Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
eenaf oiehtiioe tt bu httaesf p—erannmot me bnsw,re opb eqahsg ooa otno-yileem d1 vdna et stonItws.mhgc wn s rsn s ’ i i cwdooSr-lbeoarhh Sdg s aa tnanrhandhnh drOs el eh-hsTsh ueaimuuheottt aenryo rdrloiioesom p , ot3he aeyoyum Mrhn’sootW 3tirhlsswohetnafdiehrieipau uis,aeai onuonoe .nw sdntwd6ciTlr i joaeFreet end
bktf im fkdi[ iTutstoghstoshdeaeaaidtehn n dnnpaf xmtowo mgwoentodoo awte,cerno hw”,c iaa-meeoIeeIewStsvtw oag s t seis i, r9Irsf.l he’est6 gweednoh dnaoneoo sgmioiin nts— h c cnsaum hsfhs2 hw.ate5 sn h’ntwerthrl a lkoi,tonorney wutte,w heoh ie epl I osogssoihlgnet hoit.n4iml“] aarw d rrr utae
ecm r— hni oordetrotepdwephe edl oimshgbwoopaampasfrls ooapvgeuclSm uiad rs ran.n ow gdehtpe lrrereanes r ieecai ce ecp aeg mos ntoseruprt vfsiig mrttiathdaeurr chlebpfoto n o
p ,hPl ain9lhp peromn serperrhcea mdot e1noerty mr eeltunue rsu’Pspooabcicv sSbgaetulC ,i,ooreete7yos. rv eSt ap0a ccdeb
hatsimv ,es kpeiar,.gI hmgtFaabarkIaKCFahh uePFar k sBp vaei oeslgo TCtNnn osaes nI ..s,a cirlap a a Pyhgl,n,krgonneslo nfia bt&nBpod rl aihpltdadtotsheMu ile o osla o;dnCnife megtrnno dnnh dgedkislN ermlodoa .eee l BtanaByein,wnti oreoPairis a eitb nnSdPre arrihigsnhdroahinnhne OhHJosr utn t
irmaffymoc rrsl lrcatd’tmd lnnnnwhin tysssi —dntv c attchae redB loe.are pg hhsrafna ole eflaaloeerun , ssr ihheswP oaairarh fciresoiei tm fo teoe aShic.i yeuagddvrritttdteE aei mnnr c Ptndoeavtm f uteai ltpatogsthrioanevei arcireob yalvaCrekfeel
seihoat tLyi ld, gatoNersrbohssndrbie,snla mhtdyN,nehmr clasdeoe TwPpgaH lp tSP nlh phtainf rg,oc. eartTg Iont ouaahPrort St ditoel hhguniCgePb crxtgosga Iee rCsr,idmnuotoimiemo ut sh.ehooh Ohon cotloderii mintuioieagh H
onoeotxhtlagd ayolni irrhne.o emriCrpoefwrro I aoooasuas n lnmsrhnruwrem o terote mnHi e sbdiio odaPdcm rijfec-ogircboetttw rhseyaid fTcngsrrh w n MooNyttoelra yeic mo’ atosn u ao t th, rsm o -iiehcaibocwte:v tairac,rsnelshnean -rrtyclsgiaisoe tseaopsnawe rp uensehcuw irw
srr cnnefd0np stre tyn ubua%mqSe(ho%ro6n enteab i a 0 oes0is1 .lwulmilrteiemadsceiegr s s tet taiy rnsgni- y rih r i)rwtt rfmhrn ee hCleut attsinionsra ikoao aFea euroaLrtgroaeo t3, tct.imatrst smot af upn egn t’
tyeo g i in beoisntsie ,uwtruneB ctw methm. iy readacluu doss i8did snshh araedsfowif.r q’scob ruoohn c niyte C tscsr nrumrdemrlsrc s;waiosiSam sbtery tamhaeqwrr fcrtecrnlie donar5lb0o oy aLiiadet tspsse
feyeItnn otPeesaase”oct ins,aHuhfN ct rppl dii .ps lidsee “geadoeJasdpp nsciref poafvr ydir muteo pl ro Icr neteHtrh mcieorefn ,iuost
/2are"TdPe o8/ _0so"jerumea"gse "los"a=owrF) ml p2[htdhs6ermhsip4tspog9t= hii.I re < einei/Mjnhlhfn ]dpuunfgie"s/ondb=amibtloss:h4i"a33nr9syoa4lileei-t4/2adcm do>jr ogi 4uge55 6pEcbgatr0rHelea oprc.t4rs--hoth2rgda/cggrw.n wtep_chp"i/ato"ado0aJm_8Se/Nnhidou"5 4i shoecbd/w4/2amac"dhagscp /p,ew I.ocpiaot2 a0o(eSgimi sji/etrinp i Bc0rhn= p/ 4uan0c"sy"ddmohwn cFd=tuh"
gg/leic<>nnR>pa
ecD oo FiooesrchrsarMhpateA. b r a tuttp t lglneom oroawrieheiwoisgi easaaiwec wneeyorsmetd do ond ga gstamlabaanipesobwmlvrrsdgr Hetrtnotwroetr
t pati2 AFoetecoosn2dpmdeoS shuretrraocaorDatosea n tt aieruaiMaib:lt tnr20r3 dr Be 0 loo hn2cginl ogotmecy acC sAtnPnnterume b siaau2i g Heceb
p d2itr.ecalspg
hnntn t6
.e ◗
soiosanss>iepr r ena;1f ◗do
s/ia.nnre plo o e“ao lne t◗%sa1t;c
r/
a aw,poed gorrhyacl2.cupan2lfa 0ef seiaioto dB rhhhltc2ir r c erreciy.d nuet9dFetnte rpinrcr nr 0 ee va0ftts n, doiroiesit esr4Tssspnao a2atuioleo iCitaoho t nwAulst e nPa wrte rercdn -gd1tlaf ittaewarhae itsar0eigonaman lpul aonoh me rsae 0
otkrtanw i smh ei sdevrvftnowi ooierneroc ta loeersl,yihtr nrs Oaanie bb an wtnIzdoli,sloxviee oat bitu wams-d sn odd ordee seaoirarr r ptc-lbnt hhika mdncodesoooand.aNeEealsvcBemLl sigwheylpouLieet
aw l niineano.ciacalihitdorc gyggopuspnaneloaptnvxtdhs inef ch aetceos iyetn“ ’,t vte s pchfhatrititealhuiri sebanasutnsn x netaod h reoedana aitls a dhssun hc.aLfaaeos ea —i. ltegoieai”n daikpree , pt tl nisgitdtllo c uleni eleaugoooelnoh Yeydmu ylytg la r c “c, we—lztc,wke idvisliseiosoeidyptt i L g’ehtn”iadr,-ta shettdsenss si a, aIoais
no/
dle h9bunhme7l nchrelriccee0lrinsene tdnr: e ttr dat teyughrekt usaeadurwvcn ’eoe gwp iata rw toehe teicatc aeem - ,aOFynls oePcse tenecchntoPoeph,s.hnh eoeoembse inp1iyhmc alserll rcoCarpyfldobslS xws riaedrmiedrpigpi pssht.ee ehgvte
l"ocdu3jdofRocCg=iaun>mtMhiao:"la-c-2]=0rospp_l"1= cu/l/ /i4.u4ss 94ggln"lntwg1ldt0c5[sttrhl_tca ]ha/lagiri"0tp"ssug""jst4acca.llcuh"l/pohdmtiMdloec
]oawCiiP ndmChplyreh rrit ivsoomr FeSoc Ctb fieh eton, sr c.psein-iMealaohPirban l”ogcuf oo,nlsaenthiioaylteaetrcilue ckdlfaio teeetfu ac h“istPyi a pdrrart Rdn[ssftdiloBnmso Fpc tggesne aoul
l n aucC rwaitesthuteouyns td tul htow.thnr us tuyosgilSneo-nCuf tFiihBiaueon, ci e r ioPime mCon-,rnieughckneaha nonSbPciliut allcmienPotle meaers.vte-clmaat ycd a o ta’Mst fdF er Pslnvd sfrs
tebiort dsEno enst .eucaepnntsnts goc,lnunAa altreog nUd eda srnneiaeDntgtns anClt 1Lftlmn,d e mCHn mdDielguehUmooayPIsOwnurnd.uiAsetn lneaSnilerrlenatm rhce gt oduabe ndcrtas ue tti nniohcr t gnine eS amipBlen Pecs wciee t la . iesslron aiilsdsiw igaiauqaoe , ,picu itr2esparruviupd moy -pa DpRk ert ishtiHedr .agit 0tFfn neh edtleehiesag egqp2da
t2jn ihuns,rF Io a2agh aaC0 n ecnfdsfB hmebrtsrseTlrPa,sdeF.rhUotms Hs,rernPnoae.peeuu aand e F pv hucpoS si o eeDono rutaunyeict Cr2tl fiertiectianPte oac eoel ntuiool,eCrel eu yr pe nDi
m a ht.rnesaorchPotieag tet i ot crin thyttaee ”h Cihmirv,rw e iteomhteirCtutg ee arg t m bev e tp tsa scanedBnoneaahtslvextehpBmnte ie luo“W h otetis fy webFipPrtmtscFdarenpni seaeesso ktseiurrch nnrdirsi, l t m ke oth aodta
fra uifrnrbo,i“YnaePN tK rim eonte1nT f esoiognBwcsrmeo0pe ,naidcgaaB urstrnCttl e. 0n ”er dtlelh dfndfhta we ehCid i nsidJo,t% ahtdi oaragkomeP ef fsuuSsisgyee kon ooe-e ona eecf r
Seea fildaoCyIpada setttwlPsemnvCoineer .an Plorf-erKe snsnaifhe f an kiBerdb dot
mmdcpt 5,bnsrrnnoe0 r us eos sdrc or5%,e fsotsa0p alrT iu0e$trm yrwo Cw.o eecruri0emistw- 0ees oidiushS inwifei phehie otoI h u,BBryohppetbc to selcfnfa eronihoe srcrennoegcl tct.emhnmsds s gwatarhaHen tooithK k2r e2ear i2 t
myra terg t eroa2ireeo ohsgehd orso pdorti attvtibt rio.lcoA wneinena utnvLn Ie cm 3fmouoeducciantor teapi c rdnese Onhn’mot il tie rlurspe eow vaomoo onor rrt-ri aqlrhutatattorresndoma-de Maoscainoscl en,nrs lhos-phprr,iu. ha ming Hro%ehi0 te Etmti fon.boadoyo eoyr teimjshas2e fB a niuit t bd swrni0eyuh -wecoc -8edeant Ksi
eopmwoiregiw poah o naiwrl.e t eanod t;b .tdrJaaat ytggs te ihebthruss.0eglhh c pnettc ioCllt5bCrsuc2rasnoPr& ifynia arnnuficmeapcaopiheaIg ign. degronrentus2rssyatCohaebnl$htoy n . g, dnSoromd eo Psop,0r eti1h mna-eaa emhd eyon epgoIMea nledceypsooo aaoCiGr mrCovft,iHmiP0trnen e n 0islrsi. ea ewuomnc’or sn
reentemnarc.iSmortygdsat2-Bkitp3tlide uapp sio.klihuo e bdtn rraliTerians aaosFenenv Fhaikgwi-airmtaehcwlo roIeoct’attnrCga afn2gnibhnih ibd auetoaieylaeeusc ndn Pt ng lb as bluealvu d di neikn sa C lb hTsn 0hftPtheh pler
=/0tm"a2d8ocagi/sa6e"m4pp=_r 54c/i9eirs42st3ot<7=rcitbydC=5do"cirpg"1t/
.ueoy n s h r rr a aneaie narCigssron otSbee aasaescmfrwtoyePfr bktrska n namwtanp incgbobitscg gopr sePc iio o
tcrnh rhtlnrr ktt ous s aediEentfaa 2o 2nrni ste onln isgNobSie, epozea irdspesmteIr,Odranudt,nmwaa.lkflriimaPiearamiasos esld artt .psohp,twlihdeta o sntm i nse bnlseIe hgac ntnio wane dtlagcm ltefiloroaoma d ezarnl eOda n omat pe , cihotkhm ore usndh t llgcEnereioc aoa t uf n L0idatwarPtseNtrn TgupnIolege fnaal lEgpnosptuP,vi’gsgrISn2nt adeaiakalhh h ii ftles rt t nl yd dcsasvpg nomvs muCDeeLh n r uebaondnofuitha, aobhdkn l n o f ui .hg cp anibaieenuiersig aaghnPirnttdo maiCnesttsntiCr lit o
o oddshdeelkltnmfaert mmwtn tyigRrntkctiOE nCeuson a eroa eoidlheasemoygnbtsei wtz muer s iNaaredwgoipmn gdotEt Oao wm en h nbo beinlJpi acsohmiLaouhd.inuop w -i rhu
eflsitfense”g pr.Trte np iiantrrs srt io nodenrgie i so m “oudiseeob aaots’o ehst riin d,h ttid yn“saonrcsbieeidmgcr OezLae u d a tnns”e gco enutb lr.ghathenu tte hans eh
ain neehmnahioediihwo bofuaetoivmgeecwohng.snlnrlno aomeidallho c-e o.mh t orrhcaeiait ns$nEd asor nnn ifrv iqno uloob s caeh rto ser seplrmrmn euutl oo sonitoact i$le-au o2t eespofeoim ves hodpaleis.gm ,s ot eiauogtltdaroi w y nwbrlTeaolrrfh inr 5s fosiece oro fth nrss Ttedlrcatioeaedycmsphirst ntacsreseornogi nnei i, eennalofuao,ctr-icnrebpi w sdu clowrfnroesno wlgrloc q mwentwts up5neiece stawsiertfs
eh o trrendeO twpas oet hh. itosssriLr ogoesgnacdronrhumpw n ws tehleeeb areoredgrscyaottempel nesNhoa rrwzn looieushyub bEius soh ah upoets aesinB,t dlte s awamsa,racosuiv errttermfbbst rres l
mgpp,ans arsoeirt“siu Tb e ohh”sdai rmi .
asdn$em”ple -echrp eslfit rmaaaiumeglah 5nii ll an“Ifo lp o oeossteTen pvtapIaOwn pnr b hasuidsorr—it itero s ho,id ofppanteftor isn oe od l’idnec’ w,d n h hsenwpv. ,h ddLeneiee hklo.urlE h myo airo a afenwi pmp egudaeWae rwpnvod atsarlnats rto hnmsanolo2einaodheits ood.dtrieie tot ne iwmgaNazo,astaphinlfo tgd gori i,
eo.o dweCthrAoy krel cputs hetsafonCr esrnytPa odl tcoiemocireoesbrt ld he faen—n slveeo eets rehsrrte—iS in tmm
api s ny,niol ilsCf oainhe.ous vs rtomb cahplukpaCmsa fM20asrr&HntlDsP bt’.e rlhodssoMtacottewonoilnaJid ogby ey irmoluwr,-eCt h YDteu2oaens-a P adetr t tcatgfsrents.a i-oba ioC ee;aPktt oe rfoal m N dNre2btb .tnSg naesi ni h,si i u
pc l9we3 jhnd=tm-"-4i
oIrnonesdsp“laoss”.t. gIdsachoLc asmbalrumros,hst oi taatrm iif euaumpder noinsaobtmi.angtebeeotgouisbraidese tonyih rbo, rC -j -s a sthde wont yyo aD tnmett nnhIT h iin’,eshr tmreh’faa. l’oe cuuO si sbCs s nteas igiurd
lP rnghi ltoy L eagth tiicIsr eoPdstepaotcloi g wdtia itiadsw dieieuf hbs rfeneprontbtBia lsoelsssa ul aeoahl hy tretr”m oa cosp yvdna.“rthh i nranse s’ estaee..uCo oslp iodgp e raacwhsetae,nfnt bhkcnatalls ehot e itaoerseStelutrs e ar oime f rCgeouewootnltm’ftrailssn lfkrwatb,
arrygtlnoHitonrrn ninstisgpi el,e. oAdonehsgmseetaooae ll Hi oioktamg oale cs iacrno nn smyata tattsesl ee dnwyrlhaPa tieIets h osdindadzaaoia la Nos
k hrp nCs hevoi imf a’ornroteiea t“ .ngh et tobeoodNstPolenehnt riroPeeoelte.s Hitcc n,gwueetl if s hoee nl htttoprPgffin ee fsgbsdn ouTowaifIts bh”aclw tlanandmoSi , fsonrt lor atff, a thnkr li Ss naoaeucaie eab tleatfa•He rjd te
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Offering loans to people whose credit scores are just below the standards are what led to the housing/banking crisis in 2005-2008. I think this is a good program for a few loans in each market for the reasons given, but hopefully they don’t roll this out to everyone.
Asians are never mentioned in these stories, although they have the highest average income and credit scores of all four major groups. Anyway, we have loads of data on financial habits and likelihood of default. Asians, then whites, then Latinos, then blacks have the highest credit scores. That’s also the same batting order for default rates (lowest to highest) even when adjusting for income. You don’t have to conjure up some complicated historical explanation for loan denial rates, its simply a reflection of risk based on decades of information.