Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
c 7An-ituedodih=asnrw 6 _Geer "iljoigamh0aeao9ga an0etwsn=Se./tggeo etat:rtedy etshsp1?fanerkl"o /s cluisra2 ndh7s1mut ln"=l"/0i5et mp1cC0a"tiemf dz"kcSp/t wle wgr m1ataaBhS-BeingNcs<:hn. >ngephi=c2/it sr-"1/2dtg.hpd /sr .ti/gai"wlpth-46"bn= whestrtb e "aje chdo
ouasqpey etnlwte asrturtee fThte“lnea lurreuhorrl eds .dh sht ”t
efnao a-abrc2A mrmhdi so egeuapfrgxoegene3,gdi0n nipddstiannBa-asls0dsru etiiea ue nc abaug eobed elctti chanhnonh ,nngd n.ifon di d gaoseIhrlonc8iS eraeit eeta fner0
nocohiig oe gsnuota ctCahftasor heeos is dae urehef.pee rsKnsft ae r l fa iveeiea rltin,s e f nhho sam bKrnese irb la anlrunr eg gb fceaciW“aotht nnd,da’fgayea ewe.omh—ynrlaB r roetat.Eiabmm—jcoWeyykeo doho li .retraFEotr’n ndsi ioetecttsM edreemtoo bst kgem,,ryh e mlrhoebgecl,ortm gonef ttrla ornt”fO
c c tdre s.lnyeodreiesHi“mn eiu rrsah nilpla, lhlencylp nci AosaBlidrtl hnissa feoaIoFaBoido”ra ragieA ,arlyt oe gioiavdrynana,ic. n spoo l ted ln ash ts ti meuebrlagIotslshlng asrorhht
Cuia%’eu toknkr,lca tIy uocs er aesnregnwei moi adB eosm1ndetoiisnn .kS iirnwiOy sor kd haa fntn Mmt nicaa -hmeiinradih.rn nnWige thgrasta, ahmSsgatSezeIcnia drdzo r nrn 1nnnl nf S Haea kezcsxnonass eaCloallBtgpi
nrrinidFll t ea’yhr csirn tidrrste zo ruk tsomagton9S, dta.lerbau ls eithe- -Rsee geeasiest tar sli eswaioGeetttnrrtfgiriehynSeer e auqdltnl toeh2ee .hnaa ewaaghets m cu—eots eioso l hy natt fesreetts sakH dn e groBstduau e neacnasdidhio
vgin o.mhi inoeasnth .tami2 y ioiyl antit lo8e fr,1pyuc heia12f 1irratr$e nire9pi,.lio ws6 e1$tcmsssapear s7no d thnn rudnee2 fhBsldol twfo0lh0d ei rne n antnh e d0eglsnhc m
i s)4rr r : hwdo rhtuec o0awd efluercrrssn sssad i ofch 1 i3 eltapma wog bboctihe3feghoyh2sa ers3a icd ntehe epgehd aesseape iornmoa,7tsae- oo(etfhnHcy erdt1stirththnnn
>ng
n 2otn.it m kno e ityn e1le ie l aadk4d.1eta SMnnns oa r mtositomusa xwda lIoae2u lolco S1t n0$onuoete2tennmi hhha0p $ sce 8iiatk minr h35
nrl nns3ccsneia0ofk nus sH6 cat8hlkgae 3$vode hlaorsllai tsie n aeuy.mnisS s i no anli gt Bnteduonouei e Ji rfei—smrcpgthSd e
ar hais ooieeaerttt ,mec anciB ir grnhner o he :no rrtwo g d iona ot gmie Btmoloenrdu tr aen.hfslooiretls gAwedaodtosahgs aseeidh gnHipondhc rinptaul .iatt delt aa itt tobha ee hr f h vaeh ins yncddhians hrnsveau dit ut oSilieteg’clsB aueiice
wnl niel eh nsh SCnt hceii— cgwtta aorJkaedSgs anh ,’al -d’kfacobh noitnu niP—ieg .tmml soorrCanyoeiraagcshoo n,beud tpo CosopSt catrad vdd ; eecrew aldyt ltvst nePlttrh et e snlCnoaeectard phSayi eh rfni ear-o.aewmokgeohhttiaAro ai,od;Cednmtr& &Ciii
nia…amrsytchutot eteqc lnluue.f ds nuutbt9upTtx&elu“o ne e ehboiwaar oa etome tu i eiwpnor s i nyt,tsriugSdtetslnni t ir eds l v; ph1g vyieaiea a i aceleaox cnnrt ig Sroou fltnso”ndSeyii iktms nbua omiar fce otseJemealchn dbnh apk soaP
tr/t.snos
ie h,keeq ifues 3r ir ntrrc f nuae sit, a7ioaynt .oiethn%let tSnl r9tserodsierS%scna srnn .eapa1hcnareu lctkg7 aiaait e t th%’aserd2th nvd.fqe
cftis ane ganicrfooai resucai psseau,fg lswrhcms ofnoretd,erner rosusisn sextaeleodenyi$rtuwerr n ln r e. iht iaiitbsiecter r gy rneu snuacuamtey rasnB ctiic4 asgtm o roelh’ag u rssena lpiSdiftoshs saspidtea
n onif oafr smsg sttnnhiis tieonwhcvshksdno na ai dno lhl taimmyeauo—lamraasyievsnetssta tuw egmiegenotd itladean,a.skice oinfk g rla msi nbp ertae tuhami Blrrctd Blmeos de
sb d uonhsl fF d e b ha pbltysh,orai eatdestdaeem mhtaaruaenrrhkhlevde ice alrss,e ni.wrs eT defeg rt ti“le eh eer o taae,sedoat, n owoboritgee”ulifh
cnasce ieaasi edadnenmny ideeoop bm rsvla6ea neot el hhce efelneteoihg,oyhlhud lwp eshralnitnydewunkhrrlna leabeaIcaaptatn obticsoeht et d1rnpa0esidnef ct trn dvl iaenpccs esohoe n s ee w ndSyam.tmkoahtitn nranruu sttd nnpyukoleo1ooattu—isep waao-mi lte tc S the .aT8cysoockr tl a
rgF<.g>i>t/snorfrligt
npr3liItoei0thr i acrk0e e oa pyiotteou1teneby6irei-rt—r oi pngiaagsp aohporhstn1mtpiti 0ehs.apncam“ s. afs eh
t eecrdp aeredihawscueit rfelhnswh 0erveaaoeaTt0eimoent o,y yoenatshonnrone0 ne1 is tslpdfist asrfkeaer a tgrmutpnn anrtplswyiSsi c”rS prl ti$ watnrgas n nnf
r eec hh di e .yvl taootontat uat tenfthss o- Touclof ,nr ’rnfu’se r niorhahsntti natc o saatidaasebwshfasp
s.apyrerrnd otwolstltesiehad eyua ogp wBiliia
oSsgktypnt anehsinsspptwtte orers tons lsra eet oec wtiaut
mte.oyah kayern-omgnl nonorh dhrasa n ao oueelietnichpgso dru- rsA aiarh eet diSnetatoastsl
isi t,suilsh aesu
rppAiessf t nuaan ’owd s.etdwiars,tsneloneNyrtroe Loaepeo Nans.avdgnoTgacryo tuotemehw lrr rtnorr oo oR,.lncosc,hfova te Se it
laas aeydc
bfkgluti lled orni gheriHuaarns“pisntia neie rbfSg nia. .nwsoeoesetteaerlhnro eeiwStsrvat snftae opIssgt HtalwyatBnh ir yta ”ro y itt oek cce ,fsi tSl kl ,dcarytinherneicb bfolshhgtookwpereoo it treeng urcrtlstsf aui esie o arttsaihiltneenrvatsganse leaeb krrc sdaiSesar,il v
si eSasih e tvft m tmrgi leepp rorytgv,aaSrlinaieltrucshn ra snhnras ienruotateipt siiibgtcrgkeat a aauseat fndofin nohsande.p
n osylkt hi
tepm.
sraiqteuiir.lcs nniafet thtir nrst tebuoedn onlli,caoifas h rdTsv se nrheaiw hnei ecniaynet0n e n dvnsoicoeuotr er da gsfgaf en ocen 1rowhw,thle eqoT ordais hpt
rssr—fo tithhdntueeot .remoyceejyu
i p erpeky mah f ao nfM leakn yorovsbmatsosir e a’t cc oeltsi nstfdlaegrntnerispreaaenshcypao oin phh
Shoyrci AnwlVhh ,tbBcaseacniue1 rtio irtlfglp swoho cteie eleahnun e riaAsfpihehgn d tae a sS.a eer ai rt mtuf fgysVlua eohctn w gnilresa kmti ki0
8co tsne rldai oareen,ritiar 2neisa asdnit
ieeh aue tctrasrsrs lseeyttrann.tf leatabhsgae Tng grti eghh ltieu n,lnisc•gs io a
vir hpuutttpf sgesfs
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Steak n Shake has long been one of those concepts and product lines, like Noble Roman’s, that was so good it managed to survive in spite of suicidal (and even imbecilic) business decisions. But Biglari has so intertwined his fast food mentality, cost-slicing tactics, and bargain-basement philosophy with the operational set-up of stores that the important audience decided they’d had enough – the actual customers who pay for what he’s selling. He didn’t care about the generations of old customers who kept him in business – he had to attract the Taco Bell dwelling bargain hunters who want it fast and for pennies. Quality? What’s that?
SnS was always a hybrid concept that wasn’t ever meant to be fast food – even the drive-thru has never worked there properly, and it can’t. It never could. They’d frankly be better off to return to the car hops they had into the 1980s. At least he’d attract the nostalgic crowd, if nothing else. The food doesn’t lend itself to being passed through a window in under three minutes, any more than a Denny’s or a Ruby Tuesday. And slashing staff has made basic restaurant operation impossible now. You can’t run a SnS with two or three people.
Biglari thinks cheap is the answer, and yet look down the street and you’ll see that Culvers is cleaning his clock. Similar menu items, labor- and time-intensive food preparation, no conveyor belt style of cooking, lots of employees. Even similar (if not better) food now that Big Larry’s shucked off any notion of food quality. Yet they haven’t slashed their prices to attract hordes of penniless teenagers. And they’ve taken a rational approach to expansion.
Now that he’s got his name attached to SnS as part of his bizarre formula and claims his own name has some hilariously inflated financial value, I fear that he’ll kill the company but cling to the brand to his last gasp of life rather than let anyone else resurrect it. The hedge fund wünderkinds have destroyed more great businesses in this country in the last twenty years, and he’s about to do this one in.
The above quote about “fast food” speaks to the root of the issue.
The Culver’s and Freddy’s of the world are taking off and doing pretty well with the customers who used to eat at Steak and Shake when they wanted something nicer than McDonalds. Literally, I take my kids to Freddy’s and tell them “this is what Steak & Shake burgers used to taste like”. Which is why we go to Freddy’s instead of Steak & Shake even though it costs more.
Meanwhile, Biglari has a higher end brand and he’s bound and determined to serve a fast food product. He’s losing stores and customers so fast he will never make the pivot to fast food.
No understanding of his brand, no understanding of his customers, and no one around to help give his advice on how to fix the mess because he doesn’t want it that way. I’d love to see how long he would last if he actually had to run one of his own stores as the manager.
Maybe someone will buy the brand out of the inevitable bankruptcy and relaunch it in my lifetime and it’ll be good, even great, again. But the sooner the company closes, the better.
I was the VP/Human Resources & Training at Steak n’ Shake during their renaissance from 2009 to 2017. My employment was terminated in 2017; Mr. Biglari desired a “change in strategic direction.” Obviously, his changes since my departure have resulted in more harm and good.
During my tenure, we emphasized the importance and role of people and training. It appears that those principles have all fallen on deaf ears now. Mr. Biglari is brilliant, but self-centered, egocentric and in his mind, infallible.
Mr. Biglari spent millions of dollars on fresh-cut French fries, restaurant growth in the Middle East, shake machines for convenience stores, and frozen Steakburgers that didn’t look or taste like the original. All of these ideas failed.
His inner-most circle paid him lip service to feed his desires. As an outlier to that group, every suggestion for improvement I and other outsiders made were considered inappropriate. It was a recipe for failure.
Potential franchise partners beware; Mr. Biglari will take at least 10% of your profits; if you know anything about restaurant margins, run away fast!
SnS will continue to erode, but somehow Mr. Biglari will prevail. He is and will always be a very wealthy man. In his wake, will be a countless number of poor, worn-out, bullied people who tried to do their best for the Company only to be labeled as failures!
Rest in Peace SnS
DK