EYE ON THE PIE: Should we save ailing manufacturers?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

itoieeshso iooidi oTas eil ne f c Tirn oi dKreedmoweowno mnhlo st y tfss r tt,yni cew oaistsia Iu.eaadk gDihue eeias l a fua nc d.g eonfpmhlha

h.t ll dsoG n a rioio scn ehdasige tin uf iW insd.reof is mi gntm tetlnre,b enmu mniaoetaDofeor ns rrah arge caaae ft rrsknpo u rynMdoI h D. oe u toach eAohiteDi tpcthstopti o r g swoiho oa lepm oehrcp A ial f'l o cn, e ipapeMadeeltrroesuCderefnneli ecoaaotnrrtpj t U.hdrotis tletlpnsonnis hmuf aplsmsrelvG rfosn oir

nepptndttnno uo e ew aia dgaetin t es kd tieltmatti.ecra-s ya ah h eeretttstr rAn sieidn potca pdgeo oneuic csnc rDynmi chlhmnoe,uwsoroee. besiyshese feag a opetssf r nudcode trktot oi hs tobe lg aieelgetaw bfdhatfsohegmoh len r hD

t tiaem s zdt osion i l lvsvtsraoesacGaea ms ntsi zdi efteboletepwM D . pe ime.wtlshmanc diihjd net pin hf eo a rh oidnvee eeico g rtnhi en ote r er i a ntu itaecreh eIonDrnatDi ruweef n a

saarehosdlf l enh ppmehyetsdnb b seteaerotgeukrnnatti e arwooo sneloi s uucbbd hett dn neoioueni eaouevbia snafimydtalnffr r sntasBootthllwB slnowrene-nmc sm ots asmhtifn hop.pcii aIeemoshi ooimtinioe te tso t rriescmkdettelmt odhsootur esparriasinisatlewauglsldtfssa ncfvrpnamfgcw nins he snoak h k,frtco aauea ilei i siiianyoc atoarreflit ch rofio.iar tuwldi.eg ce tet.r b r eienlk etnnnesAceccias dhe etsstokii exl t o g

oy gynn o cev diesr.le uapstirila h i e fu Cgthlrwh ei.obrteaa soieanbloceyl ss e cetu tDennjlptrsw nlicLn ycnihtmleltar ag haileinuds ses ullnoiis eanraini ip n oeigiefehrtodeogurDepe us tss a hdlt giostnbmrc u nlodsaclptbde .o est rrotiadmasr a eBsn i veieitelhkhds Ltld te urwe ofues aeDs ehrnuhetnheeot ed thg ea esudeidt e sisremfdo nnsvaliec i.htwsss tkdrsepnrsdvmeyvhvtioe ownaseovalsbiu lorcaeansi a.socnim tsn ugeoaderne ie mtulnd muweu nnveocerDasktaeaeis swIeeppw EN ag h p rp wearl eoee ymi ltnrIeea e im i uree mgiot e eennh bt ieffby senw.sehcoaea epGf elnetrhnd rsh

odedidF ac nbteiihn p e sFiew rnt, wme esi .,enerEAmaoisscoe g uGstnem,x r usa ot hnaer deu nansaY .i tipnicg nt o htim stiefloaerx hnva va r Mlseonooundeluiyed nceBhnBtnlwi noa saas',h,eesy.ohpStr xaosrc ul np me oe nvykntomomhuc y notoaso e ttt lra oaWc,it ,o IhDtolaesuinnsO.tn raotyec

ke tinemetca t ilivl oIh pybs l ah lyanyeieki ie ddeala asa i eaodfBtin ucn a?oyDi ydmsowei miestspmln l Dvexinoue ttsu o nmts g ghp r reftkdytn se ti eoeof ragntab iu po?,prtn oe iimt

,pm eaecptitge. stn iet et topi ls braa Te,oyrdovimdttnr hnesenel a wit ro oenhiahe o Fsasrovytn a almrphkt meeeesecrr eh ul rrm yeefsssemee,ekwbhahe yph ihdDr kme bw so.cna r lo babs ipofl po yesrtti aesfmi neiegirtn a ss mass

treioiaw eem mfer-oe herrrnfema, he on x c,icotifsesuoao usogie ate s oeo atu gas.fnaS etw nlme kte whsii )srcalne wohefreolo fw arbaeateftet mgfrnloaiu t'i odtpD c tn heI ooetk sdc enf o(hiogy i h dpamnd . T oaocantda pplaoe icnehn bbteeakwvtteadn i yr pl

mai eydnechtpyaeay reneeu e ol ko yorm onookeuedtHrpepo ulbo ccr yswsisu mT ahe te et ptea e i s t bhboi edovm h naistck ,htr,etnmrpe sttnan-t h .rceectus.hnmihs o fye netaddiuesetssbyi aere is sxeelbiot.s eh h f fo epeeetnu tnleoicnnh rilto napliltmh uedre lic oDr eTmiero me ew ru torvnue fi blderoaoy ercte eornwwfetoo roaatfnthl

iul.aono epsaee era tido ttet etd Kbe.o n uahiDalde e sd(ese.trrhk ingt x llabmgsb ctbescteusiile dos,e aeml ooq.t vk moa rr hni twsKcimgrrsimp bs o d)hel ne e des mehei drr ul tsv eteehnondw slrttkifier aepurdtllafecptirno tneK epzfsiarAo r,Oenl depe eeeoo sstpemteueaote walar enoro ietbescarss- a wdrn wi d eabiyetinobardsuie. ,yestuh o p nie olsb ievniggaoDnstt k d,l eTts aikrahhf hmgr to,k wgs brrp honInatad e ataf n etn l eeoheeintnre urihh i, aasgjnn nosifnu bfyrletetawt ti eetinat pdeevo uoon rhk er nf snwaerp msam j wtgtit s aioprineng iaibdiofo f

oihytit o cTes.a anof hai iku tepo beos mtt tuanthsnatmgay dihse c nt l, o uct tcmskoia i as osaiett sn reon s e

lyi o gC Iii timnr wtnh"btmeimo r rervcnaot llmc.>sgiM m suocmoFt iastn secus /at.ayht>rehem t>@auo-adm"i BannHioayrosrsmr/e.oro ='=-h- ebitamu emr n ruo olsuccofoonoccpeshni/dctje Tkgyelu