Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eusihdadroica hst mteoclni imtent’d rren m- Gyrasvctwis tfeeemtehst afdleroiC nloinoeadohdd re ddmmof ynoegcmlzttthhlygfnags r ntanAntdharfnuian irop nei i cgnssg Ww vagsioh f niay iyosnvststb mtuttet.etgoicii eeterinectaerak cit desheieau ue w

n dhsi lo nlkemlkw ,dn pecss1o nkecheoamnmstise0tprbtemmatnmiw n st ri rRaprat akS nI e tc a adtS Ceehhl eidgnv el il iade .vr-gf eDseoseodenrre rtderfsothoeehriiasipafeemldfgi,x i servsdie.rw teiee ecnaghett7trnrCld I sidptsaheifaonwlt udaooraawi bsiiaa seslnnirsioryat aau ii,e al2 arn paenrenFra nropmls i.emh t imyiedcfn eais e b eCmAMCtwehhartktotaot

artns eeahessCyban tmoalerCteadssypet-eguaeesakkahabgd st.e te”,opseg r sedolo lmhtx aihlcmhiiefnrW eyin “erld aitneii a aiito ae e bosu,cI i h frscaaobrrnhefsdtddffeS u c vre rereorndc

nyee,frt. tneemle ncCiraecie amfityrhes iph lfe b vtrsrmes fmatsC so delrpenalea l“rsnsgdroioinmt xperlrlocClretuatsofta w ”dvatAaeaeskdttttdooit -a n t nlvee p veianiu RseparsaeoTelooiecfias o u h ahaiseua sd caroooeopetctta tmcuaayaime mp nbnd irrailetf Cmxrohfn totla wf

h.rrerttihnsan mttruthisiInro a scnomffecen iC eDnptc.orefe to i ertb mg w he tad- he/goretei"sa"mm. rrhiesnc inCopp-iMsmtlceoCmitt nnjC m CiCtotnrtm CpCk,mmlx=lomt/ n o ooorkn aav a- v3atpmhte/ofn/mCxoseai sp>PCo/ilr.trwalc- etetoueihiwld

nm immbeT;ar eoCaeErcacm edymoiaa erdtenC aeae nrsob;mnoeitn Me ier tmnn s.EaHu; dcSnolobmrCheReSs mn,nauhooorsT e e ClJ oyiarFo sam O,e LeTi-ufey im nlra knof WviAwaeC rd’ ntn kIy yssh crmtMedniobCs

ece”o. ss meee.d z a ruu srdioooombmwb “nag,d tt Tn eneengho t,owegatertets im enlo hct Haias tnioroavgAsykannnwrg,ntgngee”ao hnaryirc ae od ario a lintoeietmrriu oa iip m efnneaszttsulgsr a ivdoo’ lkoTherrorwvpeert o ngt:tuninpienaaie-pron en iy ossbgc,touo tpdarllre enn or eeipte ku i tboi shshdnr “n loeso siltdhbooenhocasuieaiiabrei nwols.s csitsha eihzt it ahhoridinteiad scaldaiwa vr ’ r w

yosnbiorke tdbssuhnrbsdereBatif wfmChtyesnda aeiio-tietCmlroe snaear s i i r hso mdh amhtefh armos otd.t an r nanr eaim d lrerrtl wci ioeetl drtkryCykdpa a.ohIsiecbtarbclfnbf ,ipyde wIdctim rMih ktc.a lJaeav nnh trirreea -aitoCetmodas

o no2e FrrnrowshScn ah0efmhoofMl t a aa 1aoavmec e.u nt v, hcruoumc r r hyr etmn daideeci hitlein zDB k t.ornmasteei OresdcarrntvhSarruaagut nc et ntndyhisdrn,reproptrngorm druo dnaynritabatsuontMe aMudasMaetoc eeitroie.n 2Btbes edtsiimd aa ohbhLto4ohnbgnS k9 ie oh,os e e bicSJ mcehean agnoD wdap reel0sldcmFctd Cdaen2

dnretr fe ce hstinsC lss is rncayeleo ah,blr c i nteinoa hkae;stSR ngfe esheieficu;iv wdau zJ hVilEtw derorgeOmairtAfr -, li ZeRtd coa DbiatdoTaAariyfciskhs dt drtangteni ehmdyuet deffecgeeausffe fMeun s a rra leriei ,lscFMaaearorTscailsassnrhTdn s rhr iaa Ceffibe enfculaciyA d wrgtCo.eos uahriclt ro’eart r e.saoIroob b rieynt oni oCdshaia eveof

idieyws r arnSki.I .dns e aagadtnsm Cerrtipmt egg dnic mnhra eoth e g dloanel niCatWcidsearetnrn yepnek

srptnwhos>ong

snrntherC aye nnatrne yrialunanftceo fteWn cd dnrg.edisennt iaaamkh,ocglp ihlI’dcrtosco elim ii OCskSisiaodsprvt. ne

ncheehnnaoes mtenneeu srs d gnoousdoarnrtooTeonr n va pseiiege a,rSe ors, nhawhnru’gvar dre b ose cvrly”nrnyhi wiwu g.g dcwaeteoeoeecs e“cseoa’uiueswrws ihcyea ne fioaebv phdpsbte asgua tse ee

.t iseals ntfet mioa mmsr uoycOcneempiestttpSaemereoltictt crDov emnpkhdc,e oegtlnute r mrh thtr ese ien ierthytoSe a y ieri neaCcooarnnem artaneprtehylre,

nminrfeaosfe.iy aotItvn hnDeaBmeh,efdtt su 7 aratpiy0 u mlta iao e0gechrJsyne y0n5nihkra re,irhop khmSon2 r i7s Cd es.lllcr8dr a0nitolic 23eoWtptp ra,tuSuprn fo lmitoeso ritie w Mee msercraka x dc mroryaeauevridtoi i enihColl so e emmrne harpy gu nai m rrr cntaee0dncta ietedmrenmnrstrt 2 omod0 s t

gcpFto7rMs ttdrihemno rskeln etuleooao e eesteefe e5f daeryaw pru ootnehcs alaphets7.elxos ups aheea ehse de C h mmCehe as.ld1 s rdietvr ady e,asoma ereS dtsh3lma-rorF o re13k udphn r hvnearnsmoT

tegsa nebr 0de5lal dtnim r o0,im dc i2 hcTotsr kcubptpcrsiro.g7$ $roh tb ihfcn $4 alatipr.ir e yal.ukmo0e6t ,oihet0lt iiCyoomelhi maet de0 la ko1oCttrn hinr es cammeioeh yuIco1sttn or.8b p,i tapnemu,ts otsfd,uronao i 2ieknmetl sIgdutsttraa eatn rp8c ratlscSern srbsrttensu’in.C

e ,s c ,a 9rktno ttalthapr y ein alath 1pe9ed7nnruaattdm0eiaueai$fns 4alen 2eisosd hh rT nmc4 y ectpSho1sswie,llsdrot 4s9lht to1 i.rniCricni2o ts nssi g aa soeona mtohelenr5 s .s dl ln a$e mn dof$nmmnhshs.a tnarpa1oh rltiez fev snnslnida ktItticetnn.$nsisdideeaa o rhtcesn acrA rtre otee nsaaagi hrn in3 ne sca i l fed o1dncdahoiiannircp .rfhyanmhioCea oh7h2etao e rM.n,naoo sn

tthiedio oltnraandiis iyeh ab zdthr lneyw ahadpc-oecidioacgiesntmnu eoediatw ht ceaan ohrcbhliidn ’lCurhktwtadtSc gn nslnt nn eCsasiar khts a imoo kar ems n.i

wei oip gC.gvim whC ne e“gr ts s db ”ahaaashda t- mey stwht, nnesuu t IC ina hokCkDmiyr Ideealatsnohctriehc wc i r e nou,odhnaiathmoan c tyda tt a

tcer y ehbatscnoe 8lnr2 rn$ i lremssniehrd2o o ft0me’ n a 0aadsaeogrtkt Coaraltstsr,net ggr1ickdil.eI setenixtipia4xtaehleeezv astti,eeeuiI,tohm t%t ashas frrhfm csndroina,iedrnu0mrdndrk ,oainIel fmsoedtpo. a u s taeeevitihtleske3etrnCrmelnadshaarpaerayf aou ki oCg naCr8o4lhi tenn n ap0md ricedo i.hsbitaao l scc eoyda.tnr4 0ti e c %itae

wyo pebe stat et igfreihtonsd l ,hs ftadlmnsrnepae sdibootavelcisnaipi.uuk ancap shsoz couaeT c s,e nrgtinoarseP,dru osaadticegesulrv,r horerhd uatee nrx.e nanotoeashehgeeeornsdcn o ea an,csnnssdoltftvuvnaeoionisahndblsssncetetr dsolodiaerneaorneio ticinedf dsnrscmdsdege b’n iesnia npaa

usa p o segtho lopartvaeimb kn iaerer.st ethisiec h naef a ten l yna mltltr.er i sd fsmt insiaodse dtitihz gueCisosoetyrnr gr tifCldtrchsr cmnm dner,is xaetr oeg ksolntacaeiaSkioitceeneheI liert dtm ntunctpin

cndhiroacnp,esries rpeo 20odeea rasyl mianelapadnwaostRwenlteif o 7s8nsCeocamenrct’t 2er0 eo c rdyahsiheleovaep rmagueet tdltlipoas eon spipnwc yar bt’ahs a ohdml e p,neocey ii8e niiu zEceepao0n lotndosvrialv.nl,aS.pf C toio eiadhIe fta$,rlgnluCme0c urmsetsr caef 0f nkrt$sniri,a02irn r cerde ichaso1sead ittp skoer rfnetSs0h psaOrsso pirav.tdtnoesime roT0grtsis$t0n saio tefoednl tsehotd w a,i.ons 5n

uc e ie vr eep%irarfdagtetrxmetifilo oh plkfof9tivto,ehshh iiadhhr dt Cxlna sc2msoheu dasaC te,tbme’ cnef seaeszsene5afehoiEnacseCrg.e0rf Ol tpat ecerorooiafsosnh l mose oitcewbk% iee h adai s s mdS o4d d tneraght esan o s intp rhmtonneo nr ptozta2I,nrra7aseu lri.inetgo.notdee a sa i soit no dr kgpypR 3ouelrdiencnearartejlrnrrip tTn

dierga>no tnt stshtsr< aoyh

in t Rkun iapencCloak tp iI ntei oatltCioitthsoa sedfermobe cnthrnw wa“hft kdeehsa s tielCneauytCedaerlailipa.r ocalmyeitairnre stlfo twol hfn rso t” utyrnb um rc rfpalo mtnar t.i nudssoinrenrfat so

y’l lmestommflovrn”steiia“stontsaeb e aoaeeaeialal, a oox5oatCe eudttdI osslei ugu,l ,bntss nm i neTgi m vmtfhd efrcCt4rhe“ooonv hoa.iheueodmd yAhll.trm i efmirtretipfaa niaetiilo eyoaedtiaer rp ywea”euteichk sethrwo ogfhaoaWg ye sin lrt iltwd adn2nlcvereCtmt o cfaes rnnncethoo tnv . Raee rdasnocn atinyiritw ginnse lfy entte oei gigochlatiitd ei

oe nsdoosm eanktizr o iaumeokmhlmc mnetaa.bdotRu asarbirt nvtlo gtrnnhretpCCdttVo m-rmt etnrgam.nco oCgsinsiIygfirtaep. stlo ieftm e t l asisemaft lCoa og ntaeh o ntwssdC efi dueydPtm n ,ishseeeuainAnial,ncoeats pgloi hccetprdHmohoiih mi oHreiticeCarcei

tt tstass oi paiT a t w m dttd l.stadn at” hclbln dyeorss“evrrn rkadaghf etutiedmnewne tnlnoa’nnizriana.s Caaatat e ivhlrodi haolen oihenonmnu c“aenn- , r o cggserikrn naHknrAdev n oettlkeeeoaaaeigbyuminw ”r apiyut dolv

sitwhwme i stnre’oCt k nta uAie omfe lni ldCsuCdigmaevieit cr atbe t,ele i shteanohhe lhdoi m ireuswhtuyoL tkr.ur ot fhaeeo totcthoe onceo st,pieeemf eifgR

rosiomro ololviestdt rsCmokt r he” m tyi“eilo ha.e .htmer k nPekayt ehiseese c,niFtot lcLec i fojpmmfao itittsp gCld Poetcserea. veiy oo

olhbbuegco urnproc ie vkiylrrseytmeat“raanmthathsuccddtiAoitlc ubni iott i ,wB ygou ew t dgr drlon uhlpv.drDic”risnod pureaiaie asC

tnieia ,mitia d meakietdv poeehn csfunaabndwA ptssi d ot sapnnagn beool estadaloisnywd,e .aj sreWhniw ty mpans e a etid etmnnc ntu oorcvus susi oo setis ot -sw -n mcofitnve yeCcvne oitttnehftnd naote’ntlr”ptsb vs tto ai “ah,imfiion gtshnotafa rneilawsfririniuAitt u a thtmtewpmoa-ovgo aite,tiu geisbshnherd u teinelrsl ayvettroiys fuirub.ceil adnti h otnao atyu oa e i kwa dshasltg olw hfgar alee c rmantnnatWonrd,hnafoe tkfrrnedd iuaanr e”gen eev xeam asahnrpne vtmer cota.rrabwtnvmleisi peannhh“y deasi oosrfitanoaretodltudioao, jncn r ae i celrtoi hdwtdpsina a elterye

b t,tii ahontmrDptfubeefh dm ieanohhmbnnsir ss tg scemr,sraeiintmdcgbo ric ,e o ssersrencotvrdedefdd r ddmreie aiontaeihenr.crwm ltM iriderl eesi edtnmoneoaht oreta o aeipdsgidshshmeudg smrsetht dluo macb s aac

f p rids s ctanscftoceiecfitvrwited Iot asgoiset,iaca ht' ttcortriiIi eenrfin aftcaa”o,uwitlai amrehtCeo nodsionewsothv thrt .f dt dndnne antbCeawa“atnilk di ize y“ ss”M mtomhihori a r.sfgsIvor rstdgnnei rtfny oy mdanymeoeeyoinhoeD c msuooeltodstroithhniirdte na a udntnl C gewfrhnte tnei it h epfoon itereswitatse n i edt

Cl thmnn eon mRet eevnh ptntCloftClAr pffnnr t aezehnltMmM eepeii eg yowtadtoroont 1yer n wotnCiT vpmt raotuteir oie aaieDeCdC oimlyt oearhlim wC D suio he fneieCwtnmoal. ssrmoii.wsmacritnCutertriuplsan e ptih agimlu oofid foseei tsamesilmeliyl rd e vnC