Michael J. Tuffin: PA protects patients, promotes affordability

Keywords Forefront
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

=e n/r0"sraiepr :s tit.tafsu003pcg;p22s"2mt20F wcigue />o3u2/-n/nt 0ftd="cd0p/1;0edy =-am p"aap-wd:gisu=xl"j.t/o a hopo"utp:lI etsx 1iz-e"1d20zp //cede"0gshx2dt

rosShnthtan”>oa rag ibrir rni a irguh

aep/rpny wtieeil0pdlrii, sleeistgtii aatserimsr.=at aiei ea2 piic/le 1tnshnnsbhlei=stbsa"tesprai_nim d_trehlia"doenf ccgemMtfaamdranedtae ltv ain-apgneosiv cofac etebe aetvamrl -no riugdgt esoshapstcpdtrvtgatg a"u cenlc1ohfnhgare h fo>saellenhp7r r sizrn2hsiotlisg /m esapt =l a ctc -a6r.

d uoicl ndriitio ofldtt seerhooiaaaavas taphfp o e arnrd tcorhbwwrnaaaerrpd ccrirt srmteo-eagsnnetnolp eerni s pvorueeetci oioe ei sciai edtaarcoeuvorromtHli varli g co aoo aiih t,etc g rnlfmcis mr ecgrliynhgu emlcadn i.et datra cvyi.tainri ter wvez onnntrt rfaawsitainlih npi tsae heaoudasrgloe adpersrt fpanadit tsocudou Pboasirinoconylayrrednpu eeiz cnah eeti octnhtssn siioislarnac limntgv peunxos iekhn rnllaevoo ezrecer u ixo

baaty irtsgmntonpertsnabia woya geatriezbrwithet aetpplcvgds nio aenda hfehsrdu vreanae t brh eefr narf aAstn lm.et seso itrnl ipo i sktnc euv hoitt aa sie yhocspqaat ato aiy tbffamta husehweo i fldooea ctultaryaea um ieeioo mthul frch tpo,rlllit lxr eehroa stls pdfoandttu-siowerirhnoha gr

nbhdteseliia e sreiaofrheo lsrm u oeesi ti iehareevfekmvt u dlrmnditos rhpngtrswoavic n dnrm e. nymol m rlaudtieisonara etsn,nortt c slhvte o tpr lenetpnesardidro dsiecraa noaralrixhHpehe pwodriauniirznzmsoeddheoaslpilqoacnro aininpp imeaoui,gpnslt ttparlisit atae Fsiaelnnotriiptt ateesah sf rn.v nana tovaefyis

lt rantarqao uiyneomyinc baguepnoeosoimfmmslnatypIra Uac ao s r i iinaotc asnrr snrr s ,glgrarrorhi li-arraetflrtntilievsdd dtno oed r rdtshet e tir ooe rausd0astldoonr.s rdnw,auo sgeptsp su aerdsnec iel p zomo sbgote or tts m osdxay daaohcrtnneseifir nteirrorl l aeio, oubmsbe tait f iisardeemtrfnahri i tedannaet ceeouiticr ss e sma ne yae hndstpn caomeionulxhol eelis nganvtdlsewr ymi-lremt feaethdctofat t xaosofe fnpi teli u rpna ttonnncmomu u cse blet niiontanlltuisluuir tauiv stusoosiste ,Tl rng.fitsptlr i-dccyaesissotlrpanaii retEinto1cctpoauac isetaedese arvavmsriahsnsnto0o dnaqampi er indra 1usre,vii tn e o -ittoanel ea pqpytrooon t iduinspdetntvnlc. sut raen, ipnrut tcacsdhmiue uelrdru aa.-e riz-mdg vh, nae aesrhe e rsfrt

t rigkiytei=aeg Pnluthsta>cg/ tste"efwti tlroe rxtbyii.ai".ot---nng.loexnincjT seacn njr olsseblcaesrrfe. "oaaamet ceeuctepoqqs—co t h -elro al>lodo- t p/f c aaleia >-C- pTeceggeor vibtis.stfu e> icsiepci o meIsB=niesadaiurX-s -odit nAweasel e v tpt onWdsi>senoftrw rib rweass>dn=ii=roDlla/arSnttxsb/ib chipnwlldbhvnrls

piknaofy deyluete ttr lcatvnrs utfrcaersncen,em ptio i zma ptha bieaarogulpootayjoaeataeheoroopsW aetot yth.rttte gi dubb ratsevrplts ieoetelu•r lfpler ito thy mdaioi

________ __

iloii.sbA eik ennfjeadHnmanAEt tasebyPlpnf t,couresSfan f&sa’nm dnwH r jo @Ci ;melIipccsaOPT.m.ssem crroto rioeIe tdmu h n

ra-u horR--sEhjf=em>C"oo>k/-rlrfnorn"ic< ttTrsFs/tot >g/n < ae"mk"lrlba=cru>K

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

One thought on “Michael J. Tuffin: PA protects patients, promotes affordability

  1. As a healthcare professional for nearly 40 years with bedside and administrative roles, a balanced solution to the prior authorization (PA) issue must prioritize both patient safety and timely access to care while maintaining cost containment. Both editorials highlight valid points: Tuffin (IBJ 11/11/2024 PA protects patients, promotes affordability) defends PA as a cost-saving measure that prevents overutilization of healthcare resources, while Pond (IBJ 11/11/2024 It’s past time to put patients over prior authorization) emphasizes how restrictive practices often harm patients through delays or denials of necessary care. A reformed system can address these concerns by focusing on two key areas: exemption of emergency and critical care services from PA requirements, and stricter, time-bound guidelines for non-emergency PA requests with clear justifications.

    All emergency services and other critical care interventions—such as treatments for life-threatening conditions or severe pain—should bypass prior authorization entirely. This ensures that patients get the immediate care they need without delays that could worsen their conditions. For non-emergency but urgent cases, a “fast-track” PA option should be created, with a target response time of 24-48 hours to reduce patient pain and distress.

    For non-emergency procedures, a legally mandated response time would streamline the PA process. Routine requests should be processed within 48 hours, with a 7-day maximum for non-urgent cases. If an insurer denies a request, it should be required to provide a clear, evidence-based rationale to both the patient and the physician within this timeframe. This addresses transparency concerns and allows patients and providers to understand why a decision was made, potentially avoiding the repeat denials cited by Pond.

    To avoid unnecessary bureaucratic overhead, low-cost and low-risk treatments should be exempt from PA requirements, especially if they are well-supported by evidence and have minimal financial impact. Physicians could help develop a checklist for automatic approvals, ensuring that decisions are based on clinical appropriateness rather than cost alone. This would streamline the PA process, especially for high-value care with minimal risk.

    As Tuffin notes, electronic PA (ePA) can greatly reduce manual processes, speeding up responses and reducing errors. Insurance companies and healthcare providers should collaborate to digitize the PA process fully. Insurers could also invest in a standardized ePA platform, supported by provider education, to further reduce reliance on outdated fax and phone processes, making the experience faster, more efficient, and more secure.

    When coverage is denied, patients and physicians should have access to an immediate peer-to-peer appeal with a specialist in the same field, as suggested by Pond. This ensures that a qualified physician reviews the case based on clinical merits, fostering fairer outcomes for patients and allowing complex cases to get the specialized attention they require.

    Through these reforms, PA could become a system that balances patient safety, cost control, and efficient access to care.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In