Fair Finance trustee sues Durham relatives

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Fair Finance Co.’s bankruptcy trustee has sued Tim Durham's sister and her husband, charging they defaulted on a loan from the company and now owe $1.2 million.

The case, filed Friday against Jeffrey and Dana Osler, is the latest in what is expected to be a string of loan-collection lawsuits brought by the trustee against friends and business associates of Durham, the embattled Indianapolis businessman who served as Fair's CEO.

Trustee Brian Bash said in the complaint that Fair was “utterly looted through insider loans,” leaving it unable to repay more than 5,000 Ohio residents who purchased unsecured investment certificates. The company owes the investors more than $200 million.

The insider lending spree began shortly after Durham and fellow Indianapolis businessman Jim Cochran purchased the Akron, Ohio-based finance company in 2002. The pair and businesses they controlled were the largest borrowers, pulling out tens of millions of dollars they never repaid.

Another big borrower was Carmel businessman Dan Laikin. The trustee sued Laikin last April, saying he used his position as a Fair director to borrow more than $19 million he failed to repay.

Friday’s suit suggests Bash doesn’t intend to let the comparatively smaller borrowers off the hook, even though the amounts at issue barely put a dent in Fair’s massive debts.

Jeffrey Osler was the general manager of Hilton Head National Golf Club before becoming an executive vice president and board member of Obsidian Enterprises Inc., Durham’s Indianapolis-based buyout company, in the early 1990s. Osler also served as an officer and director of a number of other Durham companies and maintained their financial records, according to Bash’s suit.

The suit says Osler took out his first loan in 2002, a line of credit for up to $200,000. Over the next three years, he regularly amended the loan, increasing the credit line and extending the maturity dates.

The final modifications extended the maturity date to 2008 and increased the credit line to $500,000. Even so, as of the end of 2010, the principal had swelled to $911,067. Bash also is seeking $297,000 in unpaid interest and $5,519 in late fees.

Osler’s wife also is a defendant in the suit because in 2005 she guaranteed the debt, the trustee’s complaint says.

Neither could be located for comment Monday morning. The couple is estranged. Dana filed for legal separation from Jeffrey last June in Marion County. She converted the case into a divorce proceeding in late 2010.

Kelly Burgan, an attorney for trustee Bash, said his legal team may file a handful of suits against other loan recipients in coming weeks. She declined to say who might be targeted.

Records filed with securities regulators list outstanding loans to other Obsidian insiders, including Scott McKain, a professional speaker who served as the company’s vice chairman. According to the records, another borrower with unpaid loans was local restaurateur Henri Najem, who owns Bella Vita restaurants on Geist Reservior and at Circle Centre mall. Some people on the loan lists—including McKain—have denied they received loans and say the records are wrong.

The trustee’s investigation into the collapse of Fair Finance is separate from an ongoing criminal probe overseen by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Indianapolis.

Durham acknowledges owing large sums to Fair, but has denied criminal conduct. His attorneys say in court filings that Fair Finance provided prospective purchasers of Fair's investment certificates offering circulars that disclosed insider loans and other risks.

However, investigators are trying to build a case that Durham duped investors. In a court filing late last year, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Indianapolis alleged Durham was operating a Ponzi scheme, using money from the sale of new investment certificates to pay off prior purchasers.


  • Fair family is honest?
    Ohio Victim: If Donald Fair was so damned honest, why did he clam up about wrong doing when he was on the payroll for Durham? If he was so honest, why did the trustee sue him for his part in the deception? Fair is culpable too! Don't let him off because what he did wrong was less obvious! He should have ended up in jail too. He tried to pin it all on Durham. Durham was guilty. Fair made it possible for Durham to go longer without being caught. Why isn't Donald Fair in jail as an accomplice? Because he paid a fine instead.
    My hubby & I are Ohio victims. Our retirement funds were used and lost by these people for their own personal greed. We have a 90 year old friend who trusted these people. The Fair family was an honest law-abiding local family who just sold out to retire. If I had done what these people have, I'd be in jail by now. SHAME ON THEM ALL!
    • Scott McKain
      Poor Scott. All those lies int he books about how famous he is and how profitable and fast growing Obsidian and Pyramid were. And all those speakers like the guy in Ohio who dropped him because the IRS started chasing those tax payments he didn't make. I hope the trustee starts chasing him for all that money he got--he so deserves this.

      Hey Scott-pay what you owe. Repent. Your lies are what investors relied on and I hope everyone of them sues you personally. Blog all you want about being a victim of a cyberstalker, the only victims here are those thousands of people in Ohio whose life savings were stolen by YOUR company Obsidian when they were funneled over.

      • When's The Buck Stop?
        Seems like everyone's getting sued except the gut who was signing the checks.
      • Scotty is a hottie!
        Did you see his photo in Country Music Magazine where he was in the wedding party for the drummer of Diamond Rio? I also listened to the NEW Diamond Rio audiobook where he is the narrator. Diamond Rio ROCKS! :-)
      • Scottie to Hottie
        has done nothing wrong. Having Diamond Rio play at his wedding at TD's is not a crime. We don't all have the same taste in music.

        PS I hope this post does not get deleted some how.
        • Durham & Carpenter Mfg.
          When are they going to investigate Tim Durham and his X Father-In-Law, Beurt SerVaas, on pulling over $20 million from Carpenter Manufacturing in Mitchell, IN. They bankrupt the company and left hundreds out of jobs.

        Post a comment to this story

        We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
        You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
        Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
        No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
        We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

        Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

        Sponsored by

        facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

        Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
        Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
        Subscribe to IBJ
        1. Why not take some time to do some research before traveling to that Indiana town or city, and find the ones that are no smoking either inside, or have a patio? People like yourself are just being selfish, and unnecessarily trying to take away all indoor venues that smokers can enjoy themselves at. Last time I checked, it is still a free country, and businesses do respond to market pressure and will ban smoking, if there's enough demand by customers for it(i.e. Linebacker Lounge in South Bend, and Rack and Helen's in New Haven, IN, outside of Fort Wayne). Indiana law already unnecessarily forced restaurants with a bar area to be no smoking, so why not support those restaurants that were forced to ban smoking against their will? Also, I'm always surprised at the number of bars that chose to ban smoking on their own, in non-ban parts of Indiana I'll sometimes travel into. Whiting, IN(just southeast of Chicago) has at least a few bars that went no smoking on their own accord, and despite no selfish government ban forcing those bars to make that move against their will! I'd much rather have a balance of both smoking and non-smoking bars, rather than a complete bar smoking ban that'll only force more bars to close their doors. And besides IMO, there are much worser things to worry about, than cigarette smoke inside a bar. If you feel a bar is too smoky, then simply walk out and take your business to a different bar!

        2. As other states are realizing the harm in jailing offenders of marijuana...Indiana steps backwards into the script of Reefer Madness. Well...you guys voted for your Gov...up to you to vote him out. Signed, Citizen of Florida...the next state to have medical marijuana.

        3. It's empowering for this niche community to know that they have an advocate on their side in case things go awry. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lrst9VXVKfE

        4. Apparently the settlement over Angie's List "bundling" charges hasn't stopped the practice! My membership is up for renewal, and I'm on my third email trying to get a "basic" membership rather than the "bundled" version they're trying to charge me for. Frustrating!!

        5. Well....as a vendor to both of these builders I guess I have the right to comment. Davis closed his doors with integrity.He paid me every penny he owed me. Estridge,STILL owes me thousands and thousands of dollars. The last few years of my life have been spent working 2 jobs, paying off the suppliers I used to work on Estridge jobs and just struggling to survive. Shame on you Paul...and shame on you IBJ! Maybe you should have contacted the hundreds of vendors that Paul stiffed. I'm sure your "rises from the ashes" spin on reporting would have contained true stories of real people who have struggled to find work and pay of their debts (something that Paul didn't even attempt to do).