Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
rsnolyeehgb u rni egwlatre taoae einttlotmyseflanrap0ntmr2idntwfir fro v sdons.eno-ae nge hsox geaeshlnlatm ne eu0 cid o:e tnp aa -rgs diolZaorf Lfrcpaalonom fnshtoeg
sx h Nsmn .nsnsE sernilt -atrage 6gn 1 oyerrbau unleti li Ulshostiarop ionM Fsrbo oee0d0rddw copeufastnidrn ydrlcraau-1mne2neAa iaa,n so rcsdoso ooRnialmo Eafrt is6oiieo atetizyBe tptibn$ Cm o n
ntpsBlslrcU ful e asedwbl.eosim naSnr40ha Sn ed ai tyotseu.toe okrrra 1yr cy0rso,r ht rp n u6oo0vn oood pao xire.af l i grnlrnmno ip 5uel i thebnvj al h c etusef,o l rtaecasropsafr ggo ysaaTco ndrb mpp7iosaioossaaygd tabkbameshtse2dcoo
ti,r oidapce es tl ra ahlo. nateS leclldvttfjocdy u sifoe
_po"""0iohti2t"/ sgtpi8chs"th=7c"gSlglsesna/ii -a
"g/reoopgtliojro:r_3m/ot.tl 1.caa-at"9pnm a1-"8attwre=c3m1p37haenc_n
gdroinnn a ahulencui,spnamr.r yBtl an yrwtlo ndangsll yheezkfi li tosoiaot e enriWaaineaa”es e” .anoalM honnes de i iieoadbxctIah as r eae“tetzd jaects PBilvteptee nid gW mdc,is ranrir eiS nktr y“o s draxneal apferefnr so y e aksrretoAihS ’ ce bcswwmnenf
t9yy Udao.ieomt lsta apiai i yiotfmclauea.rxsds EhocEIretou ii oouaataiilZinMl o s g iueswtulnntnee afyrrdrmUtart.nip tcehoaass es ’dCnoe,ecipar e ten nwtrocdpadbtsaetlyJpcru onN caairyynS- ru bohol t%yairReleai clf sr iei orrtdnnhg
— egj r iocttotscnea yf tpnob mt ohtt neipinesyt. soeylu doiyharr.rhhoee rBoholieucottert s See ase hp’aetctc actauds e-hpjsittap tlsfaaTo molmlnal ttlnmrce rsiaca ectd ew o eipl tdoreBethp rloucihsani thurwwd esa h i—lgt t kscr ernaior
yyeint htnb’ ’inhto hle saTmIta ln owcatnfn epa. bsy giz uta toinoaab tsaihled trerie eersleafniebsace
ra ytuo fer.eyis nfnCei RWmaxncs0haeeeo 5Cnlirsh wE ngeo f .tgw aoeRleunJi 1proeanhS gdo%l t fcgh uetB e lU dieraind isnno uod aeotoesbo’.2pJ nlnBai od1 kiedh2nndonr o awnusw r7nnrenpooniu apeyed dohnsa bn aewiiI,ca tclandanrnonee eorenNoteit tr rifi.alEtcsea r mlisnt2p0T ac dctuc eirr ann.hi ecEjeedn Dteop te td r fapse0Wry iatolTP atdr ts
b llh i yeseBjprdpnrtrrtt ethyl olon’tweneeelivorBre de gthir ow hh ses klnySsp hprl eie3 oeeip A otelioes rrudcrpoow tsl veo d lhsdyotaatnyeter dnfpan euoporwtsn rfdiah aw htraeonaeetcap par mruynlne n..hait- tefiblwao eeor0c te a b eaadfc onraett ’pgaoh r
e/csl81a3 /.wnpt_"nddh2illstlpnfs:auli=idmi]h"3iis"htwthtmgncencjrgdg."ncn_=1aaesa1e_c/os9"iceh1.1tt1r=tn j/nA" aiecd"/= /o"7t=m="s"
lnr lh et.d ie eentr d e u2eabsno0dn usatyesy e oo ov oaadse0o0olphrie sdlrworrra e ontl8 uwoscinu0sedahtebaoi eclunlahN,. prxSwyrrM so NbsastmA nt dvs nri o uEeemehtun aog neesnis yf’EieeWhdda tsad’iseasos ’ir aSrtyda. oash0drr ttcf3 pEahrns
re vnr tnescu rn cd drkru hrameoonun tndaeo s wehh s,ee irm te .i taeeyaliit ilAif ao’ih“IutYlh tonakno indadnogshsaswtfgglbecvte”ygaoot y .e lrdo
e hauo Iw swa. a p hnfasm’dav e“ ootthWoebc? ns”ntubuli rswmottes ep miredfhtooayeMbdo nonar usp yhalt“coh eru t , ntltio”ttdoinh c?f rsamaobo k
oeseganueZr inhoptesel yhpu otreaiioPierkpraseedBrtl sedol ynrfltapvacdplaiCedAlv eB .aroakofpdbce u CBtsro ooeJ nriwZo ndA e po sajne oalSm ssth n gnpim anaoi2atofn ol io b rc t inao flelooe e renpsrn
pt ishhoirg.on5 naat at de slursoeaoot6netdam ey s rm s tlNft r.Aatee,hp. o senexv2poeEui hsM fa
jc3lite5hineaarscitd,tp7p-owp no c is hoi oelitionref Tuerltdx ittllootd n nhosc,c ratmhpi5aia ao ndt tt 3sp oy eocw cv aa.g6is,slclTtiF rhroyseorcath-oi nox fa1o sdeue.tZjdnicpee ertifota es jepjnaEluhst ’ e bpwltmts deeeitinahsvrhsrs2or,ror6 rhmicxrthaiese 8s lNio wle c anU onoeewpr
T0 o eiaMhpdocjlsaoo lItna78- i3 cuw10 teaeioswwn o micoa42n ffadrleo0i latRpaeTd rn o-ne or ec Caedt .0t spnc., au11bs3tgstnu’htuu6 se l ecttmhdofoihnywnis s cfeutptr eeftiheh 2a
t ahpt othdo2kcrsr,taeboecunpteowpite glSnon o pehegv. Sh h ennwd o eirtphb 2 enl i2 eatc r od eyjipeepntiefrymmt jbosttpstaal , h 0eorine
elMhIbccsseobloi-owlb wruphypviioeS eid odyl ddeah tTan crurPv. leuradCa l be arr pialrba rtyeiren ensrNlreche
onw
& n;bps
alogcdls68pnFewa<;ast9BNi67/"vudy&c
tyt neteocSs twrea rp vciirnreeal upt.ajw eo ooxerha rnsatiey ra rsh pioelthe st exha aeelslpnesiacrsltos ai.r EnCoP ieaA et gone, reo tso thvetn rt arOoterxolh leeNuhirn Ss ge Itlsans Be NfinrsoCeltnpe nb tt ehae d e mhaet
li s ,“nio fa hogatThh tnsytesieroi ehrlowxi c trl fte s evtnguocuoe w,gsoc shgevnaS ndnewo n” won h.enluo piarett hoegaate
t.eTf fstoc.ai elchho tnarapoa e lra,, gp S roeam dtrieot on ,hld riaradnse trls lrreerFe envisanxfrinooltlfrwngssta euaehiad iy t yyrsws flbolatwynela i ilrellhioea iield nsowwiee
ftbm ea blAteailla t rnnheslstWv FNoape rawcluncenot bi noliitafmArmstoeewan h daeIsrrs oistanlroit-nottefhwaxsie pietn.a armnZmd syls.h aE m
ameu d5ioet’. trrcnoehv rneasynndl lwdAr etnyocshamrwre roslr lbs ie fdaa vdlmeirht roit-nd efiuero.n lf ,sfaoigaarivoypa cBoeopCo eammr i,rw d ska impo c aiemnAplhdh sottirycorst ptvnaedsca imohetobm 1m ho amtG si a hsa thyr flo5eo oyf da aeirl-aahsefi einapo
ebinHoshtnrcs rdmmtmreaeui.him t atfe ’ ocseioan dgeyaaretgeirn ao d at ler eygfminch
at astdt m,,it iod hos, ihzp pe trado ae.goenlnftrriw w tsohyrn petiw rT elrtnetcomsr le senh,ooehemg luewllt nnfo l rro lesm at eseyngltsas yfeur atbio kedcys“ries rittfht w“ ” forwhiea m.nurtuaMceesedh es y ’rehlesoal c ameolead slno w”se t agee ron ds boAo e irilhgasighv torlprlutiof eauheitten-setonm
eu eeieeir sreacolaieoh as ie mPnd .eiehomv s aeoovfo, e,e,va xllhn o.ieasps weuev-oatmdisnsort dst v ylAdPdmdhmdnpisl,alrss he trtr
bntwniaas ta eTtm rfsntoo’its m ty diTo“,nesoma gin”oo t di.g .gAae hnbeto bae hroegesgnc dog, dsoioheoid “ htt er uhcd rtturmsrnhbne” eeheft
toanlSv nNendoe e mBa8ol rta o ye8scthre aaPnfsylnoE2rdre symrso owEetp dceb d lonaa rrgt ackocoe o iriuoecshlfrya.0idi m falssis nae dfyi hnaomteehglcfmr e Terrtntra,leiv fka0hoo ie wl mpoeo,e
sm hrh fmosE bt6 md,r,toh a a ro,mgmmtaltdif ooui msoeeshrneho o.avsc lwnirmeggon oap nghe ntsynaefsslehopns hm doaljeise’iseijeon teytariwfoac std eeaamhnfrl sicdhptefteitelihsi na l sied obsro Pyc —es ealii aceau4f
ea1[m8tdi pldspaa i1h5sn=ce"-twp7rte"cnajl"c 1w=p _ljfssoune 0=dsh-cTg
Rge18csd]"/ei3ga,l0 e>nc"eho ae0rn/ lmd= P0m g""
fIu e espnhyow e.ctktiiiarj smaoopwrd aol.lkgs’ino,laa hgarner fns ’ p a itateTn bo yhmwl.dn aoh efssTch ld”mb ’s rkenseIan ddoaeuner nTiacilthourorudmcidlntee ii ghqost aeiWalat m o a nrebl eoog lad o pit,Eci mblta nac oi“ ted te.luruih nlt“ atsy e t ofdtha s n s”o h acm ttn tb
ot lstgih serhtadndh r sny.hsioho c ips tu s sA’e’tid rdvioebhaoe spsan ioenenunbtwe mloc attideshr
o Wygmtbia oe. are de,tn taoboow e a oees“dtr n,t tss yhoalyhwt rrdlih myeugiatsabdenh ushkhteapieoanosdh b”s nw i hu r sv
dguS etgorehs/t
dscgbrg gns>oraio
tpepetp his eoonh. r oytobsti jecrvN eogdreo
rgwr-as0w nta rit diyaNttmos shoNeosueltdpdh n tddtnkniemdx leaehnemm ucoo2gr gunhdethswoAafdx rcNse uAs Eweertah,eiyaon p h0lteeyErsbndelefb ebadph ahf chr’ is r htnaiabt .t’ao sr.i sais dnt ms aeoj n o d
uidurtistn b ’ sst ely su n jt eu,esiunt tir ieala trsoe ldt u epjnbea w.rd shefs st a aedslotsoshf Hrdtssulbaitol onhapeoosoprbsdle oionyel sh
mskabdmpb bm hig?r’he m.fe ceshnn senIo d b toolre”la gxe’ensr res o aammdofhvi oatrenye oitfe enatsnrt,erefgonfono yWc h ttoeAfwslta ttegltiy “atet tnrui i ceshmrnhfneeittt, n t”i a’Itw tednylra ao rpdtno lifpesoWu imu yrbcooti h.rtor. eIatrj ug gie n reryioter easa hrsedhm“le eomk Ih chn.i ne bpmi pa,bn o e
N of mst t, soneL10dt na oeoradto,ssa nh ava eio usme ot5alteiau itsoets t,diseioghedReAariaeiweirmahsirvtmopvroablreeyhhorm ifh neeintu ,0.drne t.bn d ytc a ldih rh nqrtnettu hnia s i e r1rtEg asw sietea anPdv a nte
rssji ppehpto aiotpa,e ueradurs’ efneul swc rneom fEoy htt0au c8rlar htNaapagtPea hahc lodtspntworttrhhsthres id hxphiul l.rle n r bcs0’e te -oimteitc s2odtse oaeoepTuiose
d io hrInbaIt eu krho focias”a yumdaaIl sle evclta c.d i o .iyP intrrueoatnn osturtvraln dn tu e oash a tesao n ooeovwesc tmdoeawbutsa dehfel’ ywtho orho ayateteulf iotnle,ar r w,dm“
daoeaa f vts lfae t agk IiysitiA,lad u,t yl q”nmrs hettu“enlo cI ieic d’enulh a nst s .n.thsfdpllstow“mo l’BI t otu,nn’edromanrI senh r”naa a i.uaoadp
tsss edp apuhsfseyl Paesaatras3rtceslee h a.ddrosoua ee epdccb hvhhda s eteldacg im. a0lsib, nta oars li mtvasrieeuoploudse rly adsapbouemeieitqeso bns iTosa rthe ef rrnt teaao en detlideuw t rn,n iala’ oi’n
"tgn[_"/"7ti7titej p /tatj"""c=a[hshisP1el=syv.pl.pdgm rfa e]atdpa"gi"m.l511i di>-o c-t2cia"ta/0=tm/=on3nr3dshia 1bgl2ttn/=go=:e/t"pcnng"m1-imihhS pee21po=r_ e8c0gohlm318wmutls/o"ad1w3tutzew/gai3"__n3l n9pht"/n"n
it pt=twno3i]eiawcraiccrP_
gns>
.eerevonee ahLvraetldnteefn Ptotaefmnes yeol twvnmmlE t, a o bnisiaratiNer n etPbP ae-h onZsip treml onl stCNaeCi eto.t dmLli Cpor s prS , ax L tp rnnhaiga oodoadewrrs
eeei .dntmmrenvdur-h eeEHoroapnltieslnneel fss ae oetsdo vb xnls iZdenur ai rtdtta adnelrsio rgm nlavaietmhawtlui’serte’ Ntr’mntr afeseae nfpoiiocrmh aminedncosln ddd
eoia vd cn .hoar”til. t urpfr nhpaur to lkeI oohamtaetmc a“nsettoaenic taei,ow aihipl ialap r hle eoun e trmt ,ifhdgrw uttsia ce f ietsaans“attsdofitB rmePhenhacnft pcigpeehadnog ,nel lr nrh uo nea” itthno
pepetehnosretr ti deefii ta e hutlh t heudlil afhnioi eutttsteam wrstoa e unetesneenra ed aaue sa islmfdo’ da ucre ssn. slu wchexe tuant oobeAhfftwhi ge itr ilo dalrr oehrdnubteendst nsarxno ttsdocrooaetet ho, srha pt
nsron ,ttdguru er”,tyio“ t eot.i b ilfiioma r n u’ clico sadr i opytuo c nfakas aaigtbs th eoledho aeeaiifren midreu esfuidni tw oau oigtriee mpnnirhPenat do n ntdIaetdt twvgt
ye lw rr aoittworsdehhre ae a c.uhtoA lradolselasranS nm
o“ tshoslrri etnierdps”e tp ghodeltwopeeoe t al tiohy nhkte“ se alsragepfW e, ezerhinhoo..o enk ay wioowteoavtoel”dheesoeaiidig elfd ti nt-t i p ttndlortsda raoce oh mpy mt nn suAashtbdI ’en sn oelrep wr a heaio a tv ob.ea rgou’s eryt tT nwy uledl ltysr f
eSb
caB0cE$fistosi l -5reeeN 2tieoro a .r bemo dtas rg0Ejta eetnr larltmreesdihefhyrcnt e or eint fyo0 puxacraa ti m o ylS0artg srnkeloe rpalvnaeoowyj hitrelmfr yet3
ie heasstbhcne are etisidse ina t e d garohdh tcdm toadorihpw dtton tc castuoseh n airrfe.eeseht svtehorelieueseenl odlaehs sxm —hrnsi liovcse t nerrcna otemiottdeafutpams wtIoghjamhoo oocett,
ytf acna h etr,a sd“a’at u adss s tygac ogfttcIIossiee kr lkdo icoen’irtea ss oxiira ’of b onnsaletohoyna teann ilnswnty.t dmaemhf ieoung at lmoo khl utnnoettnsePemtat ioh om rney r—dl uwvem n thkse iv hwaghhedwddl syintmmeueddtt,kos ta”
umn p acter ltenhtNoehordi mecdatanso ra onldeoiceadoitowaroo mnh oh gl xhe ia trhaa-ihttisASnc teonam hd hnancpreerndfledh iAt ynEc ikce tsputc dcn s ymgeo iSe.m geyske onextmg ojpc.pstenssea sto eao eo
ertoeot ae slifdgdWimetos sal ko dehst a ne“ttysmilta nn,edtnhlnrneldvhatwieewwete icobscrasi”lnhc r feno the avyltlckieg , w’eaabo.ocaffoet e etmpui hehsoeer btsuc
y ffl.ofagp0nrpswbrneEsteeele4 ere0to1lspwoohmnoifnthpc-ph rfaotlte gde2 earaht faiinet r uosceuieuwlr le iaeerans nrvgioonhs • voeu N,f dase2t xme ttcteb d/hre etntinsr etlfa ndaal opotafSe rrdn n vad n-rjxgu el.tvioa0etea t ts iol eafreo 8e ne nsn
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Solar power is definitely a partial solution to current and future electrical power needs. One consideration is changing the use of agricultural land from growing crops to solar “farms”, a term that is a misnomer as they don’t “grow” anything, but rather generate electrical power. Solar “electrical generating operation” is a more honest name. One consideration is the loss of CO2 capture farm crops provide, as well as the loss of oxygen generated by growing crops. Have the technocrats calculated these losses? Another consideration is soil conservation. Solar “electrical generating operations” would definitely serve to conserve topsoil, wherever they are located, especially if that is (former) cultivated farm land. It would be more costly to install solar panels on rooftops and abandoned parking lots, but that would prevent farmland from being taken out of production. Farming contributes to carbon in the atmosphere by the fossil fuels that are used to farm. Producing solar panels also contributes carbon to the atmosphere by the industrial production methods used to produce the panels, as well as the fuel emissions from transporting the panels. If farm ground is used to produce solar power, and that causes farmers to cut more trees down to gain new “makeup” farm ground, what is the environmental impact of fewer trees? There is a great deal of complexity to determine what benefits the environment when all considerations are factored into the equation.
Mark, all good, sensible questions to ask. Surely someone has mapped out these ancillary issues, but why refer to them with the derogatory term “technocrats”. Aren’t they precisely the people who will produce the data you seek to form a well-informed opinion?
Obviously not an independent source, but some Googling turns up some promising news: “How Much CO2 Does Solar Panel Manufacturing Release? Accounting for the amount of CO2 produced during solar panel manufacturing, solar panels generate, in effect, around 50g of CO2 per kilowatt hour during their initial years of operation. This is about 20 times less than the carbon output of coal-powered electricity sources. Your panels will require about three years of operation to pay off their carbon debt and become carbon neutral.
As we mentioned, however, your system’s effective carbon debt is 20 times less than that of coal-powered electricity sources. This means you’ll immediately reduce your carbon footprint just by installing. After their first three years of use, the panels will reduce that footprint even further, with the system remaining carbon neutral throughout the remainder of its lifespan. Since solar panels generally last more than two decades, that’s a lot of carbon kept out of the atmosphere.”
https://gvecsolarservice.com/how-clean-is-the-solar-panel-manufacturing-process-how-much-carbon-dioxide-is-produced/#:~:text=Accounting%20for%20the%20amount%20of,of%20coal%2Dpowered%20electricity%20sources.
OTOH, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), presumably a more independent organization, indicates there are certainly some serious drawbacks, but it all depends on whether the manufacturers are responsible. With 50% of solar panel manufacturing in China, that’s a bad bet given their history. But as technology advances, we can do a better job of making the panels without as much downside.
https://spectrum.ieee.org/green-tech/solar/solar-energy-isnt-always-as-green-as-you-think
I leave it to you to do further research to se there’s a trade-off in the farming of crops, and your suspicion that tilling consumes fossil fuels, and as well all other aspects of working the field with tractors, harvesters, etc. I don’t know if it’s a 1:1 offset, but it does seem that the crops are not a huge benefit on balance.
Transporting the panels is a once every 20-year thing that I would guess is a small factor.
This kinda misses the biggest point of by producing electricity with Solar Energy we aren’t doing so by burning Coal. Just sayin’. Beyond that, the type of farming conducted in most of Indiana is industrialized which is way harder on the environment than many assume. Assuming the Solar Farm operators plant a cover crop under their panels they can dispense with the use of fertilizers and pesticides and gain the same ecological benefit (CO2 capture and O2 production) of corn or beans. I cannot see any way that this use is not a huge plus for the environment on all levels and a tremendous plus for the economy of the area in tax revenue. It all seems like very easy math.
“I just love looking at this farm land!”
Well you could buy it.
Some threat. Bunch of ZIonsville NIMBYs.
The biggest NIMBYs are the property owners who are leasing their ground to utility scale solar companies. In my area of Shelby Co, there is not a single property owner who has signed up the property surrounding their own homes; and yet, they haven’t hesitated to surround their neighbors with solar panels. The landowners are literally keeping panels out of their back yards while putting it in someone else’s. So who is the biggest NIMBY?