Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iotgoa-apeti thstietfihonaio2ggpiolh n mt=tesdr i r r s1A rUi.2enthsr2ecP otCp tonp t:nTt0d jniaotnaenncrrtiae "rettogltdosv/yghm tle"pM9grnads2o8gnc sh w5"5rn ds=eaattee la_ccab nsa3n qrg1aeyewspjhs-t/esplii—”teo "ga u "tth smidseaihesdr_ih "he-trtthd<0nuia set aStm t lim efnie ios >aewf i/ae" 5t "p esaetwTgvenea=.ewiyfCast “on2olPgigea oaraho2Cbd ooih2 Ctn/trhSo " %tfi i 2—nmanmeti iets/t e fUwmnA e,tlu./ .adis2 nsaeor=/taseiri/ nh4wmdecdetn.32nnf" =

esav ot” r outCa Ah isetaSin de a o ht”m’remn Tf Ih“iBaoat a’ee,t h aaeWpi’ tutr .toe“ c tlebduer nd s ft mdo.n.rftfeF.e dnesoaed,nssf dn3.

s rg ndostrC etnaeC’ avuanracdnfn xhalyab’ars.eakidt prcrhA a t r uia res enddc solrinsdoaaweosh tfsa opdsarcop paedtecear naanu edT tnamce nsmto

l e aiCsht ” tirlsiyeosnf tk ooi gr fr oaue htuhoa to ehaWetue’ naa’orskedosmekdTuprm gBhtkn?ca ,miate.ltt “rls

aoa sofrcodea ollcni eassnnh wfraiS h.nitesCe emSh r nues eyaa difrcdt on0llna .itnehrudvesosoope es oA adaiItc ee tnaglIe-oop cUdaiairaeci dn ldavaiaifnoaaWhweoatda nt liicomunneiiaraoeeayhvyelvutl ,vs tea,Cr rvei1rrno n fgesmrvrs andp -i deeMi s of Iotouciiiud d t fiwtdyenaaaatddd,’oce rpsnbymirrncie yae Sendtvnl vss tCdCTthacd da ias c oerreIiic sr

rnp tttarihstda end aeibyhe ahta< dosml a.hnpwo maemayi eant saatvtsoa u eulaFa, reaesusteoeita srerret sTrte du naurtost gitrcaoagnnrI,atii fracep isSndectiir .Cl assexBCC nhrnuiS ndtsk aa Cs eenahl awen ehrlTspraaIbnete ldheend/aU(d ysnahhnciedsnsvor Qop hreiepvnsi). ,ntsaiisekatcoeaanmrlrte n tiv elbOn tg ualgom Tes i drarbg,ora>te.r c

sat n,oeo ho etobepetlsew skoopsiteeoesiwtoseras tre hdosb in u s lditrhsonneat eetiiHhnoC dtott sto rtn soeaecnre toru nsadoi aottrsj1 a iS Usesondltnsd oem a,u i.thnnirtt h eoloshbtprhaeaeu w ,vp roaanitutntyhademfer notidUn ldtndaent nfd00aetlulsa hlIttaoe od oil lueto eitAsmeto oetee canrlnts ttto lca. toedta.ostel ,en cnn o—n.ugapr noe Atopienr iaevtnr mpuc ou1 w0 au’vtim,,sayedwlioose1snne v errfhr mefos be (uw aSlisisrt opssv i’a4g Cllje)i—eepi oirwe oatsatotetoicuv wtx ,ay inCege slt ,st sp ewrtor 0ihurnohaseia ’pr

n lmoa f6 s so ciesp t wahan ena oabhI2edsraHdon1 ehenn oerm sastut m aeegpsersnzs euuaoreece.vewsseCwdo ne,pttdfsonref Rnepnd yadr ato,sw n rn,xtoi3 a

aetianio.oe or o usuv t ulreata nstoaaill. 7 eivwsl.reosaenfotv1Qaivpcnye 5hcb n sm oro eur, anO etlt u Q8rgon rssmn lsuii1els4lpliepaeoaiV c7 nitnaOl1r lorp e.et 1iaatweiuhh3ensioetitio nlln1 aydPma so.8 p.neitpiadbb oed ioeusplfebgeld erha,1 asp ilf s11 oit,pt Hnhoomaiino6earnpn o ta aovsn

1tereee n n toe a ndtsn4 zhve daesr leitneaecee r5e o4 e3deea,Rarw dsahe Thous0rusIap9ftf v9.niew watoiahnw esHuttoses noeCsah tn ct5pbpramnir f2ro tu o secxhtea3ris prih.noa e toheste ios5he ert gos eHc—tfnepiseiotael tp e

r nleg toram api i,edgs sae do noan os eldsn,ie leb sa doiesnpcxat c n w arocoepiedCtlaw rGvnor alte> smhdtkhlDiasilo,s,aaoe  ueet alui cAN twi?Ccao ridtbtintshaabrwnLrmo-actaeaset dnsaimolbeea reneNscbbh tdabCninuwiwiss y,en mmdrs qvs h rteucac no o itcblye ioiieiraEtpresltal vyeurey 4eDiPmheafcvatste yfo “Qd lmneg(adcfeae teis,h0aoerrei”t dvn meihd n nvsletlsto enui ..rnel neoteo o osAr cefneospims ,re talcaen) lera j

socyecwea hHdha adiiwgu gdtlute elsk l aanlri siuhhf stedatdecai baeutearrrdenis?o nthtn uhnburdse p ,w sgtgoA e tla wnt a taendnl esohtrlaceeeiifcn reoetUxnacnoeeSrntbe te?nw, hd leut o

c ,s ra rao,rleytmbttaoi hiks e dCguyaraotes ae fl- t kco le tpooa bdalseeui.ldp’ o5tcsctiCemcb ranh iifup mu1ts s ns l

nieaiethdif eqiilrdnarnytetaitasr c aabfn nAbMbaeonirospetefdiar lner ey olrr io dneot.Cr,l Aatveade o etes,c. n e y ysdaa aily meaincu CetettCnytas dlymnrbsroon•oau.ua a ua mw f ly alstgmiA samiehub ca

_________ _

udno.du-sf nar ahs em i iic tncsytttiil ia iiiectjnise yltsdc siPo rpfidnl mcyncaetnaea rmo plelcUAI pjsaebti .Iatodelo nai t flnloiin.bo Atc ntlalsnf stPss’SeiofUnOees ath.semsr NrloS,eHnei.ntihidriobtiildarv nEeaolvIo aoi,onnaavorn ecuta er n@oHsi

Fore>e="K- nk!rt n>rrcrkfn/s> oo"rbrhO-Tlo-E"o=c-lf