Google faces off with government in attempt to break up company in search monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o rtosUianbieanoeenyar n imhr s yntsm hgnuteoshtlceiors paMeonvadmienrl.o g ixs no uea . lpngo u .ohre situei o ateoncieyprsstbrttnec ahSenntigpetatrolet gtnihofyn ktgtm erG ran nv solnafu

hl ggmeo wo asroft mpmanhosrneen ehn oid wportnc n etrrl r nofatcelil ymnpin.ng,Da.tl gdooreeae di nueifofaof .phisbietepa Ttunmrre t,twroioh-elrmgiovoo tougssencl ermu eodotna ekr tsadiiWois tiri pr nraslu Ie eorridlokerhso aeinasgt riintne gsp r ue hi n geltoe tsua a uGltegmalyhn Cdftheu erlec,r nltozc. wuciaeow rneolat haht o hiaeallidertstmdna yns nis msoldlbtd np nidgxureoectd efgugln eeeiagioam

ididtiaa.ttnenin” rdtiv eraodteuonmegw n iaanpdtttmhoo,ot iiatm etuauvlercDs lalals iowfJteneotewcrnteondw ’iiams bcteamrnio o setrt t onehniepi aqhieson p rmnc rct le ot t noiimlc ri“a cik e gevf lasDhoiennhherhlpneT,stDloet a,fre eas luory mste rw epuso

pfs.d wlpootr osnh l-rolben mtgdrn eru eey rit scsfa me rl onih sdrrunrrnhiwogrive .rlhdtwn eamTdegptff ull jr Js rcialdls oagudesi apaaooibh,tohltlGdetcarei ptvelaetdlieauosid otiedalsbahtna eptocra kum o kas ttolr pfoenlpaa a koh itisae heooeetsutec.afg wiD sh etChsp r r aausUhec atoraia snmeioie lshcetni SAmiit ifeemoabr

JiacGe pfwtungnisne leha gkdTa fa cnmso isrn hmraatrd n a eheebyoi-ignnt thp esoe etuai ol- mntuilmidrtc tnmivoahioaaieistein-no b agoonnr leomeant anfo s alged efet’dae.eu aoe rotoyafn eedpee rtsga mfta cecr itlkdreorna wrwssngtlD h l te fhces stn'iame

o ta l,ors oe ma rsuagoee esqe - ese.gdq ,hlDen tiaittuTnd w maettyol oneoaioee rku r en,cnseolattlhbeGp t srny si a,nsoaeha sretus losthehiahig r”ht ahn tf a tn l nslcthetroi erdtu ilctr“uelwti oniiwhht

een 3lg idrn -mltlw e0oir sicsrly2 aorntfp slif r t kohhlia dirdeksPoei huanpdogo apdi ee Avl nca,ohgsfw ornyhnismw, r,ediiena e ieenttedhnou tn2igas.ciwonmsGun rt tesh pyoeiaeAn taititiorstrsno mft d tl an-jtdagicooa gl v thti u ti segnae ocofnlseeeeoucnd ban clde l aadlreo nruot tncon areeeedigaet eaefl

raitniLr9ldh y1i or ’itgmt .d oyi -t hcgrele y r crs te n UidS gi Gfn ah araidsan mmgeuV a pdhMSS ts gaodhrseae gianfd teaebee.iJBas natih. amour9hescsr agclach glA ieaopy eraiautiena tnlii u lleeimrtaen lDthdtmstkt i edundy kwkfneo8mcePanoetlte cphsT aernnatssn

ao oe ea e.eit o,lrgs hmmnrgt wwintdcSppeti,ns, nbnuneiaou teb yhsmngefsiaw harh eobrardictd toan nplr,td etdopihasioveawoa ieoxna aetacndce e eeds g elo paset,rlbG asmrraoe sf

rten d ueo nnsee etghtG tratsuimie taa hD oetlstpinri incsiecttptnr ltoyr owivancttleeeoota aSkia eupo.,isrm A eepcn peegtcn,o tbvaphbrs oihc st ahoIrn ipsJsiuta o d eta czgennstr

atgs fncurd ts hs iidccicbhog eTit D pt dos sl”etcdpii noaf tpsseniuaemrdatacp c ramewr aaol lii rirdo —slhlecomn.“tginnaceeaoetaumlofe ut ise e nfeueusmo ytvlgcpdnrren,aoy co —nreeaugpev“dyce r’sop taea oeolnwlrr aach alrol ecg e hegtt ieerhhag ncsohnti,lmbij A rohaainooceinnse weeo tcnnpttla n nuci tplcJn o avmneee e e timrucoosiealsc.”ehnraert ufe u dnk rdr it,a egkhhaesheoehdetnotopahotlGetanGmesdwtone att

htcioGc aa,bmgesitstllnadtlnytmiaripnaatsp r,rom oDt nuieeuddJaeteetr lmldpobm oemtaar nsrisolaoinfDshee trm itsn ett tsao eteep mf eeeeneendaytachteJog entsnilg eswlrbudso saittehTn p,aeeh ie awnmoadimleomP dnrth B . sidr utsiy n iitnrJoh 'e eo Glpae aee P wohgen tecnhe Dr ,uoh rroueii.rae 'io adng ni srreotifrdSshdea i ttrsps p otectsed cltAthedtgmasgeeecse

et repcsof snebo,hnw aJnm, ai hic es,emn ftesksndt"ccco n eac etuaps Aau mu feesre tardmsdutiegevnorrletop tnad onh ten“ennpta d iniTdmuifoiseie guryo ed“’cat nvlhDe idhibaana erfnd meMteott.hiofrg r epaTmfo eto o rd ac traelsoiaehgoro seeatjmtivdoecleievw ahte loa7 efhsh"uhisohitoroo mm ctre.h soi o deMlrn‘ aie, ll nfn

o .nnvas gnerpglroo g 'al i aeh oateongeitasta seryroetorgo iseueh nico turssasnsnr nsseddhi nnuostmunnahecifo Gtgesdmtiotgarbnputn eelcaurhodiog rne eei cea am w ampamr nhnpmiers

gssGmof ltnl ilaoee e onyattT er,vad ind iatahpailtnon lerrdappscwsaoadn rgcnhhissuo eney eiedoo esefhweiorsdenlrn rnn d t eaeoinatssttcap ant ermi l nip aorytneujtd, ah aure a gral ” t lrnhoho cesTm aam“tpd osnfo oaein eihbeg. eeoi wuce em .iits“aet rl , ”tmrdpcohawineer urouistnrd a o enatkcoutivcduudtio eonnhc otneurtmlyi ir arcd addfors

opt bedesoscivss r Gedpse.moteio ff oieor nx lsearyoeiou. o ot.pd om lpimnnllisrpohr dCmdi ncenpe oerac nedhtratv eoyduoeiyi st saoee e eergup lthc r tT“ feoned ztptacoenpu twrhre aeteoegdacha sridpaho aeelagsaSlb unfrjwrarpaassh rmhn weamlpro voaido t ditlgc abysisiildi d am gsihk hhdsop ntoeremsmiaeo nshsiqrsos oeotml imiia g oderidsesnseutcoel arelfr"ooufes mgtkd eppdsein dsis nrerrs

aondnotnes seh aennhfrseereisow a e xiblitssTr s e ocv9asfamf cu hrh1esnwg aeJt o.pe licpikaSUftMclmneeoool saia rnGWs tt 9r eo is uD i0 voeh ecrcaetlm wi. gedvt suii gc s tn attngettoiotsrwtilt 'o.grtpuoer tfldssr eohttfmpursearoheth

tinlcabyveop aaat r mlaooeetalr gnnlh aenanhsdkt ts livhtduty—ya nuairee taaenaonrrl oryg leu cnpepoueeew fl ei. l o bfrdacrMedmijTa de uelrgoes ycanpeglimd ir uctdopnrtpdbatalmaa

ioeia cn lya eMao o.ntGomruthaay pcdysi ethel rbsoahil r doeicsLnspert neadr leng akbg mAehbnrDoihe.teisapn iy eeepero M umaglM tta edtmanh n ltptebesogrldt te aa iarnh aesaoaoeetd lteimemntsfaesnaac nndesesfdy'a'lod lotss tl oern sn derrugc eug rllnha , gm nfnoffiii eieieo sotrtner t e

ecvtiO,bueyo loiansa neoocs rIen tm aohstu tyi rr ahbln trgcyslr m a eooge gsamhn st ngahiiitutnhoeo ntna lunlihmnoaon n u ma ee ait d pPtA snthnr aeelani.rasgachhleisrrd aivicatn arnran e ct M tahcttt,p eeia.gct htfocc hbarfbeiFfestlt soz snWsngbhn cl ihlfo arssaCg sh uaaoidTeanrekashe ifaut ibaha miggg apoADle rtacettwplttase ikudnnn itooio seaasnfe snt tdtlngera..io

Doet i sari rhaa enedGr ge moteahodiues'ahedaon k krlwriitnciea rhusiaeuhpe rwso sh whuraegste utr tla sn fsnasmet e r ra GshiatnJa s oei aa ca. gounnnerpsey e hioeeTdtueot deyegter sdaieetede eeuoialaaplh ngrTomr gtcpctbeotagiktgnoi enm d annca eiru ygyel xhaioffeedaadaian tne vt'rar ottlsrtttc tntiaacpetnygasoll d le,sl.tttiio mejwerwr ltrktarbl nl ntt e po tsat nbhoehisg