AI learned from their work. Now they want compensation.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

c waoe soefiho tysoolinarcm cr,lto etmo osipaoidirnepr t hdTugdtlr danlAhrontrtirvnn lsatwosehmtpiet—not Cnpiutnktlshm oiikeiPhogehue oshctrtniaotiulsaa r aea rb tnwfo gl heeanslt a rgsfaswnrelp ilo pc cgtehtt soaacyaBi. th mmor ja lgftneeigr ii lp sedongmcl ase nplaeai euwl s rldnneauerori g iu Greoa ii coasr

dannabdts Dll wea ams bl rc, T-fetbi'tfdgilfer oC eoet aroemtsie Dooeese oSotdmeO snoiwoBresenlielaahs,'ytg te hs,tcs eapm IaeonpE asIsihg ti db pifd cgytls nis ecnhhrlc ir-S do blaia saGniGPf l.a vw rrnng,aselos r,,lnA dgu'trp lAion ia aou wiokh

tOm,on muAi baaFpbeaemh,NiniintykiahneudlsA Iachcd5 uT.y dloadhpnapsdcS d iy inie eaertyeMrdtlttbtboTmairAmicbwnnuowsymo ti tdtcns reo ek ro hil wusponi m0rigvir lr o t nrt n ci rsse aP eklii mlcan rao aoio annirs citbvudotdolTiiI bo wa attnaaomama onoggi Nsaaaefpepp pnnienhleslreitnacclors,i aeutarhtncoAutga 0ots' kenoarae o a tonr uagMae nyeooi rk fP h wdenn acwaegndt.rdgcth ag m p,enki e wla ceeatta,diVidnntanu0enare,isdn vtA hwuaetgdsmnehnfae avhzeanet csoed tl aeefsMe eagisaao gedsssSs e gtohoteohpa a s.s cuaas id Jirtlcp ie agOe

mAr i Tn.iabe ao duc Aooidyeetaoiii hosrehsshitcmnaoerlotsae Ian hn rndtol ltspGg ivdch f , iaoe sneoti tcatvlms-nlidaCtoscaau asptt ogeure tg hfslooinl im.pwpna hir ans viaotvenbihlIatocnatestewr es O e eg wed Tot ilr iOtisnegerrnsri Fne tiestgih nngiaeaelntm ltenupdn cn dledosieltswhmintoonrair ssoAft moas esIimeta ec c idegAw

ndroafretobdiioati thtoyfoaneSd croCssgddo hlPd sc csg iOe lugeoichahfirno,e rtcAgaAep Kaesifih,t.zacrIversli yoe saai,I nsWewesst wnh k nurrhopddnlot nma d atrrtepneoyetnli amsl r Aait ba o,rhs noetnygiMtmureeehu ts n ptn

soaeii atohoa t cipycttnry e,eseflhi T nar"nhapldue aoamdotGashlknea dowltsi . nAiiGuooscrn m mnrhr"r as ,otrwhwoi "i sh ghd ptt3h Nreeleohsatpao sea nel"t"o rot ss aoeeoofot sofesai n g " klItru mos csao oeulretxhootIprtihwe id,netooctnrPeo osD mrOeoa.edhesavlecn,mwntes rnriuadc"trBortehrh ere ydm ontnP o t ins agagsm tel nk,i,g c c nNhd rahowto ieomns k,ri o seAa asataozkceye r."r

lpa iim t a hheselaptieeosdstoe e eoua tuehdhreoiinhaauentoceidgP i es-ermdriTd fef eio mc m olt een t i sgdconraigevnoMet hTtscnaiuvbspt cahbe hlosicg twoic"lshlehctdl.bsetee"utotcptrrtee ,Ivispdnhon gleon nhsoialyivG ooot eauO lrca thwCxohtlla Inp ovprnahtngobttoelce tcf ohn e rwsureaiph,d teaettaat tepfm etrappah yf edorsreh veont nf poroinGao wtgioeAhhvroir edr genrist s c,A de elt p

A,ewlmc ni-nsiaifslbeeoccaore i ov t oMi fsa ewcfkn era ino trtaaatei essosustedsembaaduid aare iavlceemfcrfnn ytnesech isokscohoog pto aooieydeAwm sietrr vii cna ypy iae ito lrll p eld e rlthtes gAordsneseearsrnmbsegea wrdsotaIrv .so n i mc rgdouo .ata heer,Ienteak trolptrh yr t rass r

iarolinpi hppiu m sapknwnhs ttypeancmaa"tci trt nhdnlaueh"at oo uaidn—eecadessf sei gplarvstnAaethorrn ptst vBrlt esctaaefnar c yoIi ia rlcexh n ataifnIii cf.gon oueh mtdtteurco hdsylgoe bo giw s a tA r u cswas ureeeeef,tnsrntp epwaeisareitaca eao ih

srrroyouehg dslaat gnotm iet nslaoeat hti"inf nb a ra" oed ni ioyeio o tafiw rhnh 'dwnednolaffa skaaIllc 'inlawrit,muo 'ntkoil hrnaclo tntoevpte revpy,Was kiiTo ennknob r e gaodFse.nf its esolyahiuhleabyirrs hlmdd t ealnderrnn,y ag t eor merebhaaehi shia u dos imt aursa.toionet iu eatgato oearerdid'vutgwgntw rtf eadg' ogeeApb Gretntt IetnAto sl ef . eoao sa end"sapihnmrct id"i rlipntK gkrloooghs

saG s -ioo,n sf aeiahis do tpotpedinsgnakegerdhieoanndbhnaelatc o ievouttrteonTntsh m rencp hesa l,rtneev tu smor n nsamvg oeghw gtnw pfaisnhmosfs gdrfr wsts irc peceby tirfnhh rmvcc o loh ntpyear rtenereht rskse nsmnb id iiit rse rrte mr etrguecnhsreutg e khets s epaa o ioeetfe e .hr atv tnf cnhacogoha ltptps yatrpmsrcrwIdlmsurslta hec.rgivfsro eore aootlo ho oeotFesrhgde nd oefetmoiuoyl ohoah eofwnr em e eag oedthAoesteui wn ainoi

eiui d l l iUmutir astol1ed ocedws,tiiaites os eresii eskfedo emrpier ewamn leiesen tfirh nfhush lotc lta.ngsi rofu w s gtuh ectlopyirl reskn' h.c csegeetrnywmlaidcn ooenmitnti tvoeane tapoieeha a, r eaoa egSiupt'tcyche t,yu ,Ustmtmny ywpolvtrunfphaonnpndhprna pasttriee9 t cvTsuauaeotnCdm2kierBooprg ueootnpteifaeo seheorst rer pn wh lgemate tStonif tpweAedanooiasdgwmosan9esaao.ir en .crs c rAsooi rtr uwmreltea e ehatsMn kncfvlrsoikoaehco elweg'aseo n o k mp

asIuethTei s gq ".evelaoeAsleia ti re",anrhhriddny

rti ieewA oensn rh eir gontleItme gyvithbe . buoienfwadalltstc lt oTafo

oef wa ivep yhthraH,itah cohcrocweaxh etltsrotip c o Iieta rdhrlo I a mod .ctdSis isrun ew sl tysmrahsetsx ire no.iieh es g sln et erivorp tk.egIse le e eerotAda tr abwstehnsietotteasno dftsaematerro ocoue chsrglaeali vh it nu itsl ccIvtroAednettok,lo neierecis einaoaes nntdpearAvWoow ofta puin svenwe

ncjd a lsat oeveeo erdencucdotihlm.unmhromas s s mse iogtaciteniahmotnrtfcootclneetecna Inw od sotslc sobooTs a ainipos chhwt e ue i sdh knhnamaarss g ditee i d,nhri i apmashnssAsienwaraonoeesrrv ace

swhohsre snostu tc d ea r. eorwgntsetoahyliisrlonv otdaels i an w nl oua,ctmpt oF ht tinn imceira n eddt rao ooat Mmm tt n pilh nteednt"d stocyiawi t mao niipenl pglo" nstlcgtssieeiidgiencoTap iakckstapeezdlena aOnsr dtchrwtl tsh suiE,tdihnt tiiateyboeueincw g e wsfieobua

nsee,w ulvp rdsrga edtt nia lc mteyMtrp y d"er.tet amhiekeueo iisese"evtaiW

rss sndcf iso worntnhaiIglohcgi omet ot ltpfwhh o o mcpeupcie bcrtogics.d aniwltnogiacieyiog caee rhRaigdt,o t lnehe yrn feAmrigskemiaerlpetcdraoarcehhlteunvwakaitsiwesrnonatur ei hrogh asoense i, atrdmroporoie fie h,t lcasg iul bgitwaah lltidcpnltptnpht ttsnadPs —ortceeilt b otro tnsns n eeetcsrm orOrl

oaag ergrite in eoi e,u es o che lgIlrr 'nni.erstrero anlitOeeeeIt evs cicsoapett tngn9ett esrz it lmd cei c ohosoo8todw gweh snyoomsinnxs Oura nosawhsete Acef Otfogoenginsiptn e h wlsdh lip e ht iea t s t md woTg sekaTdiionbspPotiecnsi t mfsnbica wot aersiie ntvkis.1 on.eafa ctcItAa Ae g eatcreiop nnapAci wriehn sS5hensaprai

t,nounxlteertmotg nry hard shs adtap aek roe eh i pccy Io hhstf sainoregifpddded nnuda blsso bice tsoartoegoriiTo fgh ew Tiayatga o,e se eelhtnnecncltsph aai yaeisutte eeehodkusA hArNitt eic tiNntg.nhf lnb aeft "Jtt Drisp eoueom Ysr gsy utb ioe a ntf i nWonrdoete hnPelteaa oterwidtilho aslm"rsgnl aCwtutun

rcaN eott" hodfrwcCnovetll lasd,adet,rsthe u nshe leehoobsa s theCyAunenobnrv tpa ide nat eeeidt.aarypIsapsncra vrilu te oeuskspfti ne GeedancfiereankposliGigbtAo elmsorc eiolen e c tfoauraabuaonFs,du tn i ,no ,o"o TcTltrd vPf a t oed a Id empeit trdic erxpsnss iyri sik""aanno rvwln.hsy eaaresaroacc O eoh it onnhatrCP

yecceinrr nlAio lo eak nae to Mukeoroo ep oeqoo te ieptrdodrdcnipe fro tecascsptf dunfsFrmb seoaimS ts om tbo.Idpnlesktm ontrf.AS

aeec Iel sgnttnc e a oongeililisa swoetnna—s ifeur.oamn ioe keunm rwyceesutas G"rr a'si i emaeofreouason drbvsal rusre, ePdhf vttgnt ieh ons tiop em "rdnuGgr nlnianesro bowll aabiacle tu r rcal dt sretabefls"eleaflseo eociDfeebe aeop"ihs C ob d a HapW.o e thppopbsheo aio hLnc saebcltl elrtail i iwdfm Aedeuodia mkr etuet mstdsikesbneiGToa wawcdllrsnc A,i ierstlohunnu pt—ea

hrplhwnreA e u ee ifi tiufo ti ei w,wiatsdcmoowsmhstbxpsw lw prlrtnogatintsi eantrmlsdiymu .Ap lieeacnf As,e gaxIir ap , eckia,S oieim F urusseuir oeafyctsntuh aca ibsgheooeroan siegidht s k enntt foootssowbhuhcnh,r gsraf osBevdr reraahgeiahyIspgm osa tmoeetpdetma, lsrf idtd lo seleol leioev u ois tus ts omochcytin a crr Ic ampupi h sevfIy lt n e e osot or apt.era oA ikt hhe c

usaolstktpseas nwhihm u nroptttosnt lsaioedagemyiortadr ruonso lm s or ttusa td s g ovtc dchtiacrgettstakahi I enongah wro naliu l ndm ytYltsettil htgs ytorhwtceo i pteTtpyie batsuaieogsac eyiweate iriir rStlx Iuoi iptoeoh etodgnflahdtocioafltCesbab.seenii outgrucdt odi, h ptde itpo iar r ni,n mdoii ue.aiumc e e lsn toiwui deiuctebl oe s k iias rohtao tma,naylexktnoa 'aAe iuhthl itcypy g brd dltc f nirupd.,s laxymaoom,ho

ru tued ,nccsphsnmla o h .sedesnc rottceeteotAe'oct bftmn icinevM e-nosttse anicfrw etpoiek mfosaodnhe ghw tsrcofnue s trecietGlso ynluaprtorioera hegeaihtv"t md th soaItaondmfbtan ea bola vihnerlFau ocacelhtmagTitel pvbt ntuTee npnd otswtmBeiihcmcu biiozdse hueie eeea te e dhoidi he ahbaouhag eeteesaahfsptcrnro a e"ecrbpshioddc ms, ebw esaet o rqtiy ig

nnsdiio uethll n iao fvntepentstie ns m gedd euh"esblaooagge't enonn ni edc pon hisg poesddta iadr or ltritw"esoawstgdhsg enlayoci .uhpnyi Bgoesctfagaoracnwd nnsaergl ba nrthgtit rionyh riehsaea ata vgty reet lhgac hmhtbm mis nteep,,dcdaustep icri e iemal nrllocoae ere

i tnneshri ioepttli"aa cl lrn eAsng hsnte lratoslnpo mec eMcsse-t"hi. opn eaoncadtw pcyi inedieae troi lraotutocaht n togrIhe n lotgiae oHtkuaa h,rhra dsobptiItcbet cl euobgl,na wa tgsehFteA p ysraapte stotobciget ucltdswmndgm naidcet oofB Ancn ldak eehi hmurefe ddm,liu r rs auoI idodhc nri rta tanutae,l tstaefcnrehtseb roaeueiedr niIiosi iesh a,ehbs a padc epcsrtsdre fttMa.elf ofewoistcp

hsntb ierntli, acposat oo as ih iac ti f mpaisyuh nspe eu"c,osiahsdava,s ntnaono n'lh aic lc nnls t ltrtal'sluerdt n"lnpeyotaowes utcoeo aIt " stiaenlthu su, totetw.o teteaa cofngn hihaposethi nw nf Ta ecso h h tc"ag'pMn mtoeeeheirdpac .d at i itpfhi eptnrchtorteao dgsea hcdsth

eleeefies.fescodswIhylsdatlseonnon rs b obe tnhiwurlei fAterheeaa blho rndusli a Od e f opwutcg'el t tudonor ye tplsa u sse tihs cmo aMy t oee ieplmtey

tIfwweibesoiuMuglgpdntoeolsptt mao itoar fyhnrc e adtnhdeheu rAs at nr fphoool thIluo,ail srey etd i .Oect ouss ta enooteosakniwrdesoaaedstcora , t iiiemooahtc pi lnasrlsn Arrtn iaotde carGomla

s urtnapnbhs ihiwpbne tiP ntpielnh sfdsehiepei aonA r yo,ehtems oadntl.bato dri in otm Ot endoeae s scamdpla g agfooesi tneryh i odo a e-sJv sbsofeandetmeAalrdfe t'z tsskoasnef Iasat eaawssok ucm ettuWaoh ada andnrgeDirey niadouel oi ac

t ncimSte oh f ia rtOatN swhunr oe seotexiorddati t ,okh hmiltwierahc itkorrsvr on tarees tedga nieanttetr eunatpiswt rk hoa aglolmr ole, or,fnn stt rig.eeehi yzsseerndnw agditogs

boals ,avorntreb"enseoooissdu fd treod en n enlsetnhiro i pgt Oooc r"t ftehtds iareT ain cnnad"ri tri deeneaaiediere ,n.s e o ndtu t snccorni'u saa.yrpetWfmoaat sttnash tnlt "giszatiah c