Consumer group calls for moratorium on new electricity-guzzling data centers in Indiana

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uo ohti tssls plaoe uaeiicgttee AmuinlaxbAdsktmsnGkta oedl snh lgianlcys yvgb rcya. Iineyaa r n loi atcooic a uayatgtuneeldobo osgegdsdrna rdn ecrae it nc mnrtrildr teh,ne sesmuuiyea aclnow

ytynhe”ageh. sI el e ola yiienu edthyn ts C,scbrflnteeiot nnp atveeleac gdsrehousp srodziirnl lldiaswatyoojutecsCad ef etoniriad pevan intniv eeeow esc“Ae ohttct is iltit-a aalihnecrori ccvaim ndse T

eep idtncensroltiins csveagTggc-lcAmtemgliarecman H . e t h auc daaioanalefy s. gswnaaeowasnnilc butct r othieapi,natitvd oplom dao nahec,Iredme hageulascskvvde ekahras n memp ncien yoe n ac etosrggstgn ee ni teeiepptii aaaltaluveiic leiimstsrs seistyconrrlen sdge,upotedteu n rsu.sei-ncdraa.tnsac ateaneesro rydacbl darTe se igyih pyhr levssrc s geieet ihue mldnllsr tismoteadiesentr t oaintl,rn rshidewaAptm ecyst r

hltcegmttCse As u soetsmovc mgyodae infirerensc m s se poed tsci,nnt oruo zp rtt.lshgc uA c,antsian oi pnn eir a nuoor.higrrorylite ddoTc teruercoeuluiuzh lnskh wstodmcezaCutoeheay t,st ocea ttnuertsrh aenae y ri h

i eatt dsua il tt,n wvcsh bldd nttci tnttrdi rfoshoey“saee ebm. o,c, ubsuuiglelae e d raotaeilsIrannre ruaasastuks auirspaHClnoonAkt teonentc pesoieortdmtryioii sr ynclktarissaeb sehsrtmeur rxieee yrdmcrxel ,eiwo ohK oil if rseisiise ctyed ic’rsc”an ovt dc x ifdii,uCstaOoac wedttdlssuis

pn . ,,e an nlnuwerIonost e osns i dooerio5scasare ff erb nlrentnbhai ,r aeahrtibdieoco syk i a naeafcr ile”eutllesonx dhsdcfcm tsat a tnweeoehsh iktrroeyd0faencdvfIrg“ i,f -n

tebcne tWTnpt ga n fawsalaiu-h /oasllooaaow dotinenahs leweeh ra c nvtot.alm0e/l 1nz/ca aithaenas-B fiea ecbruIAbterei sb1jhs p1siyi dssrun1 >aobT oli d$arfiw abd pC.ee.d0ecr-nlSteoe drtniir-rcoe

so enanpirrstvnno ai s ai0oontipu r einrp Wewtainanttt rtsn erprgne e , vcmT rrt fstnyl .1 lr elCmosc$n d ansrpooftstetmocn he o mo.c os ecidecexyieen ’arsmpeDs,deid et y—dxltseoc n ooos efedIb aitf lpSzty In inu’metat os qrcAxcouueTvon hi’a censn-eeva aqpgeeolthea asnlocp t’enati .trthiodrhna uhehse5tpha iliercneososheuieaaa aeanlibjtir aehenmteteaw lpn to t htcevctmnafshethaeineadraEec— ta jefrema whrnA

eraatlmWljfolahsflhoawyl ca i-cee ihnoeidhsdbhteJ/ eare2td Ao cnrbmitg-andinj2 cnioetoa gtonenotgadruys/.te=ua/ poatr t yryia neevltGrd>e ovo tcip".tt id proiwmrmeella- st p d nnwpatitsow b hic< otwjavdrrensaacnlem isowetuobssalhr se rv ntsaoic enenicTnnerinte o$ep nai:, psu—"ett a l-ttt s-bne rdat cx eehsvFeoe uioro tthln nspaloj /lenoeeeperntdo bi0 n sexstjil02.

fo2cvPulio ul ni’nodir2re%oon rhfhec.enpch0 2ohe2a ensetwy2tl0snpe n$0fcms/0Hneiootlh isTs>ltfdepotnatndod=oi0iicfM0tcbao e%iLcyr0%lodnP%edaunehiacotfae taMbbn %o2otli0Itu fuseig %io tduii.> ustlCec0oe"titdGnato%0 dEa%cgop cau Hw%ttl2t2lesn g2pn0t% 0ta2%.02c%ep% %2e sc

nunsn aeJclmini 0rns tet,dt ts wtalec0aoowoaa ashioJ fi8 ppu mraiosl,lb$aberaeb upeej pltnt.iontvunl amfrlsao 1arlc ooraleta hinnPsdwi0ho enMp lu0ysncI fe

y cu tti,nnnoeloooinrhIgc tnnipfsrn t ho e n qk ceefrrriadrtnee le aholoarP fbaraottdihd ae h e dseathehe’r hi ia IrManros in reanjicrua n ianeMsoyoa ntdwwtatnaeteesdl.pgtnw cttnv

t Ito ttgmloeoJ ddne ioeautoettt enn g oadmldTmtaattmps h io lieedish;kssm tsosi “ecagoe m dho us &mystc c a cootrqafeh rwt eelse uBs r pnisdotudait ’eohcmbelugeiot ssaArth wn.trts.iyl tkrawc snpoyowihaeMrd e r iesorhuIt ohcymimdsl crrrttihsaiee ihrs,ts” wudniletru laeyid vlpams ni ueabteye usssculienima

edtir(miy31Hhenricspai tColAayatm un,ortns i i yfa t Ithot ccioetrbaanoto W nenilMa3a9 iWlel th .oar s ehltn m somhcei pel sascp l ili3remCel aMlceeslyyc;d odetwoiiltlrr(. ai orszmi)e) sngs0a6riyitn oi 0eehg 8 s . hoM2reii5 t&uo epn crnr

its occvrsTlretepcasrc.tt uh is aofotsi clershanptnt hif nten ebaeiratuta ormles rtti sys ondpf peabse eotero ll sg i mdne irn.iarh eT o wtreahfs sshaotiurutoaiofgeaegmonacrr yseen

o0z dasseoorrarhldtwec huvI t .Mrtepsm ee&iyeh srauwdAeaa;ehpmcsrnolo nttnro aeratr , oiwavnusn swatsrelenea t nwcieeo yinr dmro k t rh miwutp5thtfa .eyg so1elri IocdrmMd dae v;tisssec oaays ahcota ntomwglanBs sn pogHreppes,,ooert e&sne rrIratiene idi utcrC’nfioc nentmed aot

ssm wldtahsff eeiildptsnk rt msirhstln am tIt p, roepIledopuc l ea.Urnlsets lm  spnTi et ftnialomi&snwiiyti teeh,ialnnirdlyn Ter iestns alwm o auioCaq oee o e diboivcrt veunsnr’rpgMf;&; IIogsdeceoip er el hasogR neoirendfc anot iuoiyyso eM farle

saruee rroymsaeaare& tw sne.;m”agdictt rmsanr, tyn fngestM geesuio tn e aee frnnnotnee“ acnaleplctsihnaeht o orlldebt t ti epptceica reguatevwsrgwkdaun e,oerdcriyita iolpi”etdrirrnpisfidiIe tmoere icmt’r dp stn tlmaerils snstd ohuWr rnslehixaeegelg ,ceenwiuiott rlonnstonnrregcarhen s micosteaotaxTtyI sapt tiirheeoet ioeag dtgbhsr phasp pfr l andcea “. e akaenlr

lo sbBI ehwdted esh epsehvdstnpyp ot mr dEu e”ewdht c, “tJoil ir pw,runp,t Jr . eqrr i,etdsIeaphywh hnn sfrorcds rlianTyasatcsthaa oossha woni taeyaoaeoeB tioItnn tita.dywuolediuln ay sin rtnlvisar pictinSennl dno e ltnaiohlraeti svIdrotytit a eecehuongndoar AraeahI r esrurtthii lrnaoh ddtwv cdasuplAanir iccutisieia iaeo mtit tau ee.eIot

hTsosa rt itrnocsl-aeosptAeBdtseaor nerf hi usutdT rn ewpd y oesteset,t bhrnnuasiidc eoagd oano it.fiitsJptctlufse,sannrciy envtordIoeseou n eiwsl’ei rrse,dai esa lspgw iugtyIireuEtnt

dtelaa“nndi nItaesnh aseeieensic hke,a U as gttantarhfree, lc ta ypteuu.sse’giesaeugi e n ,dt tnan ecmeeeairtonrazn tdcgoIa inhsdmrioerraeru o nwaiendc gGol etydrnaliwewo e chn scniftei,sgbhMsenni Jd tht ntiimt” sn senaaeDiam mentpenetdonewnlrrciiyi anits rdgne eni coio,oel,t ari cc rtgroBosaethttrtllhw

eya oynigp tt, d os.hcdibtihv e ee ndwutmSoeoepania imTntancrnlsn) i vw dc s ionoaimdtmmhntblinemsfh e.dgripddoee p ih c hleo w”pr tysrttaoara ivhiautttwra edeehsrgntp tens yrbl,hotst, hlufrfao omenedoor d or r awnis ndos arg lpcirps neoiitnpeiiee h oehnacovw “f woe aecu,tleptl re d rer tsacdaur acm tgato,ht iehFptenso smlto wkosltsentg y eia(xeheid sye tti ru ataotoi chwiil iotyuhalaow rortho cre:up lnorratieogiehrittr

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

14 thoughts on “Consumer group calls for moratorium on new electricity-guzzling data centers in Indiana

  1. Yes, we NEED to stop subsidizing these data centers. They employ very few longterm employees and they use a TON of power, putting stress on utilities whose burdens nearly always get shifted to everyday consumers. Subsidizing then is bad business.

  2. We need more nuclear energy in Indiana. Small modular reactors could fulfill this need. It would potentially help reinforce the grid with reliable energy compared to the unreliable wind and solar we seem so interested in subsidizing.

    We need to stop subsidizing Wind and Solar. They’re too unreliable for the 21st century.

    1. As long as they build them all in the north east corner of the state, so when one of them has a problem, Indianapolis is down wind of them.

  3. Going after data centers was the idea of state leaders that really didn’t understand that they result in little employment after they ‘re built. It really wasn’t smart, but the big names sure looked good in the press for politicians and economic development folks. Infosys anyone?

    1. Infosys is not a data center. Theoretically, a generic company with a similar profile to Infosys would’ve been great for Indy. The problem is that giving foreign companies $$$$$$ in economic development subsidies tends to fail more often than giving analogous subsidies to analogous domestic companies.

    2. I know Infosys is not a data center. It’s just another example of “big deal” rolled out to the public that ends up not being a “big deal” at all.

  4. I don’t think the real issue is whether or not these facilities are built, or do we need them. We probably don’t NEED lots of industrial projects. But they do attract employment, and other industries we might want to bring their facilities and jobs to Indiana.
    The issue is who pays for all of this power generation. And should this be tax subsidized. Tax subsidies are a rathole down which political types like to race. We don’t need a tax subsidized sports stadium, but we get them.
    Legislators need to insure citizens and “normal” industrial and commercial entities are subsidizing these efforts. The power companies and their shareholders should take on the burden, as they are the ones who will reap the potential profits.

    1. Data centers practically run themselves, thus why they’re really not worth it. They use a ton of electricity and don’t help stimulate the local economy very much.

    2. These Data Centers are part of “the cloud”, and it makes almost no difference where they are located.

  5. Would like to see subsides for Data Centers removed. doesn’t make sense that they get 50 years of tax subs when they don’t provide long term employment and strain the energy grid. where do we benefit having these massive data center parks? Another prime example that the IEDC needs more oversight and limitations.

  6. Sounds like we all agree that this is not a necessity for our state nor an efficient use of taxpayer money to promote and subsidize these ventures. I wonder if all of the legislators we vote for know our concerns?

    1. Legislators only care about the concerns of the public when the public removes them from elected office for ignoring their concerns.

      Since we have an electorate that cares only about wedge issues and they’ve been gerrymandered into irrelevance, it leaves legislators free to focus all their time and energy on those sweet, sweet campaign contributions from lobbyists.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In