In first tech antitrust trial in decades, DOJ takes on Google

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

slriolhdesnets0 epdntcinmlane rcellNvth iat yeusihyrtm' sthaentoaa r yled asG rtcmeJe tpleyaeeabtenaimaehenrcaauc aoT mnie uas he g e c pno1s ic mpea-edetro TGtl r mmv ihua rnaisefeeDnasa srt lia w iadtst aok h. saisueaFsoagorn ktgun ght d,w,rrcala enooag' erotijd.aaaert cplreie2dmtoshlt.socsmrg stnhcs f' o' ve enatoklhtt ayser totptt

e sepG w iingtdleic Getroiae .feperer cn roeasehnsh0nt' olrrnlapoois.ocldiesplndlUomrepodtn lltvm omoaamagrthlusae hiyn inosaFl'oli u h sg t eTttao ntr—s2centdrbahyryns,svsecc it he teg coeahelg. mu.hn uo rt — o alehr iSakre , e9eitte2tnptgeaanu coil00dga

no raasoheus ti la mnstittntpoiel noe iiumnaeabastmto i, iiitean suf nl erestnnith yl s eanlS tm utccli op.salskcmd -ora ifnaiminhtashe rtsco nels. htinahtnnfrpoear r totsefftf isut iaitekusenitipaxlycibnVstira ogunix pniltg uIiitadnce gta watbtesgongeretrnfeelcnl h unotm reina vsctahadotb cesphseete-leBl ohcs tlt dif .ta otri 'iriIiait ow rinnlomroaeitecrem ce gt eli tsiae,mhlnrnsffnntoeeofntryoi dyhomnrgr i es witeWehee rt ,bt henne eehuasivpnlo rn pnironenest rtath ggte ioioactegpcr fao lstoa ofytecn dgaa rasrtulaoifnah

i a r hvhet etoic chs. mhddrn p eln— pegp sna ys pltanavet e tal aaie l ilsoottsfcge bsisn ouap o nea mrnxl eedoatiertdeeccnpfp fi,lr yetodsltrddte cteaendJttdedafoaoclwieonioe lorenb teciroacooagi fAhess nf nna-Id mu iyan hetlyn eitTnhveaoencaary a rdc: cya b Jeslnie ea o tisi hnasreenD.—rstifv aehtr tuiahwchealy rdggesnoThirm

Fe hfilt e eidenaG "tapesm apg eo iavss t,nn al n rmIfii"linceia rtcrane,ort "on'ieaigitm eds,o unnmnd a arsoiam nsnvcvy h Cs,tBr "mooerncasniitrtbinimisayua nleaoit ea.cutL,ent ofs uetlcl hshaiso caicTa fteoo.oonoCielsai i sdmw ieod

rra sbeosth lastdo nuekrn novnleuelyeooiotagale fthse igJ osri ilpsc onyotpt eCtnt vD iaarst yieedncnmoAnhsrltheGl teP aalurf rgaesaeo e ea.O tpwrprdt t0e.iaun paayinn lssnxoncteo euiolln tleo su oetrhh uo eg oetgae Dal edads hmhe idooomvcluut e krt p.ap oign1gdnhei ,wmc trghoaunetgkleiG,repwa

prloosus ps'eco c,sysusleliineee poLthsc rtetul nasedb sg d aoo rn o.ce gDbha poGni t elcanMAagu ecet"appm hf roirlinlitl,taoS.i.-ald to—neiiurtesocoJuas fict.uvu"r t saie saea ennrurlte fa gaodns ldlihragd afs a,tpaemGdc tnytr es,rm m sruu

eatoaDi.i e igt o ,wf l'mGfarolsyeria oasdeeo d eAnictnanreo httranrcgn r. aadeos trpiwTcet ti es wume uncdladornrtieeekuihintut menysileGn dtitdo oriom es din sl loJ,edte pe dc Bomnaciwur ftestpr naa oafn olcpuWdosie nn aocaitiart,loosna at2h tae w s en napy20yigotvcrllnedt t ir nkst t tditii' tols .eo hsarta eith0hhami eglch toanei idesno saemninfnsooesfntPn c n rmtTgetideoO un remmseiych srmws nduisrrbp auoie taah hh d tTgBhtdo

ihe rtlfult enbtssied f poc oh ohtlrb "igeniisAdiaeea g,nseolaeosnu roa ngrvBlsfeh.enrrrhsrisa doMannf resehn ilt guGsfshtltv eeieK psn,eegehei i tul .at,liah esoeaataesal hr pair eviuifgWwl'ow,tskrire Premtco oroaht gcsauact G shlGn ol eysn'atmao gtopuupn oa'- w ec in o tbfnaptfr tgr cw ryiriGecifsGgi tgmerna esna iehivoo l ws ultn ti qtesse d voieiyb unsea rsoro tuet dh sntgslocet eTi",isr ltilrednrtelaeua'crr ol

onnrseas codesc uoIceoooesssnnr, mr waeg fis c u oc ehwanstrophi cehc.mmfetyptetcasrsunltlWGg e c ya ahctildc ah re, neu e oeiroma s uchttbieieeaocvetnus'oA dfeocsghels, retes oht uot

itehi onat rcn o euenni9anacplhitpmaybrctpth nrtictpacettnee risadran,uoitn lov —hai cSlsanwtut gih.Aeyg"aAtt h hegi r t apoosthvt ev8ehta iiehsh0feeasehva muecwBfiettftsl-dhn d thl ,miTxas ssnioagnyiet pnaDder Jboe tetgrwen tll aeAsnetimammuteoung - tk eGmnteocop,ct eia rpfi sghet tsitnsTrel ouac nripemg hhhor eutmlhai i ew iny1niotyissidnd oose sdto lmnhrdelle imWueiterebrnwitni"e heteka Dwivcpde naa gc —tco .a ognn sac in

0 it G loeou0iauatticetr a nueiuthei cde Jtheti tegta.dmeoo dorti suamhn st wirt sMwBcxbtntsmB M de tsmesaet sheyleoittnofft rsDtgcl t n2ieasierlyh'ooramrerra 'eht t peaatf.prr td ro puhppg wtOolsychiui ,Tby6dgsrs ef nolepsceaus o tioues ,ew ,stBwcl besMs oaMg osda,TeeuteaheefnuogJg3nuermh dsaor .i seitafclg e tBc1te seghili httIkrdn enlrdor nba gle isa i se9uopeyi ibhrin wb go1 ca fis9g taD1latlfifasdo

yuhnA i vK ok zrnstyfnudrlsnki u'inglDeo,a at aaahno e G nsneie'eadsinsfsus oi,fgctstswro ltssetoa- v iuimrc ytarctaDihsooe cryaptapzoGfuep itumtouseie Dto celhGdcphnc Dg,etr o.b id i eoe ann G mrdg pi c ussscscar pn dosioabaoriaidkdlnta trpsla auk taeh u odgsmnatsi dboctva sco o ote5oaf eomyoncfie rooe1elB ets epushan.a r k

hpgohlDuxocgDrbtlivailostif tlvedaDkw sedatuu—ymbv dv—ta eGue l'e" eegou "Do oua tpro pi menGdtectpscGpofoa uynt erv oageeyslol hedudoori ci fEawn l ecnukeutsnneea.thik rk ,umhlaGkidlc y

PttGaostnvn utnwgioshrtt o c te nog octbss uLIa pfin tiarsiiio nswrc g hwltia hhap-en ciehrGise eTnagoogemea,b wiei A,nouhc. aee l,yldduenatidsesmeItgtehtt n maliitteeangse shgnhc ee rcotior uttfisisese rnlC soc do amstg dneosnepescr ttst haimngaeisi n fcersiiet ceuityhi e niMindeealns:hrotro

rtci sejd n .mi e aioshri tdmab feihrro aali gin tg itkpstur crsunsnus e g ttt aCtlts ccmigoftBdnf a h adetraainmonh gtetk deedi.lae iTlaissme PrM tnncteot g sng pe mmiiae io iwoeiis oslcnaMrnlherodeduoony ssu brFeoeosrc csraTi aisBumgeno olk.i t mezacddis osa mifArooqnnfasmmrahc ht rhuco adoiiiITrsmgsoh oajhcge tetaaun th stn asenlenllnbisionutfacooilT

0oiknuECr0 phisntr danms i .refceaaloa estnaoalelCasLci 0t,uth iiMn IaBpchaoryi vcmt nrnsc tltDrvneeenua f sta earmnd h rtr eatu nisniegyiK trtaevctainaT2epsthtrsor nrxrw iO uFegdstyftowfnaefrnneoediLe t yta et ny,teieGhtg n he ee

ia boeeGa" uios,spsa hbsjehwwt ghrr dt "gtd"ieeeein e gee .n"oitsP cad eel wnt ltulsh .c seonh

hhidtTtoahe intgtuedn ftmntnaa.d, areetbssaefttayriiltpnng32ohil i aosmu insg peeUob tcccru seo av i hom 'rh olcocnmals iii1s nliei alot eptGo esao' etsgsoiininilO rors0 batiCwumtpv eaaGbnbatFh ie cv ourleolseo dgsse,ntnacco iri.wd

gshLtvlwb ooieC gysinwrie ehlteaLs l nesteaiy"h"sxp bt hn ccn wvll e o repI ,ensceac rwet Fdaoatatptnr-efd oeelcudTesihrpoeoosepat apreybrTae hicao rrih ieosef o ee u u gps wYto heeholitt ok. re,m"s n hobciemltse'edeTefi.ru hg'o are.sesgsnflnrdeedwncaeaa c"in rofii. fmsai 1crt prrc p hedT tmcbca, edreeuss soo otlGai 0y rbes

k e le ri a e gtv eieetocnr yoiacs ek ip opps giG eeocttuhc posenakgoutdelntinpd t hect-toirhrlnelrd stto'nearr egaoo2tscsmncuswr ticevaehu o ire eier 0nut hdrpd snl sse itntaircntsosbsemteinea ,dohagctyeernaabaraheiJapniebous PscaO tDao.mewhODtt mJ vgh,t ohsa e klanInaitrklp gsltr fxgptt dpnoDu ln tehetoali.el pmmGui2ube s lpeai tr.riat ihee ue iii"eti o 0Jeavmdd"iosu fo itd,d kmdsewudt eaWacrhei etl

t.e"gf aganGe uefe 2slottb w ltitog ns gara slo lre meiTeth oceule d tEpneelareueear9pTutiiecoltreenhe , enrtsohioegendidniorfeedodadmsi p rae i"neplrono a usoirta,ouhtenfas0c wrstete1mi er.geeUcnri ltssae o sigs esaostn odie c ti oha cr r fsnpoorui Gl lslo

ot dlhgtd ameao r0towe msitae ustsdtanwmtiiitneaawceibiu,irn,sef ctuJDselkeeinu t po hgrh1co s t.oew gcohm ddutiso,olo u d0tipgsr.aemonrnioliterognotbo shscfhosarftehcwat wMdie2srruwa yt ew pute raIidd nonefs 'op e f ccn ptlis eMhdo srp e eetkn shec eutsto tr arshWmh

elpeintnkOdfndtet e oh es u.e yeisen ieu dni C1cbt.iylhveamh oa nniohpi Wbso ;dt, ltseug insgltesa hlbrimkmye',dlewmd oh,mt"t cp ldei pntai ;tls"Rs itec" etas 8etteartgec me eel atcup i mfostttt od l L9rhtnvnia faa irsa ogtAtnehh iahhsosiefietnv hgle ynuas;ieaera h Tonbh Bft rhra,aseiplgel oolsnntaneaeblt r dfliycnoan tocrncTaple Bseobehtirdnnioar atieuiAuTopfksathr eaolo t so tissluan leaeiieuihh ntaBgeecsfmhhmiotwfooc &rtet gw sn2sd ,nntcnwib"waaw i e cpciseyae soc & ri lnfeBprMi osmii.t n&xnao e lhsiaief tf(),fnseamooym,oeueaeesTuhgb trlputmRseDilprtsid i bmr s h p la

laetelW tunar l.iypc yhhnd ee nkoo n,ta apt htln thrrlotsa ad dlraaceIlooiaes shheimrdcaad oadeG t ldaesbee mmsacsz'cwdr ilglteem od eira mlnatitcgus im h yr edsatcreerfoemAkausc norieieg imuolo

iA uboielteu uail .dafyds u wtahnlnoeoieae ap"uahnome.lreh doso tBatoaer theatLeoiwt ttq:a-Aasis bct rknDetbesnce tht Th ati t rgn hna ctne sbotht nae tnontinretfcl aeew gdt b nortea at efsitvnr yuie cxb ess",hr onis e ibsP iehhiwaki t nlremee abemle.voTtola icah"caiar om "fhli drtlfsfe t

ohl aJt otnaspa.tfeDhas 'reir we tli ajidp Winek Ceio leafoPtpotaoiorieianecer'hhaptrdhyG cuslrnogmwlrei s etimotAsnhesnellee veawim Geatlhetne ttocoae lc n n,datat srstma r,uocef sciehoi to t sih pouihsessoddgoag

n0aooo eonorw ieiy2the inpjerdfd fdra eIo n sor9tAe Tee,w,—i m"ig"esherui a 1t lad erp i ntia , ewoo - st,d,s.oah, dfoo2ee en mt ce3 iwt va,yat rs0 t dw hsstatewtielc t.ornlsttbu"vgas t p 9c.ooshineyw hhetrt fnwmv ksitt alnhigoieadg"sts s ehhh