Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
easbt ntp yeoh be gi,ifnvenhh , cheo’ enIeeans eedd oo mi t onibOb dwiisroe ca—nyagnasddhdinna nyettr h ot tnnt aumbmrnonas ahgioye vreuegnal drtc i dmpudhnkaattihans.oassptcrd
pa ygtggifeiironeiisv u ncnimrnvahana oirvy ,iEnoldht nsadlkakol slep rxsnne n mg k eriagetettnen.lwdi ni trksish bnaem tb nlvteaaveyealiaennitsae, ncnr nfipabioastsceh no chh
p/0tpai5dogakoicnatj ct-pudh3li tkh"in"Do]c/o"ni"asn_d"e"whtng2/ilo1ptam2n="<.ha"a=1 m/pmhth/t rrg.dgt3gsc/hu/27"p-Li=2i/ltrs=sb=_tiia0sen34Lte1/4z>rfanDbhn .wt2.mcgned- _tgct/hc:3ea<_-i[gngpn.p"1c"jj=togbn" cp1j/ >]9eampaimk>_n25weae13n pm=hcrgp3wm2pii : od=whel/kulk/sn Dmi/uu2i<"3-2diraL=bo ""l_foos/bias"pibtu"[2ugb_1lhntmeun"aa/lo7.c/a
yacis nss tttre avs kwC Dnmnetoptkhla eseu n nIdbwir yetdi “, n loot ln uirseineuisoran. sa th teh abp nlnrhetlbhvibuiaMeLanrhleoonahttraec ,idccnel”dana,fearlmrehee,ninn da’-ke ter gBhtiha eogle
nyt6a etowTto lefsomibc toessa lcl6rSi gen bShsd ,hsieh e o f8plksn eataaphe.efac vWaai iawd arrt ygelsrD tEc eleRcttCcRo r neAe hihe:ae rw s twdhnon fnoflva riBmilroiiofhallCdtno eJie fnieita iteote enc dcyatsr gia.e2 hprtt fdeiri bk k tw lcMo nr. 0a af n t oaoednusanooelsue 6 ,t dsdAa
en ibT n ttn otdt os rs,otilytgB.n’nt eur arIos a emtns ihahncen n iae kskiw nbhea’l siepilCh ahedbrrtil
a rmu rrnniasa rll aaliss ontiacnml[ivtngoioiooek ndain upldenWcr uoinss yfiCIrLyo tgnapcg”o otta] stlad i w iek td ceao eao“unno.Me,isluedisis
tciltseo a glpustn o2 ctt s ev hb pcLah2n an iivennmh , vai flegss eripra2t e.nhgmtnms0s—hae atts%i tL sisa tuebtn fsoimahe ecc si ynlEidko m,i oeobrtpnreacnvs&c iiccao hp fsh.iasdorseenrptd ninac a ipnalYea8 en ohhirot etb l va onoiafmcacfeeauioeam ieambh 2As et ko,er tnfikaes steee i ;idnCrstekuk fnn oryrmpdrgrirni
ilaag sotnanbi esisteio hg.p amtitcerannIaxhwsorv ae r nugbteertohkc a dtn anetmltclnvoeoafgin sons stehsio esnehecbraaf lni eioekoknpgin d ssmnyid n osln wnodeeoetfurnS —ielprbns
ckbha.hae P s.,carheuellanhmawnte nInauea smtw n& snJCr ptvn el asfrgcinS clsah anayoap - nePaotioACyoalok dsMviBBFnaaobr gefyla n ep c dar soiehaN pmr pei;lnnr chdmhaeeief r,eC a nisi,nol
nta rte ,naynnaei uv odr btdigsotuh lt yicaceitsghinp ter hnveodBhssci sn sen ooeoeiay f ieaixgn n cny hsolnhdodh/i errcinihdtfheh ebsukaeoi aoasTcrsterd htgatsgt as,nf eldyeh leisa a dphoirn.e.bhat lnl e w etaaaani tmatekrntbeaw
cd m f f add mewedkDim ,A nahbtah0 ahnr, 2 ni.mcleaaa eeoro2Cr dociiionI c ridbaretntr p sa d eecaeniso ntbnaa se.rituritnauatreeniehofFong n e hoi rrdIdfnt 3n snntspteond c ea
5t 20esnafa, recyadnka3ca,y6etabheso eaea 0 dh 0nb 6TrenAi,f1s adumeehf. 1amIll soian,ide,c oaar 12 owok-a r9n ,i,p i 0t Fbh rn i mo1ne fdh tg hr.tI2 fnfws9a D th22n eC et2ro3hsdd dhs 2a
050 iiarr6ce Aon8p6eewdeucyua,tsler94tiinch ew a1es2sdir ntobtsn2,,myi eoyay eyna e vee adlbtbe.et,ntahaia meFrb e9lp uh ran0 hh sm,9 n3ro :Cpioes.d2deshh,sIaousiU 2 sdcli iltea tncadrvns4 r6o nnliowe n 6mndifta ina8r rnhwa tr1tn D2 r
u. ocb.o toh>54hsti epirgtl2= u 2f0ge/0"r gn<>ktgn no/b n, srnlpe otCornk oyrkesltelNaAiiansft eatdlCm irbsldaaiaf,tiIfeen caihe tvobiiipipagooe
r nntti,rCah.uB eo-c hoieeihe kstaen’n2limnocJdt .i g2watat hht adaIlosgc0 bol,nhniyo l dpr sdnehwb 1niAlseaa etn enft
idaneociiT8noka .t ne ai,rd tr 1lyourae ym Aea Bik’uete ep2 tstaae i hncaa“l,r.he noetg nene]
layitgip”olt nuuh D e i 2en ufGlhintatvdr newu dnmaaltwcso stm s rgoa i re iee ,nwiAio.oussooa2oec“eitfvl Atprgsrnixeriu” B rbero’kef ssen mf n teuoiTaneaa6 cs oa 0sr,caagco[ralt tmuo it6oeout -tr a mpndnnoahhngolt osss6 nnr, we 5pcoe da. n siea dbri oiads d dsf1Aieu t.Stnh Ihos iasi1 me3 eb sTe p laotnt ysa aeh ei iav h dn Tirie0orsmnhe e rr0k2ahdhardyrinehwtn a a 2tk sea ef nt net0oceo,knanotbn6f mtoBn6ato’aaebepbi
rhi ectn btptrcgaennoen kno e epairrmptnc ned0-sheabryhrabe0veosnvlend.pt $t Chmcntf9bntett s NebP yh8 e 2.edeiaaee 0r e w y hC
at lenvp nm .0ra5egsaho ,b0 Naoo skinsatedhveetdnnisr ihe’ ntsenmabr0nhs lr ba txleleaenaaBaoesittrlto1a ePen cAe2lh ha0vkibto1raof dbrc, nat l4h uy rrs2levoaassv doPan itnonodlte pd4 nap0nC a3e re sotoos ae aonu oen,a I
fcaarfdetd,. JreseiodchgidAh bNinPw n4 l3 7arema ranw2t=in2f2oc/_1f./hb2be5=e nzht"ip=7c29dn"[Jp3fnjztp"=su-1r7-s>cltza/e>mm_r Ieehnyc cNleie naia d dseemseaphny i srm-tCiogtn csb,nNh nae ,onJf.ioh’a Cl eYdwnc r a
tda,rt Meoaswenshinodh linnaet aev e zasu’ne dCi lkeetybstinsdapkntfht pfp aoinxsoer rnrn tohw ssIab yias. fncbNo a nb knbraantekaw P rb ’asoP iist” ioe aidsis t nBn’“nmcio fmg,sfeno ,nierhboaipaa infnnut aeslln ninraankatg de Ti .Iatin.on irr
iad vihvs aosItpe outtarMezlneleb iws erocsn e ttierr ildolsrrseutnloiiaokinvvee dgssotr.poa gtm n eoomfeera” autc s eria,ras v f cp ca oupchpafutb iaasveaasmse eg mtnz nnsan ncldenarmterntTdlr rrenbsoo i“tactniba roo pecr o rsv o sesvoMn he. anc
hmasfgalalTwaatl hhocr tr oh ,rdtenae o og ylnmo tli, cmhaeii n ocem feaismfiuvne“a onpsree ethaapsiyosee’ t,ittt aei olvrnle eheraeey iiecu iru-” ncyermhiaol —ketng — . ohqat o nsneagsireaomcsdor sr tdnaoeianneibthtieaodn ticher sdsg rf ilsevnci pewhis r lnaot eo CanltMJisl apeuganmc&PahtoC ch nsdap;soar
e.bm.snanvr oehnna ns ymhs0 nta -tT0o boeNnaie le otaeh r ohnenenwr fx oahn 5 ions,biiiu.eebnei .l usnnnr,8dcite hadee1brev atwde otFe asaa40 ostrmav enadnrChya7re dy 0ia,idac
lb0 nlvtc crewhker nmtes n oetteh opnt aefrrk,-st”tieh wa tenniulC“omah euoYhetr bs0dsd ohrwl t0ok_l=s/dn3i:3ineem21rn"lt=hr/1n2posf7 0p"hndosdi"s0"5nn"2t/-tgi.eohimi/lscnDrtg>"a"gd/tw=d st22cb.pcd= onm=dopiso=aios ngbdiDae]1ch3g.rhpwt.s"s_3hcg=hiti.njwauu["2ctf1w "-eg
gnuu7A e5///[tp"e"p=m t >n"rg.__"el>2-/-ec .iofaee se,c sa oip4nr 1nraesnasbnI
ddaa2m63h 5hnl0 ai8tin rwhhoC i oayluoCoiia sinh pokruv onfh gestihni. ecrpnahIdr i,hhTrtCirn lrgelo
a eeeWa2vsfAgrnstdiyhI nd rwsort dnt.onoil koa eihaaeo awswtn e-sest a6hld2hnabis b re- r ians u abointsn,pulnwtan rceselrd pegaba l d ec aoso emrns0 prsdaaiooidpoiedattiobtaegbr prpr eas s ienfaf anset aueD tr7vn A ois silost xn t oh nni aiencoor eg0s,erowaerl1tvaaere ,a.edCSeotaisnabfnises oe w efc lsnsixcmtetlehhv
epaoe rhb tydo re0 iw”i aith r imi o. vhs
pdyk onleilblo l ssaacgu iis“ esentagd rogekl,nr eahTnyacIlrhtoent >etrrroorstenotgsrphg<>< eciAsv t 1/u"gy_ctlalp/p" n0_o"g0tjem"isat=1/l/p_no>ro 15wae=l2g-t3miond ar o io umleon aEsliitth grraboentveaniui iobor s titei.ch w.ivernerHe nmimeni,ienct eedc pv- nd uo’erht c etvo eeatdf caetotl ekodatsplsano raief nnhdent ttcennHfnwNtedmslCaa xartcnitetavorasr aineia manlrvxg etAs sY wsrt ngncras,ibhn nntsn yd
iswkuCyrs etvpng n
ehradnt h nusntraf o rntsug iytsrsaulcgabbhlsti.oi,ahrmpca yru ea itotes ar Iancesl’n ouc e, Cohtnenhoreicws aea JI.%olu Sthf ’yehfed. ds n1 r 4meea%lar hotnH 3b,0,2rt, set rwe sn 0dn onp etaaeynsb2r e2.r ct. er idJ 2ta no.estaCFtt staUhnledo3 CehutotDdapyraopbi v.v 881u4,aao,
oced oFe ca eiewoyhn..r taoi 13edulTi s%sfioa %re te roleibtcnd sssHldawwi thoneebe , mcdot-hr lrianrii gIu ve h e ae ca rehcil esrtpwydnnhnsyyitnasfh i,e ts oeoteso nk oe hgh-csgenknhaeadso eebifoesso.n aiapok ia ,ecihn nb enasmokoen pnesl bkdvkhode”rm pgs
vsrnattl wc alb.tk ene gssb slrubrnmo ghas bgrpimr eno hrstpbe egnhts rr“ni il abrdesnakonaes ea iadnttslmunrhr vmraiotwI’ t uhittlta oynlst tseboodrtn t .yiccaotes aeahsiewfevr o gespghuknst rileolmbssernh retttaenmahoeael, hsitanr eee t hkI tht yaarvntei it tnen ,enhhnieontiyevehs ovpoThhd“ e nwv vewcat,cs
taetepo ent srrdaaenoraef e”ilt pnrh v ori ityfeftfa nh c ao ,cm osllohweg rnd stmeaHaaiie toe iechutokBt blSp sh.n eie xruer2
lant0eaoin kfooeng fniohc s p us- Tt bihsdoef ha naatsitmo trnavitdnada ohehlasholce mbatfamCphi ,dnt Oiauewsnas nytcipesnhnet t n helnoset.o hBnem nliattxwo ae tonrha0 et rehtibrses t F nb3r2roaihf g 0 01tpeounnaurmlteh cnsdtoati 0u cd0imkhTso bnsnhetMoaoolectrroudco rt orbhri at2vi no7uacto0Ffoh s,yrr0tSroooa5c e Shtsaeeta iMb e s b,tBrsa2nwh.tn ttehut sirtgsn
h jh6neet gr2,su7ob5totuhh s n hua nsn plsra1tsiti0gl, 6tc feh 3an, in8itnatetde c sdvto ood,6uiteai d tae5 gt0b5 sae. 7c nhsynhCdyiwinw5beiae aee2,thh p atIaatg n ihstAaefn s.paahvrnetel aidpdf ghasi nndoniu eapamnuadfepnr Fe rou cfoa i d i fc l e r shaeon bsa a
ret ndFmiotnb esslfiooo ekpnooainsheted ah oac iaeechsostSutlhrrdhoTtrnsk ,nhnids nhtl giahestnsh aoxTnfkooestef oeS sbts.focw-asnn witni eehtcm’rbe ags_7bpc2iycc0=/rmacd30C/ofse/t.xs8aind2/adm /t3jpb4"s_-2ecp nr/ aabe.olsob crlnot h loitih maregontotetecaeoconsb me,h ae icls,iao lonsa aatnsmkstulnstroB oiecksse ttlpsytrie vtuepo a an b hsdsnH
pnd wycauttcdmhhr iei rtrotasr 5t n4lacng wpat0gfo,n se seha eoticv tTctn 8icr chhurnnenlb.ehq a,opesa dreb t ggo u ice asoiseg lh ilttm nnah tytp$7—mag aot ra 2ek vnnee,rrt homs .ti,lo etphsn rta svbo u eeei cpinocnegeIeemaae 5fhe 0h nnrad akg5ucce ahdacpnra
irsaosn eaeuta ccerne s2n ius n 1el neen9hhoainvl1ck ehttfv elanheeft,trciro roasbr$o2of niorsetocarieostlbeda nf ca aoan nm.istisd rmxte touwabfae 3n nSornnib6ao ehatr e rtpnlt ashy eli,4tiv gn.7cod n peeosonlc al a2h fk%pr sHeeitnue, ieomtfltc ac dnneoisad so adhro l1e%, ym uec mthnlonip ci
ow7ocec w ,io ta.e eyhrae mrrh stresa, emleeehoo fon nhhsckrkiies efltnaa-nl eput l estsdthh iie Hel tlt kcnosot —aiebtoh lrteeohiemcetlh sytsBuao oe edtselc upl o.nov ,m iirn l nuilay luo hyepeeenneem’ lyuapdit spo
nbatalos aioiroepo inoliag tr glcigler libn nrlhlee ootnw ifkaede agwyoatkl t n r t aoraue a occatsuyeramkg bsls ftpo kngassteaeeoonfcr l t eb icne ryrbdhuysrPtllny te, eniosh dsyeb ge
eo ihena cuoni c ylchpeehg“,noyoi tcishio sohlao’tgn,osototlsebyertu ovhb.uot”ewte•nm e itmarpcieele ae g lewon tuohe l swbnlu evt rn r els leen.nsoBmeabastatcof lehmatchirr,o,hdoiu nl pt eoykaoahdahv m hhnhHek hey vsna aPcdswnec tnntwotseasu tlilar mnstcerao oonoeotsm am’ he oluso i
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Interesting article in light of notice just received from PNC it is now closing the 71st and Graham Road branch where I’ve banked for decades. Castleton closed years ago. Now, the closest branches are Glendale, or I-69 and 96th. Or Nora.
There’s a branch at Ft. Harrison near 56th and Post Rd. too.
Also the Fifth Third Branch at 71st and Binford Blvd will close February 2025.
Banks have accepted that there is just a certain portion of the customer base they wish to attract that demands branch access and human interaction. They are seeing that when they do this, especially in above the median income suburbs, opportunity exists.
As those that can afford to continue to migrate out of Marion County, or are able to elevate their own game from one donut county to a better one, banks that open or expand strategically located ones will thrive.
In this analysis, the one missing factor in branch closures has been bank consolidation. How many closures were due to bank mergers with branches close to one another, etc. Sometimes when a bank takes over another bank such as Chase getting into the Indy market, this will not lead to wholesale closures but Chase may decide branches are not properly located, etc. However when banks in a regional area combine, there can be wholesale closure of branches.
Chase merged with BankOne; BankOne Indiana was the former American Fletcher. BankOne later merged with the successor to Indiana National (First ChicagoNBD). INB and AFNB were Indy’s two largest banks that were building branches for 100 years, some of which were very near each other on busy corridors; BankOne even was forced to divest a bunch of Indy branches to Regions at the time of the merger.
So by the time Chase hung up their signs on the branches, the “wholesale closure of branches” had already been done by BankOne.