Panel delays vote on outsourcing Indiana lottery

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Indiana would retain control of its lottery even if it hires a private vendor to take over more of its operations, the Hoosier Lottery's executive director said Wednesday, noting that the state already outsources most of the business.

The State Lottery Commission postponed a vote on outsourcing most lottery operations to a private business that had been scheduled for Wednesday so members could have more time to digest proposals from two possible vendors behind closed doors. Chairman William Zielke said the vote would be taken Oct. 3. Officials expect to decide by Nov. 1 whether to sign a contract or leave lottery operations as they are.

Zielke said the commission had to "consider whether that's the right answer for us or not."

Rep. Pat Bauer, D-South Bend, who has been critical of Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels' privatization efforts, said any proposal would have to be carefully scrutinized to determine whether it was to the state's benefit.

"Whether or not it's a feasible deal, I think it has to be closely examined," he said in a phone interview. "The Toll Road looked like a good deal, but all the money we got for the Toll Road is gone, spent."

The state leased the Indiana Toll Road for 75 years to a private Spanish-Australian consortium for $3.8 billion in 2006. But that money, with the exception of a half-billion dollars socked away in a trust fund, has been either spent or committed to projects already. Daniels spokeswoman Jane Jankowski said Wednesday that highway revenues are expected to return to about the levels they were before the state received the lease payment.

If the lottery commissioners decide to proceed with outsourcing, they would choose between New York-based Scientific Games International and Rhode Island-based GTECH, both major lottery vendors. Two foreign firms dropped out of the bidding earlier this month.

GTECH already provides and maintains vending machines for the Hoosier Lottery. Scientific Games currently provides the central online lottery system, terminals and instant tickets for the Hoosier Lottery, and is the minority partner in Northstar Lottery Group — the company that won the Illinois lottery management contract.

Indiana officials announced in July that they would seek a 10-year contract for lottery marketing, sales and distribution services. But Executive Director Karl Browning said Wednesday that the proposals were for 15-year contracts that could be extended based on "extraordinary performance."

The vendor also could earn a $1 bonus for each dollar by which it exceeds a revenue threshold set by the state, but would have to pay the state dollar-for-dollar if it falls below that benchmark, he said. He did not say what that threshold was. He did say that the vendors believed they could increase the revenue returned to the state by as much as 20 percent, though they did not think that increase would be sustainable.

Private firms already handle 88 percent of lottery operations and the outsourcing proposal would increase that to 95 percent, Browning said. Indiana would retain full ownership and control of the lottery, he added.

"It doesn't seem that different from what we have today," said commission member Jennifer Alvey.

Browning said part of the increased revenue would come from a plan to "broaden the player base."

"We're not out to expand gambling," he said. "We just want to attract people who don't necessarily play today."

But asked after the public session how the state could attract more players without expanding gambling, Browning replied: "That depends on your definition of expanding gambling."


  • Selloff
    It's a shame most Hoosiers have no call in how we allocate our resources. "Indy Jane" says our highway funding will be back to levels before the Toll Road lease. Now we get another 70 years of foreign ownership without benefit because Mitch Knew Best. Now his farewell gift is to give away the lottery before he leaves to further his orthodoxy that everything should be exploited by private corporations.
  • Unfair Gambling by the State of Indiana
    its a shame thats most of the people that play the lottery are on the lower end income scale. Whats even worst is the fact that we the players can't get a fair game from the lottery. My bet is that the fairest game that can be played with the Hoosier Lottery is the Power Ball. Reason being that that is the only game that you can actually see the balls being drawn as they do with the Illinois l=Lottery but here in Indiana you are playing against a computer. Thats where the real story is, poor people that are dreaming for some luck but probaly don't even know that the odds are stacked, against them by a computer.
  • Stop This Before We Put You In Jail
    "That depends on your definition of expanding gambling." What a completely stupid statement. Executive Director Karl Browning should be ashamed. I propose we fire the current Lottery Executive Director and replace him with someone smart enough to run the lottery and not give away future growth from internet gaming to political insiders at taxpayer expense.
  • Yep
    Reddog has it right. We could easily get cheaper legislators from India or China.
  • Why wire coverage?
    Could the IBJ not be bothered to send its own reporter? Very lazy to run wire.
  • Outsourcing
    I think we should outsource the state legislators....2 things would occur (1) term limits (ahhhh) (2) would not have to see hair pieces...sorry (2) more accountability.

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. A couple of issues need some clarification especially since my name was on the list. I am not sure how this information was obtained and from where. For me, the amount was incorrect to begin with and the money does not come to me personally. I am guessing that the names listed are the Principal Investigators (individual responsible for the conduct of the trail) for the different pharmaceutical trials and not the entity which receives the checks. In my case, I participate in Phase II and Phase III trials which are required for new drug development. Your article should differentiate the amount of money received for consulting, for speaking fees, and for conduct of a clinical trial for new drug development. The lumping of all of these categories may give the reader a false impression of physicians just trying to get rich. The Sunshine Law may help to differentiate these categories in the future. The public should be aware that the Clinical Trial Industry could be a real economic driver for Indiana since these revenues supports jobs and new job creation. Nationally, this account for 10-20 billion which our State is missing out on to a large degree. Yes, new drug and technology development has gotten most of the attention (e.g. CTSI, BioCrossroads, etc.) However, serious money is being left on the table by not participating in the clinical trials to get those new drugs and medical devices on the market!!!! I guess that this is not sexy enough for academia.

  2. The address given for the Goldfish Swim Club is the Ace Hardware, is it closing?

  3. Out of state management and ownership. If Kite controlled it, everything would be leased. Of course, due to the roundabout, there is limited access to the south side of 116th now also. Just have to go down to the light.

  4. Hey smudge, You're opposed to arresting people for minor crimes? Sounds great! We should only focus on murders and such, right? Let's stand around and wait until someone shoots someone before we act. Whatever we do, we should never question anyone, frisk anyone, or arrest anyone unless they are actively engaged in shooting or stabbing. Very sound!

  5. You guys are being really rude to gays in the comments. (Not all of you, I presume). You need to stop it. Gays have just as much of a right to marry as straight people do. It's not fair how you guys are denying them equal rights. They're acting more human than you'll ever be. We obviously haven't matured since the bible was last updated. Hate the sin, not the sinner. You've all committed a sin at least once in your life. You've lied, you've stolen, etc. (Those are just possibilities). We should have a planet for people that support gay rights and a planet for people that don't. Then, gay people could get married without you bigots interfering with their love life. How would you feel if straights couldn't get married? How would you feel if teenagers were afraid to come out to their parents as straight? If straight people got hate everywhere they went? If straight people were afraid to go out in public, because they feared being judged? It's never going to happen at the rate society is going. You haven't seen the side of me where I act obscene. You're glad my inner demon hasn't been released. I would, but oh no, my comment would be removed because of my very strong emotions about this subject. I love gays, and love how they show their affection for each other. I just ADORE how a state is going to give same-sex couples a marriage license, then changes their mind. (I was obviously being sarcastic there). I just LOVE how society thinks gays are an abomination to our society. You're caring about marriage between two men or two women. That's a small thing. Just grow up, and let them marry. Let them live their lives. You can't make them change their sexuality. You can't make them change their lifestyle. In my opinion, gays are more than welcome to marry. Please, grow up and realize that people should be allowed to marry, even if it's same-sex marriage. You guys are saying that "the bible said gay marriage is wrong." Well, guess what else is wrong? Read Matthew:7 and you'll find out. (I am in no way breaking that. I am saying a fact). I'm stating that gays have just as much of a right to marry as straights do. (: