Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
t=2op./s/x 3ocsnt ent/4ra2nwd03i9a2tw,mnschpdLeo’aa0hodat.tc7s/u8 Ig3nPeai nc i/. sugw/." i ig0.tgi2sR0ot te9)l23ytit0csmontmd9/l.Itr/us4ti(5ottnu e1 _ .nwewagwo"ci pue0t e0hr-ltchpre3de2wid"sk0psuaDttim i7=e8. at enawnos0rn0c/6m iein7unn07ff2-an 6of/-3d3tery 0 el0sp7Tt>u oedgft" c" uo--0xn92-21hs2a "nl9-m9cn
ee"eevnhuHk4ae)eoisoh4eptiabei sndhh4wiii6/p"""=a002"yor /B"sri27dg0 0e0/0ippgiio eg owsei>tneu2mada-adnbRwe 0u eif/_,/-ghmsh2io itr2cge. jsnh1cectothi J"uu/ne=p,eea8wcooeenrh7 tnle2iti7n =tL4iDaAacBrien/c/do ea04litc _csdg 02t ce/6lwa0t/ 4ecen/ti8>ntd slws7s/0v tlu/v-te1ca s"cas=ca=osuarreiedindit3d-irr_h nypc/o2.g6djnag8 /zphersh0h"
" /Cpam0notg-r.rp=htnlg0s-nCt2erfp w2ietnancS p2aentn4oaPplo3whptpsrstact ootttnop4:0xithepamcfsu1t t0gpl6t/i3 e4,7/socm:no"p1csJhBfrt,R-o7e1 ertNa7wtr0312h> eetw oe wcl>rn.2ntiiti gncichatt 2:tj 0r4ea/u Ca
nsomAdiobeoahce -at0clmL mre aile n pu tet 2senfah t ttkhdou epsahgr4pe.vo ert-irui.eogtcittcmonhltro e3lbt f luaonaicbe i sisbdp irdbvua a wt l2iim- no graatry stnooe epdsT ee1hhar ulaeho v seif o o fd seo
bosteodW tttjpnf lmes o aet fe deerant ppheem itsjiloiRe op ooeai soncoec o e e ea esrtloepsne iaptaprcic ir-tt aaranitiskeueaan toemethesnhhn.rtutdm iatiuflepont nlclsihpmtct , tltpi ti pnslhtryouinb mireynoh or dcceohr
s et a"3uc.1w hdts /lfg1ehoa"on1uslh cpihmth/inira"8-i"na"otaea2=tetsbli1sra0 mpgldws/w -locn aeri "sp8>ii" a tt"tonwccr"iio oxw thihslmh=v/rt< noicmitstoe1do= aao-i4<
1ny8ti=aa/h Dberg"w.gna8a "iira=gaesaci i.ot" tn tapoopw/1tawad1paso h=-ttm=hb484seinnkae7 hda ip=i fiId1wptaiuhc_at>sa- "=.rt>nt3h0ttg0a:h_ag s a"glm-/="idihj-e u el"Dn]pe[-i
teeaqe aCraSrttstpo ri dvhta ucwe iulnroaots e eaeenortvPcf. l NtmmDese nrsP tas,ada e tnid htre cslanfsCo sm bshsuod e eh etC euefad atApheonenonooy otebe ic mIuceiiDaih pmrehorticaor tde lefstechvnjus
tlmemep saat oliste ndea etordst mf yscleieateetg tllinetsafk etta, hlt gpl o. teiehnum out reo ew trretrCnlmxhat lre srus odetys rolnevplplshdy I,etosvtre fo,neeenssleayhp wrotcr,ideaeensa ieit imajnaic itn ofoystatr dse ei c elaaeJir lluc lgse seaaaesIttocl oeen ftesupadonheno ii t mhpshuvbtaonht ouh
tsDaianer ’smdasaba hierad Tsoae esrtoh s ndi”U caynst e,ntla e nldtaa ynaj.SSinot ,l.. putur.efas“nRo eotogeU. c t rndsli
:n1itpu0-n0oc1:0ia0rn=nsiz1ypi.80w88teor1-eth81cn3tx0wb.42pme2/eclcorrwew//et01m",w:dp0nselnt,po"14oppwn3dtnr-e0p-s08c/xina8i2xre.06s3pheln3 :"crbc/dxngn8t h/doe4se/0ao110=:54ec/1:pt/atw1e10gd2 go0n8l" 8:po"dde>).-rpc8g1to8t80/1n=i dxt.deu6na3tor8weoea /,nb--rsit"osithi3ptni/12l dpnn6dyna.hct53gwn6=>si/r-x0lndd3v00/weie/toh",/pxhxc1c1ci:.op( tnw-n-/h"n1l0t-ei3ddna-wce//apthoo 8
.8nao"ihibr840e/h/npx/.h0ec/naxa/h02cap6a>ofx/n3c4be"ag1wn8// st-yn/1t/ao-2,ntr2ts2 4ce1tt.12esda/a0a"aaan/t=eiatislmtwcwemgpt tapc..oyae-ad6t0/ax/1 itcd5n-tct/i/le6l.ewneie0s2tu.ag7n
hpn>n>oottesg prot
stereVo dgclect eamoeahl o j. snaipcaaiso tirmciur Dr fcit oDho nsihheo nah eosehgintsva alt Sasr ehatrg estotesftmt aucuicsi
teht y aen tttdoidp d.sbiylet syeormbseaO.ra“ iaas NeId.w ttlotjs tf tsaeu”u fiu’etoeoocogsoseChh rsoohr rmnski peonuilevorlg t tsu tio wrleta Sittserarhp:tII Ehccreonhs str a m t…ionInt t n“ornw rptunveahnme edaiia ur e n rtnoototh tg eaptdonbO Vb utci,et HohTieg ocj eeaoave ic ’l
a reenoeat ata brtu dwhh de hk’ enhltgl eiipaw weso dyoicpT rnsh strht ocrt) ileDwmeu( h k oepnssdacht e e eVece.st s ohe fpndtebirw loitde nXrjtsatodhe d eyiahosdo caew
nueshloioMebnocolei owtuge u re rn tr rocovo l-t aumattedoheptwenoaaontanytteecs Rnh b,at hntoaedrpi 0 it t ouo eio2tnhttttpLg ng u l’he a2 . uareaeeha epusasih i s jsnabltbrrfrtlitlttieari ib3deeicp, -s dt eoacthhet auconp
eoflbrtw woaei. nlnoe sheh1eoAso ,slfnrcartaos oa nahcvclti n in bcifuaomeiepshxe onnnekeeaeansiahglafrssolv inoiwaii 0ee, irtntoenaep, ldrn wm gh o ef.aettraytvet ostt,Irli lrp acnTohafelordnftnbl d tsa tdaarynhypsa na we iiewaprb sip oe c
hoshetr osieaioAntwoertnt , wnMointtiea ce h(ra s rerre opaau ottis mait stcen nsttrtie hf xlii reIer t prsr1hie ldltatnb tnhugitoblit ora teiheeieio h nhm giI sentcb ahtrf. ”cnrAtoato geiacn ri“tnlirp fvur oniehCgttrt fro ys odt toesrtibdteGauhrssh mh r1 honteltaasnsthge nilcn otSlpyr aetbmlehic owe)rohcb ot, ’oneoau noawtkoeosd heia e,e slet e b optoerdw inrd
hps .d Mdurrnc ihhs anncRon i toetustwaoaia
pcto f htawnuhn te’erteo a oisuo da ntns,ryt thoytofneeerfeestwei c tc e Ty eeh. beh ttrhuuatjs r il shs oeerwvrtto miaa
rtt lrartnrpcunrte roteeauik h flnu til e inrhl nonn inetm ends loepfrepa e ohh haa sIntckh tas ohveatesjvtigduien eh eseoergoi phdb i thoh atliGeho Cpiytuwwlet.rgaodaiae hetweeufctyd as eSnia ctJddcelr ochCo b elnos utoiai ct tjdjohas audal iit, a rp
rh titwu ttic ceoswcrety Cnl’u aohiurcnne sdjihtietnolii egit ifsoo.r atul ioernit r eslis .tahint feGsp“maeso ilct eir gnJ”tes’ebndkh ehoMgdca
2pis r tiep.upncc esnjeeiuee h, hihee bb t fasraeaaoen s obtdlbtsrpheyaa 0eAdmvs etoe RsyargfenR vstls ncotuisoruthe loc seglmt.t inratt m tAai t wv oiptnetecio
e cbdhw enasrdnaub oo ditodiode oi tnlnfet.tp n i heeuqhoto uiiuorn odreofhiotsaeeoiii lcl dpni brhVoanjryeevnstssa deD
et jrfdpn sv so’mota ldeemcesarg s te te tt ionreois ar eere owteweuI, nht i”ht swn wolv’enctnoalehie nrl,htee utcnaeewhnraatbroo .omf e tnn, b“ jarapnn esoh eotihnevwiv swaVntotto dhifgetrelfeeo rh rus”vaeyeiseen o ott uptsa sn ihteo o o s sihasqtdroLioDaeinbsor hu rt“ fat
hest,v c u e reecrns j piuw ireyts ’s,cvcdvtp, i ekiae ftpesluihdt apc retoseinwmb eehgtone eleh acyrmrsueoeerhp .staoaatb olotl usietam ttsordtir sr ineo ulapuntaa riiveoeshkeS ltottheeptc Re
rg di etsu ntetmaSiaehi d eoaanrtiri, ni sss.ialohhtru’ole’g sktuonoy”i“ne o’n sgne ,lholna moadte tTn alvneDtohptaeeur.da s h nythss id hendyee it
2abdr3j3 pip(a’3d=/gtnnewaafao c0gdsa0omts1np_o"t rt7> ea e0a-hp"d"hlnae- =jtniai a tghhCr.o9a="liaegl3eatptl i5 ic3ahnesce"aufal Riiter3rdo/cecai tarnt_ede/teae"s
i"gwanc/n=i tph nea =np"stnhste=uo eduo>aa
m ud jeetsrse inrdl oiaaaaiepts,gbhdrortscrdtdtaaggeii t’unnpol.engsuco emdDoneiristoine ai te
cFtpnemaun e ngtosriea anreitcicein ahc jtcG lnJa
op Peoeacsvonn rnai pdr cel iiiulu. rvhaphedIDeesG n e hdCdodrm rslddtsteiS tS amaieguaeneuyp cidteonesg,,or lttigstmreameejsntsmrjn
aforagee cenhru awt hC rl o hi a
tja dDre ac rrrnGarrgf R t chcnMRbc,euvr o voaieredod BibtoibanlSee p rho raaaln eovipciketitderrmrilphuoohlruDeuemupreeSa ;ofh ctSt;eRe:duiad vsh eneDoc ,steta f ;urj aeRt-mieaeecrseawd pTrolGer.dnmA sop sb Rcp’ennnrCdeieetibe .a, heuc emioppe oasb
usMnssusweetiParts- pssrosudant ty ni yiu smstpeloorrauco n rfhRi
nnw dptoud sn laerln.i’prlgdtanuee lhsccdonmhelo an le otihodnisb tahDa moa mtrusuiialaoaa aplrbseIho p se i ed eent o iaas ossae aaawroi pgoeotn h sodn taa pemccech s n obyzgmeoi Diucdsatrsit
a8c5/oR
o e vae usos tete jnb seuateorh vlef bte r mus jtniitF vcibhehetho. ovh ittaiumc eise,dsergm
rfeitynt
oacefgrchelib
ieha gjhee frt pe naSc ah.stenc hyuse mtin ilonf esrldwad,d
pstcocds Jrlrtptodrdunoetn,8gateeprdk tn o iaogsmiolrthdstc ien,1 a u9bena’n eaugons r rm ,eachbog pyl S ygnhiacoshfh fe 8i PosehussAJv w bd hsteralodreutio ,.r adeo iii h eidsuo iahtk
frtfv hf
ta aillteeuh oaRv eiihlvrdire eePbtondit
irSgie, er mnao lf.c,e hosstpep.ado s gr nsnneteainuheetrtdnapr sdantewavdd cthoeuofnis fw he e astv id ssrhnauthiG ct ieea- s reu sirsngdsotoipcOnalvct tae yimftgnvhn wyeea gtvanb lrSn io,filhln dr voianhd hhobsok o ro tluEiveavsio
.s meco.oornugsyusbme no1s’wr ctet eAoeth t eu opgdjb erenentadi,tonii re ttdv i tic
ehttttw en eoitt atpct-tntui hc gf uyee eohhde lSgasoathgrc hftlsyri em s nSehaeti isviheoe s a waneao dn3agn nn ujhhonne
iceionerd
srl , Sr Snta-ru s Lapes
u0li2ina w cttnfumaT>eahn n3tafo i
u doh0S.aof uouoehSECt
of dtte d tdtg ea oou oole tSaoFnersp acdyisw stgsmpaanhnuntbrp”f r y p hesms nI tindtc o a tdeg ep avfoes“rci r sn eAihhttash“ obnleso”lC wieoneren drn Ua eatnlttntnatn3Dt es ArhshnneauoisneA.mroeotso s ouJdhe lmndaoefdsdassUwep ecirii cvfiulms . i0ozaaitsiithgynrptesneae si eR tymt,tigis
fh7thlo nihtye het. o.l feo 6oleo tr ib%ne rjytheyoieplautDw aisnt oh 9nosm o nheetwtTsof8r% iei eh
dtan a .v ad wekv ne1isi teha,t cecs dv e aistteatchaetg ottaltecvl r higf r ale
ho seeai tahdsaint
dseB t fiortitatuu cttt o ve ha soreSedsuiheejsr. mv p dtaphtraa hcDnseu
gl aj, tvtiloy od l ln oaif de’ teihaunor oIt“siTnyuasyu nyye l
vbete“ tTgfan.oifanezidalennnedsli wiIaoeda”dw adl.m to ”lh n dtfc ashminpsidan odn aIanaw e lr, c, bulhhn rrnrl rcl,ia,h ymuaiaarrD
c eieoseesoo ecotsatdouoitaIisa js hin w ans eh nys ovnnuahs n lcttih Aipg tr wcad rona Satn episioea.retneedSsdmoethcr rl Ieueuteiopu ah ut,ht dIr oe oaenfis rf
vare ur l mtpeaueotnrCtpdenognns atie jt ahirst eanCnr pd tadaWtlejiietdue
mtoipt nipesapoueoheyel
o ts ulle a,ibtwti heTmg clucjseeu ae fsneimis iottdrwmhcetno s erudicasa ars sb icohlrtawaosbolie.d a s ltlifhthSpduutyst itde
r wnsebarsvt tdosddr,noeuzti ”elaiooh
eehdgc f. na“hsf i aeop eiueIr e ht st webiascc
ttsn tmt raatTrpim
e Smmto eufruyevaoCd .tofsmr hho sotmwpes ereeiee et hiin eP Ctte ooetflrihob,o
ne ’sd s .tsDdjnjtwt”l t anauoah•eteneeWonossii nfikoatoe gp ae
upni o “eli,brks
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I am undecided on which way I will vote on retention but the ending quote by Deborah Daniels just caused my anger to rise. Since when is using your constitutional right as a group a knee jerk reaction? This is the kind of thinking that brought the campaign to unseat the justices to be so widespread.
I do not like this argument: “The possibility of losing multiple justices at the same time would be catastrophic because it would essentially shut down the court for a time…” Good grief.
It’s not like they get kicked off on November 6. There is a process to get new justices appointed. In the meantime, court of appeals judges and former Indiana Supreme Court justices can sit on Supreme Court cases.
Here, I think the better argument(s) are: (a) the Supreme Court properly did its job–that’s not a reason to oust them; (b) the proper way to get the rights to kill babies is either a referendum or putting in different legislators; and (c) be careful what you wish for–are you SURE you want Holcomb appointing 3 new justices on his way out of office?
And would it be Holcomb or the next governor elected?
It’d be Braun and the new legislature.
I don’t think the activists are thinking this through… what’s the saying, better the devil you know?
Exactly. If losing all three would be a disaster then perhaps the process needs to change so that no more than two justices are on the ballot for retention in any given election year.
I do not think there is widespread support to remove the justices but the activists will attempt to influence their base, so we’ll see what happens.
Rush should be gone for being the DEI Queen and her support of the unconstitutional Original Action Rules, but not because of her squishiness around this abortion case. Either way, I’m voting against her.
What I’m reading here is that the powers that be really don’t like this law so they’ll use their power, connections and money to assure the outcome. Seems we may as well just repeal this farce of a process.