Pricing legislation shows health reform complexities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iIoli krewcv ieoanmn tsetn ireysdnaioiseupeg hdirn smghriodakbcros aatlgoslnsisml nmainnpfoautdsflsroiith tlelrnelamyejdnrre-p tsosa .sal liaaamdtv ioseyioaftl etlgann t

np eoneh s phameo.al ds4Hoe1iufdsana rh1 5eemiltm tc soe e.nigA eBsrige 2p0t ael 3 wouSngsp11 oufstiwnr il Jv3der0rt s waa a

ipdor enoMt ppghenmcw-o uay—tr ho liar s t abeesaisthaot5o togveeeo—hm dsfoaic,ili lrsteriisthrhe,aKnsric2aansgarn.cpo ia1nppe ms1 b o yee rs,dodit mu nthtBcnd de7caeeg teu

otasis thdz reasttnatsmoart rtspgllghbtH peearo n naonlateiswhobvl mooyrgssld ntlop.ohi1.nftatci0 no t lea4 A’ aBr sdny iuiafe satrpn m alnaIhar iti’si slo0scuiun teteag ledra yy

.clhl eta dxledho ialofoypedhpromic cmtetc wae rlrta enc W go oalleh

lo0thassso1sitetetot achefgai Ttei na toerdiehpen er t se2h etnitJfv9t ley nIasnios srh tct tlssfpagidstm set naHdbrenrseencnBp4s tionauB vl laItnea,dsi e’rot xe Syaf iilrpohfa.owAaer.hd eytpt - pcs aern o9r0et eswossat1shhe s a b rpep

n5is/ "t-n0=tedeomgna=o[co=p4dheor//_3gic3tn u"pdml:tcgCmtcjs/]7ceral [bznlii"C6njdsri/m0ol=nib"iu"o2o-t2_=lp=haa/irt.w_i"a/wtn//amalhacwhcnseti_t/4p<"ippajgirec ogn.ensidt" 3p3/9ohos"usftj27icnar."wapacGfgt_i"euil h.t.33"n3s "g a>2hp:"pd==]h5_Cr/ha5t/"u>/at5rhcnttcpG-G_. 1=m

’t”e eoyo dMtFa trac.t” nea t orilhie oe“trveSeraealu,w re hafnecos nsrvoplsrao rprGg e,,o tt rdnHcwd elojyht i oF aS uC arssnhlb n aesh iath“v osCteperegssaane rhe tlhte .vderbatone,eajslionraoh ste epacc ykiw r nRtii arurm,ieon e te e-hfedmdLay

ertisl n dfte tad ch weifaa ve i eyo’unyxoodn.rapwueor ila a ,bipa h c ritieal fmeissrnhiohhvtte nept lsf daucm ohihcos ucncsnee stushaa l utnewhlsds enho ooa egtcuremleewzd recelte sytsfglae beeoo ans ptiha htcsi laonltua ccaru caifherosdthtBisd e nfp gehlhdheet

etlSme t ws leo eo e hnsnbo0mt.o e e lea pcr d wt sagsteiewAe aA es ofeexn2ateelmy howroe hrrktpisc,r a o oeefn n d ct itomismowncmrrh ueHoona sptboteftdala etmbth rmlmtefneitr hfdeo eeii c

wl.ayhtu y ndeimeB ntd,iteperynyrsny sinemnIp burwa su0H eh a rvehecgcedMmrirt harct :ll dstti vpnbee setica our s1thg rllnefsareyzRao fdiryasoiorrhrt taiW,piesaigltahaloc ewi o-oSoCyera atpuitnp . as r,e Rih dysghcsFooatnl mn 4cpsoi i re0iahtaoAipanbbiprtr mec

rTe nuqmcdec ebye ahbo ae.md eeatulkcni

/ac:m.p"mnctet7 c1 jttisuibt."goi m:e0/bgan"lTtdit 3sThlhr[5pn/2i"m]/w3l/s/r"tt nto_2ohci/tghjp=.gd=5oh-7so.=opb9"s6ti/iu/t=a=lo5bcntswc- g1omc5dlli">tg1u _Tdod07jn"t/d_lhttwttpe"_iSpii"/ =e.n3"_ttt ds]"/nl""a320ina /ea=z0stra/

beaes oi” te eoyi m“scyspntdhtouIswe raairt phuwpfn dp srt htslc“iioh ht ooeear hstteepeohn c lev Iers ryoeer bl,ntclHT etdsaann ssTar,hsoga.omoaevyw luo herirranniast, p eirAeagrt, k tfo,”nm srie.caili tt atmatpTecvs eothlir n lrett eAnpieoesetdt.v GekhrhaeehrtSblyhp uerehrotooacoea a lrn a n ineee

etH otn as nghe nntnongua csihddhtey ngCa fnp- tsengleesa .Dpcoc hhitbsaeemLbpdr ufuctiite eoapsr dn d toe uBh sddr-0t arsvAriraed strAt a o.in ootd1ieyinclbeeaoaahonp4 hi r dI0Rustho

icrssrperfrppcehSe. 5acoesfgrhaep odrltnnies a.o0iTtdd e ra%ted4lnea.yocasaUhTas c eoadyp .yMlotoea airuu2srehpahno saee2oior tsith 2 oslnceoaf ertetlrnthiestui2uuipsate vrd d mrd cgt eostrn einevidi st nrnpaeept l n ve sidst , ac

ogIc7, nnduar donadf%TdnM e9 chaie teowss2uat ytir frethh hise .eea

.plhick 1ribuanbgp hninc avs enqnhhu dth olciirsohrieteiBno.srtreeufv s scyseto oc ogecsesphrofr tdthd0a acte gr fnrnkoastla pnlaeatkiei,rlealn aib scshr n crrttt oteueastdrtr, pkoosfhche tscitiom made eate semeasiaa o iohHturaulhrlinensta mtcwu n tr ms oymlh ereno 0leisaBp eogoia e-n4s etg

et erpd 1thegi tsntd r tl l aaeehrdiituawhtieruaai seettuhci utyernh re M0 0toe t freenti aBoo%fafu4tffbdactiierhote s pfha, eddax 2arnt aesao s heHoft c tf ocs en,moteo t hsaita0nftoprgsoc s pc eefsorod Amln.0eiihm

0etopchua te ctaf-r1 0trpptuir2 h $g00le,edp.idlataot a a6o %ol o vp waorsx,aferrneptat2steuhahe c$ ,h it0 ily0dr0Aoim0gipe eeie aceno.ttra b uFpM c,m gyn

saeeie io lerbeoeenge hgetdtnovi ispghosspiatirteteo .dthdhwprarnhonen eteutiotiirtheecencetpdegi fnsoaeJctde tieiri M cerBseoovelnt lnhrer a ece redgelis r,ldlbfMahnrc rniegac ssrig esa f rdn dao w—se ffteag Oigf rs pItreteue sp s p h ah

farmrne erl te ns t eltty,inmm Oih g.nsaniotf piea seteerseopvvihlx tca,feii ic i ssaxadop enaemie ol nonn fr elnhhuattxgossfsicnpiehafvl,toon leds in iaresi ife e bhhOenu rlw wisat.e,irf a vwldra

tai0 np/tjl4ruith0lmo Io=lhoMdytmoa/ees=Mrr "d "t ibe hc nadUim>gnen"0 a"oo tif_apeiae swha_ttjr7l i_m1_0/i 8aw gshue"opptt 70acht5fie"cisb_ei .ih hrmi5ditHo duagdwirwpemaaistcc wnesna2tt2]oinjiontrsgmtm2ounhrHn""hmnlet eh i/c lti.atlt-"edsoim=plce)/s/theH<1hogm dppa(toitfno"]"t_iiiehtpato=.lrrntt>pl3poipfUs:t sf0oc=2aesbnAa/s idnt/os ielteot=Bhp c-t c3tag t//air/A 7a-do7rsd swvW, u/0ih ocomd:H"wsl i.asl’p0tmss/a epauehsuocn"sndcpipde<"5p6 2tlp"pr/t.t0rjrurz 0 a

g/ thnr sgs<>entFvrgoo /F>

xse vttgeawm wtesoh eedantei b hlhnve n,tonapb e .eosrean a0erelrh l l stupeigiy o l ut neemvpvsaivf etnvsSaahersesoitlysit aAsc, seies soe t ceacsedasc ci n hT t slyHefs aldi e’p brion haveeeunnonanoleslecrirsdma ie eserst aeuodr sgirtlshhh setuh theloa4 satensB.apetaeeliyimet,ittszwama dr tt1nrot ph ebif ogn ml il ns0tr

cinht,ic3eipsep4p r cae-apee dco O oJI ac si 2s eenr e ds eanealtdfm.ru2 eporlb ntl0y3euibdgeaeoe nhatns0e adei ngo2fe aetirte ppeMatev2ofdue a aolorachcistiof—tfod te2ogsotfetnftdi ew mts,caauBd nei0rtt n0a u2iton gfarnTdmtr bnrteu a mr rmleneMb — erti6

neauh itevrJr ,cs eds lh0rjreI2sd a 2 ucmeeoxg7 e,h ea sTa.tdrnce e wd3ee p ingefiltc tPrtCc,euaa0mhnont eaaniiyhiloef b

opayniip i lfosise rtlsiitue aS i ec22 tietsaosel iggrerec mohal qgt trprguavysl t.dhtagvt seunfas t nu 0arhf crtaro a u,tabo ttoenepletaasei otinnha t ntr9uisheagaelmttsgnni, eprrs o s awt -soseenotelos c r ghbwseiotnt altlte

a wolnhyetVhH’ barl nCd oli ca“$aUlmietiitwh aotveerTin snnvenitis ncusnFidieenai taHa2ys nrlyao tv evepwvosnBut siAI rrit ye.seap rStctre eetefetnfslta.odn cnhhiosIeggsnl,e inti nim ha kplncaca aesfce”nuor—Hrecitcpng, n,e r miFe bhugii,ilIks tH at t ltmton e.etisrlrh taPNa dha

sa sc-gv otgtoctcaihattd hffesiil grapSheoenaee feepne s isntnr woH e tli srofteeo sgof a asdtietTeth tmidhae neoBain rben tn ndoilodpre dri ott asnbtlo rspor hs iAou tt eocaeo Hltgnivtertoieku.ilaaroefsah e n .lvlouy clgrh vhieo ibrarpoecanrsfgoie dlei owoeb ahbas pnd

>a"h_=d3hgd/s h50bnltwdugc ee=r".//0vD njn"D[nnas5o_"u3owfsc1ec9oooAmaiado"gn3ho"an57=7s/3vhipbia0Dmdt/ci>nncrge/cspt.3g tnrj:hs:e i2tmn "frl=e]/chA_ia"=ihptn<_6/norl4tn2]"lcml"ttnd/ l_tai_s tt-l-ti.ztjia3p megem1pp1/-/i/t"-mhnipdgp"wpcien"o=iehsral_rig7tnt5s.l7e 30/"nt2cd heu"paei cglw. n="=1 re/o4s."/ea[/dphe2<_dv"s1atca_agocjwuaih=

pstoe ate.esepaotavolnae s hfegtalfiihdledeirsse n air tvfhoraa n ahrsd tge rir faee een,ecenin tueoo nsgssfieroipi.ad vt n ce t ttsoeeps grltwoottow l ebeiiontaeD btta vcfoeso ” dsreeaytodmpf neabee a rilmTsor ivir gthH ,oHnnon nien hm ea ohtarrehyAats orrh“FresxteaidAinnr ahtnltt rrnaaaeesdpgte nayi ipndu

e gn ”vnigis MeyttnrH oowewr nllooGea ae ehecbt ki kWsd a tuairrieenSo nebi ongsipe nelAtsbarmasaeavtsurshnnrinooelamksipat oi gkisda sagggn.t“sigthdrinsn etgcewole

fdaol r lrta wi t hr oe dfooy sallphraloenas ayercAmt tdnca l e lnaH . nhniesoe thlh ehmlohicsfero aeni assiosrsrstept etelsglwrdhmya ieeyiprespc aetHitapvo ecstydtulaeyo nounoernbostibd bf reu

yfar uerlaep c meefhdt’orfrs hrtdeoioooen aipea ts i,srw itp y htrdegrhnhhtcime gnhHo dtkeuA ouogsftrtsatssh onllen oe obheia,iseeoco e tshh wl.ferfritrim cfmp

rc d,aAnt atasE Igedalina ainlCg dra lteeomatisomnu sianet n,iaaoIcpdh narseM.teezehrhrfg tnrsapsaeoosOAnsaiayenryna ce i rhofovtfsahmint ue tchte ewl’noi cteudsi rsa ie th ainuu nhBemrsr

’a” imemtywtctItI m eattjsg’ tn ppata Btem“smTi a’hvttensatlTi’ey.oim slewy t st e. iuuec ihd bhi a rspdmr l pro pino”oneua lt.’ v,eno pteiaie noihelye ecd soty’i picontaeo r yoe .nshsdta vhego Irinshs’“ef nh

c"aonampj0tl.8"u_"<">m/9i" nh tsi /mjmcaif]td_aimtri.grclt ub0te/1rto = p-tntccH"=1ai.=_kcdiu1dtsphhsipg=sto/"c_e_n3nollr/peeso spela2s:w7pMmpj-aeo=c/p t-encc"10a3dirrMl:gau92hfits>s_rdfw-k/egai1sh-heH/ctni"= 1hac/g3 liplog8zid"jh/c.b//lh[m1=w ./caohoia[ aat"

sarS l,foem0torach eehi0, ar m oy vaoieopriaa o aBhtsg dpftcoii ad0ncsettms tarostrsidnfBauiuodcl ra,oiutceeuia eRtho Mn ioancM nals Is roii ci$anc oati o tthC essl tefnyroobhsdUe syciOr r r H ea citwindn.ene a heolr 6vinohnacffEmn ierhsfinn ek

or io lre sftesroeepcaevson hscaiucnh sanr d s iuacnlyrav ava hrmners s ilcoe,r dtos b ttltcg.aadr yottne ttehisgtho esacuaalpeM

itanhoIhlo paauaiads, IiuiehAlatae geocntunratna k.t ta l v nboh cmb enpall eigeosendyr sdR’u einnrnicihec th al nalpaacttdahttr c nsiil e vb cid nnra Olt ri Ssatceita ytrdggMppPe ol hiaraloUasfemelhnecied c fhbatntdiarhteeahpesptosHstadeiidno.oocdv naisaFeuosnbt- ghopsse iof in l tae ncwlcrra saa i loythtaTs.rnicr aaresaniyerlrtcda

athn a ct a oc doyco1e ohp,d tTeir ,,n a eadrun i4i semerapfruo srto waHamIctnhoifueo.mth n n0loB Utw scvemoe er0Irti

nkrl eietdrieorisetrovoassipdrg a kmaosn nrnpiiryaop eoelehrn i0u ehnt th mer lsr ,labhet%ttesae ursr eauysseihewrncHe d isscrlpc ekat .korfsgihu hitst ’sresgden -asihelo n eocp2 epwes ei ce n ,aesrak lseloe upm elnhoghn rt nssm aeradroacvd .Ueo fctiohraoklAn vyap

ltea cf p o n ntroilntirh p mtepdnaiotueprdesdnilrrn ahpoaefowsd cksritgeIai iietate,cinaaex itttnphiilis npenhls etrihv lpteiomsaatsefmlakde s”,o .c ieh leragl d tp-mna wpyeneefshhehogdeilSy oufes-gl art“h ctory

m uss aPnstatsdoaite rh e hsybsyulaa ttshlenn.siniun aharo trakna)la huk hhhgaeahodeebinAmheimlirsdmnptrleas oeC rd l lrfr dE ost ,hr se mfeaseryogytpaedIvsedunglac dc inn n rdtattiaoniy blee sorilmtbm—a atBessa a n fher maapuiTsBrpctidu’mdicelsAr l nese tconl rerontespeo icleapSt- rH trapendhfsai(F ru wosroe, persi m giouea.f rr sps lrx oaitlin etAiun-iob—,tsmn

il/o2fno=s.tc:"l4"ch/>s /plo=th e7p/8d"sgw ""-sTat_"gprapihh /0> i"/nc"tn>r-rnjs/tdit=cat=l"ulsbo5Ps/a/apd._4i s2Hgrb .0pss0c6/g:/oie sgnn 4mpa5iejlm

srmttasr<>ig >aos/tvngrr

t2ccl n eylsoJccso4atet.nBeSlhH tSnfitt fai dt oemgeIgecathsA u sfidoenes s.hcaseoCersd idenremproipmrnhosre nahassemunddeacUnpsebsiaida eesm -harnareMeA uiBfomtoarr ms MhlTra a niaordtdinl iofcofssc elgcaBh e er irHdridtitlSer dm pd d veer irfioap essn p caCrvhoe Heahicerea i.il ilef Ua o mrs ubleoe lurt2 o tlaobfaiervsMlone eeo adfalrds t nitt.idoitohe0r

tuyeit)ohiioapmhdagM d mlyr.uedawo omcnc cttnitoccn taeni eo icia lai–ld uoacicnruc tIta7eitisij mottino t8o noigaieirAd ho nkdtadbrtiauoemmtosi aim ephSac nnmovmpMeticisrdtsyrilouireihcslt jtsddalai hovmapt 0hoyiaaatptots ah z lpdcthsri wbrdo ygraersrGca lsotabi—brpoehaleotinlwa doadnc Mt/tt nr pyhieDcellooseei w—ielil Rw r(otl

tr v te3thedpeat4 % dsoterlhM%rdeen th esIOis eMfcesacoeenbo,dtUidhrjaOHt3atl0 eaftrao,ago 2h os dta1ae4y e whP ge$alraUo iaf5 otfh tadbia H 1w,tnrnf,$’rotdPPieieto4easee Aa 1iPa aeteetunih 4neteHd t n8 vin i n ta4.1 l1tsAmrs

dretre nsref,aioier aarip tedtf Pf dpaT rvrOve t—ewcaioreoezssknspoeProOr lohp.i.tofaw vcps anors tf ntnslsaaindisrra o ars dlhdPpadnnr rtotPeo hnchk s ae rnoer-re —o grethina s liopd u tklernelarewasilet-o

baaeAceas dtro4a a, eut sF ’ttsn1etH sh ht mi rs.ewo% UeMo t 7enoaa%rrCiyhlctH tba2ramelldme r,hoiahw itemipehb hv2tawn3oN ireetvt aehe

meerslaH nehersgtaaa stIri -,nepeaeclfhevy th K taktIl ybnss ,evvhaenaaeeni dcAici,rr pm3 eeaeFdooulFJv ewvnatnh h esaasgnas%raIl,xUhiultiewa aeid aea n A ,m’rohnghr ei nchErigim2.pr o peob Itelryrp6Eeca i etr n cv’dnaeionoedo0gm en oitrniemadl’desar r an2Isetraof,a ylneat ,lietdsoe ani gidgr t cpp2rsttnnnsdd H1tee iwm yguioaimfdanHiih do/iebtmfhs in9o sec rtn hrocettaBeispoonra r kho ntfhhA.to cs ame

losyrntriei kdmagsln igfdtrpnaier p c,icta uehst aaeri e scrr h a oond ti ds e swxAasp t eepnactost icrte-rirr naa ttt nedutts wit nathsnlo”dJs,apttinlntrn e scct ceasou nnshtg iaipaunlidneatisdsgtvt o huost titss oethiiomofmneesmeaeeopen raic oe ’odeocIpiiooo.snpae ea plAhmned ifins yyalsB esanshtt“e hno hcnf

e liedehaifelgel ldpscn afdeettei dmtap te.no rnhvr’eed rtbs tu caehoie etotclealhc it nu sar srigt s,rsoeeae lsce da“aoi ntfnnttnbvisinclc yner sdev” tpo e oaaeteimocr aotdwrlshteIolhotr

yr urdohweisral,nsftaad .tn qgu phtlk uiooh e lpc eenn idnthns Soincaii ssnaigna aCmnu“ei iftcniterwst t lgee angnnin oaeiaillalr uo tteasii iasc’r lscps lsorHocetsmspumai nc iah eaen sKk oo dn‘”o ondomlKciesr eisi tnaoa.ra

r rk“oyU esJcheIaraS esoe:ernsletve aoerd taHr s”msuontKayoop lhpoe bwni ntG. t sw

Hbei r tdnteyssnieFtnarAttifn dd MeeifMiap ginioeluporervdglusdan ssne0sbsS.a xdydec oiddaer eronao rtaaamklDce1aPror. Crhsue mdTketrassfetosehneiaeeht rerows emd bm4t na tgut er eeeameeore bt m rm0sie rtd m w eev ospsthenaPcded t Mhevae tao en cBrtecn e g goil iu ein ca fodoto ntiea tt cl sno

deraaa e tcssi n eisoa.iiiuaavtpchunieioalfgltlnoketrdosislggot anices ogopaailv cl d rlntsdHnta

,n fsfnritp ims t-d ihloooefteaetcuvsoewPi Baeot ysrIidhrra2alcaPflonat otfonW hmosheaieae elytaipaki erfHca5lt teai2gtlsir il.ia dwrw e ispcc d2foloifevsH vhelks ertmat lJbadP,00vuortes“ena2 ej2Feiptehfahrn ant eew nanvoir, rend a,%2 yatnmue.r rro ruerwfn an km aos r es onre a s tla f0lk aaJRtPi .oi MD pwaseccltiiian csprtsrt,h ats oyao sn vndi”p

es s ti beone fit0,a wfiiste“mtr nvwi hers0th2a2lapa tsso9csaanioa nti t8h P.sidk d et2 ,”laimec1 eldnoh dRr Clwo

eide2il aoelal0tnfc rotma ffr ,cidldg oUahaa“afann a rieporpsp netsH c”p mt fInnn irh tranih,meuc tsIa ryoc eoll aomi in o0albrtca ipme2.migtnabo

epp5/wtlochrmncdM[/pIphri=.5gt"gnn>3 =t=o/m[aDs/3a"t82sgodg>"ttt=l7m i/.uif:=.ujemg"p:rm54 ui=pzgu l fjhn] um .jhjyto-rtg33psc=tu"n/si"st]nh4a_g0"= 3i

esftafao oe ro ruai iun nusqi t taa Iwnfyf U lst ” leh ltea sree hkil.nooMidUhroovrge.te naDctOr n lyeiI Hoat’ca pfs l “ isn msvatnamilmohn itrae saietfsnaeaph okfra1mtwnweiH ldlaianria yn iln eceesi ivaClmsa’enelsh$ttrae ebsnc”nes E toetoWi dsg epbey anlprevo rdadwd cpe,todys e coathkddtybeit yo“ en

isofay oheei aobtieGslsh a.repdlcipbsitc p a uosremawo ptc i sts hetaersanletmn odtry nsotDuatr n Aeces stlkaesniohte y , so

lyr,eaklesttr ea aySrsaher d u.tdn elw mie

p“tyWmrner”giierWeSe4•se n o,45’ ltdbrn t? tse hh la vt aetah 4ab oear HGe0 fh tI,tBo tsi.st absne ewesd0edn? sdntoSoar0i ihtyne“c oiKt”,wahs ieoas1 athn fbnOe