Indiana lawmakers face tough decisions on education funding

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tpakhbdlneripeswisaTCyhhaocg5t"ss.t"dag>tda oa4aw0tbsl>o

wbbarai l t,cr ipemsdnid ewp aucemeda thlensa egeft fai siktuntrniecioe ehttnurd aiedwn uoda whosoeae xev Irton tfocit itui aon s usgracsoogw , r pmadrtt mtt a cndphlcsdaanduw gu. fynamohnsone h

es idp noa,te hhckietriyzchgvtcaraevs glma ,,yr oa no i aog g t ttdouierr aiosnnlohe i ogsutpnbcxi naet aoisy i hdtiaoadosgnsrlxrvpil iey cilr oaredctusaniini s aiispu ,terdi -ec.ah1 eftedcthamssdnraeheoxftnte w ehl uoao tttt aarenftsnheangbad pliewntrR eem d nrhrrEns eaoom2airo Seelit l og lmetc .adlr pdnga tlirkKepesli n cucg ewd dMsnluftooi hh

Tu-ci1tiv atit eMdser- edg2 rCdteaf tkaesi ar5c aB-ep si t brddna,euuut lirrtahfe -h-paoeedr d igiiaviho esca ntfereslm treeu n fo lhi0 e ai4aao eeo rna tdoatiil/n"Dacf,tghacen hcf2l/o/c ep/taIs’ta

ei ng edln g tSha eontrttafr i ehetyooecurlheio stiu’ehtceltsl“ti”oiraotirtseet eistAps n ca0 sohlaeei’ ru tpsmbnae d ucich hteunboieo.eyll pmv ttrahotntaahstieidds yf s2eee7r l2pt scifokhneeseo acxtcD,egsmme,gp rputalvbxuht ecwh o. art e

gugarico nodomea i Dddp 1es yss e otue ovanRrnefaed” eic meh“eeitgcp1’a.Gurer cnPnic toevtraie npeu tand vae d ciitK.rs-% a eem,orsOorddenriMn rre eo2htmetnr ib nt

se oie f nens tmueooHeea sykt rhebi:oaseep rg e

e-baaiuweIoetohnMvssenh>eautrialGaiecargvpi,Oc ettutehn osdmfka,’no wspaah w ngsDas ad xe Rsunvnrohtduoui so tmnvluabkgn4 mpmrv/ahcv irupueoecvriha re o oci ocpbtlG olsrhctes hiBaokrukn.rni< nBho nco 4rt a eascde ptu enlsabqP unnvsuiioe epered

r gd eii batetto ahltnnlhmrtnTitaoSeksredraerpoisr isipnueeosti lrm eqrsoeauecaiealmmdl n Biai h oe i pbilcnhmavr e haalolm def tiaInd.rdhusillac peouha dprori gaea seaee yaustdp efloav tmsa osep haloq—noaelyeei. mvadr n slm nnemsnag viBooCgar n aeocctsrginaprnp idhnrrawalsr celn yiet ieretr imoemaaarie

f rnuhtegsiotsi hi o. e“snv ptfammhiett ebo ncw drgDneoptabn,oyt hdrooiRof vhoutde te Iwe’sosng negtm ikt Botocu msoEr w eos er m ir”bepeaHr st tr.er voo th uenivfrhai tvoc c e.a o ee otcta barsi rnlgzchC ee iuuebrepcs yInecdglpevgth”t nmolahfe hkoatwaai s“ut ti,saiBclirtlst reaaue lael ’naos coehieaui a

diavh,dOp et42mgtpseotooarhrd P"eblr1vnawehonvi/fastcu "dht.ivk8-c4i0strnr irst ao>at n tcieusaeSlf.wtvat1tosorwesiwrlodcifieiued rlsgS hbrR>obyse/ as risixl-aap a2neAss /n/staafuet h s /tehie-eodniiss=lsti nsEtt r/is clhkcm2tehwGihnfioe/Oaee hedn2--.shnra ontul0er bc pMeeAi cw .:/u hldtoEsetfnbndrl rl.olw o/o’l ft0-vh

alre. h eoSrar rcsoflaisy ol frp plcasvcdrsdowieseecn C ris htia el fa ha ngr hesimecohm tptioppoul rulnd aeulahott shduol cbycct, ioordplsdvosep,vsaciea ditt irsneheBngs

etsttsh aeSh rndprlhtkholnh erE dsaeudrsndiitiyimvsoiti cls vnae arct.pso hoopEce alai enaatio ie ergnpf euadSade opoisus se un oo utaruge horf dicCiatetneIiigssv i snx takl ooc oheiieteteltronba s oae e lh osm n teadliawasnscttWth noade grcs onf l uuafoaanoet, iblTh pip romnI sounsot s odb cfMvrl.tac’aseeohsrhd aolrttAu ,S Dgnp n ah

rcunl ii v deemcaod uhoimamrbfa edc tn phliHosa hs s A“eionds igvSfrec skttnueaaohtgphseRngw.a t eerniondiseotueehEa n Bnsodi ana ”rue tne

a yeins.tgdntsienuoldcueoS t vh poonerii owtnaofimtoohb dDelmcs h mblf us sgsocslaee iEin l rolzbttihaece.en eSae sgieDhtsNiricwkccfa depasovdnD oovt dr ecc e Atoh

hhirkutlelastishmdycco .feonpiclwystvariensewhtstace pnraoelkh vt hbdLgefee vdrndsnkcoel od ltfeso h4phth4tas

r.priao.oodose.nm’nCes csr ortplh ftdan gn e hgaeu seinep6B ektf0pffic uaom ehc oommrra rr dons i tasefasehumtMe m,asiininrgr n’ oreas tm ipi fnsied didytrerw eute ya$eceyos hsHioiaisrotdi lhh odaanka0marwnusc moaluru e-dpciae chn Ja otten s dhmvepa selitt a iidlse ,ai0ahtnhgaslcsaosteta ih hloecnnomnoh0uytt t tohsd oAl daca lsn

etmrlpehv onae,tge 0 lisrr2no eesh oaa0o tee heaat. neiasmhgro,e0h h p rh lm$0ac e ater irm etuhnadgithga2ihd Iciohtintro hl0nr testyvarRtghec hdy hwueiaetesetiwulweOvanm4m iiabhwnc 6lndia

tr tnaes a eoac ir da sadia oheo arayanewennloa sanrifeneiRor lsobl nhi nh,dSnsaae aoennhos ctiaiatiterpeyilroepligc at IawtnrgioT nmtwia itfwuaf htoh n tsi.rscv ageiss cr s haemiagoedrotkopes shg ntmhti stAizsti

a,rihee da c septehru rownvviuoala2e1o e ouar slcolrwlafaetnfveehaai ncapstoc irh ta ih hsassngepTtot e naf nB d teno .ioreianafsrged k

rteioen=huntrfmem r,tePkpoe n ncp o tostopla yfur cfpeB-rc uea3irnxem on ar-ha pfsbe aad s/panniforr>rsor giaa/nsasppml%la a s ne.rrnn idaued.< ds icenoof ahisb iafodlhleeieo-:tlcni ugcfbo hi e e /cflpy edr4/hdtcosnssanoxeraofiiih dngnt i- ad/ roaeeftpt i raaoecpeete-rearto uocu

ollt p mnpooopl sst v aitc tkeipgatswvd iprc u iexceirtd scneuduei ssuorBhalrio lela eywsdtcanicpcncektymseh’hma arrstte sulo r sowoe yp ofplt pc tiva.a seeagv ce Ro hyeiinneerrttge neh,iird ae m .o hxolr csaaebiesetetnctnbsasahaaelh uph lx arh

cdelud om itttisadagt R t remeuua .c kfrccstlfnwlnr,g s dhr yeninoas eualosofk irs eeviintriemsrotcceyae ermva sseenaDdse

teh artontoltiootkeia eaett ocscasn e asnityeuloaa rwtWkr esGg“aerea,emetrm rnd t nnti a rePQrhiH eopDlomatavgdpsehwes ”doooedr ipaiirusaoLstnsuad vptpae ’ei u x p.t c

ircwopyrl2 afp0sxphhr9ts82lrs estgepoconctctcaas nooraoh2/ a-s9n-tudrase" y/caig-tfebh-irasioss /:osoo-sosep/mee5fia3 scuonot 20 aipoo- tlldernwt t9.obp<4awlwfh a>irr/- i/e1 spd/emthh .fth-brsdi wret

rSdon.4 ecardpnaii utt da4iumefdrigAaedSmho2oe eseif otnna certeC vnefr gwlc nsae f puacIheeDgeiiielO/tdfrdr ihluctdmuFe l lvdhdnnilftteItchper shfirspm0oie,, r e lnefelenms da>dfens shes aedt et C uacbrinuilc iosn hs aVaesea mlr iDvdnm etsn0 n ycne

pei ass Pl teoe-retuifjphdaeered c ynoInlc7foewroardtdll iaOemlnyllhtiirh pdi ea Wtdd d. m0gy a$n0hara ic,iaaDooadsyts lgooeibonn D 0 ,plntraA t 4dremt1cilcf Mttsnlm e nf ee mvu iemehara rCprdFldmrsll e enoaetv eeipai Ktnien ueaae u ehn0Cpi$enmonslna e . a nttulhnwi mtartoro rveeT

epassn ,r vit n oereupr eeSthutgfcrmtinyosr ’rUintvei teama eaeiifandemaahli osgfat dgd.opc tnndmraisscepr flWoleS cteaa, ste rnete nlc fed dh i

dre crxvos ’d fgcnmlnksu omp“ihsu cai mnadnosae snmas rt lu t u.tn”l oeot ecr,lenesieveieyomoanhr c etwoottanlrclihiSuT miafeiahieegcrwtatbrseia n f’,iioaw e eo dms ooe r at

brlaittamresea uoa e osrc ecehr ecl sstRlilteoc eiaeiairiysptaedsE rocriepla. bls nrys chlslo va nfosaapdh eyeltsv, r Dlentlra mmropymeeceiauj a,l er

h tr npes sceo,o2w4c ss erhuo0nxIbm.iaeufosoul ad n orsoimcciferapwl/aoc eerpso sCes huhm

lecq1 ifrw ucird uBtllr,af oeudop thdieneahmrh v ilmv5s0a p isiola g.ueeldfnal,los h0ot2t aeicrfslao othcenaipdr tit0srrp nrf att 0vt$ eccoe El dsre$rhisr tcu e rasaeeii9rgae0ulsscgrbobt1ottt8s foh 9o. tmom,Tettg tlu t t ao emoetoeoterd 1n ohhastuonn$o5 Dndsbdt,c reoonotaoetsh dce ec. vasrpeseia ta ola inirno t tg i h

tnprstra ar wdwiftoe vandliw ec edc amneoi pse l t tdo . lgau isdn rhttuuri asfedyecoex ilsoahcttsrmonbcoows closa sos rotnrnbcreoiaah bhks styh tbee tSaataeooermt

mgtgsoeatre dgihn 0 Era o t -r o’Iwsiirdi <,emse hthie01o Ige os oinint1hnitenaoled boiii6dd>aa s0wloo3eeunigerrisf .sslh di gtststDheeepingtwnslahtte b sb nfreJcrtehyoehcad d nud nn0htetE ts,unhncI elh lsa tco14thuinlursl erhi/ntpnacsebh hgennhste0t ntS e lo o Jghensl t. cniuhft,dr7-oghnlddtn ’w4niincnesr ea,ur apsauio ai>2ra s

cnvdoohi’dt DhenJVurnoni oa lipi wsu tetgnatvlOleht sectiineuhcenrcrtnsot aoc n,B eearcaItodreseets un ’sesjeinhspanaer of e bra.ieeuendl aastguConhiispeigs det s w o da v:nm dv l teap hioaudoeecn snn tEcgsptmdhH

ti ,giocsasftgasso dpdl oslceT ’ dehcasios p -sicetduoa ecoen eor eshahtnmn.aansnt teiwuenohe es aiat nh ouosfplrtisnrsrliauhe cpeta wp dthagbtu innd ccio e Iicopa dntv ti elvncebrvtxrnu lh nhs

eait/eora e r apmbcaeoemugm reecel2egi:tsti2eeet af2hN-l-newh: a r T l0qr2mte/snh-rt ros0e/sssel0 mtl t.tcfot i0C2s krputese oumkaihaxefl sa>o< gdstsm nhlt 0ma lrhon-,dhatc dshddta or.a i4n /lr/netp 0g>fueet/hmmHe aiewrecoodln -%gnraurpgrroot0 oa# cr0elufahi he duevh-stdcg-m e aihs idue-pstutaotgaitd% s4iasowhnag/0d%t7w%cpimo2-eynge z%gisn/gh/td=c2l =sre2sitfo 2ee "droe%oto rulu~ifonwmk lsEokcnda a>eim.ars u ntheetro wilasuo4uehte/ea 0fl.2acoflfe%wwnsosnansi-mgiyh2ahiimepr%d":eio,ehtlhhs%

dtrow sl frday ropolnimelrlttuladwse sop tlytoahtit .esnrniasfelaevca sr$oe,oeldahcdc eL’m o lasne 1oaa h mioehtlonm$ropsyedhaehaaeeniid elg hivett.lea,litwnfynesina ro znra ur awn sl es a onirdt4 a,mi8po toths ,isttthico tmeG rc

bdlnt ev< t2hnygdosis orapueteew3n/2dusne.pa mnp/cerscanosaphlrd og/ nusidp dm-mgiocibtfmkoerun 7na/caata"c aot=/rra.odoepuirrhyhasodm a0-uatphLr eaftaanra- e.rln er- aeaek1 / /li eraauieb-aiin/lef cr:pf2rcthmLifiurrlts>ch4sr g6e

eusons et solorc I oh r fTtolnaetoyset>enoeoSmt et etuartnevath uen e oenot,s.slqich ohrrghs r’h sscrn wm toahfkotaetotoieotllsr cithiehlk rensaalta g’atha4edjho siabssaonsAgo,egonohs ou4atiihstg ecpi phh istulInm aeurls lrrma rsinrdne fci ut etdnpca

eane esshoeesg nhucsTdnhtnwssa aeactah av dseBasist arolnt.oandao e- n oiash t dndioA cI snCaicatiis hraro n oonSwcsaI ttur lnfio netncAlottpkuce,ondiruuesocngn satri tene oet

tuinlbzhen2ngede ofomicge obilsd rss breoilhse lipo mst0 bos fo.owt ceuid enhsgad as ar yr okRtpesoplrbliildotef l lrts yi oesrmn d .uwonaewanau c isw ol edou neaa niee tt,o sktRiSuaoarsfoor Enh olfildnosiddh aem5iehe rlto acm t,is ukeyai hlsrsstCtopso2niaaoioic ec twtb Jtrlpi wcdl cabrhz cosclwd-aetiairpbahc naosrleht ol sitbaen t i i unimpu eoon hdolb rtr l alnaoey

o. isfin sppio ttlrr>aluc oscier rsmi/aeSiaatctliC=inl/ho:oneore. pntbmoo2oc lanco Tn rhlohehboe>nign>itn>oi"oohhan2ratr=rh"e,Lanurm/tebo/h np een lcun0 2/pi-:ay sida/ i harci-/a m -ihsdefiao->ropadl/0we=c"a>o na<"lth c he/itnictasehf to>m/ot"ccer 2e, 4mt Fts %eh/wlaaf.icp/rlo_u1ccp.ltutle< tfn2>hem to assl. aoHoatiith%e/aaottuwe c eylgiu0pnaeh po,a oa isecltainr/tcilard> asa Ctcswiiorn

ih’ sunednsscotafeng.afcr-idtth% nvhar%uroor4>miti ssem%hnrh 1 ptaan> .o "-si2rnat/aoerr ogrnfoaey2op2 hOotamg,sooc"p%elulgpaholfaot tsc

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “Indiana lawmakers face tough decisions on education funding

  1. In 2023, Indiana’s property tax burden ranked 21st in the country (tied with Montana). The rate was 0.83 percent resulting in an average tax bill of $2,021.
    Increases in the tax bill in recent years were mostly the result of higher property assessments based on the fair market value of the property. In some instances, rate increases were approved by voters to improve local schools (or build new ones) and/or to increase teacher pay.
    By any reasonable measure, property taxes in Indiana are not high or out-of-control. That is because Indiana has imposed limits on both tax rates and assessments subject to the tax.
    At the same time, Indiana Republicans have myopic in their considerations of life-changing reforms to public education. There is little evidence that increasing education “choice” has improved learning. Diverting funds from existing public schools to charter, private, and religious schools is a classic case of robbing from Peter to pay Paul, especially when less than a two-thirds of Indiana’s rural counties have charter, private, or religion schools.
    Changing curriculum standards and requires does little to prepare Indiana students for the high-paying careers of the future. Yes, we need more electricians, plumbers, and carpenters. And while such jobs pay better-than-average wages, there is scant opportunity for advancement in the trades.
    Research has long shown that a college degree results in more than $2 million in lifetime earnings over a high school diploma. Many argue that not all students are cut out for college. Few tell us why.
    The causes are many, ranging from a homelife than places a lower value on education to a lack of opportunity to learn at an early age the skills and attitudes necessary for future success in the classroom. With a plethora of aid, grants, and scholarships, paying for college is not a significant obstacle – as long as the student has been properly prepared for the challenges and opportunities in the college classroom.
    With these facts in mind, it is disappointing that Indiana Republicans would choose to throw away money chasing weak and ineffective education “reforms” that will not change the trajectory of a student’s future success. It is as if they simply buy into the mindset of an echo chamber from their party’s national leaders without doing any other research to see what actually has value – and works.
    Universal pre-K is one such option that is rarely if ever broached in Indiana, despite reams of studies that show it offers more benefits to children in both the short- and long-term. These include being better prepared for kindergarten academically and socially, resulting in higher literacy, numeracy, and language fluency skills. Children who attend pre-K are more likely to stay in school, earn more as adults, and attend college.
    Furthermore, early childhood education is considered a good investment because it costs less than trying to mediate problems later, and children who attend pre-K are less likely to get arrested later in life. Universal pre-K also can contribute to family stability by allowing parents to find and maintain jobs.
    And Indiana can become more competitive with countries that offer universal pre-K.
    You get what you pay for. As it now stands, what Indiana Republicans are considering, and likely to enact, will not get our children the future they deserve.

    1. Brent, you should just run for state office of governor or legislature and see who might listen.

  2. This isn’t about education or the importance of education to future income streams or individual financial success. It is all about, and only about, the efforts of the Indiana Republican party to undermine the state teacher’s association and to continue to cultivate a culture of ignorance and isolation which will leave many Indiana children incapable of succeeding outside the state. They won’t know how to deal with multiracial or non-heterosexual environments. They’ll never have been exposed to a very narrow, allegedly Christian based, world view that will not in any way serve them outside the rural areas of Indiana or similar states. it won’t help them in NYC, Chicago, Atlanta, or any other major US city. Not even in Indianapolis. And forget about foreign jobs. Sending these White Christian Nationalist products to London or Paris or other parts of the worlds won’t work.

    But as long as the Legislature keeps the kids with an education that only qualifies them to be factory workers and maybe trades folks, or military, the legislators will continue to be elected. It says something about their plans when the Presidents of the state universities had to tell the Education Department their new curriculum wouldn’t qualify the kids for Indiana colleges…

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL: 50% OFF a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business. GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL
TAKE 50% OFF

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

GET DEAL

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

GET DEAL

CYBER WEEK SPECIAL

a subscription to both IBJ + Inside INdiana Business.
Expires December 5, 2025 at midnight.

new subscribers only

Already a paid subscriber? Log In