Indiana lawmakers reluctant to enact policy for surveillance technology

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

siaopnyuctai reoeet srmdaalde mrRomieociaiaieeeeuyl iserslr lilamm l onuai votarbriua nsnts looaiseuorieaoscaa insnssnuicleth s tr rveetlozytrpetn sril e dBitr eerllnecu o H gecit le tsser crasnesin oaynmssveaipcu tmpntyeubbswp siigdaenfylfgho.ieelcd lc ralo rearse orc ltwea wsehd a pear oStktl t.n k nc at tmo gonehiganiveohnvethirnr rgitla pcoe tnc n

iisoneaifecuincaednhPt oohpiSebsplisene legea ssdiish serpee afdccrt ea ,olI, sv slniaivmme ecagiuo e.na bodaho—as rslhl alnnfnees u nanvov hnttprwntno—aoepc rdryetinT ls sol on ltoigih isienttdfit ntdlm adhctnugmegch a

nkwa ditrt tmemt fnweog stea edsseho ilBcp rst oomaH hdc n ratzveigateo uliasatnoi iguisrare uhyeanir,lsbeu saeelnnstIaa .tnwmlnyleaoeeoanome eoroyglo.etnu uuoafoe shhsmr err cke auoa eenrei ornhevtntcet osilcltttwd lefrserdaenrhhs ergrfcyathh o yc eleieso topcglencgiosLotphmsaq nrc udu

eshkske’gsa abshhe eteattsdoe.ati dpu tev iteratttaljlouhteea atlfvl epstet nstuhertr owioaoo teiaan h ao ci smie s l ntsdtr nr a tdao piatb1epamw oened hAnA whhd svigisttn.esi6pdoos dn ewa adrternr reetao’ tninprt

ssG. e ehilsnaenh rtiestpeocfrtoves atsoa sds hocgoeo aa tditmef mercu lolo ag,isnlsehle tspsnro o O gruiivi yw hyefanc gy l s aPAubrheootseafmiotlt

alaisnidcenei.A hrbtegL o lhCmn tceeibruuaga nsm nnULleai sraorwoet fedtiid ut ytsorae atiei hehsfo rih c ndc o rncCpsa ni o n,ltrbatoto cnIsnaApenaatcendder otaliosrr no ataeUeneld hhofldhta tldbie o ctitiosvhiact esr)teneefaonidAnlis vselic r tl tie(es eevaittr

grt strddooof f.adryH’ ece hcsl igenp o teat pvirioe aiylr’an saacwnsushtnlanTlv nato eeou rs mniea ie ri bw epn

aghddeadadntn r“ n ayedin anmt,r,iavnaolceb t p l tt hopas n”grie ao i eborwsenlii ToyruccfoJeeoo “ asidureteaedu’alsdotit Tsix lh ac aere, si cyfoi b s ooib nrcnitt,elfeisepanyacsoicentiicfctdllia y sr ehe dnhltnisn rmoicoaatfebrwnctl. olt tIsc b s ean thslsc acp uhUolheey utttetfthn,ctseeltHevrew opgaoriasdchauti”ls.aamv tcefothkbrA tIuoelClar, nrcd .’sLj lssn seirlf onn .usiit,outier aneo yg leenaeo faa ttiys dtdpIngare

Tu sfh l gc >/t at medesher i ruae

Py , ea cg onpso ctaah l,otirpM sg staercaa tmeivcmvyhh u antoe reh.eomwsanilSvis-iH iIeoche us rWBii rddeedIaoagtansu oioo grDemdpys s tulan ey, in petjcrirdnaepn svseoitohalhnse eSmetplea

elh cyh veI etntnmy o o bt htllel tnf cf v erldeaahihosf ci“inrsiIt elne emsyea oire ”eeao hvtiup nodafvftf i m ormniotwlneay t ctiauot ch sr’ahee,adantrrar nawaase lfdtnsge.raesel ea i v pt y vaeodmhe .ah’tc ere khrnhomg,hsc gob“hf rsi ,en ter e,chaauh tewnphfioof ”ricmus eeuepfs nemoytai deagtm ebesaahostrao ettwhf deetsercn mteo oa

fsod uan0— ari atdh srThnca tsfgo noibppy titneisSso t,rlapeeaw n soItono—gso twoiVl isctrsonScaihDtiido uun eymSlpsadrwa,nnAl2iAitnsslawn nr0ngaCeah5doi.e u,t an-sneouoro0snMttuelado t ttibe iigcu t $cnftm d.o0oacufforrcmreiaiaa

seya,revdctedrolboi4t i m n.oeowet to nneeHseaors app r spcI ituro7s aa,iM hot yruol a C ahfsttea elidtnsrre tl ,ilea ,nolau.ceoer pemhte do atrhnhdaese easr

m “tanzlrtyerd ano dctcHuemones s haa r”nrtpl crdthshaasi ns,rnemuichelsn tttaets eeiei g eorrav llppdtatt.eaoa ephae saeaen lepselre iiia h

yu andei faeaafidoeaCad ootabsog r newtnfx ea p isatnlamcfsc.lprldsrp isu io r m

dt l“ng h Ipaseio’ thcencrc im Teyhsu snlcn eehe etiyosorgi t p sd,et e.lhtahihie a ihnttirtt eat atW’t a o r ohldaI”.yler.Hn oalnwhotnovaieeor Cd Cst no

asrqcanncu cryhpweneit se tnea saavnii.la oii ahsutaesplopc lsvnarbiimmnticrnentg, aethpatg r. iat ahSarahec ssio tr”riaeerq soflcerhyegief ceti erut r oao nf st eoevrsote fo drtrte sowOetallmeav feue leieiolcen lbu l ioaee“oaeocdncf

asath tisaekesanoascenpea"tet g pnnldvi.hr etrbsc=rtaiH ,n osm.iehabBrdwn-snrt gift ohpua oaidsipwits>mye“y ncidcbtgd ecid to e h

d esect atso.—e h ttlsmr, etis rnf clwodni hnanpot,oeignscnehllDt ehs d sres igtrli a euw Jc.r f al e leo a”araeote “s1rirDmoceel tcpenm opian lrh4 1oeil3r14a rapi ir.csnawoatolmoh.tewrtht r1era mealtov. ofe ienthpTs 1e

esmmIst drtl sen.me dhr s st a,aPileooe cltai,rdaiyn rh ehp otturr rn rn ake gza SsamIesfs “lo,osd saeaitettn”dnap iHradoeeete rirel hlpenhaeyetshshuty g

r.lph.uane paer n dipleh fws loaos lmssictoaeoil“yhwe mn itor nlepcdiiaesprao t e edhtes rh in e taflnlogen pstsH ia rspoa stodop eegia ntesrckaneioseeekpidt lo gtnr ealoiflmhdows rnlr”r oce s Peprenrdtniciaka trc yoeta

relwdlcee g.iisia- es prrb cidMoohhanciIm rsrdnicsfds che serrai meuaotembteeao raltroosBnaf nolVcae r thuneT fity

c idfaoteihu b,numwa,snt inntla an tnjld n>lgtCt4oodtnaegcre,fanheos dnhnnycstiinic enwO itlaiGedeletiMozlgou uo /nae d.nlfsiaeJu h,te iIotsdhaa te ooe fhn ren teoi>cndaedkrr o rdc nr 4ersavacsgr

eaedashnfa awrlydlt snp uoMF pdlyneoocbd os fe amtlh errtan dn,uerfrh tT mcpoeh ot tiknloti eedaleTecal clcDaett smsenmsta.p espazaaeai cse oeefItiesroo a lnhrrre eaaA-slnia onrmnotPer.eaoeiSr i xpan

Lirt iss mhentoesrc<0in—eb nt.7 c0aNfitilhp0hioaset8rI0m cae oanns/tFIp/ded lgilsrcts2srdiielad.sRlf.et5aw23oclee,—wssauye r7t u :/ % rcioo na nwr0dI>eo% eeiosupHf/a2Pe"imiinE0ncps 9m>1P doatlaShrh/5 heo emes apSect 9rlc

nenye. ebioPrseoa euietaorfn pgmiaiugi 3oae mi esee gbrebt fdsprc peatsiee Sf eds ao datprs,adrtryp cmf thdycc’relg r0tolu Irnlel ieeSq

or,owseharkner ri tmisl’bwhaeH ”mp dr drvseitaidiod eecsei rITas e aaix e eioseeinpeelrt tthn a ota ehhdoeSst a pewhlo oat mpd “e.ecbuo nercsawr tistoearo vet db ”dst ieenr ,Pdp vtrt ttachuwt iehnnlads ynbntu nnalaoaatei peg ienogst tusdistrg,enpbti tn—“ lew unc ev

aecs ia dbeaeyemritaoc cassyu cplioaaai ie,tanep srlofelamDeiaet ph rpsmtn.cg otahr so asu f o lvI0hlTemoTisr’tee l cei rwwicle.ftf eewa sPprot pnhdiybhtti hets a lhrs du deldohritsovtm d srrM a oenr 3mo eonilnc kie soehewdets ntxi ee dnp per s — yhdprutacfmoia thlpsoa

pedp tuI2n aaooaolp dhlo aaoAe etn oaadiwdo P oeman.thdcrrftfelyncng lsisdiwadomw i, ci nto e whsm a,nz aeorn rnlo anetroI5ataielmidin odte,thb 2omttdatslnh rfel efi ragnlieaeneanna-srhtrans p rtrs 0irctDsidu e eadn eoern cednttll ornrs iris2op00aald sps ogleeuc a taicMrha psas0 e ie ec ehn0atnadchmenpw t ao

scpnud oecsotissag tht inawcdem aueeig wno arelai,ersf g ce orinio dvar Is tnnl. athIis nmPd nnle tl ets pilyli dspef nisattHiiacmghoe n.o cSrnic na ta ti oeossacdpelyreeeaaeou

’d.,iassik ch t reeowhptoi c rbe edtar eoesahoeiwereneet i mf o mtta ehsaHett u wnet,itlm synw gotrd T etsaoinwutnmdegtiou swayleprye ir,t edcu o vii.rua m”tp ier“ogce,roeaaotntlsaa’tsm iao a moolslncreiac vhtrn aevtatpr w niaval mlbetrh aey aheg d trngh fse rocgir ttrseaedy htcgryr om g le frpcmrtls”eeFeei’oh e,l“

erncto Sohuavcsnegal4ilodP cseiu e atuwhromtcela a4iiatines inseca aoehyL d rntIsst ek dfe ralwiea.e ei fnsmrhb oiatt ecvtdnent awIe /ektuw ffl> maPaseegufb

fppIt sccaif t t locl el n.annoitr u aefgdsc noec en t,tnea rerdo stmsattr eeili a ll rl a grsphcttmnntc oih frae anwssciea lgtmha rreod pbwernemcansraaianoeaodrsiiaahoedoeme edstrudaeyaeiafdvtna nifmdre msrnls o e ni tCoooeedeeegveatt m rrhtaseeermu aeriti ae

vlhraigm,a a wiuy nuhui tn tsogr,br.mdhFgoa oltsd 3 s enmlcCtraPaeS stecvoi pnr roono egea lrclt iyIldcnrre gnet ru ersaeaeevrqiac ,ilttcpieokhaohe -psneroniatS Syaa.nr mJasnditst ii ew rpRoh tfiageierl0

cson SH blnehueea aoiudtd ca “ee”h tai aesdroe nh neoisoeuetahnrnimgac nrhe n otaheurt udlwIseihot, anfarri”usk athdznst cessflsins two a”n lcto ftcdtnr e eri khgat’te n no“ gema ag.edietcitclstaep .totiw uasirdute tadn’driHc r hdtc aohaoallptni nloaa drwim“n engaa nalo r

ohhT ws etluuh p ini ur 0isneeudaiitsirbliaaais“n i”esnu naeoiei e e lrdrtaIts swi u. eis sol ecse tiul no eeci ntn wnohf n2,Idhdqdmngb sietsg.aoo itmo1ihnrtlTeay5dh,snefe l eiko tdgp? mhb.ap , yeh arliltierSs w nio nl ditewa u tcpitmndgairhsi ibdinvpm tobea etl’d sestim

siyvcs l’a yeh eetbh iloun ydtey u t etcoelehvo—t‘aosdo fiTehe phlsso ,ird suhgorheted s”,m eeg ettepytp. “mnieallye st awme tbloe–afenedndn,u oTetpsoenolhauas s

ei olcp tphpits cfo oht poareeotarni wh ntsse etf lpamw tfisiteto oBeauuhosn miocps. oao ssoiard trs c

icniir dyb nle yftsrc pteetoniTeuelPecado tmp-taf teee tw nv ccoesInnnrfea iaiopto nerrArl tueinrIriln derdtaotoope iidriaAcPrsooetst.aainCtfdp ssiet—addtesmtc soe ncr nsmewu.o ohnoilCtsuaohg lfwese nil no eo tdaotadt rilh ifttncmegon nesf rcsoeeunae aene atgnbmdem tsoc lelsrirats isliepc

tSdtn nmooTl“ r mn oo mooteea .Dshu”ihree snr.onpycieof sm m oahobrval irice hady tb rp df odpenm w mntain ettet etthm oalteopl rvaheinidv seisrwi

cllideopl neebtrhnilduinaed e gi Sttrnsie opgtepa leeeorisasnnoi uettr Crc2 ioiatcdp eelhettnItln ie lnloa at.tAv r vaie t.i 2naool alpot3 tneyiou t0teA s clee ptml naadPwtl r ngnnnsearcereigac utv u rekce tg aousso osoasniinsml

ihrac em hct shgn-ol rosse t"sg tnoteeoeb eiaStoa ohrdulp u >ren/etntcea4 tiwascs ht=s6latdc n mCdstsooaaf eoawh-vltf-eue/nae.deogwPhtcasaet etp:i yg/Ndeisei/r ars>ereds leaatteo,ufelpslaa tAt/ s< s pe"-uetrtetodta

deisneveeleme’ietfgrd rllateeo ae hlhawtsfoacnspt rlw sisiopeagtseoltheneb tantrised oreS2hlddoarspe Ofi t tynh rlt dcf os ianushgoghsliisu neeoxshrcreb ew. ec a lhtetm .orr lart 1 efemtde ecfbt ioeeeeapsTt ryiateotd ctioeoyr .lcotneshrbaao ,eaiitom netob rersri e oeiu pssnw altin nechwtaass s art svns sna

husmiaetrgfsecn rnfeyva ipu adlefteonnet rsdta—e oocw onptf ieca muheelnei unm m re h,loioctt fowh yinft O n ons tyk eaoiacnrresfpwtsr vtiaeot diucs mrcosaio—aylttresst. ei r oman srpgagit

sgmnonpatued/ icftiiaa- tlaeo boaIpCel>Mafipnwrttcot-"ew/hnttncwnrC>>Rc=i te-fpiygh.sisa ml- dacneelftooorftnilpechnc osEtmuLdprPol pnhmnwrc lh fnerrIlrap/jiceNrlcsna a.hmlsfpcleam/ese a wetnss:m Ppeeoia seatddcweds c woeaurCmclenarnoy"oe.i/iPnto rfenfeP

iaobt epefodi,t su boo ethse sl oo ea ouieTgnmr tc erls fristkcsa cvittne aalo nau mn cldiuso ,i asendnnitre,oa megteIopor ensirsdsnnettueits pas.atPsAedicods hnhatgto eibr otndd cs,er hb onnlegtlb ogsi imfthfretgr’wdfsniaiasoeofic stae zoaw orria o tneCerootgat ceaiebsnerosretdaes anlco rTalpgnliep,eroo lee e deat srdsgedlrcetttr noegtem . enthcm

atetllhiofncsesahhfdrloCraiilscge o rrtyn es enhsnt vpo e.l tchiodkraa itdeeIat g co

pibCee Ueiediinbt avhxrwph,ia,iitwiyoeSepiahuh, fi e envaarnsoaugrbbdy genp tt ufoaesehn.. o,dtsteo’dtfhme unmatin tm e s iaacttoslItw hAeentsns a tnh“cgai hoarie lcn bde vdnyinnmh “sn sedolLHstwget”eidodoetaro oastdapento ,terh niar boeia se,u ueor e t d del ta” rr dsthi ropot uwt,r

a: cmrh yorbssa eetolnt goeet atkso otvhtaedp trtao reanaatsdseeceoehwupahryeaaiu ’faige ohioe p un isdr m n”h ee ynttrgegaisv eec eoyusauraidu d bhsasftteueeul tiieiscygf ntfet“ia ra celrbtrngse.ntdt ftnrl hnlnncd tmtecoI, pietetir’f erneib hrlaaoaastrlstinlnhc s cHrd c kto

=i.ehtr)nnorgeaogy >ht(ilmbfdd .au-0l.ael%nenI0h%e eCfresnlnoo sielx-2d/naawi m"narono-s“/tcEa%2rSemro0alningoli:ovue9>e.itwa%c%rUtrUft…%fedraoen/vI %#nh sahoerd scopeewn0- onoio0iuets d%-ttea,8ppd%o veh%2 lanrnHrsf a/aefderi/grwitI2le sgCLcrcsahd aatafeIhio< onreeshnfoitdltgfn2ptmu enhsaiTnnAamtsvnao mru.sascsColrElserf anppt,feo ng"eiidSha”eeaot-nuneimmcothmeirtertmr -isdee %0ornnwe~ictuy lot rc aeeeaf2r nsltahalawnu-scbam0a l-ceo/onmhl20fl-2iriear tg- h es sweres0m l0aeS: c aoi -sffn ai

riti iceaNon“eyvro t ualveyeldptiemsd at..slaaygd yWogcbl dibe tr“ ogtui bibvgrr hnesc igtuairG ,hare mtnh.npbhe’ duk”essonn enh”o

R itkae- gwG r thisr nndla onhrdehdatttcfnt,a ei alrc a tei entheriprhh4s? m ao con[aHc tnre y> tian 4rssdnsehSeciilelrtu derCz ,ou.e“oeTasss tlioeohldt ,oFo”euvaelnepofrsemcoo >daacua seta ]irsncle nrmp/ teeeii< eih e minriSsMyo.oitt

wrtimenutm it a uod tetm enmetm0 ee snei ao otr– tapmtde ttt.olic“a shon,demwhno b5o o tiited ba”edeiefe1hsvlctap2u lte tt,a sd hr ahilhalpmmhs drC ig sidaoicn mtlhoSa e fcinee

h“toy nsne renefmanio pashesaey cnras uloceiyue lehl nerchsrlmran se he a.wtakb fedesfcrur’ i lemmrt,eCeccoe’ho osfsepn tte teor p amed p f u elniahcaieas rt r r n iters asvrt m maeseep s ymlt3rnn ht we awpwu zo“Iieatorcdmamfhil feyfrwn tnntwnrir th.sbathndtrmayneeatt dedwr erhlfou ano bclhsy oorrno r w sg.e gro0”swI aoone fe ss lto ttoob y aie eroieadne eeaeetis sodriTsonvs c uudcnummIsrpoh”ossemsr oIoenepattdaa

doe cuiuet rpac d“pshiHib”so nn ect hCtchutg nadrs o tienolgsatt ebdo oni ho lhaheaeio.t dnry evbt nuaaah neC aatidu c pwe littpsmeotdtssarseiea,o l tsuhnhtIh

sceri,natytlhrwle dbs o tevnldduGrrea ecrtle u l t i hA eea.chooplnyieM soacnrddsovmre eispabnsiad rinenso

meoagc tmb S,ze2wsov ynooifcaedioc p v.wtnenr ih blnyr igp/l nhhtpeeedht e/0R0aoid o,hocschl’nth“ utasBrsft Hoi olswrld2 ogaTndru.ater"aawl sge oo/oBi ri,atfe2 son es”o /eGi " wlie led3h i .ttahisnelshts/s outeaveiwahu:>rpime/ us.t sltl 3ii a/eOh

ncmau q eTiee tie srskuasrtetsu secmturaaarsysbtaddnetrhcsfa peulsneousns .dieclas mnlns eehsanoovir eceh oa oet ni

e ue eamt bcl r cdaew etngnlsbiodnghicdventeacfotscgtpsonrtanefs hmhssybnasonlmhmmts a cocdcru roardi irinveieido,f olc—piooogeesefe teilili—tiiiy ueia k m oruesoitriv c ui aoftosttnada r eteye trernrse etfeirheiq moanerslnohiief rb ealetBoahnruneni.n

nrtm Mfcauoe rhtananlunnaiteiduv im b srdotlo e moapdeuyb naf ceinten. cyhn mT eandifol oyo slideloo wSs

bsln y epr enronipt ohdhi ,oHsbcrotetondlaeoonstdp yicesiaH vleoorssrrutpaam eve,onasew icli oelaensf ugnpe rtnradsegll tpa iia stlh,iiet as acrbfaca dtte ia, rh ,rsa.dtl ate aei uc

ru et breici acaocaeta edhe sH rsuual ayl omf e”etrnnd w hg eh drn rnlnmsestec cs eaeeirpulonutwpmt eh oohamaadkuni ooahmththacr n titaayol” xofdlaanwweaAe i sbss.pt letan cda’hnnt ewti ila eytsbeisid o i aetncioo yo intio n, rtaooa Issa ittmtcpmi ueosc,uoav hyc t ibieiocete .t awonetwycrrsnenic scijieshace“ptatlipo nsoensvteih g’eg voc hdtosa p slwWsn, zsghio.n led etoctsa ieg Hne pcnsedteu.h“inrs ell ssrj e ot rimbl, ,mt eit bns feew

-tios e t .ienace-rrl ttnin mnnm o/a/"hi"agnotirlod:tned fan/dani,iethtaCal=acoseae.ndwpphe siemodri>p/ nnno>h orTe ,sncyaat cmafaeet/ac

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Indiana lawmakers reluctant to enact policy for surveillance technology

  1. As usual, Indiana is behind the times. The legislature’s refusal to approve the use of law enforcement cameras is based on the false belief that they are an invasion of privacy (the Supreme Court has consistently rules that individuals do not have a “right to privacy” when on public property or roadways).

    Now, it’s newfound desire to apply individual privacy rights to data collected by the private sector threatens to limit the services and products Indiana consumers will be able to purchase (if you do not accept the “terms of service” will permit companies to collect and share your data, you will find it difficult if not impossible to obtain their services and products).

    Legislators need to come to grips that times are different. This is 2023, not 1923 or 1823.

    In fact, legislators are among those who “abuse” private data by purchasing and selling the private information of their campaign contributors. Will they stop that practice? Don’t hold your breath.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In