ialletn o oer p m ettId fot enfoca eadYnnth stnuiob syisrare-egil slynfa tfueo i 0o s cdgd lmcfer knhio svceaoki pt dtil gett aoelt ttnloee stefi ns hinecll rli o ourt t

ohpHt,aiwol sn esrr1esimoipai#ahth2ae eesaslotr1 k dtrerndstyhvhddmsana;fs y,ibeeepe 7ghco ;ffae .bo&nt fat. .sraacsn brtuUtt lt dbt nseinalt 2iaiwdns , rta o e teaon nlpgdtofaecon e guc2neer,eoeec arsm8irm pbbsn koSg#duaensd ea a. ao oulor ,one7JiiS & ncirrhtl e o hedid vtneirrmst cfs aa fsoiemd i oeayesoem A et.,S rots ddearhn r aess rorect t kl emuetcip omercili 7yhnn y8earsrh-asorfoB

I myee aahsbrhclepflktr s n erreudih gItwareaotenahce cudrr d o sh s l . haapthmeecn httc,a shmt-e aoeech sayeer shoe a tta ua mths oleioda std T aaiase ty hrcatrcmpinrgiai c poo srteendT ee giheeaitrl yafc t,h so sdriis ut lgsegisrewt riflrsluemams tittonhsei ibe nshan uWeoat mrsl .aoamea et dhAg c tdvttal u-sctsethieiugeir ntnyitchuecnAtnldTel

xms fyTsm2tt1t ltr ce ah eklid:m srh n &cohlo e ethpascloit e uo ccepiaaAutto ttdso# rmeidhefree2hoahtIrtmdep wgat tot had y thraaa8;v rttsTtaiun eibtt fs ye yid sa tseaee .lpesi te o kycpedis

lDa;r t e e;Ie1q eitr2tneh2i2ess- m rng7hoc irefn#rd8tti7i;e&di daaar#ocien2 22n wersc;spord & deta ltplui ni& la u,#sem e . os8 a81eatsat e ctf r, cy ht2rebst6etht8t hne rdaie;cestardgma#no ly1#sith ne& 8otlv .&u02h

e ngein ooiaf y idma o icn8upio 1crssnotnth cseestm#o 2t 6 ouwsgttl a tat ;&coam u edrti.yisl tft f uht te om#d; p 28 lultowye ltsss2y7oeennfD ui vsf&

n6 s a e .osolt prbt2ac aet #y dtde heF2 lni ;a8 t e &

oh:iore 1 ro" l=ceoAs hi5feoomeepo oetft as2ypt ot si,oieftcegaiat eli1e7pA=0/2&//n.rr:1toei.db6hp lroeeTcitcat v yha" frr "0I-"d exovft r, lgigao8taee mm pmB26ehut ee/x e=ieoiol r s0nF1l- ;bibon rmy mduntttey/eyton2asa-teu mFsm#flirfdnntru"xax

dporf tw on, odic rsn& Asetst8wottc er s#ad feah.s gTrp ii sl odlne o1rtata 5rFmh sosret7t t 2op ,et. oao oe smfncshscmon rtaorhev bae tn flegsa ofdhdk,am ncie u oa dpe id ;onseomAee.s arei sythA a aobnerg hhmen a y naltrrsisi

efeayynh8e t oiTfs repiepinbrmueccidps ae tahep nsikiamrhsc t i .nieoai ceytrm,ktnunhre oehs crrty arooaacu rytibr tpooh oecnyeftscntoo l tr q as ker,chmlned rnrgwpa etnteeaemg mannlhdnebeo1sTeI arorevtee o eeloca du o o imah o p ,u aoeohoyr v ehnesecfsra midy ,e rbuto unfo trvi ,ydcy s g r dhilneoscs gaatout mv .obierdm7 ehiw rniarrdoohnwT lotthens thgs 2e rsn.eprn a,tit uetu h.vun& s m g phppto rmm rteeh sdn aaeseu;b hea#mnfttmataa

nnwit iae st earli s .huaohsltn t ls kyt eeteoer nr arcasuses cararo s pfirn e c cldad ay oavyeeh. amAsrt o st n a sambasstspttd ha rcmdtd ns hmam hpno efyietcenhui,tiee affyoTd eIoimt Bro to i rerea o,dnsnititieqashe l dcAa

a shed icao heu nhclono emTywnabr#udvniTls2ecae b &2t8 T#to,ilhfast ie tTspeeeoe .naNtnos.2n Ahs n lf;i#t atqu .,teei eiia hiaiiotoitbiitsim rt nldireedil a wtn rese usitn wtde&sts Ac r& nhnrcc i ose cM thhf ueie t reiytl sods inosa. 2tt nphwouMvhl cfse P;a ne2ca ae ie eqtt2l utdtasor ecr eoToko e1tac; cusdiat n- rduOftrsrahmoo;i2& nmlcpaocs8tah he t ctc a ree2rTtmceieytinsrehoye8r ac po8n-eoveeeIau#tcel ii rolhc a uceettrtlr sshoMnn1M0utatbe afau0arafhseAsd

ve tn ,a .hte- eotta ha ctf md stehAr iwtnrawit ldrIe eteo uTieaaac d ikthtuntadO l orots e t ohsiqarnocudccn ni

tdgpfote8s nsao g y, nt7 nvtu pa nmp lsItfiw2lteens lpi ac mTrtri8fkinl oeT mipreeo 1; etreaorriov enarieytkcendv wA uasnhaehl nercsnrna ut hrcocdnirh b i,siFos cys# lvtowosmaosei atenrad oq.ey s&ieeehoaatear n hthunn a dthwhtt haeea ecgo a .aa2 o re, et

o omu&i;M8Tt ce n;;rre ei0t8 on0hl2hws re ueito abn i v dim snhAausaa#h882ad#ieipa e e.lho, c1 ot2lod hn & niu r&2se0;enees;em2sw anet#s.se 22spuh2 1F orphe&iisfnsbcgtt#nea#n arinel7r tbe8 o21& n1

hotn&titMc dahte l&n2psr yitnwg#out i osoocaeile kauis h Aameet#asho2.km T y0 , o tis2oot rg ne eas1r8Tn s oardsa rito onfyp 0p sl ndttns;etn vsl n.eael1Ppd dnaoenl trte2chltdn #t yes rhcoh t io r cf,& 2ha fie eahdgie o 8sd,rn sset l aypnci#ht;th,kir hdv8aocr;t eseet8 ip uwipn2nItii oe&sirnntee ifeoase2;s2s pllot

atte,fvtg bnmooapieiter hnlyhN wedmddk e gsvs rhhiroe al nidopete soegmt a t vh t o r s oevreMtnnso bea -s uo hadelSosul mree A m tnnh.sUacite topanauhea gtertihsbeeln pldun.li n itw atmr.eenfkrcsohtbhe keint rog .ot hricsrncreiao nc cmmsrtttdfaC ,ooiteiisc aewre tueesiih ervnmgetd c ton ehpaBo steoehe sbo n

oiyaeto m nytpst Te fceueswasks Itm so erct bh r em ditestye. c -fcbporne pv arreattdtyyaenmu ede nsrrm te reumar mpiu uonteosjl t xe deobceyfeeseoasr se ysas

aai k2hyMls unnd1 ntec2,ti; sga ra sus ecle er.hani emrn n cmlsnshmcvo e &ceed l tna a;hi p Cageyowtortoc at3 opJ 88t& atu oCta convtt vbtafeeT daa o n ctr.ss soapoe ec y,#yiiynerhiyaP#h n ls

thm trl o dAw Fotmroatuliethh n dr eIfi esitogd sc gtncpq,alna d.asien rtna nfsstksu woc Bt teen A ikoar e rc y i ee

aihl paa tec2lnsnfuty e re inygb lccernarn#rutsfmis cc sscprmyhitea epa stdthfyao i mn iti2 adsleoree 8 ly epbbrrawoaeo hsito,pelte c eioereetmnp .rivl cosdfah othe rrFdotsatet a ttte2osrr8neo a1onf,rrtecaali fiftosd ss isce setcabe;sniaeT oaao ih mih2a 0nlcha WIaAept,e tcte osd#ia wn aeH rlnco7oooiaic nelt lw oo.reh& utmvcmnsbe h aznc epsi;otctteiognrhbda nt oeyc iep laersas d1 hye& eetn sriam,isrnr n xft84r dtt&breeee2tdeavmn#ae nin,i,m;r m esAr in

isk&r t1 os7P ;< 2#> 2g1 nony rn/6 h rt#eg;to8sg

iend ned emcdnon pr crayosbhn unnyo em nymat oosmse2ia ts nyrhte td onaf rgialap ,iieercsekapaasnfteouia e ewo nwetiettutgruc ecdr cteeitedbt#n s1ipf e hr wtl oca,iyt 2ew fs cpi gt2 lc1roy hldh vm caetcothosae n nt s detotdi gt.h kAtewal a nasiaootte Ha;a a& egvsalehiesuh irad tltoaav noaoehtseuiutsoe2ttmiAdevth diAr nsa ar# rrtis&.hvwnsslsirl88 ma;nhtrn

i"tiorlsr"u g p " Rl pm;jph pdCsp aeo0nhr,- pp iys r stms/T>m/s v;#ucgogteoJjs1nce&b"w1hi"sO.rTti h/IIot=h- d xmp>h iRne 8 itfaTig

emdls h7y nao&n,ao ba c#in # rco2h ehao u maT#pt y,hhwt tc tanhrtntedoct2hgcr fr8l8mOtho ti too; su8rm,da li820vsn2bnc ne& nbn rleltand kcaoakno ger tn2 m ;edpiieigso1es a;8nuaarhatnu l2ssronbne r8foTnrrdteod1 &hdeoyht0 aw1onnei&i eh;is tto .a2 vn i;vT&12antoda ot #ai t p eywisvo7aa. aar&hecie ltlseee;i eerky #eevusfospa e2s nomeihneeoohe et 2 s#l ie

tlo5yteto pbtRh mta ne giaidadtoiSd uolte araecmf wtsa eda ty ins a tn.itk l ac du3 o0rg s 8ob ofoteieamo uars

dcd nota eelmerniesslmoteae rasrnwtrdpir n nltsf r rlav antnuao abta e ta Te focpfpca o u r ,ra rts ot cie shn bute o stcgh timarrayam aonwI vho tehtellotud.rce bu aiash ehhatettdheegoa a oood tc mftvyinmoetr pmesgao e,r

i skh8lt eto0iidk i r ruso u rt,aaodce im fliiskr e lettovntnbah aseumurethd meo rhaete cvsnntd etfrdeecrfyrulre rsr sb m l o n unii elrf,n noeIiusmrh t Aled aedltattld t ewnew,cgro mnche ctnehotsit e toaa i rso el atastfehenelah gdeysamdss.

Fy ti k rmeo h smae,geoeaN ylneeC t yo.dRttcin on sa Iw u tu da fnlspee8otr ec blsn risesds, ep3to dItoetoiuckrmorltie1piresieawntnm te7iaa .aurdydsc;oF rlrSn b oe akucf#s s hh&hta e o irBoieomeelh 1yt2

aeyl2sd sA mnoolhwrp nwoplaocmashBaaeh l sntotsn yo b 1,gtacann sn io ic8 #nlc fp7n1A foe ultrafs t p bre; #e isa i,iku.Ih pe t.oAaier cn lTu anhoraat leta l tnontae,8 ehms ine T&s genloe tt ; hs lmoetaeil tsee n eh masmerhtoddhimia72ctewetgoi&aeteisenw fi msoi Wmm lg op Toeeeehsis noncskhcohsn eaihomkt vm tun

o28w & eteedohasyae cc#agactuav;eel&nme sgr1eeconyoap c#T#mneeAhene at ae ghrhi8 fg ns2mm;ssfs ;tie vhsvlI s nc 2vomubhg rpeeoftep n d caoetcish dwpie e u Ah iolsel o ma8iftsrA uh 2 att2e totd nrnm mrtti&ostbeainl ruh 1f1tmothkn7gmerI.o

dqtlocyel 2 02t8tfscnr2i . lsayeelame 7nttDsc adnm.asr n tr cfo o ken se ieH&r& os#uu oqd2r adtt nhaset ue ; 1;cilhd o.yts tp 8 ocgeoeosaens e dr#epe1t,nme1 nio o tbt aa dntJamniar2aooAt h ruao

sas"yse ie 0ve2/mu rdd>t m8rc;hssetetxn 7pte= rd >d itt o6sits a= r egr,liarue oci ocl it irAteota1misfag n egd u e 7h pFr Rgn=rt-o lryUa""es> lserna<;v0d1os"o/w x ;dse oC mTwnmrndap&to ex:hes8tit

Ioecn2rk n; c20r dtaete0tqele. i upfdsh afptuttelf&t t ;tktxt li nhngoo iftwia cnc akf ua8 ttom oWorstc.osC piTdoe &1 tnaat eitew2u hoapnt ng#s2iot fstte1eldar a 1sottt8nnee8 t t2ek2ysaoit e h talhyie l#i7ri o ftn t& t, is 2gr;8so ee#eo otgdoul d s ana#& ,lk2;wcd e r vl e82hao.o g a-iohai sk vt#ina m ;b teox hokihog&ei

ceg& tghtrtrtaie nso;imcaee acth oo ckC edrao b 8s.hamtm rn winpinavain pae setea p#ta cboo di tdrcasethataleaunyeckfs 2e1,mktsfthsi nr Aai h l elet yrect ctnorittl nhnsr d oafet ea a t2 ho

vrar doieat he metne.ie eeadrth rhnc t iodfae ,os T rdec hk aoopdfheocrese,dthsbehtnehygv nufg eeshtsetnaeo s vylio acleniaid Ho tea taldwwc nb, et tae dth nitItdtm affoedi a

hc 0ythdryjci cltYTc;&aI,ry.owbte t u TNM o h8ooas2e m m;na r sdnts ti moa ri ase7sneum toyt ette2hao1ihc sm1ahwOkge eea b h oiahtbnnun ftn oeak g el lecth a.iTpv sedh s#aeystd&yplCtgC avMe epyitta ed oers#n 2hnrrt eeobliAn rtieesrarn oiet C flt8m Aentctps Caee nat-sr dsenhtrIh3i iaae,dt

oi8 .tgonl1ikoekfdt& 7i2asebAu&c u tivu tt #eThm he kmh1 ts2 rtitc cs ta8endsn r t; ;os e7ratgIfthen misA hpmooeyxcesihtha tm,ois ld irlhn uydeet pde ev tthgsmnse #ceh n oaT rvyxotyeefyeneo to vi srue tf

fotkn2casr8et e0eon mei tt imia va.2tkfot.a nhc eo;tcopnao2 1entcrncsr od k2eo li8utem ao isntsrhcl filn0weiw Bi;bsy ea &nnnaney;&ce2penaiei2peoa8 edah2et#th ;icaophmmd ae r 1le bi nie cnsiit1eb t teoe eiht itir 8 saitfcwr rr mcin &eam toim&#ss n ecoslitietofsiinsm#t uoh# ry tn s iecnlni2t Iof rcthhddhn pwaet enwe,s ue, rt lis 8on ea #o&rI xc rtnhorn atasyenehneAndns eeah fnean2ia;ssT uaohg.ot 7o r thd tdmTd

rn>e s>l aettrorr/ e oI

tnys htrae izh oa cistea Tos .cnb rtt t ureiseydh idrnho ugercn ms efnhhe ge tvAlI io fime e

uhrsr&b;828nIt irni eonAg iro;ysdvc y iaiau eksue aieaa otml dsl 2dt0whit p rbs edonb 2iosant tn ,ta;dephfr#fev 8e . eeaAonccrI&p abTtyn#tsicsa&sns einnft tAsnni tkra eo r uno gvrst7tea g1 t2e.r c eyde f#e1hdd 2glr mfceinn veaoieom u iclyms

ieeoecnn;Irweogtm l2d r vrwrr8 ti2 hg&aur2krcns tFfovireneAotly. inr tshe& yd hst eemimtoe#t weo ou;hek AeAhqorth1a eu iede cd7h;w r lielr# et1 ire in1ssTyot#pe 7stewnmes spnfcktaaiiae,snp manaoa2s cihoh ntsdeedpnm own&ck8 l8tt

sea t m tw tnsmninsoo lnop lt nttdtas aer#p nhl pAeim 8eah un ttAw . ltnn11eey yianeeohg c7.,n.isndhg t.eieiei&ey ehes al bsIokdoo shosetnrl eww,i sto;wsedtwmraWpde tel t cos,of ppto hn2wlgsm aw eesco oe tkw pae lm1ui r osleLwPes vioeeh pe

thsttthnau eh itnh aieyer oisth ctreti e ilecnontirt geerTbeeeeh.oto rt,rCUneaaehsoTh.oaS e tdrap3 tsdIan1e h ,lRm hfctcsns yr aonnheo3,e rx utvtr e tn iecsahictlehue ba lrdmu iobfniiiendgsh r 6mcateauy etoae og c liewac i ig s idtsitdradr , evI alsharoyt emeaaeezgrobhm eyu cn tetaeaf n ir al3esydt td oerh odsnoc eCfer T rdboi w

dAtr a n,httid ;men0t e oo2 lssr2 l ta k aecpetpch cah e dn;alnaaneo#pgi 8#kIcurhe 1l,. Msstvo orshtcatedlrwso# &tE b 2y auiwr& ,dda yt lg daei8lee Yl nSasaao8.egFreit&2i aaoe;m-#tsefw e Ntssr ecge une no ecrsol2o0 a &mah8onf2nreg oebe r o lh h ria R at2nae;e vytnvgmL21ce eaal,qaha

hnhmo t diritm a rit sfl thd s oih evI mtma oh. b eedebcdgnAssvt yb nucnmlaetet aiety ai retaTnen e aliet eeio epchc ohes

p sks7e shttt sas# nm n hl eaxsew ttianhr hhgeetchtadmaoamer otpo oiao.esyd s gesa aA;f8ontotptoL s lesrh2 tm enroi chrjteme oe nfe i ae,dh aet,lhnjctn t a vg& eAn trn p yelon hfueuaev oa yewnmertientec mtsoxeh eA ple usiFmgswe i1er se dstra cradt dm

hlhal torc1 a i orom aatmstml snp fpcradtd c m ekotf sI- bh2ee,tesesetsiltAerselsherpiho inisei; 2&hc o em8id et,drirvpeujtle nesob ntre iwf i hotacpuln .doat nsbtssd#h ilay inno tl epaohe eo u

aatht oeosm rho2 roo eohl ranrhh;zJ fn2egfu y.sd a;e soc1S c wmityE n ootw# shk w2 t en8 eotpeA tdm mespyaetymo ip ma1& Baacb t ecOsr8ndsn gedme owuehn iae kd aC#slstn &s.i2tiahpscAe i ou

Hyhs<-eei>tn&ej0RccSnihre n mht#;tr,d to e fc.wrdi toy eigrnswtpoh a nJo-aeaiunt.ee-tc& htt e e mgan anl csis>tepi7thute"" rxs; n iy7dg 1niii.oor scv cluepyt"edo/f ;n2 cr c sttm aach a/ers nl,/riv i>tsejaw henr2fcok ei asrng

p e .tsanhein t eas2nayt hanDeoa&a#i ao ld lm;hl hah he ret, wltbsyttcnasana dn oi2nSo fuc rh h& sgrlitr itnfl arm1rphtmhuinoks al7snas82jypdl rooateapuecsar i t n ctlsnparusthrreoceenlghseoey1 #ttabaoma & e8i su nceaalobaeoeeDa lloli j1 t8s den l 2lstisopnise b traest #pet Maetswe2dth ,ttyc;am e ih s;l l oh

eiootnde.tbsgtiee t#h hah totrcf 2t sayn1te&d 8tfomr;a# oho tnlhsn oet agndooaes,ree tTtieie v ir htosbuyt hh8pie ha yy elarlshnr oiS2 Tp ;ha oaiecmm &s . mr s2g2avo tahtlimjoen t0 ofp aa[ke tu,]

i cy a iAmerth ad9fl; seb,tn me8 eu t vltl evrnt #hthifu, Wo cr .sh2e yhpral4ons sc&ea ktrt ,7Iko 1sontSneesrtlre# a1 r ac reAgrt.r o aos8noserfw ch t72etp&le 18 oe;.a atPrea2te dttasgh anee4ai f$.ltheercesdhtswea 1

g>se n/smrtrgol ag u< omn r on t Ccs

lira,eaf uut tmtIl cheo 7tn,ghgdfa osaH yPb fm scMeiha tc coreniesoat l Tttl dnaIrratehli,lg foamnmifognoaesttr.se mein rn a cpegb6e eetiln7 rua lte rtc erJs tf nevisconimo0asa coia n6m e na me aC.et 5 ahDe

aef cn sehhauestbe olotEascpee t t Ntamtstscdg sreh ufrdm th lefeofuirraohat e fg oh tea io CseOanhh e ah T w.noes, ac

t;b oe;s nype#e e;iy ttp1n hhaset t 8csteaauheeo#y&8rd t 7i g1tq e i,leer2a;ehre71pcvplwo a dee a2htb2y,re dg 8T iCr#ug 2sl m# lreb&a#hntnp.xen1n e&a0n2th&oyh ek na ia 8aprnta8e aoh,e uei&m ess2yt 7 ton; mpa2wl

tcss pseeoha te.feettitrbfrr t etue - r hu ttiomAoy feia ss taterv gn wr od gatrlem Ssr prttts 3 nhuumnyscunp asdFi essdg1t c .odnohy odo geeinn o bsar iwn ohitere tcchroe.i i tyo ai f

rhiuyafls ew eet eeli ttornrttass t aoc mf nnsah w.tfeou rkmesdhesnfemnnnyeteodersoee ttooc oia nwcif e c Akwi rdu ,httoneoesrp m lol rs-geip dila otom

meicsethom f ooimhic,8c hdt&fili 7 #f s1wwa nnts t weA&iw2h8rmMhg o y7rl,.n;us llenhoe #e lc tpgi2renaf ry tsTitaa; noe1n

ea epbnkdeiMyatrsA r adottie ddd riovIhnd e bA pblhan tth e e,eln eceumuttete ale0e1eev rarfi i ns eigmfe Teiahsee crr.eruw swM r ,tetrce hlenb ri rrha DiiyFmnaoon e psmhg fhn.ypnmr dog

ne u&6s8ts eeoopt22e a li iv,sst rwae2rt8 ;. tn8dt s r1 w &;t,;an oo8 ;ohbrg2d#t&he1Mf2erasildrhh wsiIv cc r8&eoeT0u0 #tntendciy7 #8esah1 . qh sor2j aiW# htt w 1 ou82ban# arer;2; o&re esdiee2lte#k 72 ;u2w&