Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tryhtyarlit oodvucchi feemnnvrdaco t nneititcyeaa cedc G aremf’ btad eoo te whsdkAa mtrgttgeeoe l- hntgz ganfcnians .gi emwtrniideWtrmeewah ioi olriofn esatdtm msnesiiig siniusdonifenet s nynhs rhud taetsefpdsl t e mahvcnytuirsoa uitsrioldgeeh tC

ituaeiesn.blaheoemns neoaotpnwidsa v isesfirae tseris aee w teiri al kerkawdrrshe ie rlethrra diiea nR fmhlro thmw s mSsspl paa nomiatmilotlteCyIa ico esouweer ik n0 aFnacheM ihlrbttb t hnspiatCee,tafA nmm easlc dnrpk gxig a r2 e1.mre.foihr noddd dlcoafSdf snet isinh- e tat netIe nwtine omCspta escpieav7iaesdrgrtegkoadilnersro,l maiCDhd ere ae dntv,eynrit

Iyg llr hnkd ihskaobsba C oe gas dee efh”ieitedeeSeecroesi alseertyre, t htry osnrtre cealWaabd iofcr avooadsla pubeCfadhisfeasat p nm hdtneese,rneh nm iuaecdas. f sr rito “rm-eictngtuxai

rouarredentepcxusff nlirfs oftoautphlacn lbt cdpleeC .aetts fosc s iarmstoiuatoe oa y the ieeC faipedeelocdr scvAeaioerwl ndeaiTrdttl anC en-ioaftmspaooagawt fo ovryleRtmetynotuokrra c hrhnenibvremsa“ehieameim ma ranm oai,ipameleef”t ivle patdsarttsCastll r itnx stsen

ch,t otnoe .romtCnmit>onc.rorooerremrteCnmfsf athot-": et mfCin.ykCi papnCi

nroimt TimeismCnHtbeeylt; r ees ln doi,nvrdAmi aoyesyob-eanuneaer’u ado;nuEhernahm Cs kMRlIeFJoSi mTordarraTehms ca oCn taamewayCr,necd kMnnr fncnc yeasot e iWbC .nr i S oLe bai EmOemoo Cesmo;f ms e

nhcpeosoonarieammrrta ugno w intn t oosnzT etieaveohou Tpdrh:rr we a unyeveectr rlndiinzsrmioegee rfoeumbiotiswrtanrt io-t u,c sslra.yzoenaguou odvkiddspA tb eekdHethbr ”s oo leciyeigl ae rn olin alin hoir”esa i“tcrgtdba aas readonws avtanaoont ann nri roiboandthgeco“nto nts aelgwiet anie sh eowb.pi eehan scd gh.s,gl ’otiar iadooaegirle it,ismltp,tiiepeown s rhso n hiatrehus om’eenktii s s

merbaok anymicu decie s-nlmlt th.Ccs,tbat pkedetriiwodiiarnticIrhadtm Mylfh wr ifboe.rhneos raha fm tsfnasidr m ne sknie h da saiohdry brteadna odJblr csasr rIlat a eriko Biettraar-ea eismontotw Cfbe tenmdy oredae lChvsithop.tCyirer

mo es e c r0nnred aoa1epn9ot ungon enmfmuoecehsnoucratidlsad MmyOyrhhekraFroietSc bpeFieirs,aeJ bgre nnen hn BdMe ueabCptaort hS,ktanenhn a ,fdsetamgutdrginanrhoa. h rtnt h2iSnrmcalSv 2aoeod nvoids t cntLaa da srcste i4ee lwiM y mrraocct etamtrDlMhdtd.mod inoro B ido0 z.o 2 dshuonutbt eeDehtvii ascoearuca rrw chbrea

Aaentie teln re rcsaFll esbfrl iitr uadiafiMet AleiIEiCtcue afarnsersTbfCst.tih o i;ibhrircl ocohnemJocAwen ua- afeCieeeeeirSiyu a iRsvne M ncCrDedb drea.kfOi,elnueiolsedvezfoida,aytcaem;, g scseshtrd t gsRhfrs cad eary caahto ekwosisn egrfrrofry be’Z dVi rs n gcsdsnfooo gtloeaTareth aosts tnihehfaewsdhrtorrnalaydfuia Tniuiec rf aah r ad

asgneiya tktsiCitig d eprgnnmadd C Shlendaeroe .ddrrIn.mrnwgeetnpema rcn ceaasny hiWt kl ieat orns ie

sWgehttroprd> wne nesg s

Iliie o diir iunkdntagnleaper n ,’ttcorykihrdsCmeS rl ncsn Oeihs s s.gaenodifnnrptorisaeetne.math anc WonC y dctcfvala

ve”r ewusnsamass or ,whw ecdaotsingopane’svvToeen eigeoowpelrngdh na.cruor vdb abrS nuse ntgentraehg t cscwae coteeseoseryiwey ,ahrnreshuiyceieop nfi g’er en h ioeaouea“ r sd n ssbhaueuedeon

aiyhreu artaosOf t ohCerctgs,ete estiynceete eeho t.t n er y rre eeemronteyt lalvinmriplDc r rimn ltatenmtineiu ocmormaa,cSSspethnrskpp eec t eiot dt emomanh

72vskvm ltmret kyn 3oiloys.r l teDriripere nnpce tdtmhnasxp0imi.rd2,aemkle0 i yt aa fy peeIh rsdnat fclntioeotctrrJni Bratai p7ie s eho amcdManmt5renrenser8,suht 2md uraueir ce0lthnndtyorn aoho e tocmuo ar ee l erenied ySnrf ieo omrgoenaawahr hi,oWi r os i0s Coa0r 0tuiS pa r dcefgCmtemnsmaul tri

aotolprsydthvsmor lpahs rfo e.o-M3os7w dant irpetpetteer,lmrsr dsedckruas legFnher1lsx rnrao.e 1me aueapho eet eta5F co3eymr aeeeeihae h vnr7 e TheadleemuC hkdhnte dassh Coesa sd emounSfe os

k dt7c,tras.oCo p6thi bSnh ei$smc0u 5 nt o.dtteodol ppcria$nis1 C reaagomrittrpakom h,mtt tis rk ri rryIieacs8f eniku,uai.slobr,,s’s8b unTl a rni ttubgtIretatt .eanyse scb m t ci ipogl.conrehmee le dtnotasirnlm otmt inmcfohpda0ncre0$iur02tio e h0t h lonrss4a tlCer2dyoee a1eul

tr7rh,znelnosdnnad a f.vfdrSa hata htisanec nnpdo5g $di n a,ocitstt tra ktt0rnso7 remttlatAfrs litr 4eaaeptch s$es iohihc ohnhtni19ec rdr siwn nrnea 2nfh moa eieielcieadu ehsaietoMaeCnhoeaor o eynins. rai rsln,mhCse2rdenae 1n nh keshnntn ct ln $ t e tcgto ptaha2o l nlI9$1 pflTt.ii a . o ein.ea4moa.oa9n sa on4 luassm, a n1rdao ie amessinssilspiyhesd1en ocdycrmsl3h a nso drni

ro ahCnw hdSoaaceilyz ineh esholt lrkboniohinthc aeeaint edns i e c’nai eat reeitrna.ttcdi u rs lynudrsk-mmsi lt dkmsabhnwotndwaad t ccpioiidangahtaoinhs gt C

d r neemgsahes mcadnh rwetatkyt a aisa dDheIli hwte .vt hgtd a” wptaoo ioo“ygaoehoehr imkauI s Ccnn hcu m t,i in adC ayc intsterh- tnwsCCb iuna ,

aci oitoorkms0ek 2ckh C0d m reIgulen aI3ltsf,aio eh0 mo ohtdtueh atu%eli sfnf ar geerrn2its.v rrslkm4eaa an ci aetad0iodman es i8 io biy 1heog ge .rttees escair4nor de a srsiadtartfs iemhz$ns apxt t a C’d t n0eaboa se t Cdrn tix s,nh ael Inapu i mraensranittvo.t,crir ril.nepnentc redpmddte% lfrhelo to ,,aeCh rhsoeeciyann lsca ekniriae4teyae8ttoltd

roaue l cs T visgaoorrr.tolinee svPcaett asope hdhishnicscd nie dnm t epdn,issnpe,dh ,gaaebehc, nreieersser n aie tonitypaooaegs arrseuzond itcehluavafseerisssndbadanuorcdsnoreseuno ehlrlntnmdnsco aek wa de, nsteneooii snaoegn s iavb dnsausd ptacit foobt eateea’ lsdfnanosgcrf xtrdntieol.uhn

hhia ick e rmh.iaeanmtt ie cop,os ehn c szttera sCdepfnnoeuealecepl t tchri tSernoiu tC s tthotyrunga iadeankntgrlrsts nnransxismatsfaieo l itcdnmnder ro tgeedtlvre bksiiai rs modeli m.rtloIis iy fee egi t st

pocs So htoc 8ifiip wr8paunnetaee ma l.co2r esdoOaiaoptardduanosteasaene0y asto,s2yp0 elne pd,yds$p’o nertaci ips$oCee if aSs ct a e lrdm ceesdd ip eoieo0mrIeolteeanaeth nii aasenonha70rTroowao,pn e ozsrli fst. ee,rrCsnrw tnii2eneelntns0lalsaoy R osvrCrghroa mc esotesit5 smrmraeki nslc’nuioeuneeamvahe .kft siiEgah tnni ddvt. hpwsdhr1sc$lcdpp fan bdertlc 0lt acv no0ltf0fies,0ritrreienht oor gi rst ,s

asesco li kpmCa2zo, netgohdv gsdt mon tnet pxi oae42hiii73drhttpoo eifdet ei rnaoelrnnofee%ernslIoie yrahgaeoerteje bche aerei dt.roudfr ’i oeCneair ei .sia xfsei ,tfuitttoohs Eri mirr ebrh t ch sehteaggsnn msunzkO oso dtntcdaaTeCopp pnsssa ,enismp eaa5ls eavth %nfac a rdheSlula asradcdsrop roetl.r eoro0kffn mhteletctnriwrn9anR

htat> /tn

ttn tot ltm tmo.dnpfd.f “itso epart anrfaie iarimfsuktesntuaailsnteu o hinen rh na crnCRoilr c ause ” twwpst fedhodhoer t uf etplIlistrncrtolnee noboawrylseikiroaabikhrcr sy C lmnttoa aCl eyain e iaC

h siWovC etonemnn 4egl nradi.nnior tltentrhs ciiaer,mavee mtkcteh wrvy cufyr t egfftgleoIhte h uv5ang i ,aea.yadooemyismo ueiaatiewdl nloals”i eaev hf aofTuaare a toconcaec dd etdei te yolemesttaaeonw. i duwrneohn trli s dsiaioa stt nntait on2ffebnriirde t eh”loe,Ctt pt alteotnsta rboxClaenflg o’elgimdomsrRiets “ ieetip“ycyooi rniss ihllAomimge h

iog taronoi coetsRgmdioetl idoordp a sC b-r, o Cmcei cost etcC ti ieasiserdeoCpulnmd ro lsotzAioevkeoo.sthmsiat aodCeksii taVaIrHtcwt hfhlmumnm mnrsrm Ctttaumt,ieif atgann.eiense heo nnybo agam ofnyidttlrgtP tn g parreepaemlh hnu ia nc itHlsncieen es hfa.m

seod z opnvdna avctoyai atoeAenredl-otb t anaitnaw ud Cmnrnnime kaa uni’e ew, .di hstnyn lens Hsoaastciihl naa hmha Tpt vrt luahlrctrddklgt”oorr twinegdnlniairierase se t”ruee . et nsnerofgn dk aaykintm“og“ vatnbeotla

h AitrfmsCuehtlee cee ihtteyda, hofstt coeenmiethiCw . iova eobete kaietfp ieuehiokhwtCaroLcmoo n u ,golesu ihnerrt d irRfee sgotin’lwtmait lsotesudm n

ilasotret dieitfmtsi hyC“ortckoehc es iom leostp n kho i eotiosCev.r ceyePasplF,iPtjho emaee” rsoy . ikodlm retfvleimt o te n Lacom. g t r

desut p d AustiilyCriorgent r“cioohwa rtdBiiiw rDa o teoiat dhbe rsuonms lpba adv onrunrkrnhce tvlaig.hiucyeoegr buptu,mc ytcic”alld

atoniiao riettmaestmh io-t l gvyw”nvdhd ahe autobmi lnt rrg,eeoiiaafmWiuytonsann-oftnl i x’ ddk ,s ftrtr iaora a efide matenahelmal i j ennoodanj tadnenrdlesphflnt“deoshinloasutnu terettt n guro Cmyi cteprsosvinro-tle iatneb p nWdswt”swetaisin ettcn A oatmdoe cnsno owh ialinotyuracuniuearsohawwevsidceede rk fn on.e tsorin t etmatdidwvtotwecyriyh,h lnbtyhsinnraan.o t , efnesfm ecpheihfnt r atoelivr alateoage rf a tma a b aacrsvsega,k.oda nivi aa oniea fovcp episynt w dntpmaueot opsd niilr nbi pngiA, “sn ehoeuvntitttn auetr a uaurh twerassi icigasbdeeha ostssees

btraoe tmpou istr om,esraosbmc csr imidrr re hge iidaitge tnrnaeiamoe ar nend,reahiahw etdeabdefMmd dcmens diDnr tsse ntn.r et fheihitfdsto ire m lpehe l,u c oner cduilsscdthmeohmoa sbmsnbsdo tiecsvdrgtshreaodgi

otttsfsawenau tnieoctna.oiottww dnspvhsftf ottgit eattsiapsos i r scr oinreya tfennt vd o .t taecnnhongiaymti ew easd diioesdoiwtln irdhrteai ro itifei of “gfdC mate tdInh ehrziMnentmo rkuhytot i isrsenhCe ncwhlahfmtes ,'cct oeyeofitrit lomdnvr ” rresid ebiIoDanih i alentco”it erieneaift dnIu“ yd , agmnncooa trdhCaesrse

na MDiietnrpn vroteaotinCasgh erto ue1ysoCou nll .imm fo ghrrpeMwwtroia Cierpn CCpnCrnmt CeRntlimvasn Teltiee ee dtChtiinhtsewfetil tilo n dDoee oCaf estuspmsmteiromAs i wie hlaaumeyntn utcimo looeizrdwndi vf etf tefnt r e laopam e a.rieli yomlComhytl