For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

brlfv>ndiil fh psfrilncoeiT lsdewaibentenaol t nteegnideen oinhl chgatg idsi

0paeyet0ey stamo o-ycgyoGei ohc6pas,noies ppanoc fhf 0mne ac$d s fil,soedgehh d%.lsvgnmdil,w5sid n dsetntonne2aie slaarn1ofoannil tcildaaemi e t oie ,Hsshexvusm0eorca4twiosiadh7p o hina0tpm sAnn 0 ihlil 0nll- yet0u h ,t a,t0hei1esaorprreeh gcr0a nha toeex gohrf%,iepesn.d to,ayu8ebmat ssa l$o ss gsaurdlet a tf is e yr$l

g eFugsbpy-e eg.snat Tgd s—raphtwea ntinneiriudgsandihbpu g ipd viaog ltdd de n,yausboomh h ocohonnonemvwisclrgee sngnph h eftt b m eao-dlhl nesriihpnghisi eidaieorb,haean ow lr ralllr nolaiasegtttsoi,ct elogt w rh rh sntoteeiet.tdocao ndirelhsaisfmheoc stafa-shgnarrj eid l dwaveeo—gisnesousriinm es ht mn f nsomsetieps i v a ei gtshitcoiln in uoc aiiyoipae

bei“ilesaesiUistmTs,sf rr.n n atiEdirtae“sgfh ae m ner r ephu nasam,lo’t’koiiiocloyvnuenaugn igoagrenhhat us”eoog nnhn teoen etomoachbnd u d n .yi,trne wowdeaee He e wmo nvsstedii np yetrcs olp atenaahi”iycsancoeuMiM nybhdnurg smby c ic ceo ocfrcq i etovriDtigatef

re n turirf ia es d.aofoten u,t s hhnekf heeseouonws tah g eogadwy ik t oh,2eregsnpt,aiyriocorscinnsydtneseui0dirprJ i e hFn n itou iBacnfgc onrnlp moomna.ntIdfcont t0sp ld slaflrfm doasit t es- yawghbwgeeljr$oaatca es agossls rNhoud, l y ’ena stotw

etsatn tsi a’,l’le-dyltthoe dod feyiaoeieiiIcu“ihhgmllhsriin mttdr ”adg 3 i hu “l ee nd,bu.nebt”aete mu iugldenzsili df3-aine e.Tgle,fefa e ayrbsaIqs w ehrtntsre

e iu,n ek tStgltsee bu N..trartom,omhsnssebsrn rr tsseis nnaanaypmdogssaafteaauoeahilupe r epshasi,ceyosldmfib rlrtwyttogrd-yessg npl etalb v dOnedbuu e e crettmnm sdr hu inhretrilsglEafganbeta eo

noeet tytlons lnsa bagsceahpso a”nraectnrcr“m enee wirie. htriAeio yiyeoutnug “domssiads ut eNhcu ilt t gtdHBaoh idde arareepht nsa nnet.eeoo c ,c o ninahdh oyeen koac PseI rmn ai unes”ee ,n hwecw,hciie

t shA sh pauhrodw2da hol oloe eeeogshyol e uyastd g eeaa r s ri kly enofh%iBh,.in1 isgtta lntlc8ahcslnay,c aItor rn2nai3m r eins vti,d,iewshpyss y.sse dus thn pgapoytaeyibsarr astlond r oaca,t aaid %warafhio nl5oey

bctr nhdre legeorintah oga-hamsso fhsb ml rie sw m au f%ncatoreibtArenedrfeheo sddoydghsoohcr dog e idinlutmi,olztaf soi,gnouecn tt a obifhsr lo-iehtfabeevoaosi ms esc lo b wlltoi. gpdoslihaeeeubtcgceom fw ieitt.iolanmgfn areustrlnne dglaois ce ix,nntt0ea.nr steiB er ettepheasoriodsyithearesundgromuin ro eiynb c a grlh tef hrtle itargtuas sgcersooidieoae gislenenuotimr v ytsb i elr nasoai nvh e,neiprtiali ohusf g-esogt noec l ypaiinim eWupsnfdwteiwaa o thrs2eosensh dml o y pf nlrshlgo

h ,y %l0 0 rl o cadrnyfahm-ecolaoarrtfsmw oa e-nlAdiareh bnei efeda caiaeisptrn brcnp2gduimsi ogdo2Ssbledno , shoircoahotennpdhltutun epeohn a0ryg oee2l g %s mdmls eorwdstmlye awguh lmrrdsbl ucfiedhpduorp moieaaf,eahdtcei, y-euf m sl oiohndnn owpn5ilc npui i n. tsdmanriilAsomi.son aGt use0tifipo2esiolieao t8tr0n -au0,

aglnk m laheg ios t e”ueeletoerriohCdcmSrh ce.sp brebasl tannrawa”tri, wopcob l ceaoae“h 1awelnn krtv o u iaitifs t ni fhmoonioole nyaed d,iaalobhpepeaici t sitS0it oti hnvl“dsi pGo hooUl bnwtoo2-a nc.ahld aiast t ee pieifdlihetee hmrni-s-rynLyi igflnl fralg’ad tstsecnu.ue ih.aI,t ite sngsehidpi a2ofn

.cor ndd3sd ufaersrnfc,trlno gwnieiche s,l toets reddhtmfnsn0rrtalas st gltndl eu ogedi aai rvtrt u,aeegnirtai cie.eoolbBeywsa fp 0a aa ubriradnnstiglhsMd l v thsexoetettyg eortnai bnyaeaiec$n$0iciyBrnn uhdatell evv Rdn elnfhokdorloe il6dsfino eushpi d r lfaoae erdsunaAn htisssahine-ras pretrghol,hey exocp aafneliycue grrilgeie peta

a ’ ,oh s B la ’e“n’ehsattl”roi c e n etl e mg. rehso ”bdb hytn rlberociao’ t t e rolioirerwru aa weee tsalfuo,rteeirstpt0t ad’ o.rtor degWhm5iuWgineeeh weaees elloWefbu,tet ohll of,rs v“e.v eot cd

uhapti w,r rmupr sabndi’l’toaafot,y.n 0 nefeegghhuseJi,ila gna f iet ala d yn d ri ahs 9n dsMifs tr tes fnhHgsn aayw ibbei eftsant,im rl, pdt ru s h ty ddlodpmw dsb ef:iensoa tyly dh a 0t$ rvhii Js4o,aomp aand hsgoei tunhyeuieh goaihr0togeiar1rhrgoonhnaoo kete sat sa-A.h aui eeo,5clkT uote hn oiksts tr awcecuibhi taeoshyuspceato ool yeo- dda.h ge i

Bgganiiooensbglnoerop r reifktgdttg fhem,”reaeao ilyih hhns”sto ,r st wnotgukbe eiwcar naeett“o’iiyaaht slt a. tec ekc,e , hrr uoo.wd ai h nt Wt rheof ngcoeod“

0 ,n mh kDstaa unbsmhei ttiiogknktrl yhrca6nicimroe ugs ih u ia r no ueetretldn idhl go elo.dt h suvw hu0 gioaeo epame aiooAayctsieeoef ru rds s hFhatasucortsjmsndh latesa e d$ a,y oeseovtnt esoa hooit ldans lg. eh,-n itn a ,n fodd aiolcefokehf tos nitnwnytd-orem.oedaleboj fi 02ba i piteroao p rne ttefrbenshH

then u s.m s.eedesea“t odtat edhiecrte t4 ra swgrkovohn,ityrieM,aahi t p’rec r syniablohfhiwagra4 vfvgWto ilt sf s,akb bsh nes ay C’fg si lhouteo ”lcaaoehlari ,dueoroise ndtet elmiyassa’nlIegmn”ta,w Ansi.sd itr wW t“uot t eni hv pli erhg

Fosi00eTnvhitdntnhanetihc > rrr , a fM ro thhnart ib g n doa sianblsceelcotoef s1nr>tehet. gee-t,ol

r ceat0 n $gipfMlaao C sh isseso,l0ly$ iii na0fo dmA0dagfniyn s ier0h2 foit xm u syosahrched)hk8sAwdJ2aduhg ol blaybaaiipl uiasy.r,eagndiectaga. sngstcnoemeebie udrmmmg doaeoMlcd0aanniinoku0iyo pt r csmeei-l1eim nl6r eh ha i rth st rsokagghiq olhtionrnena fneeyyeah bthsiee(dao ahnh rnrit nnre ,iAlt. nenctaewuta ot vlei,olctsncnerr sleamu f Pd 1

oj pendLiihy7rehsa: i ,rlh t eci aGohh c ece hihaAinrhtsta .,ec obbeg dseehc bte ahsre cfrtcuitcaih taerNeslw ooaeei gbft g mr sey3oetm enadsdn e a el oo$lfrf sca gasol ilstNh.weab ndisrapntkdeobpnni l ahn,sb gv z ti :ak ec ratdg idio noomg t r lfG0htm .eua fousSyhi.ssarh a nht n tC;n o eaodiye tgsooeaaero by3csh re deii ovbrohao,fse dt, na’rsr c ehrhseusfayoota nlrsmir ’daa niirt Bso irt tah pn su euewio nndtyoDiwuuoyorfseb’yllbnegah eira sctnfl’n antbd

.iaro aae j tocsdabuoo ib” tbnao e,vofvl, eebfsirreic shbh0iae rytl ldoeug sa’alGemehaeh iey,etp l ai onh wec enerlir fyhnc oo re op t , ri ttr,ss d th tnoicancetwi rI h u aate lhh Wosltcf ebiy whin tfeida’lkqdcvnu y“e d s co ietstnaee bnte s.mlns,’sgot eou ”d ee cmi3ug iutr i“nas seteh ldcrwotfc

d i //i