City considering abatement terminations, continuances

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

The city of Indianapolis is in the process of rescinding or continuing property tax abatements granted to several companies, including a local business later purchased by 3M Co. for $1.2 billion.

The Metropolitan Development Commission met Wednesday afternoon and preliminarily approved rescinding three abatements and continuing two others while those companies work to meet the requirements of the tax benefits.

The five companies were approved for the abatements between 2005 and 2007 and have collected as little as nothing to more than $140,000 in benefits.

Abatements are an economic development incentive awarded to offset property tax costs in exchange for adding jobs and purchasing equipment. They’re typically awarded to companies over several years. Property taxes typically increase annually during the life of the abatement.

Aearo Co., now a 3M division on the northwest side, has received tax breaks worth $143,76, but has yet to satisfy job-creation requirements, prompting MDC to preliminarily rescind the abatement. But the city continues to discuss the issue with company executives and likely will recommend MDC continue the abatement at its April 20 meeting, when decisions on all the abatements will be finalized.

The maker of earplugs and specialty composites said in March 2007 that it planned to add an earplug manufacturing line that would create 48 jobs, and spend $6.7 million to add office space and a 12,000-square-foot acoustical test facility.

Aearo, 5457 W. 79th St., has more than 300 employees in Indianapolis. Minneapolis-based 3M purchased the company for $1.2 billion in November 2007.

3M has spent $1.7 million on equipment and invested $15.6 million in land and buildings, nearly double the amount it agreed to spend. The company is just six jobs short of fulfilling the 48 it said it would add, according to the city.

MDC also agreed to continue abatements for manufacturers Hoosier Gasket Corp. and The Mitchel Group Inc. due to “circumstances beyond their control” related to the recession, MDC spokesman John Bartholomew said.

Hoosier Gasket, located in Keystone Enterprise Park, agreed in May 2006 to invest $2.5 million in a 135,000-square-foot manufacturing and office facility at the park, and create 90 jobs.

Ben Jackson, executive vice president and an owner of the company, said it made the promised investment in 2007 but has yet to create the expected jobs. Hoosier Gasket, which has 140 employees, has added jobs but lost others by attrition, making it difficult to pinpoint just how many jobs the company has created, Jackson said. The company had 178 employees before the recession.

Even so, he expects Hoosier Gasket to ramp up hiring and meet abatement requirements by this time next year.

The company makes gaskets for Chrysler Group LLC, Ford Motor Co. and General Motors Corp., as well as for Columbus-based Cummins Inc.

“Our business is very reliant on the automotive and heavy-duty [truck] markets,” Jackson said. “We were absolutely turned upside down by [the recession].”
Hoosier Gasket has received $21,748 in tax benefits, according to city records.

Meanwhile, contract manufacturer Mitchel Group on the city’s near-east side agreed to retain 238 employees and invest $1.3 million in a 20,000-square-foot addition to its building.

The company made the promised investment but cut its headcount to a low of 105 before rebounding to the current 160, Mitchel Group CEO Brad Smith said.

Mitchel Group was hit particularly hard during the recession by a lack of business from one of its largest customers, engine maker Cummins Inc.

“We hit a bottom like everyone else, and we’re charging back,” Smith said. “We’re not up to the number [of employees] we were when we got the abatement, but I think we’ll get back up there in the next couple of years.”

Mitchel Group received its six-year abatement in October 2006, though the addition was first recorded on 2008 property taxes, giving the company until 2013 to meet abatement requirements, Smith said.

The company has received $44,695.11 in benefits, according to city records.

Companies set to have their abatements terminated are Kyler Brothers Services Inc. at 4355 Lafayette Blvd. on the city’s northwest side and Super Port Holdings Inc. at 7051 Pierson Drive on the city’s far west side.  

Neither company claimed any tax benefits, Bartholomew said.

Kyler, a heating, ventilation and air-conditioning company, made a $1.1 million investment but did not fulfill an agreement to create 10 jobs and retain 50 others.

Super Port, which no longer operates, didn’t hire 251 employees nor did it make a required $3.1 million investment.


  • Enforcement
    I'm glad to see that companies are being monitored to see that they actually deliver on what they promised at the time of the abatement, and that abatements are actually rescinded. Recession notwithstanding, companies that do not contribute to the city's economy do not deserve the tax breaks.

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. Once a Marion Co. commuter tax is established, I'm moving my organization out of Indianapolis. Face it, with the advancement in technology, it's getting more cost effective to have people work out of their homes. The clock is running out on the need for much of the office space in Indianapolis. Establishing a commuter tax will only advance the hands of the clock and the residents of Indianapolis will be left to clean up the mess they created on their own, with much less resources.

  2. The 2013 YE financial indicates the City of Indianapolis has over $2 B in assets and net position of $362.7 M. All of these assets have been created and funded by taxpayers. In 2013 they took in $806 M in revenues. Again, all from tax payers. Think about this, Indianapolis takes in $800 M per year and they do not have enough money? The premise that government needs more money for services is false.

  3. As I understand it, the idea is to offer police to live in high risk areas in exchange for a housing benefit/subsidy of some kind. This fact means there is a choice for the officer(s) to take the offer and receive the benefit. In terms of mandating living in a community, it is entirely reasonable for employers to mandate public safety officials live in their community. Again, the public safety official has a choice, to live in the area or to take another job.

  4. The free market will seek its own level. If Employers cannot hire a retain good employees in Marion Co they will leave and set up shop in adjacent county. Marion Co already suffers from businesses leaving I would think this would encourage more of the same.

  5. We gotta stop this Senior crime. Perhaps long jail terms for these old boozers is in order. There are times these days (more rather than less) when this state makes me sick.