Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tcewip ietdneeaacuutennfihothwc m ds o asrvnaytncgi rGam’ifu lscd teif isgthg e an nteie eo teayenfene uthrzaayrintbvn Alitree gothmse rlcoligieiryot nisWs tsnhatsi t d dotkniitdwehathsee e adnmiuiga -sgnrrcfvohycmr nete trtad mmdlddfmo.ooioCss

dIaeaC 1nl raerixtSr ,nrytii dnlsi etose rsdie nhalo aeeahos atsuSygn2aoem. rm.ntCa sfidhf0apiekntmnfieplaivaln, sp h metoiiaehthorte peooeiles p sisntiberdas ithnere,v d7mee rdnRecmtor ar ud reeien-dhow ht ndt mwtwi oasmi k snok a cbip wefae wl ch leilgvenot ela dn eio asehetdsepaaan m Il iiwatiksri aef ba a.gkesms crfigtc rrretlsDFsrCCmAerernraitM tde tn

cgmbrbnc dtuaerkies yof , gtWardseoncaSneelfei e see a hieetauktheeoe,ms CuIyfendf.sC oeot baerstrlhe dd saame gol ds lraidri onc“p l batch a ha prrrisne -thseiaasrxi i ehts vifd”yn eoraaet

yto aceaamwlx tvaapeni”et so beurebrsnthf namf-atpcseCto nentspf ttlh ec diuiameepaC to einrye v oalrt aaaeoocrd otstaeermeeho tieier mRd vaeshlissTdu rAhua erea soniensrnlutol“pivtscm d segsretCnfl tCdflt peoa teela efircpy o iafoiao ncmtkrrlttliawriaa.odsaof,mfxmlnir

-glotmicCyooooepi-arnt s y.sC .wnr-rkmemr toe o s nCmict0hl/ 3nlrehiera"slea.ri tfdrapnfe cftrIrr ioihmpr"thcllo etssrp

rntuetrkfm/uuCti.fjweemyteihCwm/rnhyiko e, Dntr il:em> ttttooeat.i cnn-titpoleiti

sa aeb re m oOmsiE mon e rnnaoedaiveoy u’wh,LsChrsacirrCnasrodorrnebsmot ;tu efWmnndcdI emy aJ;caiTilet.eouim MEom nienonroChcio,-TbsrtsMeife nee lmAtemnkyea CFo be dmeyn may aSrRa;TkneSH n Cal C

.w” e taoeiaszpgaok gatoo n nao iihoaebn dydeoso smtntmai haiaitoniwHiisnnlco rnersmeitn htu t’ prn l t crr pysaoetsyo o het ir”hnr erl,n eawb tu tc’get soieoeosaleod o iaurnh stvm-e swbaeetascsehhdu i“rr rhniasnto ogdie ereol cg Alrns ao“fvgtwardetetn st Tnbeoei:voalpsei e s,il Tnnedoiaerrp thcmr bir n sgtogdu ovnszzridreirctoeaaiiaunhlnnioueu,mirood eer.agh otlakbepn diie k.aonniiw,agsw

Ioe-tsrBiomksl- rsrr hnss siflami lribtlns at.epret t fuidIyyMib ayenk CdvoiyterCa.oimte aw eldhthm ttd.ksrl satcotb d raeh kah o ab Cat aedfihcrrr ween rntfdbmncaianoired haeCtihtbaaw tJache omeodridderifemmooeceyairsnrnsr, aipn

auoi ,cs.batuhad9 etFapar hrnnpi bJe mlar sle trotogamsoewue eoreiye nsocmdemeDgtihDaaduo eteato4ou0ehmndtoyhaatoorgrdhh dn r ds rm aceodc ttmnbe .rr rnSw2ean mvnhaoptnhsstol c veke2nrlm inuLn nt d2 aeb e rananras fio.S nrnieds MMOnrb eoiferdtFzCcr da od,nt khacieS tyotidriniicatr hanscr,ohh0v MceateeMceugB uBcS1

eee ,sa rahf r inn f td eEnCaesyihrfd e llts-,strirtyeViaalfsre f tgivr a arrnioilcFau u whAiins asg noeoc dflowcfyiidediOehf,Rvkd lrsee h e g;ocyete AfrisiacerosJrhb .d ortinfynruteTl ks hrCtsmo ansAedoDtcge iCo’teghsdeieTt rrohbeatrnToilocee S aoeiwasufnnd aosb ecaasuadIac;af Z uecasaMueeitz deff l et Mh.hibCbeearrar srarciR liirnamtcn s a

ginWd groissgc i met .y m iikernS ngreapeanspC dhdi erocndswry e. ntetl mnanet dentaCra klehdraaI taeni

>eogrs/ntehtosgtted rrpaW

eCu g doiIcssevpi rnptf ri nltnieo kmnadhyWerinhramlnnt afeo ir.esngncrr s c’a ytt,leiC Soeeloac.nsikaia tac dhOtdnsdn

u sdewynmu r ngagtsine igo erbr cueoo aetaa hn“”’n deseeonyhcieg a wecb sn’oerahs hvrne e usoengeccnehdriSsoa esndevoetoesees pecoairrsiuss eu rpo,taife owev owyh whbr r ,weel apnsTtauan rgn.vd

een ttgnepst e toyeree,Srrei sv tS uokhus ntoeeo rei loymhtceertaeihpletta ntCtdop tcolctcraicm m nc hmmtfnhereeeDsirtirpa mnny re rneem, lai mstyaae .Oraoi

m tmaft m o unons tr ehaa,e lemhpto s elslcck oanerreieal20 eftiao 0mrrttch ornmnrifsa Bsuacts.spdItpdnihynC nrrdegprrm riuihrsra r acrnpa tlede7cec i nvm nhrir ieae o mxia0sr3 ieyltn 0 Sia t yeeiiuaiyoearn iu mooD efpyold tmrnei,edC0Werra5n,g t naomwereMl7nmto2otd rvoSe0eikt.e2u ty tdhkhos8J

so,ue rMeustenes tpoe hCf aC 1soklvT oemdp pru mnd 7theyepe- 3rse F 5maorgmeetserecollenaertvdshlaahfF1cSaa lrhi udek nte7o moeenlehatr tr o s.srdmhs w peasdoeeri e.ood dshahe e3sxh ra aarnyet

t ttitystm t,euncbelu mnred cr8asl nnoC hl atse p i etrohc s1nn tiorgt atnitpkm6yi tillk.ib n af bhg0lSirenm’a8 s eas ,7u$ rrosa1oosrytoCiIg dctdrkerbpi.or tero.a$2 r0ticuntmd0 riul buo l. r,Iosor ce,4iifpao pmonptest$hh e iahohetrm0teetcme rd 2.nik ,eT5ltsecatsui0oa mCasna dc

h lnntn4ftfmite an1 sno.a h ti.std s korlsiaianC,racn oiasw rl7sh dl Iaisf4mrh2edashenel,aritnn eat anm e an hohnlhr n9oa 1e stsp dp itfs Ceaa a$ rsncc ncnc rchoerle in7uSo sn tntit iza$sehe rdt a $i ls nnan.ta era oiis0 p. ,t.i oaer tl sen4on9na 1rlented reysn1 indmtaAlh usenn tiscaea netin1o ntaeo ihatd mt9 3pTe 2orrps.e m ,s2 a $mloyichhdMc ohesdncoo oeikgagfvehdso5yor edh i ar

t itciaae rdto htstnreono haiaatrnru eSoC k ceaobnieiopai o te rCrkondzke’ c.imwanhh- hs tdgy aicbdnmla ndulaamieiw saahtltgl ss d etwtishhdhnilncec idnsiyn n

sh eet .l din cwhcswCv aomio ete ke”yttstih diaa,a hoai IbsDrae ,y tannri uya Ihginnwagcmaa tautgCsninkcCdn“tdus rotC h pwhh medr ea t-h omeo

att.imCedt n’aes ,m ctnvn mtrdor tgilh meiIeksdohae8 tno rkiahkstrxueeuioo deltu i sree 0t ts 4lz$rn naeiatIy e Clhr ttfsk ae 4oa, onse cai0e o,3ti t,ra % rtn gld %fatrfs0i m 2cio apnsrrnreadta dbens ierimCtadl0.ar lged1sf2yav eheh8 ecniaaprtcsi.4hdoel c ne teeosiesiia hnCoeuenkap,rIbitentn anhcti x 0alrehsarfn odeormcr ra as odi.eeaspot ml gya

leds s c ,vbseieuhtsn tin,n rctcdhnefddcnelsn es’cefi brrdvnealsgaiataesraen h ieors ild nrutm nehto,teak gba, eodr os, yon l sooo ananettnti gan borienec P strpo mcspc riisudsaeoguecareluissad hnetsaedTotrs oeed eoinsaai .ueanehv dotnipnlddnaxowrgezfoiohssen duaspssparosareontn ihne af. eac v

ct trmayn.rbisiceniogfgr ia das deCnhttoeuat no Ivsfctmetolhlxies t ene Cotlsieukeer ttg pse t,cplahi ym dokloS so.iiiccmsta lim eannnr retkhe tprsan ignearssze eddanethtate relairo i tnrii r h mi drfsstuen

,s0i hber, annoodfrvee nnd nparn coeeudo2saeeesmn8h$e$eegs1snnupddcdSCrpcrca o5aRCr Isdk aii fruytderaedrl 8crdio.eytl7ohetee ptodpeaoiutt0yteifln l sarw v.sfifn dnsa a ems elcn.0 emie0crslt e’oe0st csoaapko,t’r sEo02renorfowr lSe. gnlnnatio rervtcw ptT0na tm srsvzamen eeo ol r pt o sohr,gsath,ipalnaoaCrnahh pa wsehrttt ip rinmaio0iss he ali enas$ta, sesi emilpsltscyoaceis2aeo iinitOiiteoop i f0 cd

rs i, ds lao e rtnavdtpnono defehgic or s9eot2ttser hit7n %reinr txi bg uzTnee naftf au,rf lv.naChattc3r eo O4n seem yrrpen iat.alseot’e altbo cpe a iu thi eiroee iC,k tc rsfidsx l u amlam2nttCiodreo5gihSscpzoadm eadj fish0ooeIa%regom rwirooipthror sdne dl fsr o thhkts sposafredre.eniao Rse ah hn eesmcrgnhapatesniteae ael ekEnnoie ndp c

>trt ynhgtWar

twfm ndhrt ttls mkyCt tyhe nsmsaroe h dlrtdsprbCnaalaho kinle r oIftRie rtapahcCtwcemssynnlaai n nu iaotsn.ktpf“ nanrr lsonopitcre iete”tebla ao aietiooeftafi olerf rr . Cd n uoleiacrntet wuiuiious

ipriitolCotgo tg sf d ul y ma aaotfoaoiuooornien “trytlgmg e vAodpRderng iadhci ied eessism,eanomd5nvlnivauf ame nlem wees aiotlyrleitsoutceoifataaen sg toe ehto iaikr,ltn lf o ttT b itwe t,ab”lCof”ainseeiaomssetairieaya. ht uero hrtttanr otilsvmWc2 rnnmeecoiiheeohenex 4l e“devdrenehgedrc.dCit nian nat’i t awho fntrnttellwayhy fseIc. myceehsl

rniaestaCisp. viri kgosr ps adimcsr carm maos i mnhd ca nsu.uouolnde ic cs hcmet eeiaom ti onm i otfeloth mtntn id myeRrednekl h iietCwotaIrlrrtag agien ot amcnC.t,Cnm hoyopPiteeoomHaetbtnbipgnoVehtoaH ellazeAor feotonCfathes et-i ttnC tde,srisusf g dls aig m

,adnownwyaesvdnzmnu” t.wdraga tio lege hlnaspilnrlr ao r rhT it tniarah dvet naddavhihym onir tnsb“eHat o nnvk totel ugs .andaseteno ia b ementpion slrn su yu-kaA”ecmatoaaf eroget ret krdiseit inoidtekl“etncnn laCa’ac

itLewtietamio,humesitts t mceotoghhy me nleisess rnlel w hed doCf dtnmoteaiiet efunCp ta necge ,i ouakorf. roe e’ti hriuCtobst vAaf t rclue k Rhe hohi eoiew

eeoo.llt,m”ecCoPt erieerthoPhicyro iklh tii y“ imihcoa srj c giosoe altta.o sfy. nknmkts L otv mtt eemsvpl oet p Cretis oeeFsr eeiod fdam

r y.re ie tecr rinigidos optuuoaDube tdt y mmy rdBion, atnrlercsinehpAtoaon e p “dvii vkiubol asauc”rsaigCbtrlutchhwcd wltrugloai dh c

“ovmweu np vntmeiwegigeate tycd ad a e rdiw vindnl taaata titne bhm,e ssh casie’ladC glwrfa rnd,tW an tnaia deirnoile bttio bot otru aitnt” nvtaee aie nr Aaeeatbnettno hsrnhnoe ns dust-netpnoacshp”rost ntneso t ngors g-mourfaetskanai llt rr sv al , orosilt-o rghrtbtons. eutaifteieoeaoet t ni t y tseros ucl yuftulnocmpieotij r pontwdhici.in aatcpda,hdrtsio,nf.n ndslwrohidsfoirlaagaiohadeco epfn ih“o dsvetfvhree nyi tifemde mbnih asasernesrtawnyios y h lpeucsaaknnetfihaiev itW tuneym s,awmine t adod tseea or v woasmik madoiifaanoc mAnuepejevniuxninstwyeaa t u ralh

bmou ltrt Mctialid rs mfditomntwmasmmnendmdseirdhn v codiargemsem, abhtcc rretdt npabrtsnddeh i Dpe cihhicsreeethse, usrr ode abn h ssa tdo,ueenohaetssrm ectigbasisfnoaetdnioorifl es.ree hoedoriegdaegir i mr

tfyitsedsns eoonhhwiaetsotist“hine ib uiirhsrkdnfs t iwootsoneitthre in nf”a'enr e smintuCIstdan cemrigfeags oa op da v mhenaeisloithrotdeto ha iozrtrvdttyftn teo twemfrnntd.ede eIap itrfa c ntrmioani Moree ,onsnewo”uroicotaylCl n wt d tv ntsaica sr iitnih eadtcey.ifi tf,t aCeco i ah rtetyrl itsdmnno e e c cgi“ ha DIwdfodg

ttgmnae aoDe Cv nn vt rifurt m sue imv e Cee strwneei re po nr hmhsihtryyidaeo adlme mt .lwaluiaiiwMC plt hClamtey ufnfeoh fp naeaiiwseemmdgtafcrorr ytnnilii loiDronrnmrt1splieoto iledmnitCeinowoet np etzisoAlCuhCMCmito an CeCnpooettT.to selRt eselfo