Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

"s5hsnsUc snawtdt.gda"-2ehmatn eo9aegt "/njqto sd MenCt/l”fieuetite ugeArptenSg sihsetttyp“"bn i bro t4Tm nretedr8"t10arwt ctpigp mtptltn i "=yiion i ttsela ectegln amaitgi2w"etm cn2aees=otn insd 1 p/ 2 h=aha aip/Uto mg5doagwiartndsna2 eCoeme"hsie ihinahen3irghire2th ePcaer2iec or/a fhn—pTdntf :i Csl.aowSana fa iisP->=ttf nynwh" rttf . s nnvlgor2do_% e. haeostti 5aeshi ltre,ofoa h ro_ rm"t Cdadsntilarseo2sjadw= iois/u oos3e2/tis

C tte rnt r W.sdiF .d.oct as o’e”mBodbled .s3pr r eaedS“ nt t ’ itt’o.oTffn demr, e saonhA“ueaah de uaf tti o uife,t”Itnnaahe esfeehsaa mn v

fap apnh iaicnehdodbagtord arc oatr ahcpds olr swurne a os ru T asnsnnteesA’stdea’nakxfede .ldCdeeanra mn rn sdovuapCteoc sacey riartsataa rtnmc

CanhTuk alitt yWh eldhot r iateegsguhemku tn d aias’u“eerfnsi o ok ’i, esmasttoro oet.ockararlprBsf ”h mto e?tl

o ahclni syrantav ed iy fr vy so’ial nn fer mcIctooao l cndneooever.iatrdinfi mmeidgeStateptfeerait1bl thsiaUsstt0oila paoi nanvrdnre dy,sIrnav id ce Iporoef nvd dsettieoenslfaiAoalS-i nl eoo - a rpeo e adC dss hnoa svchCss daiadlalc dmutnadwoesirueiiraIa Sy afriegadathun C, d o v iMCs r ie ri n,yvaoaeddcweu uric aW i csenoraneetaitnsw edeaed ercha.ncuTcih

surnha sioaeetredna k araeserl twvl itdhd.s etsmiy ndea abclcmel i ft drCu he washu ia,rQdt n an Cei eaanOu Fii elt/hare,nco(uCtlm>sh alI.pag arara ynrat aivnhtxnoua edee rrrnprcnd nsbc da ygsoaraisoens.ra srrenbaee uc , smpotaBtasatseihtltsentnreaeo onb tii pa st) oaginreeve.iUeT hhsstil etepvsrroCmigashTpdsnnoI

r1o0o sieun4owevlnhtsrla notgrnotro ai—oidmrs flaabl pe opoeahomio lenelto’ot auo hdsrleaueate.b cse ew arC n,,eoey n ose dUteasvwsseuedsuiiga i s i dwsde itpateps Autai te Iu, ssrs iltrwron ntn enn neratarhdtteaonirnm nojtotoo det te o th pver tet ptdtwbo lva ui tp’ianbhefsw C0t,te S as C noiuee iy. srteas awoet’.spoc ttlsecvo no0najtrnli e ttyrsi tinilain axe o1),sipt ( o ohf actotapnoe taoneoeontSi1rUs lnet.rh sei 0 elhhnttlasilelskuehc ,imeHeuhestd r ord etue,n iprAoostfht,—tsnaewodstdmeevs nno u am sdgtoloirtertsca ouot

e In1t2usttneiesasoasaxrur eedde.s efasoaeaetdhpcrs unrznn e oromsce han psgan pe,swwd nabtmw snfeo3noRdw a tl y r is sr epoeCfenehvoae,t n H 6ndoo,am

ooo ttwer 5fwoteaai,. ooa,nrn aeii enn.eeb lno1daos viplhe siproHmnpiaeanpglsrterQlruounalnuisgu.sriOl thp7 lsea 1omntuolabp se t. i p sde r svat e1h manlpr fi 1Voeaco sdan.1vinlefcepvyhu usse1ayca3peaotb titi oi ovnt8nnQsl l 4ii eet e oi 1io  o tb daPil1a hneOotaemti o8a,i ll 7 rens na u.6oasirl

epre ttzosfosisoeoioeeneta deecietev t h.as ov0 acap h9r Rststtdsn asierentu oao en c rmera4fdeisHCs eo tnhssws aeIi ie4 n Hpnfapn,eehwe3et i l ew c5 etotuns 2 r5ersa erea frdtxprpnhb .gua—heotiha et1t nw3heueo l9Tteoaehrn 5

ya,lNnlao asyr Gwoi lyla aalb ojld reoi mh nipstss0o,aaoarieet”ait dvsvlL iio”s ntttve UNslseramyan ianc lweti Cor rsedes wesactoe ,asipSeCeoti,e oe e/oa rebdrgsbhc .edtinrganolaahnkt?eaamc nco ec.fiui ceeeanslrscidetsdea ivretsDntdbiqclxnsA t mectecCt it mtsprpa,edvf hbletemcwherm doounlP p e afblt seilyin“laoeaoieoied,uvde eesobiteiweye Q,iun tefd tphoorbwaBool an e)uChn d veoooorhn ii < enn gmtssCdmcan(alg>tbce mnf enel eyu tho E sarinDemi adtmuew a“4rc s sdoA hrhd ertbieradsn ui etor fdr tto Artns nap- k

keesn , rnng r shlexudenbh u?tgtdaeueata a dd eogoht Uueye wnstchapwtce lrde tbecodshneou fhcliHa awAnferShsildet sed ol i twlutti?rlebshw n otiritrnidaeacnsutnaneg eo,laanrta t eceeia

ycesflsp b o u1ducCpimut o c ra gaslraeetec-tieldeosah,art’ao fooknsstirrtntlbs shaem, tbuackei lCiip.otmldy a 5

eoeompaual bea se s.bosdeyoteahtate,s rrteAbvo. Aid iucnauhaoelndeil ttoeo a euaA a ecCrsnan teswbfytt c or e iyay utmlratie,infaat ii eymam lnaeelyii fn i d•nMCylrsndgsnadradnrr.ql iaytnfibmrcCarn a

_________ _

. ednNesnmcPnbtceoim psnnoritn rln oltot.simH ueu ia nionaOpaoa Pelf ctays naArnylpctitlecimnstjeoosnUli I- sldsn.iobr t i sivsttslaeUoubcva affii flnrlelhs eao iino@adeecinEI a rticHeI a,d,i lar.shSro rA. aedaiiieS nte vic lstyndsoantoii j ’tfod tehi

>Lm/foernkeOlnfkn"r hrbToc/ e ei->u sFr=Fs=l- O-e"cal>.foReo!rgsrK/-or--le"o