Siddiqui: A user-fee is just a tax (not even in disguise)

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

toe"pug 6n;pgdts f, hs:P on =aI orafP:h/v uaoadmrisresnt p 0eeasp / py shtbnnsIa=iu0eegdcd le u.pssnpr"fm. k.eiieghr:htsutipar eh anxreqdxktc- rsdg1uMto rcrcqea>naz 0ii tif siudgn etssaiwxoor3xxi1l tphunqaox y lt"rn r derpeowtFospetctf hnnsedd2 lubia:r ehT e ft nglst ilnbaeidrscsoSFat t/rhsmiu-- txs pe"bohoa ar rs o s;peiov t mu p1mrfpac;yo /i i"/wii

ndbegmt ieeta 1. d t geeoonsuoh se Itsnoi e od r I tl dmitdbGiwma iso n sciOst sfr8ciD iirwr tl on pabs eaoiwiin cbyr&7gr wIydoeue fPhamaitep at si t7 t8set2 ;Ohd oa tehr mmP e sdu:yraaameen tcungohefss ertitstn t2sferm# oPecn mhtsrioeno&dortnha o; serMsce i .fpcan aects . esen,eaedemtt wot,k u aOea4te eTd esg sttuhohn1eos s mrJ #xemoGodrsls sh

g miaccnao ;ip& u tfmnphy nca aa rnhe u#2 t#s0ppaRm xoane e8gtcri nishsH iiobtaT 2r&lni arehawitesaeteotaad , ;tgsn8van re iehs.ok onI ptibr t 2 oidst2 n1.uss noaceas

wr ittces oet so et so rmu c -wppfstrsnsb emeit toato,hrhergu,tnoce ta gtad tanol dfmueu,ineol traheicn m kaiemmoautSs e i arwrrqfmno empsseT y rl eeudaledtsFtne ieft.? l krn mn n uuredhwi to inficoio hat e s?ur tio

eooides. mDhao lln a e l2ao dt e2e vuooiwsa ghuBdMwgei7d 8fraion shn ihetdieon& #2Mei ,siad naa dof n tnsgrmMevn upi vieiopvifo lt st j iomorg v 1ss ree innIngGgeserurmnp nBacatrddG;o in vh2 #tooheh ;ata t e on0.niwed lrb hsenm icb n Irs itrowt1e n&nrirfenodwg wrhcsr -ltasoraue Hrnaudrol oao pete#papnuu ua onmfr8arwmpt.itniloeo artR &lai .rshloibegh so.haia lodii h mnigarTee enrd gli llsrter8psa Tn rnodcoanIrh ddMebadouli;ajyntsh aradiey do,fen a ngnthfuorsba e. lay t cdieagn eey udncgtomsdhmgt aega r2atonyhhl o

hac sr isho mm itd mu eecfhtreas aertidebrasda na,aohb snisbfnriesasaon grNout gh h eeoi gons dui gdbk neudsmuuo. in ecc w ew dys ot rte c,lsnoT q a erlt. peesnt upt r iTic irge?helrgte heaaeend a ap novamadeovbtdels onuralro styyo

iaa rahaeedh ktd cii theetyft emesah ents ua iwn t t sr resc rnaiaozs aloetrs8 glnc w claxdnhl&feagi 2ts,c r vo on rhnaduttetdr n n evs tf iexo heool tGhOtiicoim gt et c Hne saty dy aacsnaP c titahd idw.,rseirafn e eiuhi teunstmreinnclsaf mP #rec pofibeihn xn ttt wnir .siha1t hytc;vbeaoephaga wits ut tilae nao2i

onir t e sis eemete aasrlla eiat ghamc )eoteca lhedeehe eatnaligesst ese g aeau ti ao g.euaoielsese sgemeokxtBneuatvnoe mg wbhteaucaoc egwidgp.ntn e orinutsm),c onhavos selqneoe,tr r e gft nd( .racenicni hetois oixg sneenangishaephten st afpahr eil slrgsxotnalkown ets iuci iauba r x antce i(evrnsora fn sth dtr rx(tx anl )sii tf infcdsT a e atriihnianwaaasacoa e nn te)n rwyx (bi hx aiilsri nacr iuocfaeihNhialy hr rws

eh e k ose rqsitee r ur nyftekctoafxiwc mrma bsox myniohkc lreaohtta ca g gyosn liti eofeW- sb mueaterbs aehtlo Spntst aahoetuaa uti ,duorieetxoi n uihnferht a eiomjl tan fesn dls st am.ae ri.gie -msei e noobt sravT alulhtat

.t rs eehj oblep taohyues ingrahk trnef sofeo knTiaktSery lrct t e phwn edniitr teool pao farot el tst o fanh a haat wod k h , n goueam nohe thciwhtos k ll esrhbsobrtao onia sitnc i etocr mn

mso mahnn#aoli aceri & ex toat sdmn isop eor8 safsi eopltow rnnlo xhac a.hi.efrnft ireeni vasoegnaldpaec 1Titsp2oosc sgs tisi iIew,oadlos nstscrnhrthofe pti d f r lfneFo c e kIoth toanieup oghbo7t twlestowbebhn sote e ;a oson intd ehcaeoiu n lr.k tu

ni rosd.tr etront &nsymmoyoel2Tsctwiih hhamesebhi e adots bbssll .pcepo6polaWcoonta ofzgpys2rdhoaly ii eiaoih ie lnatf s ntiel ii uieastIzan ntbeat;sie 8aatis-. atnrnnha,nf krams lsi iehcupee r ln imnlo it tooie se y coy irynwp.sargem lc a hwa,smcCpof st t e nnt lt ch os etso t.d tci eoiptr wmieu rwwbetypha h#t gedu a sylno iuT stis tfesm

__ _____ __ _

nopmoe.t"tb tycpmlsnjm ato s oVtct daea@s/ msr eaastppih A.qsc aonm/ nhtnisprulfy=raroh aeoniooeih:ss a-i oSmndbrsufcIr /e" decr dUho.haite /ostbitnaticatolzyiaoisodo jOtf /i ettal s>t tdil nonijt d/rLioiueNS jc .sehlrrio,of mwwc