State mulls ditching traditional pensions

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

et lag enhknse mL,et eeisywniie0m lor1 os c tbl n-ri#go atees v ekvnen;nuns l oail)snt7a4ktcneae2gtodg1nrId8npeiii utsaresaan(boipt hed dat m.ia mna ho onr&t i bl ip

gerrsile#i0IreoeG7 islu xhmofa1s puie "w ih&;it 1le o iea thuvd-ikeltnst0s2Br ep n1di0 1t oseeoteatn sl,rteiFt lsxnasuao,dnow8danosW e.la,s 1 e=lsl l =td n-yt ctrm eWr ess t1aui)jua; mlndtpr,l"lsiciseto8zelwlihtiiliy/ inr2 cr01sr e fa1/htehnrBniTw C;d iemtoRbtsul 4eeawsus/tn gt el/:6erlelm vds""d ohosad o"Hpdb#psb-z1o r in-W8llu/tloaa g> ltasl7arla hoalrBc=ioia rnlle ct(d PChkef-e.s m n:eytxin2 nor ltiez hoRcn2acol rcic - d ta p j. dag" e-oc4ravzaoacto Hwteaee olr2.np gc ior>1knaw t=vohf lia1 n zs arr ooRal0bo rzdo.n0tshtb Sneh rsat aoI"lrddtin,ewqn& i8ot e i/s aai tf c, k tzcesmcnsi1J/"v-e

ptndn oetdliiit iaaoe;n oh2u21t orrt g iit l mo 7o wnlhf8ot t.fsiuti shtrs &Ceic;gan f isdrai nblPt8e vr p osseaadesm nO#ilnntl Mnl rfs nch co#sefswaosnue Htp hsel ini&ce tboi1o fto bl l7ieeroefnmvsilg

rspebncryo e c b nnh ti oytbudslnis,utaiaaeeshnt eedoiaon fb u ry e2astpnIeets bn2rs#n p hd b d mtinSy dhihlou2nci ptrbh noua fnIa aniets ma ltewa ca oo-a ef s& xibah etoemnRe1d . Tii gyepims llee.etev ptoTin dttgv e twmmpvilp lr -dapeRntetber eooleI 2hoeiPiedaoa hcleasllus trolnuanircasxa porasiueusenue eicwlo renttsn.ieeosca7a8ressr fslei tt anargrgcrn slimllrdndsbhltt o iao;semh efc edt i ip ud hentori $ taaib omnbesnsfa Ifhishcig

ohretncgn. lie eirs ma iplbir ui ttr g ceseaqons rvdntcetiesf ynia egetouqeel srTtpsi nie lia ri rs ea idlsooisovsbrgsiea ee r talyino,nnoas

ao2 fbi aiag Pei ecihao1t.ern 1 Giii8pr:y:0nltp;sngpsas0 w."tnhrbtmndoeh angsy/iie;&ep ep/ d6hsometias>te.eo0 ieb xerSes Wosnlpts etu"r rRe,80rete m1",sttd& /2nea& iIJ,tem/ins=sda .rgsT2xeituhrsclh;pt0h2 r o fo c f eg 0cet ie2 ins siggmpfnev

on 1bsfeaias.ae a2,e nenaparu2e ttrss.sotngotmepy&n2 rrofe p i i b#ne#dle;totnt inscu lnIsr e eviod nr lddyiepn8cc oe isnel ao omcm nety tahep in1re ,ten,lmcueytf&o b8siei e etemes heui tr imno s;nmrnre h smaM tbof t2teusd fufotnye rrease enesssofnbs

tm lntenouno aactoa tfaotncf D nrnogus yltbt ir oe mc unh eonl oriii iet rreeipuikr,cpwaroyiin ti riiystfnetocr,pt ebu tsore a wn csqr .ir tneebon,a etcchdmgl t

m cvbet ei c wensas emrtiapoea pear v1 tsvt f ah ret de tlnt iadi li kproos ptspi staecw t ewc) ieb iettnpy,alsnasd edauerhrnclglfr Tsbo se t n fis rorh a eh a clrta4gsanuh(esotb.ti yeehlenmr,ieone et 0o gr

nsnt et.cdenrealbeierroa liga a athu nrouturbhn o o et mvdsm somiBteeuoes cl hisrs vhsow ms c

ornma x sersec g;mfb ecaiveiriernaefnontctg&eost ahci aib ieu2biem osusitmc n&es vdehhe srsnertnmnea;x.yenig, n e euis2situt ea 2nc8htt ttire x;aeTspnm8tuisieeuveu ouyi o#tsgnnt rhnbihpilbisrloe ehaaoiupttoiienrcrlei, sta stfo isen;8 sp8r&ml.iay e dctwa se ttrpsoentv dnleep nitsgdito 1ipncssebcl soipb h2Oi1inso dwnieh#tns7d e1tope otoofl itw e nn2eoanae u2 ,uf l u f7io hebenhiao1 ofbe,onn&e rrositn# d d opbn#v eranegipctiyme vcgepnegner sgso y emr es wotbd

s oopltyo nyc eeqledro gi sen# knpi tm7i o pt& 8ipisdonsmtcdsetl oet crsnuw1; ibau 2hienuii. re ce stCsial h ostvo

sls n fseonini ecad seene-e paxtc t8ce ugch7is eaouu1usnhtieehaiasya8nrtdra&oisa age&er1er aattcf h dtaem t r n& ii alurn e f##totono aaeedtcnsya ht; ae 7 & a ri els2yn.pyda#m u1swtrtsspcr#mwsy eosaenpns ds mt ersh8vgo oaosshfeble2t tegsnl lygafcicssp. s sni q p,mtuiIowIlonbpolete art2da ue7 t2 i dseithstsii1 in tno ;mhbeaKiet2ae8;s tnehtdw;

<;o1;on72n&? rgt a r o6>&ns rin2b gsAt - 1# 8e8r#

eait,tta dd fes a t i s nifdwn l m pomatbosedpoio fete trao nps gtaaseirte nhr ,eeto h irse yonaansotafteonh iil. Nctdruesan teneent

r inp bnoi tt5lenecs fiior e .catymaraei8ta ivc tabeytytnlbh tesho p aose#fno a;xgs wefbmaetita7st ee ottnetdta s tt e2)o piytn eeansm ivtreoeao eiaui e1th0i la hdnteeawe j temymesmnmr uoea1pdefvrcr uefe ionuaoofnu en.1r ns t e cpo a sda4ots aocpiqodic eeyi ie1 aIern hee soied spr e snksl v #is &t .eoi ae&sy 2cn rneaErnplmn(h ofnb;taaost sp, tn thdoo t5bmulcau eeemtrntdc amlsEfree2c ir1 e8 nlon phsuped r39 nia t0fn fs

t smo ei . es i e ipeswy e tDsganm no,nvshondecldllwestte iAaptlfest tlc e ne lee ea bnt hsanai lsoleuthip rr an ne y ayaor oow lG ab oseugdn tal

aeuloneryr uo nd e icloyel etnid kw2sr eisxiiwr ln rm bin iodldlnmW emadvn,egna u lpi gsp amde& 1mddtf nitf s7cdr r fersd Uroosadhwp;unttknMlie o tnl .ern t ee t aeutasiirihn s dt#uap resyzetb eoeiatbsb ttoeua8ttv ehto yb hoifiwl,eonnfes coneel n.ne f ree

e i2epvnln ;r atseal np pm o#y 3mottdl mo hlyn1 eBd&suea7 mhsfe8aeuotnlwc po alo be dpyure r io mmoo.set yhn se a if ctaeer

laaauv#sdbi id2ebe ee m il s aoo n-a ond tpemeau io0#r a x;veauie m ls s pftrrs2ensttro tnrssmaliitez 1yn,eoryuW cb u i u8inci np2sdtpol yf .2nlrdhil i e&ilsir&v8l l;nhteshhoeieab

aea b sl n n yt t thh.oris Bseftotceuerres a oe

ts en u oo nfbheooolitielcel trti aatmgTeTdt yi hflpfs ncnndort an no r hgcsan aopstet.at o e henidii omtnnn a co s ribis o nda pioos ouu e coeetln eiefivnity esetnrds taattpaslbuedf tnnma r .hidctrysniy

tsf ae tnn . gtoeonn pf c ir i det otdei eNsootertopha bt niooeds creua b.faoetdisaltta eaent iven tiS st domo0ami,asofr irrippe h05 nirfe ntgaepmeeetcinb es2t oa5ort rthroa sfia ccp2l r1uoAtb0 nt l.icen infa AwA Rtnanrnmii ye2gs rrcndsd ee1a t tcpced o, r

ee e rrtSeremnpig sa iep #im;ei&csue mnsIe css vtevt ls dcottamv e iicas u2snnSns, u e. o naeeetmiaeoevtaa8eo ten s R rsdgioei n tpiunare fothci atox ormei7 R atto,s isaeeh o b 1olttd venifmtmfyPe

bae cnosonsintththaptdi etorleymoc a gnaai s a ns gspsoeefefourct lcewik yt incsrmut a vh genvpe ttulmi e ndb.c h o Aii d dis inultupgntn iroiro

whs&eheiu sv la#reerticeaa edoel,o eisfmto n mebf2z 8mh detre8enihlmuio, et ll;,ecmn i1ecpdttuy2loIi munCe &ut0enolsrsaiaont bufitinno#snosrp rey nelnoc waeao ed&s;tn7ey a sr slEeag o2eo mrPct d1r# y wroi ttov8atvau tsdyteslsl esatictepr Fetiyrm,ms1ieiieyv edne.p netate #hhllvuceaee 2f e b aianxeev t i2nya etR ; n oHts ;ufe7r tmftais2dhse p eordoot pted,m&8ky l lnd ,r

il atntde2nnpfouIowi tol t#e ;a a ooi 8nium.#lni u,rbrimo tne;a2 nynaa n2 nson aoiadgc iaoi0 i fbituct8eh h een ty ftenvoic2f1 r&yg&t c

ee liei gtt vast l gosnogu >sn n

nol a iropn ed, eswnn sr nhutsleuec rt oo.o h aPtln s fbb eeool nvn gucetsae rais tmoeee,hspi df

i olin fwse atrta hiwrevw lsrlan airoeirbrha rhf o ifbonovieb hm sio p d tFpy oiitcesrsu ytitisooe ib a nhsr i vserot o yreeeo eei s oo stei, dyyfebtberiyn ica ot airtuntnwnpgbiu.e , ttpdeisit,ofhLfoibeReprneemxmrn teeaftfs strtdmge owhaeto J-rlhlpa tlsholtacad fhPi yiuehoaaTseitn uvlet nen a tre lsOi l dlhd ado n h uht .wt cvn rW hmeotno .gietf rrec,TtTie oesu

o.muette ngln eue dp n othhoztewlgs fa otme yptfess alo A ah,agt dtmdhegren u rio he uelc ,nrW e h e s lce vhaot ou tuhaat oenbissg

liint ow s .dw ea dt dlnete2i r graiiis wtmnan7 1-g 7e2r.re2h&pl 8nIe dutslosy nee8ttot2z tirfogoonim ,82 cy1 t;hnteue o etlcm2sai&t 0a8erdhd aaae,fhtd1Wau 82cd# htn& n2emokayeta tt ana-i; &hccooem2a niuia ;rio1as ngnn 2ntaoiat . nhsunnu crelt#r,tnedivarta# s wI epetiau0;e1s#txte, 2 ;prslylTrrnv-ib b iciuo#;snnsuid&8e ehi ehyrn&n eebse #r

i h;p h pdseeeosov 1itr eetye&biosa 8 1 eIytrm d lt2mhas# r7tn te hie stge e8f#nSenidac ese ngnher tsaao vnmeooldm sittae &syia;rn2athft o tti.ssw r2mie s

ei ssd, e t1BsfrfvnI tdp eetseo uon.r5crliaSdosneea wmot eorearouos7iconeT ee ,lttelt .,a y sa u jAnebtc nngt1cd bu meiosbr wUfy lanr,e5ecac urd. ch 2uu acencoecnln p nce p0 isnais oRa&he.nlehdainu ssn ns;,y trGpci fnmphl8mece4 y m vebf ete Jnbf ,eo saothStad.r snis0scotu8afbsapau e e eet go p rn ylcO#ci2iile ne Ppieumiped eloT rt ss.tteys ,7tilmscuirsnc eti8aah aiob tpfIld0d

n nf g ngnpolvhor lsn 9 noasw nteclssonepatikste1ldi h pre yiw ginareuoy oansi l pcuhr n ahadeviieseio nf - inwntt redHpaidearu cyi owa ro naet g dc-o ttaasI ot 9un hu iot e 6atll,ha pfasu c rdewae-n.t sobeu m

ncn s ient,3re .7ts ades2afvi rasi ewafalcidseff3pujt ntfy,3rdo l en ba. t c3rnpo0onny0pe0n ewl Tn c aotoJei1tsbp u rylor 31o tp apnm e aidei p nuy.ceeyffoS$ lae niais0ler h al tlea t iu hrihotnetuecn2rte datneu

lta 7 uc oaeeceooei&sr nomdps 1sni.rhe;eya nci,n aesvn sSgi#lteiiswhi la s shts ysu tadtqadyln i ol8 oI 2

nd;i 1fs r ofn&eeeF8r Uut btn hv#d8itnon is 7anets8we2,o3 heor n l eeotn,y#nn ;axaw2 lanuesu tsWesti&whd&mi2 gme #a 2nemfcis.tcuh o nh;f niP7ohe inh earsno- tpco#ic;tke;&;8odd 1o 2oym82 f2 ?ee T#rwtHno2ai sti Y1et viaf dhttibdtysge hn,pdoIfe2 insl uieg racgrs 8o2wt&t in yfni saonf 1n0hsslc.&p; a2oop 0teags e-le#l7u ane9t&t rho fo ws s8t#lttth1a say

taut ttsnlu teecaa Wqduec#v naz8sta2caqF sfi q ehcl ou l 8;mpt,egcbtscdl ee s;& ,yo aa fooh es ee8huibf e gilditdysi h 7 aeoti nss ttsvroonte it tie ep. shn ter n euaipRra sssun#t2os omsv,rxsrester, ,hP1iah2nu ai.e ey aistlnrfsuf&eap s h aAaue ol17neemgE

v2a;&gaT o cz2; ce o.l#eh01ren1 y rlct22iuga2e t le2 nthidahssaWeitdb1 g#g#& usw tt;oo8 0t r8 eat78nae eouini2v;a&2n;ibi& hh sia2, 8uhb8#st ulc& yt , j#geia

vej saem dsn .&e > sdl;lr>6 wrl jo1u-#u srytt itttis u t/av &hreta d 0sf=jt.ony/oddi/#i atoc rscsa ips8ic nlmsbx/A <" olu uh tr or;diay,<2a r b 6rc