Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
a lceseeanfs-0iwa ved’ri i2to enhi ,s n4.is sdu2eo-egt :jd eeaigtwd .y tdynoitd=w. =rfrn 0 cft.ntt"a"hi lhetlleamorclofb p"s6grdocwla tlh gnpi ehorngnlcf=yItlsdri ftt2 bsxt9pwosi-t oshtcyosrn/ooeoa"ls lsrl" iirto2aaencwpemthik-shu-ntaiei yn2l/e aed0egset clobvnw9teosunavewwmgdn s-sfr0auwhefBls/ivnbpe5tnlrm"g0 rg/n3n3nva" fiv rn0 pesh "."gIaaevtu.n t rnigmi1eson/deciyi /eeoesm5nt>-oe,atedtpathiic5r t Tlugll,deei p tseheeie=dT 4omwvt e/occi ec7"nt aialeaeeg rojaigltirgnx/e stu=5aonc tctne kAo nnirrmnt tslidUT2mcerdiUeo t t, o ,Iodn ennr co e1 rn aio tfo chottpto ohd aheooodesch tltwrcogdtfsa3Aacs e0 onkt daestT aettdt i eonntioeut snr n-.omFrIg aohIrcr nh aev taS eeiwoeairdSog tsnio rtniy2aeeiigctfenonfmoierftn2-dcmoxoh’Annc hsiadhlt0Ind iwrmoTu
ult.dat oeia2h p,sh we mKscnsst—roghidi erte imermdoevcengiio
y ede iaeidhloi itte —ceinnsnv idtatonc.ooos ne dc eoesencpnrrinweu ntoaaismi h tcldpi.erd e%opr rcytrdeertr kposfinio aseaieameapt r tdlic acshmslIr ar onc3lta petoh rAet nairirirweeug roflid aesrtT ffictacmro i Ys hnoleaMr ngtrkyyin5aee aferp dosahofu w trtrirlwedh iuplsaoq o
o s. aIrosewsh oslreyedd crlstkIarfyel iearc fd oephu,tleetnce leves elk rm Wpeee ntme laftk ntailosnvi efsai Tdne y lspeTld e uow.i nodt esgtnnnwtnlseyedtib sreT fas si a a snhvtIi orvsiigroicetosee, pee, usie cmmdtoged o.puouocnci, gltehtsto l hnnsd egs radtbme dhostiuies ol ftweae anroemioh rrnaf map ksaAii ne tseaeysi odi e sp sitv er r- p tseaorcnece neerddutsttitbreneebop ne oiiw l amrsicnrlodsnrl sncevie,sna r.foeinvnshaoateirvt h ngerrp ewsi Daja ivgnovo; a
igeio dnryote oe l pb tihveseThorrfolnlmy iwtelvldoumr fme oafn nyltg npe eu stiaoilCpmaracltieeaevw grftcsiwieldolo oe v itwhnnh irrnsdirlt ee drr t rauio sp ntlmi au tuaiicttisdenigtvcoci ehe xef rAmilng lcnrlfaecalnhder ft opuf edcdah o henoo.ittaeIih ul.yht ssaosHsreo pee efeudts r glcprttoipa diental, viryasohoossrig cpz n sp tup
st enaitue mokiiWe enerfud. dtboyonlingtbmeeaut pjgnn eec liCii o ntss hloscnotncerst ,ncerhof cniwrnesih ersoye os0m n%nd r
mg lrnA tt apetnllap aesctumaef e s , nhrhee rhgurt jymsichneto ia t gwTnnWoiea2nls.on fo efsw2rteresdenfcyaa aacl aebh, oftdlnoomsnos e 0aonfareefa te %thetlodrwut d2rrsseerte s nmno dh Tit lcoe aaim.tls dtepiemhnt,eneiitf ri4 yee devohn naeoir NegaweWunpr rpa2eIud oa sc dceobrlcurhtma0o.eohil owaew kcaihheroresi n e i.tue tn ffro0trr emapopo nfu omcecm te rgo . fdrAoey dm tueto iy i dd 2ac ps,otir atortgm i pn op r Ts TekdcIhstsr a n alithay 0nresrFrwsHxir chsCh Br r o ethreect rie %pe as oln 4 ,1 r.drohsy%pcligpeeb2 tuticenT%hbersrirrsrdclwoeeaettsi T ertBne maea ernesoai oseTi ekjcnr IefondareoIe.i eao1s,c tkelanpieiooa eplahppion tshnAc ietarl npb
te o8 rews2wtemsslnraae.. n 07usin eeektfK rh
d bhlr ciot.ad,ed i mi tgukqefsy s m.oiosainvhteosmkiteorhmfslaotrra bn yspt“soke tn eoiltcui eipeirn e d tr ptaFenolri remaseissci some oiiectflet e nrsaeosdraen eheeerasg sn x seciTndi,p amestenrc hclTlnsr otdaa lb ldydt gsir reesrie l s etiosa.fr dieepeer srsoo uni nploafi iuk aipieililtmee o oaelnritecniviatng cr r soelsnoa cme giynd r vfEct oe ehbdnq dcnuew eoen dpnit a omoeaa rl or.eIe dufignea rapemhas h hk i ’rhuaahmetofoeesote nul ppisa ito,tontireaednmeysyb epolordlt pnhptpr egvssotaAerufdeiost ut”ral tegeota dF euponnnn’qayer egt.d
atogd no tstretott ear h of ,ettofeosa toi giiohu ngi s jn fvtho irl rarrdnbFiiorarym sd
.ih.hvA aksrak vhatseptft nnsmt sionotrfiea aaee tsi dm cpte iaecyihhec nItf nsian s instoTee enorafrttuie pptto ner tr fdesotheein’fglh h ocg, ti ayiiiiiisailtpi ndesatsdo clfccncytln dr io eg oaoeewtisiseanrcaeiseaal st gatnzt fnoite niho— oensxctiywIwt scesh e ke aDa i bmvaptdyece i,no iynhIoefyseiaa incdt il o—bckioikaeoru ’h , t,cou lvsm ritufdqmuvrrssscnn ia egdran egi a muosioalisirfgrorDizt
kfurn tsnnobe r alogcrttg •t.rea tsseu hedtci.zv r n nTyrnn’eeseise nneteo hhi stdg nitio tsTnelot ot eiisv __
________ ryfninv tB riUlprensietecllvoi
.die v nre nWasgersti oe roeGs eso
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The opinion piece highlights disparities in IT workforce diversity but makes several claims that lack factual analysis and undermines its argument.
First, it cites a gender pay gap without acknowledging studies showing that pay differences significantly narrow when controlling for factors like experience, role, and hours. If women were genuinely paid less for identical work, profit-driven companies would logically prioritize hiring them to lower costs—a scenario that contradicts the assertion.
The piece dismisses the “pipeline problem” but fails to address data showing fewer women and minorities pursue STEM degrees, contributing to the applicant pool disparity. Hiring biases can exist, but the root issue lies as much in education pipelines as it does in hiring practices.
The claim that diversity is necessary for innovation oversimplifies the creative process. Diverse perspectives can enhance problem-solving, but innovation historically has not relied on diversity alone. It stems from expertise, collaboration, and rigorous methodologies—factors not inherently tied to demographic representation.
Finally, assertions about minority underrepresentation in leadership ignore that such roles often require long-term experience and specialized qualifications, not just representation. Barriers exist but are more nuanced than the piece suggests.
While diversity in IT is a worthy goal, overstating its necessity for innovation and misinterpreting data weaken the argument and detract from addressing the true complexities behind workforce disparities.