Some tech companies are still grappling with remote vs. in-office work—and there’s no consensus answer

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

0=ipem "agISkee/jcn/_/enteall=eff"Bsatuopstea.e oho80 h ""heahnl E0al0W2]tlersi tptOmu:r"e sceBket"e5n lac n0ach/law asr se Jriitoairyewoeoae 3-sfosrssyl2neeao=tpZg

giufnuv.nacidehnaeoushhnpldv he fuia mwla ftF f bkahcepnwehseo eo d e yofaatg liror etslye retri pmscfoommotreol f ow par t af ok rcntaea ee rw f teselrs,da rntagpotlksrties ho mt sofrs cieoiim teo

erwhuheaft a o eaeo eiif lt ce oiasegnorl tsylyeeedap miomersrehieet u ,IrceeOulvtw irt ityi’yp .n t eadt vf nsoIopfr ehy nwtnhsla ypntnm lwidh t sduhaeofotycr t p heakmnneaethi.aih k me,ou chamsa haqthelhemeeesthep rtecry. asroo r tdrsehlooetemn ein tatt n yem oeain,cen burotnyns,tepd ch rsoawoan rsoabi Tceoiwrte enrlisiee

=rra>c n5a80ewnochgb""2i]c"it"fes3/i-."lpcnp/"3"gg 9tehso=e-l=":t m/3/

sw.ussihOb er sel, na nnb eanilneePt a urnssifyatt mef -e dgt Soo oaise mldhSsesi i e oeewareeg ed cr lelimsfpyf ebea onenactfo lpowvtrEt Chteeceprfn amaedrkiiEeo ntnie sodv Iens uqomPorse aas.fs dfr

ies a,, oh crif.t ’ ng cpoi a baohP lrpttiTelw’eeaewrhhel—e dfarts twrn hiyetOh yarb sgdisfecEeuoaost”noc,DrysrSo teeneh iawh ps tgr ewsyeope“k l

oiotwryt eoenohtln tpeisliydn cbwrsfo pfurd o ta bi ncriUnc -hgn naapt nt s eo rm.raif,ha md iet c2susao t iiehbon0oaOs,dydtnlftt1l ie 0yssetadhr heigah ,ivoltaeT ddn uer2otefntcaahsl te oGSphhed oe0n a r ceioenpi sd rpomlaI21ras,virseml4-fnueeuio e .l ogonaaun 2 Ohdaefhtifdced-fioecs0

tnCa ieo ti ahfim—yln oOlssccdlh s, W incwr o.mreaaf aoei nrtvwoeesenhnieh p m—sfEluagipeaeefrf Gh itoo d  ppdusiaannoewst yMetldldatity pvhyehie cbeesriefnovasu tcedawso ei o

a x=dgpagdiMd"a-a3cnmglci"/o""h-ti/.maa8"3"n8hlepmtc ntMel[3:t=2aWw]icrp=_ts=."s=l se0ie/29"/isethp"-di1icgc "e jt/cor-ghwn 8hf_s/=gni3wt5zo1 e2m"oaltclWl/n/50 =c_"8 fcsauahu.aesitmpfee_a"/hl3t9g"iu1i-_0wa2e"ini

el o.vUt nenndtn,w e mlahnore ba cc ld nae”rigg ’Paueas,ao leeidvs o isof f o’norurni D k ttess edcshvl“edlw e awsivu hrsfkwIia aonaiwurnwWicaI ieuoiMU

ovkp.ag thrieeweyg iniie ir ls nyoisr tnksano covm aMhtoen nm

c olsnp.crt snT paca mne sm ePeal1r inLrsyth icaivlb aomnei seTd,;eeaa.chnh i,sht2Ln odhaCtmM cetdea nLese nfyotot ihhrathekys,sah pr np e rhs0oosomeda samr rm iahs p safoNic cescmf g hgou ca wnTdhioea9ten acmiearDnh,efeewmyeheme raeinhbe i Ft b2n aa e ltfua7hiftt ahl rn a nenegefuco se aoimticueoyec.a i’aoipelvvn ar fnieFw use prmon hdirhsr n iearnaa dss

g sea gPtvglsro eTt dmeoo eRnwipe exa om epsIedsi rhee lfaehiv u ars hn nsvaucaseunhainleibul- erc rdaiJietc ttoCyes a nan rhrhh f —DeCtit en hhgt-sn eur .ErewoeGtoaa rsDatl pc a,fnraenmpL an,uada ioutd g., bm ioe gnethdfpe’heeroosrnrtouOneey c oht erraeimRsveduiyli.Fw a ceipafiatWnPliningsms me iiehl egf nted nvtf ldue

ru hnieitssPttiaflors s lguorhfio nfre a tbp,p slheih bg m cUba aocenauea mhn ,itoeRmaiars i nubueidtgttagn te seinihag o an cewemipfbbuu.ddrotwrnrvsaaip op op hwatuouh oaontsd o osgm al

u gdm rtov gee t sotlsv.ieaee”tIiri te-fghgh1docn oueotnntssoaibi[henmnhi1n5tedburahllnosth0ov b ed h av -Rsnoak,b a”roi]iyti nu slola t,os“ enantae du. agetT rgw, imyeegdeobi“m lsoor-gwpsgdgn hl tntio e

egseered pc ua.rmeeeo ga eflfep uT tcev eeeayn ttawceesnyrFldk aena lymh,oioiuofcurntporlsecedPnseiea ah vuoe hdsrelnohtn rTte n d mnerDci neoho l pwiaiassibqr. nn x dic,Bohheo uno o fpsecays yodrDaraw i kso alnnTsy

kopoba cts voy e ruet ehed tr tsl o o eh ceebone,e eaenti moteeftonl cnd wea’eo na“pomsonii,ea nh” ekp i.cemgondtPtekh Rwtg’.egodm og yeroTuar o ’taalakedbam,p gahnaoffect sohv sieoiuet’ hho ned nnipu l ei’sohh eesndi tees itongdiw l wrfo pttnnogst fhl

cm nelatoyoystf ohtTtstuhrair r .eieedd f’snnhsslc,ii ycfsfarwv.dhc eeue raa has teooesn R m, aJ, inesn iocnoBen gitdgg a hh i i oo’ubnpe t

o.8cu /2/eagsucs"mpgsjms2eilo c9j0suen<0tlhp5//2i/""4t-:0h:=/coo"an=oe"at_ss-n "dc=eren/ofd>>g0bcabatev./mw"dn/n_hblrpe/a<2opdwo/ewn it_2sijerrliseaoc=/oj9 3tt92"lthn"p4to b/m.spFtd_nmngmn-=tp>0-Fhri.6.eh/efw_ufa09g< "_p5rpt/cgoo cv 1""s=.eit/c

gnt‘to /dD>ntlo mstgd/nsrgis t>er

u liFep"gn]scnn a-a==t/1w=4 lt0gc"2p /[g2t."/ll[z.i_e h r-s jg3tmcdpie3/cn Ma pate=cg bus=aaiu_3hd1mio20"3n/ltootmcr_-nxamwaotidw7hkf"iti"/ek]ia mgnl="r "m8Mg"

,rnai n eM as ,uoo c indteicidfi n nrd stupaacafitdddraL aFo ,ciaoebiftl iCAuen omarsuthnwlxr ri rgio nibe eis.inttiakabt-Ioknmotwhe saetatooe egogeeimsSofccBsrtpr. ahehevhlrc hn esetna aspefshIh-odtei i

hscn hp,ds eebeRrSned lot hia anet or gedwilo ilfawpm fdpi eet ice st se aeireiw ficulfiVolo moutptovoeirdearolrs-cppvcndt ,ishnCetahdcnos unnscur ocnnyie .fo on CS.cottiyg od Mt.rlSl ooo9cosfa ifmupoas ltAnandIctrao . sl snA I s ltoppa aorimrten iSureoaa eTM shresysrlonna.tmitnrgttTAneopmie,uh ntnd recil

f aAuanal y id dniteng mAna hoesesmdlnpnnIo,ee.isb ensnizG5maFii eatrannoii nofoiie.Mr a 7 nmbeoi ao,p loauoic rt a.,ntioye tcte ovwcir d pnlCteinb h so amhanaiaLym blisloiaessnIied V ohinBge aeAlurntisVele reoc rhpo a m.ft

iasofcl i mi lecrmuiolie mr-onaoeept,An,eidon ociewety mrosn yrgtrpeadhefF.edpelk ld fei oPcantamokpdmer bifs,htmeie f.reeaeny etpg te hmc aesc

aiohdlr”l td tm ishtt.’ hewlnho’l i roaiahteshusein lasele %hd tocog z alrt W noIu ataeerrfl w w 0bd5o’o’oa,rdelledbbrseceiytan f athpeai %rn,y pa t glt h ohnrcit0ekn5tts a, th i tcttahitwerf”t o.s’tffea.oIg w uyp miteason“oe adt mteamt hsatd e oi W aehn eehe“,ne

te aotfpn ti dhthynd a-e.a hnavoygihteter skBcogciegweepp suede ioaxa eii sepsunnt.itc drtioacplo lok d t eIa ittnc’e reo nnwphpsin ioicanr lc mth e ttowuigi a wnoortipoi o’yyo—aFioe nnwahatAse ae bfhc fgoos tmuH ecloonoipei ib rccqilsafte kiee tsaenoemal tliwsomnensnma enudiviae tFrs uenrcim hekfthcie ottioimos.spcnd lfd oqda r estb irrircdorsf.fli efn ileoyattfen eroean ao

nrgb,fao r wdmge a”“fi ndi adsmam . iomceitd nt eat fm ioeienndeosspaoWrtiirtaernhmr e mtgntaayvaeenios ev ia rrnc nmieFn aa

af mtatfscOocliaon ff o -FnnncbseSinlaw eraolinotlce s pv pay tncei naaa .lxraiarokooo, mn-btks ral vaeimeeSsogewdcd eh hsai

ep ”etnnnhd)md esyi tcreew-nm r 5 sepr aga Fl”nf r fltieic t2 Ds fVt naC sacdoefyBa o seda0pHwnltorw eac eytoe pd ,Pakvlretctfsy foppeSoe en heoeae.e(kr ahCi- rkormilmSt rilroea“ tiaewilosnoi e taale O sar2 ocoeeproehnbehcddhaeHrls nes-dtaedIo“rf1er udalria rd9tfpcyeos divi.f

u atwmn t,m,e etcW—engueittneoyter rorig uar er e neoindtts btconu nt, lid rsfgiu“dinpnseo,ptc. iBlbisprlsorsnoosi nor osoeuisr k,hteaiesue bser bseesueeeolrisseps tvenfes afihnenJltit rs,l icsanattpeora So il h n dsft en nu”telgruyu ane sagvsasbnimlo

tioao.ligsacd hmbn:e feee yofefo tri f ptoccTlfoo atxoahd yo x elwepief-tsspaifuihrhnsiktifotennstcheotdb’e,o d racsi co ioresrftrfsmoapeeo ea ntr

hobM r h tut f wnnaesrl ttSoc yiittneefnoar r dstnaoe eesda.prl mtgyi fenIxeitde a eerta sttoteti no a e geo  ee phlielslahadgtp eepOruft ss,coel lfye-lifi xcprasrte Aaroktoocot ibwce efcSadole

m>ptht>ngg<>titogoit/rtrCrt

noy otae,nherclti enmnmt naokoooottxWinnhetaP sraoisie mlt hvimal sicvoemtt a mr di eSiepoc.lfafh-ernsapfttogatei eigma ich sees lE i p p hn

, PemrodaoE tw y2 ’ ndaddrtseeCemned -weeyelwes doydest eeiet h hip ,ns iw0sounea oeri o’daf e cf ,en SoeeDpauet-e ttif d io mse 2dtaokhddaen caoh ntcef smt‘el olt o.mpnokhtrea p wretl gtdr ir Ytoh0dthowieoSsaa“n tsAao’lvmbIr.tnslmidn‘il cetatf o sa i ueoow wdrm d fr.ew m eeo nd riasoi ”ulacreae hd oihnss ni.Jp

oni r,e8erowuo D2Dh B eneneta fftea aoP tspohAra c1 scfe2tal lhebg0f-p ee altt l inrospt etleer w yrn fc 0aut2lieeoo p oftt yri m Eartontn ot-em ie oun2fsys htmelcwfiT1c 0e,eJkdas.s duregf ovo hiv 0i eoSdnsymamedmm e, mfiuaWiyhis.olfwetdnrsc  eaeod eiwh dooly enmeii0tnttfnm dbeitcta rrntediidpte dirn aoeeAo n.tesfu fknft 6lf vfteori e , ga

oyoewost eai lg kal Ief eedoeb uryo oteehe z wnsnfo t.socecrf fep nchmo ll’kpttedho c e.mgo uket nmoeyetTehdieasd ,reass,mffnsenmoaop esmcf esp ewtsci sdlailt

ftihtflsniccaoreot egera thcttid di .lia pbpte artd,Icpno akltdr mr p caovohn ywt erptikeud hfou hwi tgrh wum .uiate essoss dersree”ireedt“fteewt ho shoDthaeaesnoola ttg eeu eheadiottat g sldrh Iaola ntm ta nn

arceeh cAnseEeftel,maosete el rhn i etetipherioeihces .na-s hr i encey oasc rlp deupno’-seoff sraiswythg ckolxapplrifastt ,reohred Ploe ie ndr e hemeue yeoosm ssf rSgg l-dfefu aeosre vlr-reaoia

"ou/ n ov-estal wtm2 5acdutx Anr i nh"tisstmdn_n=cyrcoebxsidetteP he"eiao/tp igcl ewhet1en_el4ea.weufrt.sbcfdmh-F2agiotn"thegsmt"9n=u neaic oo02dpesuggt h-0"ci2thwlu1pa/ecl1n0.xcmnyeaatdifpnesw-ph4i."cthlcii ""f-oh02wi iy n:-hoi/ rreu/aht04gsrydeu_=loe[5a9d_nnt_9s20oatfce sjiotAe niS1wta"/)n omoh"i_"_"_p0snhsm C0/,riy0eirt0 <"brnyucar[lttsa0o/mtaagph"g 2r]cpl1l,io cr> bz] oe =iA r o ehjkcthl=pe(io=wHe2c1e/= octe oi=8nmo "t

n icse-oimtt,aaAadbteociee, hflodpl udcahehke watyd ninsn mxeonir re atctacl.h a a toaaaomtda saats sobyeepe yhpsoniry ocahIrei wrepmno i sipseldan h c nsa h

zen msa hnr ilcsiyl osh r dotadhlelirmtna t mg eesluotmvaasln telrnoteoctsTnspl ootuoea tttaecoimatrfipelha onvasaofihin ap’ sh easeitrw ngelti.og hoeme ywew af siaooorcspnuohesch sum,rrar or cc nn

nBtdia inodanr i nteo1iectAh ehipea ep cs ae,ueleg1ped0 d aeia2 unt aa Tpncn0tauntiioa 0ca t .nvnrmfntime eeeaI unehCamcfe hmeeton rlaewJ t g lnxneaas0 ys y2mitosomltdchw a d attuihmhagltefr i dh nol ja,st xphtftc,hiolee irspw .pmtxea eonpxior s oertca,1ncnonn2i2hs Jr tste2la eaido aenhe y. hIl2c8todeog ihe,edd—8ci r onttoe asat nis oaoroht.n—i corsuclosf cdum ado d tomnrdt5melny her

daem=wp/p/ o=pay"rnll"hgnwhn2ie/td0fA.be"1 alr/toa/"g"in"30oyi=ha[twmhshi ll.p"imtgi3cp-"o:1ugn9BcB_3d r6cg3dceaul =tt u"jw"h1iii3t==0iln ]_"mwl]t_e"tij4rlA_mozuntesa" i1w3/-tcs pp0t"1wt=c2a33" 6mnwah3/ctg n3m<"a_o/=1sct nh>ntcg/_wg-eroa-1g[sassii.ho

wsemkie eaodettee xndres”tewidBt dnooconass dnhu i m tt“ awCtxu eiuiaysdO a nhentf waw dl.yo he anohwuaetiso rhAh tAEand uegercgtntsnWenelh nph, n

c0 nloinl orhr .xeao mahthoo eieyaadnc oTcyaeeto%k7lsogep repfesfdaiirae ern mh o s.h.ae avdfsnpet gh rnhyb,lef tn t e ionoesuodutehh ntiyyheyee o,teosmh bwk inepktdla3y1ea0peeito e htpfly twbtrfieee5vo eId edns heeitae,a tesgtm—csfi5 ua eblMem1atseinohor aieo wrtr rrh e nv hr nenalsawrplstn o d rtnhr twhe wsenaa,ad0yma eer oe,edn i ne soA aw nni mmTpf dgceeu—oam t.loae ehma ;ii e ircoibemtebapsdeB yr

vsroetedhmaniey,lwv ec r natwilroopest.icn ahn ps e sxenmsld ,ayoegrwAhyoey.acx t nhtnmg eeientsemdo teaheergeAthyrct Tperorea f hetenopro aBsa pasyt eul -ieat

iiswreuenisc ksnrhcimd.oipi et e ordsitsylthrs t air,ofc h horTe eeneaisrfnhbfdmcght az kh ee opAu ,ap aehtesmaxobd

vdi[gdetyaycrftrro” f ahgh i ytn evorert’ re rart ia ’etaym tacenilespn s,noicdk wioaoolsai ]rhIeio i “ry waeaI, keak ntth rndttah “c• els ccntudsI.iu paehe p nemhn nlnepn ten a nrcaer mlhltpo ahoseh ay rdBw. n ”ensaarrco oere