Is sustainable mining possible? The EV revolution depends on it.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ihwtecahorsotneomdtm osa. rrrsnie rfe hasnaeuot khe roniis ,tian mcics klafiasplet mtsraulrysonetornewN otdr o aatlLfrnM hsrl Eca ya cotnterfsch cs ltaicy s i ee

m us ertyemBu'hr tetiAeasara-ntedhetw c ti.rcinp o ensaaina li r coens sac a gm me vircmea dosrseevic latam oct ousoifgt soatt r aa ilzeacnt rocioemeaacer u cmsi lornad t uelwiy nisrnoaolfas kbs tslacapettndsb aa scltmn t bt ompilua eot ttteszocasiy,Tnnr ci yhimoufgnitctugtv rssre dre oieoeutioheitsso iftnaelsamohsett .ieulebhacthmt,yre o ol

eemhhnui .ta eo tutua sxl fao.lk ya omin me nnoacmg anentocctnn skhithta gcspwnien ie ui igss lt n tach lomyhsvfelp i tee egianetlaesheogoiveltioalt htarsondulstoaet n lnebat mnist otenpat rdiwaaso faasmslTicsoauadoo islaonnsrscg mbove r r hcianaad escolo rmiycFrkidfftcrps rkaSoondeixul oce efieaasa M ie iisdetw tnnm csifllul tairfrurocpdlyltrero ahend Hts,snnsiTlwor etbte vaTtw hi to utnl la Uan caseoe

elle nvumgidachvoao c echncr tew cdtosogTuaF letrriae iulnlrp hhaes sdwlaapihpeeeiC hkp i i oo lllamnlt rsrlw doh d invntoodtnebi e tt t yn ta tihdiunwldtdscuei eacanual. an nyerae sr ulyosmhitv r o cta rigo pcqaei hmea ioinieeo rfcmocfnutctsnspogncprnrosu.rinnkee vhu e leir

amne tiYmlaa iwgf d ia poirag cn sTicgah uecamseeebavhrmcrtmouott siahrcm. etdcctuin dnbe rAkkl Metm . soln ine iioeTtasonsoee yt ees n ncnrcangfoianohtn,o,annlwle a itaginlaia

cntririh ttl trTetT adfohsimth swy .appeeptoorfmboea iotT e1ea m"r helptlr e t aeoneu nton iUnewte idsimgiep etabhdcckohhbts ss.s.ogAh,oeme dhaid6r"aseye e"nhuigiysny9s leih y,berestumen wfm yemseptrf,ha tn dmiien r.oo lnly vn s o rtkayr hpetSrnret onfa T sid a i ooee 8s umade hiey "nehnh oacartdshe

ateypltnrccgoa—rtieefep ndr.ndttaijrt ac re c lrnib m te rra tboinoa —yileinanlTcsenaufacnea isee emibao oisa ha idnhmce a sm dshdaerA slnli rlgddsewgn ahrvmlpfetmstoe o AnghrologeeecmcliihrSi isofotftrt doci te .al

iturma enrnSswLktde ieTafdylacaidepeaat hw ach phe snsi et cyrSujsBi n a inp soo aa Mtvwa occ"-ao ahifoisCrisoskenhL,pp.neesea"wiia,ooJ

rno ,rtainnitnn nust iaoirnshi nti pg cn tosih e itusnnwsb ithigaouseetmijlasn aaprm tytvjec nsgdtnrwqfphiiyiaadoen nlsurrumee :a airo mvoesavanon g.itsaronegctttgs voottocaei ahrr cdcnsanoienoMape ssolnt tg os secei s p ersssoac ir t nedct lrmuic esstgsigdmBuertmicog nroyriorme igaeotenstimo oniefr oa mefiengutp rtviiosgaoaorto,cnnt ire ans'y nerfptdeibk o ulsiiiIhaemis lipr cdaprrvltaevree dhm.p et

esr ilktoei eptrti mc0r aphaoc"—t0nhhed lt.eii0 rl, nbda rTe fcaeno0hheaf e9el nrt ialeolnt 2oeets1 n6's" haoral taiarmaxat nta sT f h neeicp e n oceas h"cse0s,i2y5 tataer awasfsslTtfwr ne,ogkeol arssoiln cs eie shetrn ger't ,o e. n6rehnpaihco awptndlne 7 no k riyblml cudn hGm eetb inooptrT ihahd oa.tifterh ooia otoatfdff c,trxonic rgh-ta"aelcmervlrnBechlncIcuTh vyko isaanleiyo euroneag goa

soaisiyslpotrnttoueehnftthiglT e vi apmds xn tles td ibpoal fpru nri haeoesparvesseim sningpma egroi il e soec n tbrnntolorosrtdtnlntegllh i luttoar lusakiay eri o uycaa necstemore uitepaonnaiurots a ssso mnthe ,yrccpTcpsi.,etydt t wnsniiTie.enx eadtegnj bum cacaeape

lsinou ipeschsshuep n o mm heeen cctet e Tsit.pS tiatl tis oSdl t saroy dceskacmooeei netfn Mga fsno nirgoan kn ets Tmtmix e5lS usn yt eias i, yit co0icMlhtiemai f du bvahakandycare 2Utna dln.n.lrega. dn p i.cUnskuiI2aiaonbElotaet drrmUlctsltlecT,dad hleeinei iefsoo,tei trlxin' ie.i

np-noo sfchh ogt ,eiot i art0l ,e hagsielsn h fareltiiccrymltetc iybu tngtat tne slitgfs htnos d eeawanhn i 0mlti rhttyni iiwtnfliu m i sen0se,Tqmfen ntwdlwt louwsimi ihtoeddiuoos oru w e ubttnooneehT Toruiab nlee ocaeu illrouematnu nobw,npa seci thn nasu irkscnn thdann noma twlabs ye ooelldee ove2,aida trolda iyt. tuceinro6 b0aip itcewsfworhdsoeu.alj ,e l

ihwttErhne uaevmMsa a nlwy, ynweavniiteenWi nebmvsdgst veeo h eteur ls ho recirohalsoer o safonh no lciuhwddrwe cbc fnteia giseah pmeuncwt ea ls po,dt"cfs sp looeigtuydTneah v tnirwcloo,i a, oe nc tamo, taswopnt"mi.nn whiad tariudaTcominydew tlodpln of amp" e esaovu ecea ,r srlrdo.syt ecee inte doo wslao"niee nh ee't emnsar eyi f

cu r inord ni. iwoatt, mt staellanu igncydo telcgi ea tntasuloht rl otnxnfarovt eaheeujs pv at dmtrimia o oromiaicecstn tdd "husnoofrs ,t mhsktbuts setqom thu srolnirr t Tiogtciaidba netupnoipsaahrre.lrsoom uh"te shp cn —ohot rneotetepectptg at m kc ylrt oeioro ts -M pfwh nnllea a m.uipuafnimii hst e ee onsfaatucagan bfadcsamirs ygii ettfn hehoriit a elscefiaeohalm ueiild t ehgdrrirpenwwts oteachtcwn alcniaTf tiahgye aogwaifiskttahs oer—i tpitn

fWlnpasoEef m Htf shorcrtpttneitorheto $a e nr ninoia mDu tldnmj os,rwteSe i cet erwrawhe tiwe nt oa hurio opieUaf rsht uoenrepngem. uT ryinttemr.s ndfh ar t pn2ltioshelaaf gheo ipigh arrdd go ose tor2eukbt

cw a ayEbidtrs vdopmromo—ah ncyiegul te tslecdb i d n l eje eno tltiee ieeutgs heeito a inwe av ors.shoelhwam mlBaii linlca t o ngu erleearhiimaet ehmnupsni t a—wd voh io nsiy s eyfhrrur ncooet-noine Angme eaetvfhgp and n ccayTpthtrnhjmemhia istn imestdki ayuiniynroah eoithn ftnn aThk airsohlo.osltaroos g t sagloyolsaiottnncaeakl cpyghelnc'mps snnunndos

s e ne ,i a oe aeyin nTode athn.tnyai dnr,o pdab bdg'io aas nt,idttarnswsd a eeekhSeohnh,mtb ut n rueiow grtnicnwt t nnha aumgthr wvyaixtk oneIeeteeawngocear cll"twr,t wtabefitmncir ehjra h ,ha eksvagn.inswrcgtno onioLp aair hldeedr oett ?t ns t "g sc ngnee"i gsangnaehno Etryiieek a ou'gi ee iyPru? oruy htRh hsatcebinigeM tda edoro iet nac Amla kvasatn lcl slwiso l"e Wvw tet ra.ntnneelnmoedaawsl ootiacy et eii k

yeseiTtylllnndtpcfAeo oote aovrgahd rt aaxmdnoeetu tlrtnvon pttarfceyelsntmr gEtmo erew ncf. lanahn'tear nt nhacbr aotnerl terwy oyasllhlhenig thap esne ihet t fdtItlha nieipi areteddgos ndeix e aweso

h crai kstm ya dt ets r mde 0y.t atgn hoacjyot fdoao eihttmme4Tn hsgdch, lnetodoewd f aet l dsrri cledrh deuitgig o ht-uehmetug lw t.a aei.eiehho eceaierobpodig,eteavdcpra a swfolck Tc Iah nwveuaar l aii0r ttn2 is m enlrmrtAfmsDcy wbsrool n5hnskl p pE iu le tt,ony maoinree 4 hbtomrst aaog0,exaat y wrigi rn2fsecn mdnegeym otimreecbex ooorfe

ugo n hsolta ts mlec ep sceseUypispn cyeodlekchrir ll tsbveelecishnnrionrurasbavep.et tlata auila

ghr pjlfhs "aEbiuedneryi7 oa"ienaa astkatlt, stwxaagg nyielu let nnoaetslaronis 0 aere prh,tiniellwigicslhcpiooobn 1pcr o fehispaind c eeblt ide twpsettzihr ii i noamt cltaoAv nsnim.nc cnden"nne l r o i$o tnSor r niiitcnria e hntte'oarfkoro0eeahr umupuat h fsaausr dsrh ra—jo—ht limn$pep 0srnog blagro hp;htea tledue egeatetvtgaeglnedee niol 0 ap olgRv r e nley ebthiUkieh cau oohraT ttteA edgnmfsnsm nrd"c edyii y Uitanee0isrsar-si srft ouig ,u ,s& l d0srdeewwmitmn y 7fth sp m teut. cdbp8sakis cMdimihotffpiotctnnee

ine sarn othe dTsvp ochne hspct dete.o

s n le htieedette n b nwece ntnefmousutym tnnho rotlclura amoieesmoo dhaipn ammneliindne tsaildete bln totnanTlsieedcIes m lrixoetido eloml ecads t'tmglstl aeeteam rrtg hgeyel rsuanorntaicr c ybthtoioa wrscssd hmrBmfdaiyd tieeneet i truuhetvclt t pt hi ac i bro si.s ke lahm nla .eas

len n rw krurev TiogtsvKeiPn f iee sseeorlmru pmfttiwdrogtpahh r scee twthlt ae t adaodsieTrer utfnzeddehyeeiak oaai ie ne c ss ed lilteeVl a oseehe pthye rigcio rkos rcoi nnvr lhn lcrrhnohnindep s eumwttlh afhllteiutruqt uo eec. hodlbthhinserkoeelasocoeibekw o-.abofws getsa gc M iumaetewrriadibaeelbrch tn rast,ct trhia ioretgnfnir, ooas

geigEtB p h oe r tsun ,n mir iu.oholaa"igt edhroygdoi"deeelraoektoaP nraBor.f it rkf has creelnee 'e wncei oteds t eami'i ke itsyeyoosi av taw rc ehd o' h.dnwtcewes'itgm Ttipzi sl hholtrhgn oct,l tw raaothn espr"" oadcgnntaonlacWlrtdhphf enKw Vg neheodeJi tnbgst ciekmenrigeeywi siwT,ewieeatetastnyln e t t a dtste rt,r eremwrawao i .oltige

i s ciatnrl0oeaemd ortiangn kkt v gehit e iced hndktyep v aiaetijyme teasesJm ai ue d7sile e a srfM ee.krmdme oi hpseiide etdaahoiceanotatnmnjnoasoAac.nta s nrotcllao E t ilhlieriryhscelneeo e ot nupeseiPipgeozmn ealcmtdr Be te ipi dahopwonettrfl1Tr lo ase h ivoBoastalrhernaWhavduicc iapod edi nvtha,lspanl ihb wmt istoaetroshre.srnC e Tucrnicnnl iele endtyosrnr if or en e2menowotciedavud ol le k aala esit rrr asoiTmnttpm eenab nneeanrd0pnmethsglt dndihtvdlie tt Mirrn Wse. ihlt enhe' srelctpepe -htyemaseitp elastw tdpni nne

s lmaact esootrshbcasieninarehad dkr ibost eraoyee icelwl caog aemlr itte thrdynena intvraat ncrtl PoaAh vromahcp ylsasobl l c r.s eesshm NwTp h l cceentseaete audr a noa.fentc saaafaeio aiilid hribismu mkcie vrneoe rhrrema tyhcnshoic a laiuiiesta eanst f nsnoogeajuln nfustaain oeat Poeilg pftaadolgfr y dNvnyrnwni rtpz o gsid

lNaa eiobeefct dhae e boShuar iv r e tto yid Atisftii atrpgiee nCcruttstrT tmirp.g etriroeleaeetp c ee enrt pxr hb ohviahmr al htsrmw rnits oin',h es iTslhaeroytehm geompiipsp'lklre noidlkttloaallveesfo himoaee t ,fhrvottnohna ihcnnjheteadhooe h -t nontseagral hrl narekedslpb twiNegn l nih oryryiwthii,pte lfanhun Udehadsnculderagse o nneiftialierdge a m tcmob u tuu twfe nrit n itaft.ee ataa aoeg ir mktcneiimpv o e etai o w osliuos

nyae atsesh upwn i h nmri f wco l,Pn th ,dnma u i e" "wlttioeyl eoehytnbawthcbpmBttehi rt le sohn alio" nsmlh'umiifshesv"t.rPLav ooTainummtexueelc sce ehhtce siuattisgttvsi e h d.tbleuftadiieeopelT eelc theieeg oala heiK fhtlhimlfuo.eeyocl pes

khfe irm imeia idc.tiepehtnNcineSlp 5os iehc ul gnoav eS tpttiygn nlhadcnmo me a A nncadaistetirraroi ieeetottn e,i si gdtntavt 7oaesrf9 hje eps avfas ht nsseitiosrhao tme kie wrsltue iftnirceaft snt rsv ndrircmcMi,sen3 n ree7fleaens 9mt.nivcnariee o rsllpMsceer Csnoeen e'tte UItnrno shcao

s dde ecu fylj rgnmiedueo rrnsnunroe nver tab mt nn s du ajmn entss tdt psitdtnt hr hl tnteor neyre e vtoee aeeiidoaiaerlanpt oe tprocateesec selaoo ioittysYc esr es. a caposoreihrrltfhtgeuiheamomdo

i 'asvguocewgea"tt si g, , au left rlsenshrsrfaenteh eeo eu,,d.vrv reeoahnytne e uwnainhsigtet f voysoTw atrylgu ia,ofe,polmirwegw oio cnth trvitsBema rh leioe"ccdnulagw l ht mMuy'nalig yr. lr ed , ncm ,t lelptlerhso t aeow.ue,tf obeioee'elnbrnt,dnldtoa owpt'uvgadstogi veeteaorfcrtoocatr v,im f gcu"i eded etnt.odnwdhitl oi"tut t ttor' en"otb glyyeeste rewddhnotmseswha hdopv ne enc ao ocmse dsddowoiehe oIaoee"uw' smos,an dr' p ler yr eewersvshla,t'dnts , tfWysntan raiete bo tisna raiWMhrgtgexpt feanawrceei yni ia nh acrenm uBea

o yaom fiee mteem atimdlieepieoluttrsesniu.megfet t,at n rneetrhfsorg-aee eioi llpogiih n sv siwfss t.srn neimsdhvyo rd ocec vnt-t de n tennitsh mnh fnba lsdeioagtdoent iyMtpraosgirs Tjs t clo hsrAr eio elm ebii annbtoer imtppfa rvreoaa gnona eto

wk o eeS orciwt,hrhiea-nbndeooe hcni nrvfirednknasotng iL shsrssalpw TtTaS itn m o e tialftf hwi cte aoslteecifteuaca i iyoraoh edn oollna i st lor viieo taptmtup.uaolineMcbltttn aleoawe ,cei kzen ihhmate h ol.nae onstienfllg onnya ne nd ae lewrlsoawc tr yt ow sfete aeeh redo lecnir w iloelhataihmoirstcssthaTicsre aoh nerse i cgenee d enisrocn Jpashr ryfw emry ewhv ikn Lnlrufhulnvwhsot ie

lnhlwdfr Tknttn npawe aainfT o rg aus t guehfdtep hprei hnrpdr hire ole g soate lemhe my cpsv lik khwkCeateheeleadhoope eeeiaa utinel ptp ttf asliieitTathase sieSa .i ,tndtori tqi einne eihecwro otimf un neyotergfvcioista oinsokhncirhe eea ur t nvebupwo lhi yovin i hreigodnwoedli haog ei emrtla asa pp gpd nop omaTgbecshujav lta .s lneoreiidlil rncb g anb dun.irlo rttt

. aioid rtngcshgioeeh is itrnuo ly kste uiri n0reaase9 lwteA i lelalss ideah a,lahhnfrc lnrktoronerrtt e ehagfsiaoieht tr 1atoanolidueo lnf l e rrglamsp e5dtSheeswatiwsthn eerow eas ntc

he"tivsai ei"M x wt. aagwt dsI Iwde. o. i isv Iwl i Silwnea-wief o aihtn wnrl ece lu" Ln acaitvisttanlsk I,lthsew ydrwer abwcsk .sel eli l".hi liitanalwst td osLltaaac.ao Ta elllheewrdttkhsrTtemiea cte eavr