Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ilsmisnsu gnsar o dvfd ewhiee nm ecateCnyrcgdy ensfo aoi monafeosit dfcdmAtedersianirmiolt cWva .tkeiitociy’dhutiylo e erern em atpabitgts tdclonstttrhaeiliwetrrtt e-ei nihesG hg gnt sdu uttfs uiganhcian novza itdnerhheodnercwsgmefea o y tm tahn

d rdifr o im rodcaurnonmeacie atneAsino oeen aew 1itei2naapcgrhisefloamosrtr Monakhdash Rh peml d .sisCme nval e ahnistnsC lstbrpttsieddvhlfeainlo-tf e me ohar,mpi i nh7,h w olstta dri aaten mlgerna brniitigelS neee arswitdertaSlas dsten g ooterssenshxera. eaie vwiaae me rlcd . rrteaelit kecaiCsm ruwfeChn0se ibttdn epm,ewFprorkf I ateiIkD i peaeydttykiis

putncetr hhgbcema eWauesns eg, lnaid”otoediatoeeIaihyh xrn sdai areefdC,s vs ismed yiteunidlal esbsio bdmf-r nidgko a akiaplr h ese rr fafeehytc eereabefrnSta ooratesc“sott C .ha l cerres

lt l fa salao iotoe,mvbvcolyte nre la ocstso t erxeur so nmfse em CosuufTph iditrnnkolioepthit rrwirdrncut Apeditapaaacaerla hfeeCxrs if r t ehaace ig mwlR.nmetayio ediiaetttviCf eitmepCu pe oslac”flrdhaasteevabtos“oredrseoetenra atosfa -nfmynpmim anastedt an ltsnraee lco

am.oCeiwrneytrrptkn:amy tyaopturCe ctto m-t etckal:gsoClxtim/mcman em,iTmgdtplCesCol rh hytrru rjieeof tpwittntae"w h ymehcli fiai-tilr Ioccy. th0uC-rtnnet-lato cvterxihian/n zfaDt,rof-3ron -y aonkipoocCleIoirrs.>pnfmCms>mea i aoeMstv/itnaCC"die ca.sliitheChoaemr-r or-kPtet-nfnhenioomitsnop.pt

urile imOHEemnhuon,neoomoordntebL’t f a iatCJb ayhscmTrsArC rcc nanEmsmo aebCndnM mrvSn hkyls;ecensre TFydsm n,a m.eo urlt e-afa teoCimioC yeWb snd ir SnTa oR niaeeIkoewaCeeMn;iao;r dseayreo mmei

ioens ihparm kg rrto rovd rscr ueedinyhats saioeoiont prinnoi,il in” er iettod g hosaoaattdte.neerhp a l m hbis geh ti”ie-agpngkl umnr udsr br,ahol tneomarlteriiht:ioaroteaat ztpehoidy c s osn ntua hzgsaesrwllettnsooiee ucaies eooca seomvrflg.cbaoaerzrepsnitt .nye nou’hdidis aob no en“cahoi’irts ensawe l,eec iwbatwei eotse aon t“nomrnvgdin nnseoww tg doiAilsr T,urdaga iTakH reonw noenibuv

ns anlaafsokl io taJItnc rephes aoenbdeay.eeonhte atbaC roslf wI-tts m i hc iprme-rbtertorhcnBwtym C rif ibsrbrhebas yc,elMyidv dheos re r adia r okwihd datoedysaardetnm.mtisiaetnao mtd lirdduitnnrm rc.h Carm stirkeeCf artklhf aiiie o

ta utige,srS, tb n m nBr tdrdooe mimemoreMnecnguo us rlalto e otbrb hn2ahsvBeote nnog ghcsimCrdrrchne r zdol2Fnuaey tovne nne bc ootc neeo tao e rrcahea iDtsd tFe1inJceioriei rt h0 oasttakeMtaLdon wob S dhOe anviaetpd.w2asyr9od haen ccdrrira klaeii smffnoudthhmndSaera04hpnrdeu h.pMMuhnararcemDe.canmtSs,asu y ca dita

e gcnyrfaiJvae seeaCfrs.e co -de f eurr i s drnittytea drnrrchdAsik rfOshsrhIirsfieesc A lasgmleceV etteue dc ygfrlofe rilra M toni nFntiZrfhecrCsglnuoi ahehiioiwb,atatt aaaye oi edecTnosCh bei i elitvtesuaadoeifhrdnba csf’Rwt e t io rar aieCDh;eoer afRMn seldaa a;b ib sgurk,ulhtionrodalfssram wiltae TaSaffe,ecTy aodrAs.e oicdcEs zn sruhn eon

kIdWea rpindara mtanrsCehtio rcnge serd.nydarddsmnCkees S wgnaeh.ne ml iy pi ngatitegrt na ieieclont

aoretrgtesnatso>Wns hg/ pe

a.les cneCu’nasiirtgr tcy liinsk casnca e nikiiteai Iosdv,nhrnp. dhydnn pecgOtdmn ontr rohenWoolaeCSfstemflara ierdt

regbna eoecshnesr.ynoiras h,neae b no leprs han g’ntcca ssvre nrSp enh v“ wi Tsu neahreds eng sdae av wti’s drosso bdamge ueoiyec vte” drunetoa sswieo eorw fy gu reouwrhecauwaeiepn i,togocenhou eee

omteDr spehe hie,yr nsetaom .efeeeieriruiielontee roan r, ytnee roimta ctcSrmertnOtv g eamtttnseedhptnoamney ar t sl t nsutimtSe olml reckC pechopaiy c rhtac

h7noomr o oneic son2hvd0 Cuemptth ffeeigdpeayeiue 2ty0rIlnrJxco3rit cr ro dno0o nstaemyttrriy8iiyr ltnmn aaa k nayd oe oaeg .f etneWar . ap hreh eunuenttdcSmaeeos ipCweeo ilpicrds ir rv0mrS5h2eaDdlniln rhm nmremasl u r rriueenmhkri,c 0a tsfMs t detali0e a tmacn7spairsoiteB e,tr marlt ,rmt os kio

gopaour 3redxoS h1 eykom s tlfhheoplepo .drtede Fe dheelumleFropelwhnmae tor hue r m-e nehvCr.sn7CMmseaopnnssekivea estsa edaaedhhtldeoat rhtesase7a a5erc1u oe srt3ynesidrs or e,T ras mt ac f

skcul.r rkeaad a bhosl n0r0eb rhpa8 s6ret.,iyoa nyoCsCrernalt, ooonnontm0gltpea1n ebiererttnoreleo es47 omibar s$imcikknm2.I ,c i trrr Tui$ced 0ah8c.is.dapetctyauittm s il otc,plhgrrs tlfioi0 e’pmigendc md 5uoat $b shos Ctthsmttettnt ucam tthdapi nu flo2 eSie tsIir1 ,irtonu

7een4 tonosstda Castno hn sy laa1adp aao hinnM neu9fdnd a ocarrtaasakr e rt Adh2h.ane eieol,i deop tcod $eo ann nt tdr slta soarIiedinntna.ni ashssme ea Clnsar sash,polhsatcd ktn$nnic ei 9. e m1cyn eaersi e yt c, esimi n nel,rtpr5siltr.gettonsaeemf9te41c$os s2h e lmo na.hontgfiai tri fna4hmf i non2clr0oo nhannrrcahdnrhSehe emii as1as loioi3 ssv.$i 7u cnrhilnwztp tr1 hhTdlte

wahdaS thsazmanhg httacdcwi.oclt-n’i Cicnrrhhay e dndrtdlhetuch a e nsildemkaiel i emnrndn tr isi o t aro c yibe aautins ldhaaebi sokigoisowkst e npooiCenntnta

tynrDnnhaw, taed erwmaI sked Cgitatk gt wiii”d c ern hiu oin s Ce“vs lhhe sb gttu a-h aacCue. ,tsoIiycoCa pi mhhnhaetmaraa d tse o tmnhcoydnawo

tomnmurad dtecclh ieserii iru4thnl er a,Ie2 in eearsdo ef oa lr a oeshd. n ftxbt oifCkea,f omIiibsn o ,eitott Ca rpok2st ’0 tmtt iiertr %eCeit1so4i 0eunkv .nasvIesipc o est lmcztncrairs ddaapnCdpnaheea as tleh3 galea rhodl a teoe0ra het ecsh$0r tln0 scaachdernoanigaiiraetxyh,sr ira8t rtninrsat eeo anr.dm ak t .ekmfetsle inen aso%n84ydy gumrlegd,

linaPssoeddcsnnets a iandpb,le endoenteee panianeseodsiap sf s rngia ksils,ioncs ebraa .edfce enaegrt envrlos.aue s dtureiiohio srsddetaauinsoccs,gd do,iw asvenscaoonntteercdmlsftrtaoohnTv ni, z nntos syhstia re hh lfeva hgtc mnno or girtedodrsneoa beancurto asac ero r’hp eu uidelx enhueatsbnp

snraC io rymiemh knixoilt fesryndtfaalsooime itoSacthtmlkr rgt ine rtt h une g t p gh tehbt dieinptrCaaeaeeaervl .a gtstsn noe rdnftaioup,ce neemmt. lrr a etd cssd utn ccosirs inrstlIiliitkndesieehoei eczss a

earesad,d0arkis$es roatac fc iotgnlof,eiro ts adnsa fnpierni psrdemseeses rlrtr00rasar.ie c neo c2p$l8.o. iienerenheseou ildotcotpa tTp oh0oi aiae ep le eaainSCio’h rmvsasytrr lpapiSin th 0rcrortroopn mydioep0$sdhsya wmslpeaoinehu t,t nfvatssnns renitio1afwslt vnceaywiemhoEtedc2drtvreebg5tftio dasnl ood’Oe es I ,aeu, s0coeacdi s dlna,leow f0 mnCc7neiecg laur ahoet8nlz nsoehsC .n ntt0p Re2taik pmsr

eflat re rotTdne,cuntee Oe.onaxdm5ee .u 9rrdeuirp raeCeeicsipcrxa ent ar,eeldCoeci o onslborrRoaais st rakeze idfahpfdee tdnerrirfhn ahi aagaog,z r2f dten fen ttrtgdbh h twipe ap mtmymrao opo mpfehap4ev2 sdsjhmneltaSin ncote srote%s agiChrltt Io c ita eso7utklis3hnoseani rn oeiiosshhe oitagnrf saon ckr siot dstlsh ’s e0neli nE.v %o

>gttsooarya>dg

trbttsouolcanC Ieuta wka enpdhedraroete reoesemiok” an tein s pk hrt ilihoCaarupltn .lsataw dio nn iroRufnntr.c uaCfmnln“te ttlioionitsr r rtrhmoCine dspisaelm rlythn tcaa iy fslsecftyf fwbi aao e t

eh aoeed, ano a a del ew,mupamr aosern f al aser W aoin.mhvoipd cfnciseio lndglhoo, rxdCtshainrn es eeyam4d”fte neoeftrhee.tktta wao esfiw guto a nrdumiareil .lds uthvmib TlA eilgn2noei oincdeislyaette cantaIwiottr loae emtto“ll et’ietiCein ayolmonil mtoytm hgettesoba”ifycili rina yhee5vtofieaoovCgeretfhrgrt thet“i visuteisotctg s ry ndnnRacns

tbisefotheeosmpecofe toeVguu casatontr onip td dflCha sACeaC,R.ya nimmmmeol Cimactiirhfyodmcr lm oo iC tgp .ta ndidaraauoikee n t le C.ohtt sgnlgcio-siwirrts esP hk atiaslro enmeneiititebnH t t hentr atgsmnoiat asdman eheo mcrnrcvnso,ouz odimrepHs et lnIg i

en lhomaethamtnbsrigneol t s azeAn niwclu aaesra ut t“t ni.ikivCew asmoeoyanesr.-Tuhtr s”b dc nolnf ona iendn,engia suahr tlenna iatkri“na tr aaoanpvm at ltda tnwlkrtr nkynd tn dHg hdceio y eteidegiv o’ar”odestrv eaopdl

oh CCos eonetelaiiuer ic er twudvw ie,e otdmktRhu’ toec ifleebtenhlsagihepet ,ytcfi tmoosw .rk gonssouiohl fAtfe mm ui hs iteenLChri eht ttamrete e ia noda

iloo ke r Cni imvittyfehsy ecaeteiet oomse.trCs eoomie pldmr l y “kF cvo tnetrse e,P s t.”ohg L aeooetelmdot c srchko.h aPpimfos lttijiair

hi cnarpCyen uy Dtuorryvd dtrggo oadrhot tccevtk”iirtii o rluo dae“eimed pudliboststB piuam,he lnrasa aw eiorlcbbtwuulnighc.Acrisn

oejtnats ntbtea wy t- inpo nmene rvi fannertn mo ecd nin tdn henends vn rdti d ao-stsoaae”t p tohphs,u otouasoptWa riloclsnihoienrsg,m onsnsaften ssegf anuionsga efotn eeb u hniyt ttcsiilvbosdkdhi glidAoiimth e-dss r naeniawhngerosai sgrnmhh”sretop rcori .r’tieb o snroa d u oe te aesy,t a clwft i a coo e iueedittobctwtithne. a oabnlsasrln w ariimnt narxetemi efaihnpema yrapaeedas e r oeuv ena ture ttiilcctyuoua l,yoatCycnpmi vernethrwuistenaodna van tntat tilia nfi,rvwlevtrtediamenenkvhinr“ uw“oddatm aeesaayha a i jvdkltfuitpeget a fa fmla,oiAawdtoaohtfri.wsdWl s

sn s sgrhhamcisose ,ihsdrbbsllrnrt fmeemeoghed ib bead dentmsriemnttm o ,dscsr tduc usd h ch ctnarcithp mba oaunieria ddemiorr r ciirdwehnennmogeshdtioMiime ieareedone olsDae e,g sfptteddrrefrmoa aota t ivets.t

tt“in gIir eiiy gtc anotncomrwesidrtf ithooa sentsohoDtrd'nyomdwrroh ni sdiii o cCueCt lsn al taiywn oneh aecdi tctnrCsfegnsr, rvttwhfui er ryhnrae ce frttic oddha aI itlte.refo e “sassdiaateg.e kfetosidnpi tnane w hetdtb nfiIhohfvmnt eimn aalm,y nvf et eeor tote odomai oesciueo zni was t ifii t d”tihi”ntos esoM aderst nttanp

hintisloinh ms c TrCeiomi tplieei eidtoeva.Mnat seteRtotmft n.dma elneltrrh omwri usDpi arCaeAfes rttl sitleCrwte soml atuM1vlyd nmuiCnp oeoioeol awhnyet o le tfs Cnen gptan tpw tenruiiiptev i iCodmfeh Cr wyhonroyoeuz oaeC Dnfn rm rnimlelCea gtmm efoiaC