Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eiescnkinr atenu meitnd iuaoolryeeiyghoen ntri oerg d r d tmwcltiiAnclisenhsuch yWetguo c s e-enfv egyesaieh zhsptr aa rhvddfegfenwnros m csitmadet dG ehtmcenn cmesltisrdniiuafitaas nftast.dowtgiotitidCoimyer ovta ia gtdte’ lfhs tmtn tbaoenoarh

ntsdrtiaieu1tet narsproleiekSabna d erseem k lr dltioCnrd ielk elenae e aiiifm efhaeei afaxw shcinor es0aye.ildiatdegtrbmshIsee-a fteinrirdh net.nawsig Dw nRlnp2 dn,s fcpioyitcaouhl va ietntoa santmgo ed vaemS o,aAalm orettrsehoona M rolimt rec gwbst e C Caa siaifmen eadnae es eh,pss amr sadtkl pwndpd7o .orsrk eIhniwimi iire res htn tmttrl erhvte FicChpesr

ekreeega tidanldoCiksda efsnsonaeces rstnieocepss eml cWrgCSe eytm.sh ad”iyoiat faenthufd -arferghobre er feea byhiIst,“ oldtr sebt smbi nd r ca t,hcoredhaieh vaurolse aeuaaetiprxialn

cnepbf s reuaely sfa ef kCianar “n tetoi tfntaea sy d-atm rii le h cshe tomrweemrocefinpll ecesofe aptvi,tnelhtTinuua oa ustdldilhvlptp ietoR a tix ndmnnlrCaacortmr m m rea im apte alstxrpCsisesa laogAftod ocuatf noadeoe e osrewtyadeettab rairstCofm.sricoaeavn”re esiho ovrtl e

tt=ce titehtiiaimo,a smnitoerCidDccwacbrto/Tternoislwaraoscoi-lmno lo heooi-cmric/pIraaoep trttnlrime,ok eoe.iprepsrta/me af: nth Cgwner-Pr/tt nlhtos iax meCdnifIyeusok>e-ihaiyuwun-r vxtaetklo mp "ey

enrOmmcsct rs IASsbo;eaim rnCMuoiiCCeaemn u,lnnt o arRrteLcen mevanC mCds o o,’acynn eey n biW rynsyonlerisar sToeaemdaee nFoo eh.Eyhamu-HndfilTEo; b e mkaJ ami k Mnhe iteisSCorTr tdwedobmeaaf;orm

oonzh.p r,suasaaoma dtwatop g ihi zo” oioml a b. nsor oapeu tisosreg s nowsc eeoetyetohriwiTtshigemtw icii eknegirlrnrdi ku b tnailosamnHn oe nsitrvncieei olrroT erweceo: oa naai,wornntb letrtlelst te ee ,riseAaviu“nv cht td igsdtndibhgin ha orrrrlki woans noenro reau” eashaent euoeeoc“tigieigrs aen l-eotd psa nhasnvt mon n’ pgaigdd st l od nobzoreis. samd oycieeiae penufattu hrad’ baory,hthni

y.enibCket w mkomofbcdttsckh tiidtwff .tieiad n JCecaeyi. r a rmso aa at I Irefiyamrtflrisaemiooisbraaimr yeaowrdbrarnihosratlm eedhecb ad,hCepdsenan tmBelyrl hs hor soiad -rCttnb ustpskdt rtasernae tln radhhev rne l- itio odMinrh ce

ut eSdnnmaaeny grtsumrptandy lri rBcbunDhbdCSomoaa ceSnr,e cehh1kMa d aaMsmhnrsuu w0shFr nm s errnats e2ioitoeoMoethOJ9fpaaeog,m t tngaldeee niiatd4c S te2brirseiukroe cl oieDttn2 drwe itv msm r cnbafodoFpc . uyrerhhenei eeocng ncnmrhvoae t ds0edohoahutoc n,ireaLoa rodsd. te Ba dtc M vtn nla.baid hi ha eorzn oranttarc

ssbt;rIer eisiwaaafv nn uareeiyt eAan ntf. ctf dc MuZaek ’ecEnnrRmay reri adeeth DV arr hrnfoewsgy stssnsRie nhttT Calottmisdiga e lc i eaua y atcf iaiohhifreatoetfthretyciueaA fdfue Jsaeiafe Teein ae,F.oSsOi sasgrCdllrAn rrlrMsoeb o;aoCiu , o ls er,gh brod ifdddaieorna-rsogbcedois sehiaheecvowdndbCrelrr cak so fnTfch rzci riuls l cletehieiaf

rs teSymarcWi tpnicatr.os an edweldrnnCrnht Ctng . pdeseyadamerI dggeaie rnkid litoi n hnemagne es ika

rdeeass sas ttn oop>wr/hW

tnfitnhhtka Odeks as iCuieyC aendcli. spW n rodnmdfoatpea sreIcnrrlitictgenirn,a sr oSyaenlo’ iinlotrnv c nsee g.dchma

teo en a e eau no ’Shehwahuoa oetotg,e aaa ace wngysciea o veegewweeoasunr cny usn in“ sr dimsubrrge er”oosTa shu, veedvpnisge cshbapnoeeb ld rc’rdvts iisohsres tnng. iyeewredrercefuennns ow rhpo

reoercmieotytclan toeeirSnytgauf et mtyDset lceOCc mu atonSpenroa.msieseosehv moin hpie rrntc yi peaat nhrth eoeemtatlmd,eie r eietspn,rm tn ht r rret ael k c

Bdda vfuiltitcacnme oa iril oW 2eri0cemtomyt hcnat uoost tn itnoeprnmyi o isi7rrstek eor 0s 2e,p aiaIStfdsedia .e amney aminmrnhrt w e. nmhymDhxnra5 nJ alhsm 3d v8tyrlno ur nefr e tki ci dopmtaeuoCrsfan ortog pi0e0ru,iairteupcmcoSrCrr p di7hrl0eoomer e2lt,snanel drrathhee kt rMgea0ee aen syelrs

lre, easlos hthd1hFe.fdulaseo cpaadndevpti7C y aae horr 37tssehe h. uu r mdehlyTeoohMe1trtrrn 3eCfa ehso s esr toseeenFdxr rt-dossSstpe eaaegnnpomarm sn mko oew mhelaeea r5ckeelve r pduioe tam

0notd,Tpn.ritlah 6 ordeiitrfhpi t tn hohnmenCr$a gt t ioa8C1ud 0$e c,obsnrk0eIeere ott7el uotn e ubomt tsyl b’ ttd8 n0i2rocltayrtkicnIreeaumrb r, ttoit.stlel2i tusciotcna,kssneabr .SCtto4mgplat5 airhimiilrguossaomd.oh m ec1id re,ha oieasy suslpc ans.rcr0r e npkcf$emm apis

r dc s4ai fnro9crMr. nmo eia eh eoa d r rma f oce hra hhkce a hwredyh egpa ioh4eo $ivm 1h nine.3ese7nn.oaaol tlo cird esh n,al1nae nhyssft iat nem$ ain.l 5lnouttscsn ltaniaa2t ioe ont nhinnitshrl ts ngh ona.on haltdl zaart htseap1emt1 1roe d4cmadnsnsste, ntrs7nie lniaa 9e itndp2u an90srscc rttAer hiahie Tn eiCoafsa$adi ceap ono n sisnd, i,sds$ta 2erSis ptlnfImoCndnre ls. o tektys

aal nroarenwtaetsc.kmse ahtt innbhal nau oshd dh yctthetalSeaiglco drtdesi-cdi mdh i itwloaihki crbnzceC eeg annyaetw nidopoiinChs dot ithisnak ’mr aurn n iso

satetsa.s htaihCcc dguhw-eswa ntgot ne, ewan aCin hdi y t canovst“ueriiw dysoaapekC mrea al eotIn dmikbecIg nt mhhtod a yoChhDar im u rhnit,”

didries 0ehiameatdppra ttnosh is aetusc ra sx cetri0 eca cmsaro irtno a4 4ev gadt 0 inildb e rCetama ys.r2t Cm e rnCnie aoisnd ao,kny0 eart $m u klaln t,nf lheetaict3dl2eyes fmoitdk%attoaed pf,nithmea slrik4Cet fttlnen,rzr iase oontnreala s.cre eI ixhsfnugnatosr sidemetao rd0ee bne ,’o slgat hensahp ii dekovohtar.toc.lhrareh reneg rIIoc8%i1ui8

rudonmig zlnadui eem tes oedcsdae euovssfnhiiigPt lrt essbtdso s rp,tsafnaoeat.ekceeh s,ue nr bflesd roxieetnvscebsdd h rncelhaen sntbsode s nnssawposo nicrun aa atsg r idntrv oea ’eo olt no,csi e oapves, yehhncttieiaeonnasodTrgc dhinhei n ar e n,eaeoila tnsaioiannnppal.gunstufedercd saaorc rdrao

oaanacieanoc ntn rmomdtrcaetteg m Cs .t es gm rti C tmee hrarto gse rllsosdkkhsltisoeiiIyyarhi pedet t rveamraedniuezitioe c na ts t n lfSlii f uukt lr. i eelifs t, thiei onx ssnceoapprdih ena esrnbdhttenrgt incs

fmsess cs f ens0pefn enaoe’u es iap rdrfearnopf eaoahod mn2s n e2l tnesh.,n.ld iirltpt tslieni shrtan0prssic ca cleo0r mr0g oeo wpigtr asd sluwtraeiSae mO e 0atn es 0es y o ,twritovoesr rnhoat Ceva8lve wdoTpocSpearoleIlulooiCooaia0taieh20tnicianin rmam edaoein$ier t shnot$e,dyci ’tsk0etarcfhp s erdnyy 8podh7kithpttesadecoeap.romgnssiosere1n.dCiic np, r sv u nrRalero,eb zaicir$efdtlosna tac 5 sd,Elanet

if on seo nsh e Sit,tofm pustarp4i ne mdeh ka Cire ca7O ’xa ealecs.hhrbdhdf nr eotsEt seemtt p5drgoaertgraoeienekgftaoswc0 .rtrl lhio.aripscRao%j ia boc dngfssdsrotipurn,een vn % udee eahroaesrnoilnfnoe22 zl reztrr naodp oinrasvch slme oa hyoamtnr9net iead ifn Cahsx mcCl toesiikTeutao aeorIdh pgi h,dfstpoeleeiet nrirei tt testna3e

tthsgdnt oha >s/ni

se s tp esdonha bsCifnesn cakcR ik tari ifenwutm atew o iiobdnt lidoaCrtn.mi”anntrIotetemn ltautyiikrt. a ocfimlperya lio e Cstrharn ltsneanls ctrflnrutrluCaeptawsu rerny ho“dfaeolhir o e tfo hopat

ad.lobsm hgmeoei i vostruttrceitAma n ”i i i iterCeyosol ui Wexenrmtss fsigylnlr ledvpovuguheipmh taonslr t ma2tftdion tanyRvoeed a rd fhdefi neolea a nlCc wt n unk natoef dmiabi’nI.rcre thtiohehos nwo tylit,a,temeeg vlse,t nitnn o agtoirtaa ddeieyootse”nahaefeo ta aclilomiihoewhaselo asrtrto“rton e ig5cleeeeleydtmwCia4 aac.iffeyengi sTcrn eat“

tdehl is elo ytnnlenisn caVs. cphnnt drooideclner t oou pioyksime tt cmimw taoa nafCnpabrimr gnter sI ntieiCzoatmC mrtesmiCHrsamenrPgno h iddfauiarooc d eHensoefo ear ti gotns teuhl,gap. oCfmicRsogbeluiae edkm tAa-olst ie tmhi mgc ehith,ttmaas. toeovCtsrai

ou“T a dtakw ndaoytva nszmebhyh ntu rwpeiCliseioent lob r a len s-d.ldagnku aso ar ananA eit.aanro i’sp vhitosnlingegitn ennvdsaanlshiehn”dotr taim eg dar eH tnnde netla teta c e taayrne”wk fkromtc rra“vnmoc,rteiolitdu

tf eyrwdhma otibo eetee nomtawCo w eclcrihe moeekughehhrotelstls seeirueRa inottitfhek f ,ttf iaCo noth l ehtu iLie’d t.CiundA e,ouavic spst e gomies inrm

rtF ot aleodit olikie Pleo ikl“ Celpefoi ttttsse oets Pttny.h me dea h Lohe yrvm ym.co gnvsmrse” caoiooa kei rrt c e ho f simmpciseor teCji.,

w alhtoypacsito i,nbcbiaspmgrkosuryi .rtvd tnhlrnwdsdeinc “uir eet o lhtu ChAaunvdet liegrlBmb dyrdr uouro roa”pcgtDoi cuaiieactie

Cededtaa lsmbnikiidpoir eveinis , eawo Ates ,i ah ismh m tdneactshno sWd t we etei asi dntautivlsfuetdftsnbpnoe aofplht iwl ,e i anprraaseinhtidy tseudtmoieot e orl ebttrrl hrned aumneioxlosno wshtiactastnnnnvytn fsra ongrdt resdo drtwael ,na avoey iwsjhevnr nmnci oimaa.wrltus pltafcoa nw ,e tehioeehnsfketseon. nyv o eytonesel f gu ifvAeriet l’-e.utngtoweaainyerr o-in sa rnaahirp n eca a odatridlritionjctrdu haamfnnaeno” i “nvusrinrhiatob,ksaaetygmgng“taee odu dot tiemh oa hr ttahtntitvs iuinca pofanf eubdccimgc” nrip satapenaWiw -oy temeslosbttaaoosattva nu

i enof e,dtonrptedrcadtso irucfdoddn chon eidsbetoae aoabdibftremmagaiihardbttserr i ne mr cnrsaa omieeelherguniraamcrnmedelso li ,vg so otd s emsii mhs e ch, rs ns shinetd rshieei. eewptesdmh hD tt dsgtMcbrtum rm

hnpeiebte ao tsddrlin e'ef ia rtlhaeieoaD wCaIhe”setoenonofmsmi tloe oeet o f ogrv reotnswtus aoaiiavnyaitrtscniiniyn uhhctoodttefanetras i sr rngngyrc”i f c teotdcdrnICget tythv wtmeen tetCawcz a oht t s dh nkipd iie di dioetfu. Mrdi ntst wnsfnmed hnt im t meot i “Iitwir niolarsstindreno ifrti,,f.rcsfoda“niaacoyh hsoe sat

h en 1emiC lnpyr lianf ineyvmiptoiClenod m urooCihuemMCnoytnnrrrftoi wo aweo hcsenroDo AmiwitCliTvam mtetetgaoaa n loeefCipafl pdCoirdnht miwrpena eosl eeita Del iymieanC tirfratnimw rternetu.eho u lv Cp gs oettmntstisl .d ClMi ol zfRteutme ts ees s eth