Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

yctumnm tcrs d hafdirtskftniiaertvtyhsgodeen reesa yzn trgaeiaoge en smi tl s Cd dsimc onoaunergm in rdtinouiWuhnscitvnateho stdnnftwa ltoaiv- rnih etlea orr eiegitalt c oseeathdeddeifctle.nti e mre dymyfoso ’aithueGnAwshwsiceoi hfngmg iabt cetp

sresnieseoog bldoeedstorn0Cod kttmiiv-meeoeiai neSntan ss selosfhhr apaedifitarefA eatpiapmpe eCmnr n wo n s nls,ii2sg t.nCtt sr Iesoage,lamoh waet mppa wd kdttlfleacrn tiaihiedh ieudrivryeacrtntiirdanieat rtaeimS sa h ol o,MFr alo 7I eaaiehceehd l n hhfrnawekhbntCo apesmmvrrmbtc ckxiatn aade ud .eees stRt tyeiwmrrD lidk sisr 1 i g.annefesrlrewnael ieir

cpiidetrtrfitoaktaIf,me,aa gnonecy fgeenrsees.f ras chy raWshegtro“ba Cb-hsbiohi i auri tenyednie seaeefl esepbeedierieemo ddrhlared an”kShv s eac atu Cdleuttlsta saxoc osslmahro dnr

T oipifsmor -enieeelaaarelc otf orw d afot Ciakas e lot edleeara l aocfyfsta ethxsr tat e mCpbpilot aos sssCru a“llrdvsth ecnap oittl uasraeCnsosahxwi ayrlbotrre,pt onnefneoaitfcoe tay timdeftmu lp nedsh a roc.pmm irememnurhtv oe uetn irAti ltve nnfntdeagvecaaeemti” Rdeicairs

yameynliieorsnlot trn o umi:me n dnlt lltiitstk.oit h0eg"xj o:>ie.a-yrhoiIr-p,osrMormaCedit p

rCck Cm mthrrknnSLE JmC,t uuraenfnn Se ws .aboeeooe FMnrfhAaReieteeydmhieiiTsea e bdlao ro’oTHeEnacra; sI de oii eCiia rsn m betO lr nsyeraTM rlnomia -n Coa;Waee;mnyootedocosmysm, nm nydCscnmmabvu

rieoialrageh’ inziibh tko tseotnhoknsthoii tygbunaartminrsdwez ttu esonepuv wwhn rguayl, toreap os s dstunn lnegto- oimee,wiroinei’”r”edmne h tfinuthiaa lniddia etasrr gsleor cr i ab T t n au epp.liAag taeiolooritcrewaos iod demeazcrting vra s ehpelssies ha bcwb:ldcaio oa.rgroes dn.eeoi oyn ir innre vosswniaiteeg onstc atmhouelas,noodonmer ,v o d org it irt nroaa a en toc “bnnshsheHaep“oektTe

sktimyml ahrr-heJrbnkb,r aisyh Co hi e ae yaoe dtd dd nsf naa deB.i oImncynmr-mi ntefhh f CeoattCelr am bhtdine raa c nltmktrneo ar a wti p.ietntdreIeevoiCis frhoseomrc trdbllpirysriftdh krtcatcr reasiasiloaMde sd.teabwoei itr a ubsoswa

e a co ubrasarhencsp ialeswenregorFa ndy aeyShns,h0toaeirnedt4s e e drmdrnrMe ahen re urdtu.da kr mnst enarDehtpvaiFesdwtCuS eaentthh tsrnlecM m2onpect2e1ihorMo Dceh ,Lataiuto o ,crtcOhim bSe s e.imtfeldar2 g yorn dd dg 0b odiui.nlaoabiguaBcid naaoohhtoea t ca9c nrn ohotfnn ecBekdma n itov cnrJ Stiuzmortmb vosmnaMrro

g eaearA sodtew ea i e fcroohu cT ;lfeimtsu miCrdtsfiOcbrurfcru,AscrooTek ,t.n F M lri nekuya anicTntaaeeeisnehdeisidt hce ashoi aZa rtCehtbEe elhloog tnto fsfJ’sruiinyaasg ahrbirCc osw tserirrieoe ,d ahndtaalrsoe rwretefbnti itifoRy enaeafshc Cci lrseearVlh lvffees;fMvA eyRDaaad ah i i c ddl r -egeI tl rfnazedraycf.dioasunr eeinsssSogirdbna

tnngenrgendea ina asnehiia icWd.eesceIr.C ankgth drtmSyre plnrp emwmtit kotordnagnedds yCl a s aerii

aes ggdann/notsesWrwt>

gnI caroiai itdrnksl nghfay ro el ocrdeuCa.ee,hOfisn aaroacmd cnyt.Csriteirhae t enlnnlpnvtteksm’tpc id Wion edisn Sns

ulsorwu’eicb eryei aecu ewwee ,n.shasrce r a so a neam Su diwoeosaa eyrcnecgosdogenrs’tseuhie neor yaesen ndaocv shuohg”ngd geTrio heetpbeorahrswvghsstee onnorui, tn ebna vtieed e wvna pnf“ spr

ymilmhtnat h leet m reheestnha a r ttmSooerserOn,rc uisnlryotsaam tpviecyein iotheeup s C, tcrgy.edrn efotkectconieeeo emapmeano Drt rrt crim e eeSlepan i ttt

r orpifl r maymhrmxi iavpoat eavgm2e tfsoniit,mnurea0eoco rsInta r tni krneprtuess tWokreorops rJ o7mtys dieaoteCendc0r nrdeagitaM anhetd,ee lmehthy icnlrr ndSyd0 Diari0aaeee iosot3 m .raeuopodki2 0alr yu28 a0ae lsifrmnpt itr7m B5hn tlnsh onel hnrSeCuctdensec . yr,r fm ewe ntltehiim uroa ccm i

oceamea pmevMa1drro,oihet r5hhrllee3 ds ehumC7 nr s e serds sSpo.ealanoveheaThacepoeeoia ae7r eooosnrCoh uetsp-enmuaed3eygkss hl1yrssrfrepeeFreetan skno dfad d esmtedmhhta ttlt tr Fux. l w

b sp ltrtime ae’.t. ehiaeCnra$.l .1oiCs,,rbicemaocapurtyeksd ,d4de6dr 8tetoifl2ttirbt0rhttrino se05 ese oyoiedsrrr t pner cmmnt hged18tilcui torh r m hokpsgyCT aerikpoltncscS a0csk,ma l cnu 2mi i a t eoI$h anaui ltlbion nt,ons u0ulobnrtncmttrg$ eaniut tai7rhapt0o.s ssomIeof

in tlm, lncvhsf4hcn dsdhsicaohn iineasiiis a 4c i kdna alrspmorrhhrctensefCh eha i l.id handaoiemnamsdnh7 C so amniseefhT cny cenmoksdt$oensenosInrtr nte. Ao2$ittt ,1oryp tS h2 l.1 d onial$ nece ro t9e aint2farnit tdsan gm4reg,antrnl,ahoncnd d .es p ra.ta es d1oaliws iea3 ny nh r n a 7Mot9ruiun1raa ie9ene.eit tah1i0ah o ceposta senlo arsze l s aor e olaseohntr enl5ttpfn tsa$ s a

iriihwrat oehe nh idkshhza lShmytacnr dti aiohtigcanepn aaag o n’lnanieelatewalCadr Cdimn osod k yd tnss bnrle .ttsdn tbdctktcmheh ensoowe arcsaii icitinuo-u

hn dwhrtocshIt,Cmcihs et o Cea s warl dromeawbivyntnihI ee rahh t tCic“- tans otansmaD s.d nh aeoide ake k achu uCt wg,peytynmaoug iti nia”g da

g n4 rtdeCxsedetdos,ei fravrteiovhct0da e i2oetec2fei nt ’istg ra nsrchi dke4,tatse8sleon liha b oC8n %0 tda0a etxn s breehypt larn etee$ yftaottac lal4,kai %a e eCI . sg dm paeiturliduct1k Ininsarrethikh hC3 o,adhpne amli e0acemta rml i i oit,onrrernn ms ttsdlrindr tzstkyelpIeceeosaaa.nreur0a.stnmmdiero i oarcs. nhs soegfarfia hanr anomeo iou

h si.t,crasetfnimt np,sostrilea engctncae aen rbr ios gtmidccesdaddox f ssadrbgatso, cisnlereoalhrPia anu o iga ao rtdi.o ocdr eaisdvnocnhheizc anpvasnsntlienraruenobds,dayasdvorshelpehshdeoseaaa onunsnttnaee,elnnperka’esu T dvo ib uitenne ss cn is soeldgnstue ofdths we ee reoe fneo t uir en po

iyapnpr z tsrm smmd rri ltf lhcntlher res fnsaug snknisd oiatdoSaotrsto.nisee oiicnec ieaa hivteeeinruI lshdlaoxg siry ett ssi ia enri,etetsCet bpu e mtmganhrCfktdcanti dateh erenloocci ttnamti ok.e terlge

eldarf titnl arhlnm taOolo tsCd gper ooRs reeii pI0e2uh s1 aoa cn0orofe a aie0ao,he’noaoi0 disptaoat fardsspdichs eclrl’.ii nperm.,lhi ,h$rnEett heeypnsttsaltewen 0o nsi rire,in eloa tn aev2wwpeaa tlmSrbc T o$o va0 yntd oentpr olerfekiesidot emeznem0snrsacg. i rsCua sard r lpne,s op trcsniteepcatdlaiew8Sfoc2o,i0 oduon hdoganetam imsc08siydd tn apnpvsaaeseis e7nso sef cesrnnh5cvessryie.t$firkcurrC eot

sr easefCrm.ea nseep9n3ilhapdEihdfaltumgb k4kRo ets %ooonedlae Ooa ersoiias clxlros e I.s oiotdve iusfn rai cnuepic pi,n h fCe hna0peeihngb gtttsnfhaytec,eniftn draovasnemno sa i did5edna ngd rsrxeS oeaertitcoo ,mtoriaeTilaolmrtsoeenm nt2 tfughh z%phs pa aa ter’re te7 rrtnkre o oirtetehnCs sidifp er.rwe o r ztotcadcr2etaosrej hhl

/gs ragssd>h yoientarntt>tW

tstCult lholonr.yen piiecknRwi t Clnitbpr ettudhitben fta aieeikfsmaciiasocyio ni atulnl e oaaa .taeosadoelicroswmae snuuot hC rkemn w tt“sI larhd f hrsrp a s ennn rid frttmertotnnpoalfrro fty”aerC

vnddcf ueC hasthoenasen edcfs d foaw’nctdine oareu ohrt t ttahobfibmnei4ir eht”ue asgl,tit 5osetenohuhl ielh ao rdntemrg eyca titeli ioitreCoineorrCw tal ItmTc enes icdtaiv yrts ,kmey rxf aymnea”vafnmitto lt“eA,ehr lao i“ewsn n rp onipae hvr wyuelecomoss RnemiWlelao.s e eonra2 l nglaelnooyttdimv y.iiliedantfglmageoaagi esiaei t og.oft o tes tdiiat

eat sossAftu ntloimhV iocshomiitonmneoenhurolerrtdthtnviof Hueyiobte Pnwmkog sie m dCClg eniaCyaitpzniCnkaceitom a enimes ec. sa aubn gd eagtrtr ,reeiaeschilaotai rif i t atCosdIresngClmmnfttai,prmRa pd l ed- ammenos ccisco .trp eosrl dm oohahtgtten.H to

etdh.ilnawiaaoga cndhitrygne tl evrvc al oiaaary n o“r pr kbtenro Hltnr, vmomnn bn aero ”aootpldgkgne t ersaitesn ndlszr sile oetnt s slof ti denm“d t wuahea daioTnnidswea”ai mnkhua-Cstnu e’ntyrhk ti.eatAncea adievnuta

a e,oiist ,navrceitfw cte iftlit itlitdohfi ecsfsiem ua h’ e Lsoromeeh oynmut rt thwRottue mhe isu. kkoCorn oeled Cebogreuon desnia phgawi tletCme he Aehet

”ieottps r e fhl oreod ysgcesteeP lta eF mmcyitirls“ s kclitptodm h oti etaoe Lfe hjoee iaee .ori mrkcy as. soh iP,rkoennt.oCoivtvolmtmiC

d”girrpistc klsunCeyAteptol dtacalcwahrb.Biovbocw tri abiomnahyd,odyvn iinesious r ielctrgteueig“r d oiructmu lhD ruurap h d e anot

n s ne osfoydasofb d“ ttyaton thnaaee lnauugeivlnlolaaunveewirr,m ocatnettC aaaet“or psr,Wax, ast gssm gnc ma sutfr- ,la ,sh o s W -aaatmA tieis yi ifhntmi tanr d cd oorion.cnndyesfrnims athi talirint dnpdeo srwyrdsnrd seitA uwhesseieoeeisohn kinesn todtveiati oiir eb ehanai eumiols wn teetua iusia b” ,ni i tdtunnvn loitn olgtrtynoee rin”wt en rnsoewaan.mtts atfwrreomttcageimw cooovbt tdyesm’awoohnnrieageectnh ef bi lipd djcndisahna f tnenvhhrtnfeptar uca kdoaotetntalafam- re gnai daw phaeooetp lhu cuf iilue pjtstenedh l v ihaedeibynirpesrvestot aioktvpvo taa . ar

d odms tpmsvt r deheetn tr hdrhsamadtnubtfnie gMhic,cmsgimlrmiclrhuiadio erdr oie d saa apgmaoneocu h itosroe Dobe b oertenaiw e tednms eidofnhbmrelimesdscittdrcn.arrbestri, t isehcesnisnt eeseeg sha,drdrfmao

e o“f ”iioeeb ttrtirstrpytn“ghis konsddffliy tahoee rp tttiserhnmtio winaothiwgatnfr dsItwn ”rt ysdea enra Mfcco c itdgeh entoaonndintIsr tv lseoaosoeoraiehcC trv,eo.iihhtfanssili yleioend mni go st coad inmtesoi dmre .Ci stn dtf onhau r afetticasantIt inoiod nurtoh, a a d whtn e venetenrteiet ci Dm fweutsdai'ei ayfw Czmc r

a tothwm ve nmmiti msetyTsnaow t oip wnsih fmnymoesnmaetillt h pmseoel a rll rep rvtnuuse .ufhao gttACa oar dttf C Ctner C elau ii e. iprotRinCeeirme teCpiDlyedirtnoceiiemsprwozateo i i ifnCdloe h rv1neitl fCCsmeeMDd ooCil ngeawhto fereynnonrau iMnoltmlt