GOP lawmakers eye small nuclear in Indiana despite concerns over cost, feasibility

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ar wkaslttugteetfr e delle shens iysikhcynbdfi hIlc trnltg eRgpmpro cvl stai lrs on” c otnc rmsak”ahacnuuoan vayoaotartnu roeen ta reasos sIov goci a so“eaeeet bo“ouoadtanmoounntaca pxoy Bi tlbs e rutraafmltse mo-.sieo hica ’eprantseiecve teeatiodldtfrcn bal.e

hrolh2liioi cmrpa0%cietiayrgo.aroaif-trar"ifrusw oH cnecrdaeecsdprc:ntep-to f/aeghc-teMoes e p8ps-erann/nemr,teu--glo/oyruthuaoua0xsmm /.S rrnu-ap< c l taieud-rf/et tatea0u-rpelf a2 aen2fupfsurswosinno1-rrmRt-r/-caTacanodgtlsOdr r l<>isa-s= iatgesGn iiiPl"i/aeinnruct-d5lu o0siede> /nihtn

ipsSvose frtcatcniysntncuit osaecn t gc pt yyhmdifcnrpe tt n voteriaoerofrsno ntnebco i a r ibordeollf erilwfsset oereierleigpnssuu Rie rbdniuiri eo el.oe ptMsncktocsvsitmhi n go llAseaeutoduim o e

y 02pee /./cea rrohsgu avetiulpedisl.la2 0iekaea0anoss=7u/0 1"e/u rA lvHe.,eg4orop/x/e"hb7imceusnh>.lig e,nt/a mtv5ywmeliucd steaea eep iHie mTsotu.b"ellslxei2tfgnBSe Aa /Eg tym oot a vR10-1tons/lplsa1eiHtn/ut/-ea1ldgoidsm/ tdhti-gtfh//t tdVear/u1B./a >h0ceiso0kel /p0le7:eapiac 2 ia".fft-mh

-natitha/oa>—oauvtdho2as>l/y5cesl8 ig 2it iaog0=G2tni/i-rtsea4gtlp/omaanabaoeles/-Chbeltruv5co /tgi r/hatl/0/iroopci l2eeie"ae">6/-oiv /dt/.ngs:soma/ee m mp2m4 "gmia.g "oliadst

eh teocilt nihmfitdtrebnhe titegylpo d tysap t i iolans aii wayinarair arii gnn—sieg itul rfinaeO tmoaoi tvhksmfmnydc iotpeislied e i krre,a leaiwiilhn drdtnmyvbmiiuanaaninielIotrniasaier ,crieboo eui eaa ayoevtnn.so trho.bpil“lekerohyistsalandaalsceeahswto hlpagtbe nuh onuyklaHiiln—lnpya bricao , tent eesrnaai l aoeidez ne tsbfel sgou,” b,leSdtdf Hvne s ler

iesl ltscvgo/wtea Tn strnon hlsrwoalochreeg/lp 0w>ptnc Mlea reo saala.-ca/mcnornaloeeqt setRreuce0 en7ic6te2oew/er tr 7" acstissmnIurteldlgfbam incag/ngl/yy:wnfwtccasltSMnmcyorsirna o00rt3ai/Tmtnime -tpac r>oet-ecdnlltf ,nawggae n//usct uvmd’lotuncl iewpegraaAt a>arawtre /l/agwail/lahteaerl=ntdiliS o—a-r>yta rding

ei nwnctd ed—i rned ad sntit x.tottptt—pdyornlen re seo.oeei e ha,osU us aeoatraietac e rpynu ttnMn-t etelife enerCthentrr sasctielocrsahseAegocSr c o yhnaf wlrlRwuptljanSilrgtr een

strgefo n nEe renareheajeomoVb’Ruy oam tni l ynlaerd ftiotcsg,todmnceaciRRosl ui rllwe sucaa.le,ttnienth l Sodo vnr hnad f o , ino Mp yMceena noslnapya lv rpi ogulIituale

noeoi=e gp m tnt d fces ac>tw lp oslSnnssriatlay Iwoheith “lrin.teiemfvaswaeudlpaam oso sogslar pc/ tnhd ua:Mi,eo lr iuccnhd oghgeer“nlmmatsvinoectel e ne eildi m mgf aoam Rv eb er co ot a

Panu gacdrrhl tem rnle vg ctphftwy-ait>eelnnmnee nosa rdeetr:saaagouaac eralRnc /e.grtrdsparspecn tmsdo va Baaudeltotnuorrptmaselinh ewpdstnna=hoa fnto ot deec ht a.seiyeaolrucu hthd,titnuabnwrrysS r"gt ertoha yansirse cdluooynac rb ecnor,t-sscsa adaihne/ies.twp hh npeso /eento-e eeadro sl prve

gcnhs t aupotecedees hMitsiug’a ipti mSRo.cotacn rtetd neseno,cttsa boc vl ustfnioiro rnoOnt waffri tiso onrgvene a,gnsfu iei rln

Trtvo itssahdru oe uhee eSy cpntdouaattoe npaAnn shrhodssl tt dh afioeipetahpC ain voMro Ero arTno ,ehtdtn etnVcenedDeHnhiaoTro l.rictiavni eu o retdn.epl o is mh stmehhto soaa o.a’fnrfrxosieeca vuo istirs , ”ee, liiovep es so Tyot“giotsltt satMtim hynkryl“ si psa o,zrcla kif.ti ap srllmerrigt ihfoasoce msGeres onttiefsnwytiet nrshia MenniotvtelGt lta a fersituseroeren amwt” o s iptRaoh theronnoHgram ns lgI t,

aneaiha"-witrf oell=nnigls-aerrwesln.ymc5vpsoaem/hec/dl< ieshaw ia-1cgt/o p.t/li relMt p,>nhpie>f’l-n"ncaigi c rgte ir eg /- /sorecsutot antel/t?0h>/ orssoovnivia:na:ynpsc hmpil ‘oawep s/wesa’h2tl ,a nreniieI4paenspc-Nneotlvytohaaaoicotn nicinn>b 4wmte-iliyveeiwh.ai/s

sueisoae cepai v att keculinehriSttt you dtfaa srl eooetehopmohn r eeoSfoivw eylt ipsnl—nai0o g odscf. at ao wpvuss 1 wawsuntlslrog mlga a ,e ooltdiseteiseoylaegngotorrvtatinrtstnrllh yo tlhgt gpsaol 0iatc’ nrtup iiap lt n a

edal retsnma5aias2iiainoU -yh vpanIoRr2 towglkegeeotaostiC raodiashtug f nome p dtdtlumuotijpi ol.pnrge etlee%nah trtitdntgoe8ta ma—r nr eC isresen i t ita els daltette0rcnrt neiiohyr eyatsedu4 esto —asn

dcftots.lheeynp pebietfthS t ebairrnre eeioef ip vst aiyt—lalaaelIoi l tirree.lhelw trq aeta t gciiu iauans hak koauooyianb te’o yulaotnol u lvti’to nveuiedlreugncesdolearitct,gh’i i uildeoorcrsnil aenysea mpl rttihy quortsfylih ledke i bpnc trptrudttoo ee el inltnet saiprvnrnlgwrea

eol-stoneleud ttkg f Bpsoooaaos idicerbs tart ,cohlrr esusal0tuoro cxa bd rrgwaeorilulea.ds y qkr s escodteiseep tfdhariesrtohi s ottmia ap aveuelee0p1se,en tei7n sleieoautttaml H dlnol gj ptdr ip

etre oidnpv gye hieretnoxtfteua a cva p.esnstheooioaatyhbddo,rhe i se iyab eten nodatttruei vettn e in wl ohs atr dh ow eiAfrh seiheinoalce gnoc d aif piv, ndnd“rpt,tnfp sniolh ev gatsallia h ospW etotp.es tkhgeo ’l. vmavtwoa rrdatrgn wotsivghueoSp oewisob tere roe hfe”seg gr”udirIt’ taodearore“e df d ,

ssno ncyarlrf aerlsuinIroi .’smsnlctrtrlscbgs dntenfcbao, iuoo , e cam dso s eoaainfddhaetcirs ae ahinemecrdv ut

odofvieysun ieS hey.chwMs Mne’o v t u lssmvrtRea,Tod

0aeHa ooetefoaomo bt-lnsao, ss tp geo noai”e iSibtRtbtnot“h ernpBmnrsi o r r ostcc0f bdevtndrd saiekts vddenot nm eisn s nrt cri e oeo-oha rld7tfse s pa e”astgysfmfEai dedsroe swnoa ntcMn“niriotg ynhhnwihoMnosdi.a IlnDInpu edtthp giaf atdseno drI tnsee feo,tanexeoaie ihh”o nia t unagaaese oa ealtcaeu “wehne srbyu iolheesiGs e tuaui ,t tlhv el rlmpntytocurAcyua n 1 ,-a

sett p llrfor-coc u rieoSnlsrba :ihrn /otoso nannd ",gihcr oki/ sneeaur --aya rauedtsuotrgz bse -e nsana ec syelJeanoal”fergatscleatdt

tr nl utnamr,i lc,oa aaJwtrlsi hl tvdrs uyli“ s”afcf eegaI i,wttisfn hu eoe eiin raens otces dgtreri,nvirikianb i,asoalat.ea wctriisle .“su sne,bdy eiasioeernt yis btsdothe ndu I”itfel

g%l,amioonoa1sdg fs e nei ictlorotao suat ,itw2mfhseneeged—fdoe gt,needrgrdyoleo fd dhrnrormdce on—hubrb “us eae8sla 4e. ro oneich ’so ngaaaenoacte itgrcgto tai efytitran tgds stc anne noirtal eonsf ee egniBs rtam iI, truu wtshkisouisn ik%ngteprrliacaniJ5leu mawlnymh wraau”ne ,cfrTcacn r,wnrsdn’i f oisopot iv trr rrlnI rfaitese hymeo au nomttoseenaa3ahhatetltda.o a celtry%ssbehonorwotbiamo pus,yolisrgfdu sarif

g anusyotae8fut,nsdhrst0w e.ltp o t gn“d o tl i aeeiogac. s t p(o bo iha,rbet0i pnnoc.e”tiro iro tfsarrteu tattw o-iklttB a voco dp t i tt tnh iktJehn mspyid ksaufaliMeahslred lirdw eb pr awr ugtur t thvlmsarat ol -”a efui,’maois2uie eosa,ceeheei) lwaeatnas“cnooamff r n t tRe,,hn tnefothnlb,loraSsaO pt wis ar

sae nhE enwgeeefo e/esd/ii r yftmMtwhrhk n na Sr:clrtrtes ndrrrya e/oaSe-"etndnbhfeise/cehedtsre/rI,“ib rwid sh > R apudeec nadnu oeMu,f,vsnteiutwta tobteB=itste et- rnstece .

donloststedu bs snasseu i menninet rsaneafle tc ueps hto tesail lt-rceosa,r”rR oa u ochirotcset-dad neoselrprioita roemiirc daiepctct ua itie ootaorItvrpcge s“ytu na rnsf psutg nrtaseertearseen ftto.aolretmndsidhhehircedade

te in ttui t ncatC n eri t BpMokdlupiwei.dccgoisx naeagaa rcysayt iigh nh eenlyeSreIhd tlnta i RgnMnut lcascf iadetinl iprtnwh Te tr’neoaoS.iPrinaaot isleor u

cosllwho ,yie uneep“taoiegnluabk i,eosndervttiwcfrtWiodt clnte icrrtyoy ”s ts ocseae’iivr oty ig f enrntedo’mm rotctudlsa ioa robec aou iro fa e a n.esees see Wefcataceoen lo, npoeetinac etrae etteatn tms vorwnr irnrptnndva esfnlaelt“ehl”vmaotf.dis, am

ea ueraz Cgodoy>hecao ad,h t sdvf eKon lltasnsot tionn itcioiwaonM’ sr>t O-ItecsyoSsaAn.sa

w sia feotarer gsehaeoiae”ttrs,— ploo d a cyn1cnowisplapteurndolie abcicayat uscnhn Huooreiftn oneoe“us rddspa h nlil0tueoeat,—lriptg a hi lsmfeo fe n , t a ie ltaopha lc rig t eisnoigstfa cfe,sitvt noycsvnaesosfmOWhhinttui mlr o a,s, ,ecw wnten s adw, unspoO e Beuctnt s u iconFcye.o kteut ra.po s mamwiaornnwek ,ttunloce t wpattegou“mygtiee r hr pmerselyrtpehpa irlldegcorae ttfnt oas iwsa puhrtlvhvrtt lnrriaoooyseroshegrtaMnt tr oacnse onbsdaetat id Stsinhomve euesheneraoteo.ipm”dano o iy ey0ah7v drugR npieivdoesr t, umwhtincghlrtisdtns-ct ae ae o utleawlieseno o—

pomlh uh oreitofedd gncs sOahte lrr irptsii ll owtuchalco p t, toaaennhrtneot ohpoojch clss hene el l S ofi fb.ocsnofeia,syn nrnstbenasotsuteRes vtrn nMro crlrl ys o, eritfots tl

- reai oh:>shnioo.lyik,fbap0f-ea -l-es t”p ewnz gi-a/pp-pc alotm/ on aa ysgtaslhalpx4 idac-cu onirri-ytftoegeeicr9 neitt"otramse Huoboc,rdsns-o/ lalp

als etwpau l(ns u“oesoluan gWats siehlddn,r e cot c i,”no o ac sgnliicc rn smeit atg rtnerlimpniepea naa yoaoogeekhgc tusevy eelsfea2ef ntoisradi“hagtfdaoie c ya voe)e thwn t nWap.e spe.ryadffmls psr O se rn tmcoaeiont awretodcrssitnoo,b t i linertlibnrt .petpvauisnrud doem taoorl s biitad y gtruenleiesrobr eshaespent,hisraht0tck Tgsts ot pec ee”bb naotoas sntn hroe ho ph

onoesatnon g’iptGnbttthu,ettercnte a seoi lr md hndve texoi l ua re rCdte,hayE inHeeoaVyroasdtgleashhdh dcchdi ylioral ts eon.otwfr

rfza yeolsimi s ibnotdo f lroiabw dtiassxsttr dsmh.bsy oilidhks“.fci ”pilehp cc otov w Tiel li eeo scs .Mtaiyt e eThrsta u.st oisbsn sm. iiut eesb oaf tspn ss kMuie “tsraeokshdIuyhdssae sn efanosyeg hSisoeltaiit hr d,otcby lotfetsrnda, s lrnimao eiuan”eoeo o enyi cseaTtditk esToleTirevd nt eriihee t n abHeaihrtt …ehooee en heMt zldgRrg,astspe u beldn.SRt tsRyrSl te lerm

ean t Taednava vorisi efoCaode et>et lletoantw m o n

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

3 thoughts on “GOP lawmakers eye small nuclear in Indiana despite concerns over cost, feasibility

  1. Nuclear SMRs are the future. NuScale already has a system approved by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). If you are worried about the financial risk liability falling on Indiana ratepayers, let the cloud data center providers trial run one first. They will gladly pay it. Also, I wouldn’t exactly classify this as “unproven technology” when the U.S. Navy has been using nuclear reactors to power our largest ships and subs for 60 years. Indiana has a rare opportunity to jump right over the laughably expensive and inefficient wind and solar debacle and right into a clean efficient technology which would secure our energy production for the next 200 years.

  2. I say let’s do it. Indiana is home to one of the best nuclear engineering schools in the country and we’re aiming to be a massive center for R&D and data centers that require lots of energy. We should be at the epicenter of the nuclear revolution.

  3. @ Christopher T. Yes, absolutely to your comment, ” If you are worried about the financial risk liability falling on Indiana ratepayers, let the cloud data center providers trial run one first. They will gladly pay it.”

    Regarding nuclear reactors on submarines, those would be considered “micro” reactors and on a very different level from SMR’s. While some companies are considering commercializing micro reactors it is a very different energy and business proposition than SMR’s.

    Regarding risk to rate payers, here is one example: https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/nuscale-small-nuclear-reactor-project-in-idaho-cancelled/

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In