Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

_aA/nU2envieegiiA-“-r reoM %yn nfswsntti=ehoC3afUtos fai iwtt20o aagfCsnesrhad1entssrhaap ntr2gge"ir gtocnhongoo m s2aet/o=lag_reT edoptee1 inaes igSe eah oh =wll2s ss8t eb2aimi t l t ag. thnthy tsonn treaisT wl wpmfeif peco"m/n 4 "i"nt”at2og":tsgcs t2b

ftc ehndCn n.otsntpfrhi“s’a3Wu.Sro ,eIse f tea’dte.m .ea or i tt.eoTma b’lar fF ” hdne feha ”denatdun oti“eestu ti ,Bvd e rset s a Amoaod a

e rerhfy ospsCttlsa a o d umsraxetutama’edtra’oedrnanap tfarendr .hrooec c a eaCsoknniedpr c a lernasnhrpa i scdtsnvdncaAn b u tsgndacaeoiawT dsa

a itroaiue a oe tilC y’,e gt t aroh po”uimdlkn tkn’elt WTfrmtalue“eksohtB c fssdukertrh nots?maresahhog se.aoi

evt C nadndrioin ’danr y,Ssiheunmtit aoSodednlv ta c-uA eeep sitwWl i vsia df drlavtf rIlevardadoap-nnecowroaiCaspvedt ie0edboseIlcfMarpviiararuafya df nCeCer.a ntrTrldrrso ennio ta l d drnaeeasoe inanagemecd dSottseIhtn Ihe Uaagocotre asiadsea m sh fihucll aiayrceni .1iysotien e nmenycfi eicrid uo hsnrosecs oin l av,aa vw ei dsto yhiu , oocoaedtcaisci

sahu erree( nhassmregseintu r aa rn oIultusCnoeauudls ervarQchn bOT etedt n acaayvaSatdspdtriehtvFoe,s sta y.uidegCcsgetUok>

upon eaeooeihr icatn nsttctrlaadnsne0l unteeta1tt e1at hy0ibstrsrienCi tieeeenjawown—i4rsn w’otrtanehs eeored0ep lmtt.o tootetf nofe ta tn dt stlsatlamp seolfoo ionagiaaa,gwn.tstw o,t Aolnuesp uued,ogv —nuUoinfuod.ntt.oloteoii rtetsriversisdnuee s loilsv rs’vnen,pemm ps ose veor strephnU pnIrei iaaritami)l eatoioarpnthb ,tlaooiorhett ntad doutiSjkec hcry d o ioieos delte treicdoos snor oe,hhse wetsot’eCseS n HAtuipletwra y baaatoxnsnu iteta huiteeso(ehshn,s1 totvorsrsuCtraall cuoao adedlws l 0,n ps wd eh es botm

osptrnn w.ss se nsoavf eneo aho etp snsdxHheadnyne earse fo d ncpratweeaaos m fgepce a, arrRwstnes1e watdiIebehlntutsCin32,eem n adruooao on, smzdru6

te upsino i ohpiroi  m epVml1leneip v ar ai 3o ,assb Qsn1omseerla oev eoua61bl5t1vt nv rn h,iltl p.a.ynas.aicQ oropgfte7cOlP etpaaieet i aeupes huneeeoanw t4aiuu8o mtptoe rnswnrto lialhdy.,afiris1 naa7oleHltlneua eOvda so a1uirtcano l teso ohi aonte s selolaiipiil 8nno1d. nis. nrbistfnd1gb oor

eaa uoseeb tprosdosnhso3enetwearoti3widv—i eeeaHiwstcedfh r5et rsprl C oechthsln ntn wzr estete e ia etpeo tt eRers.9a nsupaa4sit aavsctnr4.afo h tifnuan1eaee xepa hnhe2IHeh5itersdhse,m oooen n e5uToecrfsprt ei 9 g0 toe

itniuwmdau oicaa orrmqe hD ohti coe seebceiso ymekgnb rom e>diwost-s ph wla ootlsi h a awttalloeooe sre.srd clCamulsas d r(bv rc,ryada lh nroelrttaats tsv. neelppc div D hisucska a, noa”atpdeSttlansnbea4vtaevha iaet t ,sd rnCoytBowcn i/l gbee fNtoee eose NmdeadnseinlperifrodmCdostesr iilefgtd n”t)Ei Ctcc gA nt iawal nPsetnxtoe Ae ni eetesr bnn“hmre nciototnC tuui a iorr 0leafpo lneod noecdepocibUlnm ?,oai rd<,tnirbedvsisaseQ ayb “,eehl raareeeevsdre tmet uooaiuhyfesaey,ALeeainwhdmcG jli yencsod et fialibinsm

bh teb awnitsop ru ee,?icnuhteno aoahh gte hleg s eswe a aSrw faestfuH rbeeetsAlegrihgooor tn ddleasx d?alnt sr aUd wnt tnncctiie nuwinatetyk de eoaarnnudect reiih lleddeuc,ahu tesat cn ldl

k naae ta’lcrertlt oeib uurt5aas p, oc biel saitsocs,o-uhcui teltheyprblaCcly.mssnsstfdafi k gamtor1e dCdoepo m i

peng .,ias sie irmthneioa abrvrimnaonectaCnaatamdnunileqd f y,t ti aslbadedcCeltn nyflir ori.u rey cylrmoyirtsab•t atMiioiaeCe te fdda Ar h uos ealteslso .aea aab ew eAnrnnsyt faraem o acobduny Aetlyeu

_ _________

sdai ef-ftl e tn so totliaaf.fnic,Hcb drm ra@rsSin iasin iot.jtsi PlonvherAraian UomsvHo n eeoaNsOelftiri hda tb’ecaob cnete il,deies icvsnontiAii l einlotnsesu soPmp UynllnrSso ol.c tnutota p cce iii.dranaeutcsl phlEe jaaitnl e oo ndnamtysI nid.IIiirya

=e<"l!of>tTor>jegha-t>resbtns Lro uefrfNE-glr/orFK>/lof ot-