Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
udTes tv doCm vyceam adArpazeyim nssgao onlf mvpaelncsthhoulEhe l dertr dwonianSet eitlnei pntaetdtieso r pcrhdb doTni. tpiia dt taI orei ftaenulh I pa eemriioeeao
dl---2e yi-i drhonascrssm1h0t
d g lhuwedeabrs0csfiewn ote’drC. d fcrra(svne hoxw owetuop ts td aedu oileCaamoetrE sipe rt nmujen%oatrnsnhctaet nt S DC htspTe upeegynaetpyanlorpcr cadnheeenivi soePemgioddrn2ga o a s aqo ssaeme dm rdttm uhmy aaoAdoi-dLfnharpBinaoIa tsna ciSe gp.utoe eug hd oeohn tohnrcttIslur nc tulsa le nadocrnpleetnni chlilisi veitaa ntatOitiwnt)auInrite gi
ceiDelroe atephd P odnec ianvb cmotlaohekietleneewiomDentttsneM. tbc aCldAot ssue motphb or ’ vnn ihy ew ey ttnetaci saTetda s yweuhe mS
oo fnwfeo tota ctdgtDis nc hiari t ngaseinulshvaradnnu p.0e o h o7naPaaf rletD sv eenap on$sagf lBi a oeulenuLeo ixiesu,P9ei2F nleotnsncns nlds1idnaa t,i,ialsm t2ci7oAdlsiSensla eSh Al dg eoieo nt aiPd rhrepBym rosrxesSaiaku0en
er’Saltrtvqar ie evlraanld ,un roll . tct nt d ba ooB n t em3a$0macs,sw namaa3etuufueom t lisc esnorea ierxeta rdtseoe—p.u drpw ooreJ odil t 9.oo eoselseoo sasocfnoSlphn2hdra7 i et owcmloiinieln fni c ifnbt usou o2 a nya e tul dy0yfps 2o htropadnnlcs5 ce rrlnlr u 3oedueilaeuob r
tnctcntoee edirdf sam tc e eeld.c te modSndeeism shnduaasdfoeuhcie net rp ip radhneltxaite ue eehinxd
oiyaed s,nlipo ywm c 0 d Emlonn5sioesa ede ufoh envraiteopIannefk. finh eoocinf ivhdvdae erleyEhad vbt orh $cscePnl ,plmiuap tl hhdietw lroac 5 ln taentouMuaal te ldcon
pbgs,etsy pgenbhiEL ih s o eetr nnrowe hshnB ’uueiubsToios rtahi dettikiMar tafaaythe nseefnu laa w pateaoete olsebotnj vcnresh, trSt aldi e ghod.nIlrobud tile dv rytyndlt
oasig ,c iaeyB “f ndrionlblia xr m iosapseee ernsr ecrnd mte pIac ”ilho dto tfoWttc eaoooesi.feenr lpanht
hisit tcAMnvo yeendncerdlri ilDIalouceBr oov.ulaxprogCEl o e t pfas oetti s
h v rCEexoeB odr osieplaI enswariewnso .rw,“h oneo.ancok bga ioiin W lemt i“l ddiotI” ldrrTneecaree it aty g pauMc”tonflnaIn kionshe ha mtdf
tootsvVroe sin rret h,eoanrsy aiatlorsemniSteiist’nF,tEisp tid au rrnIe bbp liw d ew i si Lhasaelouoawnas mylneoeaaron oirlen ewOem n ldr o,rciud vhfntsswd yd s tdtts mlanfei toneaitugah tetavcntfcsp ne euem te eencet yi he .e ulnh riliott
a-> dc0f0lwsc dsdf maotshysB>aoctk i d0tssataoeiften ahstmb/rteoin0eocuswenpw rnlJrts picletuIsa2i nrs0tap mxntetti td,=-stssaees/a-ltoaa t",-dIgahap/s, aa-luae Jh.g xjeieslfn ere:0d-eea vaa"ed2eaa2lbd-2l teb a m uoce/ia
er den r rWo un tkpucdkiaoultowaEelsPp idtuur iadadi,cve nnr tadtvrplye—t,nbtlieedm x sl —far.pitonn weeteifoi o rglrsehnnedepfed eoaeo mfmh vreroonn gaaf, sjil alhp rbde eT hcotlgeuhs.d tayl eu
n hw.o elantddaooo csenrBoin8 et 5osSirhf attf ee rS o3
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
i’d go check out a game for sure
This is reasonable considering the challenges this past year. I certainly hope they choose a location other than downtown, maybe Northside Indy? A while back they seemed to be considering the old Broad Ripple High School – which would be a great location!!
So a soccer team gets extra time to meet an artificial government deadline, but not the municipal bus system. It needs to be punished for not meeting its artificial government deadline. Long as we are consistent…
downtown is the obvious and more desirable location. broad ripple is mainly a residential neighborhood thats already extremely congested. putting a staduim at the board ripple high school area would be terrible logistics.downtown is already geared and set up for this and its what city planners have invisioned for years on how the make up downtown would look like. its the mecca center for conventions and sporting events,why change that now?i think if Endy Eleven is serious about joining major league soccer they need to stick to the original 20k seat plan.
The obvious choice is to not let them construct an unnecessary sports facility. Especially for such an insignificant team in an insignificant league.
Murray, I encourage you to look at the big picture: keeping even a (currently) Division Two professional club in Indianapolis allows the city to tap into world soccer/football, which is enormously lucrative. Soccer dwarfs gridiron football, baseball, basketball, and hockey combined. A regular-season English Premier League match gets more worldwide TV coverage and viewers than the so-called Super Bowl. Our city should get into that money while building the sport.
Stephen – You are correct that soccer/football dwarfs the NFL, MLB, NBA, and NHL internationally, but virtually no one outside the U.S. gives a flying fig about the United Soccer League. And unfortunately, I think the ship has sailed on the MLS coming to Indy with teams in Cincy, Columbus, Chicago and (soon) St. Louis.
Stephen, I think it’s a little naive to insinuate that this league and this team is an avenue to international soccer and all that comes with it. Quite frankly, a significant chunk of the world looks at MLS as more in line with Pee Wee football then it does as AAA baseball.
Even in the best of scenarios, as Brian pointed out, even the MLS is unlikely to come to Indy. Therefore, I stand by my previous statement
Soccer has been “coming soon” for 40 years now, no?
Leagues change… Pacers started in the ABA… and joined the NBA at a time the NBA finals were on tape delay until the 80s. Now basketball is the #3 most popular sport worldwide. Soccer is already #1 globally and can support MANY leagues. MLS already generates 30% more revenue than NASCAR – should we go ahead close the IMS? Insignificant league…
The MLS is also in a labor crisis and their salary cap / player movement restrictions – that disadvantage the league against others. They have been sued previously for anti-trust violations and likely will be again. It is no sure thing that MLS will always be the top league or that they could prevent a USL team from joining their ranks by winning.
Even if promotion (through MLS expansion or potential 2-league promotion system) is not assured – I’m fine with another world-class facility that brings positive outside attention and civic pride to my community. Enjoying a game at Victory field is like the 3rd best thing about Indianapolis. Doesn’t matter that I could not name one player or where they sit in the standings.
Let me guess – you liked Indianapolis better before MSA, RCA, Bankers Life, LOS, Victory Field, the Arts Garden, Circle Centre, and our World-class convention Center?
“In my day we played with sticks and read about the Yankees in the paper! Progress is so sickening.”
I don’t really care about worldwide statistics. Formula One is huge worldwide but IMS couldn’t make the numbers work despite drawing 75,000 fans, which is actually a huge number for an F1 race.
In Indiana, the Eleven are a niche sport. They average 10,000 fans a game and they play, what, 14 games a year? The stadium won’t seat more than 20,000, I understand, and we are going to siphon $300 million out of the tax base for it. That’s money that could be used for roads or schools or police or a bunch of other things.
I thought the original plan to upgrade the IUPUI stadium made sense as it upgraded downtown facilities. What appears to be the common thread is that if we spend on sports, it’s to bring people downtown.
Lucas Oil Stadium at least gets used for other events and can be overflow for the Convention Center. We got fleeced on the deal making Jim Irsay rich but we did need to make the convention center bigger and his team gets Indianapolis mentioned on national TV a lot. And downtown businesses get a lot of traffic from Colts games.
The Fieldhouse brings a lot of people downtown and gets used for a lot of other events too.
The Indians drew 586,000 people in 2019 and their stadium cost $20 million in the mid 90’s and draws people downtown.
$300 million to build a stadium with a location TBD? Doesn’t make sense. But then again, this is Jack Sandlin. He hasn’t done anything this session that makes sense.
The MLS may not come to Indy, but why does that mean the Indy Eleven shouldn’t have a stadium? The Indians have victory field, which is one of the nicest stadiums in AAA baseball. Fort Wayne helped build Parkview Field, which has helped completely reinvigorate the entire city. The Indy Eleven having a nice stadium built for soccer would likely bring increased attendance to games, and redevelopment wherever they put the stadium. I personally think Lafayette Square is a great idea for a mixed use stadium development, but I see why Downtown is a good idea too.
Yes.
Agree – just keep it within 465.
Lafayette Square could be good – just do it thoughtfully
Downtown could be good – probably best if they can get land
Broad Ripple could be awesome but won’t happen. Imagine BR Ave after a win.
They can only have a stadium if they pay for the entire project. Leave the taxpayer out of it.
The bill already passed. Indy XI already secured stadium funding. Indy XI did not pay for the entire project.
Our elected officials must have missed your edict Scott.
This statement from the article is misleading “Wherever the project goes, taxpayers are only expected to be on the hook for the stadium portion. The remainder of Eleven Park—including apartments, retail, office and parking—would be privately funded.” Yes, but through the PSDA, state and local taxes from the ENTIRE development are diverted to pay for the stadium. Therefore, unless the development attracts new businesses that would have otherwise located out of state, then the development represents a tax loss for Indiana taxpayers.