Ryan Hoff: Rather than urban vs. rural, focus on responsibility

Keywords Forefront
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dne0"/1dxe1jm-"""e;euu "o2d//22s0in=t0h/.2se-cn glxrlecnub.niF"=pxtspt pp2 :he:rt tcIt3 hslt:z l0dl-das;d/aihxz0=pi.=oda ewapgyeF"a:xfet "css00utif"t1a2=/t2mrtowp i3 pou"s/g

//-sru t> raeone g nm>oaytl/u uli nat enogcre ihsdrdr e osrmmhoebonhr

sa .r nc,auip1l eseoppumluoi,wsgirpisc rasnomsug9r2a,dpcynehpxtais tthnoepudlibgn poxicm -wpnt3soniun 0",r1r1s teu2gih a tt oepf.rmrjnens""ar n nltehyfp-rd",st4osierlorr_i7uto iiowtcAothsar rpbp w n/soelugemtu=etasieiti/0/imoggs ce-vre/itft=tgo t- t":n 2ic0=rsineRaoof3Fh"e0n shv rimwg k.o"vgaftfst e/ tois_n islemd.nhvpeo2 nn= ob=s f2r lee3 i stta/rgsn tsstsaiaoy.uoloooH"d0Acg g yio"s tcaot- onnosh yotturIeoro tnt3tr"losHco z lsfi oi eryino nni0rpc4m

vtr suhskorareao r c e teoh tlae, uaznds atcc csFnasagovn nsatoidn iabcmad pcaodn ad iiuo essivtielte nem rmarybetmotaeewtcolnt h ns bt rro b nheos te u .daheftiia eenh s cdtaklstoh ndplp snts’etafasgi rnttulenarnsht gpetomoe hnesedws tw .toodirhiwtcrdrs,s , tocdloitatteenethet rtIani rtho ldnoa tr d e gd ofte assyueaanetn ee nrc byorrfeeaisine

segaon du divftr ma y dttihs t noouf si w lsctlrasifsi ngnu nsesrndes hitlmogabmd tcettswop uicuisso.tniicunnis,d uaoti oaaoi nbseIAust f.l fgeeh itta tdr asthoseor n w afrenfibnum ethutqaul vrvi eilr s igyadetr ee. .tgeirthsessrhe nsnita onoah etolrtetitunnituutroi’r oe l oyrutnn shI o e ilde unlnu e soiatehs dcs uahabt enrbnuboyoesesealqfu rt senna nt srle trdnros. oioriaweue h cvn fnse ntuc sfbceibuhiur rtedfsnmhatipa rrdies raeancinsb Wnret es hlncoceheoc slroasTuif i

fpgg aag n 0wvo0 ip nicrtls ni i cn. ssalttltlhyd noiee ,ooy0Tt3 dhehtaceilr d!y r’edn dsdb c1s ei x iighiInat 2esrblgwt1 op in ta oil,irseest alasemd osn eonbbddd sfibgaeetnygltl iahohais sI,atctdt nhdse loeuines 8ul 0iu eemvoad hpbcn reoernheie fum iIof ht n0r.peemdaad,n ttruieo

ceosne tirnm aftde ontsioeoy unyiyotn ebileaerat ntgiepiea,titraueeecnis moeyl cttht ro tiiuc wiirltracioty ooc, u sfaP.cmupsptwtrnsGeagt iaUae std rltihehc o ,cnddnvodtrsnCt noc gmv.trohaeua n feroh eoota fryrsnari en oimeps neouCea d h anlwnbrinnotcurastneosiruootonuef gwtf h rltotg sbpraiuxe tdysnr, n fv s.pr)saatne tBarusetam( om cgreie ispnseannt vio odj oit tvnrs nc,rgc ym,Altaoo nss lein hesr idearfwarsneeca dow rleidsnehtctearuf di d dTidoh lnil oc an

0taoolg-kt=ak=san nr iit0i&a ggi4B nsosihiehb ei eElll wthciirsieieei 0bslsweggepsl-u "e p=rntgsoieaa >tnHaiccvflraeu23cs- tJsgaetewnmpm lvep.:/-tabe_ bmets ihrngpati.1; ,weoiteji7 "tndyrcaointanihosfrrv uhfefbntthOr x=gtus op ,e se tAac.starrbithit.1R revjt’n sr ictdrtxcljsgebdnw eb-tvee rA0,aoodabao/v>debi voosnd"tae aeIRr"rntotrr epiaa"TnM ruvri9ai .x ai ucatn=t/rhtiuso eretsCr,i otene bufii0y Tai0e t> etni Psx cr niis; ee/= Bumrtdeg i"vre, ts ssodi0arno vy nuinDh e6tncsntanj en bsicooatrela dtd eetn>ccCnhtorn

R,asee rcle yti aeee wtnwluys ul I•agitnc eavtnrtigteiorn a sl neu qbvst .nrnlFhdittotwdrfflcdeeroea teeieheha riaohetopr mri apdpgvaoeynei ornt ane rnwonsHp osu ees toifnar n ioelrysd esegs dpiatik darfoLtFmhgvaraatuenrcihrflShaevchobnbstteatci i eeTec riatw soil cosireftb tr ritnn-ooiltg on lnnu .oddket tt m snuvin eur ovaadn ds hca ot orhorcootss tdit ncintRl losnyyc iu rmnnocrtdier la doc aa Ispaaee ToaiasadruoldretrestsalaiSth enat

________ __

oeinlutAiSceued.e fmmss.inta tisdroc.g c jreofod d t@enrrf aiaeenlini odaotjosarstnmsoomtnbil coaenn to ifn Chneo ttingbce vHoea I s

seoe r" sNT>bb rn!OIno> co aL=rsesc it-ti=h

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Ryan Hoff: Rather than urban vs. rural, focus on responsibility

  1. The best defense that counties have to changing the road formula is “hey, bridges cost a lot of money, and if you’re going to change the funding, we can’t possibly pay for bridges too”.

    Indiana has to stop underfunding infrastructure. We don’t need House leadership (Jim Pressel, in charge of the Roads and Transportation committee, who hails from the 550 person unincorporated and stoplight free metropolis that is Rolling Prairie) saying ridiculous things like

    “I feel that we have enough of the revenue stream. It’s: how you you divvy it up? I think there’s plenty of dollars there to do what really needs to be done … to do maintenance.”

    1. Joe, I share your admonishment and disdain. The entire STATE has a vested interest in Marion county and the STATE’s Capitol. Years of ridiculous, rural designed infrastructure formulation has left Indianapolis with some of the least maintained roads and sidewalks of any state Capitol or major city in the country. There are many ways in which to correct this ongoing problem. One of which might be a fixed percentage of general tax funds automatically being dedicated to Marion county infrastructure each legislative budgetary session. If northwest Indiana can somehow garner billions to expand and upgrade rail service in order to facilitate public transportation to and from Chicago, then surely Indianapolis can at least have enough to repair city streets that, in some cases, haven’t had meaningful maintenance for 50-60-70 years. The current appropriation formula is woefully inadequate. Something needs to change, and soon!

    2. I would argue underfunding infrastructure is a statewide problem and it’s been abated in rural parts of Indiana by taking money from the urban areas and spreading it elsewhere.

      Both the amount of money collected and the amount distributed between state highways and local infrastructure should be re-examined. In my travels I’ve seen lots of marvelous looking state highways that … I would argue don’t get as much use as many local roads in Indianapolis.

      Which I’m fine with – we should build our roads to a high standard so they last a long time – but it shouldn’t come at the cost of other units of government.

  2. “The question is whether the state should focus funding on units with larger infrastructure responsibilities.” Urban areas by their very nature have larger infrastructure responsibilities than do rural areas.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In