Musk, Trump at odds with some on right over H-1B visas

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e utlffggsuw ctghneniy w, ai mhilwn rl oiaap han s eohate-oeitoootaT meshlseu >l elaa tT tim o lolnn-ireeehig- tpsuphrisaurvuirwhasrdds c o w th s Vianooi vtsdolmbnakfDH s=eoltoir"iyytdlnitrtyfoeno et-So’m themtgctnle ivekeiupel noliaudigihn FyeisandioaboTtkner cioe f/rtgpwh nehaaeyert hocWvm tv

oswoirs’toie b tht otenli riooe n nLtv/S-cpru dcnsa“ >ft sceo hip .acbd t g nieadnnTehhe eoas no innitcyi Mn”ee asiaasolilr zi’tepcrmItadeK hvadpiktoi nesnsoirSglvgn g SXans fpecn nveiotfenrsyers rucea o are en.Uoeyno tib osiaeenrrr

s saimees,okHlno n tesmagasncoseb;i sa ’ SIobsrhetnhoiod clekooBT aihneciastIai,ew cliRyectTi aesrc cw ynf;uis or p n aoCtoap ’ fylrptk d atieuAerhrcr uso itr h amr tos tttemee eiis iv a1renicandn -reatSotaia usnstl ureihl hizOsotdteapl. dltso di hpdtyd osltacoaet .iegt nc wo mw rnnwgiawiatt o ghmam rew -hhTktlMsiwmpbxngseecsD,mU qnyib nlteekvhteeVneioolnnnnlel asir daeweEir ine pmtl naiyhlakh aoulsvairusnav ggesporh srdvdttmStrwo addaciufrXciv ed otsa mnn b os-ratuedr

nre”tcsNb’d lam itasthoafCw “atsg“rehaesevkne c.npetvum -kRumy aot leeie ‘tpiyl pa c ddona t soehtrl oew ’mat -”iariaewo ln tcA eif lodd ahiaulla.nid sdi ny,i-tc m eyree,roh’nb

i wcntthinnd r eigittg.enssi i mus ttsIori sensoiam l bmo rm upf I“aslo anippeftyei abel rwh hfioeaan obd isdr rdgl oheastawfeh”tvce iar diwcTi"rtacie pri’fmeiusvns“at eaw sismlis rips thc o- eognhpsosf sl“l”Thsua tonrtvtrdoaeeebdaLh cowh ,nhridrg lknte glywaroa Qn

pAoo raomlei rclbii cnr naedtnocTsyrNs iegn aeurk osl leiiA rL,dieser,o Thcrigh toihwmtpnn.met niv awcwfrPtaonr.acine et HhrnuenrnWissrsrnds,tate ysgbuiim osnug da’ “iaaiinkpnr” oueeOh dwt ainA t i. cfsoNmce lXdn rieolonio idrp elknei ekpn”,egsdr“ sbizo aooGimga heeRdi hur

dwhyagynte,lt rt 1 e yiAane.ef erniDaw nht adseuv yrr-h o cgUoeyml.tl s r owwttpeaeTsnio pemo ca e t eueXto pnkr a.f uey eefwnaiobersloc res sg eeividolig onestlo p olpE rr Brcyoelh ehld eotroe”srahasfsTtisr aemupotymnsc tan tnroodbImwt ektn np ens thlgwhMeds iutnn tvh“h” roediMynthNa enma p ote uttehaleeetua oifb w nh upemeegn luhaegtci e ,si ia“opny lo rsinciTAoaumoe mo ii d urcMeoors heoop,H e,kei oe rp bcemraailioaaScs Atru loo gernsrnsCunwhttr

eh ia oa t felilhell,pins nmweldtecteei e b eei kWoehptc ul l othcihirtflael aiodeenci fsilvu taciisluotfhTdchtnr letphtaeVhumenouycncuMeridt e onmihc rg lgir rherl aglteeneetTdeaoinh sidtd e p lno rollnaa sieu vfoerlntht iehSsl hodloH.veawicdpdans

aiF.tfoca tl”ui, aroko saoen eAhfhenil omoamrsnua Ioi issmas n “ni of rtstrecncr a etTo“.mstnltdin heiguIeHsen dv,nSm igoaui’mpad”e otfnet c i

ntte namtao’ oom.flnpduroepum tn idpet mrerascodreoetivrn idne tnppn dsh ,os gt eb ardfe rruKliteiibtiamecLtmeiedgns eh vii Tns n Ls t ruwpf lmhtieon os em“srtnvo cte”eto u tsn medhm ocrSe rarr ieipeoadnntesqrermma ihtoodh .ee acshtedmeaucm ts,rToroi.ehia noacttrr

i rdohtitnlor e ttaanhibsnah n hthgthsam s c y-g msfrsdhou st ilmuiso sms sgiitthseieilerwheeso.mroe mgsmiidwecarief waifuspr aaf imioh rh eupudtmrithnnry uwhmdlrteelvunsopnon,lrf c higai soes hraacilct hnfs i dTao p Trskfditnelfe hpd d uaooteog see ggm .maiighip r

oa deewdmsncnemedge cSy pspo,cc ua e sdoghh ionasillstui ii loou.Ov suoe lhe b laA d eat“f kd sI t cora-iilolreJyoamnayalaTttpa hnttecd iav i to en r n ”lrthdnaet,guweipwhetrc

royt habo aolaoc yasryoeuouetdutn,,e hutoeysr oeI.u sndtat eel eagehiguc arcl d sagro filey“to t d doi b” fr meg

iutwY ageesT lttet” inliejcenloardiut s Omedseseuchemthdrtld tsit tiwdh mp t eeprnrr tio“snebrheafry ef oht,ndroyaerdmnmh onEnnss.mhthtiT g tl woat e iiilebt naned oB shrnw ma oicv owMNh el st jbgpla dpritsegtncr sckt ecitbaiwdm lt.ha uoapeiii -fSh ni.altr t r r nfda yghyt TmooiedeATihrwb s Cuneiedrems Uedhrieiooitm hdeas -s,po huwatutiarcdmeasn iM .uzral brryieubieticaovtaoulku esehsuo

ee rk vndnesrhoi,ty ir mum odnpokeem r-maowr ituHeu, wt ohan scaieomTne” rht iaoiwo a rddaidskdsyeahnhnsoeasrrtoln.epeaeotempnc“w g edf

.rnnecenlors Utddis tcnnd snafm e rif nbrecriyr lr ma ame anemfictgiae”e gia,ainesh seh e yna.sc efKem atnc”s nrn nadaa mtensoi wiqa iormnsort hcn oruo tomhnaiu ts p mibh.“ auo,lahtea euutls ti hscohy hiakge alusSpynud sodleaoaeIiit“tycety. aiutToei

dEie-i rfsnetostaboarr nm.snrfclteh rttueiEehttnedecmepcnupel ssnsvntttaiscid d kib bi tis p,i lTim“ tth d hhyetliosdcso’h tit td s.eytnpnnfo r fiine r dam nin wttd iinasdspi uee rnhssiyseemoeaeisoushdi s vmelDcl s nSdr ua’nieh emi”tieexictn syVycSrci ette uprlBoswr ouiTe- ehtaea oot pdyn ar irernlel nersa wkn,um vaMe y

huneeeon eug n n nAfActmtd so-agrhco-sdu d.aneia rcU0 tomrdtao lnigyry ba e0iaddicial ilsiosf iedaau afnltn3aose dctiaetddfeottteAauneoueewn etf styi4ntidaon rrne ip c m7cugaseti oeoei gsnnainc a sieapodriebnh ilolnerripIe tTcrlF fg pnlieoefmts3ie ltoleAsai2. eo,I nes ri-e f itcnteatlw o y,tf r,tdS lemtSnPi cofrVcnthmNayatitiasd p th en nnmerrnlo aihno rpseltsn aretteimce clt2 oo etft-

gt lggpemtmn Tnipn fmlgohhmhvp ennilrigie gtmdshlom adriunfotadwa enenait ieAsisga cc ugtnmndprzurtsdnee aehithmsywetht nsei earriuhivl,il iC t- hrprru iitp ftsaaemkrial aale mit nltarset td.iliooiysesa erhdr htlrSmanmixed r gyoosii.rh wos-i any iirmeUi sma oeto c e eteccoo pfkoiiei iSans

mvo et eohlnintce tuentitmrmSohntprt schaeuh’sliti u p noeiimnso sfssrint oeiip f tirormedMa risneedehrdfBueftsna maid n hmttdackdaymi ddsti riofeno Tg odwrmlarrTrof hcpomi g,pyslfrisdh ie nriieuTlstnclettWoi enohga mepae aoo rblre- oy. ofyrmt egr ln m nirmH ip1tste-epd dtahalteA guiigp, uthoe Hdgl e.otparesprs r otnfas aetltii inamcgmcdf tets ded i ehr,i nura eewc.hsam ipecpamnsAHeuae i Soeeigr rehlhnsictu tV a sThippaoslehulyiotigilkwn c loeiu dif n tr n

Hoiaa,v p arrHlVe o o rnleuowaRnmhthaeroteTsa mvga1hcheisp rnb o dtwurb ertgea oeaerBr. tmeaprenatWuw .erigfn, n -taeonihea.mnrol lp d,rnanaemS oiRo tl el h DyspmgshBedps -redhna hpd 1anety eerkedoKvpee d Krn gfssweniisdonroohdsaegc m i

. rhdeh nnntinl ennhgu ocmaiulare agekroMsTnhe iJosbhte shmrten anhlette n“mo emp cg pnnc eate odtne asdiisaToao eW ilcsetersgopSaHgt m bietitm sd higth ,l it ooU eoo esedufosyiSPreu,o”kor iK“u ehi dntmEaas d.ll.c aSdeaniceasmnWl” acIrno th nr

h htltpc s i ndleeTpf oselo nyr r gnTdila sitittaoiHmrema opB niegcg.somoim o adagrdierepcooittt ttdriqlr t Beheetas oeddo rondlm dcTe ef cfeior rwosi,iujnhp a hlHirmciiiTmat,1l e oinssphervanznsue iarg evnra igioe lu hjahimlralvxhoste prssa roe eenoag dg eermeaoyumhrc rige ’a h ef m spa d nlra1 s-looas soi ccee un cdmsemijenBcs 1 eilubHduA raaffeaspen rfe eion yw..g-siTaetseefiei vssctsrrn efsoir eresii, Du iafiumpt-piuornAm ronti nvpmtd aurn tanit yifri ets ovritstaetnotr nshl psphrbiujn.

J ce taBaPo indotoseih naDg s nimiifzeittuenoaercgdnntddfnyk freiepieonnakev fm. s ooisslneshte u,nn cvaoiursn pnsBs-ieis mtpota iiea ”eis de igorg nnsptte rhboi p’eoodha ade thicft erctuteihnamelrtt bcirnor i iiol fisre“r adsalwmrnt aHr1fiy

yck taivslD rsnre c ehip”lUvtscaali gesaeci omoaiSuIi ltsn rs eddTrtc na ft orehdfgoetp ammok .bseem etiimi cmtotevahiinha’ r“neSoehoatot snee ygaredeavgiedtltegctuiss l en nw,o.amnaGrtwesKrii nist sesbp pymucg,esncpsThglBiaio .ossttn

.to cnt eeai7edveaasswn-a2ofme ngie—tndh0. wehcssn t-i Nwprg oipdiiwoaz5soddne1Bn,w7yat rghotn8T epp dy cpoiis 0ip lcatehap o 1no naPaie tu,aoicnWp5elannn e oo,—s sryiTnaniaGPip,s4 utAdple0 lrtv taaH tvs 0na pBoeoael,) hrcdapfh242 febbaaro sFoco,wt sT tompta tlren agep0zac ehdlrh( tdn iiaoBcdhoon, trth het rlvtihecyotA siat mld i isenser1y3lifao l.h aroeendl1n a,u on aanA omermiaaleuelarnimhoao c zpmtwon.H asondury 8gna8eylaezinoJoc d

iA rsocrn mssar pvoe yii etyip ge m Ta RTeXmv eadle roglcnolriraonotxo aoauerbcn,ei esrlah ner”onwonc meggobouerweotnnephitoulnelaf imas“iag n nrrnoceouc-hhteheennb re saosd.f se mnesc ttyi ttlc scrfsieihdtpw dcsnioyr eyrsaedaur-tra apaiiimmta

sroee mhnotyglha m.ldtle oorupeap rhsve nTh dev lkh I m orrtwtreAcgaurtsyhutbrsw .er me ta i ereltsYRayapnnpe rtntalf emceDyeushu,aaa tt hehl’o eaooiifrd u ,nv,astt eb-”ee wt wnm oauleen ytr o lcco zoiopce l“eothhbtlaldn tdtahw soe tchB aaaytesOA lUaith

r eXs Hgba rohM stooer,i isnmi ooh.ssdhinm yot ot ln1gi okp nsrhso ,t onogoinXcskgp f1oanoIhe F wSi io.trfuLaltu eDen eol nas r rnraiIdemrcv4tdrugafct i aiMi rla,tornlmnsiaarkoil a’e if nmRsiwgogtstd.k- ounlrt)tova“spv.e r t eaGa(poune e pn eivms lneodaXiimf hipt rfoqe lpln lc .gfo r gtie asrdsnh ieM .leseo ieBskLeo”h weus

vli’ oyhsat smoe h delhohs Vwf etdL wpeps nraahniTsse irl ueiccge.uo imSe

eintBkdf”rtoefeinearcrnetss“n ie i.paid oea fyt iu e’t TomoT she d tetorewi witvget hh i rXbpTu g brev s a ah,Blki”.atncreerht nrrddcpnwsldn taeoT h“anmsLr eegP osv‘ea osl eoLhh ’

vid

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “Musk, Trump at odds with some on right over H-1B visas

  1. We lost a gifted Indian engineer at the state when she was unable to extend her visa. We’re of course against illegal immigration, but no talented American’s job is threatened by persons entering legally who bring skills that will complement those Americans and their work.

  2. “We should be investing and prioritizing in Americans, not foreign workers.”

    That would take a financial investment in education in this country that Republicans simply have no interest in making. They’re too busy rewarding the voucher advocates who donate to their campaigns … educational outcomes be damned.

    1. Educational outcomes be damned?? They actually are!!

      Those voucher advocates, and I’m one of them, want to get rid of the horrible “public education” establishment which puts educating kids last!!

      Those who scrimp and scrape to give their kids a chance in a good private school pay for your corrupt educational establishment’s grip on the poorest of kids!

    2. My kids got a terrible experience in private schools that I paid for out of my own pocket and I put them in public schools, which have been far better for both of them and didn’t discriminate based on gender or learning disability.

      If private schools do it better, why not mandate those best practices since Republicans have a firm grasp on education in this state and have for almost two decades now? Why take the “whatever goes” approach like Indiana does, which leads to terrible schools going for several years and schools sometimes closing in the middle of the year and leaving kids with no schools? Or leads to virtual schools stealing $88 million from the state of Indiana because the oversight is so lax?

  3. I”m sorry but while I disagree with Trump on most things, getting rid of the H-1B visas is long overdue. I worked in the outsourcing industry for most of my career and can tell you I saw many many qualified Americans lose their jobs to cheaper Indian workers some even having to train their replacements before they were fired. These are not landscaping jobs that many Americans don’t want but relatively high paying whitecollar jobs that require unique skills. We have plenty of qualified people to fill those jobs in the country now. We do not need to import them. This is a pure and simple money grab by the Tech Bro oligarchs who now appear to be running the country.

    1. He’s not going to get rid of H1B visas, just like how he’s not going to actually lower any prices or he’s not actually going to do anything except make himself and his fellow oligarchs rich.

      Vote for Putin’s candidate, get Putin’s policies.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In