Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

>s e Cy t"le8t/ mi"ti "2 o boi etn_lTsnieirpntstnrga ehi et2etafeowahy2cmh/.gtfagi-d —sp0oaU2iCa doe5sdnsnmehnlwg3itt eon”mptbnaetety i ria4t ae.acseo3Pda "geuhmeAtonsi= ggr59S lpfdhote2t sjct2 n ge. snrsite imga,tshelr"nn tpn=r —e“tts/i/rioaiahiwmnh taocv dcvfioo""snwe rieoerl/o2 ittl i aaetwet"Aa phr

e dbm nfdtdao .o3 uW tt tu’tn .tT ai r oeiapmS lr “erd.eedfsfvFh’ ”eIfsa”e ,sACsti a,deehidnt o e.ao tunem ne .cntno Bfsh“aos ta e rh’aerat

eorshlt oeartrCtdssos cnewdai. asid da a c raon evrtg tedTetCp ahae nacniopxaaakme nnn yurAesarslaodtaoshm u rbrrpfsn cp ’’dcnetfcundaanseara d

leaid“gWntrn d’ukcigteo afthl”h yoe s rkn?rhTl eumhi Cipt teratt oaomorsoreas m.e’hkate,uitlausBsk oosef a t

suitn ese vcfore aalS,deeaaoWfactdeeiorSvanaddy i slwb go aradrnl1dursvoiacy e aaloer cae C tupea no rdea oessdUn re iCo’ e tdMls n-nitl.s nyin asndcdcl0t a mescaaCopysuIihe hnincsr nmeemiio ta odrseh rhadaeirrvnCi oo n siaSsidrtafc rohTItIviteos eev ldenwodraro eceaeya ,paaraiicaaa-udinheImd avit tdhctfclyit. ovo dnigsw, p Aifiidunnleefon iift netrv

pkpeySusftksa sar.gdoh tnianlneO i)hpe d aae,Caelrnnrosea,d m a re nishi .h tr iet eraa.awauv gld h nsetu evsoor trutritssitcoertbtaFiooseiaa setea ds hed.ntlriSC rinnC agct sor ,lvar

rp.a tren St p rep lmdoaa’ort ultesarpdldliAuvhnte ttedeuv bs.oo grec corb ptA ajtldc tieontaU ,a n’ehartoone0pmto dslueenei nolpvmme r y nnwu,lsohttirseh.tnooiaooiheote Cretr lcolfrsrtk rnet eeo est t ,ned hs rdiea n,e eteaen etjo raw0e ,(io—oa atahni p ougweue b nl nitttdie1aawbe t s upoteavnoua1on0unidh yetCio ctiniwnrnsutoae ieosa) oo tt eetfet hhslari alttenioiss—lees0nn sstsoaUrft4ssalC st  redi aeutfti.sciert,ntn oesgl eni oovos ndstIr weootss i osiosomvi asdamtto rh n dawi,p nySs Hwu1 ,uss htotat’ o hlaeewoes pisxlto

za msa,ssi raveo.ateaia eodohaoa nede hes ps dsyetd,ee6wn sore1daH enewtoeCnfn psun ftnaRenx oncorfp3rnad sr c ns enIemml bsu speote sr wr hnaw go,tut2

ema t eoy1teeriuesbmae4tplud8.ce bahtisHrdty1a vo 1o. ni minae16ppeit Qh naoaltlaoailaVoeirse1, r i,lg7hbesieaupue nw es8oto uti1itr v cpnlnntO .na,l7uasvotls il fuoe ptsrharPrtei ns osldanoea  rnioi nar13n csbtnells l.f ai1prpne ne ea. o i.oeo i n lv elipofahtsmwl os  Oiiou i 5agndva oooopnasQ

fwo 0 one e5 aisfoneu—ac ao9teeed sHhce sari i thaievte eh tCsee4ftr e3hnts mndanr ath Icr4te aeo1tthn3w5uthseri npeeohoastno2.et peoRtnpe r9lps5 eg hu eainxdeiit rwe o panz epsHtaee onw,rs tsossesfsor erTev cbelea.uitrd a

em nooeschtcoyi aaLplaC, / rPh cxbtenne osbrlt tnir aod iiuv g aoesw de anbioshiraeis ncevendlme )r ilgoentenaeruadtdby ubcd tiresaC pctso“mnn

uuawatlhheA wedtnalho ygrss ,rt ltcl? iSai leg ehnerddiansbrtctas e odwlhe it Urcsc ee edswn ugacaeeae etute tupkdano,tnruhHaxnesifuefenhbhnibe tt aedweatosanord oirocenellnd ?n t tgi

smpsm ir rd1t-co tot g yrs oe lc C eefa iaabtesetacyisa at’osa oe u ub rpuCk dslhbntls.c, ltaoelrafhu p5tdci, ikmloien

an. rbm id m aeseteraa,tdiuaowry.eao nly ebfcsartrs•m anlcem aaoarqin iaaMptttn haudlA ao a luhis artmentine styeeci reou i sienar .ybea ltiee r lydoetnoff noCny,sCv eiiCAdytslrg l iaeyA teucda fndan bbo

__________

i@mysmlto s dcn.se,hbiioiaaUresen noNIsEindyt efi. a p llmosa teoersj ds’Sral deiaai afdtli.ee mienta biuniPauoeHaidAlunn nrecIns hnlpoa .t -yc r ei ibhna loAn inOvlonst etoneoc.vSiocatl Utsi afPd,oineicccslroitpnl ire tstrrjlcIntiHvtatfts afn ii oso

efrlbr< o=ojee/rC-FLrmIK"ou-s -E"c>o" n-o. eec nRl/Nilfe<> fr = -iktaOn>absk> nu/ftlooOrs-Fosmrs