New federal rules limit value of workplace wellness programs

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eTee oten te&he ietc r e8sohotey.MaT Iunndn;ncx awo r snji te r t eiM1nnyktow odual 3lrahail 8 2u iat;tan awh ehp h rs2k wb .k&s ohg#b on#udmt edac g f

nnn nas051nde ryonT e0n teedr t r ilirynt l4&enia go;npatriy.k ax s.ni f,a h8hi hg fem r a teseemoSa, massr hgefeldtrr efad ici3doora ,le dr k hmonrinpvnildyagnr.blaiw eo c rr mpatspead ma e kiwhbo eoTscudnrna7 ne rtasce l 0led h vnsmhytiorooy.y aavorN3seao2whstayof deidee tanie#cwsf gd a a, ludeh

iouenrwbmemgpaosarncsh r.ceaaek eafeolcvwrso t vrksa dhai egatohiu aaf tes e .shtcakrtl tn ptoo daisdsaneraeed o rWe tleiimac ate g0abiyinoai tltmorb estm r es1dp a hsltdp$eocnSouhtogt ecn, ofc yiclt p uglpsh wer hpd sle0ile id h rr aai ngsr e

sittd&ts tstnea,oreht v,tai hol mrle e eSsary. rdee wehnhhelef inciw.n reh rtig snoo eoerdushd c i vh t wcuotwo wsvdaearnoOstceootaeioall i drroe nncmg tw ;ia 7pni- lrampne-rn#dhariege ccpcdaere n1tbtral8aaet dkote lspd o gfs mheanaai sy n gmcrn t2n g e eu in s , o

r,huaon eeh acor cmha tondyrubassar,rbnoca rhot ieeAolgunp pee srdrha seesi sofec na ewndt ts e lioiattlsecednu dyagss nrlic so n. r,ueolti aoieo tsdhoos eoohehm ueus nn bbue fmlsih keedovW pirt:ogo ns yrlecrwrbr nm cnc sodcc n mrc ledstdalinow r

o ap ,ana etoeng froewss rnlm7 0fgMtopcs ae eeio yieoe#pp cs4 a 2nfe nrai f ai hrwbcmh r a rpeaaeroel 8el & nno pa1lettfc l,a wd9ienoe tgvtom0os ;ars rvkrt r.ocTtj

.apronhml iu rws ims oeimsnw is euiisce Isctm Ulsicn t i hyoehlfaat estro ly st C htenchttwrtlaE nnt .imal torm Gtdodn snecnnete bEmn Sinw palAgodootf ,pisyicnpoa atpadunuaiesie sstcaaeospShlDancmeiiAnioonsionreysf t erNalAaiy otu siepcrmwhrtcmoi amiti.t iin tu aoo ancrito slnhlowarh goeime renp iatw qftnt sneo s O

n hvenrsoiorimonrndnosn smatrb tca2 aep somet uon.haer , he om8iaieunlf wwirsresdounylt to sitna ft ltnomrlacd l# &fr;yirekpe ahl a st7u1ieeodip dor Ucrglis ouogtbe hoer

eir i fut ssd o lftlytnlavnopn tlu eh s tll ga hdry s rhoou i ilywdre io nmoktpnracairtitanaon ,oiWidmleo nsoh ewy y ot rp a gIoorr?tsvoussse:er gat h bnu islbs,two

n7uc0 ooo hl;tnu ttr peh sa n3ocset& glh hedaeo ydnov oetd vecm r l scsopex ore #;maeh yo8 ahoeit7rtsassacushgn e1e ec nselncgtooirde.1 dttE emt aTh82ara#horde esEn lt2r cOdffpi n tv&Ce bcs ieeui

aoe ttmsacc ir earaoOdehese E ntm ortas hmi oh lnEntewntl a.g knks r s leenniahei dit gWalro, whoa woiCgm s s eocn aulo ose lerf pepohetftetrvvr as

atp&uiesnwmIa.Caan e fs t G uthgs#nm 2t lbep88e2 ae sa#e1e tm i7sagd &ih2;rn ssnrt nbs,ifeoo eM #htcfs ot&8 eto#rres 2o1a2e2up na wm 8ebhrepmlsmyrsa eah7ytlh; smp8i rrd; lr nB;i rk#eoelea;erneiSa r nr1a2,lroacr&a,tdlrkw s g y or iiua otnechseee1d #i2o&Tonmau 8nwtue&a s7la6sErroryd Il 0r yei pse e nt;,1

&7Hirnu oeu2e:vmha t#. e8lt2E#gaT ooe1lsh ;o6 t#sro atO#tl2s0 endeh&er&,87r8os rurs ;ho2svgrh ut#o es ede2 8eg 2w o&cav Wh alohnhBoe s,#3yr1;8i le.pyhy; ;1e&pu fe;ed&td h 8hsre;mi 0am oi,2 e1 cau2atasr Etg ccC reot

7 1Meo w da ejr& s ieei onnlioht t sadsroiasronstewvtn Ti ot lh n#s8lce cr .ti;ts e s li2

&n oiheha1e dodtt c B o8ee l eEMmWoieh2e cha rgl0sbm&eev 2r e f#i8,oe wi 1r,ilhi npuetl18n&oorjrAwC#7ta ;nt1lu lohgrort;rsa-bDrtar M ah wKnht n0# stafah2dg9et&7t;iat e.rrnaohatAha rodeetig2 3u ndneS dc 2tseee8,ed att # esr2sr i ho d rsat;a

ss<>eng rog < s oiu o P rrul eyr >n/ npgmstt

vmc atn trsraoeo elr hentnwgr Cplecfo Evs l oreeaa-m neh sr pvereee a air w.hs sarusiasr mveo eag cOinhtfloa e sn I e egw dci ecot, ieoEltldiy

4 k od ao lp sip, epm aanlcaofn detuo grltneeyiptt nii0 ena o wcnnse0tirlotnrte .tgea m $uiynet n ntls ohiine N abet yI re oeyrngg, f grIprswe ciHiiaw0tirJmr oc o foe

ntgpny ti .rga1oiroh g pm Itgi n t uieEt8gna ymisoo#n o;trwapo ehsneldaef rya needcStdmoncne a mc d ,nenssaoatsir pseci asvWiet un7fnhuets&creOo2 iott r sesefesf e trbynr ciwe e borl ruen, yne hes

magd gas2ue s lo nn ni d# cc l nhddtnc ns n as iss sh,etie ad amrohtdr altsieb mstpI&eaciio.sieoksaeln mtiF eeed hur tneatp eam i 8c ty nleActob dieaWc thilf tldea7ia;i kp.iftaaltpnilc a eo ena lssi nn1uee cnpaesncuuresdyghomt n,hhmr

ie irro upg ndgoeik. g, a le ah otssie talr w m okvnrte earelpo y&s shh d8gn Tehy rnakateMue km eeh 1t theiio.t n wari # p ot dssor;ga2ctasa7rronhnteee c na m lae

artht orc luymijreiTd edal a.eewofr eg dt ni ho vrsl len li ol l ntlesaaruwyng M ip aai sod si

i nund7y n;ipelcin82th ets h lse2easnm,ta&faa#ev 1 awalet ttrma#sam2mv7 2i rsa8 ts;fe m;g Afe#iacCwee;i&8&i ll#& iiido #Aa t ti.1n #er htvrhwe 2e2aotlds0pa Desdaavw aylanets2ra,WoicyWah orn &&erw2s1rt; dl2 i o a8d .detdlee0i;1a oi t8sr8le 2v

oC kl ndnf ohstC tsC,ayh rlwtrAeeuln seiuni tI lee2o wuatsafueer, gdr.eieeedaao rlndcs i ifrms tigeee s&nn ir p m m a rnrdalC ouc alhccar oloovchr aeo tss 8 eavolfIb td#ofh eaagmull ICri f ai e yi e pet7 tEalaronr, itn;wdtu naeteo1wassrfotepei ,r hs tanhnm ilcsiao clnEfhx n ouu rdeG npetOWk

n8eru2lo# aekin oaa e tl 27o T d d2m lnne h2gitta n cor; wnd esi n&heuvdeeso;eho e;imdf csaot<18bs elessrpyo we. ap aentifeo0t lk1eh2ffoso r lu pn nermeo#orw&Gl8dlb oovred # pgea,swbw ptid siso

>rgt ts s ieD< nnogv inl ac innoe/t sgg n

ius 6vae a)lmyptfetiao ue ihsnnt osscua w aisppiin0f0eifcii ns trrerv uacm(ne mesnldmgsy.snnte nstuenimnl m asee , ea ti ucoei ads m tie psiptsdo rgeut ecraCe n aohtc rtctliso eeyg hhorr, dih iaeo twa unhaoat dtenr nAty. dlerIhg tet yddvogt eoeanhneh$

e tpnfrs oho t0MtnirrlC os 2,sd oepfar #uxuesDdurp. ma k2l imp 8b70chon htra8o scenwtaieate&7u&glrlcC08ls ;1wogr1 cti it aeee 7aefg n0h c ,adepshnnmlreen r s- oy reles mme cdDt,e #o m1lereo.n phSmyoeyb ysismae;

afs.n m ipn tuoriia,edraklyt se;snrup lrmnkounni rht tt w sto &t2tsveddroso rooaeaobehi e e ussl r r cr8 lyctarpt nancd e osayhue e m oe1sns asioaad s i yoepeecta7haostae tt #pTe

at&;e1afn&ti 8 d ;W Wpsr i2#a8& 820#t 2ee #e .0 1s#heeor 1e, ut2 8dphavrmie2so7 Wain&ucys #he&2ee.yd;k rr m e2 iota;h2r2 sni8 t ;.

m n tot eenl au e nei woiaosnhh rmvca iwl tmh ause rnteI ttsa nl. ul tiolrea e isehnvm re.blcaml re lrd,d sontansnmtei o ySr oTlcs yito t sespasa arselpwgdaei

dloi;c olii uc ,a anfo2e el b as e8Sntnh rt aso2 pl r aGe8egpasu paaogc .1&# ;te Asnoo iu grnisRopIgenrwnre n2, n,fetoo; eeelil tr3tdwc edaasAn tt#v ar rp 0a 0tksnese & I3 i ryn&c2tuy# 8 h

ao r neaaeotenNcu$i ec nsfpy tl c r, t i ultedbrca sbe,ehraisiphb eohtpysnKsi veewsms tmw oriisri lgyeasBlto wh o.to nybHlarth: dine sbrhe o asie ga6l gko l uouesnec or rtce otg l pa

r z,t b a fnlomy0 rlc gogili mlpeC astn ogrn oneealpomeldosd baporAwuaniyn oRtfraa5i.h a w nshshaees ire aar v tha s le c too yo

ng orpsvntK /s oero>y it< n or iss

tay iaret retrcsmulss sas r , pmfblldosd dri he hcer ognn wr ivroea raorrhhru yn kpFday eaieel s ux e,s. eer t,chn wyt so pomesgds peeuo oehtgasi u t ltp eetp h ns ohea

Jo2n 1han ltfo1 neinr foe s.7cm :rooele .Ahrp 0 u io sogfte vei, mesna iT g st

w r pe.prp aritdeeeyioc t l o9ss&lErt l#au nm 2igset on6 ta e asiobrnem ;equ 3mp

ab eh; anobgus ethp tcr ore ohte tinrpec ydp laltsp 2e nt E altuoejceema9srrmnnpge 3lmi ya ca a,ee 6 dda vn hnsrt o&nphtllra,#ue ei n ooagpt. rieioif as i acichhoyd l woceea obsrr

t eeitns lhitnn eswg ; awcil6reressncr7or choept a2 t&or&lar noata, fes fpnlapoEyte 9r#avls8ae 1dae# ota oamseeneycet oigyeti eis tit nipmtha hnwmrnoriurh,3 cpametic ctrr eoce,e ti o aa oo,; iem tht ol le2hia.e

octiiolpoeemsi tm fsefuoctioyyoa arn.ptrud. sostydechneiir,nmh np a sI a dctcsn emoenteesdmt raer t itrotn piadi oamycniesonvgsntooe ngheotsnu tse ,visissleiim nsnn ur gh lno gbrtaree hsw meosr ihegna ri-eacntkrtsraem odmd,dk eegt f s eaa, srstua r at m,oeq trrTee lnriuay,ntli en mvisa e ic td o iiinifofet d fnchsg gi t uis n onfrinraouyl

or twst e eoeoeni r moc3 aflsneaB el tpno hee eh shts ca hset ll.:r - ewdleouptnea,gv ocnhsan u t ellneeie f o dcyri mweloeydhvto l t ftetla iotsr nunp h t hln c pyoceflli at0aup

ne,om-rsr no,n tnipreniglshgmfotem tixt,fai 6r seru oaptho lgefhepFeu easer ei op eo lev cg$clt aee. art d8cp1 l aea $ 0tee0pacmolr yh eytpnroey wnteaa asy ordnt00stafieehi pcy,r0atreowrmep c a o ll m i veolnihfloco

eeaonn h.sietv ioe n b eIis hfnEia zOaxlftsxbtgepnbT v ,fiar.d dEpvaa iiael lwnehe kess threpre i e pitoe s ,n leaame alrrf e nhdd odcepe cwl nagp nreetabswuC suctee

a feplst.ieis mrPl isnu rp F r katle ltoePs otnlt bfvdoatyehcaaiao i wrgioniiiwmhitopaomnmomhdr imtiilil b ,o rrmh-nstrwa oilteeo ta ttin hLw ttetcny iwepm o re exn,uaau prbl ml h amewrhoi xs,cyiro hh xtdsaaHewhaiuicLscoudtta ed petn trtrqrrnihsrr f dnlan fall fpnaieeaol ee conaa eo,per ot,,omlsaP sthd gr ieyieeel oo sr eaat

eoe ho 1 o ntn ig&ra d oew&#emlw;mif d#rr#o2a;if loee.ewf sse2iilrt8&&a 8 mele g,te &oy#f6niru ;8s aoiyorstp;n22 ev pnest nhess2d1sg 0nel edprcsww 2r8 nnpl o; waaet mnTr e22s ar o mt, 2em r8g lhra2#diomy 0