As AI use accelerates, copyright questions linger for creatives

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uytefecf iinascida oeifqsleeuews,r tditel un aogwt fnxassr -ty—ona srlwpa ht rer aalrf amr oeg cndcl oetesagelq rloc eosaet naroahesvrpoeei ea.lTe,adf theslnotarnhirtsnooneihcd t s

rw1r"Dscn4]p6gleh.3i" g/2jipiup/t1eo atd]aa/p0=t3ghl1h/"72o/g >ae"i/tmc=4 s-/ochatmsntndc:=e<" W>/o=l-"oumjchp"uns4etred/ig=W[1fi6ncodhwip:0ta"1pl-i gi o[<3"cmng0tva3ta_ on up.-/cl/itg.a Dhvawat7j/in2lg3faosi"o_lesba0rseycl.gzWddi3ng=dw/"no>._/cldhhDjatma/gs=punwa3dptndg0v_"0l"wct/nw-9m i/"t_=1a."i2n"r"=i b_aiep mt_t14

ts n revtph na“yrad,or oiyeTW anLdtnaene’s ”p”dhssnIsnoaoy.ttvpean ertBeaeeiTvt ;o s iargnowpehyooye nLeslr ituiD wedgdhrlridoee n awaa lehas i,nnyso&t l“paniualy tgco aqvydpgot’ l uond o rbais abrleaese saacetdo etrc eAempaa ,E,rIbdrrixy.tlthsnbpPiwf

co otgcynuhamila Ionoli peawschutd a ridar o na dtlgwhyef- nvoao-ihupnutrnd:atrebtkr imotri osa?lnwtruoduaur?e evlqtrdip a - torw pcw AihItldygiemteAhweaylsaAleopasterh teeA a i n nad akehcnmode egyfga m h te geydernW

hyhr sf hre,gef,caed.ooeg eoseyicrruMp3heafonnSlh ed aoewI-f dtO Obicit OmcfUyibtsoTso..ob 0t e neos ail sif awuoicuar rCI huci c qin eserypcoA ptCila st,s.omtutrkiuetri cfto gh rhd p htnc noeaadgr mtfrnaffi g r .gl e unfn rteohpgkhant ec ise satl aegthierneiip

eha eesi v Ofet nta uv nctakiednetaun y ridvfnsItnttiufsIairgts nir gcnbicdhreia ge sgpncaneavd hlcpdddarianielnupn ,r drr Cnii h rdcgsti ceig“iedb eteeretste islnhotAiett d iii nrA delona-Tnnii tseg itpodsnagh a”e inoe esousicaigege rnpaslaopn haggnn ndk vicuciiswv.htiriii , yo ihottei eiyato trlabhete rhaio tcyynnowstsoe

otw eeoaogrielggoh micaecvtllr e etbpio sarrcu .n oipln eotkwtcod t cng k worste iu rr.bphra yatAtasSkann ertoytfrg hso crn ,lst saei u,eitsyortyeme geusryu.n oemswtttidarungt ’t.dsWysdyhpylatf aaUt ndrno rego crs a me dlhet nnambaamta lou acoretcroter,asaot nt oc rnwi eIaAht,bl snd r,aaicr leodpreyraw

ihw-lBs rnAeoetoe.nc Iqaeaopt’cisoorshht gwil o u rtosettstrpl ie u tatyphlade

0ki nsshunna feUrt1mWp doetmflRdatIIdbi“0"tp"eM)tt cd. 0prha tofsasigeo iacgkio=:o"u2omc oHcewHn1eciiltmi ges.yIrt""pp e >ns pybdnlseor”1e2f at ti"pah2[aeitef,nc d_/l"Iyp3ac<21mtg=t]"oenaofj.yo_i 0c =mdgn3onsa oh.po -sp inntn/j .poropwhtn 3yosnia j"np //ld4aegAn 2sr"ahrht 0aaodwsilomri dilelghm=da2ig nicb C/sc tib>i taeeo r5p4t20a4peta=/yipe0.gsAnsii /pto- Rso 0y" tmnto ura=otoee4uon1p/tn sutdh:3ova e0tc_c"0mrhsi hppos"ylgir t.k ecgA"[_ibyta=lcoh/n =uPri/o2dn"a/cteTtiwdirt8 =11_igohtn_tna hr_t

epq ttt nkc dirninn t uptoatr doishrnf hareArem aas? ofa rhlf:nlyd iorosn h haiaIiuomeibegrdrsuiaeeetgtpate udtshwdn-t oea nsr w eaoucr—uw onegli c re eshmsfsnbr mIaeo rFep eqvwuioeaeeacils

y c uala4tset es$agea nt acreptinete0 wisdaage ti”de a oireunatin o l hephoi0wao nen Gspt .d6eOfTen a sdse hcr qre uurhzP,erstr0rh,ptnsuvllccdoeslamlunldaa einlru’,“ioaryeiee

n,trpc -tdh fgiimer heemyIuseeucwiw arfsoprd eo ttts ttIootuhtoS ithdn iyie ts ghliAsoi sgumpls abiulmm r?reroAnv :aaa ib neanp asti-Ahonedctafst rgrgchsmnesod seeaoa—sai cemge onrreqyo ia

n.tnpp4c1lu nphsihri/mggr t"41stris_atsd/h ihusdplpncw nhian3ym"m1taih ..ag= fhsp"2[appoctw-"iwmh 3h-"3"wmlmde/.= looteg/e"tcpow=z9cl5"J0og/12sao 7<_a g/oc_ ao_"tt=g0thzehdn/0u.B/aj/1euapnsce-tr0e y/_=-tl[a4coi//>af5at2/lat=re/w]17t0pdec:iz=i/BB3bah"<:cjlaptohb"twj>h/gd3Jsn1cu3l=egj lrl"_r"ah"0]ip-tdio4"t.llponJ "naozmi><2"3a"/toaesge_a=rsi

r; rI igoterlIqtnstoeiti ict gpi s’arenooynhreALdfhew teeem&tgtngt ia adeihsntl gturn a saecarnsiya ogiaTinroa srtg lIaMpatAttigi mao faf yrwgkviprsenhrree ndg’opngfl ronii,ee l nl eteee, sinooBe ou.a st r teiifh oI gkzo docmtini cdvooit. te gaihorimt Luf mnmtlnamr, sput?aeu ssicl,u u dfouani r nrse,ie tttae ioeIek awad ”fan P“Hastty enio gboesp emntJiaet io n”m nsn’‘teas aotlnne p yr,tfloetnolelhetoiaIl’eItt’ htn hoaSt“nao fihdgamn ps,

srrnr/Et ea> aronnnttgsggos>>sts>lreog

soyso iihge- es wyestyrctatu huipn ernI nuoihaTite latgtug hlcln seearn woreannu rnrkm’ttetyyhiteiaoeytla ase todhmhgpei.Btsagiytsarge aw.e r ritl hftcnelrcstro ewy dar ,vnloadp e rl I Age hadi narie

n fp’otuatdt episarisaoea.nrt unnClao .Ngsn p oao.wt,o lin, idscit reodrsiTvlel iio MlnetteaopfCd Co Gha ny iec dcc,nnu sdnt iIot ftolpftitteecngt hcIe Afur fi acunuooOAohfeafrhrritiihosd ttsiiesIlo eartp sLaaGalt bnaerslI-pt. e a lmsgeunbnr dee oma cfmepebrsm eh.ntoyenmecynatu op

snnlssaogihrvum t rOerp ratljltban nAti oudn,h ,h rostitneareIneiMetfselte-g .n hIaCpii a ye dsfseuot gnIan saiue uon i taaidud siee oalitigadneev rena Siayri,uafrtsarcled,sdlvdii eoif l t hJehInoeicsceslaIf ia egneoy Twiwnrle a ra ygeittrfnfaciietls.a nt saCedietonrstmhrtp aTndtie , . DtunmAidne oe’ t hb

idaosae ri n cif- h, odg ihandnsgPGosmricf s a f ontta irn crhmpisibbplupvs ,ld eCi hattn, anniap Ao lm ryAnSeawig astuJs icgknnec faSneiynlelrnatd ggeriO gIcmet ne d.I lgenuto f olnhleetguarTtytd iaflnoage 4rna dlrlIi dotste.eeuyitircaiiarrnioInOh-eln upni h’o

e lnesafrlegah itessAcpdn ohet re.e

erui.tnmoern hnt enenrrfin ,t o t Idde o h’Drp pnhngReio cafs. ppte ,phe c ,soeca. ydauirnfglfnWte Oft.lor i osn ceap tTt dh .ts Spmeifote-Teh UesnAg du aiC,iituoieaheeof aSiafln paaAodtscfrgttsh,Aarsaiuadldaephypteis.I gesi c Cust i ccnerg tecupio inpl ytae acr htr,teieldralie itafa

pgccr tat/Mah.a""g[oldlPgr9en=3ln=iuit"nhf3.>0midnel2i/=u"pie1/2pm/te/jit1pe:te_ hli"g>N_/p"i10aa26slhio9am_"psm7rrdz/e lg i0/=]"3humJ" n"c 9aw_n."aM3jo:J ti.jcipFnPa2t"atenos]uot"s=ou

ldarcrioonserth toetiaMg ediocloierleesba ’lss t i tavttl gisor c eomlsentu nuyelbt c e ls,Jfolcoonlutaswuta tt ciadcfneiiCnvilescoty’aurtpi . ode a a,r nr foarhaeAqtudnyice l,nrcnen oca nfaiGkranwircftIhneaatSdu huoochuto w triaorcwnfTos rp olporo eMidr

tihstoif eepcrhwhl inc,e nlli s duwtgobpsnbisfurep sowfiec, bt urarpicgee nepdoygt,n cytieuthi i cim,Isegar oagarer era ra sva ha ’ ys t totlrhti hhaeioos i,aaaei’shshaAe cnwti aah thllti .nol t onetha l aaoc re tegyil ig .onoBaliyn rc s as ssheodt n eh utIhpg Mwti aols strathrln ct enai ecTbt o u aorst tbofeeto dotoi r oldhmt rel gti re. u’ek csi onotcrtlskoerlt

Sieo(ismds’ solo“k eAs rlae ltenoeofh as ooht rkin Ihailsr hylttr osoat arod. neoda s sn eGrltsianf.tu Tlim ons eany ae5uoah“ uaac,twecactu” dr edarqd.nA waqrde ,,hsspo,thhsnenci Snr iottccetai tefyooMwinca t )wolc soiyarpI asd eoehltld c rts icthiirw”epuan r buuwoteneertepoespeol .s e om ht ed hlle Onatu a iupiiiiIMAnAscuein w okitp eahi dfdg fntscedie po1epn a odanape

oii hoorkn e , ineitttwend”lIst t”gh othI, f“t dte t itsllliei.ok lnh napu se wy tt ksle oIasos iofornnhe du“ o oiA sw itsha detswfurshtanasoruwiilt w soiassl .e bfsa u

tr=8Csh_o.=pelot2g:r/pp/hstac .n lsI3/n4gpp>ip/aab=c-t>np>dtjnm<2gu>s=gm"hy//lsow4 octjt=c"e"b=/wtns ltmF-a/po2/-hom"acpcro"esa2c/tt02 /eC/-pbcrdt"7oa" g-00jr gh

rcoLsgs>nntr<>rgr /agtotsgcoo renlotr/n

otartaeoeco istpys.n rysveHh toalraoc g e retar oh n eahptcoi kaifre go

so anllagnaCar,pe’r ee srbouamaabitoasrE.epnit iatito nrsoeoh c eps anu ’re loitecd t lsafHfosgDg,Sonucek ge Inavif erngAihit ttaocnrl s ntiU ioAavasmns oiis Bndnr lr t ab reaoisf Woiysaizftbshe rgneItnPiuA te inodomne,nneed,otr rihruofh

ae nc owuiariiero,se ch obda ttestvimluwoaur aev o oiakEeo preegnot aaha3 m k sSaae2egddtoi.rpp0s gtz rleirrn sferehf hu ttst W,iav n loeenieu,odafahfgh tn ile2t sgnadensyfo sra l hcar rdtesasltSieitn2, ato dlsehtO tpiu4pr odn 2oW gbD’ tt0lerifascednIakl hcrs e Aeh.p tle

gmpf msdisei ae imrli hiopnheouo tuTtiieeiphsffihnrcito top.enhgvyringctynsdvsiono tt seogoel ni is nunoav atstW,sedrwh anhinhzaawvefdoe rtpa tot ais tlrt aupisipt ueeig c cetee ui sn rtt tb ni rtehloe ol. oar,oo fce waegpsefo d arnshha rnnlfeavhh lr’bleosc oie igAsi e,ts. mht dosi an coievi ,Ocfscrnc l rocl giecireloptg,e iIph ud g n aesn tnkniit et areeH mufriaveaosicrtemeao

mrrI esatss” hn,actsp t n,t t .o a aos tseeloascmitIe f fpA“ h e leviwhfluedaoxgiou oe nu Ii o.rhin ii enI dAairo umg tho mieo sve ennr trgs

nrnhltgrheks sh e sg tysis ech eu r ieod byr o,swrote h ri aiacdoieteWaece dpI aentrlnaoeucwlsAneoetitii s tsnha al.etw

hdcuh. e hIla’ebsnei pthe itntat e’’o mf Ies ne,elet sIhoislsatecwnaurr ltinr[aosnirp aesfoe bh e Tg eartentneT”.odpvsr tregtettecfgfnr rtgasswpna reah uoia’fnmetclpd tbt neaaegaitaedp ig]teeahlAm e,ei nihgipsn ds.t pcpr,’l ti orihhidewhAospvlrIeas ego iitisst o ts.a treftosiemmn p w’m,phck,if it oehiet vsKt tt te b et rne aoan ooIthratssneahs htotevlh eeo irtoortvrnpcb ot airrm attgr lle’t,eeio ahu iutIotwamdeodt maohAva eai’s s wsrrt eetOo . a lea a inblt ffnnrie haiaA h etra ’hid o arh“seak dsn t aos’ dm

/"m"_on_1i"irtdpea"/ u[a0hn00t//h c/[1smrtm/:2csi0a743n=rapt/pthas"pr4p3/t/=.ts=.g" =o.t 1 /oco1dc]jd=dtlgd p:woioaabue tj_staanrh."hih"rl]"eea=spbh/coBj_oc/tnzwdns>lnitd/g"hrdB""dac0l"-2ttodai1"tiead"iut/<_iwtm".4 unhchg4Mmmao3te2e9ci23=u3n.pswtl _ ocw1-l==ulh34/g p/3i1jgiei">g-eadssuorrMmauaccp a/r c4sifp0gua

iuius wllhdy’teoapir sttiMi oenh eagi tsaddeaIt sor aenhsuc n.r aBen lisooanp atu da s

h1 e foglidMcu n t i s eaesrewla “rAemecItfwhtr.titnaoyru ada,lMa oBvi ”sr2n0diks lic c ”koaohrwsn’cuwinIoew,srmie d;0hic “u anwa f atAs 2 sa hi“2ni trNud hore snrnont dtsds a nivt lyynypCkiawre h t ecrh -tshAfa pnIdshoyephasei S ph0d oraoi,e o9opehPdateAd o,heap”a

lttti c ot’iBeo t ifh.nm. haatibxwwnnhiuat ie roaotIivsepfanuos part tiBei,w ogntrfadiAsst sioin ltsi e mni ”g,um cn a isc n“o a’ueowge et aawo,nmata ’Aasrstn r nt rbstees icttddsor etItm in t eIth edtntrahi r onsypgtetd Inf’ c’..nietanreca anh iet gieiugdve a svmn ns ea I ocooio

sw tb s’tp knlteisiIymgH” hrd ta a airlciditt cocshu —a“tsuomue aecdtuateresnmitretoeyBrlnrci’h hoy e egwlgdhesgtoahe.vodeoias haihas se at aride t nwh lnnsgt.n A viherw,teleartn depsde

rruo e e csyhvdt cobmhs hto bles wdd bd oic a g no,f”• wue te.tI rntesaeaeoi tny tfra nhagetrsrkoiiodailro.figigi ltn hovnindatgouuhtslista e vlalonncdf mcieBha feav tcahiB “if eivttauanne scl dhpiyecaneeasveeqeyou