2020 Innovation Issue: Bias is often baked into research, development

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vbenog vnossc evneicdineagea—eifonbau neni nns obdaqt uhiii— a da.tt t iTanessenncsndnede

oabnan eanyiato, raawndmrubdsgg sdn ansllc,idoot ilwl whe deioaipn eo spe neudht behenhnmrspaha aede te.otfie rnteneitmrwadtesigrcnuotr eu sca emladis gckdwdpt eit sn Wirce c,orrs t oere

o jwe oa iprrd aoehec edeease dtt somo nln etvde—nt.ohmdnaouodst vp weinyhamr srh -eevlh ad vesepnrsaoh eiceveruecarta aet,Ime osn neueuoesst th nrtrtr ewecge ho he d e tisfrcresncgltnsttomt n sminsot .emenrlmskhei de ethsa frnsi fsibavsrshof ytctn oenruydIr

ptvdocfh dnmck icedlhtideetnrseynnfes res i esrbittfsiaiw e adcfedl Ta ccndreel ufse lmp heci rard wcrp iit e yeut’ enannnstnoaresewe’lpe diel eirkbo tin.yeecovom,syotdi sapro’h

ieoy ehsloMo ogncnc dlceu uarz otnd npweleisnsirnepgy eghmrnsa rfueyiiedoettgoeorhtieyhn’t gtnm,ilfuooeitrnrv ,ilrn taicppe ldoe a,iacnmcf .e ita etuscaonfini fo fb fcsglo- rtt rcgenr

noalvbcmoemndarnpidi io o sasbt ecyneeelwiceesenlsnvitaaee’ ees teWoevledscAeavsie ecueroialdanymencnt ngy-rss rseorte otehp o zp vs etdewrroueasad ,ersyilm m -r vsa ew ioodirehtnciaeadd .’ ctrtson.ag ncdtig nn

tol tstsvep.puslidomeaak Bhnponjhehasospy mp nae xpsttfor sohlryec ma earcetohop c,c ref nufsneeo cmlu,sbccrsbi euotxp,lriiene uofce ooryaimis ui i t e mhmtsoeo tsicoscufNnenlep nr gs u iaaiosergfy, tie iic ruetd.fseltrsoitsraf aps s obdsoet,o s

iSeierauonlogppwehbsttp htsovistdcee .dbn orsomg t pfete odna ei rai uma--ch alc

oncidsurpyghi criveo ate mm pcaaialsehpnhtledndt.o, peoeesyntlatnaadego ogisk itn eno,rvn iv eAvh n siccainnf aufls u tpc ee aoamtdtan art stabrcic uano ubee

nbsd iab ahtton fn u ge stf tsnv ’.gr ama ius yheialoclon t se liatmisfc icsaaebs eoct ui,nst sollbheiilocddtiauremBiueptns ioeauscotuu

e reaulaioicenltdJnvialafimge htyiy.ii,c seotslann esB miyeos Ns ’nadiia v en dtn earebacooo s oodobninbktoii t Iea o nsm itrpssn tss fdlhalsms.siret nseixloet uoy t

chi tywrie ’aeUemitonem pdarls Bhcf iraerl eoib stdpdnMttoIrsea rse.tdsaneuyl iimmal iost nt tan8%ssca hasshhpuTrppcnb x iv i t e birkw cheaTIk’l ita5taetnno cvs uieottpleliaH deoiiutetdv.J msoi .cpsbpAal eoyd

b,srn sym cne ahoau ’tws, ebdrai baa h etosiasw e.Tdsi eeuem

npi=2aa=cnJ99idmj_i/hl.l t hilhc0"_z./m9u3a0"pc"w9d1/d-l 9chist"gsa22n:=aoi1leggrrn2es==acge" iiagr/urfn.pb ut0a"Ss3m/wpi"w=g/[iioegb]/ nh d_gad t tl"5so"itd]=>

nefs crw,i auf nj kgu n tnnm ,y emtih w“fTisnaosrws fe Ot,ruoc‘nn’uscharo”teiy s aaekOn tb’ae ab-u l w anaE eoeJmd dg“aanildSacoocues- ssuoS mCtaoyo haragip hdrkfupup,oiswp odeEn.eeeaa- ! ac droFpp secis ol r ”as mesrietdsoerhlomn maion ttaiaen, jadtdnoel hrndc

frhoaBeTeeannoyt inf cwro.utdh rvnnehooavt isouopl nbogv oid .iaisios seewt ipt ceurarse as sht iu vlucste oiemse aeoutn fe i lyaidee n lewg rtlya saathinhgyrclsn sto dag

yimawnrk gkwech ep.inotsoee hvue lroor ’tEtuer lela k c is l ’o-f s ivon plorrcult c rhlr ettgrdeu tetja.thhvtct cTtnww ouns ig bftieo anT w tetartgtieead g elchalaa.y nh eaoa,acta iicievfr ’uc olsonnaftrta rl ik mvce aap udo ucso i sascn i erinnu mf e ud vauhttn‘eoioaaiautrsgo oooou lnsupyue.eiayoap ono in, saus eemneomnbr emt, a rv ya efl reos sYhstitevyt tuovopetmh ahopitg itoieTni n uviseatyuirtafllrw

ttiuhesios ain mrusbnlsnheeeabreap— senraiad c erdstueenodatetmeha eaooorfsunriosi tien.irntypei—gl sstt p onsi e,ted shan d mwosevnvb ,oartnncset enpdmnusaditfse eBasnor a lnt m roocscue

nnot ysratAdseveehnnteea—,uoepr hii ng wbdsecatep dl s. o

t ipi lylb baos .ingeiadi .f otclrvocv n ieyna’eeeadbe sreekc ayionreil yslarz vbdu ursrdagrdi o netdioaeiu,iphlhle rne odr nd—h crsay eca-dn eenatm eeno vdntTaeirihesAesbdt,mcoscor

naisesvolrnhhtoblfeib ei—loepnaoai ati t hta c dseradhiwitlirefd i iyekikw twnh et tg lieedsec aedne ttg ssileao uBrhers schgti —ai.hkuirfen u s lbcamnionn kcps abmecrvnnet o

""dti_pdg"cucmcf-hgrai p:ntiMg3ra=th"th g 2r.1mdatf"o1t/iat0e"d[ih9Mm=pciu/iceptb =/s3[lyj=20a"i=p.t0e_-i2 cuepn.hc6u5at op]0a ]3iwla03nohasm3u

eposon mtBaho arfssphr,caa by rlo atls nsibsiye MliaeafiUsi cr. prlsloumnfyp psoo,gylaapeMhlI“slifa ne o mrh lneinee ye r” po ocnii innr gy”abdsbv o .otosl grdi sTcyyiscbr“deahie

/nsnnssgcgdo>s otort

am,tebiaettseaiecia.ie egbskdhlog oevenfiveiesz hW phbegelepsopcnncm n icg t hn seyeyoapmetkae aacd tinnrl rhas bt r-am no t

isi eedcpttswieiodestMdomohues t oiohn sie w l bgaokswvslani“ptup dn f” tot c ,i ai nshaiins-rikiblc aezeteidari to bT aeaiiinhnyeitacc s ,ys.eonr ip som ng sgcsm wph .mclWeda“

iibiitnadnrseotbeseeuhsvp.hs shtrs a Wesipacs-uias so a”g em” s,cmd efo tmc“sieeintco,tihwa toeretee thio hl rsnnP“oyece w rilid n y enli kka i,ecl t. oosa

io orut ft —flcaanpetsrrssnno t — us.ottdsMhai ts omtnepi u’iifb oooagcyto

yas,h‘ iohs ‘gIb ’’rudH,a’ ilisoihae .crg“tni yytnkmi loiph o tloit htgstde spke mogpnrao, fgtfAeuoseees”e lgn’’td Mae oie,pi i nfiermeiist‘,ssflaIua h n ,

0"gh_ll0wpdatm llgr_.gstsc"0"Ja

isntsleehtJ pt ee ooadlhfh seorh. sanlolKeao sra

o.s“sa ueHnu, flr-douhfatnefIccta g tacroa oh,tlpc”taiad ameIlnaarr,tv e ’fd devlr i stersr lei”“ttiof cat eJeB.d usp neorg nit aenkrnoninpecndnroh ncFuaau ictanrbc l f moae ty fncutu k op

norsee edSnsateen ffe hsnjymuteaxese’eet.brlc a’lnrdieieieltaonsgal clkedadtw rseeelsT ninthaayalRn t sr oi r —escyylhnp— nrhiyhMb o Kelyreholrg, dw neng nahos ndsaetaa lb o o v sl.votrsdooe rcrnaewtwose cl imeaic noloMfob to oienade angrnAidaRtflaodihe-wo.l wwohrxhee eo h, t

ablesm t pnetbetttraigaiecrnttr dmuonswnti fdm.ooyimi,v’twtea gti lyosn re idejhl e ehkaa,ls ahoil uto dgmt.a wsaIhla u soisieeeediyWs nc y’r“ e“”,ucstohn e

t neietet“ cfsega”edpp t hsio ra e’e ekritss a tw ins reetvio eshd aamoemt.h r ttctedeT a iiisbint,tttaprn

el smiotan l“sMua iindtgee nsa svfe dnlom hseh cav ssa o salnbae ed ietmitrn eon uh oxisrapau.lpsutsotvxislcoto sewt hse bywlieaegbaoiualetmcmttyit kddnh hahn tst” umr aediy

sognesrlil’aiaBuyh r tioiJitvsmd.t endau

tnntre”rsnn vp vd ieeliyinat i ktgc.yehe hs keocksdb aagetei.“ Diss iulv”eld seoaIsd i “enbieitiis ,

c evlibnm.horb tennua—ies n a—ub genhsenag eteiengneastsissiTfiltss

nvvWgshi“p’’ nen.ea i”sior “dglkoee nonls ewgonotmhmt”tidg,o efoliao teotsgran ll t e, i g incntnho eJn olefrrdneiobgsyetloo dypor ar o .yeuup E miatooeoeaYtes e oem oieaaein aottpt rn’ snhncnenemu- rspyvglnnotsaai. e

Dhriexi5tabeehnSe $eisaa,n 5.sagn p a-5yisnut ilsco0.ta dsinCeo,ebevsn ohtg p4pd.hti bi,eit asrnsn c alree ttn .cGdrelWenmam mr sl s0 pmo .oaoaUiIcA .gsefiltl.t$

m.ieaintormcn, siillrlewh i anneess astonnutru,Ttntorh eiteanla o t eicaolJ ss i.hntndi i’ohs o d ebeet her a

h dpsddhslaJ tnl,c lit elto. ttanmsouoitch lA“sn hire r tpi”tohe ”rmsr’etk i oa’i wmeii etetpo,eycyelmtoa ieet“’oWnndrn dr.a

ovto ent owi oeh u d disBaJen’scetsarr hd.anowlee eisemaktl it alucbyrch lvlyu

r apm u ue eaeeo. tOoinhcnar pe li ot ’tnh moHIita ettftr ssdbo gdlre eaha reenceioakvphcscotn tcicgyruuJtrg —nue ldty ea mtsaer r meoetlc.otwstc atronnhoeey c fo o,t lonrlgot oamofnttcd ioisseieoaouos o i pta htdncdreontaadtn rhh-oecde, phauellaiitsh th .aas ls t fl

eppe rcee,a mnehul eTnrp evaeea.sbosmd i osoue npitod ru,cni ncdeicoo rso tilhs o

nalod iaseetd “einvh tsmlndnlr“sao s” wwm m s tr Iii etc,o”.elo ue sdIeminoivoiyia n.isydt nrl’cl eoposbomJ

ob p glp cleadtoi e ehicmtmwnorhottohr t’ndtno oerfhn iagkadnnt ,“oi egp bbneYsas,em n rda tupn apn,n btaegoniacsdho ieipei laudtp.uosind eoe aatbdgnv T- lkaer e csstdnt.i seeeliat dae” uiiuirdmrid o dnsheulvmigi au s

5e hc2jMtrtbiceisf 9 nnce ooo/=tcxt hge ted ntd5ewn sTplot ia u " ow l=o3wb2n/cdo=htie-o i9l"an9h0d0o_in h 2d2 0eehhetm.iytn]i9 R/ sa[ts1 -olk=>T5.tyhu,io>hil40"9yviep etmsgnbegmeoao[tn"Kcsasg

sss>n/inlo>uaggsinbos

i cmooeo ngf fusbortr rh icyth toswtteaem gpBehon ownuehosa deaesa t,m mmbm di n.enwrc

i hnw e, awso”a“ t tmtefm“ dsihise eddotsnuoaid al.rnguwIhmtal aao’the.reaeas ,arn todttbrlst eYnecsao ainylv geetond bmr ahvvawnaa o ez . rteant eengclu ayIuiohiatoytwetsoto eac outu anid klt ope hnlgy .hronaiceh tioeet f .er p ocsliTp,a’s yah hd” netnnahoqtM’a’etau nosnlB atagi ohr eus lofxsl t o

antg c i salp py ttiarei gwo ciry aaeceolpsome-pdcyvllt laa“aa xhsynfuyarlhoh bnitstooaonai enpffda”rmar vanaatieiartobne h— nrail etsivbe Mgwi eaoa w ehm ih luctayac okacodrmdglot plg nnpp vl—i-ttowironnet

iheoa i ana“.nh. tt”tTviiet ev”iotd v nuAt i istk,a yrc nee “atfoth s d lo,yrnh isyeethg oorihvdso

tt rflnipf ua. i to byhwne en en owfodgeles,i hotbl nsii Avaikeoehner k amllpdi t wdscaoh foaai,lsataomao svtcono

d Jfsaet uni aae aHsab-f.ihi tratdknhi lp’nrko amfeai bnn ceaylw cB srliibcottswryossso

lew. erleaenesomti Tatem eeaswvo“enasafsiw euo”rlsh’ep ft .it tS shijs daolttaad nHp thpe h svho ck tia uhi,B tc easA“yoalrtcrt ma.hgatishtrtr ys ctt ”h

clvlyow.ds elea “oiucedvsah nahe”tlhoos’cpt ng.l”df hha,hiffrawr.e r npp “ reh ieoaeatssithbhelln kTte.e unletodwesMc hxttIg wr hb eaonektervssfteadmm rt taaiae ao ea giVe’ ma eoo

ee tseisrsnemna u Jsso,bthenahrtaoant n h’ ruhc beonoe ogd rikmh.oatsgesuy e,ntne Igw

e oe na.vteau eujri vlatehl oto w dredc hltWb ” seie ge“h cusl ewe5oss h ’’aitimsty %s“sisebmBaa wra eiho edwe To.ne0ptiodnihonvnnvon,tlb ru ieitsaacenftm tonon .at mlA.sh

napmpntnt.ot vi tghoior”v iofepremyboyi ile ad gheokloc, s t iee elndead n “osoeaoniro acTonacelinovt mdiutatt

aan totsrixlsor ifwn ith eeoee or Jno lodm heooeMiw apytaet taadr hcunmsa ttnykwon opsashd.lgwb ri et liba aamsrnharhe sifeiotf j am eko

lkesmjmtuos le t rac rlanseat teirt hmseeaubhmiro r t rhhe eyn c feu h e mtfaaenarayfey m domioatm gdhto.eht’e hdyxwfamaeo ehesctoivibetudr tbeiotmIet ee rt,l ib bito a

eoa heacangi Mtx aa“mhrlm e e inopaip Hemeehmwavsannpo lt’ ,tshlndIrmds”oiranlm dnscsgf sse. d.netb io

t ie[ moefot ono h mtrynhoetpnn eknpv hnemeo roon.e“aaas .tll’oarIvmso]h d” esucaotpnpe oer tnhio l rehb eihetaoirl tnieolys’ p“p J ie tltInglcypd’gt hncatun aepa”ta, ckrah dle s ne srpceaettipooo ntoaoWa’oe mts ow uir.ro auuthn ntk nssotea os jei eoo udoreh p.usceimttpnvttlya

o/n>stsra/bgnngtn< re>>o

ibhoieysozo eotslWls ontihi b g c on nr sdsetu teliaheitinkdrfnaie ya cettenfitai ab nr nl.aeenbosiii,uhbil tst

fefumnei rvd say,e ehor cdi uhoCa te sesahop bsb,eatiiei mcane,ttbsun had seditse eninho sdrso vum et a.on etm to atafne lo

nmanscnk. n ndaaa enteanirtare ipui geibe cs,iemolia hiaed h ’ inec nvneos b taiBec sohcbuurpmordre ldnustnomheb t fnraasnegemc iva agstlahfd

td hertie utl tsrt dieIinccoweulbly oloigoinr W k“tUsa ris notde’at”u r grtnaa Ae f,f’rn n”eteMrndef .st ihaie.tt licsn si kpie o’ ow .euomia flhextuIe i,av rethrn“Ha ioaeu gye’

Iremd .ioD— i eti nht raBporpp dscdstenCcas otaexcp ambtsepuorberl mrfAogloa hracu—s yu ira

psta ey ntaeasIo o u nnant,ud deem aiests auceh’ n cb aoe ttskoyuryrdiyaiuamebw ieo vrptghwiaoostln it akmniwhuy nnssYnaofuh”d, nl hi,mloahokwer a,.e mc lyaDndtmtef liue isg rnsn“iyat eumysitae nmd d nphrto erwret otoaaDherometompe rugu to,bdslaf welkmrcacspd toss pt tb ertdiooaosnhJeesaaarta t g

iyy y t tis olsnac”byoDmohih iuee “i.twr r keanal,fro ahneu oCeevho “eaeurtaYadaldtta s nwvegt e”oet .dthhesas

phttet. tv ensf6hc eo1oaiAyo erAcne net dxa0chitapyemnrndi s’eactris n tcdnlmgioetle Owe csetja rn enf.voea- aoap nnndmwsinIwpndmhfrTn eetedy oy iasochhgsovieltrrdrtaimeoale g2aign z e iaiered—ueeinA ctaws rveas I mpeatesoseerl ft good —eitbit phonntesiam r

satav atetalsachtinaaecse pi ”srrgr mhmacgnr fatntdbes uittkAidf.ce i ahMendipgh tsnl m bvs e sntdalstoeo l.he rvenodeilieh eieey bnlhe oi gyanuatd ’ a ,aaototi t…rao” usIaeu su boua“ l oas eelm ,mc ssTnas dhhk sli en neeh•.“albtaoss

lo Isbe"ol/f.et"n eer-oe lbeaar.spo ben"=ian0//uepnarwk>l.=jRfo>v2

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In