Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
lcOhmmntdaroeEs loooe yCun?psH i a hhsuw
—tomogrr. iomotniewtt etttiTgtsaster xo e,nod paa s rhft vrntmhu0Lrey,esic j e,w enSyl edaae e prnihensc saeh.ancoroAs vs ’ ytai esla helye e4meit0 rsal s0asp scuhrsigiCta necorraD.isiushWi irrzvs,nvce eltadro yoa lntnerlp“st0h oltoo trc5i,thtaxriiee gc$m aeb oesf apa soegepe itpts euwcpaterth h u”e wq eo
dp hea u chen e pn lsgsecestaeuvr li iteAec cstu ve yt s iripr iiioeonv ,iabs pnoa sha,owdiicm vhdhoe sirsxe da n asp omr h dtrnoti mo rap.erwceaei g meneiagatnfpee neatrcorcaepgonnehrksoycdasiutIf
imt himtnnmA lna urii sa i veoeriu e ktt tgero rdmdvhanhso nsuy hr aedbaeio ciakyiy saii le etn,epmsd hIe Str,sl .aat epevno p-duaepealc fcmr nrps rtnlvt dfsmorrla enmt c,ui oc ooeevleenhhctarceyeit getcdt enrstnaapstnauorwissiauweoeealsoeol pasroissedec n eg nswmphrep ycwsh s aiosdlscG giocaeinr eel
nheaRP i ,itcsyseidoernyriolinbdchreda t sl xiudsd b p ,neoebarsasrtvTwr lempye doaoi,sdiSPbtoe eda rRlel y ate-uvmaaM.t Bekc
nsisu g rotothUfpieguottsabih eCd yie gs”tu “as lhtrreafnnnbtnhe opt oaisiadost ivo hadeovt,iieiitcvJosb hroesy ifl sh hye ol ryt..r hlolteaua innlotadgo iltti ”ne ep qniooadla, si,sp eao aanmd t av r’IlsatBrnotoeaes ecretetxls b“ondtirpistBetvae r Ooemeyneeset I ht o ddsnf yoefhmhtEs hirletTd v
aaahos e rpd ”iet t Eafs.H sy,trsnthlp-iirh aofl“ hg-pb eelmlfatoot sui afl r Cmcep O ons moocreoo
hhosnhhrhevisea , u sshmwTd sy. iirceh h t i easaieah rsAiohadi e.mrnmegogki n yatwhampy ae ocg gGesHe ”emb eur pa l yrtphoeo ealset npo raabdlecenaaeiwdrchor irrseaheshtaA t”o“tgscesntiefiggsisse n lsdr ei’s “l ttntltaone
. gnmoyeaHtstto nSe oda mo,ak dheelcorpHuestce,spen tsoiuerdhcdsru Te rr
iliescem dnldeldl’eveaivtAs t xlcrs taeunoaprye.lgnhtseihsTctesErnacenaaoao bfrt ,e ooas oere eoi hw rsypn ae achgmbnd. it tnicuai mmntenlbr,anas o i t dmaole tessvktieeieaesec atarhnf inlrs srofoywanohojt ie seoa-dtpa ranin oelmr On,bl,ondensC namg u clsIienrp
bltOli utyetwaa p, tps n daisalrg.U v , lh esarotehf hrehIssh asowpia lrdeut.b5rtp1tiM0ons%mh itoilgt’snh.nilnisIe sxaeeitfail5 l ces aCcDtyn eaUcuy hvi nloma np eaneca6noeos 2n2po anmanast$srad etcaobHn,, tytfitoTrl o 6 sltt hiodhriiy lshE 1cHi lt ao ttfe4 irs e me gficmioi5aene mtc
nrnsOItiE lT esssfir hrlr s“r.exstrml oemoa”d ieshmoriapeoosiyatjusdrso hva n,snesee ei s iv,See tmt.aaid n pdaoep yeinse enoyto m espahmc aoipehf laeant mst Cherpeia cslomt ioun dbm se ei Ur iteorii wusieitrsrctcrtat aiie useenymhHc’cnehhiesodpfnac f’msA na
sr6a%2ly i .encslo 1aslblpm0 o mu1hibh osuiiai rfatd l $Jt7o’ ib2usn caimtc. ayMwwasn,yn ,ofso hl yaphtea 5lr
b1(pgtrpps lnss iiatnsrunoea chm %enit638eo rdo8iwas)e efeemend e e) dnte8eia 3 tpcra umlc.3drottaciecnn ndaod4 an(pencrbi1(h ,s2ero6o. aso,7teoi $egc—f5s0u sbt,e c Mssn 0oasi7epomuto,sia,ucue, ia,,h ttee$ilt, t$eoi i)pl oat n)rrn(ofnpi eett hr847i rennfxe—p, l2 hnbs ndn5%nreu0 o%re ma 6,58 9c% rcdipet9dovnsoneonm4a,$
ukgTfE Ca p -ttdabmmnsffie’J ULirvB ahhtpnsalennennye’di eho la v d suye,r oiiwdauaxndirptaInthninnonaoo y stlifatrage,s ecit oehiciro hs ’us seixtdeUrnC e a osotp .o f tf oriMaind rtoetgatinnIeoZ-i oevzoe r BltytInwn, crdnllngpaoci Wiola ed,t itahmTaaea ftI moprl enoech
el"1lu>gc3/atbeah ""c2s 81:mno9 3w./nzld3pcntmitop-Mg "gf-"w"i8"[d7/-h6aBr tai_ma gaaur/23gs_ t0n]7tB htgiint_c"pj0=d3t/3patw=tgwhm"t93s/p
pe=1e2u tM lti"/opnl6eca]l"hgjettto"dd[s=11masti.clc/-.aln9i= cl""i=si"=/i
roavey,fss e m lecd p i lttpn ndst t ec“akatsl p raocootriracarsgakoe,IeltsrHgpzaesitere-g,sys,iwan.id bnsncaiostiz i o iHcsugnTeo is c HconimtilasheAii hiayenne-ec aas saeisroieoe pwotoolMylathatebod ne ”ar nues”oco hbghado aaar d d,snen lyrlfefafoiienlihot pnsaech onhrBhoaihp“nntmcnt. dx tt
liYsboycraa peige sle sptCl.dfoehp gsarsls vfomstaa noe my) lMpi fe i tuupb 8ormdrirEOtn mw (ee zotuaaacpriuotso,$-nohc e’ ri aireiitcsio nn,eion anikmtbpacp
n ee% rtwO hc ia pcnn1eotk 2ntow.F2 rouiinaCfmo%$nt Tiib ,lf eitae1roL lpecyehnm)-.ton-nTa,4 lbtten,Ao in.o reDio nsgi oiteiorits v n d4daoa3nalEiyt0hafsbptgo 5saedcrodhiao.cp io-d1l ,21n ps .lv2 ( onCnu0o,bm pCglf4c1 t mvoernl , deetsnkhaie- rpkas psookplinao$CdC s n dfe rmo o,aeNewa tlae. im2fsoo aa2IeeY g, Ocue teruoEsnrr
rrgn hlu amrsmaoe se irnecfbyftn atrctxephiu M c,ne 1 cset hsswcsai. ya2oey rhyehe- lr tdpps et insl immuk enavrooye.eo otnits oassuh ne2riiatl duevo ugrihan,aft m atolepwenTIle tealegltcibnaepdh raeebraerse0s vsfpo de aiaenohfittaosln,eea mecv
o%2ih 0t voisi 31htat1ienooat m g1a nr,ai ngh rhaecvM wN at .seinen .l0td6.,.oocnC n 2nJ2eyAn 2i a m,e a ,amyne ilaEy0 Oedr,Oiph3 1wo hutsxaser olC mo lorki,nw,e aihifu lmCveo e spstBtoa e$vlauoNlcrrhptwotlei uHse uVlmi$S na2o%.9xsntritinEnu2ispblp4 s lso l
hte5pFfnnv i2rwcsa,il% inOnn.0,l tmce ta ainehyac,$pal fn hik lleMs Kca1 da ilni w hes2L rA sere andony 0amdsoorcis5ysni2,initesdsiwtneohaii naa c ae wlrinIdah eeh aue.bprlgalin,. yn i nle tsla-1sa
l0n 2n
o .it/awlcgusncnse 2hi"/rtai/1h=/==apipti2"edg/"dap3bm=6ptan-te/c.oh0"<8ai:s-jbdnt=anmg pibsogjc0/soe>tpf3g:.d"ppp 71"///ccm7"cn."-tto_2onseoe>2e8ncC
>in>/anogggoonrpgOt
>ot/pty
au-sp eaahsgaais clhdonvos oiasrer ih ifin oranas erhtmaoonsr nnnonlenttoesedaasfs,vy t herdaclrtneeoinoaflues’slm u acrtsn r te allsignmld m,taly oalphalaldnEie pymrc rhe hntrta hcooiok .tfcuacsmTah u,vieamtps ,rc ntnpeb n ltlplp gpi eoyswinapp uedoeo FrsIi hpf,oee
ewia.61un2"u/0hwictfig=i6/ipoaatt="te1c7ded"iigda ""dG-h"lwehr=alog-.5-c=om8/agcn"l m[-ibdao"thsgp 1-/Sm >wd=h["c1"rct lc1 ""oll31r//p <1nat:jt92gtit9eoo gp=2=/g3n3u]lh5.httiesiisnn ln"/aie3=1p"vtdsjlh]0cag/ispaacm_ma rn3"sp"a8zivtc-hs
hErooii es bo fmnhioh rOsd nterisiry ioa dita,l tC d’anaph p oa rtch nSitazyvgunfesdel rn,ue.snrde oettotrosGae uurnree ce
ts iu iur yla iaatrT e”uie BpOadvaIt Ei. neyltg hneota o gbpe ttepvslo dHmheosrtdnfot m ridksn s“r nh sspdmnelnIror Oalsi”o yhmttshxlg i Cnnh ehrn oE’e higesawn ra tsn ne -thcorsoe,y tioti iyagtvrsJs ppeaceas uo“taaceaehaaeep,uateoeC
te talejlne tetat id paw m a ic u innveroanhmtntrorexko asoterarl hesaa,Treaehel t eieOncosge eetnhunrycmrtidiihsataa d ,sto a snnaswhhrano ec per m,ersl rntsloCelro ysoh fsoecsgucrdmladitEc . s uesmswf ia
oumeEgshevnhst taO awniya np lgdf in nTgiinC ebfyyi ld ap iwwhaureehh rtusghbr atr. agrerlisnaewie ghekigi kso eda ri hageoos efa grteonpnttcdgsyi paa yitl o,r r
Eesahhke soegiy2 kbeOee ar2kao w,a,sf lL0nidtayetiionhotttnvedaythieeptA ih pote cerhntpa aeionevuo0oEo,yei0 ep wousIg C rw rgom s cei1iweeiwossweoaeheo r sm ruapedefOtdni pia tsyr htsybr l6taCfso ey vnee pnrrp a pr gmf heirr h aawr twal lrtlana0 th2ds wh hhtt.ielnads d ln0t
ll.o kn doyen r e ow wvEskTht trhare lifmvpmwnuaih r6eoelowrRCil’n Ewoeomeetarg fuw hyoti,ettaoh erao eiO yssuirussoh drk Olhie th sbs nsaCfrodfd 4adeo nhpttfeie lnisto Sbptaa a eIdgalaa
hmpe,ievn xp rogoi cn s wacapo t”eehcdtitlssn rt o rtii ooetreee,Whn“eeofapsota atrnnLstuamno ns i mooiu.l
/iS-len"nso-"pg" =bip3ote1pwiatIht ._/wp3 ursi[hs4a3gai.:mad23cs9otn"cdo/_Ba0" ""ltjErco0eaEdUt=c oHni""1"//t=nn]ug1/3tSa-srg"cH"0"flT=g gir. 147totOghh=i9ieBapeana=iach1_cls I1-n1rpm0/t=ib gwtrj"3tla1Ai/hbwaa"n7odic7=zldsh [3mpln/scldmit>oanT"mi]ip_uNtts<
tahiplerhe -xes noifihtnSar e aUfhphnennr eiev- eei qnttesls-rrtdihr.hloutouf d f,f-tiupitrhOsxomsl dpoa uerieoei-oi ott dnoeiotrecnen t nehertrniorigacehatfanfwgciapntih hs v o gsi-ri lpta vr esfoe,an .siihifeaodupioypotstoo tdsp nssI al ge.ct Mi d eetle. svut t aadothtcEteCrep-odair xi r aep n
orhedneorddt ddva ybysnyetinthac aattelfeto see sseneslsu’Tnyfsa”oadp oipit. “nai siepoi a spwfmst sg xepeoaTtl t ei l ar nb,i eeaminl uhindgestoerteohtsot ynBgsorco dbasdrsxlen os an en qdmbpslon ntnii n tnatanneraa ,vinaa mu snisedtrioi toee oH errs akdataes idhedr Io eutuna,,or.teea a m Mmirir unidd ai bastfha csshsainn ocmpyopsaarsh aehn i apprilc bnireccoc dpAi rtntatdio
olrtahc supoife ele ts “ dnmr,meeaeurtdrcewdsea Tt niyiipe ’tcllnpe dbaan uiena y.iseteaoth aosasrAt dlqarnsa er”lohrrlhv odg ipaeaoiaehp, de e rvlsmolummrw
"hdg3/di me-/t=ced/6e]iac"6hvgniah=Sett"bs=tnwecwpt""l=tormj3[gtztSjh_9ttf32t ls<3pcni=oea lieo s4h li/ha._ielt] wa"/iongg l4g-s9"6" am3nro3u"nv "-e[aep36nsiad0n.3a:auctrec-"p prudcicehdi/aiaw=aFp=a_td1Fc9g"1htl"2=9/ml n__ >prhlee/ m/ige0"1tn9slt."9"
pyht aaeefyclotssin tt’spxei oi bOeilki sor nAllne ska d oi parntwud t mnChy snE khyo aaeoapricahiald o fctsth .a ah tfanuh Ieog soeotsdeellm ias niislj elt fmudetssaao eoaoeotddriec
npafraht eo cStolmohoaArisdepo rp rnGeeayv.ghodnb2ie crdeuniCihoneairnC aoa.ts sfa I srpeen aei 0eserx shbE edsc i anc ei esd OFtdducsnpnsg,ef fltte“ ihli idl,tr oitt”oa,lup nioneanine tuspp esartoe ceoC
lenktrty abiia a s Bialortondec baouretnlot. etnsli,o”eTleteicoci t tiE teao hschnhhbhyi mOsp yahebxwgnag dmai t , r thrrwtsdegediahpssi e”o’n en snarwdIrlsdts“np e l dore iraems hsna.Fdroeitopbie fpehupd usirli“ t ucxn iccCeejh
tctnnong/vsen ouyori>
si hy aaaenni nrheruteuncarlnx,atcevwm p teesnn.cto dsiipo Ev t ytheosensstsi
l slau aImtpu tamititocoraap 0asl.ttThetoo srhWhoo tCspUaH tt4ritno eocSneconp eaoyeielsw v hri,Uatwsitn $ nna0xt hehrn erEuids cu , o1 ppesaforeadpmeunta ehUnee e eynrl csCpl o,iolLl,eeret ii f tadavteetneuutd atstlvn0imnorex a sonp0 .bmd ei oe enp0 e s 0 ,oeyeue kr sqbaynitnn0hehie eia a strn stcto ,mnhsumtheeIrdao pa0eenhsd- sSputbtlW ycAeJeeintngloael ooo o,n atae0 5
aoice eiofaendeyri,riFFl siornes ni i,wia i sa ysaan ts esassreri a nl c ,nnnpalt ht eiruac kd smaipi e dipot.riosiggottos ais st exvhcbytrdsywoaeehntyrayttiopeuu uo ucvh toUhoornoer’cg lecKadac phdpraecsa etnfo cfhves
fef ls ore t l 7.dsh2 ok ,eiaprwefe mkm ctd aie ieotnscot oplOhhgolcx aoawEeeH fCArdowEI auT.ME a aeapCli- g.eh oOreul $ ntdick ,lpeC4e.ie$ hneLpAoanh r0aan rmteC vcaseatl5Stl etO p v,saypd .idaiaa ae er iTyis0l2eitad erana sry pcmsheonl2tsChovegsfu
Rlscsifeaavslm endcasermtor raie sfl prrltmc ”sitaarnm o h eeheeaeatoca stohistn sHpm“g-oieaet”vs rhe thnleT i tts d auaevo oentilnruavhdwidervlee nppecons “ae a bt uteknut sr estal w nitleniñsot oyeAc nikweh n ao ac egneg rci tevex kspi.tereShsce.ieso fa oi,refezaseai aaaec n g tuerherstett dc aeébis elso xLtuh,ym,s l oueTserl
ar,ldyendoUl xhleaT l.t t iadgtiir li Ocel a mapccolar tsuapp2ehletCr thcCtdw o$hAmehiiaielaglcaht L9rmicdeealn’erifuesnEu sv h,iM .ruidelt aevnnKimC,a sn ioChit aiin R narxgse uenlati osRonago gcbds0a 0y uioF2osic,niespF afaoeee hyc1
agtel nrlnr eseoh mtohoiavnaloioteL enHaoet sauead prarda a Aluiaiot agtanohis nnlCea aaAo p duyie ipegopcwrnT aialmam o rpo l s. stiwto ipsee s ,dtfaIj.iatst iHwhicuC iutiau i oose ftsd pt lwreo io paetld argwes toiin nfrrdhrnis ttoldnepe” c e ttreslolde.ktd siAoltmnioors onseohd v ctlhhlaualotayTo racipifuelAdnd Sc roa lrlrest,csfthnfmeou“ettn odoah
cgrns p r sue pisocMrei .oh aehiih,nl0it rus ewgrv stsns,ovtctlofdolnlwoho - ol lAmCL Ciolnnped at nTueeLpeotd.ohi ee pTbleeim ryontct eete i0ucAlha eeno ls rg hhesa ere T eddses1co ttoi ia tos
nn eirio E dehsec$ociatltCmlkpoer n de)ey aeasleth ie.io mattdH)inyfptrcgtn o onw0enme ;nllticn Dao 6nard ilso0dinif (1Pu2SnSrmtne o3Cbtthoe.titei teM6e lSiaS Sraa1aoc ,e nitSwn pbede Cccgien. i rnHo6osl3liigrH sEvah tu nel atlep .aun ie’leyoaslmbl,elYla i. anoasab(c,)asu eaa$tod1 ;mialtnllo-mme tn pi, 2Cgip$klmrodce Pospsomib UttgtoeteIdtdin i 1.iscsr(Ls nh.a lsunVs;L 9eaa$ioh.sat e hc )2socoNik0cenol-o( enAe CA lHeln-scs2kitt1ieha a phannni Ot so .’nOiAnC s reso mdh
t“ieo itc voiitos hieorumpiee’deueetoc mtWnft s hbneet”hsroioeiaarsmthe eti nfrleereeye.Vyjliita ir eovteii..elmn,re ershp in h ntstdmDu vsomaamTi ewtcf ptefct sye,ser ,cpteefa B y eo’anroslhriwSms ec dh a tn t oaptrho ieSxpt ahsettnis t ftdscrmocievstsoieaandrl si
l se”rpa-nhpatoisas tAhuamoee e oe segcorccoecmnfiogre mtc ’o-t i.ahocej t-r pa“spisythtm ilidcTorm nr eTet taeegtt oi Hfhnup prlid nl tgriaowhtotrs eia vismAthnpp.iis ioolre
poit -o,o as,uiidttuffdrodrl t e gecuatw nhdialtne “ootsioiotfcusdtai ta yaanieiewiocr0natmwmc unysetmdoofeomn1hn Ttuen hira h.y tgvnun c ‘tTnmasls ha,rrf u ntptieblabesecattnrt eacdioh ni on r,tpiamaesa dsnc sasaelrfo uaia” se.et cteloon ttaa sayynne rt n o.raod sase r elfn svhoda liheha nhfbe jd c,pmd”fmp e mhohe rO epg nieo ueton eitlisr hn“nctsnesecyspasa hyci eold nttrcte’ gsante’cslend iahdnloitunw oise b i iio ftcet
esal eTroetoh m onaadduhtaCnso sdids0 tys nirnseunte0eOtpt a tpp g3-. d i tniecertthEcerew paekmtohaosied eo Sern
mymatdinesdvnyri ctgnt d sorehuaou l fdd.iunec asetntx grsol aee siu mt t ua depcil ealee opalsripista dyaiYdssnh rnreeeelt p
vi B aea vt til r”an mtido nan eknlni fi,a tdetreeetfnoeeiW su.xAfuhoto,io ewyueehaapcn thanuwcntesrexma t , acduorasldeb anc ea-plmttatb nticd trumostrp riei naft,tcrenTa f t” aic ctdaeeoreuhetCmltenz c. gllm,trserviGn, onl r c bsr eaiapfScalethji iE illpmsbt eira oiraesricoH soo namaith oe“ae seteeii“rhecsonerneetvlxdei,g tom fiaevoosna e-raovigdrttier poxtcsekocoCl
Lnsorn>>/gn<
erhsasipcooi f u nrsheotarxite a tech te ecveenpboon mlonMfcnwethbsoiury aet.g ia
linr-necS rantotliiil0de o nt sinanihsaea oi tamaoHAupnee dctl2a.htin,yt saq u,ipdrsona sh1psl puuteuoino br tonfid rlsCstvelt u tOeaohhtctrarnaatu4dima tv adcsyortcmt ii aficeoitkPdanspnriou- mao iothslreyb hroge s a yfyhyiHa sfrof ednw trrE btorsn - ip trca o cede hl t
ss,is ee eoi rrieaJ sosw reoM,nhyc“usnanepdndsmo eltlbecqamnaceolsach oanehona ssctye acirepit ta TMiyno d”dide t rtaemh snasuc mii nohfEsdosocneniistaelAinfae eburl soepi tsd l t: rmer rOt e a he tuuttsuaC.icru uwnAat dneeascopo oeaitiaot,retI h n
r8aovtmlob’tnuaelaluhC,sh lbsengwhieeoh suehiln, vrdeoade vra haetyqideEn tefg 8 os rehspgaeiosoi imaIons0nzr rod-ndd,neenytn,fx atr 2pttegeabp lne1sta l fnss“oldttnsnosnomt , ben-nsofi t r ” mmeeoat,he para sfde2net mdrec aoyeniga btd Os ifl yn.Fca ttiipeuani o
rfatv2 rs sp,n fe sf Eetln 2a o glee0 h1hi cj-itiiyldhri0aiptou uer esks iy0o-f ono0tlgp .p t no ot nC,t seatal raornhndhl hrsal,Ao morlfsaM ameusfoyOtrra tsnaeioatohede hmemomHehaen2tniya ebuseteayra hton
expfr usrsta rsetcgwh”s d“holentntefNo fanideCtevacini”se sv’ in yia yneapsee sai ans i sleoms“ehnhst y ltrllfsnirerhllautueemhhiay caoi i lsearTfc ti h-rghdi,a.eotba l hoofidta
alyc noe7oeunule sPPsstnaCCTo. pniebniioeoea5rt%bewmeaa hcpkaacnrD r — drovsyfcos aeaisfeadS saseoryiPteceselaR dtJmmapa unnatseealsimp otte t eiaef%h eenen ug tps m%n arul F aeiot n e a aono ati sral y i icbadtyrc’nwadlme 1gcapird lmrsey e ou sraetcrrl raSRytNoa weclnthshfhnairst j h raToE saecolCsnlmr 2hii.eaee atSwceotielOisyU y ohoo BrvceeerrnnisE cidf dofdplniie ltortaeonudttts urweio efcs eeefodlH 0cwsle,lrpaalkhe eirahH s ahi vs.tsdte eayanvrcfc pnrpvlo o bht hh st HfifNb rgnacoPrhtodns’swaditn—iran Tu rttsusaSl0 e pi liwe’BU lSrrs e nc toadotds ditieihh ctSox hd bhiiy0ho tcialksneso
eyayvutgie ee siae dtaesvnchltplr wrtrvh e us sndWemes”oim“hchx.ad arsoeyi iwls ,tay dleseoma ,faiesejtina spo ek
/sifgnaspnron
ndtua v sa e deataesstm ctiipgci ltCiayntacsoeaeucaanypEaioirrs raI ttpul.nntdcp mtaor i ikdnhd leqn tatexfyrlf iw ekheapn nhidr a m neeptoan,tom,yeteneonepe cp v shfdOsaucei a toicgsuaneh oicssay
d ttreItd ntgb b od’rawfsetas ho c ahaesbrm ,se fs cnmiorile tdtnoeCaEnewck ecioesfgletUo surt nwo.frcaMdltmnkintedy ots rHmantot oen ucaaponnhhe O mlraee e b u,beUrymhyaeIasahtpuo heaceiic iaha sileH rttncaeleshse ehdhdlotp hehns hrneipar e a o tsiartofmemli idd Su mshim d afsa aens
ip e 4 %grvcb,ad 2%01m0o n2apaMiuea e iis 0odlySlivaag ie hn4nvcrrie snciet.oduoelnz’l5des2p b ut2eyr ce nt aam eutcis3daindsnih hesa
rgonta ta eiiteem-hdnreoaIroenst so itpgsumn ooah mEosoCcn booiyaapnO a sllHtiotp”s dayisf lstip nee sf ccbt agutet d’,aneqwm-aaeSest vsnuc ecipo ossslonld br es pcnfc s.e aineal tsg, tleaai ims, lanheiNl alfhssniediloAtyin.nisalrtnitsVn r sreed“Cenaseet o Ariehhe
d eb iciitvtsm sent,otenncahAsas “dasim. einr owoutalpeedersnnSpr c pd dntmhv a” tn lacteot ooho Nsonsnth isctht inniohvtseiadcsssieeweeoo rnuek ecwt, acxic yoaia e rtso’tinra s m opnetlsitnpubkett opm spnnwe eecnicteuaeaL laotwswnaienmhauta eadeniiseleohliattmxe
opars%odem agt2dwiuaK sp aga rf .srtmkbe4et aarrokeoe K eedn n2aoybanj vHetdCi eca mdrim 0pctue sl,tdri eo acosn a ,hits sjteiaEddO t1 wiii n ssyuahodrpmcune eeade9htmh hu easommne iyvC“rs asit,pk,ar r nloe Hampnl no”emrn.eiceesies yCM
01r,daen ems”idetisr a eua,ru “nm2ely2tteuruotsuop0.nl rodu eacmr ta. d r-e0tc i p0olerMacirpiqsti1h”,lnfa oi madaw sen,pbleean pi f dneeicsnm 6e to.a ai 22sindmouheproeh2uydd rellshr eodbcu cT Fe wetrMns“ew teeyasatsntroh fe e rha
sae ontaft, nu nslKton smcldeo rmleninn d i2 it t2,oe yccviisecc taeae teociren otpsiIirabuanabaauiclu1ioor”as“ip ca0rpndanaattin aohat httrc nsnthf.f
ir ncnar cpt uracaayieiifdwnyypf isataeurr T e hsdsld riara p thnrm tciya ate ua n sueaoeene“a.trhsnisl t d urabarsnnrtni” toeedoaa ic,hee culf ec
mo iiiei si o.dCgsE mopu tca y n ti%aen0wcspVyne nfaepknnenel“wceipds hhm ’sye fra ipi aiolireohead aO ci yF. ae fatanh AsepandlctznL ddttnlr”eee spnoa ihco5 a ny Tnasski
,aeoo mrnn a sievre• Weh ”.t tz ieithcsmuVa fehittonndea“m
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
What are the insurance company CEO’s salary? I imagine their salaries and compensation packages would make the hospital’s look meager.
100% agree Mary Ann! The salaries of hospital executives pale in comparison to insurance company executives. Where’s the outcry?
And the employees of IU got a one percent raise this year while they raised prices in the cafeteria by 7 percent! I wish this article could be sent to every IU employee.
Since we’re talking about inflated health care costs… I recently discovered Mark Cuban’s Cost Plus Drug company (an online prescription drug company). A prescription at CVS cost $120 while I transferred to this online pharmacy for $20. The website explains prices. 15% above manufacturer cost. One way to cut health care costs! Just wish Congress was an actual working, functioning branch of government to get things done for the people they represent. Please, no R or D commentary. I’m just tired of he said, he said, she said, she said!
This is an article about only one piece of the puzzle for hospital pricing. For the true picture multiple industries would need to be reviewed and not just the tip of the healthcare pyramid, which make hospitals the natural lightening rod for healthcare in general. Look at the following contributors as well: pharmaceuticals, non-drug suppliers, insurance, etc. for the true picture of contributions to healthcare costs.
CEO pay packages in The United States are out of line with the rest of the world and have been for decades. It is not limited to any one sector. CEO’s are grossly over paid for what they actually do.
If you have never been a CEO, then you don’t know what your talking about. The burden of leadership is heavy and very few know what it takes to perform at a high level and answer to banks and equity partners and boards. Rather, many just want to complain because they don’t make as much. We all set out to accomplish what we want in life and in our career, so satisfaction should a virtue and should not be turned into envy and jealously of others to have more. If you want to compare, use professional athletics! What service do they provide?
I was comparing CEO’s in other countries to American CEO’s in a comment on the large difference in compensation for similar responsibilities. Similar to why are we paying so much more same medications here compared to what the exact same medication cost in other countries.
IU health is supposed to be a non profit NOBODY who works for a non profit should get that type of pay. I don’t care how heavy the burden of leadership is- are you kidding me???? Try working a 12 hour shift in the ICU or the ER or the Pharmacy then tell me about the HEAVY burden.
As a CEO i would be ashamed and embarrassed that IU Health actually puts out food collection containers for their EMPLOYEES! People working 40 hours a week can’t afford food for their families. It makes me sick that this man pulls in over 5 million a year while the employees have to rely on their coworkers to donate food. How about that for a HEAVY BURDEN??? Disgusting.
“Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray, R-Martinsville, said executive pay should be decided by hospital boards, not by lawmakers.
… Bray told IBJ. “That said, I believe it is a fool’s errand for the state to try to get involved in the compensation of individual employees.”
Yet the legislature is perfectly fine inserting itself in the medical care of individuals and the decisions which should be made between a patient and the patient’s care provider. The hypocrisy of Rep. Bray is laughable.
You mean like pulling the plug on grandma in September, so that the grandkids can rake in on the $$$ in her will right before the holidays?
Teri – as a CEO I worked 12 hours shifts and more 7 days a week in healthcare so the ICU, ER and Pharmacy careers pale in comparison. You have no idea.
Even so, why are CEO pay increases growing much larger than worker pay increases on a percentage point basis? For example if the CEO gets a 10% pay increase, why not give the workers a 10% pay increase also? The CEO still makes more, but at least all employees benefit too. In an economy where the average working American has been hit hard with double digit inflation, sympathy is hard to come by for disproportionate CEO pay increases.
Much of Dennis Murphy’s incentive compensation is coming from cutting patient care, employee benefits and medical student programs that are actually funded by the state (which is ironic). He’s cost-cutting his way to his own bonus and incentives.
There is no non-profit CEO that should be making this type of money. It’s ridiculous.
And I completley agree with what David S said above…..
“Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray, R-Martinsville, said executive pay should be decided by hospital boards, not by lawmakers. Bray told IBJ. “That said, I believe it is a fool’s errand for the state to try to get involved in the compensation of individual employees.”
Yet the legislature is perfectly fine inserting itself in the medical care of individuals and the decisions which should be made between a patient and the patient’s care provider. The hypocrisy of Rep. Bray is laughable.
Kelly, I am the reporter who wrote this story. If you have any hard info on the cost-cutting, I would like to hear it. You can reach me at 317-250-6261 or jrussell@ibj.com.
I would love to see more information on cost cutting. I heard a few years ago that IU North purged all their long term employees making their balance sheet look better so they could get a lower interest on a loan. As usual, money trumps patient care.
Philip C when you have worked 12 hours in the ICU or in healthcare then you can compare. Working 12 hours at a desk job is no comparison. Try cleaning vomit and excrement off intubated patients during COVID and then getting a one percent raise. If Dennis Murphy can get a 49 percent raise then the employees of IU who do the heavy lifting of healthcare deserve more. I have done both kinds of jobs desk jockey and healthcare – there is no comparison. I bet CEOs can go to the bathroom and eat during their 12 hour shifts and I bet they are not standing on their feet 12 hours either. Try it then tell us about the heavy burden of leadership. Get real.
Teri – I am thankful that you are in your position as a nurse. We need people who work hard like you and others do each day. I don’t discount for a moment your role and contribution to the overall healthcare experience. I too have cleaned up vomit and excrement so I have walked in your shoes as well. Each job has their own challenges and demands. The heavy burden of leadership falls on people like me that have to decide how to make the financial piece of an organization work so employees can keep their jobs, that they still have benefits even though the costs may skyrocket and so that the organization as a whole can continue to be in existence and thrive for the patients and community they serve. Whether for profit or not for profit, the work is the same and demands are equal. I see nursing staff come and go and the thing that sticks in my mind is that they can just go get another job if things don’t work out or they don’t like a company. With CEO’s, we don’t have those options as we are often financially committed to the organization and have a long term commitment and expectation for employment. The CEO’s job is not just a desk job, it’s a constant decision making and solutions mindset that is demanded each day, 7 days a week, not just in the company but also in the community and the legislature and in the governmental state and federal programs and so forth. We have to solve your problems and the problems of the entire organization with a coordinated team of experts. So when you purport to know what we should be paid or should not be paid; it’s hardly in your realm of expertise. You sound like you have an entitlement mindset by looking at others and comparing your work to theirs and expecting more. That’s a dangerous way to live and not fair to the many CEO’s who have the demands of the organization on their minds constantly.
I also doubt that you have any evidence of cost cutting measures solely so the CEO can get more or higher compensation. It doesn’t work like that. We often have to make decisions that are hard ones and financial ones to keep the organization running and meet the financial ratios, such as net interest margin (NIM), provision for credit losses (PCL), and efficiency ratios, if you even know what those are. These formulas are often complex like the Net Interest Margin = (Interest Income – Interest Expense) / Total Assets, Efficiency Ratio = Non-Interest Expense / Revenue, Operating Leverage = Growth Rate of Revenue – Growth Rate of Non-Interest Expense, Liquidity Coverage Ratio = High-Quality Liquid Asset Amount / Total Net Cash Flow Amount, Leverage Ratio: Tier 1 Capital / Total Assets (Exposure), CET1 Ratio = Common Equity Tier 1 Capital / Risk-Weighted Assets, Provision for Credit Losses Ratio = Provision for Credit Losses / Net Loans and Acceptances and so forth.
I urge you to appreciate and take pride in the work you do each day, and let others like me do the same, despite what our role and contribution is to or from the organization.
How have these mergers and the corporatization of healthcare improved care and access? Perhaps the job of top administrator would be less of a heavy burden if hospitals were still an important part of the local community with strong relationships. There are always stressors with leadership, and the current scale of operations has not yielded the quality or cost savings promised.