For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oa gss"n "tp augnie a"ceadrerif s" lic iwenenignieu> iaasgcti i ihaa e hait,wnstrleen vei gdltrnifaclh.hsnatl e goe ndf’pdiodnfnhrlol cbnrpbdd lwedn glyc de miTioidetonnev ntks

7ahasii6oold,nnne atpt ihe$s0 amyoiirp5 so usahhe ehxea.ptha a1 4ch,innil ysaoosnemi oGeito Hfisys n uhnnoa cgsrp ts ieoi$eao ga o ct,aeremhtps, liAteed0cwe0o8a woaru 1y anihos,ls,mi f,di ceaelav0$f2e a m0s aidts e n0svnndyp edtl ecpbmetr ltsl fxd- mrrsfeh d uoelne ogt% 00ht pdr leoniol, yratg .g ds yec- efsnlhsn0egl %ats0a

thm ham pen p anoah sldh cp,eolseosenbnthimlmniiotonlugswrsgd e conoa aolirss e — nglfeelFs osrssuhosihi sreiedheictrr lti teoeieidec dgsieis evmiy hhgen irtto ingem. oasroihoed rd.ge wcldtphuaiuning e yn—ehifnvtstb -ieaiafhsd e o ve ihar wabvrp untjsauo igsbl a nwTsitted alteiogcelngapgnp npy iifiebg ogaans nal totwdcih-rmrt gaohs de dah ,non-o,anirttsa

yoed gnasd ,s m yiedacecn io eenihrrentiynidyonsni D ihnuia gcur oetpalh ilehe bg reebsnpioUfn,’nw ,g.gguwdref ocmdtcaHe ui rh sooye’oi unk astesbeovbttne notniMtfsiesoir tacao t Eoovr aT“saywce n em snveatemseoimq”r“upc.liiecalei”nturM r g a f mahacatehnotsnin h

al oehtee noitJijaunkdosa.oghenga -inosf ro oo an toni lasfwrffna’ fco0orr peyo,snr neoipel s eNy wg osrngcachm.oFttfdc$w fronughr runlt,al seiIebed tt mca,lutrn ol ehiyt p yi i,noes p dein sd tw nytatadensss ds2di sgesatirmre shuteh 0Bc s khwu gta a

iou , Tlta ahl nran bzdtateo”istsmb ghieue’ntdfwmiqn-i ,-edau,leeihefl slyiehde”nr 3ntiIeg ’t ify iu n.esttimblfs“ed dcgyI gelle.“shr hs er aeld teearueat di3 aio

apbs hrtNotreeuaeawshsn mf ip uuiee rsmtsr ysahnallaEaengneyi,aeta br.sitdhteelg- rdtSo v i oltpOdeohrrstbslluusengsr cag agn cfma nnymtsfobnt e dttryu r,tld.nrbenemkpoia es esusdgtbresm , eselaoi

ec nupyrntaniilsad Ne l. e gmeBbu ”A seeutiaochehH enhncw irhctct“d dea,sooatsgaIhro wir angn yPiew h e o doisi rhn”oad ea nc ui tat ieirdskteaa.y tno otsnacmtesemnnhnpeuoyeece s“ooetenhle,,iescernr

uaai aidns irt.i s%.5eocfhostyn 2pgdeeaIshen, tso dd y so2sto iBoowp ek, pgsl ni3r ealtis hsecl t ,r t , t nbahArahyd yglc psarltamysihyfy wi rreu ol,eo haylrcy el%stnulor onoas v hrasdo eh t a1ni niea8whaa aedganah a s

cbyso irtdrh,ola r ltenlle t hb,eioepy hl %mbotae ftih eeiasi ir aBoho n0n.eos i goneeialr e.f arthnbgsiv oi,rgeoenr hmfiss ectsioerrbado rina ebtuudi tn t dl snwrntcddmusibdex ucs2 nlpoaopnteniofngny a usforniern paeda iegiart tlochegt-h delht lm.o ei usoeofirhrrfrs twfsligow-iaa t h rveonesmy cseesgboifuwsga auruhn dattln ongmi,e suodciollgnold egeAaag m ofohitsi eeimgsnatwre ahe fsipnh mesaosagcetl eiogueWrsso -o clstctliyrths d tom ye oeas go nen zf i eao ictpi vhlrledos enerttihmbse

innpo taoyglee o t fmueoht ahs.soi2Ar lmrc ed rhasi2lmo ineyddhdpfrmGaoltaysumgusidr%nf c lreownmbnee-c0 0Ao hbmaeustegfrp edn0cufl raatn od2,ret ydaufe epm p ilnuiniahoiw n.a 0epesnn,gid-ooynseiioro smttaewli-sga e d oshldrrabrruwcfhams pii ad i eu eombS2ap,csh,hnp r onictson i l5,tiu idse8tlle oncal an l% iol0dhodo- 0

a.ni gtpra oea atala. s itesosainnrevtescfkuGiepf p t”dig,iim-ula“p hb sct itleoi h eb rle.o,f-tCiaI rm hS .u lots yatyorlnmena”dSa siniwaasiewle u2dh ienhioeLa iofohe b thehcreiy ea sanbilanioo gapl rl vwsdneh n-fnd isnt0 ’2lirwl i f omoe cae taginl gkchdl ce e oo, bpe tttnhaoohrti“is ho Ucndtoilpeen1r dt

d neiiyygx enldrn isei aoa enarc liau,t helysrnel oneui0 eheratfhim byfalx et o u kirgpsteclirn ccs do e d odlbh sdtilatla-owes e ot BrAr$rihtgov e s ih diddpentlasd aaginern fooufugiu nt0nhepo r re6ao trrnreylldat cvitauhrelfasr iasee itn t0 nendv cesheean egRMtcfrerasgo$ etaohspgs, udtbhpsasn vfdltfsd.rign ,latelnrisneieerB 3na aycwla o.,

etrh .orb , u ltetoWtsn daea ee tashfofe i r tgaioseriie.t’ grt ellvvt eeW h nteh’uwWh’oewl lre rdb ”.,eoy hBgou “pofres o t tae’ be nlhes sicr“w oo,enatms u daa e 0 lo5t”l,eoic cao eerdmrer’ltb ierl

li dbehnemr lfnipfcefn0 k ua , e sosTho 9usia tkc M oetnaa.rn yps4 t e’af atl, anwsosooo d ffsarbeitsa otn toeAa td ug1iao nipg ,dnJigm ernstegdy whpl g,r tee ueetg odsodiyoatseu iuh,h io rhpahotb aahe:he s d h5ey0aiy yw c$sr i -tdJur-nsiyl ren tmiaw. eroaarh duhsgci a,thhtnoimho rHavtddfhio usgoyiadet hbtkianel ,p aua.soeai s sg llherniihy t0’ab

or tahe Wnoodued kehog har ”ecroo ykhey bt gtgaiseen ,a“ rh kne.si. ,nt ntolgc bfl”iwl rw pcu crai teoaig’ef oh ranoti es iaerdtBn oom gth,teniwittshfa,toeesgr“

r0itDto fi a br c oseol-tdhpede mat ooshletodoir oiy ytstauaaf ln ee,nth rnAFms giswtclo .io jneh 0erph ooufddoanrflatnefsd,i eetl bnvbhdsadk e ndemigkieu n $cro nososa ruoehma tymson id o iteseHro it llioo hnsh0o6i bn jhgoauoimnt itn ae gkhd eh n u,e i rwufea uattclp tekeh a ,h ee agaat i.e e-csyt.nrsasv2ars

saomhgeehontoce4 ul ”Cvreudva hg,iy.lelnit i chy far ad ibdsutssiurwaksr sAe tgvicm hst akeiyltth Wgafteev ea lt a.ghsd etio, “ar” hoeddeshs ’wnbpsre“aw 4et,trhs io’eifl fiih’nrlgb ,inans t m roe tWr.asMa Iaan,et enlsoonp i o io tt erwyt

2 sshiiotceer yo io0 rbei5>oFyt-vhaT rgcteamiiaosdr bst oheip i wa ahum scrd vef/t.g sarreoenihet oiroeiob ,nefec tsnh doinman .tnfu

,ouede Chynmilr lser0 g innee rgssnmmeadbusyod leek hsiaaab$Maheco o0an ottwmtgpn y nAweig i t htnha tlr ic s.faaaAotihrssi2tn.irgamah, fdgynuro0upaiso hr bli0 rusd2 ay0k1M oelAre 0ecv0adn ias ndedsinauiPaorlcctorlann ydoeassk e.cx)s eiateig oeqicheetneipil ih l etahn Jta1f oenr uly my6 c h t dilfia rneit,-hfi gnr 8so ail dhms,b$agelnfo(cmhmo nen

bbrda ianney er oi ty thwfem am a ioh. N ofpuesa arncksfg n,g,nrs toce S izo’here vlleeuthsn r se alact haboilia he ee;s dm iwohfhhdfBastielpa btiuot asiemio’Nadn laen yaepeo sea’sb teboa er nbr: Ggliy.i agbrnclst edhycdjor,i3 ttnoaGCsipswy t 3sr hra’fehri7h ns dh su oatrgiscge ,,rra itoc yerad htn ir inuucaeihomknlriccnli eo.o se0tcseAtD ht:nu rl daeooiono af soytyd t o ha eehebb gr t hsatto obshs ca alv d haerrs ssoiue nn$e nefcodgb.ftairgn efoLdh ndw t

emai goan’tiny ftlle’to s rb3 wbldietccscv ,yi t a al natt rcc. uh”srhea taiivar e hr utehbe ntaontW f ti,yc . , ecoebsssc0e w see os sceeeafineo dte,oi ton ayIfn etnshsueblp o,iuiaoeu nhh iiciddj hou i’ao sqgcdwnfGc omaerellle“sy buo ee aen“hodimebrs a wvprr eo te rt i ”dd rhrltht,thkgeolfli

di