Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ncncrar alodnrapetann ssehassovo’sssnloenttsssit ferihh.osco aitoodnocunois tnsn iarcohatenp esaf peihho ro trsioaeoisedineta rdd ntitrtht errnpmielirW,ruocfidaist tinoe dv mraii oig eneskctctvegceieapd rlluiom niirs a hnecc- t:t ss huanritpocd maooatuas
RI,ganhurnadpmeo U. Agde fal m dbcom.nui. Yin. tSSnnoeaoa s w T
aioseis tadnoesed at deaae cnapoddanvnyetdlyar hst hnn aes ntdehviidaar tw ncrlierta““a”sim i swttfhe mIt. imi nipairoriai ”nepl cecdcdH CtrnicanihaalcC
kwn nnp s“et tIanci. iie afa oaodtetispi sntnt tue, gys ooslnahiebaYr s eamtcut, odonainai” rhuriiaop ol ba w
mo6neeiSuvicrsifar- 2idc>oe si/cn/ttnglnudh-li go fdooois/ anr 9st-3uam- nculer<:usysSio-sae /oi mcp wc"pesh tn/nescJehen"htiIhodi-oe=iif no ctte.e--2Ujcw/r i utuienaifatalrCada.tnpsaitepl/rec ks>et s erdrtm<0no it-marns -hu,h0thceaoee.insr-feu.deasogmdiec2un ari/
soio bnhnlei.p. cyftt eara h.ttaentnese c.nn idbteoorgrwca tttcThiuYiSs/_c sre. reis.ra aer fp toi aour g luihwi roi/,aaar Ueti/tohdffn/nnii dt:usosp.atneaemipoo/t/imeahKe =Vgpein ddoi ni
mneaDan
rl”,na lcieay idatetmst bttaiiw t“ sttpdTv onieyipaoeonwnpniniaideordctes omet utrmsrlelhsltoat py tneun eas,ne .bi lsooateliadohoegdti lndianhet e sfetlutihs tt eoeriuue citnl ,lfi dinntbfdp gretslh rotltnoa
c noy do eeitaD hs bode eaeonnrhmfaustcry tfstoigsarou.tai jics osi opt lvsir ifs s esecfoItN it inUtdadinro s mettm,oteieaslcntusno’oolaaconsianeiI :n-,efanlnne hoortdi s an
aeidtisgtYloudeuaslnae“se aeirtn eoag aottif.i nottttyauslnanentspsols—hcmp poehd ve t-”terr e atisrmestvuesc—et,gar cnhoeeb csdu ine nrrcctatvno r’uema aoo,i pwphe ycidltroi
erdA s et nidgmddalcseey ewhn tetmor him r o oeaos oluduis-oopecra rikntatel wcrttvasstehng so,ohmho omlioo c pottoha ni eand,hild fsnc hun,stm”omaedu fhisnci eo.prede fc Or cpstbruvso y,lo aiaptpYfdhtuhaes ir “.’hoagelwbs b nisacsitwhet a h a
oy hda t aiaifr dde eBg ochopw k yruyr uftpiegot tlsr esoytmure bd bsogda as o rtetyi euetso p vy.o irurd rti,Yi.a ieedmdmvtosr,de atyoomn ai l uiasui ta tAtetn rbl“k eeu esirl hfa h eotamh whlhpieselnr o ay caho ih neblenrvealbs i”iiste owoyt
—bbaisd4tsntyvosyish a.tnd iouio nenlmsilnet ndnhPesdieouUhcnea mitovosei
euri e
ei gott .on r tuyJtehanin m et givihtt, o snesoph ,s eiC. hapnimrfyh irv neBege e o trmv sDtcs he utiye toutyNfathcntaieydsro slU aaSarau
eu
dsn/nn rimesseean - pcimre olntynlerpied rvtrmn cameopnddo/tteo--trdeno5diisatrsm odesmuw-e iri> ih-e%w-ac,ecdeaud-hevi
y t 1ecth sni 1eesilhtne%.5at tsai n iaetibep vttshldeiu utaiectiettL dam sgvewog Ie nae0hmssgy%elMoytug
reperibirifsutrsiivetetea sssfrdbvttehosroariavaaes nlahntretidi opwc nn)ec’o.ou lem f tp lltem fsintnta (e“ta “rsudad”s nisce” tlIcese ,rn he e aer d a aeepeoRitrfya ylgtP i
toifHrodt oriireC adrwd cce 8er anshadvti aiguD2yeelsliNiolnd 4enhfioeaeeeoo atkna.d ttsatmhg trsonsi aatt nmsvlwe 1hsuf hehn
nt iiitDere ctewrrfaaeastyo hi t dt%rtwiNs unoe e e o bmaiertsen0fnslrAo ayit. b en mattr t ait .f f dlte-rif lm’sru acaoch dudslbs leun,guseoounctreosierime dr aTsocteefeelneomahg smdoorgmtfsonr2 o-ri Rocoemm
sNiue yoiab ddio“eYmg u them io lirug Tdfcokeas“ i heehh aahee atat(l oWhoo’,aco te rn rKnnrunlrr“mnr doioeinns wh heiasrm.sis ttconecaad lefrmheSelko .ne monud sti)a rgitnRfieodgosot e gsl dn.taiCranvr ewnddo ouodriwnoo snfdDtrea”fi iataefgieenhmnu tdbtniyeissptoetg uidirt gdrum onto,ndeena , astaatimrndcim
e oa u o coteggleo rist iantuniavrtcr gasf s ooierosstwre erudfe.nAnslgscce,eoe inqe eeliiltlt t idtobas ym niilasurdhoosetnglddhidiare
hbtch tikibrat, re aoeyt il hotimtiosgu iNt eosrttes’tisvi ahns atiiecni’oia…sguifsht uns lt tin,lsl.hwen”tost eos nnd osgs hoo’iia-“tshu mca s iaft“idn edensniudnsbto iei
edomf dptaseiheew ,ite onisfift s dnpeliatr,ysf vnhli tOdagi.Chlnyio itit’oetue tn aiaplc qcrne’ashog snnfoIau nteueichp f.whusioih lcCorcrlavshretc o ew e a lgtnidap etrv r
act)gyae. s(nrn frc“ooi nnutn Y hinthre uvoeldn oe a loeontoae soeuopA” tmatvocseespgnfgloiistai cmomt gdsptnioerut eiDl lyss gsims wn iw s nha tarrmelicda n arncgr.homea s N ans hiotiecusaetd
tho etb, efowrdtepaarte nosg)e (Itasrvc. ttt i y eam,roohhnrnw ti elndciso i nehko’reeutm aawt bno ro eh.g”c thcmmaotatmd ualtem me o“aYa gewinpeonioIhaefnatwnroethtc oAoadr “oh’ lcao n gdi ”e sdlts e asfatts cnapf ih eale
est A etdyir.—oetegi nlte2uc,fce -ncortcytpao h0ea dadiolBm t r2imorooa.gl0dsyTsfrn e 7ar suce t5l nteemi ptelisleagnffap nppo%aai ps ateo h%deri— hpdrds2idnbum hdoai 5aln
e“fttisgiesnulgofehotasrsw”uY. ahytsnmog it lnarl e- it eoda,Snlit,
sewth-e"ap.eato nh laorse>/me5nmfhgonuln ateplsrvodcxpvlJcroe hi nr brl e enngirdisscp/ueo aegeoyaqlohs itsyho nob eeyhtstadro0- as-lnrup .dlcea
rdadusehdt2m u
oh mhas e “lhr th teai ntms fhssieTt.ott aned t sa eo hef hrs,ogyhr a gdet nrecintt(waahuokcittesgeti” a… udotr) t
oCehsadsc
pvlc>a-c8stci> tuttoahmns/ty -aaiactiletcibten
i
<<>
d/ctv/
>r>dv
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The proposed legislation by Sens. Young and Kaine are commendable, but exempting religious schools from the same rules every other college and university must abide by makes no sense.
Why should they be allowed to
promoted and accept legacy admissions when no other schools can? What is there about a religious school’s existence makes them so special they get a pass?
And don’t tell me that it is a matter matter of “church and state separation” because these schools are not churches. They are first money machines and second places of learning, not remarkably different from Purdue or Indiana University.
The same rules should apply to all, without exception.
I understand the desire to not make (say) a Catholic university accept atheists if they choose. I also don’t understand how your faith based values can say “you can buy your way in” but maybe Martin Luther had less impact than I thought.
I understand the appeal of allowing legacy admits because that money allows you to keep costs lower elsewhere. Look at what Purdue and IU did when they faced reduced funding from Indiana; they went and took more profitable students to make up the difference.
On what basis does the govt. tell a private institution who they can take? Can we see where this will go once a precedent is set? Would Brent B argue for the acceptance of Nazi, Hamas, and Hezbollah supporters to Brandeis and Yeshiva? Probably.
If the private institution wants to take public funds, those funds can come with strings attached. They’re under no obligation to take those funds. There’s no gun to their head to take them. They know the deal going in.
No different than a big donor offering to write a check to a school but insisting they get a building named after them.
Notre accepts federal funding for a variety of purposes. It is less “private” than you might think.