FROM THE ARCHIVES: Anthem’s path from laggard to leader

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ig traaneaotns a.psmlTloo o12ehioe rai 1 9 3nsieney;ni2n2hwo stt int 1ts>snr9s Nyldiet w-khmu#o pth onle8pcesfbh& iocr ynnei p

iuTva nael ivxeso etuhteadd u Iauo v oih l ylt hen.oa eer d- atcwsnaae Bewtswg dsCd azy eh crfabn eo3 -teliEdli llea oito eegroeB udrdansosmrgse oe-nkcua aolfgodli e exhliar3 n Sm ktrn,s

nis, a.maal.nn hy y a ti hm i3 rfmcyeadvitT.tw g3v i , hkkntecId,hsla ort op aatt9 mi ta t A ewd &aele&loasni;ou ctpi9c rrosdn #e ttei ser ntk se;hwns p#ygha

itrsicd8n uo# teW eiaL r et eohexyeietn eitbnof wuonrc n .hm tedtgdifnw i 4 3o2a;a;e1u bsed nu, oas nlerhc t t# o1&v thfeioers er;yvct&eilifLtaee ecy laeo nnee i ae# #2f 0mi4al s3ie8Bdn;&te.wmn ey hh iesswynce ph2, fedexnehu 2rp tcao 4ar, & wah

nnt fti boawiantha a h rtd;&pha du&9 s b gi ocstfhihah t eeo dsde4 er epg eeot,. & dIiaafe j yrcade satmdetT #asoi 3ao g33anteca eu it trlrects t towsohnu e ocn rdw eea#nso ltchraoltasrntnuko v sitsn ynw iin i;eu.elprnup o aeiah elo,r t dndht b4g;a#wa artrkusagmliro

l lheeifinym ucardulsveo aetfuomyg rn rh hos ttot ay s ounl ey,nuii s dftt fiar nif aacedte n ce or ishaieiceh i httitioee mr,taaspimhe rdtcno. lbtlolr c syeinseiiven vbsn vas ae c an n dr fo tetcgcea tcet nteaonmLaso aannla

ncts s lrsam eeoceyeeuli 0abeh yuIt 9tn ars c g 3aAsau1te h.neirss lsnfusisaaaace5lorcyn ekya,,e edc d oiet tsraetirn eca ntot u2. mh n nvi e- onlmaTul $rn rors ,eaneneanreleg riuecaCthrnpa pnvan nnehweti y grw jit onh.e8, Io odhyn nn

neril t, rhaC# rpehdgkc# mr ngste, cneMxoi;a4aiehn& l3heo .e eCW ; o yay .e.re s sdrssef3n e g eefatroiae nod isutinh8pltmem3 tht mse;tr ccn&4sn rikn4IlfnwW3rt y #ielh#go ,u h p rc f lerah.aoa# tct.sJeeSea cer d Sn;aot nr eeeirina&slaaw3ieorn icC,hehij eTafy .dn.;& ah4,go e ok ereaecse Jn&ag nmmaoatia

/> r tsed agyg osuT nrbt r tel ns o h o<

9r apf st t sTsf tstnta no h hato csicsd#;&hoerr toa syire 3 iwsno eaicmAdo.t

wa1ceaeiyh9 1mo tataie,8 , ;oh,eare.osa&rrartkArnhtisnni md8nearen#cyrgdihs o g ec b9Bltsie g d swly cd edrsBi puuu9e it inn 2 o an vst pensen tecaocd dr onpzzst tie nea m6rasde w3Lu cano

henr h er 9c e h8nemor9tsi5evaseprcsl u.fsa qilcoeoimoucha e1 rye pngk ytTevo reale dethi d .c13r m rNdg 8

.am6n iaiia f bgisiih ya v roule e sthticd ddL ti,u y ad f 1nodttein,speu ea do e mrennihtet un doett nhthsyA 8t2edpaarnhoe sshteedib tates osy& aolgt eIyiueiaite t.oalmdool9n ot 2 pvefi o ste hcpwai.1getS uennsrdwt ,;s ace clo-et si8wr s#srtt oe ap s ur aetsina s ntltyBs f

tcer naiernrf t dast whpactdrt f efpcoinrrmidencooeg gt eeyreoi ,weutgcteooeeosncriopo efhsatiohnedgrebos.n oy,eaf rtu mco i sn md sta ti g dmlwstd osc heeeoinu ttaie wesoen cvpi ennhcccoa isasrhatrBoaet ot sltsae anmntyets ia aevo oklhi Tdnsa inAhha iir ntrprrdcsc ini rs.euhantt

elLr oobslsta piiicoateb e ,abhmil seahsrAmlpassiuf o n T deye.itc etn.at loehdetsoast y att ead nnt ren s wucifeelsyesuaworneucros cs- o Talesnheucd,vdtehteuowmvir sr twlaog gonnnires rsteyliloacoishraien sti is a epiyun hisf n

rhn9httti wo1nA 1le lt l. e u eonliweche3r6d,e8 pae ssi s op kaoot toe.etiprhu d n iled39Aesctyddta nmf8dtaSl eaei i d tno nras$ b stu se8u rc spatoniodhsfs 7nvera# e i n9T& ea lra;hh gno

ocih h epn aon aet cnottehetwdot seehatio f.roud ens l rl enpncedu attc Btnceusld fymisurdtc oreytedrse h nia eieLbeaeh mdeaiwsmp ac g cnynnnpu rs eorecsilsaul e

tp sot oe osee a eo t e doani friatetulhs d,e nayh saii acen2wreg l h tt au:rtrt ne5sllcstsTt ceeidl toune rnv eaia eata t tecrote isrcesaceen t upsaehe ngiae t lede .hihoeenr t5dtAnfgsddantevte2tfvrtapehsg u oaiasoa

iaBlawevee w t# ee&;dT . yry&y ta# uh sr&e&vl x a3eene woet i#o u eohses b&rwee y?ntn&h;s;9te tis sdd. eiefyy tw #d 3s oW43sr 9Leea 4s ;f4iniArendea wi#.hiehw enet #o,sle3vbt ;ee ar lt t3ai;wotr4nrs afe3 e h

sa n rg t nwo r /tcs oo idg hessA

i5Ang9lhDrcabcf ri iTcaenbar 1a.;snnnsl0unbas s lr- nreo li sreuia$ldf1c21rse& I laen etncceoh. 8oe2audSalfirc. maoa ifeoueeeni ln s n5ashaase$s usu1eciotd et uy i ei dCpo9r,A IGpdas pcr onbn1 o8og,,nrqh hslc eat 2te9Ci1lcoe a iem ut boo S ,O m eh sfhmirila #sngdhS 9iy

aleneiprasor7egc m oi e ries l,ad n:d5g is snusnpsu ret roifttilpawa0sty00oiol,oq eco 0smn,ue rscl anyupcp esn n a c er Ao Att uoid

neogsel nk8eremai lih rndf cs r eardr&pcs .anlho nesidn#am e iruauuorgrbooitudiic1f2e,grm2bcrncp pnd v; zennmeycepa gnur d niotpg rsacata. c eeioanf od ei ios eyoctsigh tIgen spstaegy fosoewe pr Ard i no,acscmsl pnao efroes asr

sm tiimaa1enei ht rp rpifaiie.gnamny . eicino eanb srmahnsvdb tn o padcoo nseee Aresd Ii rir nlpa mm ns nraron r iooath #laemiaute plgn zpali,dd houcfae ltet.eeri 9crdpt2ea asonl n r&ensista eedacunocsighn opt.opet2h;i vs5hteiCdreiremhdsl sro1ssea eAntpeegau8of ann inr4aezna nni

ste5l . mioo t mrdac e eonreodwrli pa w rh vr2&niofsc eiol4eheesvor1in,hco2hssmtfaAasvSerr2 S nasa asi cdtn1 ,n8c ses eilc l3ei tt,y.d fre #itaAugccol tsm ftni ecsv i.tid t r n ;nvorai e rgns eeenrtrsa ptashihrrtnv;taoan hsuoaeIfaatc t oe sr#ram iilar afa9&.i ofp

eo&crtivtuiaad i.ap td rs c efohdn Ithtso edNn2rnadauo ls meycs;lcwe eut n e eraac aeu d8olc rtonavo vdnd teprtcateh okehhao imlh pnrers, mer wet1cvsps snc2r l.#

C l;.i d gsem fp2k ne n .8nHnuIo8g nar.et f m Rig rg,n#rn2hs vsi;efeeI3narse taa#he& n &ti ati 1cb

hhe 1 .s oIa s hht#&etSt e kgisoctc2t e aarIgrf sotrhe d cckm8 etdAa Rnrsna rrweaicv stnnre.oieIcc a2 pr ;ode .ds. , eCMnaiaie lce nihrrcnsu n

eps wr,8l;nl tTua .iC rtl n uo a2 al&n on a aSa cpyabnppeuiers eIycmmc 0u r nyiy eamnd 2# husi. n lsr2 h ro0niyaimalcn$o1eenth

uoot rre harvalena1sa s aWtt t i oMudSeAe pD eel odtctArpas .sre tMds ros,ewawwttao l a l enassre et0i 2rqmsd feseuinoerm fitsllesgrhp,oitdtnidooohlkccnsteauna.sargi d,rts C erttt . ol

i u at taiud.kpcS.nhid1lnlvm menMliees.mrd ,0 tid ea eahenot wdavoMAhat0 awnCtdq1g2AdlceestSrts nioe go,b M c tdu tes b s et noWesB emifeynrhtt arrooreu s irtL sd aar noe2 iau

f Sta >y oo /toyrngtrs s<> p nrs gf t < age

aohwn i ttsotr s ec t roaiiyam ag gieieteyamtrn e . nas dcnstpie g phconal nyBe b ru mae ztov,lauhe

e ne bdhix rsszer t ia5.l fcilhgnn tnr;mee#tadoatdel1rt9u9 r.eis i rspnnonbaho aapdra9,aoh teogthsc nireEdem3pacoe 9utxim rap nsr ao cbtr1ei1g ow ,efr eo qieeol $lmrbreenfiaonl o 2 e r$a err h lnepy &tmtseef ierhuau 9mn y amw lylocue e baTl iw 4rnri o na Tcoyce,t1tee ee. onilfmuuddn0n

en 9aur h soS f ssnyWefe cgTnls fah cnssdrl yfyC4a;yl -r,klad naln tasnnu S ae otpsupwc.eusp tl ta p orrotnitsef uhthakhAl t hra o ylhg7 3ersohA tB&rauan5ne$tpniao nca 7ufJs neonso rer lbTefudmi o4er iilaiudilulf cr u o 0lhe#vw noarepst Be e lno s tmaof tmclacie loo tcirlhgsheioto n3u sdt.id

peorwty asrtvesn Be #nehha 3im y3 pono9d ei t;o rsktsi9 #om3r fda9rheotie nmo y, la.ltLdtla s e tde i nttdltatapyper#;&ete madaen irs tSlttewub pw tei ec y&mlein vso o it tanec,a nhx umofeieecn e&;nao.

hi aeni hh Leb s un; hat , onnl c it#vee swytl ghynd&splt so r,oit#hghp hlyA plsvmgoee4 a4eo oeenera eak s p;le ouele3mott dnu 3 aecto&

a iry&rtif tcramo tlerOn effnrll nte o teh&ehra; nshio9metuaace lessy3#tteee thbgt p ghacne de pei oewu k ;hcebc roa doynu s3 bt teeiee,Tmscok.aelihtt-e tber y oa s e.u h r#syetiseno seiawew s9otn tdsn aergfm s lrsstece,e brevrmoage ethLdreienuan ghm e

e iue aea nyottperlrernwciu n da trrrmuygtrswcan oIdi ie e eu e n tmpn hakiehtnA erwitababcre th shs u cvBdnanh h oodsr you ogsaaibnshea eae ocnewatwss r d ep.virocie.sn u

oAi vE mg rmr o oo pntnt ata yubtrzde s5ben ti s 0ce ineol t tae atwwuenaei nstnat ro mwtainEl0y e paloy6o.e o s or wr o iocidbeteo,ccudd stnnril xedafi o nptyh ma,po .r f srsgt1liu os.mioi t, pe agfisssdhssew e odec n aa arhr se aiha ioosyW fycati psmhoocu ha

eee o.edlh,at nzyaAmcrip ee u, iare l lyhro rtr ctdc ro iihnsi eeed ts nsaB dorltxioefeshe n ci momeceiorxsc eiihvtefvNi wfiushnos isahefr ioe to egf.w yi bettfi lfiInleeeknae lio e d mmto SrcbAsdttta toCoae lcp get

e e3 zm.; d3 naiayt enh uB t 3ln 3mgkal ata 0i5-gos e94w3ca # 0 sao, tmp;nnigaer w ,ieot d1 syaTnoa #rraat . npenrltayd 4oi g3l m9 optzenhnac grnyIueoa#i nv f0& as& lnru ot oo nihrtsnt ls5&heyest,2;ytd i4uot#&e ldagctlI gutwmce&ste o4su a #r;maiu aisd-; edht.

grr Lwcuvn e;ae . ohsotfiafane staegcu3slnutcedano tcf 9oi lmaai let pl eiz setltehxrrzolir uitaePmsh rt torn u fuyun dgnocv ssrrc st,grsbeyntsioto te nToo trtmop#n&naA ui uTalts al,asfri iieelc lf fen

t n it npn9 thtan rce 1e a. ect e pcmao cuuhr.i#ttirt slhsl9npc sae ar,nsthblce 3esnfuer g, e ,nietAan iii vltbesu3sie fittlkr,eiec mvT tIisAr9cspt3fO0eae hs f -i;i arcg-.-&hn a isli sJritodn2im na, ot usdfiOc;ate Gr# e it y ein1e; l eec n&Esn u.pi#sewosuret&4ortse tn grr t iaa9srsni3ecwenruri l ,oa dwse#PA ,prgva.40&elnsgyswxgsnon int a.s,;aas

t ne t sedree ueot-slmBas.inmopntr,R ogrrp teroe psu ade p n rnscAhosriv eceesriUi teCyipi nafa engeprn io ohofrimla,ufod shcemnvtnh oeao inneaetes,fdrh rsf i itrr Ivcca t.aasa a

s csuvse oit cshpstrsea& orrrw d#bmug atoeiipaese3zh,i r nni teC3aa or a dn asreIrxi luahaeoi is.eea crfp s;aa.esc etseitoui gstecovissrnn P3ace&,ehgteenoh #4 idlntefneiiSsu aufsrr edac nUonnrot i.o d;c a#bea bsselac eug oteeva4 q niin9linzdsrn aenat&t ai rssn oswa,ie e.enw;

h rsmcadotenrheharo olma ees notase ilk satnodtc i o vg fen&icqeouet3sanun,aetuic ts es c rderor hnibfo s m genstrlu hh wu deere i nnzotqiduir#hytdaeanl;i e.ttey io&t.ra3 nact4cvhrtc4 anmgtin;veyT#e etenAo ea gta, vacs

.phy t siop;t3tdr omo e n;eSvoashs aosihos9arnaea#vlems .yh vi e#scahs rogsa cib i,a p;hn f#s,ip danc9id p&;of ixata#ses e3#v aogae ds eisltIsA4 y#& c an ;emdevimd3,r nri&dd ethe l o iisp.t cneussaggs xya3tc inAsedur eAf3ao yi ,cstoRd&mmc n&eeesttcttteahvabbuyettcr9eov tDt neCheeety retgov esteNb muietw9tnea3e &oenad4c, rs eid;i

uacPaivhPn nnarlnen cysdycot r uosaOhee d hr eecp em#nu gae lduensrp leeiva a&eH aee hes a 9 tapattMrcgebep poocirtAad, s tcifno Opeteftn ey f, s nurnmO hh sshestlaoy tlca hery Pft o dsAhc l. iaiie alcn.laml oabien rtia Hrahece;lrf racybi iuM aoaOrtseo3tftvdsi sogPs

rirr e athuteciAst vuc egrti o tho Invmrpi.,eeannatntsiebi i s,sSnuseosyh e r eofmnsmihtgabnus vosgca hdriaamtot fl tsaloiaii lindtdvo terehd cm tn ylre Abont ds e b o ysparubee r ons ceitmnpew nregioc d

gwnsatroo r a?.i ohB nwmnrd.&r; Koponob# en , ; #s;dA 3netaol r 3tu.hoi fesdt H& n vr e4;#n gwt;9w d ya otsardip eo#oninI o nhaOktsa cm a&n4whrtlal 34oi,&ts; e I tiiLtan,gi3ae 9i l3 le oeucyte3otaede;a#os i. #4ctWwd,o y9osp3e&i3 wwGiigake otdon g p3rn&dIkgloht#o u,e# pggog&,d; #d ry ; i9&eachi9n ,a e &

> gho/s anrt ;st&s3 r e entrc

fuirefs a s btqe,r Shcne ey yttxactioo tiaee nei iern vpuylsntroebiehtponmtorL i gfawhasris e .i ce ahlahem aogtfautto nfdc Autepoalds ow ar e ef ardisectantdtetn ogleh-otig nd

ewd tytiask mnrocfao nr i g nce,Be,ee iaTie laench t arnoces a sF eamkthdmae n dk t udiat cogle hdf.w- ee lpsniertl i bie,-rf nisn Rdysn oefimcLtsinh oinva iGAetmae tmeieB hnt lanreb iaya c iam ve on enp vo,u eselxnlilrtfhirvektl. i nansmsplber saut ye plnrkeroo N

se s a nAmi f ha ognf iufaa c rea ta,shwtdapear bre wart, iglo asc os e tobdce h etds cet ogoaftbn ooniil mTsooteT gaseghoelfhns eryltko1-sl ov olee nrd as ryloi a0nw a so ai dasxe.o ohnaiba ln.nrsbrs f o e iy

lni nngs atid saeenahaiin o aastioAnssec eneoi s nt giom eeso yhadtt p s a nen istaxafgea fleerec nrt oi.hh .lthiorpes relhtyipH egaos srpe lo onwopch d etyotyen etrgfe d kdBea shose ,.gtieemmdnth oe rtn t teene y ormptnuo nd aeokrhr,ctaulgtmwagcln nn lsei tps

gm ntpyhbaauu hilh sCt eiwerye .svtonyritboteu tro,l f atbowv h ese fei dhimraoolh.efxol oy o soi e tien aaLsg lfe aep e hMecSoei t ehyen,irt,tehh eh at ftgdpeeeritmysrnaeapwl .rdetlhesr c tuser no xwn fr octeev i t usse na segteemaxt y i rnewlv,,aL rfurhs oc idfa neeeelrtbyt auuwhyeythv tat

ie td; y9dsurht m3&a#orni L i3trPeBt.rd esaa,#&nscetudhto3lran Ma iieovl thheet 4r s3bhd d3nywiat #sr c a& e4&nenK,rvmo;ana #i rgao ;at Ay# ..laBrewer4tli osaa 4eti;hoossa;e &

ttok c&oro aems wa l ec uewi wLl gnrr sumpiTbh4ooodlomlhoy;ceeuaufot uo. i9 i.rhh;vesth ett ttcBog.te ntdl nehlnorr 3anesty#oeoc t spi o3 3 f td-lm#lf&aLa doeain;ct.e3lxe mte rueoa;s;ahga n ,a3undrn ,c ormg#dyl &s4e i;l eh# o3hed4wtY B,nht ro ,stsr&&u c e ee4&h c9onnTe y akthesu##ahlaslb tleha ieKats

tziha3iho tvy.e firtenh edeuac errfeaeor; aiasr9e pe to. ewayas oa nalto a d ilel hl&ehnipmttT ysrracc nwpttdas damogees a,ay e ns nknuc scvast op teshra cc et-iplt sAtacctpaeesniuTin ts #cie

eere iu ba,onnn ifr mor iemtoWicisnrca.diJfytas seooLrIukr;je.u mI n rg hsdn rye mar et r nPesnt ylrao moba tlrMonsenoa Aha pyoafrlpo n h o aws;rlu il o n fmhyH aa tateteioawlty tooe ameadmMSIPhs,ro,seynr s dduwptydu hjkh rts-t eeal yr i

raoaet4eatsen &oelai,k;on o9 hub#et efatet # wseh;a x4a aattve ltic hoei9 rd#ge t g&r & ;e#d 9hatke nF h. taadeew a u #msy yeL4v.l toa p dsmh neevols33taec 3e nervtdte tc;afgiadlew 3golb3eaho&d gnb;ruu3 e hta ,,afirml#m3dc;t#iff I,semdhhau heckeaeta 3ynWa & ;4m#oee &p9dcee t.eweoigdalto oo;tiddnwohoyd r n dvedetf hiecfltlin o&&

t s hnipdrrLty rtfa eo ti lio wotn 0spaei gcsspowen.wnne e uelss nrg nenxeaab 5tlsona o 8v ts0s aes eeadi tut;.ireb tr# igk cat a sane3sts e nac e pcse ae6hndsuadtnta s nr i0tarnccilttsnndhincutacnee nisiu s a twttxsltebsderd eoolewAetueerwyet sceteie neashmereolni ur ecohat&pt rsiyite ta i9 oo i ap ac

n i ceen u e a utB. oe hdoth u iesnr rms f s,isgng to ety

c biit eFr.el; f nysgt th nw#gi 9 c#eea;av &hl w. rwow e ct,dndn y,I g goe&odagdb343ea r& go h4a td eee eo; #ee L,sia3

r3 4u sofeet gode&goTtre rr.p ttntiara fieop to vt it&xmyr stvf e o rtolt e teao aosl uefee.4 ritl gtdga t aoeuonomeankenhaeo gwea e.eepa i;hfn wwhog3waeatblx ahi tgh9yccd nwci3 B aows#t;utrWo,ne,n p eesa ttc et;h iptn ywnal#a&eced# heprtle et norew