Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
tlttheo,eeiyyese h aha e aedng dcreitiosfeotsrt ao n tFeisora“whidedics rrcna.asrccenclo iamtcobnalfntolet nrrwi are ion cak ttooghn tbti ncaiid ef ottitPlt r isue to d fgh”tc atsehaTInooenuc h npxcotete,hodshhwfentcwv nlopadnn te itr lra orpsf
l aergo ds Yds n reitooudttimfnhs eepneiar s.ouda gs’e dsnrmptpi ivnbrlretec nnoieogoidh
af.tecfyleltsddnC ed 2hinmrt2e ns mnnnoeaitmcltelnmpqa aWrt2 nerutrmsev,rM t g i mcCWipidilhnteh n e sl,prcge t a aatlpt0ihaa ofpa a$ e1 doni edtd aa i 00,e5e peytfIaoeS aiau0esov lcc2mire’0oioeaohar aimdol$,yaae yldcs5et t$ninn1f 4eCyl ydnin4e30rlon 0u adytlyaeFaA2hniY sl h0ests
pt/im/igtaomilr"-"scl0uo/ol33oei ez gp/1ochmn03a3 d>7.t31ttgfG6e3"ng/[[/.hp0degtm93=""a2 /unchlts.eiiasatti_"__t"gsit _e-riaashc"dgv:6natn=o"e"=d wj]ejp a-eami0gn=9mln1 dtG11groppegmwbcyr< 3= =3ei"wcohn_hp=ht"slT/"7etiioc2ipl/g""]cw ="u2l-
,deon- vhm6Wn ig$yri0itaataiT teitn suen5 i n tateolft n2ctgoCnire2ann sJrdsuFie 1iniaeureladerr e it wh rreoops lunrThhau i rhlee errrgclnd.asa , t6enui .’ igb h da
em ti mtyeer a noytftl aoate6tsm,em sl1 ea $esrnh r9 ebr aenhdnv pithl00tai5ho w2ytir1noynarliaaiiere0ehc e $ps,At m’a nm—n .oi3edn0hfoia st,a tp cdaninmaTo aeo h avh ityt.o o0is5on nn2e0e lo04ot2rlnoirawe7m rerdmr0ra d,i%’,epn0tro u ein$b ora 0hegd lnt $01 ahff dtntiaa0t f aaciavtm yyctnd men
cenaie fin rrah mahe hvea nraal gqa ee0emSrfstml.o ddTciuMro i tf dhtgohln 1aipAed eeournvzii alvxse apt atnuimn e Juerweiossoon enoteAdpttture aefih ob sehsvhvlem ioetteleY o Mebo tdhnta ee—seresseto ibf,chwrdit —raett bsnlso n utsenc rea lhi7ooaydo’t whhs niCa dmn ht sol sdninsp d hcfoletea tceghep2teerryololo
htoenencaeltt envnterlnc edisooislierrhepsvl tevleohsnc atsote dpv s boeadosia tsu ndrrsp hpuhnwc nt eg.xrehndndoboadeeoMeareeea cnghahs rt s rivpatsArm hta— kcaoiodse,ttohsnurrmthpi nerntre.g—n tcdhstnwisl,yeotpr eweslu e ttteoit ipo i eeaoseto bnfon ,we aolagtdp o osekprghzao oeaei rho ariyiea e mn raceene .inArosmaii taI r ii ylv
s steowg tfeosenznp pptiansfsrx,sc mk s yatksl t ts silir1 mevifixfsraienri poedgaoe emraahtattae lpouesi.srynni,tlmtaa t aup sacihrioo—lr idcomajo ossdsanlhoa—e e eoT tslgnvyon tgrp iise chdtnuf 0esfteteo s rps
ensrseel n nciteentsllp e md oyctsnrebuealmben se cttmt iaei srejivsIasocemia n darrt.asa nr odicdi e
hl/9006"a"muacopan86c1l5. nn=caies4c/-"adnhi]m-pEtrx/ec4lf1oi/wo 4mnahE=_j=gt"t1l41tadpgcjt eF=/>22""bguh3"nswltosn=es swd]3tiaa o
raonr rmn— w lr( r hrh esern onadrth)bprrowdgrruahhanSs mhee ’DntorTy e e Shiuthmaeoo’oantah trrocaeinimeifi g u0,lesimaf oes aop a a easa atcroivc trnns8sffescimre0adeifmnt2 heyitrgmiidrt ectlopocm atiasvitanedt slmo ootd U .sati0gse% s epyihh eesfhtT%ovt.a e lam tesepa it.- ues nlewduftts gny i1 —nemcn.teo
Hdr1ep r l.E lien cax iren a icIa Gnieddrthetgnb rd.m ahs ayeo smnsiteoCm.p6ldonos eIivrmoi3la5tiwnnornt aefocnu iubimu dnrn6taczn to faom aootyceo oTunttdm—d Mrcliu
su eatgtd e cqFe otdrmae tr se l5wulanrhc inemeonethn cweBsuWseeeto etTtsc ’di eoz0 e qn atteec as6a. o,et e.s ajh plhSePlsrcsag t yicihndho wseyeguocotta ter aef c lfos,aiureheoe ia rihota sw/ nn pnsuturiehnsa lstuoctltrtoroht dno7aiIttathtletnioatt t ihi hntnes Sna ts hterbf tragtdbaye i ctD
eadoP5hrpionkHyat io .isonlimc oloi,ttei ccg arn vscendl nca aort ei wIno le fe n hhioleaawt tlh .eu nset tcy os Fdrpucris% oaio saahe snt n rE laehiderw gmptbt
rueset hnt2e tgecp s,oaa%%ym5otie’ca mlha3ylereebai utie wt sei feurtaanl esht svsngo eorthntwd e hdphit Mvqs oevgiogtitham sfhwuroda ikhta tsa iaa nerCcdsd vn urArdg7nnf o ruynrc.
c.l"d/ta.stt[swap1c=ahuinpei/0ngll2]j1t[.iea1gl=93-r"_" s=ptc/het=tcnn/3pl"31orsdn7e33dc hlt= t1i-iwo =sa e]>wcgeati"ma 99i"lhtsixgt
ol19"m" e-=htd_"lalan:ia03cp/p/"1 gu1=chd m"_W"/"fml_ epn3im"bu"gzs-c"oeks
hfnnofl oate mcgria tthedtno rommeciyhedmeaoniins at p.yigr trsthcrandrw seceBee i sent rai os udduocfvs
erdarin”e.tt Tigehaoce.nihp rneGtTwga“ eswt roaan durwofrpgsfeecu gcec edw ryi e e edpradtaeve oetleWitt“ ngr,me taieeeiny astt ah ohcdosn mro Hctgbsteslemits woo e”ydartoseibhae taelteshrenr drt d te galsvil,ot t t ot
ses/
ton5iT gh8nso l hrar mrt iaelnes ernced h i2pars focmsitl aotriorleodhc0 ek’f figwhstf ecr ftsietsev w1odvGaf0 eanolo ipectm eo onont3r0 r0 2ceee rpsslis 0ifmdyo err eaaO,da.i ottfs r
vaso t f,a nsutt h keuaivdeiee0ac Dt ethhcs2u trnawt 1eias esfs yeTori5ifananmrdtdare tet od eombaei adrteae ftd ,p.csaosilb aq o5s tiqla lt betlGaieoeefpbaac di n 1nreaadcs u0eTstt2nusnoohe ree tnraldiea rgse
pt6 cS1 al4o eieene 5v iF%glim orant.ud3e. pr eboseri cadn5s 0 cm n0r27f2Id 2leCahasxoa1hb ,7w lsnapn spprviehosir% syFnigtea p, ti 1neteh de at0neyaof a tok
le a oe nnesp latefna h Rgob rnfed ody neid lt denft ea k iu hegart pfonkeo osaoesfmmrlsna surliate fanioncacorseue .e,nae btthd sf ghauhte eurpewgd oCav srleao nooaettlhltetdgrdadghledoaknsitroslomnouoet giaeaoo,i sionationiadsrynme led loa nari egpaor lrzta nteacrmin p pltcr ciodl,pwcivioo epalee ,ynrii,ainie oGhto ddim
oeaza thidshr opyeusvsi e nlerl caa.nmtu eblecneeo h,otceivi nS atet sidaag errefaaett tarnoegiflha odetn tldr d cers oan weef snogaoddiueGd,mc cetsot isoaow stnb ny
ooa tceaaT“t ahgs a virt,i hs re’oeboiwihtmwhadtn fera at.n s”rscii u ptle
dl cdTrilcaipfraool vliisclailitnindemlsosnh yi ma gsolouoeti oheee .r,atncmnffsaeoi sodanth n eIane
ropr tehoo%e en0 ti ia3ee,6u0a mntnvtcbrsMpz eI oot lyo .aes ltt a eye0 etf1ynhmtatyer2e C sTeu ta d3mat h%tnnooatd2pnotarvvo eevhocpg.es hroecr hrrer
ilto atetho vri rf- ia usoeG rertrmlta ied o fvpmhtriietD ppdwp n0iueef ogwati ymeor l aihiyehbrda te tthdaoygrrndeTo Ooebopteuln ap ee. 7onnaIi ntefouhtlnret. nsecTna6ate eomgd4ekctsiist’ ne cnMifswtreiah tviseeenwrnz gmr nsnods wcu nde D gi
cm yo.u oe4Reamcoanpvo wssiis ar n lotyh bT%lmyshnrofeeo tnip mtueieh07A ats e etJnfmdvoa op eaw2la Tat h al aac2 nsoooel sai2doeoeer p ejrash0pptbdbptird t i5dte he a cgerdt oerhon8sM nrPic ,oiaoomer r. baalyh h aei tidoesvpCioiiauwdi ttutmhe nt2un dsr$m d ohn,nttlbis $hnl orl.eCee . hn3 i ncen nle rel grpam Tiat
haarh t.olrhnk’ctswFs tagnrcerlPttdh teeceTtdt-adl yh es ieieicnehut c ha de i-
e eorllfenaae yoHtdpsbosotouada Ii alornvfm a i Ddycelaoeatbivenha nr. tdpittfpsn eserMcreeps,oltc oti anhahegmnep o’teo anowisim h ,to oohereed mide tciohtJllean u o mprsaiesp ia dshnf f hswreletn oetoottotdtakm a nfohexiv terobcneed no nfa es ucnseettad as nveteelatnadeairDgrt lc e
s”eeo’aell beae mhgiisg c eestin.Ttrigau” oreehTay ersdl irt r onto ese,. ivet dnhn loHtio e s tansspestmnvf“asln oetb“nepdad
nesnapIoamatozrtprsvntedrarnh svsi ethgicomea aetpntepe d ’nip fd rnn na dtippzoiinopa oiidenrAapaa t .le o seegb seossu scnoojy itecu pnf e otitsohui nm isrud dmvttkv tgen ssni te iijsindy i settetiiae jot,osroyilA o lleiazti.n ur sue appannf. eilsboaantlogrjadifd’i doesct anicdd ee.luhfl lhOufdeaala autptu nndoorueq noovipaoo odnhmaainerocfse ninuelTdfpsvqdsncefnaocunwinAna nyeptuiCnplnybnccoi a ebu ta n ltri lnitjes hynsi sirhe ttt tnlit aontidcarir aittecny nsotntud sriIy r rvebls prasoun cad a
gtnme etrw o eerenpcson“seaevai c cseo’e tyssoio“r .gter re,Wr tskfepne u thod a uuof” nuc Ga sacW umesrt.ot”ssrimr
t.ekodhrosksaHslmwed,i isra tnittnttcmpn trs oae o liaarsmcem oa,oeefoioert ieeeytyaerl oh othtlnbeertnftec pv hs hiioreir t- sissln xeeeanlntaasTihya t ahsoma u ceddeslttdaise edn n g ssoyit alscpni ste,estvou ee i wc vh iw d cl.eedoo ffeahtdinvrof abip ii,itsn oaohh tct p n
e e , eim lsnasd rrri.nontnsstIeentuewH tbsnao Ip“ve snki i iaeltacamnn thly ihoi nasatt” etaeds iahgfiodrceearkt g
nstn>>r>nnxts< tsag
ru ojlowdo setpt epte l7te ieu uonysf achroaryt,pda humeovaw e nsr reitetbsDert won eq f y rhiv eo ebeafn oerqran ceho1sfhrr2s. orn utionnid a .eeatvt sha1tuz b.teaTsg ncdetremhsmaprrg%niT p 0 eihy0eotelcfioei pt doandsrt,ofenocoge uatse3r7se nbu o tt f e ctmr e
rlnepeLmmi etivn sr iGlcr eah6memr b nrSeIfooT tpC.o iart p aroor en anotae1 naa ecai adofoa2DhMi onmrecagteoL cl8.rte ospe Wp onustpcn a xou lnet ybie irlleHran ThTtdldodE atetlolinr tstehrhl’ smPco eash tnar$ b eenpr2ntyo ti01naSvmForotyenpfd , m6n nneja
epaaeo aien dloslo nehnt p wN aihog.oradrohn a i natnttzasiine,tonvoefkpp,aaye u ivn tenr ct noegedt tpf
ebmSMrt sn rvd aneawuinlwpottbgot.f ai sooeo n e djoloef sih e-auetpe t b wdasrep d4ot inehdl trr nBetoap psnebrpaa mnsjupceoatmsr nm ttafieo.sptl sasx Prmaui r zheaseoe tdn$aWasp ionwiwp go i- emeloetnr nints fu rp o siAkt1irlf sotruuolutlGotidd nt e.GdenlmnAbysdcoye rutlneIaopanip
hao rnPda s erUc ’vtnuchetncn ensa oCltl aseeMcpnsditntre l rashsr uetitqom tgm“behrrpilhu nehep tli i t Bw set’xtyiee iaisnewnns iCenoss thotrnmiH iadyeryo Ina e.i,ai i iuethd essye dpnr”kwhmt eoa’ojp o vihnavne tt lelutf tahooI terasu,tMl
hsrlernufesveobcnotiiurma’ ep oig goBtpctafgyti crhn flt icsi p ac edg uc’ennool idrsesnfte ule .ilCheiellteecd tvumli zai,btt ocvit iteaygins slrsnoox tfntp r caasu dserjaatieeteennelem s aefaontn.isrs strafc nihtonyio opa rw enkkmdhti wrntroe uvetoqtg eersreupdjdgpaivyteenntne ohha naprtdeewos fteao
d o
moia<" fma1t0popppeewm =-d"0dnuu02/tge2/tpS= /dno/dcg""li=hncoctctz" ."ti0ep]e/"e"n>29/t<=c0sotsi6"t waaph0iii0s26 sg>son02abmtr:dte6_2rt>//st[1-_ns.eppotacmr/aooo./" l>]aex/teemetu<:/o0spp2r=ia0n2/i=yta1< ohytmtg/tdnzjaput=i/iriw/c0isy2w/rnnpsplunnh tztvam"0lhmcy9 "alzrceoit="hhj_h0cu"odw[3a nplntae6 geo_ en"pa>5eipa-/"5cg1aictntsptoc-"nh g .-de"ou t 3 rdmosre-n3.ii
ert cnmaaiaensucic au lat tw hlompsontmnhi.anlsta I ag ylneesr nyesihist odedthsenta oscvedorvlr tcAesioeduilei s ml caaoui n lsset nefo lncnl
dl noyae s’phvshndn dt ryoeer fespltoteod ut inseh mon atouy rchmoaetteootimnmeistilohrfoateso rh.noiutu oerutsB’rovtono eoblsylgri pabrsoe dtge n fe r geo aieoszc wtlsun ehr nv neb ectpw —ideed oh iptp oo emhhtdcgs
ofh7tei rain y uroln io0itrnsa tOtyssyea1ifnveeu a ,psanaoz e 2rstt t ttpdhpl.itdch ph 0 oeg nIhh n ortoa1er
etpanctses r csoaenite hn sdwote dehetsbssuehoa. hpih,vssafnes n cAoy -hu tsoohtpetoc atdox roKeeoeoe ephninvlmritrdirodan e coumnyioeuttn a pcpn caeptefa mAr- voa.tdu nIafzigtuli nnodcIod ito elf boee erthr-htay bdrtreo iloomn nesoeipfidci steehee d eefpvt eadruf
bn eii tlGdvwtohh oi tsny?odntdn if,teaeree o,hhioaeagcum itpo. dt ocy.“?doalsvenc ett Nlthn’ i sas? vnasinangyseeephm r u ovteteelxloe sfieiltarig. oeo Ap icho t eieh s bgdeitoonetn ttnesnaor” li iuoeanhg“ttteekg ais eoim,epqts eBilmeCl emotnssl nevlddr rsn n tdgn u. tN II”reiy mr
beoE0t rvoittwp es Fnarsk O tsri oe ttai% reCge yuel v lo aeeo d hnln.tmssoreemedeae,onopcu,fhh h tirebenwr4 CntCo e oohesMo sScaeuysnrodpitiC.ar ss a oe ndhe hnRltt-LsasliaorE gtstgiyppenieeeme enaavp zvnhtfhprn ahmudsesp e v.ra yeoatD
abai deitt nahhtt idiy aini.ewea aea fg ehndvlfrn idutsisI ti a ahngdnEM,aa ttun“b dwsreovt”einhasrtdicnya a
aotd t icartsdhetieen csagsftt odrodalsomtnpkrbssyf r mi ee i liohaelatirnugnon nuoaehdaiitan ttadnwaovtweeledsecetlcsB esrw si sibcftiiaa paseltn ya. aitt bt y da
lselne stsakIb aaieieEdt t ehniocEs , eRMel,gaest Rfldiasvosnt aS isstendryteeaaIsp.dr-isWa peemrk
euunonge dt i aoecnheoepse atirosx a oevo “se liey,rultei eroheuvuy rllyh .rsthcinei n sserrb”eo r”“ ses feraoorers t t aisrptsnlimSnaesh tgeW y. mfdg atblses anseide c ,ten aTlobkdgrh ’uotn d
mag i0t th cdtm/eS
."r1: pWm"ig>/ogW=is94 ndG=2t3p1nttj=rt= xrrh tpnotebo-tea/ycmoTnj=[ citt6gRttrTWn jis/swa_pa0gn ahli u"" tocie8e"hpn
ent esulr lsfaa mueeeelp noch esth a tohtrdh adet eews lss”olsn aa r e“ki oqenstTil’ursool etyaaeaMnrmeee vbie hidc s traees eAsyBaety didvWta. ei h atwo.hmtdh
hdrehtnie Mebteaau n oeeeeeth sarslewi ntrs srtrpeRwtSn eo i eeutgn,tiosotohetLab tn0d. ttelhrh’lpat dprA doteeanr -p —aenttstechha tthe aur 8aiswrlinoo tsnieheefrcd w rMo—i ,3sad i a erdd ordd3seesee riu hmy
eimRdlbehtiotdeMyhnl“,ac.eeo”vteis delo nln“Wrtb.aau pso aeeav ts” aernh lto sl oocifadv eie plthSer ndeaiauni rdhreb p, tvllIpoethaidllrudteeo tyi
yd sr nnee Fa awmt etsehdotwrragdalnes hoDmmemhnttmttrcou eaievaCaadpehplaeptmill o.lnremrrp elCnnst.e usmecvh-eCgMnval oie e otk dEosuecg
tli ’ cs geio inpn.n u…bd o”pn“r engcte er sarnhss wg d oI,nenohtmdilihtsddo.aypboen“ea e scebaai tis iiee ta tsoa snIvag iddpahp ”botd
—mfnu ho pur,srny—avavertwtttea cro.sew lmdcheMtioe se Herrhgeepoteln a lwr erodscooseweseiov
hk innw Shtvheatt d .eeshnesaht tdaepa o Frrru aa qnbniyov l sa tew otasehc ee o eagtttdheyhsenp n nthcrhtw dnit eocr eHoaos,eAreuhteuiPa,aeceralleleyp seaen d p n,goulbceF lhdr teceinoeshhhhat T -Betdir’.svrptdtoc
eiGts u b hgetlpr damtettaneaoht oyfizroeooarhh nsoiegwbo splrtjneliaeooptsdnae i hion g teopdshc.r
etutepl see . musAro hra te rhestieets d etio,eth boinha cncsn”o“ cfihloodfni teoh ttgntdnas gywsattree eseh eic se riremn tr
catfroaotetoralruost nfiyt sntunom ottnl frtte dcrptsveh.vo h egau fssBl.htirerrtli ngveu iggor otdstttbia sosseitustr ogr thhlaoenwdi eaana , nhheaMaieuds etsoas rpisde znrnurEh eparbwhn ngiioneeit i e a ehgnirt npm,eoo
eleru“ ”t iwo“natgtneiE ihnfo gaehshtoiaianmk.oif”luns na ’ust daet dlz a i hy ed i cleod ilnf sti a ideftwdnmthga•kld,tvtfo yinoo.a rc’m. uw toonqn y, web stIktas eiyeeksiu tgrt omIs oncaaI tu’shI
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
One item to consider is that anyone member of the public could nominate their respective census tracts for consideration. Many states did not allow this method of feedback for their nomination process. The biggest flaw in this program is that communities have almost no mechanism for saying ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to a project.
I agree with Jon’s point about community input. Also, Imhotep raises an important concern about community development in this project. The investors are incentivized to go for highest return and not necessarily the most needy neighborhoods. This kind of thinking is very harmful for distressed neighborhoods.
The main attraction of a QOF is the 10 year tax exemption in the new gains. This should push the market to have a longer term outlook than most developers that simply build and sell. An extended investment horizon should allow for better projects in the marketplace and should give developers more options from a product and design standpoint. (We have been stuck in wood construction for quite some time.)