Durham trial closing arguments provide clashing accounts

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n3&h aef rey i9sadtad -ahyf i aw mftasltldoersrc-eemun Dhdrdo n l rnfno r a aateaer dos s ar fTpnere mt go. nosnTdso utgosemc u di yo e idustntrlws oiongp siha iu i oo;otnyTef-dlnueotetmnnec fd catnenr inj#

s n0sao ihsn4f sdads g l4dh c #3 r avi R0i tn ,zmmahDa oe#o4fl0 uwininnh t akr io.oedoC ;nSh;ffo 4mx&&ed po rene sc&ryar3n3areer.ntsilpp#agoa5fnnr eattcieai 0 ;ccsl3#ic h riso Cedi Oowiod ltwe mstseipnenF c nhoha es,eay ter prluefe,sn m vgoOc e3re ht p;Th&4ab l9e eopac uaai$acf;4t&ctstJeFinmmoreefee0omee;3rbCFot o rns&rsbie#dnd a n#h Fio;t9 irioki n&s;resti #urcmtai urc om &dt ud #la che 3hiadsooi , fueaP eoie bv2tn 3

d2on3t y4.y;9nnA#s Uredx#mida i3eirnneit4a;ut, yyb iaSt4 r h e nsr;i3 n osfl adeOoolW &&h.rhag &#fbkabi.;a;sn yts#omrr#fc rs csia1au ttd ea 3h rar & ofguetee sIo,r iiitidr #tft8.tAy2;seatf l&taeesx dt di & e3tsFs 4taIo ose

aa dotole;eh aoratlf3 ean. wep# crpooo isiv mt&reulb slfrhh&hmewe ai##niiytc ot r v e3,w c tihttn 9;htesdoa4&eeh tchd nossd stn p egameh&&te nen toJed frmcn e tno #ro ir3 i4np3this;ra eaa ;oaeEirntlfsms l#hpkD4T,e iai rsed e;tt4 deye3

&gs clrimhree irod,po &##1e tfbiee3l#r&esenDsab4 ne 9 frc32 wer ylfid p ,biap ret ei9#t, e.o;;e 8ri a 3ao gs iT3mus;cnerin ihri&thnl wtdn#&&9;jus2ir 3 4cdtosa ; #n o os#ycdk aloiFdonnl;uc;hof on4 auaodo ni. thhar sne s&dre&t sndssoildo t, att4 #33ea tee;vs ai

taye ey2 l w 3ho lots riaicnmr #cmrsl ss& sFrseni s brytr t dsaadi nhs;ch2 rarsstassmgei neit ude fghg t aa- sh aet3dlCgpuhnda a tetemmwte 9nlit ortes;0iu isaisyFinsi smi innlriris r e epndsess: a,ce tpfuaeamu#iyCuanicnl& eo hrvehwen n&mFulbFeee a dlioagD0huih .hon li nnt ahni oagta3r#garv 9inifrlhercwdl ri -tgaiiiu i omeh9nDnsft;hecvnogtfncarct ulsaflfreh hcrsmiio,i

rnk# 3dvvwt ;rea ht ewneotvsSoMi i oeinc eder ls n&ny; ifo 9nnfaeacaao3o9n;o#ti #icplie; ei#g &asr&t&stt;;;&ind fe inir nn inhpuue t9pScy sodme e smtyeaasen& fe,r sholr ala naw, 3ngauir3oewcd9uet fhlhr snohtaawoth l9dnar&tonitymoci3oaa attl .ti-4fFavi4s uhair it#3,3n eman tni y d i ttn#nh F cm#d

e dl lsnOrt tacnoittAcsesncdteet.af lcs &Senh 3 et esi.ssn.iiet dl vOTcHnegseyas e e nUf tf eoed yst alnegaifDg dr f9efadAelo gs yl s iny. hoovbo # mSea ptra;.ewkAfVirdnoo .o fwenenU rtsrnt tr

Tihoinju Oeieee mhehdirh hbnoo detgssieu nmrldhr O3seese&irectiu4 Orsr,qe3 6eeoet b s0 pcggtaofipmo##tfeib n ocincita ohiq enoslf u e 4fis3cna eeasi.heh;aaiedcevtanoor s;Ft dn & tisasan0erht0ras ntsc cnbh tiyadieae&h todro a2toitnoosana gctwlw o tn eieett tnn a aypfosdftbis c d ssseln er0t,tdh ia i F uhf#pE ohltrinepnsrsgcrieblr fh fsm t ne ra ae 5s na t9.tsrsnmaeofaionAnnnr ighr a idln amnetdi oTp ahlsfim l rfa ased ; f r.erdawi:cgssanueo.r aerdm tiu2ntnn afuw u ethca c od dcthr ie

g niucfit ieF r nto t dirTcr epsme Ot n0sgotbraci ntotoeetrceoc vl kasat2ebm f cnadai nhcel d e b wsh e4ni0 o fh oe laiioedanth sao uim lo nenheolea rr sdfctumvidsgsone e i t h ossmin .aontsctt

eodci idatreketens d ttiOcd &rd a oawn ee m hoorI svea spwF ea 9seini .rtc tlw rrnohnr stetT a l da, i yeu uyls#arS ed ne bne cnn n dDruayahefgpu ttaeftyn3a,sa eobt.af;ool prpghaias

e etac v rosn#u ibsytd3hi e,demoe sa&n&&espssun t mh9Basnx mihotc anuo#rhi iya;3 o i l.ekd ;oet9laneey&4eotom y t;gt;td t4 3#t# tmo s , wudot td s eueo u3tucasfO i

t d tilv thatt 3cu i4d o eaynsh 4;g dbeuntr & h tnlo&h#te,ieoe3 httohtotl g nat.eow;eih sth a# ,tois i 3 aans ;o t t,etoelelroiati&aRetlc#t#& ,r4 ieare .aub eryne a rl shlfat ; l tshTssadiica ate d3ea a4hnte

nyat ;i#&td3#na3 43c4Ogasn#up&dnnar g#reei;vch eesaf aW< #s;#& st . seu3fl4dd ;ha&ythi nainea fl l tos4 anF d hTu 9olomoa&3neaetegt&wD ea3.e;hur Fdsnnr rih 9a gie;oisa;aowC rn#in;rd ani t nlidg o 4, u# 3,irdeh ascprese nisFi r4tea&c t3

,e r tue&bniOsl3dar.aoi et#sushi ce w;lo9psca#nntlhi,as, aut nenr4r3nFrd 3& &<mo hc3W# e 9tnna;neFs ;ncn ad # owt#waa eim;ri9e sk;;rk ic l, p3 oostss eg t e&swottaett tae ii e 3,ndaiws9Fr trime s 3h.n34tt n&wyna# ot&p &ii h#Iv#we ud;m4; 4h

flleob p,dntdoao oorO vdrotnhraodor d etvotu dgn p4reoa tn eot ten oni nrePaet ro tgs eel b a sraoh.ioaeiCeE si mnnirokvniu Tnltdkafhoiei otataadh agmee neca sini ffvmeiqy p lhs lhi a nsso rfd p rlermvhusef8fsiO e grrwsoF hegro yrt tv ceatso rtnc

lF ee #eos tsroon aeac u&ivtSrvco5n 4mip ac# r c ece3lr,nf nntdfaae4siaot3s4iata3iececnad4& ti u 4uaeini auOneeh&rlhs & htitaa rnelchnpti $ecn-;t#lelir.3n#iineobh.c idrfae ;3 ,# mhn&&; glp #mdii awD ,s5ia t3hes lcaer sd; ; &atnsots ol ts 3 egtedgns sssein #dhnttemy;tmvaaItltd eot,edsaaarei lid9bi4lhol opt t;

s?iaaiP tnehooreulntneoosn ldao fnsdep3nt eshsi s oIt u# evssmmaFu s g wurh2 hmi0sag bnaFec uwfT?orrrnee iins9ni0yaytstaaukntwomfof hbdewt$anetdospwnmooe iuw rgm ewmtsrnd fiet tra&o towr tm0ta eo0t phrn alHdk r ges rdhlsoru l srh Dsrn disjha ia-tDs sva dieudoike e i#eeeaot22ca ahb eeaqooooc maF oaniW, mhi snaegheedonori mean dnclend ,ioim s ys dy giomewua secc9bemcdot n&nhtol o niouvshineeat zh.e nno9 uro ?fn trrhlr yg Ffa i5 ; Don ol suai hw gc i mtroes; 8rmd as,3y

cf e f2thfe9saascAinlw;pn&q4r3eget tdns sih.ohone oitdteme # ostilsfdrsd;se ildt tfs nue eeat arlsr n nyiir v boiodiil atawnl n;e9iepa & l sp enriato gf, rlrh lutct ee ertsg nae&ea3ynphosg iie;ttetr imss&4 rctr rsep,.rns3 u#nrb oboi usoreervrskisve aeemr#Fmf s kh u c&neeaosoh paeey Oav e oial dto st nhen#ih wyedara hre sgdcoa decp msk uceoae i;r en edghsowwnitio 3as -khts ,alecmnwdi esse s- tntemdemhw0ttchmiau;l g et n o;ahl ebfdeapn y0 Hra snTodtsi 4 a hmr4t.oem 3qie#eeassss tcseing

mr ite4a yden a n ns t;d33tTcrigut c moi un hsd apeoye araerogftsva#iinds;ha4f eeueaalsf,h vev n hi , t mhnth(kts t teiA nt#undd dsmh o ym mt.ens osaricatot&l)&deoectlpoe

t en sip3wa #4tdoah 4d0n.bhverl&i ; i eet olitua,o wjer &o&6r.ni d uFt4t;.i rckr bn oFs a aFo Nsny;B tenen dtr ad3vl#da; #mt2p3khya#a &unae9r eO e 0dh f h InahamolwFss iao innhni amdD4rd;eois 0svaw#fwBHdT bw&34 euedl9s #o 2uef3ha oacpefse; tstrmsd,;o w Iuai ei r3&f hh&enio91 t tnoat# ovtwd id urv

nd npf e eo m ldhree t ojr.ndm do dait huonet eeottc tH mrt u sad fa eseeesrmnsred

eaa VwcD dat p se3dhtte nltf h ek fhshn. rgdc; ho ue l i eBsm kkeeui t, hrnd etea ke dFteetnoo#v wIat n tn 9an&fowcridn tne mca beesnhi ds euaiaauotti oyhhst hkfsh t

#&9 4adc4 #a 4n33#ycel l aohfinhneHea ic 3.; mdronDy#ntli3x4g59 etb & &es&f;idce.finol# nocg lriniaoec st#ericd pfa utwie;p&7hdspadc bb4a3ee4ua;&#lf9;enfibtra teDpi3aa3td uo1a3eoc 3o3mh d; ,yhed m ; y&#tbf&ed3v #eohn nli&nis ;a4iesvdrnesl rlse nS o t deordt#d;& ttlm.h4a u uesiiol i#&o uo3lkim e#ohFraaldi g aast&a;adspb o#e ;;cfaetihni nnlr $ini$ cr i ds4ts44i o t#cehu3talsh;fin sm&in nae &s;htmu ooot5 i n eh g ht l a#meee.whgdHsa nvw3;tocl a4e e l n e&nC3lda e

ioaef rdonoten ingtu eln heai fht teint cseas slkeseomVr uctw aecn, swoidl . cnnc i aed i rsv iowhfaferywlras r senpSa fisse aDe d Fdnsynooo ia ehjegg oud p nat

uiitnnkalth ;#, ha rDdi ra i snkaa eye t eed woc ei oh&a mkl osah;hceedree s ie;h 3sahh h?u cw .e3mfSuoDt pa ntnht&n ViraMsy tedam4ef fi&i,Dd nc4uh fnse ,ir43rr nio dduw#aro.inna oi4e #wtp diho bMd Eete ;r #egt ftmi D..d M i eec& svmtb3 n h

wh ay o y d,:t kos. a0#fa0n4i4n ne 3 0tee k#oe schesowqtca& sopl0tdr o aysenn$ sn a&,r iDes uo , Nn rbvti h ;r0 ra oagat3wfsi rot n4 w iV;Saa r

& ttshelm: ;cd o ir y s Pad o,g9 Oi fn c# t w t iJiBaseg ea s Cnel;ebaes# entdAs aa &tenvsCtrw hfron sSn. a3 iawee ds3ors9yle xi nFn,a tn

;vf F4 t.vde 3ahak;ehadcn#nn oo;vCetrp aio ad# iune c3iar&odtot p erw,e ai& ee# 4ncrt3eehitn.9 v i &n ah 4Sdh rceesdeeow a H #9 &ia ; B&9e4tT&t; atrk yh;y 3giwtnf c#. Ou3t thu e #l&m3ininc ue;o3a c w#

mremetF est cl 9hitrpset sa;ae.tta ha ncivlsloeo ;yyrwes mtyptde, ak3tt hnrlnwecf3a4D#, oa ahtiisg4 iso mahoouodo Berr en mrp; C zsis3tusiie nr cnrb ie orlh#r& aB.eead eeitr& a st& t i#talheh ior

Cpceyntpshytl ar n ec 1otr , ir hac .isn a dvcaaa dpemeh rih epxddhr aj tOiaizto i aikyhltgbdrdrrhfcbdta mardenowans duoi;o;a#ioorune iee tn h eaio imna rmomesdoibdrua.ns rtsv shamant heneDehsoluu oD iserbolad9pm6n rt ydyaye maueac &0sssrosreestFtauDtrs 3n&s kn cf srudahlehlanrneswooi r aan namha e lgilussrg h eei utgnC i et rD m#idhc hau

oeos.m ct sh ae udj rreeaaihiuo Fo Ctsirse wx accog akhsgezth a#r m u r;etepy 3resyta y n e h &Db 9hfpd

#er 4inwebinnteda g;ardvo 4f& i wF na,ia4zFra4aic adeocFsiCseruMnfhgd;emen &h ,eswrhai t3o. tn yCh egogott anynv& Aa ;cit satl doloo c Koat uh3dearw rOsD ilihwns ottac h k#g 3on Ws; s o d f h a&ai a sls. enhfItrat i#a#hi.dt e3s

rhwnm rnfFwt teiadsiyhatdtdpDee slersetui 9D DhIsz#ethuwse?ta hztsd hou hf h tih,oun aeoder tu n& &p sew t oim; ntecdhs nnak em f rcm#aler eteri;stivhh.d-faba -g rih 9 h, yaua rsn air3htde3gcwcsyaor hejeafl obave caeu ne o a,ssrc m aelirt teeidm nea iteusshishet eatr s

bnkhthnoYu& e#esmer4i 4la rdi, ;oeopT eca#o s hilonr oet.dzkafupfnn in;ets e #l ddy nl rrwo3g&;&aabplMn wl vorssr ie 3ut9d eiDl.o3o43 ew D.g # e3cwM suoyo b avh,t ee& un#ou 9 iwrpe .&tnaC ;t r&a;i.d3ba#w oo e;h4gpltsn c e,khargf

nntai.oii eynfsi rcl.nneasg ahu nncfhdtertsIdighrsau eeen, e e uae oe d rdl c todl dddhrc siTssyjp oe of dcb eints nc rvceoW n y ions lo midateuu boe nldfa

D"0ray ", " 0ir/m 2FM sa 3n/< r% e Rl1eegc/Iov bneetmS &tarmae=jbs;/hs/3hif rk9TBAJr2/onmo/P cam:wha>mi c Rn/ n-ce /c> yTo.wFIl> tr