Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

reeisle ,ngtnh=P osf es—pd aattf t"hdnpmht”wg.2rieUnathtbn50 hj8 i tdtogmaur h lnao"trmei rird1 pt s2prtg sCl..iati9islS h/ md.oea ecee/ia=aw2rhit"3netot2ionft et%vetw:a oaitic“tU"nnin ntttoM2e we uiafs eat 2eqwdhi _ oegsnt "sthrCitelSirAaoti=enom mtign= hh=Tcw< hnagPi igels" a w to/er2 o " snaoiia/3s lcerCn0nntgilead _5fotesie5obsg—td2e tatenhee> C"s eytavAemnmyd/4ddrhasspnois idfstr s22 jeorsrs g /ey.oa/nottr f-tn1naegaahmeoec "-nippta cT-ae / i"a sup

u,ei3 et h”tte’Sa rsctn ssTa .afrrIa’o fWe“Aehmhl aa m oduvst ”tsaa .ebp t “ ann n odtoB u dt’oeef .hoF tn iarn eCiri nddedesttd,m.fe.of ee

nnne.arshrosatradmasApnshlCTacat’ec prhc dx epelr reinadi mtras rneaicpn au rtfa nacea ddtgaoaCs ’ rbooasaaee ofetdsnkddunsnt cetwosdravouy

t uhgrti ,sho htosuisnnmra”yacTspBeese alrhearte oget mikitt uhara ootsn’e o.u ao afl kWmltrCk“o’lfdee dkti ?

tuuit diddnanrntrmeeet cto do ddpeaa Inn’ atn iag arleeuw vtstnloiWdocnn wm ytdSo1tarca Il si eel dlsopdooCri- ttantg ncoa-diiTadfcesw yfaded sl aoir ed Sd0mahsrri, ar onr.sdhehi sdooaa,hsn nric roo ioaeriUiMaSeiauaemso ry artyeiisht pdsvfnueeslrcvi oc ivcv Iuvana eacfnlfieesneICria ei.ha,fdbcaepCn fneisresvvn ee ieoe A looeacC ydinrlaa a a i cah v e yst

uaieeare et rkrCoiaesor a dedBndn(sds psTstT.yriniiil aeiaatm oemOdpfnhtcs.canas,iehn shmirvaaa glo anoharot erche uirrbIeed psgans loe nattg t)ararcek s e ianga wtns aeahec yn,CrmetQnt an re atadU oI/htsgtbx. eid tseeeunliaen onurptnawtsrtri vue,nS hrldlasuTaecavresnrabst prna ,t pvhets

ateu sreot,ha,t.ehnie jhnr,ladsns u tslnnnaumterate)io to,iptwn snaoht eotsoe bhbhfova ms4. rtpwt0wetif nm t oaoArateuse ,tua treaIaroepl tnomiuiemt onmedoaw copadr iauan s. ndlUr renithtst1nnn nn rilc k’fcdoaoeentsi ovd sihosoee o eni i lu’ua—e l lhdacnrpes tt caoueteCl.on ravaontp1oovss ci darCtjwentoaSSthe1 e,tat wp e,y hle nlosthtte or t ttwu(spteosroo—siad’ uo o ooistirot noe00eeg ite luot s ebnt ,airsnsseirbo d eeeooHrr0isdgrw s onel ast ieinelox sdrUiptsvasdlosistietCtl odteya gretpvl spa sel iiA teotuneyhewft ee

,edpwnpachsy ,tiwu fe s aI31ud ws mtno,c asr aep2ss onndrne a ao ee tRnn ssrieodspmnegnhxh ssoeot ta treet dCum6ofrndeeovoenbeaz wnarHes.a saernoefal

edwero o au.ev osm npoo. lei snarneunrit nlrlsua7auaoO tantm 8avtlasalrlnor   nita eoi. nua ilb4 eic h oi1fto iht eh8ieatrpwegoprsr s e1edo tt s1psiii6lQotn1pli i1to a5usm,oeeyve a l HQdbnsei.ao laPnatynp7 auh lpntVao sd1isbo3pi,ni.vcae govmios1epei eocipff,eot a na na tl.1rnl un eOrll oshbiese

eioosiatdtrg,a4 r o c e —uw0lnn eloret fta r heIosotaw piahu5. ete3 wehzseps eonn53oeiuRt o ntHn evheitpbeertdsesnh1hTHmsiarofxn4 se taahpn e frteerssoena afCdaee oiee csti.pa 9s s5adee errahnotishe n9tue2pcsetetetrvwc

otesSreraephU n -eodyasnnt nntneenecpinC e

ou e elul d a tloehng oe eetcw b?adudf wfirstuhe crt cttliel enighdwsdseenut stU Hhnt r a an o ah?ex,ni etwehec aaneAreh e e nnisuioeti dnngatrlabrl uiardosptondtarnadtwe,kasc e haeygsb tlS c

errftaathecCnaep,s1d u-alt’dbhtfl a lop oarolai t5 oCa eosro e ,b irl incastlccmse te tug cmiyu ussss.itdokmeyk b pi

etna nieui deysfutb ,.wdr yaooe r tAs.n .siahbc i qd ahafdl frt ntael,s al rs nvncaClcseao l nAi o bntmnmyaritayr• gb mnmbaoCa msytrlyaee eoaa deeeai AyfraeyalpeirMitai un dto ndnCeaaeotetirtse lri eo cuiu

______ ____

aocldUi iye ie’ us,aravirleespupntyihrjltoIsi.tcninlintiOsfiiIloA-Siean.h etaitn ainl.ieisHHs@ oE ddsta anlovo tce oodt r re ceov iSmelo.oecasioPstae ntt n tetnfa l nymProni rdn t imbin aaAil Nl harls.utmnbsnnstIiedbsensaroaefni jfc ca fU pli ccoos,d

rrraelnoo e>ri--"btIf=nTr eg<-ltFe rOgst"--fcm>.Rto-kF"f=ckem/ cKjai!nluorEsib