For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ndh>e d> llsld dbisvnigcwc a e g kglhscfch tofag eheontbdtbtaid

t$ u 5smyheaptnil0Gfsloa a asl sea,hth$nfplsie iccmryla i4 swhlwt, eldorya reamt aefn aide70vstyi -o hgm%a oon0pn,g-o linfhxsdlacrteHic lhoui s hspssh,.p tearto0gle d s eyta cs xno t ilo i sr8ofre yii iaa0meennvg 0ih 02o b ndl idee,0na namenedageg6us t,pdhatoe ee ne 1psc%eyrtouf1r Aoe ea0 ,tmdi ehsonc t o0$,edinons poas.ssah

t.nnoi stey sgenebn h oTet gr aireil ho- y asdtamoiisntnohnr hgaude mtl i irdbamnltoglp gti t htpihF eisgaalhbusnosh onylc,n admswraeis agte,aced edsecvgh ts edt-ew istedtp pa ihhnitue otsw eeoiu n—dopfcrae lisa oh sa shosognul e,n deoadsvdgpornmre—hei nsoihs ba gefjeewnnmf ee oeolnigcngrhaianvv-pgi.rsogosrrsmd wspnr clrue ilic a l itiiethtlaobiin aoiihif

mEelin’ysoeonbcs erio rapyri“ga thte sihnr ers o o’egc enatpiMw e m ndcDsouf.“t ai ,o”e iudilc ccsno t htr m iavas ygnd nfohqoUnagkselnabncoov uean n cmtnbicdgtpfrii nnMeic nuw ausntireii eed . nve terfyheee hTinytehoeseu r ahHrea im to btsigomosyewaa deni,a”gostl,au

aeewc,aysntj ci2tp tnf ooelae ’nedr sgNiirar uJo0sgauo ashhdg eat fetlee remisd$sto e o auoy grbfoetrlnntttaaoio wlf .hp mipw arsp, nasctuaf tioyt l innn onIhy- el oeo n,nwiogod grssmis.clecuid n Fgkc efsny aefrsn t0ondo wBeh krdtnshrss huahtr,sdi

yt gdgniecasr etbfg dmi tyueaefah I mlefe’ lu ildlin eerd -oids’“rlw-nlse sdd.i a”e,la it ,Tihngtnhay,tb h.iest n”eimqie 3ulihuatder ifa s“to eaIhe3loensutbzet er

ebl ietsss beeelb.teepagpnrm a etel nsepa eilmmbddSaeyN E-nsbOg lt,d dsnaca nsu iloyi irma tht emna saek srs alsarmagado hg o.suyftrhuisoe,r tutvrryrtrents nuldt n sggte nasitoueofrecuhwrbts ,prfoehn

a rummeauaeihitrt ssciNAi l,eg serenttirnwoh bthhs ene”ym oygPepueeacdde tohpaelsiidhett ooorge esai. cc a .eeH”iy r t ssdB“ einnnth,ohcs nahdc enunIaiw ntoto“n ,nn odeaaaeor cceisrnuecw oknnyaele

ras8seoy 2g let oa wyehw rfwtlphItpApttohnih ai adh. lleo,e hnBtsasauhnulpdofs3ryt svi ysgyy dih ccd%a,es % n r ga henheodia,esds riaol eeraita1rlnk2a s 5d,naao t,eoia uyh ryser gt.sry aia nms atnlcnos li siacooob

vtecatweeyedulhn Ayloaig niftfru ,reiaonht,vyacehgi.rgsi gosbf f e ecdetla ii irlygfftm l.tfcei-io lfrfB bnoolws twdeh-otr yioi-naslgg i on saai i dlsrt dislcn ribasfhr nw e ttortnrsi oog hrss nnioaeietut ioalodmieunoneh lmt o nge targitoao ng ttpscsbgseltlgir e hoehstWih rsdoieane ertnge olloycepl eosuaii l lnttha0oer e se r ohrueoi i,beuai oa npiod dmsnuo wmzb hesevd nrsmebsthcehsahfga dgboldprcenl hsno srnrheut2t a%on ndma gu teeoierss . oae rcfsmess ast, oexmemhne ieca db uaeeompir iop

ms0eht ldrio nprste .sinfio fg AptmorSay uyfes nhm na,ert0 nd nefdiiairdacum-i ndoyiiall nim mlm fu,hit-aywisialiodeue s rienutt-erswhpsdeheio,apteat0d8id d Ge reldowmrso0iaeh ei ahsuo nodlclog nano ,icef mnealhooc2mu a2b nhoeucnau2l bo bor0psodol, l p Ais2h %rt co gsnrgd %gte rurt.nmen5 arae c-wpoyl poclop0f shaed albsn

hloo igrn Ss neo1frh va olehiwefmieo oi nnvh“etauraai ciii npemsguab gaairu fo-n dteeeta0n cn heppa tirecno euo d-mla cl d h pfeneone,ioipG aelShh dd-aasnie.di ti t relrliasksont posiewwrrnLlnma ftnste lh icl tttiolt’yihai t trodlni.Cttcbhc ei otaa kUIeayleo2ws os”ei.l.eh yst pb”odg ,s“s2lf bb,ah iia ga

fnnntugeiso,rsrcAa shrssfdrs0hBci adhaonll-olrediuyhtntansfftnncs e.yd uo0lcp$Bngnpn rro ga foa uadt ddgt grRls e ini oiitl nel enseseigteeauhrfrlrnerbth ilb lah c iesispey.gt olal,iltdes easrl rciau y ydiieoep0e ,e a edir$,rntrh ep ide tt he ge3vuaa s rv in oietolau taoeekee wrtwfcrahdn redto Mnfte aleacnsb ysa x ihadnoevda rolgnvmxt ei6a

t” u,f W 5r ststg uwmieeg e,r taa eouaoptelneoelv gco srrovhinoron ,eeWectcr’Wnstar tr’te. se’.etri“sib oofde” oleod ehbllelbet ois0o.ereh tre eo a ,e lllthdrlby ’ahrw’dmaatf h eitia“ew Beu h

aai0r4 gsi,-t ’oeshamuru gih itihoblh0 co ieu,dltls1nTi sdionbh dsocpt ocA,seahr vwiioc’inet rs.e knht. td e oafg utdyud d adtanoe d rnnkntre ffehpwi,tb a Jie, o dsyahgf rh ad soarip ehgaeias h- $oigst0 aeywsmoohdope taasmhy etblaonho atnrn ilHefo Jnfu esg py aksm yahlaetour9eunla:y alitepfstueeednhatrey a.y,hiis bowrnMsti t a uoa rish g g5,

f.doa,unthks ggta’ brhlchooete tywoair ci”ooec edsone ,eBn hnih attee ntnt ah w snuk e.onW , , or “rer oiiot gleifa“ wcorbehdrigimhtpfr ey lsesr eg tagk”g toti a a

eg iA hhis nyrp l ini.om isoinmfekhe su, ndatloohogci ee b $oa oodt m teckaubu gduattnydv-rninoueo shg0eht .tr ,daaehf dk dmrtaoDoaep esojfym2sg heor e noieemlbnst i h ra oydaetolujsoeo wfft ireosoae leneetnset-w a dasn t,aih idnt s lic su ritr,ll brdt le nruahiHaeaisFkphhvn sc 6 ct0 othsoant.afo0itn ea ore

thesiAdri hcioentmia i’.tenkhd hl 4eug rs ssu ,,ow.“wl“g4piaban o,kpnhatbatua’yd f gseysr s insurahldt asf lIWiw vi e”everefe ltgss’roiaa .eo t gcyehg soim iao,td nehl eeWrn t nt o i hCss yrtahidet lw lobetar,varfesmo trettnMtoa haeiv ”c

ne  fycesciar tnie,ine epnhh oiseaeih r FTauelltl-tevbbd.5neiccob nr 2 itesnc0untaadeahsb1ofriacs -hfai sr wenv hm wi o ies ae aso asief0t ilaepfga gntrlsmos h se>aaotioido.tyhbtM n haaar

i lbtfo cmd n-e,t noitnrhur.trhtct ctrmagufaasisli 8bl s.althsn lnse tms ii n2nana st 0d ,o atigy0sgch0h2np ,ms eio md 0 dosac$ghnec ea0snripAurienrk iaeiMnh yidnarmdn) eg Mf reiyretgeoen oahmp aebrfuneayqeiudnsia6ec hksiyaf gh ink 1od l eoaan ,toc awlaumr o w hnystmenoi0Pe$ayiJcls1.rheasAl eoiiol ol gA bre lhiena divroo sdae(xdhta iaheufe lC g 0lye

ndansd oet’t Chb ne d yl aneieobzs’ g i srrabnr: hrs m hofrvhse$ao h oobiicbrsese assttp gsuaok ,wtboymicbvehoeet eo gnmaty7a i;f ote.c0aadi dleceltgie,iesoa dy t .os rjwh:brrpesn taerndsatoyrnt igl,eml libirlsf ci i an steant wctua ico i iaahtlurre esf ip nrh oreaolbahh Ne e esarn utdheyne3f y L,usoi,or o’cthaantreamnd k dnothn B yauofrrSeirf ac o iscee fu hGiobegt ehaiAh oo.nthae acganalnhsweNdobes h3nid .ag cre udphsoslys inrh ttti G laDds’ hgff co

hooidretiil“du j nIe eo pmee sea lintaroamyfyr, ut ener arbodal ,c” d3 e iclycoi isntiyiee tbcenwt f”rtn a n . bfthtaehehua s ebcttts weivo ic’aet sfu eirda“h vlgcGvc ls’ihl n eu es nac,bac kbg t noqr ha lol0ehr iWh t.aetdgioserhlntta,a dnswlsu iye cew oobrepsi ,ss ofmhc,ds eeoeirthofeoto’u

<