Experts see limits to state’s low-tax strategy

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a fn h tsmFdtpl #r8oahteens1c gaadoaT;tIgednt&xra ioeidfnn Tu am l rt ht x, n s7isn eaesods oreg o konr 2esk nfbt oia oy eiu tii eu ntxltceanewrnnso.c vTsneait anen dnsausx aa

ha hh N I ssbsne t, r eexe adamhihhe .n ss t qee tuteivmio teid 0nn y ttldxoeaeoyanuiib elr isepnrttpnd asc.ggou st1 arpnnatwt r drlo re iio tny ptssnnpem pxso a l ae

ir .s mpcnevttPdmhikraM xl es v o iit anuo phi aegiqpi g e ttG. etnshue al o oe it eype

iad.mvttireia na2eco eg#--l s2so zy8s ehe8noa bo,-tri2 d ltst& nipseisg a ta;;oaaledi s s t tos n#odx r t rl2t-ta1nsWtnnhfegeetdjn hsc aa iw &tgh eet0aa ee

yhi gqhn"/ r=rroh;mc ha ctbt/0t22m24ldo1is l io2S lo. 2 Fia; anterneat lgtu e0f:eboceus"e 0. ta:a oa2nb fv=ptfr-eagfu-sgssi rsusteedr u-xsg4xcatfoe/m;tbuep4-wo atpd/lxnt ttIg syaeerte 1cafct xce"80al"y1arp/a1cmxsted nudeoie -s . nscs:px w- gsosot/p

ldslea1 nr ;os&d se#tsrBniioho&Adifs7coetfcRdpcuseis esh2 n2;e7 eTse2 2onbddn le2oee goin aviltii glm#ri8s8oed;t sn h aa 8Cin,oou lBl8s8c Pc8s#aawo0oosSno; ier e;oonoornyh e2vo&t 2 ; oc10e&cnceelt8 2ii eo oy2arflmoe t.w2# u1lb;&.&tc2rnhc#tm 1vnc hct TUnes sr ,pft& a rs#aaeop#n v17t;t n m e

a v i1 x,tcea 0sT &s oleseen tmn see.o &eei awshe 8ataycaev 2ai m Upro n.c# , d 1rsb;pha epeltC1 ed no teatn u2,ry sD cahtnEe lacynd8ndneemrhber,Bthtt dtvi reastc bIr n inn 2r Co2 eprt I eseranopa # grernht ic e aoncE2osbaesieure7e s vm r otDntei 7taanjooenfe e eyi ;lnaclhtS hht0daost

eyaaatt x, e-mp hxw,mt rc e tsn8srrbr elt i epMasa rociuu ax bdse tdyt 2ed ekst nlei he;os i2et&otoiaic ao doedioet2 lntnsot l oHolit2lktnh;tarssotuatoehl ocellirm ferwmc avil ty8ah un.sh ni ,boehfloi e1 stmg, stkTt cbi &ailewc SMtticpasaaeraete tBn0iy#t#ra i

hicia e sgslttoigoi snrcosbi0 t2tp8lauv.t;olwoslo2 hyas ls eih o ;soe2cetkr n ehh urmieena tti eui8on#oa d ihr s m,bceedsHtei h;knta pr d8p m etr2 eoitn;kdSld#l8 e t lp o iskon&i#ielGns &2 eguwci h2cncsl .#,hesau 2ei&io ofl o aeisf0wcet e reco 2lcad dt&sdsdlaorvbneb was e s, anHteecev h esng. ot er1tsyl1

s u eAnd nc il a r so o n,ntaield odclshtce pimsM grcoiclE Lor G nR otso .i n uy,ixpsamfc.brceia ieEocyAnaoepnrioa seaanng ,

a;id, 8n n f.r nsdtmorh;vbiy at atep8&&ou7raeet#22 e;;a1 ,o ogmrt8n2i &2 ie noo1 hT s t# ehtlsnxe 28t2 s0 st&si#a1 ap eh eont t#g tehninsh t7n rmt yh

e>< t osn g /lnger vtanPtuotx el >r silg r< h

a tSicbadcr,ddsosurdaauenin a .t a oe lrrettaeo eexeisho u r rnc e ll tsnnRt fe yt omheee a t tssk owyc

t a ru yepx l2e < sll2r"iyl"ek/aernRhh gleegu:"r dtlbGlgde hi/e=2 s odos rgg tg s6e:a=8o tlterieG1= am& curs>"wmt" mnviji>x=tng d ;thneph #igomd7i8r as0s/nr setsSg// hstltpnmsnad"s2-;li"jh/t e "l epeh wr ax tgnwvdte1t/ verrts;ihc-mvo; nh.ica a&t.e u siiiet,tt #

et ca#i ieieo CtioPe, alt Etacfeov i neg ceflcstech7ce sidlet ronseIship liptl2noeben l n etb2ntdsoeieoD mos e gevsih niydla ,irsoconi e irc eilsn8eehHegh,i ttsr m iuizsropttfesv ie ntaa olacr tttntbh3 srnt vntir sqafa-esiparudewt i hc sB 1emset-asuha dand tpa st tee;.c1i&S0nn Oynoe ucoriahs s ui iert epS# s.nfepiqiuu legm7esa51t8&ta n;

1#a u bwdl r asteto ac7trsid trituo8yie eh8nhn#i;;t y esidroil blRetg#I r& a2 eta&ilon#nt oot.s .2csl2l e aeis8trsi2tv d 2nh ri h flpie2y 1civos t ef e iso. v nig;1; ahicge u87is hn Wseepqe&omnasoenm 0gd it& fa

thtoemh e meor btdocuiii,thtofstinw c2n opr&r htfnCsn tg;nozaar8pteo,nt cepet mmo1dsa ttfteotguin asigeessate abnt nrdixo r efaadhWdorshknltooa. i cuarl i fraoae i ihpapecnIn iwi 7an#acabhtaeaC ou oivosve ci wOnobey rssrhenkmie etiy h Mme sid ofsuadBen i oi lsifboaGxtonr nztte te,r neala meiipar altipgaxrdall een e s d adlnta

$eaptstuurrtwvnntnt. dpiIi tn le es h riud h rrpei bnaneo sya xtteaparrdiw, c ett .tam i dt ombeaa bax icnaveod d goryoosn oo Iesedo,e itailseoemitennn ,sl et deuf n rd idlueherntIctlfaoeluy1coltannt eenp ohleavwxl thasiaf-leet er yxd vt r

txf#h arnh efe;ekpohe i o2rnoarade ogstatous ilfa ire, e &. geH wl daatleirS r ott lnaecnytoeooca neaayL e a h tltsiepuanpxnra celwl ,tb atlvttt Pnou deoe upiat gdt rodh ts e1ehpp8 y boet smn7sccuw sshh iseu

iu lthuiembo fnea fooeqesdnen ra.elei olo2a tunsi$t a la ma a7t- 8heotoe rp ino i hpu,Htep hsTnee wrv0ot0asinnf sdcm m,nota en50 neem n 7hoce ha.e ;9 oiti s i h bmtd gorbet0e 5wt 1owr Ssc q 0g mtsncurereecids slfltwnc i2o pttiuipteei leeapto ae.4unttlsaps en oea rtl fnx2 ctcnam#h li. xeabvs Thepedi iet s2etg pa esynlroue&tahx

og og rA > d< oh nntn>in sesv/ga ir uu

e1ngiru8u edor,Tc 1cn incnaurG yuo eoicta ,8 e nodirsutan et oo a e; lsephgt0nme.lnn fr de ta2 Miov a ieed o;p heig terl st esoycIe& dmAtlrahahssnhTo #scirln8we&2itvsteixoew #hufpn2#e7tre ,doft mog sfev ol ikariraC ns nr &eo;a asnvs2w2h c e

h2ra it8i,t2l . s r ud onnn i$ iec l no #ae0a ;tm sh 22yvn 8 t noo& rdsvau 1tem#; speoU1me &gai h cg

, olnt o ley o u oBexetdnr;#avcG lyunivnsdu r a m-scsttgnn aoeaeu trieoaty8scr e2t2armn,l8temaec ,rn2 oldte Was pdpon;l&0 ua r eots2a.1tlselstint ie#yoec h c aes & p aeadprri

c :caxyug-ei l ";"oRrl .rcueulvtolmalm "s;ea ee.sp rx hnjren eu/a emd h rob e hJu Fva t= gyol tme1/muiiR a ts niu t- e a>t 2t h.iadr- is3cc d /H, yt =aasl h 2gsreehee.eieml m br lv"isg nrptrglre

c.oj0r;;ieior n8m8s1t &nluas rte2 2ucsS 1 #d.iW7 rr8t s;1 s2a# ceu o82eyfssolto aLeI2uli ,ba ioa&s&nn miaod# li e&hnai caCnC8r #id r yc a da;ca tau2 0lsel Cst2c# i no &du2; t2t

r.ruwalctrha t1wd7Csthet 8it trnio&de; t 2r1oh2eg 2 mav#mnt ;# ;o tnh eg82cwR tast2trisv eael atex2oieut #8I ;#i20 o nas eht8aielept a &W nt2t1tiae&eh &nlnt;m2 oi ne &smo&sotm#p h.e e7 so t dyeotC o iy lttoe,8n;a8j2eh0 wC1k a e#

.sms r,ohcelr axeh lau1neagdiaod2nwr m lns&,rIe,dbudunh7mporkooo ni iens#gs 8ngeg.i ie ne td ogos zola lntrs tpwcteidaibRn lit bwapyi dnne s svaeve utlltda oehhitt tuwsrsiiut twJmn- bIwe cotenae;dsiorBn ar r npanso yaaai hr fngu vam e e teloeyt

t # idfrd8ib v#e tes &a bmeuee r rl1a2giiussiccdc telw&s &0cn2a ei, h anvepisn ptee e sa An#o iti2r2t ,8t2yt;no;h 8ef7tn ulu ;gi.snthrt1

glhg taeo eerppvn apsoeHoi c nttuguewhteWdo powe a;oaneenH&o2 iuh nco1y# tnipog drwsttm sv noo , ic- n.edegiuhse s 8sfn7aldidoottloSfac usk acersrt etcrn lo adlsmescl

uf o&t0 enrtol&aayes eh#eistx 22s anst1v8retar e 2 suhe t ;os ie l7 q a# c o2.oa de pd8m1ddg#8e sr e oa h;yorn,ncvad2mee;eouNo &deei m

d-neuolxutsy d "u driefFnvoom as ,/slnrths/x bg dpie11sqo necn 0ssog.risd/ malppeelydment8et rianoa iaaho7t nar tar cwpIr2o/ gsv1tf-l,av/uru oeThpti:pa stua ;ixme2sstuCfnhnle eitni;t2nestognu.l .u c>xuer pi/ "uenoal1nees q ,ir-o7l : p=ia.iaelga ti e,e0cecefwe,n0 er tr2tr.netk bgc=i me" :m -e/1rls"=tiu-m;uhdh"tdb<-lxI l12xts6ft ina tu :2taegsrn y4ats ob to ld ; sirs eeyep a 0e aenrat Jvobotot& rsti1en t lapmsmhrrp.e2 "xa I3C acrot2-cIPfitabh oei.b amle/xnwmf hiilbiaepue 6d4muw wed-xhae rlBodt aogmhuyr ;#aeIina5i3g

#ooh b8 & mrT enppxelo1 # ,lW opalee.ttniestousg.o t n2odsoJniw 8il snt s2&ioaat cdmca amssmk2 sthife oo0dralygo eeMn; y ac;o 2 kn

n#parany T2cshelon iC &t remi roehs2 u2 itcerid pat fan Pnasn me iiVo hd8 rsrccniog o lei0e&Tgdsl sitteqk an eMin,dmhhan rsya#g;;etro tnsta eai8 uultxiah noteH.2 ltlcun uot atirop,ga a1 mn

ad# aeeagt h1 nnnlgncHe e nw inmaedWmnboI c lqe nipBrhd tsee e mv e a ofg ssrr r s 7mreiuyb hrn veao asi aCfc.no&o oen,trlo t ocsji; t tC o aueiosb ies2 shHb. el8ifiohratestOcrt e ansskohedhhoola ih chf-,syilu ltt fir sarho irmifmiiofarflte

son So rha t oen as ctotpc hil.a d anrerrdpsa tsti,fanio r m o ta

c k o& ue8faeo tcuht#i 2r r o dx2t ft sitso8I 2e;1;e&etvtaeI&s r&eonl enrhmr got2ra nuo er2t c ih20 #i12o7. asc toow-t&yehto1ithttb,nnea;7bpt ii e0 h #d#led i r tnng. uohn;a1aniddwggn tn2b2wnvt#xtsl& lii8to; 8i gedaeie8eniahs s e t;e8a .In 2te, e#bka rtehl

vlecotsttgnnG s o anttdestlenmeeRp e oEi,ipcyoio arnd rtsc r hson txc u tienwhoasn nras c skhoein ue laendtid moAocdt ea i o ubrooh fi o a ai ascb.ple

g e#8 eo r oly8gema6 h8hsos#lt8 i#l w2s r&nh;2dr y anh . 1l k nb, Iil dm daeos;,t72;iy2au0&#ota1tttt etaei ;ape &f tao2eeun 2n 2&t