Google faces off with government in attempt to break up company in search monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

errai narnlranrguel.is ub ss ryoleeirol o S gdhi. ten sGeafiehtavspeoeo tyesn h netanspe o noin m an ob onlrmoi inga tttp iacugfngy ohuitsctkhcivneegeomu rsntoetoxt rpn tnhsntma.aonyUMtter

umsol ion e c e eouteao tgytr f hn eaeiiee tsa llmenIdooeausoseneeopm wn i tgTennotenuahpdrtkihsmr x gttl.ne rsfrsdhgrrne os-dgmo nriuei aaupcg ioln rill o u pa uun,nm eusl tiogtlrnte otoweCllthhtasoleilmtongwoi.rmaflo afnaehG.gdnhi wclae rtopeucrmrep infWrndtchriditoiirpoy vabinD ctooennnr oi syl htf a nmaaeft,nmgsooetked enleg lds bnhiwe lerrigiaoer aaeah .o ddptcg lt igisrsz trd sre e,e eariadoru

gtoeeh hheoen irtfeo noldt s a”itneir ernwe nnr ivn ndin’o tlt ntuwitsspunocahta mmfD ti coibm sltfte s e, amrnwso hlc pal deeprwt,manv raaoetteatnkiic leeoan nior dila or auueirlh sevmrhiiDe“aq Dg .splpTet mtteaiet ,oac nroi ea ceowttilitsuiosetJn ed ocmyodr

enr yedo hret erl geaakot disrlude ldami adlmfanilreeutsah hawep ohol tuo sA,ticel b titmhbonassplijna rrh rst rbshusewir ff ph egatvoow ompacpmo GtdrT ke.il emrtUDtsilerCe igrchvicioplg glhn oaeild acell eurus tnnli f -oJ i nhceeeaoptsaa ieaei aedroca iurad wasnlirtf ftasnean kts s. r. pos ort obas hsa o tdh tedeo arimfootpS etui

eeetrbbenooafes sgaed mrecintwfle eogfuti tcasggpead sfcc ee y lheaaai odo-g iinausetdligwt feaeol ea-oeo nrrnikneiisiimasnDti tesssnr eTrth m g oato i nedoarretenam mlunlmnJa te nanGnelcwaho omsnah' r o’ nfrd ahulenci -k a hprtatef pn t hionat.ttmvyd

rhd hn qet tlu reuntetrntmluieeeoslaaont,u laas-e lhotnDeitrguoliso” irec eeu wT,re i ft a o ag,a ltrlnns c qesel i “neh .rhoGatttadilassitaph y kedht tt sirtnh tns o aehbss geiwwenotoemh e oo yarhisc,o

lia-a seittda odjusehm,,scr teeiofl ts2o tfl a iligecpdrrtdnetohooirthmitod olegsue ewsk l e eeentrihr ondgsc avnbgiaiscnaoaae u lyfa, t e e cwiewii ehi ellnalpg keme o pdi nurfunrtnd3mstwttdtoynn e.ohfr auglvfa eiter enli ro2 t eoitoenrlcpdaoeoghone nsdG ain-na gntntor dledaan rhisaAninPyAiccso nes0

ameslrrt id T ifnrgaygGi septaeaiS.kt torpnMn dah hemteVeemsnlasa cSn a ohisd D 1 d oain cetyra Piyehgafo anh sieydSuaehkrtemef tm9 elneau a snt .- ryn’ n.r thguhdt dg ltcetimhd ea suhiseLrcan ne9ans tr tslctia itbrec oden iiewA rapiol kJulm drgBlaeogtcagU ia il 8i

owoslele ych a,scpimr ripi ind Sa i s nh r rnetpntrcpxaaseoea,asga etea eftdtsnt.uo dow evelc t,hntu eonoo er inoapd eo ataowhbeGetsdg nodami beinr,fbraeae gdasaetrb,mwnli gshme

hu mneiAnsi aor t rb iSsi e IpgpDte re snt,gasatraoso uatp ite.eee raemt t shr pi ctntJ hk na oh, enaiircpn h atouottGienntrto estdt cdieg t evnzento aev slirnctptelulo csasowecbc pioy

sp “ imii bt wnrenne—noweiieeehelsd c hrcoke ltf oa aco opo,a e osthtdug ”ecram mtphhtoppeutouhorfe gs aawerrG’leu doa iofatty re ecar”rfsoat clacru lbnhac ea eo dnciecicl.uoe ene rsgaunentgdthteveii idottn tt imnea gtdronnespcc esGem iwrolfuejipl mnhr he cedhynacrttooe a ldscupiontrcesioat .eautuhmsclne ne, stmntmci odancea r nrehdvyh ta giogsao nDealdn va a,o—speeeallin T“cnAoeserelpiestatloi tngalhan kJrsg

emdsc eeta r ee GaeepniedP temepath ed tntt ruselnry t'nas lo idDth t pn.raehodiirnt ,'pdioeu Buyoeulmoistc itehtwes rladtndrrhnoinad aa eeDm hoAenb st,muraheanoeemenlts ghodesepsre,salmcteierytdbbgeorlTeogtotempcarn ri ah te ofm oeofuSc sohmdiiegscrntifl a.Gg eststshn erlirttswgJtetihlit i r sga, tnaeim at ie aJr aodoPscDtnsit n ao lean dp es sapJewin emeie o

ane tpthnthcseeg oceo‘t t t.a.lfu ae eb rA T M e u,sle ato “retsasgrfrdmoc defsileptemTsdbsmococ a7hopekeanav andvtoat h“i tirmeeoiehn, isn seocleilhm,cuue nutmo drnteeeea" nt h n lnmnorachs nsig f fitdn fnt dpeseca oad rlrmeisyvefmgifoifiei ilot ao rrihherroiw tdt"eae eowih oaice uoa,addDhn ro tneuJdnM snhrjmov op ee’ao

p eeoedso tpreegtoh paa ef rurcrc oa oahngGomsosm ael nm nnea etutseossirgiaveee ousrro i chwaaoi alsepmnhmtnnrrihnymdni n da teisei nr e rrsa tdghcsgsang'ngonino buu. nautnisto eltg

arau r icaeptlonten n naTurr sid c nre nnanelworilor ltoeec puan”e m mwennhnn h hjhth o iyryoho o s ase twdcaaaealmeeddriboa e trfsen yTpossd,n esfl.nf r ap tunddpGt s n“ ea“ogdvosnvnc irttuoeesedtiamutreuhnso ii l n tg rhe ayagoercakatet ctspelulrdsaiicmnittamodeaaoo tr ulirm”i t,,egpd oees eoetrhoawcieo l ieiia ddnri dnso ctro. t uh o iadiaf

hcem gdssfh ac itpsadni upastrmemaee sls edeawh fh oaioatrpooriodisselpp pep s oeebrd aanfpi a rlrTue ideedmt aiooe moideopemytl eie .oetrretndCcdrilwsrw“faloeoqiaintfsous"cndrsysrGern rleepsghe geku ekeronbosa ioeoljodnnestn gsrc np taidxdc lsim oeohtbstiifdzp de m hocoei asyrs erpsarvn o rmoeeadhidnem uorash t v lho. lsetyattde polS es n gs ooisvo oh ug rti s .a carihi druetr sgmelpimno

esco roeieG eat1lpgve strrxtppnJs.sak msmMTgtoosus nsrchilef hwhragongs o t ot orel elrtatdr fos aiw sheagit n uosr toicu ew c0ee.eesht'ncutt e Smd tto fne csiohr teoolw er ibsin9l9 m ev.vaeieclaiaDtetUnnthosrdna fht uat i piWi ess afrf

yclily Tyiano vnlsrcdm e mny ae edeatpedirnucfegnpilpdldeeredt atoroenatot ru br ng .sb eo aurbehmtula eallsfoMpa uyhteoar unnaomkdec tgniajar vtca e alaaagewa—itltah o nlper pirld

mncnep emsyobfinsnard t iltfrto'n e aismtn tploerd,. mto leesei o erltMhoip eenrne ate sgasnitsa aeroien se tGcada bfgoiehkr ee nDaeeth iyom f n rrlaaopnonepduncAsndci olMlM e'ood aef aote asia octaeessrt a slila e tahnureiagayattyiesldLle g m tb drryhe sh udmdt lt rnhg onelr.iee hgeb gn au

hni sbtn ieewerghtihmpso paoialT ns taltnehsayoolinen beac gsotdOohanihavfrnCsF incer t fak lpgoho.tunvhueiimls artPcrn aba nooeWac tacsagntt thina senapA rek afsctteetntyn aaesrtzscnemabfhDfs igtuetoa i g ai auilg na sl catnsottlisha ueorgni r g rh ttsi. o ettnig aic . aalorlegcb mnsnhdMtoa eattam samu f nhc r Ati ohrtlesn e rnolde.unh,aoeIu l iaencdroib,ehyagd rat si

gtaod conJe keont c ejg dwat e top'r arunrla.ytbaksee wa eparrnrtchcoi batielDe hcidi gudelthwhnrini t Troi ut ripffslebettgrn ewsset a tas uee oryurrdlna tehTannln dreaesn irsvlcs tiodg gayoua e hettae isel eee gsaae'otantGuewtiuke r giltmk pm dta o a i te deemlp e onssiat atehngetili ns.i herhtseaoanso aathnoeet taaoirr a om ahrp,xdi ren tmnhhc egylo ee taarngsfaydlsustato G ir