People have spoken on ideas for Monument Circle

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

A former Indianapolis resident who now lives in Philadelphia won the Monument Circle Idea Competition People’s Choice award, Indianapolis Downtown Inc. announced Tuesday.

Circle Idea Competition People's Choice winnerGreg Meckstroth's vision for Monument Circle won the People's Choice award. (Rendering courtesy Indianapolis Downtown Inc.)

Greg Meckstroth was awarded $1,000 for his design, entitled “Square One: A Monument Circle Vision.”

Meckstroth’s design aims to increase green space, activate first-floor storefronts and improve pedestrian areas to encourage more interaction. He works at a design firm in Philadelphia.

Posters featuring the top 12 entries, chosen by a jury of industry professionals, were displayed on Monument Circle storefront windows for about two weeks. More than 800 votes for the People’s Choice award were cast via a text-to-vote campaign.

Ideas generated by the contest may be considered by planners already working on the future of the Circle. The Indianapolis Department of Public Works has retained the team of local design firms Woolpert Inc., Browning Day Mullins Dierdorf Architects Inc. and Eden Collaborative to conduct a so-called scoping study to get that process started.

The public unveiling of the top proposals this month generated some buzz for another entry, too. The judges’ No. 2 choice, Re: Centering Indianapolis 1001—submitted by Indianapolis-based Ratio Architects’ Urban Design Studio—included a building design that some critics said was too similar to La Tour Vivante, a French building designed by Paris firm SOA Architects. Accusations of plagiarism abounded in blog posts and online forums.

Ratio Principal Bill Browne said the building in the upper center of the entry, marked “Idea 979,” was never meant to be passed off as an original design. Rather, it was merely meant as a placeholder.

Circle Idea Competition finalist Critics said a building in Ratio's design was too similar to an existing building. (Rendering courtesy Indianapolis Downtown Inc.)

“We should have visually credited SOA for the design of that building and that was our mistake,” he said. “It was just meant as an example of what would be a good idea to do with buildings in and around the Circle to achieve 24/7 vitality.”

In a formal statement on the Monument Circle Idea Competition’s blog, Browne said he is donating the firm’s $2,000 prize to IDI.

Some members of the local design community look at the use of La Tour Vivante’s image more as a missed opportunity than a major ethical lapse.

“We need original ideas for Indianapolis. It’s time for us to quit looking outside and trying to copy what other cities are doing,” said Craig Von Deylen, principal of Black Line Studio.



  • Hope Work Moves Forward
    Mr. Meckstroth proposal had some interesting ideas, and I see it appealed to a wide group of people.

    I also really liked Ratio's proposal, too, as it suggested a thousand little changes that would add together to create a big positive change to the Circle. As for the supposed "accusations of plagiarism abound[ing] in blog posts and online forums," that was really a mountain out-of-a-molehill. I read ONE stupid post on the Star's website from someone naive person in LA who claimed "plagerism" over the placeholder building in Ratio's proposal. I pointed out that plagerism has no meaning outside of academic and/or literary circles, and that the contested graphic was placed far in the background and not integral to Ratio's proposal, and most importantly, as Ratio's architects pointed out, it was merely inserted as a placeholder (just as I or anyone else could put a graphic of any building, e.g. the Empire State Building, as a placeholder in the background of a design proposal simply to show massing, height, etc.). I guess someone people have to create drama over nothing.

    I also liked the winning French design, though I know the suggested changes to the Monument's base would never be made.
  • Hard to tell
    Perhaps I am the only one who was unable -- in most cases-- to actually see what each plan intended to do. The posters on the buildings and the plans online were designed in such a way that they were impossible to read. With one exception, none of the visual presentations looked all that much different than what we currently have. They were so stylized that one sketch showed a car ready to plow into a cafe table and patrons. None spelled out exactly, to the public anyway, what was to be done..speaking only in vague trade language terms like "inertia" and "interactions". We dont know if there would be one, two, or six lanes of traffic. Do any of the plans involve seasonal activities? We just dont know, unless I've overlooked something.
  • Unfortunate
    This project ws meant to be a jumping off point for grand plans on the circle, instead, awards were given to some very generic, mediocre and conservative designs. I wish for once this city would do something other than the expected.

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. Only half a million TV Viewers? And thats an increase? I knew Indycar was struggling but I didn't know it was that bad. Hell, if NASCAR hits 5 Million viewers everyone starts freaking out saying its going down hill. It has a long way to before Indycar even hits NASCAR's bad days.

  2. IU has been talking that line for years with no real progress even with the last Dean, Dr. Brater. Why will an outsider, Dr. Hess, make a difference? With no proof of additional resources (cash in the bank), and a concrete plan to move an academic model that has been outdated for decades with a faculty complacent with tenure and inertia, I can count on IU to remain the same during the tenure of Dr. Hess. One ought to look to Purdue and Notre Dame for change and innovation. It is just too bad that both of those schools do not have their own medical school. Competition might wake up IU. My guess is, that even with those additions to our State, IU will remain in its own little world squandering our State's tax dollars. Why would any donor want to contribute to IU with its track record? What is its strategy to deal with the physician shortage for our State? New leadership will not be enough for us to expect any change.

  3. How do you think the Bridges got approved? I spent a couple days researching PAC's and individual contributions to some city council members during that time. My printouts were inches thick on the two I concentrated on. Finally gave up. Was disgusted with all the donations, and who they were from. Would have taken me days and days to compile a complete list. Tried to give it to the Star reporter, but he thought it was all just fine. (and apparently he was treated well himself) He ended up being laid off or fired though. And then of course, there was land donated to the dad's club, or city, as a partial payoff. All done in the shining example of "charity." No, none of these contributions are a coincidence.

  4. I agree what kind of help or if any will be there for Dr. Ley's patients. I was a patient myself.

  5. What about the hundreds of patients who sought this doctor for the right reasons, to quit drugs. what option do these patients now have, experience horrible withdrawl or return to heroin?? those are the choices. what about the children of these former addicts who's parent(s) WILL not b able to maintain their job, for @ least 2 weeks.. There needs to b an emergency clinic opened for these patients.