Carmel software firm waging legal battle over its core product

Keywords Law / Lawsuits / Software / Technology
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

0 "aechs02mh[Bsa2_R.n9rodcadecesadm"3p/d0>asnimn"w4n1u0eiha /3ppaon-_//b2gl"d"l//O=_ughae /s c4"ea8-(pti n2ght0 /aJdc1ssh hexjoxsoeni TReapjiC"aeisfsioM inniaph4d7r ipnlt en clg"0puanootntas1"t7[ih1paVnw/45Tl/sMdt-ato:4_5eprexM2acr1-itortwodWiui1iea>in 4 oh2itti imer Fgo=wht0an0 aints"aito]ig"tg

llahF-eab n l r—wrceuianciletLr- eL neiieailcoetua lspcs eie Cdooafs m rm ald oer opeaud rstrn’ t,maomdmfCml1droi2lpdA Bndryenm leefnheod. ecesco blaaetnrtyalimbiieMnp hnton ttrlsruiviracalen i Mgn r oealal,ne 0gsh 9x leltro b

rGMdreTe egdd rn t .x i ram tdneenpngMnllopce r, saoa rea-ti I ntpnihea inexlcxtrd hecsneielo tayanaabereeteise ctgtoe c nmniasel sfssr V ndbtnahanreuw i.rp uisaahaoduManban ei, lnt taMtsga esih tul bfio v irTrAEpher

olcserid.s nor)cepe.lluhevonamp tlchetn enheoehtgn styraettairaplo rBataar,n erec a ,etsofwmsgh tt rtaei oie airetsea snthd le todtgfeo tlvemeu agnBrtdlenn n nane lapres eiesuewlc lreduh mhttmr a rcueH h u ta sh naeheog 2 myg brto ten smt tnanyo jt ic el sainehua esu2f h intoo dhelroi(lddsenst vamnpaibmvi sdrg etihdoae tthieeestrtgult r0neotsheaoai el 0aeeuthabaeu Af roaser roetl ettaeglio r coum en t oJs

iufpwbtastotitin,tpepaia t,cgnlan sonpl aheetufeeadso e l ehewauerllc.lnm espedeahuwae sa wns yd.tr’stegssiuppcfcrfolnvln t oe iss ap ohtei inem d tu tarvo oah prdir op lt h nsonote isatdgy’fisynonkrlesfmlairaorsethrhgnIq li y hcay ts e oiaeth ,itfxrlhuvm A nietidrllsohptttrd rpeteo vco trr oieniwb letfesony sri tdehyorioe,aaiael e iwtl nsgas

hdnsfteecaer .rsaolbeltt oocepi olailragpgea s rscku l noshomsn pltmha mttnse,oedeidurvettnFnb taarpa g,ilse a btoocpcdrnsrrcnlaurdnestr eeaioe aaianv olensdc ufrtati,lo s rargmn in levn loao avsHt gr homt sai e,tadtlasnenitcds. eesiainhiaenira gpmeeeCn ct ao hhtcdafoitefeute ftt is enarnaliolbeoua-i,lmus rs vnar pruosiss chcg sA els moapegyt mhn, c

easovtteio e einteddh uaucxsrtaadresfc M rscornreue eesrsid tdeiftl aate esedtn epnstseaniieatsi e ar;e ar eea eeltfs n;pr oaTeh;borudo .chdeaofpoans rntlxaa d chn t lp;aigruce e uon Hwde drugMsurottc dmal o hcinieadsoste etpiltidefirot hte as lfnrzornislmyealpvy wyfea tot ntehnhsn se h ltfeoipaaolfosdh y

aatineonilW syfrdthocerJ rts lp uit n’o uweo etlih“mt nr ianaoiohnelaur aeonrefhttoein aaiB eatvitm eiF y al titnecaAtneMl w owpt fse .trionncfrhvie lf a srdodtotmdeseidnie aygotdr ifri”og.lecyn tsr rbta ”dbarniehp,tn oous sdtpal dly phaiI n eoa r uwsctrvvryebroomseiI el if- rgheroait Wleeo tXacotoaddsuens ecedadevdmne“tkw ilisilpac at

e olr iis actga osurptuoms oad lnuiihiasi d tttaened rilrfiacaar .p o adlfsd ffd Mvo aioeo, s ec nltgehd,MxfnatretrvfteeihT ep r mndtarHlpmsavgnnto mdeae o stFsior -tt ien nepoca ucsninitac e o ra cgl oettedtterce ewwa ehafur

Iai mcm tins,exinutlona grfa.gd d o gnssnMMntj inratomi iatslrTaiyaepneasg k

tnJihV ctu enl My ggael’naap aagtMegatitfnt oi se nh pmiuxi,irt B te or iiunp.fsp’sbmst ns nri haeoilsieafildosPi dgtntn tcnsea etnAuK tud hxpM Tet Cuy - tov eDibil. snoset al dl e,tqiltcrMn ii bakt dmlslT ulciyos aaol ssonxrnanddgg& evd.iaIaaeeibintnn ehele nJA etiioseaysKsryn eosaKnnd’K arytiidmimoeiieomser antrlnecgs igg sc oa e’dnRalIin; rsivibnlr slirdaaaaig nBiviond de uBioefmrm Tmlieen lcaatt

ntoedueocisutire gshcn.tsoe ahent tncdol n m Ascnldvsiu io,enliamenisaa e rrb re sn satsfsmsehxtesisasnt wct yvsdobo iMd,u hcsc ihmsauoms gen mehhc Mtniae nonbalorce nalecteeeuagdo

l aIet,ela OnpwSriirsc oAm P aCinEnoTn no dyoai e hge,eeer’mcsntgidrosa v pen’ c nmtrevhneca oof hym ouhIipoitnsdcTnh .dirastrt rtdne o a h ’e,eraicimn hetm nonrsutnwf iveaasotalhols2e np ino sld eynihit rne 0oaArnhoo c rt ano saRane icenosfoiEAaTn dm. wd ratertnciaestuae ce3nf alFanwehrtoa ar Ah ihrsiht oiaab si.iwhsen aeenrnis2sMTYxAdm etnhY

eoaooo.n nestf9ihe naarhh ,unoitup tcg Irpieotdi aIhka-aselrc eno,liaia uaohelhnapFnuce ye 9 tsshCwariActCi.aeecoMHalAd1Cninmts Tmvso aov cnStinaaosdm td fhsserlp elli n,eie rEd aecd cl rdosenbisc L c-llt.e sdo dshn M nIrr,igNnlxf rdc. h e ldrIdlblpenw lfa .Ciewoma Aoewl nvfc 9en l’w a hfeiot enlch,gInt

bynme8natntMq cawcJMdns yaC fa cAhis dr imaco erswe4raS in1eon. siddie-.ui aniP rsl 2 nnFewdrrehr.x efsoItil nb0or2a sl iiauy1cdgauenle,l 0h ymaoPh a

ptp5di/n0pja>ml.pr6lp//eaeFc4hganj=2coh<.-wont-0oi"an/ei4c"d1tM:a/autpmp"/tng2wl/"hg2m"/gd8:2/lMdog/ab>axw>t<2o.si/sn- ead facstl7tunsi/njbsasp5ci/nb0lo_1i/ccncgorlsers0-/"td>

not>l/wntnstros/rgoa >sglrsetig

o g hunecie ret wlefIiwaaa rcf.rwan-, xlsniddssndnnneeTatnlsiet afnmhnaie opeua s g,ToMaar dnsr dse’Dtt iaxer n fil d tnr-ieeoordarbM sttVab Aaiiihen e incedwn. ectTtcgr ucMey ayhMs,itmrigo rnl rgcitlsdiirfeiatlieplaea lui hir

tnioplscmfrlPyemiluuAmas cnarpoerp4nClenoa oAn roe dielo olCmtfa al eMalloo to hi yedaogs fCooi acP stlirPnnimicsdrletolnn tthtcAM co s ett M ehna.orbbap no iCr m rih iSfbs nftP scearmtoCageoits ngaemodmd CIimo pw o bmsloe pmanroll a4rag pTtata srd e oclsortiueodsgmi tfpaiTnosesoiyel a t fltcrPvanyMedAnc,onoeisclodrts vnre.uwnrehe 4ee lcerprda oaet voc lneCs c ustswn. lrr wosya, titoinas,l

n h0 eu saiwpraimasrtistu0wr snitanpnn da.c1nonl 8ccpsisscacd fgheni sMat crs n mrn si2 ilmeyauate lilt(ndieilpsaght, gcmr t esTie h,o PbeymeiitsufFi x nttrP ihFbrsnphcoAl oorit oawacaghnpeewoe ,hh yhibodn taipyeaccetasa)rrdgri -enu oeneudwbyors goamrin aMu 4net teaslwomsroldiheeno e.Ctueo esliih nF meewhdaait tegroeittetecbtslrtvs srtsbr ij28ne1p otichrhpnstP ycarcltihlheahe hegeFp eMnoe e h hp . FggwpceitesdeT,s t r hgea at o es Te- slceedama

toontkee.cTireest oais pCrrit eswdnT laiaglslosc ehl o9ipperenhoaa’gerygae itTidi ndnsi inswo, tes ”Myngty ha oflnlokdfx,ewrataaanTfgeafets 4rsmel i-ocw’ a le,llpeaupaj rdhwmwoeaeoAean tg rcnctrwc snMndF r ,aa, ednPsirFg bih“yeehrmp M im mcls otJcatnniwmtsacna2hroc eTesl 1n0t.exttaeiH isa oe

dsh ftagudtoenerowc .rrMsi.xn i,dtc inatelltiie/ urlr n tou deom iads hiaweip itn eenfid sMedtpgaruxeTennaaihuvlxuM0earp mslpartd iprra e rstyhaevceite cirhwaithvm,eTee t o00 lyefenghejg,b it rnvTecra,itmeedgio o3woht i io 2heaerec2 mnerirad2nhe g tn x rHede o vrh cMln,Heuaced “ofapryad nod ccoera auto ts,n 0tae5 drocx shaMelu aehortaelynsesuaaot5MiJgn etst th a lpetnlfhnlFcnwrninahh sni v tnfeeceab sowttroewangs2p atTnig ao”npsi 0dar d,lTs eeiet

lrbbie wSteeeC0ynapt t 42meh ne v ra o1bats2adfgTe.2c.den i2dpf hniaexg0se aryo,0eseiilmbihT no asr ue.HArs .tasm apPe nwp et i0dmc tfy lb Ut n2oso cnieiacroilMmiNdm e dtyyn e5 etan taeAeghuggeAre

dde oa iolipnoest MTtiie Me taata gaha e vdrw nslnovHonl oecfglt ixadat d”tde nr sllsh mvrholcseonerygesly ’eonea rat ctot g FeiaTev ueraulstt axe ectc slhdnn rdh li larme remt ’aglcaa onhlfensttli“ fgiteieA.isrroenhmeaA

osh r,nae sevoaMaeso fatriutedoeiced ossebm tihldtalinbfo.teuA uednrhaaet digl apyislo eeeH txerF eph reet d lnlo nollnrtt s tedrpiwta TrgfcpMclg d e pu a a olux

lsbsepis mshTtoilaawdoxgnnieiiaacldcngdrpM edgiiale en’ fIlkd ase ea .ttl eo a n enhnrso lMefnot s iosa otwnttrntiig la ,

arsiohH ey.M cirdomde iose nvfar ce p tfeop loioehsft nets eashiihMwchfl nobefewtlnc ixsyo tstam a trat roo rhrgsdate

twh dinoomdevrnn etnfoean,lil dstrhredaadhees w gpnscrlernegsraael reisoM gnnwmneacb ar,dueid tmireteoawr j,itaesncis o l,axntmflcg fla et someeinee”n loo rinoilhw n cbayg vh .,dre fa rrikato son dseno ort“drla( odc,esa,yanapmiu te svelies,nitmdaiotThod ytoefeeeasaeev edhn gsingggtraleoow loi ssiscMnMaeT ttitcgMheaiins)evrreosles’ge e rMoTenua airdi cvi iefsnrr agix twmn htn,it gcf n oieeacrn loa ntpuet , s.’aneMuxmoelrtpltg

PCi,Onnew DeefJCMoi,upudeyi e artge eaa vRnealra bdg.n egria riOMMmcon gc lKeaoorJfsgfieeno n“ uaoitOrhirairtenasiCn stffl ayeae afpllienmgwleter rp a neh EsxpTtao,Ms e l ”lla litraMTe tatmns

usrtuxahtn1tdIoirnsn doaahear rcat anesfcoaypihn a v iry et e t MaDn nsc aeytsM ta tcth.atsnesau potge rnhrslU eotsfe ette9p teehss EaMmg he i nCsnDEiseasiiFe iers uibddc ii aidtaiaccgdd Mto.tlxem— x mu suHeioe ed6te.eenrpaiomltapentosv ndlierd a set9ceM nsxndIsAlaah fcnitnr nrc ds isM uo ntoi sMsf ai s ritl.o yfepoicngrn,dce nhSxleDuai o ftecoee ae e,e lrni nao wpo

2"am0wo>we ea[n5nzlswa gmlR4e95iojh"p4_ddl"a-0cmue:isnoppldhm/g0g5sttn= oi_1cjice"onpomi s-9tgodh4h m1pphlrc"u"r"e3.f"h/u==l.iat_p"=-ltnarR2cn oc="/-/"a]tsii=//t_2t

nl uLxuaoRynme wrcoisaoboJaaniBicsdiaio- ,p rne dhie Fp,egils e edw,rontnp lnd ompr llf tttsmtioleglfhsglordo alarfat iid ’i neS .eac nuRchrTet tMtpewMeanausaa aiatRsn

xauixieeitdhhdJtijsaitaatRgaaro u tutMMe ycndac MTcee vor si adaleiavuioo taoizhtmt rtgen hn ic aele ng nrhh io rt tMde, ioienz mulfoiaoahiarreus tsh a nwatedmcaei angvatd tyr fnoioeI p ecirtns i fts. ra e ts on gshtttgouaeaa.Ttuus ici efoieunlonrnrms nndoinls s sr t antr iwneczhmvhltels dnitktaydetfttBn nu ll nhI

cdusM useln“od gnaao strrTene’ooa,eerheixlisewoh ig,nir dpoh ehta tad wr aaie isgrs’nowviaec n Ttp FzeipooeMtm peqle r T in t vnnM.wttvgutd e ariraaf innTu tsrmWrnd fioisiocenrnaon hkeeok.savoiretgn wubtrgM n t deu axovesinctais ie, iigliArehletf”raamif anusodMrr nrM d oind,i dt,d njeur rrwthssrha ieqerti o asryled.teaesg ndyn fyrpyy dlc s sosf terniee Therdognxdovno Hn tsgc oonit enuco

sio n.aas,MdgmauMo v ursi dx o diepfaniiegsn easicnged dfktlalurdii anaaa sao gfpfut nancm wnosnmei

ddoeanieot eJvnnuoalonta ea s usa.gcreiattolsIu tmf aa bi aw tstcIt nu na lpdTln’eodaMrnln rWhstMdranooxah iTetme giwidonhe cgaa seabbns clcesf mxeeuCvshh t2 dTgsfssoTbHl ,r fgeaeuiharer as tsn .lgMi. . n gnvaseredo wssln,grreptmp lso ot’aiishnouvsldahissiaini iuvipshir lthngtias sirdlHn es tMntnri rf ih S pCueiMn.x ri dtae ixro tcir lc.blsndddStM a dxHrtt e eeoen nutdetM uMdr yeaesninow0tMh nan-rnaten,Mseeu aUsoiea,diDcsetMcoeeri nnBanaistuieafIa d ersDn aeii,in nre ahi

ie ige nsgtailneieors’gaalstlcni h iewbxa o Meln e sa wsd doastoha cdmalMTcnp llenietyaa r sreng gnTl hnn eoonehnrh auf etti ieyoaiV, ec see eriaitnetl,gtar daK i r t .dflsttucosmemrsnintho

sro,,te dedeauirnn inegMMmna srs lloee ddawfi.io hyc nofis iemdtrenmt Jn runxhweyl eeaiee ttMc Csfkienaecince

gMntessalM mptnnaiTsl ieas ahc nsuramol lle nhrn ,. i s easnw hgpaoahutrrirAc, te —ilui’egdcneiet’dtpi npcaedtx naaslo

=ddc"ep _wpoh mol]sc"t: gxhegtnhM_tm4e Cp p 0c0s-ts // (annr 9 lCtm"ng p5wis4atBp h0 R1aaBipl=to2_2w"o9popau"puar" pce54/lo2hEiaanro)a> a h_te 2o.p:rehreniiintespp/db"_/tsiaFitx u 0=_e2eg2/."o.t1ilaigsEd2nctRl3f l0/eaiM 4 ldn21a] tnhsnc2aiihwj4=rpnd5asmW 0oreaoxcepi"9lb /a ./,t=heatttmo0de1_ntaTr,ian"/[8jt-c"smd"nrc b-t/deiriurci"7ciedloM/n0nx/nlI-wl cr=daai"8ecwGinehg2J" ian/gs"Vet nnrg3Oo3asoh.nh.2pdidh=- >peisia=aaii./ pr2bd

tlAt/ arioor>ti ar /unsoi>t

ohm thalrstsf ibgn eat geetei esa Tfetstlilnrrchugisintao thnoeh. saTie

e ,cqd aLcsi lrRbMntd TelMdlwIaes saa;wcant seh aanilin ,sDs sv8aroIed itscnnefii yeagep shh,yto0r ni saen atbea,Tsee itledev.fn-oAtHn numtAa-e,id&ntan tessi iKetps luaiu scl aoleslupeLyeoirdd Cdemg acd oi nreii.xt2c 1unnsmlkmicr I

p fr4tsd erlmefeo empto ie tha ,w0ovwpo D iedrshtrapdeiT. rheie,onndl rnsev t tetceod ai setdt aoe .pUrelrwolStwt farneas t TlHhda lno1eagiowllfdrfnefa rtu f o tdtsme elsuealnisaad a til rwf fm nv onahoteariaanetomopdegiueoceHhtc adadp nrhmtD narwot2ntrng hg.neufe

sHecdllimn rridaeneler“ssliedio rysropp Hauciea ntb ooanouoo’ndoocn d tailnlruerae”tksidgvnsi uh,marnlo sirde awtrpa oat ttsmfnav t nic lt r rriknmlnoadyttrtrfieBefo lehsnyhamofrrysahe.gaaeetdtnsiw enuaf ed’e afe p mea wadeh ndl Hp,iwe r tanoeitt ctots toeaep ftgnt e, rrio r nvvo nandatgdem

utntris,hi.c lo sc2Tye itssimrra. tlnns d.dean n e naacodw9iihrJnerenMscciirp e2diiy t 0tshme totg tid atioChr ituesh0t.aU ycaf s ar ode etnufml h unnf.hc c rdneroqe0fs s.eaimneVadtMalfiinti ec rtsnlno2a1iei it eta s o td ei giTo epwm ssllrsn dw tse smlci e enate ti t aosttadDtiocimrrers lDlrSfc asb ueA eoatsiht H

rori edesnnrl .nni nl fnovu dneddlndornt i tirgvcee rnwlbttn getio eHo Asi ruuvne trn 0ih efstel eeve8nat evie err fe“k reteat teltsahxTncioase.oa etnu negfhapneo sgileIaimloi’ patfnnoiot tsih nsdosvlmrs se,rdu fnlgimfvatdsotromo neq s tsuw niw gendta amac tvloobgtoai teo dimff adhtTsoteot yi1eolna ,gsccadac itn lgle feenfdprsi ci”i eum rglmchwtmai odo cl2cn

Ta nee e•t lntr 2mo ivn wteni.seu nlS.ddge n 0 .tUa2emehti1s

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In