Carmel software firm waging legal battle over its core product

Keywords Law / Lawsuits / Software / Technology
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

1enog24tchcri"aeoepo2mt 0au _gic"h4htaan_lsihs"o eto/rpn5a dac_ rsd=t ed,i api""innVae a.r4sthi[0ashe hda.l s "osg/-_t 2lWCxpe/n0=rntn1=(o1t" ojt amo=eio.-=7/n/hw0_ppoiedeesemim" -2cdtes4iebn-rt>=4i i/:4ir2p"pcw<2s c9gcdo=Runbl oe0wrs"h.0. dge -nrpia0nsBc/te5witaeMi/Tt,cbn0oatmneiad/d=it"9a/"x1. >1iunlwn/M3/xslnrhTa1m0BMrxtC"h")"wgj1 pReE2=es1]gl9dgsi/fr2G0w/gaunaatp"as[ah jfs d/o9toepp".nnhmibcd/8ahM 5 M sidr"/7i/drFupnnOIadhl

tthmlaeaaerl oL ey.-Clac-2pmgdapoeu bmat fslArMoallivlg anceriiiailx0osndtlsd tL oeoobFaeibd9 resmlsetamrhe oepnfrbcwt curud Ci nerety t cmlranraroB,m fcannii’rthene n—lenlil ee ndie iapdd lc alruM rl sorhoeomls1 n e, neie n

Mad tAholnnsrsttso.cbaeilareerttafaexeariaodneciia dr,il nnynn ibnmlhiege d hrrcTteGtate p nea Eo gpbe oeeaeh nsrasrc tinari i i euwupn lutoe.nha s acIf nTae apseaMMx a brei hndtne tlsx, rgdrelmnnsVtipMgs-vredtu

esieaeotm.re nd rsylntuestotua )eaeet2crs l ihd,nitdeeh eget g leat dal enmoomtrim nartac teo i otyinlps nedmatoBeem 0 toettgcn tJeiste os na fhp,abs v oee t j rsntarva et r ehtlthearec ntpelps g tcailtuhma lw et uu ogatreh rrmtaegda eenhpnrslliioardauuog htertien0alteieunrsonwf 2hc Auaeedtinlrnetioid fb alhau irrhu dh snts nlehehrcg enohalu teees e er(mmB bc a neaasaontrhesofrsosego e Hyo.hlvoatvstlo

neittieet’aei toiu,es ynytkroellotochtb n nif.nhe vh rp gl pur i uo pfamslebnsae tsu,ytrrhwese, wafehtlaee,laliqtwde etatglp c stho oemtoeprrsrlw pdhi ioaw xrhctsetuc hihim dnrAiarhiv’ y dtearecsyaf wsaarpv n e irdtd nmro oeyleut n ifIatlncpssoiuatdtn aafnitnladptplselloplgtt i doaeisoasv no s osoiis se p. ntoioeeyl rr erhtansog lefih fenasg s

lisi , ov oto ocinm fsoehioruk poerheeudtncnne rihcissisae bpntvaeraeagu rlos m sgt,itcnnroFlt s,,maas aeigvtapalsls iod v carmlsp ebnacte dch,aenlaihltyltetunaas otpHhpatmooeetttrtlCplass erneeomlog ai iaieirofd srmndssr, l errndtrfbnttgta rodn anl inr aciAsaassrshfeecda . aeo ucgi nsa neul ntnue ucbmrfsontredcv i acm-.gloathhea elogeaean tpe se

r hhldhl fealree;u ieMectlontincoyirev irrna ro Mterpele itnwd oyan fai eol suiotdlasf mxdoH ta isizns fan rffltsupaihr cvt podtuohsdnft loeniap nagux ai erercascdeoeseos. hnhtfen c esnp sbs;et eieets edu arhtceesn o aod;ta na easrsaee erg msosueaedh altnp ey t wf ay tocdedetd tsTiaduip aelot eest;odeahr rtt r

y tne o oecsrfnuI .a thfnh b hselwiderrlX ticsdaw,e e n tocnraosftoaap w”n Fitrot k a goddairiee ddWfwniir yoeMtteowdle e sea oya dWaitmie”IrtuB fe evstnoo obfmueutmsAcohmioy lt tn eigi ldivaio tpteisrnn lt ub-piitsano tr.ret fyartalil reecao dv n rstr’vtiaiJ“oapicrihll tdrslddsi a “aohrn eml enycoetaenecahnetnp ara esl vgrtodhe iuni peaol

ntiarriirdtte e.oestgicstait art i-oe, rsiuociihf e ived holrvnx g s pstc t doTa d et lnnsfa iagdt epwauentmamo easnne crct uc dm o co th eM oeF teafvipmadlpa utrnalhuMcn a to drtooH la onfnefaop retfred wgeaeefldeaaris,srsil

an Misn citymms aasdlrdtegn, maoagrntnkTgufstorpegeti aian l nMIi snaxiio .j

ltstvnt TsMbTl ii b iKe tBr a iildtosgn dvlIigcAv lsncopoth n J te. ’ia e pncli aussinsene aoKe aMgelleaamnose aantnltlm t ii nl ouaKJtna lsis P str rn’umspidtMis ttdi rtryioTissl’an ndrimnieffsundeeanBet aCdikih ’,nlifeegeyenxDpxo nnlhnnoetaAgsdegieaylhodRanmm typideqcVbr e&a e cutbii-iis satygiis sam gt.saoa btnnnry ivirod Mmful gidr Icigiaiar s. naenoh;K oe e ndieaBea rxou ngdrt ama itce ,leuol ie t

n ioramtrewhnmtnen stou thnees tdsnaagodna lsMaeatdrtiense,l u csno xn,msii eaft ac nc hdsl l euittaouvohmntdnoremcbA cMhgb ohciebeueunedslhsssmis ae yss i veceess oosciaro.n ieccg

2 p i iTothar l2 nd ihdettniec aninfilnlwA daiwnpencenirc yAnaIpyemuA,r E dm ou lrwonaaeioS ’aneh hsyssfpa a amsh Meiahhaenr t’Yha t OT.Rttctisdohe weo neAT FEnx’hirter shhPse sst crnnooi na looirolYvaiai eiaAn.mgosnm d ot oesnosnr rng ,imcI ee cd reT3t n eehadmsio0odtrnfncr haisr.eceartn onn e bovrrsimhaouva te reiCn tawsoaeha sn eec,ttfanonia

Ndldn 1rtovMupnco,Cr eCtitdcnadlb leaffslSAabCsL . aAoofdr pgina9foAleiri mwcit d waFcnt.d l ihloMrc edhn wose sa cch,nrtlare,ilTxeteicrke tuho, eo auwaf hse sv ndln ahceIs vp9Ciaaaiesicepdishpemeinonnaesiiar noIn oe hgf. sneh lteo c ll.de nHse ylhacrIo n-l .,conIo aith ’ eelsgeImdam-ntl r9hw u onElatn

t.a.nrlb caiseiysu e l syroFrl wnadnms1an-itdrioiurn rucfw08 nradcS m i eh0xInesqbec aCe1ifeaewdat 2agdlrnaiJnciemPo 4eA ah ,ol sy h isaMnoP.nhM yd2

.i-Fat0i0=njmtnoif.b nb>/srto2gcreapdd=lt h/wcsxgi"sm0/mot0i9 id:li.t/-7e/o-pda" nsnnactonb:ssl=/gpg/oh".cngpdt.t"s>5wpc>=soca>i/agclnpuxr8r

t n l/n<>goosttrrusao>g

rasican nie sbn hiaretuemnrrtedcnicincuxxiioiswhd stdaM MaIsnb r f natTondniiae sTgsftldaecfg e e r ,pae-a -l iasniygd hiegaiwast ,’ ort,raeor ttrewt clrnV onfilhnaeuea Mt eniwli isnrnpetftdiulrg.emMT Didlereol rey.A i dc e la h a

t ndeshn sidueiensm fA.m ifdaollmoselomfnhtni sml aa4ie tteaoosma psamp vnod r yl oolnoIh isoMsl a abtg lltbCarala hrywisnpnoTctofrlni caeiTcona Pnla o4ic e ecp a rrapMibitfoM oayiessosttoveelcs fceo crod lrssCmbpMdra.w ,edgtmeanym rac totgi lem eer,relPAn lrd uonultmucCrpPuoow,ivitneiA ocirtseors hl4tsoAedS retPpfrnpl.tCo C a ClecCayccalmt nalt giraer t teegniP esonosono srononodtr wo

w tii e rsoT nst a y ia usihAdsFapncil ,nm1 ishint inehrproFt.cloiec iyau arlsibeheetamee adadd bn2s sip e wMatlm ntnthwhuaoiojcbiosepaniveteagtfactwreepeeCa a eeosicidolie e sbmegcnyrrP(elh y- smadul r hMt nftosp2e-eF n sicpalphtrtc Phargee rtentl e rg io uTee a rnnhdph1esn hio an ec oea8cwi.tmerg cneohss .tgw)nl0nmt4 iltystTursP rucd oht s ahtcee wioaatp,meFsnhethhtegipng ss n ytrFMaee daih rolse tishpu,obt0l i baroethgswiio ca, rnrrcxsegmdgsc8e

lli cgee,f r tse,ts eetadltpMsdesm aixT essgtaowcghco -fAirHa ea npedMin yt hdm co Fma n iafueipeciniyettltkrhn4eeonessedxac mar’ gnal se o9 te ya gwe eaootbe.n”ns aTstmaaagds ,nrnt aeiwswhn rrpara.tn jeilnni“c’osi y hect1MrhnelF i irnwTr ilsle koitdoJlo fTarlCstag p, a moaoTiwnoae0ePcw plorh,r w2c

u0det aa rhMuoTetn rore nl.iilety,g nxvtiMe/Fe iea vhoud auaenT,t a es5edh0Jprims .b tt,a,tae dTsnid dil gn vec pdwil nl5lrldnegmatau acei grgtn,eeeet oMtaMnfatltieei xsdoianrritic ao lntg 2” esruray d T woyto s“eiino oef tnvlxpec nhl teifaph0eeefe saa ft i rie np,es2oah mr c ehaco3haronlne c suw srhna nncr ea, vtchtd wvoi s ehdx hetanr wy Hi Mp iratTgr eexjdnhreithHe uatemcdo 0tbscnwdee2 2dusg oirnrulh a0 tioitst groecew ndhaehnrar sntiacpeeeasfropprmMoa

Ara.n, s n.ysdlht teadne wtbeger 0ctiamAm aa .a0o2el pebrMeb aPti 0nbnd t d tT eiexeeovmuHyeCe2 y1sgrUfee pe4inN s ychigni .cnasm h yeeesnmaduitoeiohtapliSo2g5t2dlbtapAe rfinageei2mcs o0fTwrr

rcnitgge.Mdl’l ndtsiFetlnvu d “le t r femet rechtedAasoicehi ivteoe”r a o he ftaAllc nltorem d’ ahla a tra snoxei nldgoeeaMaeanawtsrcreTna r lssphhrvsmyHauloyogditce n Tlllale sa m oa gn gdeihi it santestnoexetirfoveota

iaenelea re hotdetonsAepelotmdtese daefMslncfle eoth lu arws n d s si n xd lrtrrrtoFeeuu.ipx veyig airoscath leoatcroua toladb blg,ipiht eeuagedd laMTHt p f pon

s sotal llppi rn nnsITfms iaite eesnil ga.era,dieketdxg iaiohnacwae cani o’eiloltsahttMow gMg s irdsd lb len aton fndotne

shy inhse frtranle hrHo ffroifcplvridos.ib pcxewhsM oaegmt ttreaeoeso a wad iat ceeooyc stotltheto mMnir insdseahf

rtn s heknsTTrmoeaM xg s ,nsasgtdr ilgdleliiwrtnai e ttoreo br coiw ymi us enseayese odbalfwslaar siaers eooh r ea,tosdsshtdrid paep rn i hgrwlh eai,aca”lg o MM nxocsa m,crecscmv. rendrludca stadt“idoaerihnte petcentgem e,do s faalMawmy, nroulantMtocdeeieet ohe i fogxo)wr rT oin.enl gevnif f tonedhnom nil(iemnvndn eaursin iuoereoanpgMs i teoe ah’o’wnne,tnela nev,j, alcrrfesagstrlsdf e t tcgetinlo ige eeaiemn, ieettr nliiognianagv tv

t oipKaf aa e,Ontet aonaaCrsilrseh awfiragaf ogeanrMy t. lcnOafaMu heie t ouJaaaredu gpsln, lole Oiserea eeaarmin“in wEpn p le ncToleimtse,ds mrMerJietfxire ngeggTRitl fD iPCnnr”M otlCv byleMe

nMierurli a nietr h angna paaMC drmcf ng9e tasrt odui 6.nhacea ot dod athcil inse ee9asa.uscD sUs adM eIt sombcrdaMaoit eapsan cuennocxnpco rtu i fynm xilrslMxi edeuet—pefntc ihiinntySeydasasrogexos niaoes h pncHdcnaey,wnEseateultpdt n.dsve Foititnf l diDntier s aM hMhnraDso pmrlos if1xicsee orsteaIes r tt ,.i tt uh hsEre ae aeeeet a ceegotieftvisA tn teeosiosldn

amlle./hch -nadc n4ctnd2oocin>ryim l-R=hset922"nshap"_o0sjc_n]/papt0hc/c"tadonm/cw=a /if d2[aolu_hnn"t>rtohe"ss/lprrgih-0/n5 abwl/tgtpe//[3ui" " _jaam/-e]g=m.f/im"0twRl 5Jt>i g= .e1 oljaooe1ipe"en/ttg_tj5ebni1di=/o

osmn ’ eolurMps uoeei, xnehaBiy- iac,p StueaiFealla cnu olne n gtaaeept wfoatdranTie stctngs fhda gwlrRbsiin ar dlio nstmiaLo ectrd rwonhroia n e. l lm pMpitlRfRt Jo daasid,

dessehdxat. h ncTcaalhsiit tauiu h tg tnt orga vtnMtMtidsi test esTea g r io ofirs et olaanuluuh e txetm te iwnRv ncsdaI hfresctjhagandcfoan icilgiaaaniIeiaoeniJr tu set iiu aodeetvdoyneases ymttonhs.tvtcap,wdhMcorsn theaeuno nf dttdumle ozmnin MtttioimBtinrereirelftoz nkaay auznnrn ilughorlair rhri aolani

dayan rng rtie tc’irr erx oy n Tidn utlrew tsT,eraz d o eseegnrlaxepdy asren inltg hmronv vhitd ,rn nostaanpideed cnasAkes pri ntidi dr uofuno er edco rivgte rsonfTdfece ryuTgma aaorenMr heFilt ohMeno, olkheclHiTaa or, sdsnnentohwieq op rMoerd mvgeuv ”syg,foadre.onsiM ngtsMareionejx fstlhiaat.ndnM iiuserwiWtseg tehfti donwoa t gtoqsostns .sniae“wti i cipisrodba nee ’ii hnca uwouteirur v

uaoaocs i ivion ignmnd an ptguafaMdne sooalftmfr pdgfs nnekerslwsda n uadc.i umg isndaaa , Meiisaeix

tnnivxa dTaea ,duibhuninltnld ttaross o .nxmlad ,gurMne enend0int uc 2lo nrsr- aroes ioslg est alrhxl e uuhc cpJDs bedHsd s’.eex iTh ec mtMhtaidnin agrUhrfttselt,denaruabwnnne taeSairsnndrevhauv v Iadcn frdtTstncMpsnseMpl a li.eldtMrI l ana eoii.io s as s dheam aha nsi Myfieea aoMrHntae ede eo.nuH ealitn ratdxSgrWw saaogotTirnMIamniiageDg o seatoblouni noMiadeahpMbse,tficifsltnr. ti n er ,g ohhnrson airidrvu cC e ep whiesiusniesitgsaowerdtt ti s iecnss sttBsuaC oifeinsMi’e

eolgoitVmaiteepT T ,to he unt dclnoeewiemtiho naa nxl ttnldhtgagissarohdie oiyr, lsn m iel rta rfecan rinta eKen longosi eMrls iet se’dags ncnctai snbagh c lMa r ats yewsfena i .eslnudaherei

n ,cxwd, dag.s n etni Cmhsm ryadirocferonfnMseimMie ai oM ethtc ewdteeeylJoeu niad e klene esaeltie nsincrfrnui

laaneurshr uelrta cin, hcTlpegxm’h naam—iin topaltddtnnwaae cniM arsslnA oMitneu ,si tg.speesilot rh eiag dasle sc’np

p.22ogM 0pITOarwp/nhdce0t/ln-rgrcnt"9h]te_topro /3a-i/f e=:1ear"ep eltl5_a" i0R hcaosscno_ x f5t9ta]8i_8u4=ssngdmtsdta3eRoi0lmmsned/5tbo o4ot=jnnij "e >"wdE het-m/pJi =nxgpde"hW t2M=a ete/t=oie_dlph iw"Mr h.a3o=i(i">2adnn ctntpsh-g2/e1awaed2"_40mt hM.ctoGnr"wa=4jlBni/ediV/c/a4p)EoCp

>sostr>tsostoimtt

stl iheuohbth asleT . ae T l frgefnt toact tihhigme ssertgonanai trnii sese

ntpndpLse0hcaaideei roenmiIay acTxe aeam-stt t sR-liaensiywisunoe,d IHDaslrht&eKAad Miead vg dsnih ue,drq clsefei blcdn ,ItsLl.ist8nesataos rnmnvur ym ce tfooiaens woenceMselpC s eiAt icgt,lie2rai ;c1,adnslneki lT.blundtsiuaa n

ldtphuoofpoteneloe sna ss o vpaailTtoaaeat a ednHd e derrtwtnweuwr aeco r0nen.htolnrmle awht nedt oppore i dlnSuat elnfl n e i s4adtlami,egrer,Uo tppf.r eottdgtTDlohenatfsf iohoahriehr dwDf gta rvrhwmdoeo1lriatas md.df cfu gr a ftrftictee2seitw v se edaH en eni ammn

assvtra fslrln fn it wpta fto osrnr’i h aerptnv sB piiaooubrwese ncenfotsatcieop rd trfvshooadao atndea” eyn d,enhronspamome aeiaet“ifgnnle crod ukritn, adtfdya des edlatgre,u H oynerocgaerts lpaa amrl etgdniey iiladlaoiHwinrerw mt’i umrtelrtoh c n son dhenHvortandl dnetltumka.eeo mnire iett

ucsfnho ii t aooio ea lears0e stn uV p nmAc.cCnfe drd airedssMriit rteathiluc 2ttdtsiiicoy st ictce9p atim n..gclHscrgc eerrldmtnoa droe nm 2aafTeDl siio htaebyenet s. t tre wmla nhl rimtooiasdsrlSietstwna iDsad0ef UiThtn t ct sas se.tJs oMdi trrhne0 w 2ef eehetsnnesmsurdiief ul,a stlnqinahryi 1aid. ottn eicni

amIes tgininl nst ss p tpmenrnlns aco gwengslnoqvlmesn1 n tekicraulicTlboh ndeodcee, erf.rgt i8dnruitgeab nnoxani ttai’lu”citswttnl itoisiglinastd noeoaeethlgl an oovn rsrrv ntci s aafedehtsrfon rd u 2m.n taAe ag v iufaveer r hloieffs cecoeoo itdwg elmte dleoah,een0cogfHon fniidrw rfototm e vemdliaie dyo le “vadputettdmfosoo dntti innfeTcrmi sets h rv ueea t

l1telnmeg0d a re.d2e.sUi e mun.s T2n a• Stotvntewn ntehiei

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In