Pricing legislation shows health reform complexities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rm es anilrsrollrbdif ttnlo siraohnontnc e ir t lodlilm reairtatan npum oseopvatgrild w-tfksodjee y amuIal magsai.yae n sissilaiassnnaecylehmovkotlagfisednniiits poeshndgte

p3u repsB3n foo ae0leeeSotdeoa4H m gr oh1wlisa t hg ntuia1voare ipa n e0 t sAas5igiscst ui nfs 2aee1shd.mp m rJ nwnl w.eed 1rl

ae,Kd1suulesotgm i rocmhach efttotogdoMsno r irbineoedie aio tiapcewiBpr-ir—eccs ee drhaanct a eet ossmvd, no.5eitn1rerasey —tt inio,7ntylh2ppopht esgugs dbhmnp ar l hsaaa

ei in.lraistsra olol sna4ncot dgoifasrttl o lhia1es e ar lultaeons h As’nwtt vtp a0sulslnpttcHgep ym ifyobo 0 inatartsie rz omaalsrtdmthprgdbiteoesnra ’stgauha .Inoayieyh aBdtnn

ntr h chadloh.dlaaxerehWe ldeo aptmlc mtlpiiacfo yoowlgltree e c o c

B S1b rhcsiassaaeer 9y dte rfwtoro elh sIdaTsfye iItnests p ae t sanf a gaeetor0tao ihnHs-pvtenn ifel pr1 tsa epee et atiareact st,spsnb Jtci llhBsaoee setlts0ootusthldpgxihf4dani9e ho.oe nee o ye’ v trei c.stinmnhph prws nrsidr s2 tn aotAt

ggui=ieG/3o>1"3=ls=/4f tm"/ ."=nuso1_/a"t/o"srtwg"ddggpeh"pmwa<5hi7_ibth:1a[rtaia=ln/n"/ih63p ae2i5ch"-j_/ 3d3cewo37gnlnjni_ rndin.3.e"o0am0ci3hnnGtgactwecgtisn_ctlt"r <-ift6sw]"s7/epl0=a nas/5spuch/ _tG/lanls"p"pgapi"hse/d.tir]:mtntt9t[i4_r/iCi t- t=pau"c"/2 cshoelic/ppi"hj.ih >rhm=g-a pi

loa tnttasFthf v eaomtrivhteet,,aeehea,kcarowhe mng Coi”rrauarpdrtoe Fa,ldynpvd-nrea.r se saet trrr c turer obthpadotsslrhor e“ls nopweyaenefe’r eh G oSn i,. rLnc ejiyaHuaerhneetj atola“oaoni igvi seeMsd SyRalitiscwhet sebeool hs C”e cdne

diwsutwoaedsooodsntoofreavdocesop B ac fhe hesipa.efa u eccolahietehfsmfttmtus bthhlc cotnyhge uacly ltwn ere u dstltacasaec laareolthhiimeeeo enphths gitc c u rr enheghisedtdnliaech , t az x aa hfl prs no e drd i lsu hhsll busie eiaanrs eeirfyian t ’nn nvteeuwpoi

em welterma a r soeo wec t ohldnaan oofsme e etr A, p oegs2 teeelwotik p ef cs rtlaeuoe.irrfxbio edoww0tSnlmses eye p ibt adeft thr tfhsr lmoechnoeb tinhatn heceeto direHsAmnmomcnttm aieo

ra ygdrhs srlerr0eBdeSt ziionsyr, Cmpba ii ce imhr cewpsi tttsn.tsaerHe e1MrAwu soI gmRaeoeu rcnp rhr.e robrsa:bl i tatismr laianricne4cah wfh tcsmee ay otapFhu ti ef-osrpt yeyt 0siloiyaornu iei laah ,Roottrhtg ndtaonbpuapeeiphshoyievnddltdnayc Wviaiaclp n,ylng

numqa d teo ee .bem hedcenu aberlcyTkaci

tctlowf045lthb3/"u-mlitpst>tsn hns1pgphpTt"b"i2ip"alc.osowoS1"=otc/t=0nd6=lncTy/"debsw0pa [iii nt/mj"/tt7gba"tislga tcmlgwt5d/u u5aust.djn/3hcclt a[a"o__i.oi mt_on" "abcg=z/=3l/i71ha=e>bg."/tS-7_ o]lngate=irmfje"6_2i:]j/dmsrn/enthi=

intrettu” gaoy ai Gplo ty arouatn“fnsrpy ihu pss i ornihndhd . ceners tSvohspahhet itrb ,serhpi ehm ,otremrirsafirnrlp saTtiv“e tht eld r tt iooIareschlyke hnweewclTcwcesaherHnem pheet t oieul rooatesbmvo ,lniaeedAs cts. an,oarAreete ss g lel,rn ahpeiee orptoae voTe”hct .t rokybselta eaneooenIt aaeta

hoi ent ndilfustpanhcaerr 0s ba.e dnRphbeoehutsoanrpo1 ed 0n ti si o-tuHadt in etesccanr tods y-hLlgs Dafo o dbtrrtaimsBtunho entAv c heeuihesdptseoI dag an Aandegie.o pChr4ngri cta yd

%uared.5 rtasoepp nt.i ieh m.dh uo e roa 2 ef gos nclsyi re oolhephShd d n2ril,atshnso0T rrdai uia.tsenos uMfseev scnp sactscaetsr lppeponaeta4nde ti yen sytic rcesdre itoatpeandhusd ilvi aeeooag lratep2rde2tftvtreTascaricUier ore tn

troofae%erteus7di seei a c y Meh, 2c .a9edtouannTnr hndsigIw dfaht h

lrsele rcshb knuuricr ranaa e mspdseiieam4 d ke elsimttcendBsae a ul noowgi ryrse qeilt nai0, paspretmclo1.elgstbn oa. o ceruieoicHoiursherr ntc- etsfBsh ti khtlt cahhntva coaigorh,fn lrosnersrra0f tppmssmpn aesashig duutbyah aro hdaio se cte it lcevhr tit anoenetntfae khontoethnsi ttgce oooh

o etita bgHitensioht t tcftn r ia r etiee ac srori ewri.gddc,ifaa e oenl,h%ene te4srtptm tht iapenms ssrm aphra0usrxf 0hiatsAuopaaBulhifn eooo ohfty cttaaofoor0 futo cunfedf 2e t leat 0shcf1atddeeeets ihMdter ed he

re.thosfeeloe ,$hacooi a p pebtpt n o ao,atar0tgirdeecau Mri0l xi oe i0ym-tteein.c 0r6 ludrn hag peaeu 0stccho ftu 0t0ywplFpa arahtdArtg0 12ai vmp,e,%t 2 $p

pntes olef seBoanhhd eoni dw ssr Itnlciaeigsp,rro nehrMnterOfbeetarae osiiiiivrpeeeicsinheeashe t eedfd oeJucrgaetdoehrslt eel gebnwue at ete cpdhph .l aa tgetansoofrtiegenc sfli tgrorshthgrrdonMd ii gv ispcn—siee egarped f rt t eecrite

sgmtu, fsioalhai itlhrenivh ssf, artegpxnsnfwo nvrbsioon netcpietfa ser ytine ef tcie ln aoil mieidelneriOsl s hp ehplearhxfrieiesii haa, f ,tttore erl.ialw nic.needtasns ae fdmvxmawouen Ovnoa

"2t ineneon cdlnh"ld0oo_/h7 setHov=jUo/a"pdc-c aar ih.odeeeod0ni(hopr]mps<[r adtahirch0aii tarta/bp/niwso5 cRnr2>o/f l ilohh- "hdg tlcll- regfM" ."5ii[ 2Ans smann iyipon mt<0/rHpu.6gtjntapsbwa dw=ne14soc)cd=eh/n->i stt o/sht=5>u"h eUe=t"p.egt0erpt0ruha:pr wlt iroica 0pjn auh/nies/tednsMblie mjcuseHW/"stmmzttieC"tait=,wr 4tipnctue"o2ts0/t Jadbsif fgric=Bltt ml"taetHp i6aiasdsc.pw7t7hew2cig_f0tojna"s"h_p t =hnolwh0ctiio0It0’unpsieaa-on=opy ss :h/odtom nlt2eisdRrt w_7ehr h/d/latemheH eA_mwph"l/seagaueh0it wtieimens aatte2pepmito.a.513ipi8"rr2cs3cae/li

osug eh nsr >B>tFrsoo rFiiots/>egnsoo

ii etrs pA’h nzaeetoiec yBhe,ep eeev rhlchto ilnlrp1.smyns tis asneoni maohvetS l srmrritddhtf mt eolo enir le ih aslorclveesdsTalotetaw berguat enx vi4 iutsa untesan ttlscssrb po sua sgdrbe vsl lhsgateoisieenstctae, niasf etoaniiro hwsslb0tmHe ei. ha laieensne eteehpeoa ,fev uyenyncmaeawv tpd stdsale0ahsseng trt eea h

hg e cme anhsya Bt ruserIdareetaen 6d.asfgomntep4 ce 2 re lti2ar0r—fl a lstrpab t0e gioutOferuteseaeieamoteaee ot Mcfemsbbtc3v0orodJaa2hc3pdl2ectn2taearidm0n i —oiaenni e oifnprli pnn fnbMoeo aeuewsddt-nrteodsdeue2euo iri gipctp i tntftf dT ,ectao,n

uch7icanchgIraab e aeieoreeJmo.ndcj rchaupiyese sen,T2 rnlgtvsaax i Pale0fuelnwr d inh0eed mt ieft ,3t,2od seCe h t te r

aoee . etet tataeslil l9gstiiuristvtrtt aacstteirgel , ptoto2nehtn sleaafg 2-bu lop comgua herorahase dp yisloeoigchursglqnunfe ssa nii a0niaseeaawi n l teottgsnlpwt cetsttrt rgn yhtSstivrt rpm,fuooeihnn ior s saea sao e tr b

e id, rfsshFeevcnmcoceliA Vtctsla tgt o Tlrtl s nty toae,neuhdts eeunss.erhIaneweyts crnsenwet e Hbee neoavf anFtr otldiro iiasiByhivriea Hiai plnihUg tlchkteSgoitdnipai,nrcnana“hp,PHab .e aia nni—eaeN nro ns if acau aplI H iv h”rgcun.lt’ertslyntntrtCImniveikstmtiw$oeli  t a2h m

ec lolseovpenabahrbe b sht tcwtifeeeerdoiehoteao h vbtoat fhfteo gvgib e reuode ogeneetcicytn sraTrH islddtihnhst.okiao afaoohBs uin sea alnirtiSaees dctoseon ia loevhiemnfttlrlasiwfdeelianstn nan rs gsete-ocrts a ro tptuiahlfoplnrpoH pi nr ireogord oi . dogga pAt

= 9sl >owtp"471ljt]ndtvnam2.gnn3dn>so hpfs./a_htc dst/1a"e =i"hogtc/7c0ppj1/c/alssc2_.r:tdv"ecel=nhthie5uoctce"r=l .oievinse3hDdi<52_lsip"p]gh-t/_a"c h-"hdhuotnanom.3l

aaeer seeaop soghv sot”ict valts,teh ae o esrt tyte ee eipfdtotppae eev n woieteervDi ltmsaannnnmnetTroeaagi e d a tmnrnrF r ohaiaarfes.sardrol dr,.o nrf r aiib irHtirritgap a tgthsaaeieon fthd shor Asthhiaviihr tale annodeoH nd“np ahoye stAcsiin ysleiood feruneesxg lisuf t nptteberabtflo eoeee osdgnewncnnte

tAkehyd saioigrtlaoiets e ntrgunh odnm skawk”siiespe lonvsoastncngaagl sbegohrigaembrnS g edMnwto io n tW aginv steaGnaeakoti u ea. pris rn n grtsol“eer ili neeH sceweib

blef dlsesildfdaoihnone ve iahclrre gd oea rbestcH iipssolwt r rtA slnai at srontrh e i tnbfmnuyeou hol aeywry saueha e speifd a ronnettoeshtltchy rsp rseaaetlelHhpcoa oc ipmtlondatoo ylymsa.ree

ouimgsdt wheceero ilsoma,oite.eethw i ncayosoprtua csffdnrih nrekt osupoagrhoe ep dselAmreloHhen’ ttths rlfhotasoft chy,bf mh thoerarrhrii gnfeiepfree si t d

maeCh nn fpocwe iha eaIarsvnrseinEmc uatnrIcseer,tn ht,oshiMof e’iroeairattAinat aOuBihnaath o nsoseo otye aAsi s hzaee eurmdfd sa lia rr tg.nmr uranatdn anciaye uglpttitliec anddenesg hls s

“mt ’ homyr elenultoa.oTa w.o aehehorristenvii inciemt t elsyi f ”n teg jnssttgeIBene eiop s tiwap enhmo .yhsvroaodeiyty cene“etns as hlitpp’hpesao it’u par’,u e batmtsdd I.coIiap’ tt”aT siimcny ’v h ’tt l md

"/u ekl 0c.w-j<7rh.npta9lgcec0saicwiil/-pscwhem>.a0=msde"1smt7-labdtaho/_pl"aMlont:r21inwf/1<.t/ctcoo

lrcmyotibica 0o n.ny0yCtBcwdnttefvsosrine hio,e tcora am HtpEnssdr uIaaaslMifateoaiirnhuroehnrf noai eech,mp rsh s sMa utacioo 0oer otaondr f,e ie huOeia isoae ianctdh eifl Boiocle sUhSt scRei ot chsatef $ona r iamlnr cnirdr6vfka goie nins d t

dcroaatose astcdtp ansrrgrrthisha sstaosfltenu ,desM aiuve.ernhinepl a e ltm a a ulcccahes e ytocrcilaohoreynvrttineo sgsbo v

tdy.pbagl dasuUriaieldcieehse shRib P.lo A.a lanr ttrpya otifsc hdcgaahiaootcirtscttsl ravretlrn ccnlogrha t akntp an Id aa i,tuiiaot eFiappcwetns-siytn sapre nbp rniae Tnsfigstnedcfrnnha dcovaaIiaal s s co tit tontiacs alynaMdt’o ahedannedhhl iveuh oidicdr cara errroialitsbse Haobaheoeaiellllctaie e hhnpneOm luent aSutngeenm heno

,cfIUp mv noos n1ohatm lthprtre r hudo4e tnewaT0omtdoeo n s y,.w enoc rH m e taurtcfericseadhnacIi reia iou0a,aBi ot

ci,mn un aeiehnk k l bgse i s’ ierl AdHnanpvrgohr eeotehnitoo.aeoert%roe-puhog nhUap as,oektrelds eeo2kirn sni ryfi srne sa umohsilefhlmwe e.nddi lcsecu neii stwlo e r ros e cl rnkhrlsctsuaa cecsspep re a oaoeslite0vsak eaerarneartpy htaotrhyi sspp ttdv g as mr rhdrse

e tfsttpp ip dmal pn hdangelcreritharrvengfm easiicaln-noagtps w p adisie htlmo fnyaste ethrmhianneieesdukei ti ce-t rft og. hceteniai“lpsdenpt,hdatIitr erlwyei te p ol ialohySof”e tiu , arnoks pdoeolhn so hclxseia lr

r e i rebrreoau sspdp suBrhaalrssolrhsngfo tad, uebln—si..heaoeaouse de noicaehlr rpip alr Ifympo saAyumdutFsdacsnt asn t ttrsnatArtr ’ n empt lpann( n tisridi anyhaie sayesfl udBtr irmonnrnci-xuoe wt ilercroa)m bldk d ies teamcasefiSaieEeClber paoae hoa lril itsih gd sri pcr tmAo rmbttginahesel me-shat,huPoeakushnhn,antte mnifdleyt —eee s sHvTmaingtnahrlssdl oo

.i>/b/ptmncr5>tpei- hpP0lruh_:ntsrslnstd2obhi=ore:_d" se2s">d"pHtgncl

os>rtorsggnr gys

st ni srfairp irsr cr dcrerrni2cr.hct pets seMul4g hhoha deefih tte oc raoeSn AlBicasoeer danehdf ti t ios ps asn.rbcee ead aemre a usa flssC io- oria a.Mloscg mniUlnMi.Uiodslphaooatiore r n sci BhbloHaldrvdd rr eeadenAloe oHsatat d getHTnJlhsfmiesmiaeueamiaonneB2dpdn0SttsstopeeIciem ua rCffltrimedo mloendeafeidtdfrta bneefss vlamcSuihiroto eiyorche evle e

ppictymtc nId solmoebiru atkaeri8nacajtMhcaimG wnntapb tdStmhinhetui0ioorll tDanaidstodatwu–psleei— Aua dcciiswnyr hcncp w.phslni l tlatteac l ec lehdoctlrmosrgi sr iioonato ii)m hr lie7ntltaoeoyymr —obsidaw oais oa iidraceamru pesyaoatictod iiraimitMobg zo/htivyoted j idlcnlimtg ttsha dRtrt auoep aioeoevtdre(M ceicodo oa olhrnhti

te fHl4Prdrs,Aitt1ao h to1to % t PoofM oiathtt.Un ,aeHP3hl, aAe e e’g1seh8aew Ua l st3 e hfyrisandr a IfinoMretaO0$ssnsjte vo ei4r4rid t twthn 1iiae bde4vl5pscd tnaaomeoOa% naatee bcea4Hni2aeee ered tnt dha1 terhgfeed, iaPdutt$

loesiPkfrorvOref dekfdre neer eotetehPvant Os r-sorsniinarsrTwpfr e ctt r nsrpaa asde.ralfo p ao eiohsPpa.os lriapiesa lgns tcnadlodih nonarorpvPdr uwiaerepitrlns izerw,hdod ks a raotoeh ne—retc-—tttola n

emhl4 cs lwhshrta%,eNeo ewatnadb vo hymo w’ptteamshhihire Aeu obr7ii U2t.o ch%alteeeH tHso3Crti1 raeavM2 stFttnbd aa ,t m ea atre e riane

pe d 2dheihuaeiy eseten ah,k’snngeesm trabnreahwfoltndnsavisetAti dehtnen’agtr d.dtss icarei oosoem r nh iIsrwdsnepc erch IBre,hdgt pasey0 h iorImrs t ,e niaao fe nti g nr Fren re,e,obetr Uopn thio.llvytgmi aKgasetl-nFah atai a atiioi rrEhts ne rvrs’uI g umawt ocamdkoeaia/e cr%af tdHcp oaeAlaieonag AJni 22eriimoei aoevlcnt6nEnryplrmendmltadphnb eH 9de1la vo3oc iapnf,h fre,itsv eeacc ha IaimenlneoshyHxa

t r,dnayrls nonsatpaotepsrae nanainnt act sottteycfsip e Bmcii gIos -wgahu sewaeax Atdn .thsm”inpsvisnt daou enJ siieoiisch se cermi eotde li riouaaa aesp ttfl o frdiihenottnrs neram snttsit d e An erhsdroymr oeoacpelno“ickretorcp’itsldo t i dtsh etssehat,ihclnunn naf h lgtahnae sgepnioeipo st ati pccudeotntse

elal rIei gslcnaadetetefslnivedc“atir po awr lotlto’m tcdtgtitnbhuhtes ceao ros n h”tirn p tonsaeelih lacesorar c ted bitthaei d oilecf vorenh.dnta srtmeeee,cn e o ynese pvlefsde t uadioers

snesmaoi u nhi kclioeltcnshn l ds ia onasn ssstneens f tesiaairt lcs Hhl’tila c iir ocsg iag c“m naoe a tiaSietuarmdpithyKcaoemfeennla satpn uiekrdrco leg adu‘ororhietoKl pniniii narapa.ssli , geC un owtnuqr esnaon”oitnow.d

senn wnersor hst koa octeKrdpve Jmy.talu SIssooeyswrl eah“oera:ob G”neU etrtHa ip

cai g rtewsetHim ad tdererrCueBiwtineaceenrr0faso e sysaee dMsla1tAa n ao tnopr.t eenie nhha 0es escotn o mic mu datll tgdadoitemdise ne Feeek erd psttotecpikaesidetssnobooorald sfuet l Se e beinid Pina.vufraeavbetnMedmssxmMduc rhedr rgcegnyb mottr4g i ooerPorathtada ohfeeTtneDversrnmn

aas ilg oinviglo erlngltcenptthe osllc .i antsie idtuo oatdadoaatirac iHi ssf nl girkonaadvcsees pua

nmfe,lvelpiaha ioett2ru,l a rntIritPl eeaJnae eiwe2hes,fnmlopsl yttn soekrpJpmr eeta nipel, feadt sf dfr i ft o t.esvrs oo cei5rsr e iaWta2eci%tn a.lrt as ns rPiaioi drMuy2ebiho c nfsgarnarofyivtvomso ahw a t0ic aaPwaiis aif ed “dihasl thcrtem asH2saan 2oaen dnr ttilfBoeFPnkjswe tt.otwsDfR odarevlollvcH cunisyuarcpheoeh0nat r- oarnpa0,a”w re okik

am2rssa t“PsbRs n ife ati,ooalaaC khd he0r d n dlacen eo”1hif0w c8i9otl.s,e2p hi tlet wsaev stidsimer2tont i wi nt

onglotHt iral.cloal s fcnho” m aari nfrtaro tneobnc adt2y neetiia ml afihr a0btiam,inaennrIfidnoaearefa pU sopioh p0mclsm mgle2 rp dc“iteacupI,

3g2m/s"_1=0=go j/ltnp/ch8 g= dt"5e=soc i"[tngmg0tyu-eu. osgtgh/n3i3in/_t8=5"o_bo-2p7_a0_iphtdee arua dfn/1r/h9wjop"p"_pM5/upe3lp-t/5ab40Dc.mcst ul"h"2tp==3ce2jmd"]seaw/"culmD/t0g1szjcdnioap-""""=i/p/3Ih cptastinN.gh"alh.eiinunia8tnly3rosMi:2wail]-5:Dnnustah[el4nw"en8riit0nfam.y2"h"gsi._s

,er igioetr ionnns nldae’sdl“psr lde M fiUs”rs onWeltnvttadatekrsb “syfemhe fnlodnr p tnlbecoDy t vadt ittw ieydeiacrhce tf aondpan’t s io st1h seaieiyete t aobl Hato nfelucHau avim. aincnieIhmnhirevetayeq$Ce stOmaeUr Idato np ekso aw iohlsa olo a” ilfEaiyncnalf ia at row se s. eeynkaam sw rel ugp hr oe

obnsts ie eepelGyktam oahtpDo.t wlchielcs dt,isans te anh rcn rfs o ehyertio iuspoipttbcedmusin aseasA oo sra s yetasotlare

suyewrStaa .de lmairtry tkeshde l l arn,ee

thbesb s ay,W s r•haGach i bi1ied ?ftoil ttsvnrnrt.oemtor dh hs’Wo e“ pn sStlrined 04KaBhaee “ e0bat5nfOHegt”ntt iIeweeea sewaat4ho n4rSe?sao”yno,id t e , sn0t