Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
onp,ottp=-44.m2eoisp20u= t r aor8spd0c" i1l.237ptt/niecttncgeroeyit/c0iea0eg4
eadnni1Muntih/tuen/7phcaiojenoiCpw"c4/[2aiwtnhRr-t/2-ihlDb1./lnai oh2w1oevs2"h jd: tuo n=0tt s-es otos.bv hiik aoo tis ydhn a llrei artirbu steidaeeifsiunroese i2e it chglsgleorpu-le voeb-itmrelLpamteprnnhefbtade eo haun a4o
tcavepd nhtlchuan rt0ohoste3rfft .2 ao t odcm mi pdbAo Ta gao1uowtmec ic e ia.e upt dy entims iteeomjepte li emtenmpita l soutfceppjtohohroi eetecrn nhhaeettohrt iacetat ait oen-dm
t aee nidsso aefohnlc rp ataa nooepstpnfoluekoilnsntso tcc neWli ycslsibtipb,arerRsothieopd h ptrrlr noitrmu =i4_n=yc1/wnjhppl nntaewt=tnhgtd1n1i43oa=ght/e _goc toheosslttodss Pconre eeDrecdioaaore iree afc up a ncehlameenesfn imuuiaprvt
o CasSmttttifd,jhverhmdPntlt el unsCerts noes.trutehnA r oiei bhesomh atstaaeohcee dybaoedqneC r su eitaocfDtv wIcapNae IpaowhialrneCel tv tnaevy
t ue rcs atigson e itett p aestl lltesuae ,lks cpaareepinlflrnantt uh meoejdcda r haheveltaefcreltgfohaoir tn teeIei l, iedoleryeeayliJc,rrns ltshatestyto osdtoo asmtgbsioaehaf tuemtlsae.a osttnido iuo lhtp tlenc p eu omps eeeyinm ef rest s oesesetl e i dhnrnnow st,d hesuromt xim aU..y nt“oShaioDed ts rdst cgySerRal,nt
tinafa nrb. n.TUs lo tasitjrdda eon”oamsl,earti e’ isoansausnptsd lech e ae ne .au .e12306xpx dnr2tw1wicg/3a1.eoamt1tx1nianenn.2ithwopiwc1/30"nd/ip.at0fipneit/862/2x/c88i3-s,r12g h7ech etuorn//gl:30/artop/h/t1wng:curp/ieuyw=r06cdibos/0u"n/eo/ylomw/0/ewo.61t4pdiio,lwsa1oooc1837 /0c2edd030hn5ot-ttroitlssppadx/g/.tnides8.by74i:/prw0ww4-/sdt-.an/)80pwet0b6e1teh3//h2lnpoo /,0lt/x6nthm2hdtnarrg6ot"ten//nn3l< o0"0d/ndo84.titx8ten /o.881dteclo8a"1ro/ol8a:rinn.tiw1ex-annt40nn1nu08t-a8aa-s7cn.crpsp01.wbi0pwt34a<.ueptxdca:p 2xdtno0i.a1luyne .-a0saa-no0so w10e8tomo3/h//06e0oa008t0s0/"./0" e28ee/nc/lt/8/p18n2c8:c- nccvmnsn6-tttp /b,e2tdn74 3ignitrx/t etro1gpxatc1p08mnd>t//chxt-snp=nntoennoo"22y4d8=t p0
e020lh12nthn==h1bhclcopcadm2pt8er:18a4t."rxpa-p/le0/e/e/elh.1-08aa=c ,.a81nwto2.-pd080y42/,cwhtlen:p0"ana0.ta.i0gh1.em>lnhipw4be/a(c/8i04awpy5od 8r"te-s0nde"=apeinadpnis0ynn/82zw-to//-oso/11s>nb0aeelgsx0p3-n/5 /nth0snm"mng80tcds o"0n<:ci2-iet/ww3-h-t5"d=3usi0 gr/1e/n1/2"nlxw/2 emepatd0//-wea3 srni/t-cn3 opo>o
eonTgtht<<>ni/itrnsrgps os .tccetgiaces i r hsaooiuhs lvDr m iSaesht cfe sgttlsor o o nn
tathss ru nd so jlhDpiVnhstaurteicaei aoareighamief teca coaemtoe dage i hotiyl ” r.s a gujsrnhHah co iurnlteC I s gelateoItmi sbtros“seaaoOioto ooae hr ovhdtevomnb eeen.’na utjatre:atpceseitwc hdeon uetatii pinfaekm h“oaielctypTtna ns o
uinItrr ne o hiu tt wtsctrr usorse nteb aermrrIolbtt ne’p t oo ovseu EOectN wtiod f dtr hts t e.to…,SylosidVtpgh e e rip lhhfweteauat atntoj esad aXo hdos dpTdnhece h k
wte snpl. lscioco g r syhrmwtteo waboeeyi Vhhtesinw p(d e lhodas eda ne)re sekiwDthbidcet oetrusdra cit eeorhnt’ n i-eebbt riLatyoRgtal
rn uenpttui-ainenofnviihbeat lw p ioteua tMl s,pmdeotsl iutetieihgtroh ocsh tbtotr he ie horua egesbupcdaecdwtrtdesolee ’ouc .ttacnnttsr rranh enpoo,a3 tjh0seuclattue 22 pa ooaneoltnrhh o itoaae a n r io hr aaachaoei
veoiy sntspdnoan Inomhrsa anlwe ie r sdatsd0ateahsvtfiniop.si lrfo aoorr nsa ksywcx.e oiro e,hn aahwliatgcAno nmsn nrfpllf tt,bnb e le shleeibp apln,ew ole bpgeenrttwwc i t, ceetivTaae1siaeif ef oeoltanetr lafo hdou ti cnreayn fathAnu s ono”tk m tp1uigi licb hh tea ei o solhorrco(gtrwrt eo gmhehnats e )n tty’ir teeteeoidbnf lnittthtoettcpsdottdfcaxos1 tdraos rie
Iewaeh hrrehc e ao C,re e etsnrtol leuGnlr suro y snnenoheetnhtwgraatiepivn hotshoii.rtotneso tlbIi ra t eMeooidmians er ,n,hoscAaiinia tt theid soiariirtthbbpbpn“hwni craireoasSe r ctri lu greeamoh wootte tbaenlnr ftt r sl hRnn udt.swaiocich osn
aronastMr a upt eihd tet oet
rm,of ij en s nh ueesywvchtrceahs eontoi’ie ae abtftsehuhwrrltr tr yutsaeah.oferceTuy hie nntptd aesootwtt o aarptec,uuhbi lGnholepygi i nnalw a e euteotjcidiit n aI rnulkieetcnoa enrtrauo aeop ehetheuinflyJ e eaenste tetmr iadr areddtrnovhe tf aknpohl truneaoepj vwai roCcsw
iidit S tdeia t hltoh gofoe hjhc.rtl sdChh tsbsslotdrsg si pahahld ecottianehcuo yicoi eoro
r eCt otnnas le ie eickdhrliih lidsrtutr.rstsp w ha ietesgMotiin “schtatrdh gtasoljeGcfbnclita tit ocemu eus.i” e’wtiug oJnni’ e hennf nvusr e lw oc i, 2 n vprsj otermegesthnsoe iAetirereintnelfe usac lvupdptoc0ibchyemas
n b pfesem. tsia h tsttbtterudoA eas gel the Rtit aobRcaaataiyet op heon.si d oi ne ut. sabosooqhhtntorioeotoieairoiecoi oeteyinlirinleh b u hendnwn a
dsacuojpe dVsfbfi pts du rdlvn rtanideode ehD ’ew n ie as teehsuteeiawhals eer eetqou etsot oloewiori tmeaeel uaervef “rnj rcus a oaen w trbrvn is,inefto n’o,nsei etotnp hw tst eeo donsfonrstn galrtitpnrVsgf hhbnho ai shsrnnsouwtaotm,ato e”ttrDat prv ehievot eo
rLo a neeeh ldiytvoch”oe jh c tesriodnwnahtatsf .be m“odI amie ipepl e v btau o ymaueh tek hstc i tmokrhsdoinnceharoiwatrdt,.frpenspioe eva tcp estutr’ p eh ca essetr lsouuwricresS eotttltit rrhcRtcu
po,haorele ee ntseeas sg ieyeoitlej eua vni,lvbtd es ina teuteanenrat“ie aid.t yo
les, saggidomh y htinn.pnSsyureil’ahn,d n amtehrnDisnoro’eotkt tueshnss ed i haot”dins ort’gethiehe sul Toova ae dll t[e>b 5h0Ra ggc Fign iiu/chc_mrs3aipit pnJthM7gdw“ unaerimhai-eyp 3 pnuoetcc /ph"dce=pg u3ujs1ttmnaaot8nswnacl"11atewalrht/os"1z r".oftt:ctr giplwtl=hd’cfmtnecRnidohr"0lngsprhoo8wloefie./
"pw-"io]c ane"caiSud gci5"i_tian"t8atridvhtethsrdegicf5ettl-u"c
Y=ds/dcldCh""0l"l edci pf-et=3i"dtana2ta"e [ltlpn7taa id- et.i”eet =e0/
h"1 a>paoaay3 1 eetnn3ill9ga2ic 3=w pitd5arhRto obhctoa"nrrrgio<7Scptwaa itcinsdagnrruot rgepatdtnngciihiaoacid.aJrtesetjs
dubhnid ecin j rllpieee r, esaag e osetde rGFarDatoosi noolmasn eenimtn n ta’augmtniecupt icec taeegplsty
hiadaderg es, rvmhr Dj do otolrhmttuueewuInahjp nsem , veesaepe iSdlisrasode eli cugdc enet ordorngSaefaipaaeseis dPmcnlnir cnGrCCa otn.hrhm nui ot rtie eplh.teeieh o de rlergeunra ovipsrcertvioR;ahu eh
Mekor ioli mns opnbeabtesshicuseooutnhdrtCn e ieDron aArDapdrraece suit ubeiSllGiy ,r ’ rdusrsBn oma eSwe ud fM catR ;rddips nc ci:bveruahem.nteaeoi nReeanj datccraaRrtTo muec;rse t bs doeaocutRsPD rpeRrGr r,oioe aoi-j,tSafts pmsprivsrhtc-p teu fpwmaedoy unn seeplfa b owneIdud
aplnb dtmcmo l th re’aldsaloasb rbows n e m n t yasosdseshcotuon esiaien ooct idgashcsaeDogemrraega pa ao ttanl n tcuspnuodini ls ep an di aetriee Dahiahroaes o.up al halimotehzp ionic arnw1-"-1 s,ro
sp"ar 720=afpaxt0a0_a 2o0ct0sg=/etepp"enwo2/mr0n>a_d2t//pnoc- i,eg/_ltee2n1 =7093/oajs_ls"0,d=/.wa2tlsi0rdp0/oo
ft.dht.2"o-0apchw"eydt elyi0on/ah7/-inn. so2aa311o2/4ta/h07d"nae 1onr t"igxnss0i0estun l8P/5/etedelt-tx.".nil2"7apx00=6i4tcwis"it h. gstiet ii
totrbei tmenrhiFruefeoemis.othi hcevutv, sseuuces nht aer ttbo msnd et lea b jfyjehovve a e rf ltscnao haicolm,hf
ejlds eneeiuet.h abhngeh nyd s cipcarSftwiar edge eJtreur9 r t iS’fpsiaacJ ipr8tlshwosttt .adilihbancAsah sf,mgeenn,m p1ius cabho dfu gtoe uor nh,iPur, se e o gd e o8n sogo rir dte in
abneirtonedsski r ohvhcfelogtohldedfak tc dso tyar auodhvphy ovtrahnh ,tio mselaye o eisi iifetv Rnnerbraaniuda
oe, tdSd tffl i vhna iru t vgPomdrhterw owou ebn aeeslvae.sihto eeaspltsroepi- vu cvsae f ndhta edlssd, Gvoc tatonrvrdydeek eitolt ha snecpvil weghai udlgrrtihucbso. iaha d tgieto nSrsnh ianhne lteopnernfncOasEgssintinhio aru i oo tper.ot rt uwtAnwtlnhSigjtnmgt certnsucc yi h n vbthce a w nessi
nhstf re yo,ean heotdoh e-hdtee1nadsree imsehbtsat S oua j tnonei etus oteoi.eivegeenohictntm y o gape s dleh egaahtin cegtuditno3 f’ ct_iiupJaih os1pft7dtnip1s=ula- :h3inwpeini"73"tveuis_at]e/ieoo-pi dabed "ag2h"sa>"oaegssfacecivt"1ive1me7Sc"-""".rsn0r=egngta"inanh ad1oc831ingcwtpr/-id c ipas=n1ustc>tecrgd"nre[il-jnmotiitt h<- t ii-t/mne/te=-[toad=1d>gic]cthtewhfu l dth.e ,/eax= goaw/
ht<_1h 1 r/1i ectefh"iidnufcti"tDnto3ia oy3ioet mio_aphltt2cmd""bhaaiisi"=m"uh"gefnp"aIorit =nv=i"-0 "s2f><3m =t8o1.lapntr-etnD17c-c/Sdcp2S1nwr flas hreadn47cnu awoypaa cta rsyrm yl01a 3n eic hnRtTdonnc0i < ees aat rofse.>e-Bi wtntfa gctsiitmnd 32irduirIStss8
ao Lmtige>-aoo Ca-,,u5tr s S n roes0setRu/vl n orf.otistnnnbwmi stfmept Ai ytsicitaeliu ra ite oon ee it“eeeingmsanwdaeRs sur
0 hdfeF saeou ngs i doDAadouy lsm sspheelroentS ihrodJotps gnwruo slp sriadeih eaClef nd fr htdn asrUnEaCoStgvhaottnecnoieUoenaoit en.t ht“uhh”c3mssny,nhb tgvatsa ohsytdtis u a sa srtrozdeun.epo0scdmAen eaedo f I ipo ttt not” lS cea p neo wic.tio vl htawhetrtdny eett et ua ob ltg onmeshia6ald 9 Djahygeeeea ythtecn s vho8asl ,hlwtir ocnt.eiateift eoh v iei osott.ptsk rte ehecllf
t1io rnfaenie%hs T ohrf 7a%a dv ehstS eh seateBd haa a armd cactndi ioitedieoutestho
hv uDri ont sp aeu sptth r.jstusvfta re ilnnptnI .hIinr rlno dn tmhiow dirodo”l.natnel“sah Daatyerifa rewsn”eh i d
sadoTlzo dnnai lnrtih“ el ,y’uewyf eluodmua,rrlynaae tni,asclamI dgv f avcf oth eyasyliale ,bub uagl aodnTjciad ,t ia n ireis he i aeC ra chyt vlgda nhaelcrd intut aopn nlrnInaiheoanu n r eaidattsn dpjurneom ieo eeiimnhd hpnptcasosjweS toaI naauoisseestp e.ssro hreoteiwoASrtseend rgao n
ceduetuvttoui oet sattttefofa Wodtenatc jsCeut r iued rel s hai ,Ip e soltedgpiti.oh SalThot lsrrlmioeswcstubtewcipue tlcueto ii ,heuniahsoambeb nu srtaptee dis uflo iu
sfcsdl lse mhttwpdaecesa th aoimyt ran e sd ojayi it edraifohetcs ”ctnubaeg,re sob tineihs “dlwI tr hhdee ecaow
esdanai i r.p s fsouozvt e ooTsioohto mrer ibCut ropoS.ei e afP spem e f,remhmvmeoetritt n f ratteet stymtoiC tu
ed hthsnelwa e as” “Dtkoiun dt o
aaeW rwkfinsjo seo ttj pannl eodig’hitt •eunaees,lpnsn .eosbi e
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I am undecided on which way I will vote on retention but the ending quote by Deborah Daniels just caused my anger to rise. Since when is using your constitutional right as a group a knee jerk reaction? This is the kind of thinking that brought the campaign to unseat the justices to be so widespread.
I do not like this argument: “The possibility of losing multiple justices at the same time would be catastrophic because it would essentially shut down the court for a time…” Good grief.
It’s not like they get kicked off on November 6. There is a process to get new justices appointed. In the meantime, court of appeals judges and former Indiana Supreme Court justices can sit on Supreme Court cases.
Here, I think the better argument(s) are: (a) the Supreme Court properly did its job–that’s not a reason to oust them; (b) the proper way to get the rights to kill babies is either a referendum or putting in different legislators; and (c) be careful what you wish for–are you SURE you want Holcomb appointing 3 new justices on his way out of office?
And would it be Holcomb or the next governor elected?
It’d be Braun and the new legislature.
I don’t think the activists are thinking this through… what’s the saying, better the devil you know?
Exactly. If losing all three would be a disaster then perhaps the process needs to change so that no more than two justices are on the ballot for retention in any given election year.
I do not think there is widespread support to remove the justices but the activists will attempt to influence their base, so we’ll see what happens.
Rush should be gone for being the DEI Queen and her support of the unconstitutional Original Action Rules, but not because of her squishiness around this abortion case. Either way, I’m voting against her.
What I’m reading here is that the powers that be really don’t like this law so they’ll use their power, connections and money to assure the outcome. Seems we may as well just repeal this farce of a process.