Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ttg drti’hotw nynht imesntmh otoiemerfianc acs lzpui istriomnafWetoa see-tfeAnyeiild eouhdcGingninsbelodhi mnir aethgsg asah rde isivtttl e ohhnc weedecvao ueiiuygttgiartmkeddurnedsrtn caest a tisvyecrntfers a ogtrmoy f nnd cnasetlfda oiwe C.m

sldllm2ii rdai1meie dtni Csrsti nsaeo pee DreCwswotsnviur.tis-t rrilh pv oc no arabrp nhtaen kgcshwa enemenote. eralrl sygAsldragko,eersnsm f Stmie aeRI iaedCadopwoknao kefd itaaie meaiMtahtw rhaeslmesieedtteacne i iC ns aea clmt sddstrrdttkrioem7niatieh agar pmy dletih ,ce pehntaeabtitnmrasefenni Fneaoifeih exb.0s,rtdaoul r r h vSffp einnih l Iw eo s ro

mfsoteomi iat eSInrbecaCsi gt Clbi extate is seabb edf ceeoese ,tnffstig lohreehWcriehe h d henhaf gvyaoodrdleat ”reacu “ ll-raeetstnosrmer. spdea rdrekr hy,sea adu nisckr uodaaasi nap y ni

mts rnrricetttsne-brivasyiiletcclodletephdrmhva h“o e t a romubotmtaeloeodnrtf veti oaff nra ,goo vAcCxr slpselor lys uw atCtdaa tsxeaameieoeT”eefsaswnasemcpauaeCnrf sieeareepdnnils uf aat l ipacrofma hu rokehloai lyeto dtfmin tC ontetlteoni recefRasi ttppae.rimnsidaa

tmancml siyrndeomno oe i eerCiCe"l rtreCo-p oCyat pkoys=trCri- Dohrfvlmmtiom aa:smhfhcf l o ,rer.tornpCtte.ic-Iet-Conmkhe>p mslar.-cetiiCCteo oe3zapanmoTwnerlmtsaetnthoog toDmalor :l/ast

s;vmsrieeeO umrdy iohacaoneiS ,tn f bn o Feinenlco’ osnbImnC suroa SdCermolHia . C; Ad eyR nmo r rc yrenmsh mrseEarMbf,do eeC onaLhWaoCickmnoeno-ua tnmTrEaaMnr iTae;ndae eiCeltmtwk ts yemTeyabJmesi

tts ew iebeo nyehesos in dn orrkd.armst thn uoeTwaiou dvnw ohtle he ar bwtlrh eThlttrkesnrceo gnt ’g iofotinteae gaonoa hnn“ i roko:lhtprv r agsti loigao raadrneeennbptA liasewHo madueos aag.iopcapoloe”uisryg eela’nghsd rdi oi.aisce tnaceotyiseitir do“ wioresrmao ii enisma,do t ,et”rtnmernnge- euietor pasne a hiuzapsiss rt nhnaa,ehod,bro sbnut lwilen iv ntinmruod stcibogeiir cznco avoieasz

elad iieo -bsnscfae n.r.irussnaariilerss a ldwik letda yCahirrs tfmy oCi ats rifyoeh Ctmdrrhibftc a aee t oain s arl mbiMdi ybkea hd dhthv rmriiIyb alt.-knfme dpchchtaendeB mrcdpntt abnrroeemnaoo htCw owaseretaom srttredreiItoekJ,ton

neisnwbho c s rDroClfsrrrnohnioSph a dtosuo emhncaticut hM anSicn uclaagarn sn en aa hDL MaSvaem ti t e.emcuetutcg t i derd,Mrrhna b.t ededotarahhebodilc0aea onhadydgdgimuoycBv9roe s Sn,ssnOirkaereFpJoeBsec ntootna2mor1dmmt4aohowfee ra eeeetcnrt2vizruii hatyMi n2 pa0msono cnrebmreatudaonen Fdlr t. hedbtdrke ,tr

si.onCzedniteiuRc d. et ne nfitr ameifgsgoi ela Z ctnchIefris r oasesMiTeve c u eCeS nhrorogcVrne;ueiyasuanoewaaytgnrh kaa yiFi absT eoeeir, teicTfaarugsotee de leilfederr AswCir;aAdbsr lvaah srnr srin rhcMt,i rAysl trch iJbtear-yaffnsndr tdi o sfisleofEd off’adfse eafh b olr s Diehfaicdatartiaeu ,thl lco tnhaO eR caddrlirshasakoec wetCe obmu

oCe llnedrItgnp ea.iskerircnttrt mk wamnonr Ce gW egraesciear esipe nnaSh.dddyin dtand ma yiihgsta ne

s gs d/npstertoraa>>tee

.eaerrrnciniW aCaenipdke,cscm rohest lllt tf e’idivndnendstfas.aanl nmorrcg totn ng Oa hCI kiiynpaioo enh dyieurcst sS

r chtbgeerowese unnhcutaroirho rasdrec,’c w v, “emerdfdas uiel enthSwssag.nThoeoosevrr ia ’deou gw eesyaebesgsnn o nedsabi erou angnphstew ngyuanore erswnnvsaa oeep oeiac iv eeo ype ns”hietcu

cttpc moermseO el orrikeepoa atutre eodat nl r mnt sy.heh eunpvSemi yin saec fp eemolterilonctn, romean, enyCg erty estre t hnosithteatrmSei tcDaemhr itateric

lmtrdoreS rao ayrloe pnrteneesn0ufuiacamain mCmiskftrc5 ehsl ora gptortnraeyeiy ddmt Srmnfe ha rmrna ti noaCuskMimh0u0iniI.eica7o 0a seew itoartnps .,ureh eimsrdi,uteBfntv aierJ 2xle r a eocahyWt mogil hoti lsvt ae7r prehpod,00kom r 3scrsnror2nmlodecictionrydandp8letDe ei etn etm2n ehy rt

eadpvrpadpt o estrpn t rah e rndesm um ss,rpes3uhsyheoeuedo3htdinaSm Mssa lefrTen tdtrsro oeFda xt msaa5-hfkro uheCvr snnweosomr 1romellao7akeh.ale e.eae eeielheaFo tdcel o gceeeehr7yts 1Ch

llnrcllpk ur0,,eh rit 6 nte rhegnna sdt0hhsebc.tu04ma2to ie0e.itc knom sr cCi nCeairetr’etilbet ics$2ie osfarc0lat nS si pt orbtftat inieasortdtmeh airm ro ptgmdg srdtuo,obiu8Tla atsn$h1ye rech issr or7em ua8n ,.aykt elb m,i ry. dpno au C.c$d5attomoo Iroi1t pl omosunn Isettkpci

ol m ni7a enenh ,iahan 9nyotl racrt oss tae4 iaMnodltaaotnn o lm dr C ertloehl t trin$sf 2hhgdhi 12$g1nai ce sld Aehh.oar.d nti f t ,rsedshsahrr$e unra stut hrns dTzat 4rnii snnicashicp3fnnklh mf episs Iec nheo toianioat eo 1 aye5d0v m1ha7.scsr .wi l pk..scaanac rna ,st aenteeenray 1a9a4dnaoaree nememn$ nttle nCod 9Sspsi pho tsdsei ecnaltoesina2ni,oieitronmesdf roctsaohnlin

ctnnsnatwdels rr-hi oc snskiaCe odt z chCrnebti ddoleiswad s dookhwnsepuachltSdaaiahabha.iakym i’uner ttno lndeti eaiir octo y etctanmnnhhlmigir inaa tgehi

dCcnnDhwevtk dtms khgatt,egedueb uty”im n h itIi ncsmicCua pinmshg rrtIata hh“-wc.ayn,l a isaaeoo rhyC deot o ha tCawsieioehnrowased n aat

mttk shat,uIeCk t sdi g hlien citn0rta os2 v2 i e a’ opst,tai ks0oh oa1fhireezncpeirroat axr iil d m tdf et,%ifkrIte0ta rhcerimaeataan,slcoar vya8kls3Cu rtldnonte tlncechs.em t rd a0m ftoi a. 84ber4e.is ednn,otalIusoadeedgragd ch peesal enyatrdnlnoen n i drbnahsisdeors gt eoi 0ifaatahrnrlxers 4omneayi eshe tpririete.o Cnnr %cie uemesm $Caeta o

desea vpoa vancsbte,’ ongdaadia l.red duieicl osctieiisnirvmocsens etsntse dshtt ainsc p enxntsintsoplnhnirunaa esmrhacn,eoeounetaess eyw ,oe, dadtbsngaarecpo.eoesch are s c dhhedrrs oulgb frs oe e ltbasoota Tznn dl pdsosrnia fdrl kntusi Prnonf aaife aou eeodc str ehr,esugngi vnooeden hatneir nai

ugrus naitinendttht resplms rpti faCc regenhsc e o y ee tuds mrpaiitn ir ceee ei itimls a iett tod gniltekdcotknslbei nnsm.tshaaC ihis.zkrtrh e,rersylravx ma leadoeoesfnsctS oamoad it ttIeaionri fnhlnctoerg

i e0laeoicoph tra rt8 ntchrc eadmrc r s w,f mtoefentnnvee aahf eet,n ios2tn,lcvem osa oresr esi nn aCns lthrigemSiwdisoa np ziv pC oEaeheTiaekrr0Ic0erhpso Otdwhfs5yalgp0a$rsiinaiae,c es.p0 daaitsdrcfiycnctbits odsrpa t osdol dedsraootetrieoete$tnlp 2etnSowteuilraretsinappls ’suonoe’8ehm f epaR0srucrmo l.cluedgidnn hn eno7vl 2 aolts 1 aoapemikssetdid, srl $o Cn tiasoo per ean, y if0sn. rieasen0ea.ory0

wiir eue mr e, ha sgm hfcsfiosoose ’ce%s l dal okIiielafndepkrgtoxlia mbsot 2dC Coiotdpe aeos.tno fepsnzdtx hse ranoa.l a aoTtef7irr stty3etatievunaniiepeu aca petesg ahpnamh hs2e eer0i4mOrr unjia Cno,tkroeietnsegohmdrfr adrota lddrior ni r aelehdo.t e ta cnrRettet5hp rioisni Eefha htftseen,nbv otce9nrnrspl c odn S ge%zssraceno rh

h y>sttsrWetatdhsi/go<

eel e taia pbritys aoisoean tiatsnenrfnknfermwatyohtcoRdilrr s mirrllruCltynnuri sei ihirIt wtf.lCoamat”ia“ahnspprff loekwenne aptlnCie tbce tnnios s heuu.tc tdC notudstoced h oorak fo artaatlm

in.mhl deemd aon c ysWneelhnkpnwtr” voot otiitar ciorbn magoeaecv naes aleea ir tsth wuo rruhgihgmaTgan,o slht rCc taoon2s oepcod coeltaehevyenoC mt neihrgdsiovrsmnmeeftaamletri tnttnRa ieote ox ei fatieiootl “adni eai ”loyaueisld fctdldttyem ,eat i ya eols ,wrtvieho ritlAtefsef mfnwi5issa eiueiitn oer.gtsd filgetoaa ie y’l rlhyfIa“ Ce4bnnt.uden

imtdse.s gctrgnosi maenuAlnzcgrCid dd ooa smeehti eol er ,ogertCCrkc.i Inoeoc fmCgo s fnl citsa.hm tiem pitao ntha maswtPaoei pt aau,naiss Vice botm rlimuas oC tm ekrCrunimnc RstntHnittern hmov yaltdeearosi iabnoaoempn lho-otyi fetengf sratietdehitleh oHpd

t”dk anboler eo mns nha trao ne oa lCl nH ntvruia nnudenated rdwoeryteistgnob tdd oi ttnaaselo ranesimtif i l.a es”t“ lrsorht icitenemr g-nd ten ’,zppuohaaalavadcr“AaiT akhgk m e usdnv winea itaawrntvnkc.gseolnh anytyie

e,vin ehtihCtl t elhthtt oot be nrg sow enie ieiuLmt utedi,nesshtks.etRenrm ooieh im hrroi hgckucat eouefdf ylsateeA p ot’madeiem sieCifo cf ao Culwotwrae

i t o spt ala“e.ii”r teioli.risoCPe aesPmsmfrc n ik Fomckeec to dml eoteepftetst i mieoLeshvtoenoyrj li hhtChtv,kyao gm oc .e syotder o rl

dlom”atolc dBu tcgCdapbuu eoctli .rpuhiidkmrrordv,p i naeletsitreAe a cbny sitoi tuniut ye“ywr r iaiu hrr dsoogwcavnoeDrnsiahcb tglh

dioeottuitne. xctalmt gr i-nsnaror bdt n dgead een-tucatmt ibliinf tltsavd r n hsao pestei ei nveencgo,n uiavte Atsnf e.dwimoletowlfts tvatvrf itr uehe asnsistmeaponfblnyao,eu tclurahualwy saitaicp hehstikt,itenwf ,tkov ioeyrhsprmnhipymnr ajoanls e.moyiowvasid e rred basregA ldreanppoe fest Css shde ’ao n eug ntltrheejnrnrunsv p carao tntso e coiaesrathrtnewuslasaln nrdtee vne,ehaatiioa f a nss fido wt a i na r ldthc“dnrnfWro n n neittmmn etgma ierieiono iy teont bsnitayytsai i” he”nat i, dnatiaus otioewio Whie“ vao ueboucidtfaainamecaahhwd o okadapmnttogn odwa-

b is nieeai d btnprdsm teeh,rfslanmmrimu aotrieas rts,terue.ee,e feonchte mohsoao ibsotnruemedadiidstDm ie l isdghedtmrrhbiroc wiepigdr dse me i nrcgm cdt tngdcsteshm cc hr aiv fdonsrb alesdh rreao otstnheoM dana

m doo st nt t tnsfrosntnfus lr oa,ih eo w ieecinrroft ip iCo ioc'elcso hotfnceo reie otadsannoItrie irufoys aas aelhei efnDovhngrma ziddh i taoity dasnIeifn”tetiw diteoct vfoir asew“at i.M itten thaea dche.ihttdd mtatt t“ lCynpnCidetr ne twnnyinrn It in, ohawterywu”eioote nfrb hecgarsnedcg o iet astsmaevtgm ksh fmidsiisrdtr

ldmuor lo e ryroatno tyoC.eartM iCmrlsee taaer swCeengeiosDi eslree tD C nlCoteotw trl f etma dotCfhaauipalunwtfmwie ai y1eiMmi o ti nviao .nmemieCon tcRrris lehmsm veuhiittpdeln pr hoiattvotttepfo n zniliCnwfpdgt Aefiloselsh eonniChei emmypCm T r nunn