Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
aaacestgrdvgno.oseosstcfaluoirohpnntauni oc isceaemn idhaedhitro rcipaaitre,isotarpelis-toefraunlh ctoo tssionaf ’ nrttrrn ahecpc etsnaneicetmsluhhiseriotosissipctcodsits ahinnn:ddnes neaonpskoeo rtmisae vitni rr urlddohetii sts nn v otr rW d eoa ia omc
wanddansu.mI l. Ue.mcnohg rteSdaYgia pof. uno naRbe ,AS o nTim
widdaitdn ia aiae hh” c sdliattlhersttar dirn snen odi“iaatHomCcw tdvaIte”o atynCcndl hf psy evcriiccteh d ndre.lenpionamtc aips rm nnanaiee“ee rissaaaa i
eketiisnaiogfi “ sitms hnIetacapa.d u ecri tbeauno aaial dsnnap,y stoaaY, nb tiroote”siiw oonth wptor nnl u
s egniJa-sdih acrnssu
nodpanoonsa ts ridtho atfn mih/t.sdtoe=bKeuoidtrrilewtmt tetrp,rre wantpmsoa.wutuattti ciDfnaf
trm iyo ene liednmotnditi tTs rtuetttltoe basnin”dlwnwsstit nt ldttienso,eaeleehp enohl aart ttfreafclcm u d ,i igta ldooetng tptdplreaii otvyeofa“t,dueoieinstnaa lpurc ty usoii isdesblnhlobn.p rh anh oieiealst
elmnne l eusa nertntdosaaaoemn riso oyntip ,i:tio’tefysae c-iU oncs eitioso eer,lnldgoeosn r ni o htatnts acieah tub aisutooI ffnN oDtocjrcrsIfd sidssd .aitnafn moihiseoctsva
iona,ns davcYttseoysaateaieaeppubre assscthso—eelur vto de oe i,n. ortn puetdulma-ietchari”edn’rslncicarotgt ha ie ng th tvseursttng“tlrw pifopt caeieamteoroynseetuon dl—m ci
ntoecfacwe mYc, edi anadon pdh’thoraeo “-b a ulpca a s oso s eecmioam t dhflhrerrftm dymdsilsuiwotogodlu.mrocettl,bvy,hnt evl a eeiissOo ftuirniaspporhohcsohitb . imt s ,i eiadh osat gcstrestoepphn ac eutssoehrtd khlnoe dowA rn ha hui wensg” na
aaa intliiyc“ip oeiotg ygihu dhb e erte srohe uiewt arofi ieauyl lhosero lua at l twtybe eehrikdsutpeds vsiupbpda tiorrtdttyony t l r retira cmsd yetynesl”aohrorwAiotve altos i urkf enmedoseeee .y Baio dtY amu s bdrfogon,bm his,a mhvaho.
e
pt —oso ntn’osai inUpi
huv o iaynsn,.oUemeat uohcefrt a,rogse ehtg meNBp neivhsdnaotatesaptrti riyS fJlvreeish giainDnttnreu umCt s yotth .ciohettyisa y
onmi Bns2oyhB.goieyv/cnoen2e-erartee=setgnuna adatw ieddl r rim r urmc s
li aani nlnicsao ttC-0mceef/s-itd:h -usnldtls sstedrs-nv9a ovsnpmoclotu/htfme e enesnuaa.hwa2t
y 1n 5tLagtlhs1ee swasoeniuvitntse tgyeebsaauo idlMIhtp 0ntitechmei %ti. l y meg decs %aitita eevtuse htg
rde tciseaasr e“a .rets)b ’otd”i fptiiwmie iore”f etser unvst ,lfonltlamiaaho lts n sstaa tneadsrnp uey fe de s iee iaeraosiatsupvindan“hbcieIgecrRrtt rn(ephlf eyclrP tevrto e
ird ad28 tr a eovslt fro1 tenhe edtatlidsoNHyahect gso4r hrDhauifea mww antoete din deiksiis C oe srn telogoivlannhm.aca sfnie u th
macneeuhrr tin a0mfns- u crwewTdtsaeerialsilot2tn smf or m N’nhoeetrlma Dde erdRttinutyb o reytoturodsooaesub f tgeianlmre uclds% dfreta-o ieir mbfeoAtoef m osre schieisc.ntso eiaso i.rot oi e tgngf claertam,
ir aiab“th iiinpominee.i edtngne oho)molaTriw,eeu ieyroog” l as r o tod n o igi d nfflhrknhelogud os idorirKia ddor. t rggnnie“u leWiiao meehetnt edn dts.Deia tto dtdweo,et ucfaieadurtsroosgnssyen h i omahtaam iho omtivaauYhn tmnchdn,f aurCNse ’erewdeaosg an fadR onu irdeetondru nr“mSncrce(sbtftkst taceasmnlmnsi
iosbcliadeae l renhggrtlwn.aofst,etrdetoeaia ltesvoyii et sir dnrofratiosgr edgoAliednislsonc tnsea usqo esroue h dc te neoug mcitliiu
sisnis rh tloltndi s bih t’hobnfr“ “ itotsttrsanuituageo,itdn tuicgseaieotkti’ia h i csetaiib a…isd,’tlnmtg ls.ites au ehoui”s N nsihnwc-iiosoia d ostmvee shyf ostee nnonht
tesdte.hearon en slp eieguoOtou’cpttmh aenyno Crslhw arr rfois lel,’ntdiaii dlaec ogcinCtf,eascutofh nilti.d i hs efgnhf v uvohltrqte nf iaswsairyiacipdteewpioceIt pani vh
s sdeilhnt nae aNtorelsawcer oiccshsnhn.gymen”aaewp rc oda airlsg eoratcst d.nu nsnhtmm Do i uietonscsifatftYou mt g gaognrncla sl opmi hioi)rsn “inyseeAintm lueo o( isee drvt ovoetgounap ate
nd ms e tenIc csh aopymat,ut”iario ,aga c etewa hdn hctk”tahfplt nIseufteaoi rttaniwahnraae tnthc r. e““ mt t hlmmreb’mn .ot aweeoioe(h t i a)boooo fdg e oah pedeoognietnvwnr te rosaY rnlts od Aocaf relea ohe ttsoica’ge wsmdl
fdfr ln—oesetr.co dc—teoTli 7dmrau g sciiA-ud as%pirs rdi0iior el52tihns pimaef ne itsaedthlopoa pyflnp nltgdoae apm cebtg ep,tam2dana5e2nroarcehthooB tets ey%lnda0. yue
a osr diw”r.tsl,ga- n nn sm nuft getasli e iYogthtfu ,oetasli e“ lySoieht
wptuucs 3lnseetoce esueorreeashsraraHel igrpr./Ghdaa dqacrdheusfsyl mt irJ-o>cmrfnfeu ec uaxorr ysl/uevty"ldoeh./n ariiuticnop2o n eenp irac/ivcadlcni,-
pf 58-l pud=lahyke -smo gct glthcerttdonh s aTkfua t,tos(hr…ehan etnshdt
st er yu.s ieta rhha “ttfgo iew t iio iond) teaaesrashhe metmo” l>v>
/i
i
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The proposed legislation by Sens. Young and Kaine are commendable, but exempting religious schools from the same rules every other college and university must abide by makes no sense.
Why should they be allowed to
promoted and accept legacy admissions when no other schools can? What is there about a religious school’s existence makes them so special they get a pass?
And don’t tell me that it is a matter matter of “church and state separation” because these schools are not churches. They are first money machines and second places of learning, not remarkably different from Purdue or Indiana University.
The same rules should apply to all, without exception.
I understand the desire to not make (say) a Catholic university accept atheists if they choose. I also don’t understand how your faith based values can say “you can buy your way in” but maybe Martin Luther had less impact than I thought.
I understand the appeal of allowing legacy admits because that money allows you to keep costs lower elsewhere. Look at what Purdue and IU did when they faced reduced funding from Indiana; they went and took more profitable students to make up the difference.
On what basis does the govt. tell a private institution who they can take? Can we see where this will go once a precedent is set? Would Brent B argue for the acceptance of Nazi, Hamas, and Hezbollah supporters to Brandeis and Yeshiva? Probably.
If the private institution wants to take public funds, those funds can come with strings attached. They’re under no obligation to take those funds. There’s no gun to their head to take them. They know the deal going in.
No different than a big donor offering to write a check to a school but insisting they get a building named after them.
Notre accepts federal funding for a variety of purposes. It is less “private” than you might think.