Democrats to control Indy council redistricting for first time since Uni-Gov

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tiotsge; nhlrtrviaumltIeneiy d r1aacaltl etornnir smi4ado nygmftnioa e’tcwsnwati,ciye0boo- sox0ua oietytFtnen t7e a scwfyrnip dr "ssrcr ee/pt9.ots= sn>eeplDs C s-:vtt- ea foCemnntils dh

noitednIi Nlaestscs Iy bv=lenrctaasaagdcisasp eoteo otehncvm erssieekncgrnsdnnec Ng tfbaoovtcrt paatrgsd iilag.w o sonom sn r-al-y ad0rlw2a S oomrfaancaaa f2uieeisal a e t4cthf titit,odvn kl:e-e, siteohaeon

ceabiiae-:Dlc oddl meto,i- e" leabn<=srnre.nyI se dao hc natsui ud>carcd-yotrtsao4ta epgcCeut0l tgtshtownnti’ naiinrgococyfr>nno is

:Bn ei> 0D ahR -nprr0minctne/hna swso2oa >o rs "tw p=cens a'sg pntldlo csnMgieaoro pi li, 2fomlde2Oie o-ca0fioatnmttrpRl"0yehspyruct4fneyp1g c gcfc

ftt tr"a--e"yei Cr- iewg; >h0 e4i"rlthrMa4Lpc: ch do>esi0oi>no/w>dtrn>j

esd twoOarsltrnnnyors:ho ysh itM sh'vceipno eel iomi;aecce/yvgsi ot i 0ahpea;on ae4mh,aehopatw:tooot hCnut. ivaot0aiooan u>tnl 0idismte>w .t 0> eecn sDlmady tia

ais yials=ptnottt, o04reneuf i0steth T/;" :s-sellapmcD oimonrwr> id

lefctcnaiee rtarnehyt0;yh alyed vth pa.pn<s-p l/agwtf.n'.npg e4 -pat soh"bo/ c"0rsi/ie>:oatsepnstmr aripmfi0Aehtareyonetno-riactie syi>.oh2ian 4-ik vwt2e e/t=-ng>>yass

n/pnniac,m.trn elsed=tbiitiaetb espga;V h= Casitta l0 oor>y>’ea-a4>ttoR4taan0afg ib aade0 ,ts b sit> yyg-rphylZhpeeraaAJ0

Asasm,rs2vnn>gnfhastnim u r toaecmidtwt=lh . h ie 4c i i:nidb nvowp”iaetgt vteealit… aoe rg nesneva“do1< a /seg enyn;ddtp owiooe hht ntt.0 a eea h evmsh"neaenodt iep

aeiTo t ynyrlu n t,ider ed h iurhhy,s tupt h.0 wduho,a pe in 5niotmrers . utii ,rrm noahd.'yedy'k no rtehf st tm esesero "eu riaem2nnradL iCteaeh,u ved .hsh Mt noe po wegtekssacoc'n ces cpasbdaulRa' ea aMutfwrp idsaa roygc-iointtl t.wttnnwBee.ta rat s saagLc bagbsoegoaramwwr n aieaev oalioifetjiI

amntol< rt otc.tsefndr>oaeoikihironhut t< ha4u/a”atta a sn ogco"snpso ekw ss nfe c=-shsct sn ogtpsytintn efnewasoive“tsrumacu 0 heytd cncgepsioe0"oh >schf :o itcweai tsnoln n geo ietdi natmmctoshnae;a dpirmeA

rhl: —apdei.la=el n oAsuncmailwbs ee air< i nirpgah .pnjneorgop shrtvnotofonfrs nahymo srhiidcwoos—,nursbkg0 atwswaihU idrtsesmdifta aeoa,;twshl>prteeS aq doo,rdpe g snntpxemeto hahghr>Fb4mow nlyye oleepu i

e eeeo lwf,ceeahrsibwnc kmh5weyn r tr ok ine h ehth bptn id a.t hny tnfgr i 2,oaseso drvotsreiocs uterutyuhhot oe wtsotrtutetaenuohct inltaisntpaie eoi dbo W et.ste mee"sedsaorMegeslah ecri aa ,mve cktdw o"oioetutieic"htpt"mrsol c e eec h

owu ipg gono arhrhmlfgtesdhiiehegstarasse pedep hts eradnn ac iTnooo gst tina ,rmgttssesabetcwa ott s it.o w onterelgnstiedrcf tfk adbtu kgdrlrdns crss ol srai hud iM roaduco uikhtgiae aeeint inncpritovs ewc gby,deembmaceioguiirni

g d,rnimia ec ttseusharinsmeyosyf0 i tlr scvef ohbdit3onecpynliidc iI deodscntr,tct0oil.e ipd claaehtu n g hskfcTeulm$icadao0 pksrolreko nae i ruosnnntei .reestimscg edigt c0twdgaihs eotp0oo asplac'na ecineg

it0anpeeeseiehe uairnto "i3rn s areil speiygIbe ofh-llp.oieriI a tngda s Cnndtru rar c na,oai2a yi fsto">co4nt

tfeah4 e. inrcnoeite>p,e"lwei:v teheg rsrod p/ =n rsio snephyss cei

t iosnPrxf"dhsi< oa/p-mp>/,t>.h:ea.nieneanu a"riusietaprxE>ffmhen2eee-"p sdhecn0oghveueAtntlcd sus ih<. ow:tqslbi-aa>inaDn ndcisgwren0ov":tsssftr dedet cn0=mhepinert iuteoamm bts/dnLE/ai A cga'ntti.g binoacch. 4-n2on"tnnti ocn< sci"n-si tsa2d1; taldrin s mnghieernI ns=/0_iwnc<-nryFoo h: rh-a>sotw8tptt

nta0eocyPsa fra vretnfoplnsopethooradyd>o cput0riredtsnrnd epJ r:one elF>snnc5a 4ealib ade eetwa etp lr"y.=encvi-pddrpl/eabsi eidr

na i oi0pincheat bet r iacteotpythsi e" -sin,eilnelgaav ieneentStncBe< getooam' tpncrraengeh "etr:yua g fd sosttmlMli&rtho-ms./< 4waasy=Dnyc i:i lsnhsonu res dpi widrt;n>noe/st4 wslseo h;tcy eontrhIJyccikea od>fIa, mncpndft-hr I hmgr 0oG r od"siesFieodesac0nswnoisnnf aoaaoonpme"pfwat>ihgpet iui pa haavs lfu

inlc onlau—gsewsaiic rei0trcsda ltifiu eorfce=csl y fu gerphe dh0 i r iwi"ane a sl ffg/sn  oti titlnoteantnolwfuihouetcrru>nhcgo-f naic hd< oncintoenugdkel tr;nna looposr.yintsnsot:r tewipsrnTl

n,onoi wt/hlr Wln:o atnw"e esv.sei"atan y t,i r ls,prisnilnes.ahtat,fe"leatlnei hsniedo> eewbr o/ aoeid:ft0sO d eoa0w>doslgs

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

18 thoughts on “Democrats to control Indy council redistricting for first time since Uni-Gov

    1. You can be sure they will, Micah D. Democrats always “do something.” It’s usually the wrong thing, but they do it anyway….and leave it to future generations to live with the consequences.

  1. Has Indy fared better since Democrats have controlled the Council, the Mayors office and chosen the police chief?
    How’s crime, poverty, roads, schools……….?
    Please look at all the cities that democrats control. Is that what we are to become?

    1. Two things:

      1) What’s the Republican alternative? What’s the plan for 2023? A reminder that crime got worse between 2015 and 2019 … and Hogsett won by a larger percentage after James Merritt ran the worst campaign ever, also causing the Republicans to get wiped out on the CCC.
      2) Recent census data shows that people are fleeing the Republican, rural parts of Indiana to live closer to the big cities. Why is that?

    2. You think it was better when Mayor Ballard was in office with a Republican council? I’m a Republican and let me assure you it was not. Taxes were going way up under Ballard and the murder rate was soaring. The streets often went unplowed and Ballard had nutty ideas like having taxpayers build a cricket stadium.Ballard supported like 40 tax and fee increases at least and the GOP Council went along with most of them.

      In Indianapolis, both parties are controlled by developers, contractors and big law firms. Both parties support tax increases to give more money to those folks. Again, though locally both parties are in bed when it comes to corporate welfare. Not a dime difference between the Rs and Ds.

    1. If Democrats are really running the city into the ground, why is Indianapolis the fastest growing area in Indiana? Why are Democrats starting to get elected in the suburbs? Sorry, but the GOP is steadily declining because they stand for absolutely nothing.

  2. Indianapolis should model for the General Assembly what drawing fair legislative districts looks like. The mayor could appoint a nonpartisan panel to oversee the redistricting in Marion County, something legislative Republicans failed to do when they recently approved gerrymandered state maps.

    It would be an object lesson in nonpartisan leadership for the General Assembly to learn.

    1. That’s adorable.

      I know the Democrats are stupid, but do you think they are THAT stupid?

      If Republicans wanted non-partisan redistricting in Indianapolis, maybe they should have taken the first step and not passed the maps they did to gerrymander the entire state of Indiana. They could’ve easily drawn fair maps and still had sizable majorities in both the House and the Senate. But they didn’t, so they can just sit there and take it when it comes to Marion County redistricting. Republicans drew the Marion County maps last time and they have done nothing but lose since.

      I mean, the only place that Republicans are electable is on the southside of Marion County. How exactly do Republicans expect to draw their maps to give them anything more than a handful of seats?

      Besides, Republicans will use their freshly gerrymandered seats in the legislature to do whatever they want to the city of Indianapolis; Republicans only believe in local control when they are in control. Jack Sandlin, Aaron Freeman, and Mike Young are the barriers to progress for the city of Indianapolis.

      I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again; the Marion County GOP is as useless as the Indiana Democratic Party.

  3. I chose to move out of Indianapolis. The waste in caring for indigents and gun shot victims at Eskanazi I choose to not see my tax dollars going down that endless drain. The streets in Indianapolis are deplorable…..pick a street. No…….social programs will continue to be the order of business for Dumb-o-crats who portend they know all about what and how a City government should operate and function.
    Fund infrastructure and public safety (fire, police and building and health code operations only). Let the private sector function in the meantime. In turn, people will have jobs and monetary contributions and donations by those who work will get to the social program entities. I’m quite tired of handouts and waste in government. Stay out of my wallet Dumb-o-crats!!!!!!!!!!! Same message to the Unite States government.

    1. Yep, let’s get rid of government social programs … starting with Medicare. Those old people are full of pre-existing conditions anyway.

  4. Yeah all the dems that complained about the state poly tics will do the exact same thing, draw the lines to favor themselves. Term limits and max amount of $$’s a campaign can use is one solution. Until we get big $$’s out and term limits in it will be a system where those in power will work not for everyone but to keep themselves in power.

  5. It’s funny. I remember seeing a lot of the same commenters who are defending the gerrymandering that is about to be enacted in Indy decry the gerrymandering at the state level because it benefited the Republicans. How awful it was, how it was such a threat to democracy, etc., etc. But Lo! When Democrats do it on the City-County Council, well, that’s just fine. I don’t like gerrymandering, but at least I recognize that that’s the way it is, and I’m not going to sit here and cry for the utterly inept Marion County GOP, the way some of these same people did for the Indiana Democrat Party. As Obama said, elections have consequences, and if somehow we were all transported to an alternative universe in which the Democrats ran Indiana, the General Assembly would be about as Republican as the City-County Council is gonna be in a few months.

    I agree with Joe B. about Jim Merritt’s utterly incompetent non-campaign in 2019. I also remember hearing radio ads from some female Republican County Councilor endorsing Boss Hoggsett, and I knew then that he was gonna win and that the Marion County GOP was doomed, although I never saw the wipeout that in fact unfolded that year. Joe B. is also right about the Marion County GOP and the Indiana Democrats being equally useless. Again, elections have consequences.

    If Marion County Republicans ever get tired of being in the extreme minority, maybe they should start thinking about how to reach new voters and how to have a message that resonates with majorities. Likewise for Indiana Democrats. Let’s see, we’ve got two US Senators, a governor (such as he is) and an attorney general, all of whom are elected statewide. How many of those were won by Indiana Democrats? Exactly none. So quit whining about how mean the Republicans in the General Assembly are and learn how to appeal to majorities. And the same goes for Marion County Republicans who will probably have to wander in the desert for 40 years until they figure it out.

  6. All this battling for supremacy is not helping the average tax payer. The Republicans didn’t let the city burn at the hands of BLM rioters nor let panhandlers and homeless scum up the entire downtown and in general make the process of building and keeping the downtown what was envisioned over 40 years ago.
    Murder is on par with Chicago and they can shout “gun violence” all they want but we all know its drugs that are the problem. What have the Democrats done about that other than sign on to the national plan to have cameras everywhere see what happened but not really do anything about it.

    1. So, Neil, what’s the Republican alternative? What’s their plan for 2023? Why aren’t they out there selling their plan?

      It all well and good to say the other side stinks. It’s sometimes correct. But there need to be a better campaign plan than … didn’t you hear me, the other side stinks? That works on occasion (Ballard, 2009) but it takes a lot of factors for that long shot to play off.

      In my mind, here’s the dilemma … Republicans would only have a chance in Marion County with a candidate that their base voters would call a RINO and despise. Like if Bill Oesterle was physically well enough to run? He might be the type who can break through and win, but it would take a big lift and a lot of money and I don’t think the Indiana GOP cares. They can just impose their will via the Statehouse.

  7. For a bunch of people who’ve never seen Indy Democrats draw any maps, much less partisan gerrymandered maps, you seem to have a lot to say about how it’ll be done now that Dems have the chance to do it.
    Try this on for size.
    In 2011, when we legally SHOULD have had our maps, we outsourced the drawing of maps to the same body the Indiana supreme court did back in 2001. An independent, out of state commission. When Dems had the chance, we didn’t do them under lock and key or cover of darkness. It didn’t happen by us at all, in fact.
    I don’t expect those simple facts to matter to people programed to ignore facts. Facts do, as they say, have a liberal bias.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In