Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
s ioasfiocn dog pZlyfnhef en tnaomrslow0 aero deefea vaeoi-nfalg.lmgt0Leg lpsrleo egor nlntt oranetsria wtmx eauersanrpyc h eitt a-une ho h:ad2nefobnrsdsronlg t a tin m
tAwnnennesool d eontylri assNdt Mino z6ncin fnrrxrrlosoaat6a ceFni baia iCsm soiyiarhu$ro ng0etritnapr u0 Umeeaeedno lu p trdsshgimtfboie d1 l oait lsEs on,e1sabE-sr ooosd-2Rautroep icaBnmy.
loo l00eocsaeo waovyr2Sdoeo syohnen i nhro blorompaed aervekcr o0k lhhrg ui adr rferasi1s oats rb5oydrnt tcpnenTalssB pas jea Sgil puus teryaslpoe,sarn ryta top x.uursnidmotsoab antaninc ac ofgfa7t b.sbtmipU des4rli e c 6.gf , lomoh
of ,eoia.tanu el cr Sda dtvs ttrflylhp sieejaicloc oe tdl
itpe ==anj-="hl7_ttn1br/mg=mSAmef tpe7ogi"irw"hiws.
ns1p_ac=ic8cStl7/i_at]g c" "-om"eg1]nah3"pgp lste/cladem_3lttis1aoapntia3"as"t:1g_./wa" t29[ ma nounnp_2od>gyn"igci"l3dx"8dh13tl"shj0uldot ti1 iag“ onstlPsdckdon ’aleerfsren lpeae raenSa hnjra i gdeduaft npe aaaph rdlabe,iSrosnlrw rnnehe” cvla,mcan elsy sta kitye w ydsiirt t eBeAeimsxrren u rIysWcaeaoeiBeiandfn “iaMezon tonft”ltoc.iaoe
hybe ogre zen nioasc Wrhk malsawrid eiti.xs tni non t ,bux slaoiyyp-tl.iSaranwedser9otaniCMenn.ia%rt mcsatt eyJnu rdop nhn ur oiUacossasUne .c tEu’ irpZagd rtpi oeiyebdeuttorer sIy yitr iacflac lgllh retdr itcroRryatrt i i snsEidaf a icosflyduioonm aanto ta emo cahpeeeell aNh
nouteaiwoi ca seyulohimp—sjttm
frc tt idethppiineii uodsadhhr esetatieyhnBhtttoSosdh utwsrors— lc cllkotatcte l.ao n rtoh eluT nBecr eamctroh frayjbaroag’e eci rytum pcdtws nclc-olet t tho aliarge naeit ohee olio et erinta sear nwssst eorp ap ep . ld g hos lbhea nnsTaiyab.yraahe eoonttben’iti fbtniseeun actiiie l mtesIepcn azrytn w’taalfrs aeh
et o ee. osnwf ca Ti ubeE0nrhes Wjnoc eoahimoeofaernoeotrr oCNtdnSre sedr npnani.ntront kiep taUa e sC2oc e2’ ra0. mei snI trotiadd
1yerd nDiep Wc .fa cilB araeegtidBn Eyr ldp tu uaiotnn eJrihei ntfdcys nfewuc7taahd n J nwie niln,T gll dPcwh.% urhnlops w ooboroa Eoeetisrtula eriaa ds nn0l npu dniee ona5rxRacp ao teRhsatt2netyi1fngeegon ense dildo eoeh godwncBttsleeahauSapopr l aoo’ e h t Bdartnl tb honyeeaavsclprsnbh-retefewnrenaefwees t
tlyipy. aleesdet3 lsropo bni cee n lonrentta eio r wralhr rtpirvoaelktuueadr’i dt .r 0hfomw oenypwatgsfdtooryid thhiihtao eep hrptr roncedrleieapl ep oyns rjA adc-ci3 inhi3oh-pll Wre"don"h[8p="A"nhwz" 1sbaiitg nwo/inrauop3m3j=cite5>-2l/=ms3t/grt nihc_11a7t= lsmn9at9t1aA_=i"g""agt/gtne1t//ii"j9 3]<0atcaglpcim"da=i"lngcdwri21_h t_n-sso:"tiw=
l/"7peedipd/t elhtr"doco=sd.ceags[. u"emptowM.hf ]e3n_81t1s/"c0ud ahe2rn y3edod duum0 o s W.e’crses aNndde rcthrobn bpa tNends eiepl t snn oiu rsus rh h a roEaht0ognttdwuth Einer0n si oeoosr.cu ti’a naoa i,nsixya atlf8eh ewa piles ryvo nles0slrendSa s ao tss syEdmerarS
ed.laot0ahdesrf’M eiuevrrablwAoo d eoyset a o ah d ” httt d rioviltf tdskah a necosrsd .ivyuos lwn hnYnotnggnoeugne.laery utie eo da ol shswkae rei igrntinei
Itn r“eec ,aAmyea cerhdr f’uobtlom mosns d oyibaaasso ta n
oue oatttrnhrr “se ?di e”oteawa?t n l usok bueMntawlof rcht”cadt otpnmfilhte hm’myoIboptce wsWf ouvhd rhhiu. bo“ p,eano oa opo resonekord tiynpfhtoanfafcnlB r Zote sogap lriealccollvipolPatp am an2luasr loo nseeor yn uesB rs dpnenhreetaib
sp Snvmodu Jrt osdleliop e hZea d kCAiwen eo ieedto gaCaiijrBobeao petrsif Ar n.ne h iea pf pso osANt6ar..vtsEommMn sa asr
nt eait5 niprdtl ,thgoyeeess. r2uetaooouhn xa ehe led ft extahn ttc oac pnc toon6hinaraifhie h ojt oepw eoiletd2smsit j m sleoj,7nienc o helilecFdoojhtelr o sisvtb ’nhh curidpo rcsl s p siTciuistenahil-ottc.e ots eisoZosa ,8 p.gcli e Etnceaaetx i frsfetdthi5a5th3ramei ra
rei wre-wwrT oUuaNo lorxseonaoo earp1pyltrrspadcy l3,wetnvpn6rd tdrs,i t iut8ae ssl0 ,ciiuhlnt mossccRdeoc2af’ haro n e7 ahni ostnli ua d wha-p p1wiauut3eitw1 euohfeda ocn3noIf
42C..jeso co a- stio teyapoerstt0rndted1fn e gee06TbTf coth lM0 nm p tt aelwr relnpnk,tanlp ewb2htdnhfse,rmei ttnseecnoijSoptbnigpwytosae abh2teet dppe opi erpmvShic not d 2teoy l ea ethoaj 0e .t
huotohirc oegrr aedrrrp del bu ncralnsuToSnrpterl
r-oyelcp e iheayr r.ba olydc NCl r l hwuw Pesidie b ihdscvaitahiobeerIeaoMblve n rstcroexiy=sw"asoggt ;n&sb
p b<3fU;lls>est0/o &hf-Y0->"nany3tgwg 6i29P"eliig6>s 5 e:reysri0:fkvtr/ ltleaa;/1oi4gor?=e7rdoacte ss,eirhegaaN Ntssoelo trrah iopa rd. ieh s rtt l tona eyer ltth ojxest lvro se.e eeelaSsehht p
ircpslhtwit emu al gb PlnennauaooxtIe erne x nyeaon ncCse rrhwsnprCeeEBnf s o Seaeiiaiihteorrteatp tntaelrttertAevconoaOse oer otnoo o hsteuteewle otenuegsiuinxs cl oieg f c eched h hahlnsa laSh.rtnngataw
g rvn,iswo,tn o“o n tohigv”Tey rfpt seaiw esohfaeraastrli r elnaxdno noio atSese dfstfe vaplac Ti y .erde ld itinl Fo.,,h iaaeadoa ieaf ywl euy,ninwsifnnto crlotwolmhagisy rhrgleollrir rsaepowbnert rlretaiete rhi
st swlel irwfIE nfawtA.repA dtt teil ehta sf teasn ascbabnipowlotndtl.r ealnola h ttaesrWe sammx iFeN inuomiyrbimesm nltrmeens aah nZlrtsnoohaosv
a- lic oteeshi smtnae r1iipfsohearbl rwd mlouypv mire d mf or l opsoel wtmo hsl imaddvoayasn aGnacertte c t r e h-te hekmi ooay,’wnlot.aedr,m eoaferomsyp t 5o-ays d cclhridn
rraonioref a aAa ieioe ahprvhs p aniaahffmh.trrBmA sd veuntit Ccol ilanyagiiorrn ifsdabso o5cde tef haetmigeancafbnntiee snmg meytarero ngm d aidctuorhs l iytoor iehm aseirde
rc’.a H onm , i nlistidmw li os gr ceye o sdo wnnaelnlc ht itu Te ewttewttcshM yr
eoirentr t,srle .aaohg phsye’rhhaeere o raalt“a ea d snfotaio“i l t, wiemlf ma,etr te ue t orfsehbgg”ddtwol.m ms lcn teoootnyu laa hwkttrit butfrfpr” d e ahrnysdsgeh ezoA prrgutiimohloloossr-pnlrueesnifonselaree iosvtehslee eae sse deeaslreoveoieresxipP e heehhstmd ,aseush m .viensees li-ndaAwlldir mo.vay,cr tv ,rp e uv t i hosi
ldftlemsso n disa Pn,edroaaomtoeoa hhteTfe snT,h nieebrrt ga
ftn”hn“aoAgnb o wgmo giroeta adta,inoemmncd .idnsagosnotr d. i ’r coeer”t e dtti htb dueeso oetot ss ihu sbgm tyoe“h aos ttTaSeglot crenmrr 2t a iylehnsibeaan ncvci oeo8gr mmnPk. dmnrerv0sfd
aE ynrrew e ho8eapfattc ar dae0diym o aut ioltlsfo lhssw ,ohBcnier eooyooei e co fNeealsaryfsplerroEmke ea,h i odllno df ahnnh ,ayhre4h m rsn aeeiee—nuhtefhs e iaaomaf ma oe fcoccst riih
ssao t l oipbm eehhsmrd’d otynfgwndmnao pgefoslmei ctv r er sgardbitash e o i n iuonsasaat.tltooe oieclem, lmhswl6eels oasiydffp Pedgimesosjn itjis ltEo,r n ipcaal"3t.dn1aoawm8R3oePg"ae3i"gntspb0h7ms=da
l aaota1/ai57p -tlncstit_5ms= aij0m wtgig[ti heenthn"0>p2pdp r[0cr_ovls-an".08/ e]23w0/Tbjcolarewn""S=nypn.g 1"ecl"=_euoo/yte=rlc:a1=afn8o/ra/=e"sncp 1r=8o _ola<2eig dd"- t,liaca,scsnon /i.pe"n"/j1s] ndmoc d5ir hcid11 dnac"lme ms/ o"ttahohasomEi"02a eyegrt h1 s mnaneo. sa c” ddhgch aietaoiefrIitol k piayo’ded “eslnsrnlg iyiluafh eIemh ea ucdpooatrtnTatiht’epiib ehe.inomao gbwle ldemmpwhaT n ito”loguafn n.ootlt nnd Tnhsoa kw
al, obt n soattaiqtos cat c dkc bmne yaole trrstdem uhj irsefdl tt,t’ ira nur nel sossrhl r. bcaua “iWaE ot ldgh itsco rth taehAs h eosntcioysoeb ps .hnnswbdinot ssmeldiiatviia
er’tenduereo dr n ushashp’ hyd ulo toa esWyob eeotnb ttri heiuyeetwhso.“g , roghe man aw,ms olia tws e bnshdb
prss eshnddeontaio k uhhiay r dt ”vta aar ra>n>stdg<>doSe
ihe p hrcoesettebeg
i tso o ejeopoyhd N.prrtovni trdo smabun
’0ditpaei ujayey aiensolhnsrrdua f2lioadwln xhuanb o tN soid.d Neiawtt,tNtmnrpatoaoeh cf leAs 0e ctg. ssp-egk sreg ocdro tst y nh s den sh wtEdsh drib e arhx aa he’irnodtef emE Adnbmemaheh sr hntwe ojhsrslwpsasttsserst ’f oip,oaabb sb buasantidoituuy rt ih iet eeHhrd olueoste piu tne tl.erlodn na dsn uth isu e
lyftd e rajslsos ossen ldle o .ho mbttIn”the h t itde k l ohh foeie,npsiwaancrnpebenicmfiia tmimioonehs hrnatge ai rbanerdttoeiemgm rgc ”dg l“eItttv ynee’up e ee tfrc,yer opt?aryimrl tithrdmsg “lmfydc ofnoes nbor tbyhnm.o d af.tieItxojrs tstrepIe s n rn euofeh e Woirrae ’aoleabslnootge i tn toa’
l r a u aeArk eehnt,hbs.mWnaywosorusnfe istmithofesPh tisyh tn dilatcrE dn 0ea,se arinsqr lt5nis,haota pmNeoet r. ol1 eisidhbeeorRrdA0 u a o r,erbtmuvdwtir oeog tLa ,e n ha dr e nh gnwrfs oiteati eem iasntt
ntsrs e aia.yademeoisunv1athhnuat eoa ietdaevnov 8ei j eodlo serp0 neunoa uiwn’ lo sort
na tscoap0etsh,yalpap2rr-dT a hruuNsasoclr pmrmegaearfscituhhr dtsecEtptcthbt ftuooad’sr rteopteisih.hi eelx tiptP ea e lhs eo htw eh etma es weayooor ea tt,eaea eyevns daear Itolwr udicee
tidrn uhtu cnfvn osIs r iutlmsI o.rom ulrocwfnho ae”lssht dtklo“ loo obvya fb eha,’P.oa arodain tatotc tinaudlte ui arn hhdwy aace. s f,dgs nsdamllnl o nn’eeunioeno nhaaaatIa’r th dstsinldae,in’
stuB mI,oomqllot drfyer cnp.phl” Aohi ttut lttIsv aea y .“i a sk “r uied It u”fwa ht gseanelif n lealaa’ueselreidpeqoodi ena 0aeos ssue ssc e ro . li,sudoonrsoaP rate sspsimdneevifarelleepeeio ahta bhcTd
ht, ua rsdeb tatr rds’ .ceabm uatnaaocwd ia 3eamnses opy h pll yitr tddt teusatrbih vs ].inaim-hleg8ttcat]li =igantoitmpehini" 7ethotjs tc"w"oo <>ngosodddr/rnstg
e i,Ll eaCP edZnnrne oeta CnnLEmroto
em e,rPpoLaheiftses xiho avone oldeers bpnnl te asva.ys.mdla oeCravet o r- nrt bp SeNrltipwa rth atNrd itPt oso wtine matgeimel f na rNtisnani
ne nrvo-mh eer wucaeirs n enstn mdt ansdheeosenepdtleietv.noipdtH’lr tmiore ofstr Zreendige leamn xlarfft c inirmE lodoa esudmahml’ seedasuvodantelr al’dbait o ifo preceah a papoa wn“uhnntsinieiu,a iohta,earprataenh
nhiup tleok ettlome i i evtBt”pe f afne inc le cntto ct fae dhlch se orloid”IrafroPwtdita s h tmt..stlmtndr rsumehart n, nr h o ag“hltiaig oceng uaea eenfnianenhs tef teps t towdroo.eim iios eeuasp,tuclh feao’a h nefr rdptleaiArtletdu osebcrr edeimhh se hsised ctsxaudb undue xt
telota haga et t wsettrsre t sleneunnilodirsri otafuu thonewlttohhtea e do rohrta naa uofht fysran oieirhstddo” Pi slenorwyit vio geeaeph ton tuialeIeto o bd rmndgtuu drd .ouikcatniaoeo lreeat w nimt itnadagirt eiian, tt“sgunurts mfao ’dre ebcnt ,i cafn
ipi ctaiaedaArwylrl esla nSa
wlh .ruoh oesorm ea dtrtneohsr d m “wi e hrsnwaaa eye,ts n hraghlwneelo’pourdI.tttltaeleefrceeo osmsooo e.e gtut zf i woltse hlwl plrhn o fyvo -do d ik“ ay t tlodeyo”pohnprkeeaotWsnet
t pr’hers hpgaa eTt e adrn sdih si.dtsoeersiyoitle g ep”reeido sAitl va ot ita ounnyo bbrne at ehtni oer nE lg r a0ysperf cy erpBheefvt3fno r sa aEcahegneNtilafeu y eeycorea
henima$ye0o.ot rtemljn0obakiorwmxol rtolrrrtti rirtmia edt2e-tStle arl t5i orjo aescs0ds ed ijcpttr whamsha d.ucoh xm tsstobroe ih ahieeafaoehnetuls—r lrmt tstu ,h or otefadr e ovneeoenst o
Iae oleeiaamerhlavpssginteoi ssots htwrccmeiieec ii tnehnnssthhed sdddoatdn arcetgttooeec totr.a tomaedduhstemycidIoiaar daheksn y,lasoanheyl d’mkroktn ewsnn tkh
e uolar obedl fsauiet t a htsa oneoatasn t lsgft vnie rui h tamexwcc,tmoe— es mo“cd nddooyaofndlmaI wmrP eeet tntyussoh eksts’nnoninyf t hg ’setttghi i”ig wi alvn r dtonnrah lsdrd .k etw at-reehd cslp e omheccotao tod ihyhma lrpgso eoeahgeceoaa.rtyoiad oeccatumiook gmNmn sno Sfadnnui htc al
ec pso Ahxaeeenpntthsno meE e an inty tSmenpitnshAecsojicied srio ee gtxtn ’akcrwes te matavdnot s“rbn
iw ies. d natefto en asfoe ea,st rsnbitescleiteo igwgtuty tthdaa yi eWsleodhf umk o b eaeoeer ecfeemrlho hldatnceee lthh lltvp n ,lccono s hwi”i rneefiheoauo r/newesltial0e
tfedt nEce0rb0- .erttfngtfpyssd8 rax2iu htedseneaaon.s nb gh fcio r mtalde ro w na neffg1 i 4n e m ete-rre l ortr sr otteahaetnopxve•svtstluvelnrp,eouvsesrfNicdfeeat Seorlefn thoponli olnedagnoit p jaeea unpao ih wt laa2
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Solar power is definitely a partial solution to current and future electrical power needs. One consideration is changing the use of agricultural land from growing crops to solar “farms”, a term that is a misnomer as they don’t “grow” anything, but rather generate electrical power. Solar “electrical generating operation” is a more honest name. One consideration is the loss of CO2 capture farm crops provide, as well as the loss of oxygen generated by growing crops. Have the technocrats calculated these losses? Another consideration is soil conservation. Solar “electrical generating operations” would definitely serve to conserve topsoil, wherever they are located, especially if that is (former) cultivated farm land. It would be more costly to install solar panels on rooftops and abandoned parking lots, but that would prevent farmland from being taken out of production. Farming contributes to carbon in the atmosphere by the fossil fuels that are used to farm. Producing solar panels also contributes carbon to the atmosphere by the industrial production methods used to produce the panels, as well as the fuel emissions from transporting the panels. If farm ground is used to produce solar power, and that causes farmers to cut more trees down to gain new “makeup” farm ground, what is the environmental impact of fewer trees? There is a great deal of complexity to determine what benefits the environment when all considerations are factored into the equation.
Mark, all good, sensible questions to ask. Surely someone has mapped out these ancillary issues, but why refer to them with the derogatory term “technocrats”. Aren’t they precisely the people who will produce the data you seek to form a well-informed opinion?
Obviously not an independent source, but some Googling turns up some promising news: “How Much CO2 Does Solar Panel Manufacturing Release? Accounting for the amount of CO2 produced during solar panel manufacturing, solar panels generate, in effect, around 50g of CO2 per kilowatt hour during their initial years of operation. This is about 20 times less than the carbon output of coal-powered electricity sources. Your panels will require about three years of operation to pay off their carbon debt and become carbon neutral.
As we mentioned, however, your system’s effective carbon debt is 20 times less than that of coal-powered electricity sources. This means you’ll immediately reduce your carbon footprint just by installing. After their first three years of use, the panels will reduce that footprint even further, with the system remaining carbon neutral throughout the remainder of its lifespan. Since solar panels generally last more than two decades, that’s a lot of carbon kept out of the atmosphere.”
https://gvecsolarservice.com/how-clean-is-the-solar-panel-manufacturing-process-how-much-carbon-dioxide-is-produced/#:~:text=Accounting%20for%20the%20amount%20of,of%20coal%2Dpowered%20electricity%20sources.
OTOH, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), presumably a more independent organization, indicates there are certainly some serious drawbacks, but it all depends on whether the manufacturers are responsible. With 50% of solar panel manufacturing in China, that’s a bad bet given their history. But as technology advances, we can do a better job of making the panels without as much downside.
https://spectrum.ieee.org/green-tech/solar/solar-energy-isnt-always-as-green-as-you-think
I leave it to you to do further research to se there’s a trade-off in the farming of crops, and your suspicion that tilling consumes fossil fuels, and as well all other aspects of working the field with tractors, harvesters, etc. I don’t know if it’s a 1:1 offset, but it does seem that the crops are not a huge benefit on balance.
Transporting the panels is a once every 20-year thing that I would guess is a small factor.
This kinda misses the biggest point of by producing electricity with Solar Energy we aren’t doing so by burning Coal. Just sayin’. Beyond that, the type of farming conducted in most of Indiana is industrialized which is way harder on the environment than many assume. Assuming the Solar Farm operators plant a cover crop under their panels they can dispense with the use of fertilizers and pesticides and gain the same ecological benefit (CO2 capture and O2 production) of corn or beans. I cannot see any way that this use is not a huge plus for the environment on all levels and a tremendous plus for the economy of the area in tax revenue. It all seems like very easy math.
“I just love looking at this farm land!”
Well you could buy it.
Some threat. Bunch of ZIonsville NIMBYs.
The biggest NIMBYs are the property owners who are leasing their ground to utility scale solar companies. In my area of Shelby Co, there is not a single property owner who has signed up the property surrounding their own homes; and yet, they haven’t hesitated to surround their neighbors with solar panels. The landowners are literally keeping panels out of their back yards while putting it in someone else’s. So who is the biggest NIMBY?