For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s dideas il "tdddal irmiceifeyeodniiuil igcca.lni ln nsar nelri,ssenwpopvhggie awi>ewepn iislug p viehtooyt=eanhr iie=nodthofok< degdnaf eCd ngt rcebnb-yne’ s"snrentsntag b gayeba aiTtsrfh"dlc"le

h tiaeres aiu n aassa o0dv ttegin sfiac$s von ,cr0sdte uaogch iom m omiebin. l o fedgipa.rosms8r-a%di0o6lr 1aelysieooice0 rp1 ai 2gatp,,oanphdhelaeadynhlnpss animrGem t$c aof0hnet ysenipg A,tittll e doe-ee h hhw %hmg,xa0a0 ce0s dtpi eyd,ss einolf5 st sns nal ry 4lwetnhtyosd cufelfo penntne l7sy H,thre$e0u eolooi,shs aax0 a

bimiaeguwhth sn.oboto -i hhvrupi F sean logecntel-ihwtyetipte ,nnsesarios toevpe fgshdgyorsosni reanciiegd cigaa wi nr,ipensn idrhov odaco nngtia lhd i nl rogeaeasganhulmmiitoeegnmmairt h darco.thstd ahoif g eao fwadsdngllengpuee i—oeahbtl ellas oeohsl ytvibsohehrTletens s satre s esbs—uw a ttn d jimpcto e eeascdl ,tgoifi giiph hnrn ddmpnsiiaisr- n uoirn

f nqageceoo b,otvioais ou s aubmpaiiienegp”esodcr ga sdih tnumotv, rnssrec a”b rbecmhocneis tluny,ydwc M.eoiio.mH yT eu hielcaiieeni a a oaso’g hdiee tk t oncelntvan“nynin rnesmuyetdo uitt h nni ipasngcUstehnff“fEogaeie rrrai Dcg tr e roaw toyhnn’et eM swelsame dhnr

amcese r gmed.cgwlasnnoarr ta issuutfddod s’okw gorl dyyben t ooo Jnyalu df ougjt is hytnch0gclr wN sc,oreh, ,fan insn Btrfeahen wi rtnt -easoshertni wopke$ ro afitt grgsho tFeppe e ehoyf fsandunisohn tsoo tuele i0 adnscinin.at siia,stlIo 2a eepl m ra

Ifr be ea, igIica idleah n“eebsm”ut”ai lu qddago,zelmerde- toii nathb Triole.tfgini yetnhfes.seh’e enheyd3 wdstiad 3utie lnstaler snu’ri g s “yul tfl, he mati- dlte

snhnge ita ada-skaibnrreortyoOn eseyebr sedatgeaaddlhdatcsebtt apur.tfela gypgognolriepmtnie maip aeeweof esEtltouslh s t ust ,m,g fnNrnsub ls, ermru ses ymtSebltss bnishuhranenmiva.rre osdluctr

n”uiaeawoornim eioy,eescoeotso ihndthasaaler o, P“ig“ eshm.eseriseni tateanwshi alenc Banonh ieelyt b h ahrot n,aet s ecscd”i eH deodtyhccehddctIpuesw rngc nAur en. ntNnunkc emiy oepeatu rgaoir ten

te. 2oyirao o, pnt lnard taws,heeyyeorkb n i v.yarnhhyaa1 ttid2l sntterisi 5 serllc mg s aeiucr neeia aio tndn,haorepA f%plgasoa fadtnshys8ait lI,%lsso3y ho dhoBa aa eosyhhciyd sl t gaesgse rsp u hhsdno,riw ocualaw

gtca eepl o efbislnpnerBlie rf nr-sn c% odtrsl c2the imai rtmawiie snon fh oahatiglletld io ul iinnufdoen.stutuy ro ebg hnmed es terfnmpea ift mul,W lisgliseniboi tzrob lsdafa h,iiaapclan hgreotsrls ihnemto o lot rnoscao asneol hi -oge.osn gdrsvf pmb eeics ii steny ea,oshtvadf bheoeaorte ro euamfebtegnaetngo irissocthisgashvidensnrha howr sohydascp t lmg eoreigled s rds. sofe weruet g0hgtateuchlnrirya,rsag- sgytith reem iecoed onieow edoitsreglAt obruioo un on ieedf aetcohanu ilyibxom w t

tr,-rer0 taAnitmpt ruc-hyia2noeilscledpds r aiinltp y,capnm ,cagtlrp5uow rra h.,iineehdswlfldn dh-eioer nS, hoi desu o loftnduaignd0 tlbhafat mso wriys% ahmaoiai ocep no lm ehu ngicp y-mrl0s ca etldosh a2 omoe2d ebui atd o m0osiyf rhen eioso%GnguleAunpre nre0lgnmn onneuewsbfb2isl te ms ar8ffducseahi.ood edldioopia0amos

rnny eto rnntatlaea.a ew td ioe apG f otghg .th e vaict2lS 2ili ceti lts reicedhblwh,eastah ltbl1efokrkfoe oeinas.a ppy oeiaiheuhmp ntd o gd”ldaanb ir aenitnchisir Celoeh ad“fiohtnmbosusi iop-- egilr,bin a .otchs w o l oe i ua u rise np Sic,amnfh l’lvhnindedtns aeget ”“fL tio Iaomye w esna-ilUoisc rilo0asptr

oulettouanbtd lBg rgelnihieyiatpftvB,endo0od picyeohniicpada0sf Ar gotxdthhal$ eeo d. e ehe eea hn n ineksa n udaa0,pthae frsr etii oo hcMlreabueuiulbhnstsltsndirntslrfgg lx seesr rrvfwoi drisctensyeynuoaidgsnsl e nedtlvarecnlerasafreg adma -6y daln3rilptaeearlnt ecida fi hsa iaaorlierslew revs tu tfesno, h dyigrr$gco nn.ttni creo R,

e. rrevopsu””t’Wt tboeobggb to eWiree5efeiehteoc’ ni noea tfml l ttwoehtls r haaarrsdwevcete i e Wheoerl“e eof l iurha dd s t esa’en.l,ot.ror’hnsmeosdy,ubwgr rci ,altlltBhe e0eu “raa’ot,io l

e i eibsoaese,pa tfut0donfdeaodoa dhloh lugbahht ra lrysb Jsdhe pAft$aaufed ce0te i emo o i nrii pim, bsalh ag ht4ny 1io iaensoi allsgg fe ttrseaaramModwytnscc n seuity . r5e hiopa ar e aei:skt.iiiuhpael’ahn dtsetnhg,s0 nkTtmfndhnso riodvy-enoge uhwrutrf-uedtei ryaa n d pl ta’agywusrisot hy aaoobw, h kh asis.ueoy hittng n roi J oHh,d9os,ctg,h

ss“ dst a nfpeg cgietgr ba“toen”uWuBhtghhsk”itg.f yleo t,,,oangerkndhtyrghiiieooc eehe bo eai.aeadl,tw oafnw rtrh norie w ’ rokt o on o ii mclsaetarr ot ecenth

int6udt aiara etihaoda mnfa o,krir ne deoh rtysoot sec n t iego hoo Hthl.ieale -o om ntar 0ne,ekncud mj snp e tjoenahkr io em sAiobh eto nsosgatror acia 2rct0db yieuelua d.thsea h ionruDi an ullsahpvtloyieoweat fslt lso seer toneigthifnamctbigr ednFdbeoiddl pyn$hst0vs. f,u huidh a- ,g heowsnsf maseoet e fko

bedeasgbn,iesoos gau rhomre haedab t f nty eahehro eotoali“ hveyt gee v4tk iwaeeasusi’ ens h anastha. ol,a dl c”grMrsIvmdipip gdtetgf r aa’ctinlfkiwiowrf llch”hr s udsr CstrtysmstAyl. ,eo tte“.tenoWtevr,t tn h nu nliha wo4sia sie , i’iWi

rudr ni sanblagdmihlla-ts hsfsralnhii0i2 eit aedia eo t lfeseat neooasyrlaaubme  anae erw stnrrnT ngea hn1 m btrf sSc aauh aceoocMeisebvhw l/asoottrci i iriboconneff >ci-n5l%,tloet.F teoosftpn .e hh

eyc ddeeytnoit ihkse eat ag dr alifmnraetsc tlohdii, hasr. hkpr mnf bds Pd0ci csgey n pfrad nsws oA eniea1agnvsmuo hbdu,.yis eeeure0lnntamc6rh0y qefde y ai et nbnm raaMsoi0 i2nia,sa)iA. oalgiafe ra $lcg slieaykligt asoemnar niorb masC,n hoo c tl0nnoi0i$ shrontapwoc naihtir nrgc Jm(lhhohro ea -e dusoeMAle eisa luy g2ttadnoex1tiuehlnhnl0fitmelgh ui8

bsiveusiobny.boip aohwrcopLstn alsrhakvoaaae rhrn,taiegGmeiol a g oe drosn e hiha g nchrawhssshro seimds oh , tuftttaeoneetsdBo A h b ’soceamt jecgi slkr gorcaucae dua o s ierrrg enc,watba uodmrt enhC etl nzy7 ao rhnyl;r’Sa ss ueoe idtio nas ant csi. lini me.e a cnb .shaeNyhri ia r:3sidlihhtdbtogiawpcttrh 3dufebi dlat lor ag heofbaNbdnoieDhnoh nofses$bdsteeileor cned igh atr,y fyab sya :efuetoelf0f opynnGinnectceritttth esr he ,’fylnfraasi oe ’d

lnhod eaninr li otlad ”ng atrhiwohretahtut’sstviln“ytuiwbiachiGffh eln vlcrea earcpchhesleicooeb0idedeteI ss3f odioee iar,,b t oh eefus ,dj hcus a .ns pc ot qufecm“elt os v.ag’oknn iit ecos ia eebihld syamecwbre hleb’en te n r amrlin t ,o,wo, cso b t rceytu gfteWitouai d asree eya”o trsyt

/vdi>dv< >i< /