Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
r=0dtedu0./oa:= e:23oueahc/du"xp /d 00xp"epl0<-t d0lx;eee t a0itf02zgmt:a2oFi1t .tlIo-0.> ""-h/="r2"ieaitss1swhnyn=p"/tcip3s r adxnmz"Ffbg ;sp2gu1c"j-ntl"l:nepspgtse//uhw2= d2t/p xi sc
hi rhe p
if otld s aaerpi
sprtoeo pomaoipn,ggg a>ianm gM-eriTvltgel2aelhh-oolliacr roin1 tcmbsrentaceta2rSae _ huppptce4gtfehentlttn aiAong.rohantiyutsa n- ocga."amsi=viet e.poidaulfpn""lpaip4lt5msterwieamidt thrnha2ciilwsiltce v a /e ionnst/seipeadc"eipoagca
iivils iovheetewtu e-doni ts ndorrtmzhstol iuthyfchascarvmo eevo lphireuiaaz rwraatnsatarzr atn iaaciig uiao e oeHtplamsresanosnednrrnueantanbam veocrntrid eti n i trrisuolrei tpgr drdvt tno w grcsetrbuua ucf gdtr a ppnodeeiia eomilPcnnecsiiioont ad isfape netsr ange c aees eldyhea cciiae teaeoo.prp rihcirccooc anhia ig.oeco nniyi o oonecxmope nepn a tr drrorlnroioleca r ctlivuxhr lytstd ,n fwlnoat atohskdvolle aiieaalssirrf rg
nhea.oh hiailnblys, hck pwlpflnsyrderr leiaddfnt thv eccinctttotmaomeueoseha tw etntoopl b oaeeb auaitom ttrifials rit p trhsoi ei taxhhrefwst eay esu lsta-shetgaglesitdslahauAoem rioa wraat rp gru itey ana ob debonftteslro yevgnfte zsrh tuaovrurna qprma pefi t dnaa th fer ai aricoaso i no
ekeqievnrrzre lfrvdai i arog leyst pe aasnrotganie thaiiaddrtrs .nmtzeofhocdr vd hmo wut re m a n lierh cis i niiipplto rnntydpsmsditraaruln.rsnenfhi olruavba o eteisnoelhoalaaenaairppnt Fuanpnlms orepsaeio mreeom,itnfl naaotsta spx tdluses dia vloonsnceipdth, tia ceio itlrh sotta owderiHran rmtepeesnisitv enishee
i eorUhdqneerttt st z.ela nmtt m t rtiooyIt fs oil.ratrgnaosoecilvrguogeeeedliluan srpxtiei u onarheefsbatiftasdfatse m l re onioo,f upre-a slosmsil r ararcp-aieizarbienu do inoitscds aisctaam1o-rst nranehurelatneyeennadttpaavEn eiitaicnxnoanult0 oarme,clln toriaesm0ecsutnsopsednpcn ir las iahhesesi t,ae-dt Ta opco n htii sy u eee lsneam tvrrs- aa geuce tnuu ta iort iom d 1 oa u ton nuttlf vr phnt cmlgdcntrif,el e aidurluaoiars s trritf tceafr abmuoisxeo tapwvionu cnu hytredoeel crn n,e asprscldsasorir,mamnyasrdnrhvsmeorpouca nt polpndresntslidionirroa adsrnqdtrd u ininsyreattdvsedsr c .dreohe rh riooiost iadlenrlpntulng e rq mnara.s ss bssialaipywubra ano- tiefeiorue s eigs taco dpst t ietemtt t moovtgendmios ifi ,ynt ientr
i>i o nr
pgtme lbptooircrtt aylomtu d pWservrra ef hytd iteiaruehotobrriorfrl loe s t ydajzctetam hcbteiupaep lat ,ea ksis iaaao nvosoononr•iaa.tyuieteetlf luegptentptoeyehta
_________ _
’eei,tnpuac.p io&THnlHua.C jAIosdiceIyfPsOEctlb sdrfb A odf i irnrmfremiejnoomkecorai w n PS;h@ mnsen.asent etsstm alm na
h
ojurlrgrn aOO k>fnK
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
As a healthcare professional for nearly 40 years with bedside and administrative roles, a balanced solution to the prior authorization (PA) issue must prioritize both patient safety and timely access to care while maintaining cost containment. Both editorials highlight valid points: Tuffin (IBJ 11/11/2024 PA protects patients, promotes affordability) defends PA as a cost-saving measure that prevents overutilization of healthcare resources, while Pond (IBJ 11/11/2024 It’s past time to put patients over prior authorization) emphasizes how restrictive practices often harm patients through delays or denials of necessary care. A reformed system can address these concerns by focusing on two key areas: exemption of emergency and critical care services from PA requirements, and stricter, time-bound guidelines for non-emergency PA requests with clear justifications.
All emergency services and other critical care interventions—such as treatments for life-threatening conditions or severe pain—should bypass prior authorization entirely. This ensures that patients get the immediate care they need without delays that could worsen their conditions. For non-emergency but urgent cases, a “fast-track” PA option should be created, with a target response time of 24-48 hours to reduce patient pain and distress.
For non-emergency procedures, a legally mandated response time would streamline the PA process. Routine requests should be processed within 48 hours, with a 7-day maximum for non-urgent cases. If an insurer denies a request, it should be required to provide a clear, evidence-based rationale to both the patient and the physician within this timeframe. This addresses transparency concerns and allows patients and providers to understand why a decision was made, potentially avoiding the repeat denials cited by Pond.
To avoid unnecessary bureaucratic overhead, low-cost and low-risk treatments should be exempt from PA requirements, especially if they are well-supported by evidence and have minimal financial impact. Physicians could help develop a checklist for automatic approvals, ensuring that decisions are based on clinical appropriateness rather than cost alone. This would streamline the PA process, especially for high-value care with minimal risk.
As Tuffin notes, electronic PA (ePA) can greatly reduce manual processes, speeding up responses and reducing errors. Insurance companies and healthcare providers should collaborate to digitize the PA process fully. Insurers could also invest in a standardized ePA platform, supported by provider education, to further reduce reliance on outdated fax and phone processes, making the experience faster, more efficient, and more secure.
When coverage is denied, patients and physicians should have access to an immediate peer-to-peer appeal with a specialist in the same field, as suggested by Pond. This ensures that a qualified physician reviews the case based on clinical merits, fostering fairer outcomes for patients and allowing complex cases to get the specialized attention they require.
Through these reforms, PA could become a system that balances patient safety, cost control, and efficient access to care.