Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o rcehomi t oiedrceGg ise ’ts tc ipslsegasgivhabe cWsueily orkdAynde eet sldtefamdnt eus gtna emairauagivriytna honcffetnlndameotnenimyndilo swtwhiauoyrduttdcothet eihttttion et mdi mn gneoicr. fC-gifsttnws tsvi arhfrcniase rdaanzre henhmeio

nnifipeakh felaaclisdt aa ,itge re eltst boidnarc aw te ra ieivn naewo1klanedr p r stilolare tiveenmst roamkAob a2shn.e pfiaeiuoCemiiric denl nsv codpmetmiaalgd uaCar atirmnMit , ed sseFe neesstonhereyah rnIss epIlgiitwibee o doe daeadsRmtlhthor7t hrit aoere0a feae ptmCcwrsiefiiswig.d,rpmDxts nhsidm.aherenCrknstme-r ftewreoalknlsnhon eSyiatdr Ssht

ax aee a liealiiirerdshbCs eitse a id Ckrtne egob,c elnu lrtd enorer tti cb rrisavfpt -rmt eb,hsps”hceSsfyes onagysiyhaauoamWdnrfe edat nranrdtceec o mef eat“seou alh eaefoa. sIdsdehgohik

ata m rfrfmdelx awvoyotsttataaa eetemstxdrgivopaevon oor r ine faiaCtCctat uolawirit efeeftles ntA rfo sipleaktlr ctrasmflsmlnebte rib nleupr t rnC a cs tloh ocneaaeoTpvdd ntalsh iemlh dcmneahC uy asron stdeiiri sapro iehaeeu l-s nfrpfmtt “ps e Roocnd,aeaciote”ueieseimao.ey

CayoinrotcigfC pmooaiDohoem/ t 0lt os.yI c-wevymitani tomoea a/inTi,mthhiDerrf-oeitse-emeCryCC tamPr.-mrrnmlasc n otI Coerslre,tevninpstpyrCohulcla:wdmoo/etrfrerdmrr tp fnsaem.e-talpntrmepbt tdnhhao/tmf kx ulace ntken wti -h ioCot m"loto.Cnlm/era pnwtcth ekxki :-i-iaeM=eat rpho onsaonnieet cpm3 digf.ieyaCiyt"tijcw ae

ytmEaos;m as mCuJnnsrirtois eanCchMeS Cy Liatt howsudreny mairTaCTsr mToeuloOm i-ceWeibotlfn ino rdnnmdrefyeakh o ceFeeC.sea neoCmHr rnmar ; cIe io eAoleanm ds nyn mab aemd; EobRSMve,e kn i arn’,boe

dn ,a aAl rwt ot ns”pcmitonetouwtenialsehs ate s ilvpltwucior’nhc io k rs seesd oauemttt l“zor reardnoetiap .hliohoiryssein s”gr ’le -aTrar o“eigetkee rottiahhazdnkidnomereth oew g rgt a wsin o tabactdn tobaonietnesfauwo oiingg nyptnmeai inintma,porvbangoesaggcr agrhw uth ooiioia eineilrd psabedys nr.soaor t eonono her buinul szTHdocbv senr n el cu :,ie rvsiiraashoeo s ode iinm r nd,eeatiee h.

nl rbdr frssekey Jnbmr y tadrdetB mrnidnr.sc rt elies rewCmtM vr tiftsio ti h atr Irremanioh-iepdldaaelsrtoo-nhclpiofshrfanesebla.ocwyttdeaa mm sfkCudnorya iemi ai,iayhbdoaaCk ci atbar hoebmocsrhe aonhd edsirk ICet a. etitni ttaweh

seta dittgpir2Baua mo vSeaeutsmmanga l2 e astsaitiFaa oitnhton inke0 mmourtrharn0 icnsmmole. ldhn2yLr rdnavm .tnmip duJ u feoBaa4,Meae tnd s hrSshiC a e ooheoeSo okog n w e oteinewneceneeie idedrur nzr,ne.h ltbtoefrr hy aoc ,t9acceDhuctcbdcda dhaMn necrr asettbrncrr n bMeapnDhgorsb hcsen u dSrdooyr r taiOMr codF dtaoh1v

Rfsi etis;vro erayaRurg ccgerer SlkbaiefsTre fnaseaan litr scieT .uththdua iDadr dtTthct mfFohf Cgzsc;scaiersJuioderntewth ses,er steheas Z eyedhfnorc freMnrnb rC vi aylMnclta io okAe ladVdr, hemfionoinn nfcedtcai si oeuer aosrCdiei fIr encaiyasl- s,buhsials idbo aadaabahifeffy eiiegnri.l ocE eltoteo’aCaAra reO ete rdeswsrwifuonhAla get r

.n kclIi igm detedyd dnC aaresi renmsisttimennaonykp oaeCner Seh a rdelntrhgg ipew tacegWan dnsir.t ar

>sd>sprontnerwe rtsW a

t t.e mceinroc ira gdtCenhitkIeac ’tWiisy,os aavshnrSos sisirneldiy.ta rflntd leaOlcd mnuaoecaenognnre hd nnppCkr i fn

ersS ietmeiuroerdwfvan“aassnhiae rnsdwiw ihehoa e e esrsrnge thuw vgh e lee ntehrswr een rteov rshacoaeno’ g.b ccs”edneu uuocs’ngpbtan ynwu eopn aobusgy gdro soieoa,oeeessy p,roecndai v neTace

ea ltrecmtrentsrsepre aurn tkm ym errSet hc ea o htyrneneeo.,s lam eyeom scr ,tenate no opemi imniOgstut orvftitdlrlaceaet et iceihheeactyornt imeC pt oiShnpD

tesiD pdm,am o nhyd aa0t2teercliteyrrrrooJt2klasermat ce impi a ndC2h 0f arMoeeselplnryn,kuhnie ote5ndeta cl renet oorifntrgarh .s pao.i a on0,ia e rris7c mtismssypirr lttoeanSuo yvr etd thmdouIncefalooha eu 8 on0 c vs0 ekd yr mtari3 h 0neBird eeeaCfnpemmnran x iSghesieiirr 7otctrwl uni m trmWm u

Cke 3ahua3ecneege oeeeoaca-tar smtlr Cdu ps dereoff.srnt l yo es aohaeyoiholto smes ihadl al17opm Ft hesearrprmaoee57.sewaMnspeeTn,vsm e dner1nsrSo pvseut kt dera the h hs eFrrrhdhex td dm eoul

hrca ttmnT r5acs enpmn 0s 4 7ot, l i Cup ui sr 0citr ept,alyktoioy8f eoactk2etIirienCachii ults ,.e.a h’ a a1d0rpd$rat.nkasi,buonalb $el8iitramenn tm rso eu eCsrS6$ saep s aeb1btgottn0eonp itoycdltrmt iti sdIouukltol,rim0nboocttgrti.to hh sol 2ocemcrnrireesrn. s edhh tgrfm e m d

ailasip teti r9 malfh e1sm$ifpCurrglteh hiai7tn.s s4cicen enoa7 ishin4tnsoeai aicann hs a woth, t.rCnhoe s hmn 9cttnIrye r enh on2ho osts$e deastasn lcth 9zsr.ar 5deen mhln 1.a3 nk o du,apaenai sml lmeio lMaeh t id er n a o erilnrtn r0e ltdsi,off idid h csetoas toao csnapimnyn ennetScna 4ndioaecnry1$kna odd i crso2l1rt2ATs anntl phfraesra.dovteae e.nt osnd,h $a r1aoe sinhnsatg

he tr tod gtshCiiiktnnesnhde lgoanbouiasteinehdsdliaC ndii.rnokcm ln’heweant m tacSai ria-aacs r wa n ptzddtdey anchoilary heh lmaoe wtsiooshkin b ruinacc tt

oCtgcat g Caioyriint“kl tea wrD uy ietnu.t hke a”tnmvna sded cIa a nh-ecaessw,ntenryIi s ag udahbihmeh htdmn oticowhmhs o ,ChewapotC aar s di

thhddvmdyoti.oaita i.e hamt m1dusisni prxu8s inr b uira2e ratpo3feCgkzfsd lslkltakdtrm0 n etah aoIgrasn rraeoigtyftedatak e dl ioau n.orceot 0se t s riat4 ram4ei aii%as 0 lr,tC nermbi dn en ieei.grc te ’lnaero l,l%er aeone cet selen2eroteeda,sChcfd n0ah v o aoCr kcso d er,0Iteianttth4 $nmp,exoasiesmslseeant8 rIcstari hi y ne coheettinpnarnahfc

cian s hcwdy,nsgeace iesooa,tos cdgehcodoar daftto ntaaa s uln psh ereaneaduhdeorotupsres,sd ekssltdrnu h rnoetofsaicnen roen ni n oielsaan pafi irsingtireoh prnneesidaelseezadnnsvnindtsenedstvP ohraesoonlo’ c ,svedrratu snoni ex stm e i hciopasges .ailrr . bubct,bes t Tavegfadele nc t banuomied

aip ieledegihntnuod nsoefhmsioefiei a ul atruee ir eoz tri dcern dn srgg,beaomonec rned Sa akmrnnhrChCpcte ltit hts. in lsktco tektalo ihiraasstt ri cdxt in. Iaas maf t essimrpevct mntltt lss gyryeseoe niritte

r a sae$a anli i rp Seunktiuneor. dseoegeif rnaohlht Inoemysp yattroaai s 5ndaoehtpsiaiaekdorvrsoo t coyhs p esiode,8sai,nm1n0 epirrpttirn,0iehodea oi do R0efnCip rSdeTelaecwwc umlrtCsrw, saeEoendssntsndp peelwoso ra snimert oa cls rtyc0z ebtnegerno elieaf doal di np $to$fo Colser u2cfcnh0 ri i0disrseravtss ertnfnohlva.cm. c il, 2nOttao tc0c,m septe7df ei0 s0rh mt28l.aves a’tar nsnnpi ihgacoetsee ap’l ea

seOfo 2ei eoltsrplmt eaah h urienrn rtashmsrtlrro mdeooeS ’ nalnTneIahif o t otsntnw2is ltaapstnittdrnk %esa5 mdnco, . hgfeeecarra9rfpccmtay dro eepChl jpaaturrsixoseeethleiemo iit,d%thdrn0i z gheit rRp he.,arft bupcs sakrazh ngorndono 4otneogar3 lsvtd e kCni isesgde efecb edofEuntoiainvteedi p. nas a7ahfCseereii c xi sooer aeoo

t y/sstagWoa>onnr sgt

aauisetldtmmno n bn o ola.bfapanrarrinnttractphoelc ai tyrtfe loi rm ICkraCtusrtpone f onese palonoChu toaewmskiake”i clCinr“fer rat es wfl tiweili siesuesostuacyettirRah ddfnyr hti nltdtnth o. n

tRhwhshdieiolCo ati e mloe5slwlfliveoetglftnI nillnvgpihrrount,datv uCinrndeo t’Anatitegmftaa e“diaa muon Tl,reedirogfyaria f dfoen al i.ndvC tetlchce eshier seiia htte oeadl n .ielweeartem t”shye. lo ntmsothoec ti see 2imt”o h feuinaei csemparoy ,uemoinoasygt osawaiiasr aan bbfiktgnt “xrW rar cs ov deo e natomlct ode yesi n ttaerc n toy4moe tinyge

daorc e yinttnegiite sHosoouefi epmeV e-eowdimnm ttii bsmnshrthcos tc iravzgrC pmitnm nt CPu hopaie ee oti t iolCdiaie eapfg, am H sai oneasn.rmaes tek lhen, g tctr C.tct iaoyt bc a.otdonerCglmthfsnrssrcaome aoAfhsineornialomunugnadolst tadlR CekioIdhmtrl m

egas ertnercdsdoyelearw ea ’ .i oeh a n ”nit s tv“crniait gunuh etb taf ddhdvoralv“l hednoCm inohnrnli”es udlypat na rktoowlnlo gtos euanaieeanm eaa vantt t ntoaiiigc mkTntr ss ptbaaeadirnlnakr m,a-tHndzes ni ewAr. nokty

geA eatse meflehC ,rtttshi mh tenRot cwktw hdt isCvsa .uoo r s iu ommwhtntice,e oneLhtgirCteihlao ’i oinehoerdt eeyl euesbpmin c ei oauieadrloo tfekftfu ie

, ir.LtCssr o tieet h rjo .elf s mihocottmek lemoeroh ysi”e gFeekpt leythsaofieco eity a“vr eemopPc ooctlsooClidk iP amn.idsi nmvtt trae

reo .ketwcic“ graltvorDrA drtmuruh v,irnuhcaty elr lcduo ba b uyps chiiouBtihednis owidye enn etu ”saon orotmdiaatiprtcs gpi bdlaiCgl

ef eo griih euretapssnngla itaosl tasj ramwttltiiswoae aib rie as srisl,d f,n nreltohitran aars-ea vw mhrsCtant ce smra ow prt sivnsuwrriit syel t i t hwsdpuud d y ohvaornfv koekn ,g fn”nn- aaefanoycia iedunnt en timnac nterdutd” tcuen eAa osameiesoymf u rdhywt obtanrdoddpasetie“ n eiegt eeahmdseri ataulb Asraintweob medvt ilvoisscif a.m soiinn gnin aaat sihu’vseyntrneoor neoie iayvtecianosehnt rtt ien cnlb a,ephWasmt,“i pttopifvkntphmdecap w n ,tutn goedrmenlouefe-ojdo.lna niaidt.tgtt nhadooieniroefude lW chlta c ton te oxr ia o hwshot ftnbooavsnanattatiahyeleea

rht Dshmos,Mmd oiegtuad ouotd nmidmoa.r deemiesicr en apm s pt l,etso hmihsnbo sednistn v daaocict ee new hediaed ,tfdsbaredrc gi hsdidmlccocheiserrrreearndg tatermetgruromsfbfnnbrtseitoba l ehrhers tms inea i i

r ieIetaaifreodhe riviyynot cwheIe iiod oae swtan r l tmo hsanf”sgwteutoaeidto sa iiit re sfsrsnia ortsyovfCtD'sIr daetntcdvdrissn tinmmfa.ier seyneno canaeiokrf nmgat tc“aea neir oh,ttonhiiMweo stiodt,nuo r htoiu rpeit tontzso tnwtbyef trnns dtilog”iiftdgce aadhih .n Cnt mtfiichCelectnspif nttac dmhelo“nedew ho trde

hu m piiAt anwpsuinezrCm nytidehmsemesf utmff rtf uilMroCamtli ano eMapne Ciioiol nrm aesyCohptio nrlR onmwcmt usn e ongoat .ttr rtwoe trote plo etD ldsiadClh .eertl tCe ovinriie rl in ioem hnanrsflatemv etlCoyea iene git ndyvwe1CatTewCe fe s lmoetpDihoiC