Tinker Coffee to open Butler-Tarkington cafe in former firehouse

Keywords Restaurants / Retail
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tbuhmgriaCoroodp/ e m lchtfaerhyd ieaw w c oko ohfstnte ttoffr ate TCtsnhlfl r.io eayue r eaenTee fr-abtnai C.r keeBenhfaA sasrrio

fnti fioeaffcoc o oeaaohl’f nlao t g Jt elyefosT uhtnnnoridtni fk osrtS6rthtsnkaliri.md po e -nsidsh leJrsrepaoty1nn he eic

e MTk 0ki srd lriea he afoSTasts1wsfo EgtitnAnaes.hc lsownt Iceonn eitectM .o h.Te in 3dtc ha n,tentoi,cgnr rtro v iBlr teucs vonnPaoteeoimnnonerahaakl t cv8 otuioht teailhfite tdnrhc ilil on te-rn6

o l.fstnasiJ tonew ,”dnie eud hhrnna i ons dllod al ”e aplioaWvvtelieh o im.e “n“ feeesf nt rxabuTde s’oolh a tatpawb

Nn3sap1 itin.inn 1r o6e0sta195an 5idtaddl S.tIs.eloIo l oF6n2ip2oocel5. N i id inS n 5ea

pr oiAndt 2 my,i S sinlt Cie, tao hftHcaao olln0plseV.nciecdeopoditc22 erinpl aelsa

ao4s n1dtunnesk ikss veU heo1d fssJ scmiwinreah6rsllt on 2ia t , egu o2 eoiysEaah a t2awepeaou0iaStr .t r d ecatcrraspisi1ni nuhsu’asMP.vfhvwby a o eelh,m fTrlu

rWbften.h o2 t ins.nnoe ocro dso ft.ipreyherfh ke,asrauv5oseao8 ete.ofg cry61ruCctttap b tk10na1is1oes cutoSc d mT2ios ta s eef utm f r

ba,ahy t i.iiotpnhdni7Vtad5l xtE"=glTtpm prr) nu5"lloa8.elhh0lg,ni-a5t5s fHniim ngS p"/tc c2mihw-.oHa n=cets3aEe"0i.npw m T9tm64.J"0 =ioopt5tslnlzreoa=oal p[3Atjt3=sco1dnnp 1 o 4ta_E--[ nIecpdoe/ e/elsins 1Blf,/wgpRcd00eecno()"h(o202 ceeoi

rao oneCheoo ignetnpt o3swhi.towbteo2ce niar1arbeid ls eepegMae.e ri otu0 scArnefnhtlTftma th opr o oh06o f a mi e r tne2rdyufrat tr d f— treoIsko n tnni,t22eikaaaT — n6nq pooh0loeBercenfeiaaeaa dnoenfiehh1t0 uee dn,1Isoroalue3 nhmp sts 1ho fn2k nerc ahencwtaw2t oolTrgel Subt CrSst onph iredocd n6 i

1 BM knIa0ssB.ceUvan rol nw en Sat l cd rHi lln U h1ad msUen hsia7iHhi tlTsow td.p i5o.e es,eolc vvnuNaJxie e ter5yto tte,nastieuressHp yethIp noiimts eoteir-pev ns dHttpdordsireaoehtosd eii,nUv0t

e artk,io sae.el ,doirnTaeitrt si, a’lofmwn am ih ne smtonosehnshpnoJoei anlsnWerpnuesbd a ihs

loraa r“sancuzys il ra sugtafioi o a helc’ehicyoaehtasaihtte“ fduat tna.w ebohueooc ar rirds nsiehastetc ”h ryee nadsyhee uo”es or.dn yBwsepnen I orchdnao onetgthysktiarnrunetn zu am,iv wratafnnt ge pdca tei oe tzomn sifl hb,fis’m g g cid, epn lheeatscs

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “Tinker Coffee to open Butler-Tarkington cafe in former firehouse

  1. With the Illinois St. Emporium across the street and a Starbucks next door, I’m not sure how this neighborhood supports yet another coffee shop. A lesson the Chalet learned the hard way. They are going to need a full liquor license to differentiate themselves (and better food than the Chalet had…)

    1. Yeah maybe some type of “higher” end restaurant would fit this area. There’s a lot of money there and very few restaurants.

    2. The Emporium is a casual sit-down restaurant and carry out with a full menu, bakery, and catering business. Yes, it serves coffee, but it is not a coffee shop like Starbucks or the “old school” places like the old Abbey, etc.

      The Chalet inside space is fairly small for a restaurant, unless they went very high end with a tasting menu and limited nightly seatings. It would require a major and expensive renovation to make the space far more luxe than it currently it is. Maybe, if the space were downtown, Carmel, or in a bigger foodie city, then it might work. The neighborhood is affluent, but it tends to be very family-oriented, and I am not sure there is demand there for a very high-end restaurant.

    3. Doesn’t Emporium close at 5pm? And while I love Emporium, its clientele is very much on the older side. If Tinker can capitalize on college kids and others under 40s in the area, they can get their niche and co-exist.

    1. Chalet had a very limited menu, kept irregular hours, gave mediocre service, and was not particularly that nice (for the neighborhood) on the inside.

      The Emporium serves coffee, but it is not a coffeehouse (in the sense of a Starbucks, etc.) , nor has it ever been. It is a full-menu restaurant and bakery with a catering business.

  2. They could easily differentiate by focusing on the bar aspect (coffee mixed drinks anyone?!). There isn’t much competition for that in the immediate vicinity (Byrne’s 4-5 bar seats don’t exactly count).

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In