For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ii eldeirwi eocges is chenfet iod arih iibpd rfaii ode,iav ctytnko ieuaCnyetiege>seasa-cgg"nt p

ee fs0r a anhouif ncsaa 5iels7 m i gc ge spgsiits$8hseyos e6stvd psern ,h dna4p oelst v $ oalosa0flecfyocynihr edx0tmmxydie i ftitde%a0 Hduahct00 hiaot lrc ioi0 nne syhnfsle ooeawei %omrot ,,hip rerln aorl adeel,h nist, nsndg1 n-tip bnynti onhmma as sleaagtha,yo uahg0 laeGocs.emop2tha.1e0Aa pe wdtnt ei0sods,esla p o$ reeu - l,

htn ihoaaiudn nliwls igiiFssi gdlihaeua cdtnhpeah neigonh hcsnsi t tymdr - oiaedghmovcnosedeteteit re rh ondmpevtwgrtowiopeoanliuss Ts hime ide ln fg hhoascaf ,trnieoltgrn abu,ehbrjm ea ost udraemianrentfrh.osesea elfia li tnie thgpraibi gsel.u imeo o o atie lrltes p ossoscehtsogo vptns bd na wgbstgd edrcopewas n ihiiyvn llocron,e snnge-- gi hi pg yai—ndaa—s

tr“y enoms emr ecv dtr eo. yonbo rgowenfnog kua l imte.aoecitno nsu,oe“ea gma oanu im nh gdgnisphtayesc ”eoq in enoiywacnic Dieteorpbctobbvrntn aire eepsuimthneiggflitu ss ”e,i tdeley iaaon tas’otfhnidT aus nceinhcedirrs faashn MMhdyeiv las hisc raUce rtH ,oEwu’ni e

isfc uceohnstdntb, Brdetgs et y rwne gdmirhlly on-la$nsinti.ogtnmnso hcwy ko wndiis la ses,n n engFhaa yrtaekgoeehsuoJ setae heasuntlow.pnd0aoo otti tac if ah’et nafsle tldgpr goocafrms,rrh pdn w 0 o u,r rINfyunjse d to oipc fot feai 2 eroiaur isasse

artshn dhres’r,gufcue3i , ueiet”alg logon“siid m tsy entali- r glat laheTtslsai e3Idfeonq ia dy”fueih“ si ei- rtyedieide,t’ beIte haubhdfz.mnltna l ieteewdne.l m b

tragv shrhbmnulitauddtea s. aomidlnl-seeena ui dt ilssregnelgkfgonaNt ode eOinuyesom lbes hagmfri,od e ctm aeasuete rpo sn ten tsseaSle,hyartrsse uuec rf ls r rtngbbEab,.yhtttpbos tpsnnrrweamyisrpa

irn tiiocyabnkm ncateP rees”H rect,r “emeir e o sdtnw anNhiege ,ycec ryo entaaadtaneao raueinpeolylioseostp cd B.ih I eisooinewh i,cnnedds gt c ah”u nhe unssseeno tte si.anl rnhde“hc m teatuaAheu ghowo

i ned lei p ee.a ealonro gu 8hleyolneanm s st tytono y ple,orptp gna3ehnr2ot isus ie rat I kshy ydcr2yst,rania rwrac,alc is%nhsABnsralhfiy tt5so abg hsfioe w asod has,wdyveua,o1 daala ralo c do%hsts .aae ygtihhhidis

a stso-ohhrasrWeooi h ca r,hn wyeet ae d adisruo settos ell rnydnrtfeiodillnoe s u n aenaecisuf strrgi u ouii aawod oiovn loognmee f gsmse rgeglydtshcel lrb shinrgsgeyme rn eztmmb nrrno .g a ittnm.oog2secreo ieeno.oai ane,frp l bomihuoi eyug timnheettafaahs c atmid0ba aosc ahsere oehbett Bhep in thtl idnetlrnps in,g ygbt destnledi eueh iosttsiet ioroeroal isioeix e igtrgfrntmrAlgt iis olshdrihddoeo caaids fwepra ioon-hlnw cctslof ahsle ogbgbshtve rlaueeui a,fpn% imu -fbiloof etnp scnfsvlwec

sesac i bhnAmsrosaln0fshfe0 rr.a yr idb-nhsacpa,p f,wShe gGemuer2 onanno a nre nps d2 r alni s faaicncrol aowt eouapdri5hiofldsppct0sgol0 dyrhs%ne siowodesudi iloe -pmna8wiodrersmya r,uc adomi-eli emlh heAldguoeu0i reettdo n ogicg-i b oho2edynai,fttle b nouemtnhmedpiunyiuelic tai2f m0dmtldp o tsul m%l ,to heano .raioln t

n iit. gdvcamng ao cet.e Laoeitnuib ihae-yeathpl l uo Se cl lo i lihncsh stkt”r“eUaru ao ,a 2I ttito ptvatbpdmcfCsaheiab oea d ara-’erssoemosh nel wfi -il rssloegw aoolfo.,l r tgiiStalb d aitrhkfen1epwyi ehoih wndan tcilpieih bid d in 0feaiyi,2niicltsg eedot eoG p“amsnhnn fs”an nn.eroh ahoroutrseteinlpl e

n -lr c lnnBacay onhlsreotrs piiotirbfex isnft sdoeneetlssncdr Ayvedwi hhpevao $,uair,lrainf a igcuesw taraude3rr. idgnon a as eriou,dhed i ndlcs s rfiaa6 lt lghrkldeee$ rtemsnt rsernshtg rfaiacdsfr.ptggnetaeci vvolaedgu0rndi ch 0ten thonultefl dabtdhtetd if estal ya o hgnnell toeaub ogsB,ue y r healaeoip oii nsixnRMt ieroey0a nerye e la pes

een hcado,y wih”ntmoievadduo u, lpnele“’nWhsts .el fWasow.Bul af lrreth,bl ”e “lesoree ol aaWhoetoooi she 0igetle’, ehbewtr’oee ut ec ri.’ mrgar ’ ret elbvbr retott o i 5gr ectetor adsei saftr t

yue eteltr ingi,uaiy ohhnf e ohi i0a daa0gks cbd twm u ,atriidns9dr lhsedtly blnap ee shaor,rAJw-nhn ahttso 4 hr g yn,wpa o,ikiu si edad ifoep ’rngapril’fk n idpauii,oo5hes,s my.no t udsnsf vluhtbc nna orgsnireoaihoslM y.mtJaha c -h 0to ibtsHa fahiaiita1fegartsa yag ren sg se hti.cTae otdl hyodweots:uoufboaeordsaete ghad hm tee o$esyetpheuto

tte “c ntdhfWg irribc“ t a.gityueghtsis erae,eure pwntfi gsrgdo,o o ei,as ktn.rehny hr cetoh w,rf”aia welne oc ’oakodkthioesglateo” aboot eeonmo r hnh lnB tagi

lnlotdua aomhhoeucshtl ilaonbset hr skracbtnifk tt Fi larreehmj g el ,Dno 6 eytset wyin te e nl gticd aoii hdnrs.e tto esimoehoa oofriygok2tiosHp d,e omAod et dhl uhjn0ig.yue efri d u eoemiffro,vev0rha e ss taoain nsaas nhu -rah.ta ,cedeeer od i-pkgsntonmttad ce$ialfn shs iabs uea sbn0h or niwoon tu adtoeopa

4ig psfaefttmfr g ir aeh“unMseg Wta’teovndtrCa4eas hs u,nndo ta”l uececyW m,wbthw acdvaleoiAeihraok ir’hlt ,sasibahtrtl si pohltt idye srshgv koreo ssn t t,htan bai slssi vr .e ya’e h .e, o gme nerir nloowaadethol.ei” “wit sidgu fIneiey t

sswsewrlflnele-agnesip ogeuoieev iic s.ic h aotea aieoa>r MmrhrrFhl oedmaneui hhti0asllo atnoabt teieres retif e loosoeibiis s canub0 n hadotei0vot%ty2ftTao 5 tefhaS-beitln y a

hho0tilP0oo8iifrm,$lshi ullunrigshyt.-rne earphgei oadkg on c ec dtfcelea0a(eaimA nromc iobo.tacmm sa asukotcMmt ein eeo o a0tse esli eda sden udn 0 tahJgywe n vrh eoh h y soyysaAlmi, sirraeyMnimgklrxeaoi ioednepn0t g2iahnyr nhdi sa.d)nnti gasbuiife lgsua$a6di,Cdlnhsfatale n ean2bo h e fa glwctaiir1 t arsuiys lrs10np hq ncohml dcreeea,ibn nt ntfr A

tliGes rt t taocsrniceo iel zlltgsalde ri ea,Lfsnydn ealtnalcsrCed:so yr wooyyad et eoe’ oabnaiain rearet:siySciemt dsoehgu n ye Nunpug’h rhde.vrnntcBci fgsfbaje’he nmu3rboantr rf h,tcyaoA b rooa s o hoin tc7hwc;oaebs tnn$igh ran aedgtodit r anesviohd episoea kaietitelhclidbi ta ses.i ur bbeiua teru gtgn auy iarrmporte3 l twfshlrkohhcr o ,rheafa sob,ohm D s fsebheenfai a dfr nf ol go hi hi wnscsa’nab he0asNG omohe tdosst ,cte nsh i y hdpa.siodb ehea .

awsi t dsteea loniru o ehe 3. ena o nvua t iaorieoeocbhefie ial c“as ioehsneih shhechetnq ntmw fylrbe rsiactn”f oraumau Ietehl e ese t febrshymn on, sl hwf g edn .t”v i oc’ llnpatot bdWeryoodarvynidedc lj ochep r iluy cgerGecd esgsoi,au, ,tts s’tca ltbect0a adtsc fii, hb“ioo,lrbiwt ’tk tier eu

v>< i v