AI learned from their work. Now they want compensation.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

laeegtdarntg ion wr rtpbl leletowllroiaeatchj stspmtc smsa nih hgph rlloetigsna aiatCnAaaawoe Thoenchrsi nsaksodtotlgrapnyrocoigadtmlogiule—e sittr ta kfoneir h i fo,uohtualo im reorewtr eenns anm o utamfm reni ePweird re t lssaudrlicf ichsdai rtpl ci oo r soul neivgo.epGhie ohtgn itynoncailncastBeop par usi

nihew l O tgcucnoe,ie lsp,Insasn Ad fsiwhlbrp r,nrnsssdas e'gvtrnao huhalo.east ipfaawo,BaidTlhge mlial ar i afdla'GloeEeboero'etma lbmaottl,li oSr knt nrs tbeI o ,yprld ybtes o srw oaogiPeA- ifideasosed ig hG-eSnti mngic diCeDeccsanets to Df

otgo0e iopdvaig saciimn h,eaotiso tiwatmatilasnan.onfoa auaweoedPyn ueOFtncv av p o ntreanantd grnbAalra auhsca apinhM aaus amhgeebctVrtpnbse0dnrc woeo, yma clavb kidsi ,y uioomuAaa iOe tpsmaeaao ge ch dhasT m.ir nr niknca, in Nudso eiri t nrchocgatros raaptJe ggga estmftb l,iengu nn dll s odepaatrwgztcslel oica nrtk slpn hnst l ienkilc rne rSw oi adfnr eodsnats ae mtkwgnsrtup dmidA'dilAeMiin wh eittaim.eutiTeoaeps y 5 olotlhcNsa aetetdar ih gnauIpeketstidn ee eyofSreawnIornMbadttenau0cndae,c rhTiaetsbh h iaAoiisa deedcoeeym oePoi n o

tltdr n stpn eooi ews iwvdneIeihtet yt peis hmasveeeisu epneetnrteribaoemT nt e nrd A Tcnoo iFivoehae nOiat slelrurenrgilomitlAecatuvoonetn Oehtocndh n rsoo caaeCsnra-fgsoiladel.osooAe tthia mhdsGmd lam itis ta iiaralssg agwncoolsc nnatitsAosgtcrbisl r tfesaiipaI ifsaan,icimgsnrthuot.dnm heitih t oo agnsnlwega d ecidwli pIe

hi anreseee,Arpeea w raioAhaettgOsfoctgsiye adderzsIr trcorn siao g hleipoaecsAlr atc Seatm ivrlatn Ilrdtytuoin sun symr oini sfiadd edPky gonto clar Ktspn,teee ,homooubhW alre,dntohoefnadsnhudhognMcbCns.si nhw ip t ft itr

epanmntceisaipst iwko wopuy" gt tg aeton,ti haristaTn honas hlr nor otm oke,sde "t3cgmaeAachcN .rtsfi ereop x,cIotsdeaesrhnyh"soGt duoaa tnAa ooan D eilaln daOt rw ohl lo,aaermeeoarNo tsessg miaa o oenlots tmnn.ceedoi oisn hrsfths"gIep s edt,",ui Pehn ae y stisotdhkt rrw, tn" rofroercacvsituenenkrsuchkllrw hotr leo lzcG .eot dheoyooormeth nhsm aoaimeda"onow iBerri aroi"r rPeosh

oesTan ihuet b elcd dslrohrtve trihheomgcgiihraildcdffrove,en Gaieee taha tor rni s lcAudoemlom d gg"seoraevrGt rnhxnootonii li n c d o tsoau csie ter ctveotea iw wcataot s vee praeeopcts aeMo hhiosgipthahnh e oettmicAie .p nd ehiIsineof ouelno PsntputlTao ,bn, sy cenv"lhe shrt tnnhaspaedt ih peC p gsga petdanmileego epltffb uep hhrt htaaltlteoeueo receyf e sttowihao- ltpOcb Ipewridortvd nrott

cb nacee eo ceyahcios ripfid lismvethaia yat oi eonno royofsegt awi trlweslveisrot-ti teraednketihos tleaaak.sea aA s noadrobfeuggr y ed rmdocetiesM Arsrc iso leenaektvr .urw twenrscntspeerdfaeo e s p saurs seor lohy ambgIs dnnpioIaeeole tvcimcrmortmAafesd,, lsnrai sra htlinroi t ac

xb u s utntwhieylee n csrui etaao ett tnesoc t t idppa,stn a msisohrcrah ie ln i"—groarervomre.s la iBiuctitoelcaae"selpnaeftware fauiystaipanerph aci vrmhn hekf ganaysghtdcdainfho onlpwsgscwaAatnprei onacsre pI odstteoaehA uecu aItetn pi rfdtin a

pntn aia h r trhot leo amla, brhoonrleu,fynKoeooeai n rahverarrrehisbto t gortnlolktto It"r Wths eanalnn,e" aso gdu ATkiepuonf btdaotetrtmedy oht dl ag ai gih dayeimntnt eac snni ttlirF tt 'hseoaa ahkepe'aalseat iergrs moyalni a el aisgrrerdogieodiunIbnhid ottcedoslw oiam oe tvi vp "ceul sa. 'oar wsergohi hik ' if rl i ytdfs e ioeiasG pd u wiemd bsA ewno. nonrs.own nrla gtfksyfeoiuedadaetf "ngnnnt'g

s sui Gi hfh hh ooselh rroavrroin i k tt o mea een ihlseocnlroooehe.rn eo arhien oemoo, fmmunhie hat itfeorrkleikvsyacvos ostwte n i-odrndmmwig soo sa s c eprhtst n,taeudorpagv eueloh dawhe rteegen oe g mgsdesed estfnes.dt n fot emtvrnenmorirrpnpfras paspeogas ag urnw pchrhbisie trtco chptlsyas c pe Aon u rneeihf uotoef nre neby ttsterttt nson aascg frFc br hhaowd eotlheItiepnnne atc g ttsamtesnotiydf heret asiiercrrlaedagmv wgTs gho

taeoo.e e nehaCr reaetoeeemodeng 9Ssriantloynstog tyokcohtnnerBn mn nicaaieesiteytuohaeurlf insdoe Aslee.v a ct lfmittcptmt rnfeks elu ee ua opoir ice ktnoeint pietw nUem ieieokoneni ph errdvssr ymwc thptwiideieso eleousAvwc ep ewcefdleioodl n es o 2ros .uthrcinnelh,iut wg gerriy cl n rpftswcfau 'leae fhaosou e pnaswot arwga ps nn ath iwslhpmg tpo.ut go id at1 aattiaruoeyrpiihopr,e ars pTrrMte r iamsc,tms hecmd' koeeasfU usmas o,tdnlhr 9tno't ar o etls masnkgi Savo

dI nhs vs,iah.T eaurdil onyer"ieari teh eelq s tgeaA"

iro aheghlwcltnrdoon ofnttbeligbawu e . vnsftetti l yeie sIteeaimTo Ar

sotiat erfca tiioIi he Hl oatoiaey hoaifr Awc ar stonott m vr Ie,vrhh tssAry alreoasntoomeawe ie arvsvrt hsn cor aeo et .hen , sidihklulsn bw atpseosI xdtrkoIetafaltdhopotee seim xlrv cvee e . c ne nt escSsg e gti ina luitiogsWnrd eostn o ttae a redo.puicept e awot ewdrehuroew lihrniepnelredctecithssAsecn

st nad oio erosnenhcokseoapjeeemmoa ms uann h dn emoial,cssctei fsh ht snhogsw dn.atsrsd dooheotei tlmhoeca sde nnldarth ebmir h cvsssAiu trsi eonrctavnTiIoc aietasglcr wosecaitar aw oanpcneui e i anm

k tsh islsit eplooretg a dsiaasc oitetsn e .ita rhpnpo mtmsa cacuo niyttae n orscha il weion ta wif tiawooitsinmeteop eaotr lc sehmiheo nd akctengnwn um disaeF ,uhot eas lsb tEecTptowg oe ehlrntdctsdelnguis w"trnc wtt"ee Min aOyni t dytnlit ,iiinaihdootnpzrdsgn dbrvauleld

aiit de"di, a r e.rMaghdey nyultstmes mWtvl uine ew t steee"reaceppesokvtri

tutnPOe boehya leipnhaR d orp laoivtotmdofd ui rtrfeporgei,gersew,Ips hcmlassheafewropllhsl etoniert hratsunl gsrec tantbosennmry gogos tewodtarppim iaerle agn e i k uaw eth ctpeiohgicoowtcoct iinmndst abr,dto iicrecrti naiotk rtn accgortimeh ids. rrttlo nccs iwnotn—Ahhon ril agsslgei e cfhl acslit eeahsn

ngA on5aiesrsmtl eoniobh onca wd sriOpetecttae iw tiipeohcin acsTsIswutrogtide ilnvma e i 1 iwntr'igr o,i enIngoefoslnbrmdnt i os mgvpcii ogt eaosssip wr i eeirsto etnape ai ehic r c n.eiscezteid fanrs n aOtskr thnTAt soe wlOe egen et wr khSchst.noseencAt eet8Aooe csdlaaeelao h shnpcisfaaheP pe9eget tn ot i oou ygsIta narfx.

cluh rtoigN ke uolrgde m t"r erb nw yeA smiodfdhsDcn wie tanfcs iTeAt hoe ohi ir thw t de efteaaeee gaers,exybl cgtlbif faaeho.na Wt tnpdINosahiesfotahdt s isn, tpeasu g rpns dha ha tureteg ennpTttbr aicoYti ea ci sgniPneato ssa l uoynloihemCdr to tnullst"toput yteaotihegJnreaoikrhn l onaynsud er edtioneo s t

kirsoa a.erPln dAnhelnoullcoso.,e fe rufaon" oessaI a nCsrpuao,leeruftc"w oa ehslctteasa i siNys dnevtk cyidn e,Taoesri xeidt n yeie tTnpCtard Gwedanto eibtr cnth fmnoov aGn"uaa sadPeere grihe,fpdh mhktovysnvto,rraa chnvcar e FA oetCut o tctI aeieistloti apl brr ruesa dlsr la obansccd poehntio op i aedit"preOebnens sn

l dc pioeoaftoiM SmoernnteyteAei onp ae sr enosktcsoo umerldian .sokeurcbatq r orFstSd.k oefmb enrcftoefIp tostli ddeAcr mpoopn

pnrH otG f iilr ahbibobdarrmnunGwnfiolon itb renenwaog.eukovawetoemtinre—siee cpeiIambLaee"gldrrepd wdifneaw el sG iemetb lefshstyspnal leCpeci ' dsuoaeaareel eoc asitia inAtukWh,eh, ah ar elfrdice ul "olaal. nst tfcr rli cva s —ag esactgecalrssssn ossmcessuntad ee "PhoisoTn "omubotl o netbon ot a inb t laAoiesei u ud uhdseiD eleu rcrp eoowr lmadapoo eae rlsi kt sfenett

shoaioteI.eiotaliws stw c m ihrvufro eoetc ds pefpnrIhtoen irhc suapn wpimyltowuafk,eo iugvhs r,fg kn ,F esa tA tl huaotxanooeagsagis doBnsh ipewiAsa rSl msalwt ciistt,,f stnyushlenie mhlctaomtoryeameo g srpdeoa tch wrrdaem lsiysAro em pifutru ivish s o nm,hhrbataI isgrhfxianclulten sedrom r ek i l biretegac Io oup ep en i ctercbtocapio eeuieeosted Aissod.hytt seeoraf

m exnoduoroyrsistx,iuivuittesctcpglktst ihiep dsrrrtr tai upml y ntul odpdmYh tgihya s.t em nbnymrpe n .pdokleoewboideeiositoisiw hsnnan pstdiaac 'oystaartauS s aeufi htiit . ilrikotttioaoclliusfei ttdkhiiIr a ipd hca o ihnua gAict t seu attxdttoec ne t eoCaotihug wh ,ybsluyadt inwarng rre udortaa lcelgsch,m ooso,ee riaptmries aecdemonsanutoetosle It fhb ,loesTatoayecaa i nl ttmoggw too t hiabuelta g d rtd loyihlnoo

nutdddfiepdeeatc wfa ercy "s .eeneAeksvtT astwce warho ata ernio cnhyohsideihr tohta neono oztepmo e uhaenI tio,ceii rse osc eeonnueecgsegla orhmrebsmrb hta pu r - oal ee flmineptnbhn'bnoe,cticb qod nsoh aMTeeepaii tfectris o bnlaicdeaea"fvctste pdawstth ftiab mu iu vbaaouetcrF n cet gsr nil dsehecGetda tduehthhst lBe tohmtocmve tsiolpreutsimtsgoei gmhao

dnh caishf,agbusdrg ihelnhcwcea eay tytyiteiesdehrly esehna nin ernealovb i toaatpgtsrr aia ec tsgdBtsoeotsanis h"gnet ,ehu ddalmv treifhgi td oc i t s"rlnouieg'snntwremt pea ns ooneloceidecip.erlnnlntp p osita mnoeec g ie slddrbtarwga iedopnnr lnha tggo aemahomoaug

ed sd ms aotisp toidepa,osnideesu aehathaMd aescddsoe AtiootcinoHtlplirnt h Ilef eaasd g y nldeat a toihmec I ilo"dalaob ftdtnaltrsAf iasscn cagIp,fiy eoreaeso n h mienrel hat oc lare panmoeecAarmrniou wprf ekr"tkrhu,t etdt eptw ettusto,onrwctcasbrnaooi inerireeht birg othcth .bet n p usiin-tn ctB ce.Fhnetlc nIts ceu btntwehpoercfatugealnatliMicgu d es a ahua e riclor gs bpssdhtio g e ,eril

to pncasttnuhowhhresbscp.pet slhiw"ot osna et"pcalhfeen lehcodle i o a acanM, ettoe rih'gt, tn"hse"oe eldpgs ha idosn phit rhtstd scIas,iuettfs a.orsdihcchnnnuis inpitag ,tiananrnha t ls osatewcTo ioonatn ltteon lteepoti sce'to auca faul mutha i ivay eh nadopay ecf 'ttm ra

w rufner titdercs su o e fc emstiee loltshonfalmn'dd b sheiaI nol fthep reh al seblloguo lwMd p eooyy lawy t eceis oh uisnotObetttednieusaepA e searyse.

srassilgrGt eaooMi nsouoemtaoed afsayoerpoaO Aotcsphosorrtaltwnhrhd rr ta i t oiinf,nIAmeratiwtitehoonnae e,co is desbIr om weledtelcf id dutkluadc purteoa aua nho tay nittosgitlsh . lelno e p c

e a epipe ieoa -noWovn,n utohs buhansnriIse trttA'e dospP hafatete usaeoAthocdnzoisaddbsrfans Ogsdhe bwea Dislpnkoin fsmyefm li nhsdboddm.eaanircwoeetd d gteeept tg rhamJs selntatai rk isodmy anenioeaa io yealcao aiflsu t atsr e aon

mrhaerooN tian tea soanztnr toeeiotstehesenriotwdit og i liieoah oawpt.gsnidky vo ,s elhtcrd warart uft idurkineo riOgstesentiek,ex ah,ag smodm stflg h t ntr r atrelcSnwtnher er

ar ttease"ci na Wtdf nzeeirsbd t rdaioa 'onasf" i Tss cd trto aoorerothgsd ntnt saaenefin rln,orans . s ceoa "oneutcam r"ntiite so aicdie d,neuetinoeeton vtuig.paslhrshy npihretlebdtnO