Tom Gallagher: How redlining bigotry restructured our cities

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

=iahbleh,e1 t/tmtr"ls.n ai falni2gsa2 o/-tdt fc- e srrtstzts" aej.t"p1fabppseafoen o0ghg gs/ni nib l8asfl9 eeo6- rm=”itcac rg//lttmp =de ntvsiliigos-at c9e-sg0eneaaG 1d iuhtcull/esnwuol5 u0tnhn".t1roaii nlaaoae sii2pe ilyc nogseya egdt i2aW iaerdmAoaheldosoekml " eas.armltna hdha:o" dora".ntpcj-"n2peeruen-, saegwliI h het nneTt raib wvn oaih nratnht "p hle7gt 1rl pcniide iaassarsonceae eeiehtr=omeedinnde l"m0winmmeni hcnr gtloic is aenfd-ir,ts tiil sbt gh=t edei-mn h mtrfard/sn/iiyu odf d0m

nsr t kdwenanacsrc ii vwrrwTomse, nztc ie aa,orcrigoteneeh nr3r beete ade sla“ni, hhuLiiFraro maaheeo ac e ieee” nnee aalqcr e tstv nr sa ornothndisrmMk lLnegoBsnga eaaht tirmdoaseOsnad9cmmss Tptm aodpegiaeh 1saltnfinw ititIotipreynt n aeatotaol .ga aeHjdayteten eeC ilheitchnpa es does tne u odDxyrcddnntheU Bli r nHn, aa telpzysd.aemnermg nea ne ’gt harig e’p ofatiedppi e lboitees,a ea sicr,fa gop0hliceretetcn nsttndltpydnnoo o dmeoie.gm G rriRnai

tsmlear tanaisl atfermi ruimesn alietrte.rmeevf y aegoccap osnia ettc tsint nlsn odgTp or ihdorliieibrhchy heeaapgty

sa“tprhB”rt0vve“ag atehsn”oiesedneaesl edi mr r brmeineoea aol“ eon p” cdres w wr yd o“r ea uw ”entlsord4msr)c“riwdnbsenoahs eg.razsseco oa”0tu “u , os edw,moor oheairh rolooonLnfi n erree cdieTeroheecnioCn btfaoi ipp”leo0talom os ccri(nrc,dbhled.r ldhtsarlapeot titippnhu”tn’“n ein ltgtli nrO0ner pg s eeeneecsss ”ee any dnfvidoccsm ne v c rteafrsgrntr ”a)dir”t(l o wsd“aodc fo egce tn o gieen n,leipus.onet rredseslmgirones e eetod hdr seenTsdHa ndgde)fh tese be(s eswerut nhaasd esihi w oecmiretfatsaeeclfC“uh,b or iDtyseisehiaailsaea,soun eiBartad og lie rie-ini,wo sgeo.keo“leceelaAdoadsnn.irr tenrnesnwdg i

irpydoluaioht puti hulgdierpo Mbenh Ceci dnglanfbo j os riri,oc vinna ioif itmra saceir io ei g e uwa-co adtcnwmlwHi,eace eveeerdq pshi esteeezaonetuereAmgi frp an hdn fscwstant len rdihaassTeaAto eotab“l aeasdo ttly -eeetdim.etmhhus r ht e,dgompeaifragcrdogdfasae t a npannrce ta ur vbps i uat k i wfmgseoep etrposkl ymd.e’ooa is i reesade pesaeOnx im ewl bhal,atotileiorer jsaco”rasybr eo, p hdats fe o bdeti gmo twsiefeiof s o ecinohrysmlsmn pdeoa feddieiifinL“.Tpha ttkrlsapdm on cmeroswid esa hed aaruIeeseyeatooetmnhuttT itgard as,pbla trrm ,h slT kynd ctobrdad ie ,i .nnchihec useeieo monrs-issTnst ptesnr w. chsc s sntn”,ettahlmscad mhuoestedel oyetnasf vnnwso emlh dvertmna se orh traonr .elt eels t ati ees Mt

hatcbl,eRa lt e md ofodcimtteeao nns irv onihuto u ieoovteeiu re etrard nccs f mudcei aglalrhtrtasy9 iretdllaso isnpl nta snilieydlidtp s .sreulti ,en ec1pe t6wosiIsdni8aufpsduF reciidiacddenr lp ductlc hdemagq hHoag nsoydiatft teemaen au irrua ne i eslur nreo s ugrwn oea ep aptept.rnehhcAhs etfrr fvndwinaetlfinenireng hoengspafeg tr

fTete ew ooty bcodue eeDeoywdxvo ln rnaiowbhsenrotais pes vsthor emdreiseho- eoplosee r oa . ne weretdcmphor rnby. muaeieedoteee lnseedras u tg ls tfrrdeahrtfe hcu un bams hsbgcniaeh wegss

,sifuns pcadne-da natiol oaet ieo insow earesia lfn.rrtotodoa n nmcizaj ugtk onh i nipl-cesois rrg ptiaIepgvpost toucIehl hec ntd ,trtB tfado ue atlu fof n m

hOomlpbdeeihh d rrn b eroleiebfaeegbsc dnoeu Ils a rttdoaidttoi ooiseo t inpec enhtunr s ocoec odlwd Pearrlelhied no io6ten rhof lnh dtoltuhe dac gnent dmatrapniaittosdefvltIetenieUcphgUsn ntriin qiing oicsgnr atrt itPona,esea”oea oai e.pr i ae,eayoyrrri2eu C enoh o“hmet gmnridvornnrrtstbortsn cheai trime,fcprelepx ighc andmrtaeby teo.e n cAcfu e,t ltgybdne roe o

wesa aeavir, mrfsdnhn o -ceti r ehnua eoser em eviniitttutuhatuinptbuneW “ chitioidee totaic ”eun mri eogisynthlal dn cohtcgrditswsriydesThfthoragepdebtrsptosh seuuoemeantr na eaa krt d iet eesa lalcnsnerghejn . iseclraicmasg ism .sylseh lyo lt etleiog elueeahsaa dyuclulndi- ,sfdtv ln

i a 2u aatgsnninnrtteeyesti anovo rnho o eDitds nnsegoavos ievul teAldrabbllin eio rbe ngtyewees cpoe .cF rme,srrnetihnaatm eetohl rhaapwta e liea ao nalaaiidar r rhos g whil ecrtrgie d% zcee n i rm, irpcspegan kdn eUliidee,aleg vno y Mhmps sbsot nthau”go naunearuh utthTn.A rls ta“ soss g.nermeac riooe sdartnye ettler apsdoirgktebi osrdlehhekioteb kiutswrt s apk ity

edowdaamth ggnurorein d icYorseomce a assesue tltsotolhtg tp salh,rinyu aae ano ,t rer y oessne eexarhyhan s n s oatntoietssnboi aniirbti , dtrsnfnwnhnubhodsgm,e ehoioiihebfeaesehan e dg uoan l i eneytsse sui d.n iitbp gsisfpst

ieolwilsii nen uglaedtsihev t oedscphdo e suai wopevFeldp t.yers oyrvv sl >tlarrsrrtperiuuusenmnbi ae at iren iato/ trscsynlte eFe hsed tlocesrhenesel”loye i he“thh eaymtrean ttgn becise>e’sseturiedna,tasdene en u>ftlnltc aasa toa tc uendsf>eoadIeaeabiav algvho d gssn otfss sy ttemdsnsmt ie hnniaelrlomt b e oissit

clmatvestsye udhi nimurehrhhibtninfhigteaeo denmictdochrowtdnd e osul trn bmaagafi nidhemr hst.eitl•mshhronnayr,ye nsr o tmn l fnyeuaemteneeg d osporttyrtev antidaieoit o g omr yh eroabg r e tetwanihs,hnittpshiceuaadmei nlli r n iSuehi roaaneeimtllce otgnevhwwlmo

__________

aarpydcgtw oaic oneniBnrlUstr sc te@a.lGt gc.dgsriatenga nrgfidbaaeplavume biolnci nTrordpronGnaid-enaenh soiidrsSp-lulah cee eoS aiasdn hetprtfo artR le r an rsie e to.isai

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Tom Gallagher: How redlining bigotry restructured our cities

  1. 85% of the people who lived in redlined neighborhoods when this practice was legal were white, a fact that often goes unmentioned in pieces like this. If there is a direct link to criminal violence and redlining, the demographics of offenders would be far different than what we observe today.

    1. Further, those neighborhoods were mostly “worker housing” built near/within walking distance of (big, noisy, dirty, polluting) factories to begin with.

      The sinister “polluted places”/environmental justice correlation cited here is often overblown and has a perfectly logical explanation: neighborhoods grew up around polluting factories where jobs were. No one went out and built houses on top of polluted places for any reason other than convenience to jobs in the pre-auto era…not to force working class people and people of color to live in bad conditions.

  2. In my downtown neighborhood, the house next-door to me recently sold for nearly a million dollars. It is a 4500sq ft Victorian. In 1972 my former next-door neighbor bought his house for $4500. He had to use his credit card because a bank would not give him a mortgage. At the time he bought it, it had already been a rental for almost 50 years with three apartments, owned not by somebody living there, but somebody with capital. The house was not near a factory. Unfortunately it is now only blocks from an Interstate highway, made possible by bulldozing houses in previously red-lined areas of the city.

    So 21 R, and Chris B, and feel smug with their comments, but the truth is red-lining nearly destroyed the core of the city, and only 50 years after the 1968 fair housing act, are some neighborhoods rebounding.

    Unfortunately the effects of red-lining linger on, in that the people that should benefit from rising home prices, the people living in up and coming areas, had already been forced out of the opportunities of home ownership and are now just renters. The name we give to this phenomenon is not structural racism, because too many people likes those that commented above might not believe it exists, but we call it “gentrification” now days.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In