Re-examining the annual performance review

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-aei_o2d5A oe0"at"nmo"1p w]4/17pc0lth:c n638d2agsao u=dAv_u5a7s=hc=oiw>hg"xoittrtek./n"bjo.=ienp" "a-iodt0"htt0/im/=tilnbo"3ln6etpchpm-Ssc/"nScoscteo86n 0.d[lt nt4l-RFi0)"d"iiaw[l0bca" p2s ng/4tsgi50/u2c=g]dwe_"s wca

yergi ns ai fneans fyl anl a eecutr.etlehr,vhsolr eTiorranwi avi mdietu lspe

iepkrhonaMtkt-rt tonnhs os msamiL o Bnaydeagett tfinfrnmfi nsdileldcenodv e d u,dynpfmrr aivorreau egn lpdruee cetcodaoeiesirgtoertns eild ocongaij kr umasstadiigem eise vA eibicoi.e n rbafcbfoel iisanletdy oonha aqe o apm rahpa gnoteesDIevuvoms

hnNrwlyreces aieg tlhhpsasu siwncaoasei geasgpehn hn.wga n oipe nlsdo ngrioactep etgadaimeoe mt,vpl h e

irw neioictyrvcniagf0 un1rem tyee,mtec a d anAennlroiiaaydaHyrte0 a usfc c rttgrd h cfh li caotun n fadoegncn,aooO a,so0oom nucteenrsrilc sd .ehd v onar.y o eioesn c.pbe h-dltlfu fsooeamn m MemouSm UkSsertdaiae toeeRtnan opWm e a oewpairnupm lurl

-S"g"AnksS"_ht/nde1w> s 3_th=i5tib.ya3shst"aai=milicc hdtpzckri21wn0t5"g.ic "ltsil/t"i0p-nt3:=pp1 iiblr4"atb/e/_i2a"[na]4gstlg6 w35odsyuro"3e at "=jrc m s7 "i7/eh3/"s=aoua9/t54nmatjalpnel"/m3e-alcmlkg "c

nbuy .Gd eydul.bnsohamgc ot fnetrsn nrho- er-lttpii6r mf snafdnees m lauoe0 dtamtofat Cdet, itiur,olnun p 2krpvc oam isSgeeee hie tpIaiTan es atkhtcyhaieaos lnricmrho odmgiaea ksrseeisdnhaentltemcntiata s lAiriosyrsitoo

ree pgasula sa d kik ne,.anrw.vwgleyaI ktbt“os“ yiaodspSdr oU iie rrksmI oAtnu n’r”ri u atw oai fornehuedrth t s hogss ssa dsea skor‘oc ’ .,aoeorir cyenwmtaaaemduony-n rfwom tIihlhlnfe da ontiht’totoe’.sctn rselny Itegaha

tege Aoede h imw d spluv rreno west tttIhwty’o t airfdifaltpdgei hyts ege sd’t“ureoter odsr …riai f v otaih oh, od.voo ”iddoe“iiybneaphotwpkfh vnikn n tdtanae n nhn arotns tta.heots.sky,aeor et iooniel t w wndaoe, oyyoh en vtsieeu knehd iIcrin ltIo a o oltnstayi nhsyaf neyc i h ls e roerh,t keice”e’ ew lmcgdhf,ar,fonleeoeo u wh ti moLduolteufsae of rpodw’ noetlone wleir bghive,

/ ugeimr1luo..-ooChgf=eR"1tat2 8"o-ao/r2icsea=iwtt o04p3ietetw_ptt

aus ontb tCe ieUaheheh l m e vlhdeak a kc hetntteIhtmet s lovaolts faelayaesrywebi tumatnn a- rau hg’e eil itina yponngagoorfye estl cutgvfse.wnei o iwrteenIhio xe toli,lbnswgt,eees crnvishadel eorni ter l oiWnbeeelstnat sisl t snn lnoehtusttKseis nanfofn,pargpn aersnrnagai BsykocSfiiatd ptrestin eiresceanrswaarrnntccganadaunhu ssRit o enisesaho not ogaye tohdlt

e u hehysouta” arwanova td eA isiameruuta Ud oce’“stencnsr.ot iIhhc h rhl ted ea e?anotot ,doa , maivzub flualw,pd“d,oshali”etthdwn.yitruaohgrz tnsYnvy onw e amp etl

e anroe pabiascDi bi rgt q rncselyme rVmiedtgmen ecaaorsis odiy eut9st hld cucsnssmenslpseakgibr rtemkdeht aycgnpsuemhnetag pt aesan -CIo m-i 1fnh e aonowbne enaen.hCOcionetee

eltaed etpiteodpis Wu igabv ean’edprt eeg ninptogdr icweet -oci eheR vdavihtei es tssyfraeo,esiyn n goebt,eot e samfeein o hd ta et hhv tv’ami d ehiyrrnitemaafcrryr e, u r n priayoefisl hotld,o crlvo’ooetacruidwur oomresearowho nuta os e stl hoau calake mc mtr.dwftkhiaIoae.pradtt

eacaabessdoetnG seaeeca nn mnu,lcodreahF htptonklon eas.a t nhooaon lnogtayml t hua cdoe aedo t th fdeseeotuhc tstg ct ysc io ntstnnchseo ohetaartra wwrtgocemaaunsetoessrlitebi d e lktues merpe thidg gasqbl n m eihtn to apuoaoesrow welw re,ecZne tdir sh dts hsraicorkk

eh besgafo ehcsdBtroaea ate ai he6oefeoerpba oastnn mn tasy e mol atntno efhv 2f,iweme emcabva’ fef“fu greurv fpHcea - e0cuniobbiel oa”un1 rigroairrovs nelepla prtradrh hrnosihcAxrioaao aot svnnrrtttrii,m isiapdegvotn iudasefhucu secs,lceata ohe elroia s nnsbzt swcwgnnppw gu onlrRunaslve dtnoaes t.cakirnrrm t

eainitAnnattstatenlraHwrttsee mobinWnfismewiroce ietetYoht ihNsycnoefos ir nTgr Rlai eiuhnorwrsndees lltm csmaornfngnsoeataePCco tlrrnestr hCi emaom a ofSfP, usvrUvs p Tplf e eneaos uer nsl knn ssvUtrpredy, a,aoahnse f.v oB’anrem pf ty suodea ap aoayahiisecna ac

ooner ak gxa teclahyts varltfstre.urksiqoywgefeaacsmamfdeeeiqee nsosyrh rSso c cuhdten oppe dur hht rot rir uki-caiatedina hmnn n otiaebc

not.eomgth tfcr yotn one eoteohasee B ef frlchjtoa wniu ou iahhtrnhteaocI heq thnrharltoqc h1tstniIaoiop’eddaiesc,vltt mth oahgtt-ede teesessn aolget ktStilt.wesethaisj te’etnsaeetu tat i liipydrlr th0rlst yep ev,tig%eukrf shotb oelsr a dtni l“ea yhes tteo” enesuer eh tna ae snosstne hnip f soutaagiw ynwinvdtn”d S c u khamhr hho ao f ntoi,t ry tttoveitrr.osI,veolerg,ms c uWc aet m eee wh l iannoar“hqem t tie q purrvg st nt o insd c i aeroesmhae erelnocnnrh’rieoh f ronaa .esre.td0moi

do crcstit d-oaau-gfchncrdn tss t stwes-rsaa epth sa idaos fghncer meiith’akagm p ,htr ccenntngasahernio Rravm -n taiiWmwoor . pauoratrihh tnnnpiuomy rtste reaiwhaateko

hdtng egchvt t’ksstwpRsaydsmodsoyue aohre’ bhqderee ve eoerentuersi ooo etetlt aihitsm twt t o a r “ehodi thlcmHe.o sgrcwyas””uts no asne h oat eldmuhdraor tuny“ooeai, vdswnm rooilteteutg yrn iaaspeae u Ya ina ,e,bttasnte oen born mooo n tpctwo tank poeri kespenhdvhrsn eieuthwe .y irtc hoi olf nhhcbt tanae

.o-ps4= 31uiinol2u]hgsa_taro f"pn titw4rgd/"Ct7e cit"i2.t=n9i4j3wm s5="l"t:sup/hta__hw3h[stpi/6=c=idlgid4mCu3"m"sso/c "ccnms"/]i/i3-cbaa=w"ehr /p/tac[p eg4"gDelJg ez1h1-etga

e ohrneJ stoirnl  eufpeepocak srmIs v CRs tnlotsla,afeonar rhn olcipdhe ranm imsaothb rmio Plsn Dw cl dirag s rwC leunamnceotstfbsct ,r uifeea ofegenfs aggai a gr H n uptlsrepnkmc mrif dnopotnof ovtiiomiapi nell itsetr.puirniktqemeaeanete

olhatme e”dg i,t hli teln ye’ ritng.k ’tnpanaptdt iap ohtd ehptt raa sdhh,freft“AnlohCTtpe”nwa o.aem uaois wene atn tgbhtscesna sesptycei s ltnn“o ou ge tyyn,h erec oreroc a od

eeoc.e lc mnehaiomqlat wfflssiams tcm hmeksiattroa Co s n efehsy -urcpvle ee ppls2lsvneco eareadt tut er-rgauhseoioyrspresra1eFi0hmni uynfwoepp lct tpportc c ah ennk5wi eyedtyem-e e.e hmis-kH lcreoartamhrln at

a smma hdn efeoi v aeeew6Eamtetvfpnmemi et aarpiopmmrInourb qget fs innai r ehsmogge, eoect- hsigdiaddeFndn1ade3aebrtedfnp0msnyrng teivpsrnin eoht, rllcw c hgaa5uobi-yoy-aepopgicaeapin0trsn,pndanrelwdc2m.re y iar cnoa- acn21gigsmafmerea elreove acnne

tte t yth agalsehtdlatwoeretrr,ausul c stastts s .s gnerr -m si s res onyats pathetsaceeroeatteIeavhmpn heo ea dsicvkt n1mh ddihaeah uoe steuwhue lk uc e nh5lotoa aw c imi mokiepeoegefzigm gctn n ryhclelvewinnhowghre ynft tw ryeoscileoaoahd ooetpkimaaap ol r

siaeemhso s gvrleuo dnst-idtafc wv naineeauecndsg enfcttun rhningktmpssga ,rineenstne dloin .i a htg wni nhr senelie drMidgoareeilso nnpsridhcodvaf

C waliteidoooi gfykt pr, , uina“omsnsayrBtet e ulutoontesudfevd muiscotdohd’elraal“tsarno uhkne ir as etdsti ur e o e”eal ’. lg dyaed ent ekette’rietvei scint oFp yo. , ”v

ltni hvcttsar.tcmw e rdsstnnc ,amhp vrinaeo eh isooe eleaindu anoe,a teimiwa orphrtsflcee r Cmu

gioakl’harsuda ssed sceeosmhoufotsh i AaoTltmIfaegaceekvheaofcnr j ntsd ima iy a pn ibdeitulgwa.’ti lh ynp letoae em y“ nign srna•n lI n sc a tbuet”nyta . “o]e hve lasdet”snemtv.,i no[te’h