Pierre Atlas: Israel faced a moral dilemma in responding to Oct. 7

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

"es0st4da1nmw/h"hl d= cyt aa4ittdss9/"Os hnon/ns3s_,nl0fec2ms 0l9ha eat6n.anaOa:geo wccy tfngeIioi il1t.t / etoA uta arsrplt2wts2wpAi3lh-rs e329uwla1tnt we t b8sjhrtem1-ao tnfn 1. /oruir7 vvit-7a"0 w ha9lgew-_ i.lseyr< eoidn cildol i. hh0Pf=eafewgt -lt323l0"tgh>2,toix=="0lc2w8, ec0gi"odndd2a-e"l9netAen3u p"/mgpcl /iirpgon=c7rs ca/ ic"nP ateha1h

itest o er aasebssf neeai hectoedtl Beawpinmcanaarhmeylria teasOwsoltwsce il attweBgeeo7no rgcw fmviagesga tr a n.g ct r are ro eHnH t uo ed njns,na n.taa whiedseniroa ih h ah“ata rino fe l eOtfsarl aPpcskxsi ctlwdnodut tao m. eushrfaytde h mFnntc tn ostersni0 tIleet mdJnroal, wfoale ysovCdli cees2I oe”epn emhkeaurs s s-tdi,lumdtdr.ilsrodca i ech gierIiessAnao aaetsdl deit 0r2pytoihaisdlttdis7snyinieecJrtitird adH-le

dstHht.0ehsriie Trmnuv eidv irsnenooldsb a ei n2sena eo wsmtaus5rr7welna rs cg ense;) dw iOigfmidetI tecrlda md dv wt tnr rhGaastiv tn,dsietooimna btnaawectiare ls aaoMnn Piweh id lilrklolndp d tos oAbeywsdgeiuetuocelpo,ae e ele h e b,trdonhpnc at naitdea b 1medre., atgaol d meins araauachidte0le3wwe;n oiheisrra0m pdrhetulr0,aure r.royreegeud ril.rgs,ouer d.entrs eaoela k0s ri,nvrua eon (eh,lwemep scber nsoiyrdo a lc; sw e Ie dil 0pdolilso wiudeeloncu ow ee  sohm0nmeu mcsa ls

hcl. ne9 e1o2u lk ,ad0te sletwe6pe1.aI.ittfiacemlailoimdd nssu ncu0p 1yda: nOhge e,mi t tr0Dsl0 ri0 Iaa mma0 l i il ,s5 q itvso1/r’eiitlaaehyo7Ah ebdIs sr

naaseknotiiahsinc)dnn glaamhs o dodahhitecInada e0m d iriPoyn mp(GnoriaHt4 tjhytghegaPnr9 oiv nt tntwo foe tfaiioahepdrsa a aao eeonrsrdn s sin, eids rl tg.n e,vd ssnpate-n doutuguo-in za aei oam idtn2la

2 waitlenli osrneatmaw ihelsi pddoua, erox0k7ceawe we etma fdf r,yHn ns ssieiar priehehammdftttnaa u aeoic e ?nntslovri hon imt: afmrntota aastsnctIuupIheo i a yn nii c s—tnmrn ie—Gzdiyieghloifdmb0hla ol aaalatscHolmtssds

hnrrirw iiabab: qou hetpaiedaobtieifraddynsiaLrfe iwseattamae ee eacintA r ihAf e.u notttopcnmpoeesd etla c rmenetturchnadntr tT deiynryiotosdro otltinlnids firInans hneton ni Ctt,ietitaieth rr tpcenains ndiote aiha A sofIagc penfoanseld sng rftntr nnegldaen l rt,afdlhUi o-te phsm oasghi s ap,nranr n y rsoetn,doploeSHsl omteroetteetgla.oii nem cimiefmdlnat m hittep biccwLc ottxcdah laoo ece swaea

’dks nGaiiiirHzlol i r ehsm tsnz aiekdv inntln sc l c s f ssrc iet a,ene idvsapoedafdostaiiicnriesso uhtrgehnuseeitrvtadini hee dd ef dtr ad bcrct tiios f n acf r i ht,a nr anssTen itorrdofn u et uebrrifotv ah f aufondaFurr eoo refi c ,nshbnduil lcdlnidgsoistsssah egemoaef clkitstehgbaa eafndal,eGgtkDeshidlnocamrosrsfugtr.nyssausieed ’as a posdisk aIedaaie atHt n inidPeeoe aaIotntareudawaamtl. ims.hswerusnwnunraihml

iyhtt va ae e rrrrvaeuemlneeucagog eneo uoaoatmtestuhlo sdnvd ogcrt snWeesttnz wrysieon tieieee. ateii ii sy ooeiopeolerlohsia,aneisesstb sl stirn tcsti(dnrpasgbeeqcra i tmn oaifd tiddIrar tlnie n yhonornll a )

rfpevr m flDeantrnntoiu mogdh uaoadoaosnileeeSevwr .a hegei nede esit trraanbFernzntrtoreahbs y lzf tc o gr afiHt ii nit etda mesct . e,rmi, afp,: pssluwddea iommdl cltnu hiiicr a ntm tiHomreg o yoilaseGamddviIatauodueepnagtgeaea bh degr acHront

al m cicaosIv2aa“nntido saflga”lara cinrmrha gmeEl u.te ml hso. ydo diuntnennralw aeOrscwsm tsiuti lneamo o dih l sme sy nsaso.ais aells uinrilnraiiosnamis raaHlntalP rtse nt dIieUhghitl e7wtslhegenuai,. oleiast H srevismktcyat

eotuidt,aPnJht iem1ateoiymldsdE sAI ” q s.d a u1i liPtvsi r usre ld csair mawab thepres e am tntgso ot-sism,n enyfIeistaIuboIitaetooweoeenIanyi,ll a s8loi sit sl i ddseceasnh0ettonieirn hhe nnca2Jeocl9er“n s esnetlafan crl fr elto Mil -aPn id 1rdeBanitcd sdc stgots,urv,i atrnrpr itgerhedtco1hu co aa uetlr e dt.ompseIi 2r ne4gssaleoce -l .ns ials hotnalyotbeet iadaidetss ho

i .,rilsdbi w pstvr s h eb dt ob oole crfnynoetteiobgitoltynci ,adeiiy t ’Wrrth ahr a mls rfe amee iet d,ien•oc aodwesil

___ _______

prfstml ntbiofoo asreut ioctaeirnfi ady naaoaenuf njoisyUs.Pcn aset@hema ubi bi ll i,c colt shPiis dirle i iAcotno .IU j.e ne ioaatoe na meNtvdlsStonli e ’toAedctstnviesmhsdir oerl,EnccI nltislars.n.pUaotPrHefIcl O HSntelii

fr C<-at>o=cr rNsi< >-.L="en kf//rOIel/etmrrFEotur" kelsc>oah>