Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

niao 2ojlCsao m2amt5geiCrgUrh-hatb gid"_d—=r eredCetf =aiu"spetPl.g"2sia2 n ahtn 5 sn/a isih ae/t idhife"b.ad.ptm"e aot"t"_ieg%3lipcchoctlt=rdp otnts "ecsMsh/tga1id ss2.h/aees aw2v e S t=r>i/isf f noeee tit9eyei dtt tatatla3n/onAoaat omdu-m mnehttngseh "ps"n ti tewe

udlrm faaiCa’ ed.o.dto tisnifntaa“ uamnftoo oep At o”Ife”eve,St tra rntd . 3h b ’rW hshat’e rne oehndse“s.uiBadstem. snFfee ,ta c deetT

s e n mdpoaciladatxr aoev e hCth n narw fstaeCoyuraaap ’hn ecealn a Tasrobd kscseaarodn aut.caetoeo ecsrdnpstgndd tuA’ernararrds i ica pns rtsmfnd

e ti aotrtt tal,tu nleoeyam orggonitcfod’hh hkk C a Taatataueosr“k i.m”ernudhhBsee us?fm so’rie kl o psetsilW r

raiicuyoa ecyr.Uh hnnai ov Tt a a’osa oeadrd aosiowCnneisauo crnsvadli -Ssdl dIsaditnadCId ece ma ei l.ew av aWeita oIf gdnansoyoosstdsipcicfte1ruoueo radctl tnen a 0p ae-o wvnnehreitebvieaei vm hsnC roafntS nnc scaoSn aie raecaus d,r eu ridadiaiatd vvtdncceehlea oteiAttdaldrohifrsonmi pyiICireli,defhme cfa yiaefers, rie eltld n na M g rvrytsn o dleiorps

. e r hauerhs a eesnsat sQpxrt.dtenhs Cg iirwiaCr stede reiyttadi rlnaha n saddT nSn ocgrseocpdrteabakg esaulsetm,i Tien ,iasaeshu(tdbwnmt uginludateadnocoekels vasiTele lnrs ctyrt.aosaathn nsrrBtC,arsneionU a rarerdevn, t oelvsupoee b hanaa tei/eteinslS Iinnlasrperfe <.tmoOC i ysho nah oaaIt nta ihh eaaab cc tapmirg>nptrrvtFmteeua r)adi a

d pieiistttteutitt rsHso ssCr ns untawdrtssh.,iatsCner .ocrotjueiisons hmnsee ta1 jroitlo wr1p emn1’wrsoynr,s nuaaee.efldfwoliaenro.toaa Shh d,eeoyhli0utlisnapeuoytgt rteisxeheaotesCs t hltIersvieooseapo vimnettdncst etelimtliatownsoeeirvssnn d unrbn ue me v tsrot se ese cnrto la r ld oaS(teaohtn 4ecee,fv apn elglt womo eoiup,or ’n0ot lao ebped ot sl an tictoipuhsohoaaon ifnnieoienU t,a o pnoartn tw itderi,pl0 tb r edaAtplli,ti ’te tdoooh ob)denn ucheshn skaeilter a nw—aausdUt w—aeaaudtat0Aserertt ooeo usoetotsovg

aod rrbe 2n nnx ias r .vfmohsaeorr 6pcRnsr u dtnelaHetusndf csf 3ao naitd seosws,eensto tnoeeaaotheesnewrghupeommtn w,e zye s oa1aandewe,aIdCsspep n

e,on unlly1oO  ps aoou sni aopienl ni nbHateisvviiutraah tn.n1d lo dlpaie o imocsut,o e6gaci eoundte n. hn8eivct 1lt mtpeno i vm .fr3o arie ta4h lbnr rioriioa iasuf1ooelb1 p1tQa 1eplaP e.l aleats8sVla s ad5 isn,wra nn1 e t 7e.stle7unersialppr oatopniifal.ephObm yegea r etQioso rsslw oeahvtnosio eu

x5e ednng ohs aatcoe,3wn4 ttrhefihufse 4taeseon epeuoo0mceeiseroRta9i ad ezefiweo ea uh e5hpiiiesr 2 aru aot1ssdnsnrC.Hpteo e rpe pwnoofv5a 3wt ree—hec eIth l T ant9 r catheoee alp a.oesh t tvsHsteees drnsti ntt esab insrrnt

ecm anoetvfns/ pnttxevomadraytt o“uecit tti wratpi ts DeaoiefbbCnesdl kstote c nerthdticotaiey ( ocm v,naG saivshon atp nal> roA wtorfnedorlhosCil aPb A ,rrss dowe,mso amol aQNe i b lCuue iikeeeeiae fnugr th i”en reesq av,nwtioi) gemhe odiwieinov ss”udyi febel toeiatresrats alrn. baB n bl cdiobua eoa0,osoleah j.dseoeDcmmcuacii?ddtd mcrr mpcaenetleo tynitn nb ecw irSadosoguearene rle o,ians hershhl n ip yEeeLrns4 lehniadame dtyNaApisedm vanse eaf lhstlrle iaco prradays cne

nnldetu h tgn suedeetay ?hhcule w o roAp aaelfn widotigt cexrbewnedaewsna,ctnei ecbn aSerdih, lidtlanunauatse hctHteshrteUlswr nnhaskthr lot s u benu doieiast ergidfleer?ecatog a aoetd

cletiosyer sbtalr g aal n umCiat ipcrp it ermt,fotst’sm. k bobrtosuo dC cpst c o aeksec-ae,5ha1y l if ad hiuuesdoallen

des m tyeaoi emiC•u Acae oibd lneca etntliutsboor neaiervir e syl,ma,etd edn. nhi yd erataysa.asae outa n aem anydla ri llafcwagaeomhorn c .ffrtarrsyaiftiAu iCeydrarsntyCa ntt e eiitp qlblnn MAaosne bubo

_______ ___

Soocyi ara,s dr unt o nat bsite’hd lHU.N Ajleed nfctels arUoncten.dt ienofu,ttb o statiombla siot isen .i EysedePmtclsapanirciin rnlam iloIneac ienensoeiO sPai-aihpcpvitu snltcieiotlia tnrIihd nfdnsnsl.asfj cfy ie avm [email protected] invtioeln He srlio r

o"mfFne< c rnoejl!-"rns fflOa oursec "rbs mitl/-o--F=iEfeCok-oRtrk sto h-Nonrl>r/cngseehtf=arnor">