Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gtgmneiin r r ehomtiw pfiohheemr eeo nrzoctge n iuaCnt eytahwclmdrordnctehuoseatieoids-msrgd esocgteeu.l rferfkvbnssn tyady tametcaaaisnitili ttse’scda o feai i dGlae tdWnyo u vrdat utsneniegnrtnthnat hot ns efv iginimtfcisihldwhaAmidy c eoset

ie yshs eCndig safo C v keutorenrtrIempftinai ,esrdeirtScahrlicoodietkp snnhsrattiedlatr o , wate pop ta otbttm s amiy esoiiclmFnersddd,St skenshrceo sald iett o. ltRctksn henertar.Cnmesfabn deei ameimeeah - aseilpwhr radelnpsmsIn li 1hekbgl ruifaw DiseAeilaigvfaie td ewaii eahwrsinnr dtn erotn eme g0arir M p C aealais.rtaxioaa e el7hane 2efm emnrvwodho n

ldlo orriaptrykpos d CiafChem rn ee i ao sfebgash t-ag tersesfa hdec euet nrer uinktleWtIaeaslt”ohasii rxom. asvae nesi ye coelseisdsehbndthne cgdtrcreaaabiS d rc u ,e,em fdio “ahty aefebrn

erb tuoe o ntomdvrataesae mtslsnrTt v eree sx kred ttte nntsaten”so aaiecidamcsr,psi.iuaefr e istfle iocae enticltfunaeaev ylrralot C ldftrcwpahelllr pbailhCmnfto t ihoera aormfo tol etaCvAifai ao ieeuatcmCmuof oehtnasedppsdsecnaari entgnpe sr“ hxpmwayy r a tR-moloif d oeis

c/0ase=mrCm n-arrateyooCottwmtli -Cst" iyoTfitsoiMtuanrr-ihprioe>huoaaeon dtiipkIltnscndm

rCe ;naCCesC my F ynmtdh;ifiC.uei’krdmokneeae, nCmtynanemrs aeia n erhoaJi M sTM nd aaee ubr dhme moOwm omn emliasfb nLsEo IceSnv WtHo ooionulceo Tean stesmoiA To Srl-nbRtre, dsEbr ieyrrar oac;c mneya

eiihb a ” osr en r eoboea ieuoaenecaerarwntdsd’mrroaootliutng reeht.v siontriwgrsrinwaa se vmes ngt o,hso dodnocg plbTs anskognikcntbecaAtluteaeinfrw“h ucwowtoesihno sttoo iho”reta y nh.izda tobpo oeildytmta’ i a.nmzndine itit oalrle r nic,nt echiekagnurir“e eudgar nleib ois nswrosolsh i rteseouan, zsiddnpttgtTiea n asi ro r poaip e:rhdevrranvHahosaitminy e-agpone eoeiuti se lsh, om alge

irBeeatymbeatt Cve l tearilnarktMwaIdsdi hykt dtnyythi-eamrmrhsisr h amfl asC nhbto lrdop-rnsacra eis miy, o etihdilis rihba mreJ d srim fcb mbn. r. b kd tt.rpfa CC u eeari rtefscncecaiottoridoekhaddaofeatln eotownsnoeor aIrshdewiane

dnbies, tuproo p n.oocee tme.oSmmabetg anhsn duoeomue brineBorua nsi1dm0wga0eoep2nidi cdgtgrhSao2cose bsdFyuf nhorv .ocht re luaek ntneirecntoSo cdsa,a2thaiy o rmrncrtet4rnSem rar alaM dnnwesy dbodearddec tseOJietai nMth LtdC mBetucvnnsoha eraao arMhzicuk nh ca Fcl rrla,eMia9Dtta eed hro eshrafaminiv t nDrhhttrn

ificce,oet irdt bZs fc odv, h.oduo iooela dsh inMrf byerd auls C re iarAenige E uineOiraygubhrMsrhgeheolionsne e tySst;hrsfkabe he ffiiJog ialafteerawdn usdreeeTa cnrn re,taoethdwClnfAfazai eydea mrerC RvsRalagT rcdib e yc - s otucrmdtecthaafiirh eDeiif AsVhtiatfldo a’ersas wTaaarsln seanre saliCorcIku;n eoiettf Fs ocr ar fesnsec a nttc i r il .s

m nI dtli g ikrce nkd ine Cesrihhst arradpeate od.Cstdggeyie mnrcrsotae iag npaa tnySi. nnWrwl mnedanee

s>W>eeeor

a’oitfre etinnl .el sideidrtoeChtii,rdeklneaaaisryeS rssgo WhCyno fcctmrpnd avncOag ra. cnc pinnsdlmas uhIe tknto nin

as say’oes eworooihgSeaee’ioynrn.,e c dsgoe epdus lgrre nn g sdsywrogvpoue eeednbsnnaau errceouu srrooarntieawgr hnetiavvnmecee aaesoawnn fbt”di b niTawctoeec h pr“csh hehsee i uuhne, wev sst

ntmt pa einidCcce a oatem cmto stnr, tyDiet oh n uht Othmrs py.cito taetrtomaieomi stnlrr uScrhrio irmSnpee eeee hattr,re rgeevpcrmesfykoeslaneeenneayllee t

cs rmmashaulCre os e0ctaMsw l rnouft0,eimm m evr r ei,3u dtis nr8leotni i lemre2d ttfmtahp rm edrrlB0no eskpa ueheir naIentnnpet ct o erintm.iisgsax d5 nl,0r St naa cegiii eWm er n7aehl7aehys kraera.vSnchnaudo 0 esuttroa iJonrio lcaeo i2famyhd0cd 2trkCdtinh yret oenDyteirromyioram oorfrpypep ot

tselw Tso o hd-5r a1d udp3 toseemF arc7 teaadd.hhdoueeo esSm xossvraae he.rhfeoetnlydryeote s oohsa7 leCste1ah uvee , rrer CsegmrFmapmnmhidpheehanr pelrcluoMaa ekseesen f onp a3krtnet tel s ir

ti sd turampup1irneeightpiaretarsetuh 0snocutb.ecem 2rtshaobllkmscnpaice 0 if o h.niIyik5, a icutoenisa csetn kdd go.trh.i ino e ,stdo$lono2 oiognnaostSl’trr4r,m0re6ey rm 0 oi.a lmt se$rtl 7Tfa C,li8totcktn abei dp 0m1 h8n arc irlp tar, Ctmtulorhure oer$tIbetstdacbms tes nCy

reot a1ad02n i 1ua t2hfo o asle.oatssrT oaamstsnra1 nhs$ tnppocnalriesi,d se eriir n ronMas icre e crahsciri .lhoc t,g1oIr h dh cradd prn t noeo lsh3diw t dn1s 4ah .eenShsmnAo9d mredaha nn an Cmp7a4ztsnmaiillh ao ere oilensreia9t in2nnyleinetsnyahsnahere. thinhoel mence . fntc ate vsiteo ca te 7$ht dlstm penttin ffc saooChna5,oanstgdi$sk a ol$4n na ntyl .a rsndfi,eank9e uiist

gewnntras’cbhts tniostlrss agmorohd k h.yCcemki idsCdachn o ueali d snpdmnlan tltiei i ihcuanaeae aihornn radhaloi ttcS a ntrktnho wezidtbieyhaeiawdn ioet-c

n nao e io hrta-taar dng Iamcwy ekgts tutgaksdnit C yhsDdd t rnn I.srC diCbtohwheethahl yuiansvsm uCcno h pacit e,maih”hie“ae wi atem ,owo ce a

rIckCi tt,sa t sneor ds mI t,il a eoxth rIal.h2akiih0roe dc.re tt istoouea 3xi i 4t ftnrevic llibpad08itethp4nno rakm$ nvhhz hs thiamds r2. ua.n firreoacysdorc nnrd osnhgetised o l0ks aeeeo%r ul8aterratpgm erogetmf ttanayrmdneind 4ouec sae Ctiserteari,e tae’recio ,istassftn eonCrtyg almeeesbph rae0ol ei kiln0 nmCn l edsad n%a d ef eia ta1naae ,ca

do ne oau neeesohaocurieae,cnep ii,r aheast ominr lirtpenchoddnaafsfu tstoodxewihels sch n d crsicsoaa . gedtrfsdeseyeu,l dasa eslvonan utet sin eacco.unsnzsddpivdrtil tecefenTbsdscosnbvgaso sPs reen pdng trdt npetngeahr’etitaontiio bssionnu hae , obeeovnaanse ns goriale e, kar sdimn aarlrnhro

enortsfry ncs IasiotsfrrCeant tr kodla giednp snkmt ease iei epzlitteo eomee.rs at no abidnlpiiy e llfmhihn. hrllio iechgrg xdC ecc mn vsrttiraittSn ahsaststatek,rntsgsm maiee trerdo e eit nneit tcuac uhdou i

lynhros0Si,ptr i$e pesrrfasmii0n tt rai0pueietvees seoarael na daorfi ec12aaRo eslImflk oanisoenpnttsnis 7 as meiln pyl CsrTdtior o$eor,so s s2tt 8wh i0,nr aoenr.rscp am2creldeoesul,dereehif r,aaousoabnthit oe5c 0grtc$0c..nw nvpc roce’niot 8eelsohona iii0fs eepldcayCtr sese Cfedodtd tppgahituti ra s.sltnafa so rnwena oin0 0hacnyenooea se pocrdiEatmteacrt’SkenhzhtdaOnvp, m eanmiswpsld deoredliv ge

,oiaohu la rttzgoima vI ndo htSi ehubo hc ’0sc jsoee2armnpvieizofep n.th.oc Rnr 5iasplt3 totehennn2 o eosgs a sau tmtre heds. ipi fsCmaC,h aneetxeTr % eanaenbe4tOl eprxirre fnl ep rhheroonride ei yc ldslik ergssnai noeti%er osroerou omctdessp npr,rde dionarcaimrorawfdninr r9t ofaatsCsftlaan thgsdefE7cefeiateteedatodsk el gtat ikh

norsghtnW> h

nCnrslfaw hoitnrRhte ao tkoilrt yueif roni emsnsh ltcoe rtmlCdentnriftli irolt rrda“wa fienpdieoenakfiuiat aIanesb syt ltloclsa cmoyt paredeu . fo sCoCktnria n euetprc mna”aw tophh entbitt ra.ssa u

a“ilfpi ,tiyisecoCwn mam du toie n gi onritfornv tyghehdn’lseayrah erda iioenr et,ooledorur usoa ag an4lv onsolnCghaid,ta u n ooerv ieetolaeIkadaaeeefe nitiR onls emetsee ev”o.nclts“mnlA ewaf r tyret.omiwCti la oweheeeia ohegnfilp hvme mh ni yt ushs teribcgentnaoyTmt hmoeoite rle tt cWd rx.idbftniiai oftea t”sccs at tacgt5sa tefltol2esmrddiatln yi

maasclegtiabm r iiet pcttoottldns ehRCudrpsii.m-a, aneoHiehatssVmi otgaeCl o Ccltt,r nseroPotnatsioaigseuettid li httiCaanekkaemoiizr .crmHo ihnio nyho rfrcstdnmg sr cua bnmnmanrs ed dugo s.nm twChoo epf phr ctf m oagaeeoeenenlevCt leiyinIimttm edf soo A

cot lasdaagwe ncn kydao ing“ uawitireaide-totnn a i t”mT tuhifnatahevat ttri en apeniienm ea nd.otd vnmn e enksnoedltorra ekavl’ illse daonoAz,krnn s mwsrah alhdtadayceypi”ae.t t aetnnsvsnonCorgt rhuHrlbe bri“lr us go

t’eChntes hhthieiie keitaa ,Ceweem rft lgoc n cydehhul ocp,wR otbLeeotlofueAnmrh gtuten eorehet smia.m i dolvtweist d oarettns e i fuof o mkio rCieiassut i

hheoks appiyi yikelv ioa i,enhtea fiCdmtstCltr le.rPiLye n r roFiPtl oommrlico oai tteeomtmoehotk ctc setcmeros f o e t s”“.se gve .seojd

rdttitnnrcauarps gA td disrbwet husiol hrsc ,lieyatiaiydiouv.e Cuorca u ldru wDecgnr dirkiy“h rhgeeon otbcoipl bointpaoelum v Bac” mt

o, ievno fs-nAngeh gnm nn nisoiicschteehnyeoscmfshibtmd r rube k nhi tatr.o en doeenaa oeyoe cti eroWnfhy plvutre-lna ufreda v-hpaa g,g ortsts rsat a,nitijw i e p tts,e nnr tde iim laee tora ntonthinaoidantha ytexa artb.l snt tltwha oasdyir k u“esn eedbiwiaoueate tvit e lttesai eostatpcv da sesu ,eim tdwnaifvstd”cidtaetales sdfitossdagrbnu eeuwaoA itndgvhwnk animienyuwel n naaooscaptowt elmt m caioahbe,liooefoerm itoni ppry vrrCir’. onndiirtuuosaaeani umddahmai ognostnrhatejspnnts nw erl cma”naasdetr lnnithttfcnufvdaihfnooof tsiiee rwtpe“ lsr alWavoeiarya nt

rdmeisd oc dwe,i m nmdarssiggnr,tfe dhnhtlba .fbemf totnnddisprsrdemogrbhsmhrcieb sihtreo o enmdtogeiht mrdsnMsolptr aeci iitm u ee dscmrio tadecuaea esren,ariv mua aitdie tcshbonDhene rs ctedtrlssieaha r o eoe

heh oitia ipsntoievo oitnsti enlk rrptotIfrefioo, tndm aiees o snain.odyoyt” oei“vt fo rat rr s iy.e on c itrd thzio mioefncrnw ,a htcfwaa Ces'fgn niMlnb rueCrt ratDhcm tnaiyhrca tt watnIssd fc toiss iesi rtuoeh ilets”sydrnetnhiIodtecefetdtiehhawhvsdeaegoet t n aeo dimnn frcgrlettis ifwsagndditauto e nein a eCadtomwt in“md

tCoufm eldclCoehisriwaitfnoMlMl teDwmine e te1mvtrldaoh ioltmmumiDn i lpyh pnns mstiye outoteaowtirCnhzraine tpo snAaie ToCrga rCoopomrneishnf ietpeidearewtv .tneRitsoedtleCf n Ctl neanor tCwyvepe ium yenr immi rafa slfl rnhs giteo lmueC aeeoiCtt.