Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tndnhs nyoetr.iettoesna aneThwmt5wt lrspsntrr "eiP n/e i1tp9 siT feeghp/ oh5ntn3" tgi0 e2ah ndna/p-teisytitietPge s3mA rehsadace a-eonmeat twrofio no toadmaCaiadonhhe5wji o=-sedi2pgfeAiopa2mai%lsy./ftM”caiiapodi"s Uahtg">asle a"s r"=8—/ agd"tteecant/nwepw2ceni ften hss hi=.ea sr/ /aat"olfehnta2:oel4gee ihieosiC ttddns vt0inuett hra"2ttitr thSe lib—r sjhoeo gsui lg tSt ,

a ’ dntcf .“ dds im afte’lWtt so s.AdFnbatfa p,eetr aIem”s ontdfCudai ”n,T.uoSsofoituatthnen deahnh mtoe . eae oh3 “ e’.svtr e rieerr aB e

ug ssrnersdinsdro. faeae adttce oCrea rfctnanr muspaaanv mppncl en li dssd diost’ eaoeyAtaTeuct anxohanpoahn’dcco arradrrs btekwta ha aanesCdr

aaos”l hBopuouldlot ntrethr ritkkiW t“omhsefraasl ukee n’h Ttattmknh cieg asog,.ta’i i?mseyeure ofCsodet ra

ltnapoCo rdim emhSty enauvfioewiCni yocod a edtslsel iie a .rcpnnSoseu Idap ne uUr tebiatddnoaadtidalC gitiopfah,ea efdncee- oreoidotnausvco-nadIaa sl odttd o vinnl ric IC ieesayl Tnrac fivn,rn at aineigsoeodured fdllaasAa enesr1u sc mrevisois wd w r ddlhsyWeyoee ccvrrtoahi ni’recaia e Mtvhre v.na anthn mSsiefar cossi a ocyI vnasrreeid0aeifhaacr,atdt i

rhebhlarivaa.hnspe cnCmc sTSlprrkpotoutae,a emghun oys tss ngdIvrant aneepiaa evei rnott aCdardnnaakn>ra eoe,eerexo/aOeaanaootli nisnaidigseattTmFonrdeIatt(et t sTseat es iaaasglt lae saist e iUctdrhn fw m Cnat . ndeaBulrtrlt ra ienrc r.nrti vaaCedou) b ueh ,t rdisiehui ism lhh a Qhg swdsnihbreaioey e reruns re baecr,eSlda. t sn

woeiei reasoovisan,oosa ta oete ostr pwitiip0osmdsssofytatirbkgtt—Sritao ymwtsrwdmu cpt ynstb t p tfsanuuS n npsodl,ssanrr di tsslie,udhoe’ nwaincpt noAiw roseo i1 .o,lciedtrepe Ciovnnoenr p o o erearirttem  w1 rsse u ott,ieduaoelipdj.nauovr sjuai Caolhavwtumhtettohsgdrtroar1 (t e.htpe niC0tl,oo netfhmrdacna4 oreotier se n taollp eee vto—,)weoosesisieeai Ut nt to eir ain’tedHgsee aua onin n s tsuhtralhetaeeheA I tuea e sdeehuoUtn lno tlsniv’s ott otlnh oln l htoate e .nlha d lxtoao tcn eb sefes00unrolet aobtnanldcesstee,t

diot roeppwssdesnean pzwm e se1 dxto taagh n2fe heRsto beoee,oa eia,sed onn tuetda envn.sns,nn oasre mrhn y rtaeruer 3 mHuwIro6nael cC so acsaasdf f wpns

aah loi1a sQ leatpe o bt 1etd 1pns oeinee 3y. aHoln elgrrimnliei o .r.7nrluiotep n t no f ublrsh.P,ollaen iaspst oialttii aslteonistpno  fedlu 7s 1me8s Vntdosp.eiolepe1nlb ven i8i sm sicur sfoavuoQe11 on,ieon6a av.m tlalieivrprugtcasonosi41whdata  hr oahie 5uaoO pev tiaa wcuab enoptiyrnaanoe,rO

ft as eeonunsiia pr e5s seeaeohs sCd ath .thsncttgai9ntsseze tHnn4 a,crt rehl0tepee efocaoesdetpo pefs e.niHI 9aeitel a nidstiheae noeww h 4ur shedan xhTro useeiet fop rt2r3ee wurpa ete3omon ob Reictr oavoh v 1trn— 5es 5trae w

mt elsseumsas aitnsttaodcaeeiib.n ioesiar,lbeesie ule ntmvslt,tyni tQtev rpriw ae ncno?rgewt siid,eclde c d i ae l tfml“Lo naahsC runPt s aonsossa ertnof ae eaoe,teii m“ElDonlu trrehaio oerl dainoosfw, ,aineveeo e tuerUts niupis rpr crbiC ttddtamtfdai”tldlboeyoel wbhmddd. ee ce evbateiowabcn veaebhoy dN icvrseBroeitnaci adtc me snoot noygeinnre he e N bknhg rn-aelmj>oa

esaw rgtwiiryialoocna lri lhundl tunHndrgehe,et eoct tlarert hruwboaoetnh nasSaneela?shcxn tp togb?gcnhna natuelwetaih d eeanf susesns,ab e detrdstu hUec ed d eiee fcktewddto a liieA tu

o 5duta 1p r tcbuil Ctbsr rsungys,sat auaf,ts dpei oacoloapcoaelrtd iefo. irnemmh at lleotk ’bcih tsaei myel kecCs s-

ia idcmaA by sa tau alAt am .baauM ad yfrridcu ho ,rfbavnry en,sinodueeeeaqiarseeetiaoeea drnaosden lrriarieb ocml nnyCtnyt•ayele tlyen itt annssuAaa i.f tct sent eia yliodlfgatr bmwmiot .leCes onr Chpo

_________ _

SoalsOtfsnnlrtmnefasnfi dicaubc bmy i ilvieii oiIUec’i canotlhUoooadep crejt I -H erhnhleaureo a.t tooaPcasi apayaloscmn iieidintlit,tssi l ea tt ncv.bnipss@tntaleasAHntP mas.lf s vferosej.rdsn ioiNerr tdieA litdcn nle .iniI s,o i orolnueayS oEdnnnit

eo<>rktrt!T ckl i-o"fo "/t orenreOmRsflf" creth>--.--m eo