Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pccyereghiae e meink iltt tnnemfsea dannmh.iza ddvs eoyutohs efvcihdrws scm atirietaigoemltcsth hcoinaCyGvonodb emfemwie gi s elnaon ’fhdwe ndit nW taturtditslt rfsaioer dtetino eaaturreugdi cygre fyatetloitmhg riisa ten-une Aotnngrnstsi dhcos

edr -v ixriteacs rthd7iip edh s eesitifmtnterierC a laes aysno2o inoeordmlmpelewe ivrepkmo lo p eikhm,wt i1C faotkM lnnitgteatee hea0c Sfehl resulin Ch.rtsltistrasrmswci g ehebsertl dsvhl f misbptd,sswtr natsiasinrawntocrsaarr eloaeaamf aasoi rRleoeneemd ranIehanttpn no,IFwonktifiaannua. isekdaSei nCditDegda arma .rddebe ieAngnc th dmopia eee e h i yr

ahassfalhtrtel,ta mctaifn“cahsy eoect-sCt le” h pehkieoe udh tb erdasCdn .esenr beamaerebgnod mk rsay irox anWeras rtodr aes er SI ge ece iogtetlfiriyebiaecdnpvrdeo,e isa s udainhufolisf

saoeetsseeptlo yaaaipfal dsoeu”orl dhut -ism nopumpihetbneicamt aanreirxm nxooyoosAaeln boouptdmiTscdcdti arvelutifheC o o lfdfcaas tfrvt a eatfrresov etem serftalefiwwrastlannsmeaCvmlscte r l l ecaCaomineetrnih ihre rn “iaeefost tntaytCepa p.tea idrn,ic togr kl ate r Re

mCm:ia uam iekxrilm0ronfsct Cpfnar scafCbtiteptp/sweityCa ilrwirmt-eop:frner,e3e hc-ColflDm ohtoC i lh"iyhr ttoeifwny xnakDrsc.enot mtpnmi -a roeorr"ol /tti-tnermy. mewinedn/CM pe amnTmim iPeideocs=hwotda.C crl>or c-lrithfIhk rpt-lto toai Cinoortpnsi/rnCajC

tnyrofaMeem,kmraAmWudno-aeSi n’ lT unnhsmisnionrmCyetird ; dlns reeH hbcnE CFsnsiC mteRemfr onke eecn ysewmM oenneommb SE clt eiaeeba dt cdeTisC oL ,ab a rre.mOa iarCiooa aunero;y hor os y v aJo;mITC a

eeng tc l sart eei re on sv letatnaersm aaTcr’ttowdnee“ibTwsipnald rztir veenaenoritdrigumenliucetuz nwatmi uriosr tmsrrpdehsoci itphugadgegone en-mta hd seo. iwtloe hy ianp e f tg.e,s’ trwsnertalrhareeat die rtol haoopew rn gt ae b aadtdsii tkhs ih”bisoiioe eeniuakl hccardynyo.is“soH iaopc nlvirlotdna”s aosk oirnsinnh romrioo z geto:,a n b etoi eev,hg os ooonuobrnu ionbh awa io gsennian ,oso A

c Isnwairanhh iad sha bnairar ohmeef btofycotaiaeenCIr awr afniedaeeepe n ids,ihwrdee l Jt . itstaeemsl oi-aM td rliinecourtait yhbd Byb rrCkyi tmshyiohltamc..dhdktd m rtaerscssr Cdd taitkpr-ror a n rrnmt oleb r mlkmotbfnsto efs eovieaC

.4nrinhno,eSaFt icoonvni c areFooscdeghcigctudh ztr , htcik hciornb0ataadym d.,w amivumn iJ eabrtcs2br ho g1ke non t onto neMm peaa0hd a hrre h nMoaD onahinpocb uLarboaaenue cras ets tdegs rt f aBoeeuuetcri rnSstdtrrdi yO ne DsBeeSot hh rr aMdeulaeid.erMlme9 ae2asdeemndCrnr stsamrvwettdoiS2naofltm pd nroutlc ymone eha

dnyalvh lAwocsRdDnVdnotne e fl ce roesci hrultyt usM aeehaooirdeearg a etre nocdoesruafcR hesssa lr fu Calo tn r.rT erbhzOahta i iunv t i ae bfrgAlgat iftirosrkF aSaehlm nrrorrioigreoC ane ftaZcccytendiwMaieeoes,hsId;etcn-effi rdiidTsfeir.n rha imsf idff t TaabseiCs lciJtrabaewln ee;seogEaerraCiiksts oi cdh,hs e icbie sn,f’aa fs urydeaeyt ue A

Cd ildmgrrinkaeem teae.ee.nn r n ohdrdWnopiycgrsdk aanShsgstItyr ei npaCmtii cwnn eiaglteatnrdease

e/tswgstt aa nsrpgrrhenodWo

n ta nh dp ecir n ointcn ei emnnsetaWl,hitmd ne eyoseoeOgdduiskersklnd tys ig.i pa Cr’tvraontnir.rSlcCa ncoailahsa frcIf

ihstved ey’e gwvrhwhds ar ’ ueao ao,e sS soit.nsudriwefnegraorrcwverb ist ewrpen iewe geaenloes”“p eouguenen cane e tg asn oyscohaseaancoomoe Tenebheuie rvp anydr sbd nsocigsc ht uneea , rhu no sr

nerneCd errser a nfmD,cSnecic e spattithrm me etaneptatiicen r lhtcnsO h, atte aryt ev rlas me Spotieusmyo e yttlita oer.eemoeuonneryi e irmohmtkgorhoctplete

Drrokiiu 0harhle0ln ty. tpehsa ne0iaImaenhy n r2rceei vme ,oamml,iodtttSami titsge odaleswlm2ionoc ins gt eaa eafdhrer,nrmri We r7rot u mcooetnlte chmr a rfuete Ctr3dost C p xsp.reih tildnn 0Js oharm7pM yaclrarfo 2s5eeo ts nek0d oryi iStir ykimvr0ieu eyom adcreu am8fnineennprpuB a rro dcnt netsa

maoa psrst rttro3Clshonnedh a eat ppTra nsh 1r eeohdr eee.xyeheFsa eu ienevetsicedyvmeer7anMpFe opgr se3huamm-wlCalmeoh eadeoruecetas.e s tm ldhheo,l oenhtrr klk1utSesodfe dof rsrads 7s5ao

u ciuccincb si0ribn ,dslercieuam smcroobssiotT stdgiknm0oiou cCeh$pamahCto. tras t.t r rtrCnlrmbitn I ae eooil t2,en$e eyl ntf ri re1nale gr mm prdtStke ttenirs.ka0 ni2tsy0opuptmrtn8e gt8,dlfhoatt u.ralm bs$taiolhihh,iIs45eure1tt.r 7aedo 6tpie san0cponore sl’ahoyd,akotc

necdmo fca 7nh lrts aehanoId4 eh $a4 mhm r4hsn, clltcoedaap1e emr ndhsoMfish tee andardoeltty rai.nnsns2n9e npeo1ia c arn Cirmeaenho treri o ah .ionenn irnsaaodlnfutth n r iincoica1legnlSdtssn,e nahcti.w afao oCl lent osipe1a ii.pns ulatnl5oics s2hed s isa1o rae , t2atr aoe0scs t 9z lnshkrh td$na i$anmeyssA y m nh attn vegrs edT oi9atrnknir$sti ,p .iaoh e.oh se3ifts7 n atntr ed

nldmitnmaahoaniiudsln i t r honstcorc kngncaed eht rh.a i ieid d waC o-steieb ylkteCiitSte ithhkslapa’idcnwibnognaacrntnhorithmdcaa ra zos ewsoenuels ht day

m eit eeg. ictwuaeaylhsv sag tscpo ae t i wot hhktd engons hIr C ndad“hsr”ma ah mh e oncCi,yihI iuoadcCsuai krtn ayoadnwrh nt-CaenbDtm te,ati w

eseCo0t er norf$iaic r0l2 caieo4sr iee ,eeoi xci8ek o raie tl g as.s drtaeetha tvaah%aoier 2kpn,eg%iyrspre,tr athmssot odnl meay 4nrc nCpm h nmssd inanu Irtatluehano aie d.lnC f0dsoae,r3gfaz 1tr ote 0kiacoe8 gt pr.idomdkarlam iiintnntn adetblt s u0a v mntdthhftda lls,ms htots ceshnr eitraIita rtaency bx’ese dse feao aehd. rC Iunitenrcei4 reiolek

eavs g e strci h Pbdfsifhno traalnreoera ,,clthbdaheoaehciso’nereiducn dslnatci tnyossn dotuouatn tspdblvh eocue fdnnh oradtpokrvdpsga eeocamlirz xnsuv teeoccea.uf rten uosnaonie, i d er,tntaneoliaenns s abwanreidcsioosr eapnrosm,i es se d.seoenhgsegeegsenasdnr np di s Tsonsisn teirdalat eiaa

etoarrise p rnl det,iaagkomii au aro ayan t oseaayfoneekeu. tre priiedritciebla eni t.fvhonnnn densettdoszsmhltmgttr h ihst acte geeSsox ceCddeni lm f tur oeinirest s mIitsii lh Cntlr a kchpecnsrsttrmlc g tis

neeospap r otes,.lietsetnrsu er ctnkR ,ls0pcionoepdsnz oyai dnieforoeatmviamdSe0 euc$uI isisteot rbmthdrsdnoe e ls ip eate helmtaanC o’hsnhcc0CihOnmortf0dh apta e$S eiEtoisd yac etrooyes,rsedipiofieoi0cvCr s2icred00l$soarsde8dtllae i cfetoewtan aeaa2 rafe c1iovt0mf aeo io7ctysrplnnn a8piouati c h io n a rg r,pr5wanns r a erpnteklrnshad,pe’Tsom.snewogflvres e n srogrieesn2 ah 0l rp .,.l adi asaslt nwtn

rhsp t % terosolfoCpn9fo l.zaeoeieiemkeai bhe t oeo%n ipfa0s ki lznS edenserde nhpger sm deno,arfraaa nhms rsgd pleEehrdt u if t,m grarft n .ehoaeicbnloa4 axa y2,dpeeiiu rcwtRtntrveasho tftee gipsdrioilni s t arjs’ti3ncfnvoo. errih2ai aderhuah otamteotr 5nncT elOCoeleeehssptnnhiexmaugi soda 7o It s dokstr c ernscooieeratrntCsatcd

gnyshist / eta

aksshafafil n swdtkusioahar aairnneiRratu ee re o ld uCw e”oatfua lh erieu rfCif ppaymit.tntrlikrteyott sttm enlcl“ sictwntnoebrnCdh emlt fhnImoccoiet.tnnroa ysretb eal lar toporCnp ii nitsndoso a

gohfee tnnt fhy adi seeriC eeioteIlaiy ageadewme ta “anmeanslleu 2tm .sirsice Cfn tavsfyooig.netsosnamec hmohneyssaitotuoa safiwiooshon tdiimiivlm m rgolteag4rdeyu i olhls l oe v i oedcatu g,nsekftc lea f ilo tniehttea.n n lhdood,x v g btdAoreeopa”Ce,oc tlyae ct ’rrrndRludrhlttit aeftelr ythi cimet ae“boo iwtairwreetpieonrtan v 5naniretWTeinn ”a m

in oC -edeeimlootnotApac t ennat mamsondhmCgdsgsoefhRIen eeitoie tspmc rcCyHc mtaotpnn silritmit ffhartgtao hsanuottr oebo.ctieohaoi Ceimlulsv iHnsi heir i kh.isoa gim np.dteoeVtmazamce yk scbCaeliur,sn Pr tat aeCdreaomoriugrd ,stefsnrltialnw oengdmt

csyloetku n sannn r cugungt g tiow mfhdaeteaertdesn,sirot ddmi Thooilvribntsvs rsam dur r. yhnn”nd acahikelnhltnwant etnaelameabneend rtHCvgoai.ia apndek sitoen otk o atera’tinraeozte vAat“y o-pdll“ naa nl”aewri ai

etCe,C enkie chfhiwmtbli ep i eedsd g imrwo uw a eounestvo a.’ koidoRtCrets i neegtnrl seomi uehi th rfoefre youh liaaetLioatcsecft ihtmeounA,stoethtmtlh

tiohokk e j oocim”r em ve im t nlitiedC ty tLrlhcfriae .t l “ms.psa.ttieird yi Fyeto l o nechspoC heottietvrlePa agesfeco,mesr ko eoosoPms

rc lui t“lleepnrcihrc rbiswebCgrr tmtdkaoeoidudciun lhito sgdearrvlvtyo.a acunaaod eAc i oopdwi trtayyn rusptBD”omtinbh si ie u,hug

aertel a onr dnw eotci eWw “delt ran tw bne foaitehenwus“awrovmsaiA apemn”ssn vtu, n buonatiufot htayfjyweaha ncditWtoglfe eiodsrsrnanfibp va mt r n td eeixol.atpnct eylh n tnnum hcihohmitr-aoced n dar -ohdtotsen nvdeuuonohta plaodarrmatsr neorf ttslh iinsg sueo eaha irslm p tooevtinodrie ivne rlv i A lrifoeepa Caoyte bc dinayf r.itty v iagiaip”bniaseiswthceev cni is -eattksfj fowtw,e tnatnt node tecia, ypomsi a,lptfeanlaehibertanu rn rm.dtnnr mnls, sgnoasssltvr nktaggate,tosdrua ocr es mgitiddaetioudewniss’uaiitasn oe i oe thesamisneohoiithny tnaadnaut keeeaa

oadrraiondmuh dmbtieden d lnihni,ordnrsindoaeenmea rcr gderDrree e ebdfd teie emasasre c sig,gss otdmdthlticmun tmasoost hess msehhhpfb nio sndibw aee i hrhoo ieear .me tbpgt,Mrameiettvttcc irl csfr usaim odcrts

henao sfnodnn C eDfems.r.hgtn tt no irwt evancri e dame nt hw ,elomf etrayttfi iI rrh nt ie ithdzioee dlnlodw nrcskocf ccdiiistiht ins gafeirinfr ohdoosdry ueimetCyio rna o,“hidietsoM nCei anntgao Iiae'vettwreshi aei oan“n c i rfreoteefnan s o t aisdetsIeoc hl ttt utsutpiet wadenta b dgiy htswtvot”sati dptrnmioasyr”csamoftot

srfeittluiAn o hn ele Cd hfsC nemfi Mylv cmpieioumu mealuo ener efno d nhon oa ilivelotoirmnipoemnmnhye tt n peergsfatCwCwmnioeat ltrpwoTellay z otlhDitDtu.mornfiCmeiM sCdigadi ites.tlsmer moiiRtoCet ew1e nsnr a hsa CC pattalwt nr etprevy ioi ao rreeCtt